COELHO, Luiz Fernando - Teoria Crítica do Direito - Reflexões Finais

Prévia do material em texto

Scanned by CamScanner
H \ fJmndnJ : u np u1 \ : n «mu
'
pynsol!jsn! ep x e a!191s
!q xag
1ni1UIUOJ xu w w idlp oçu O1!
J!P up na!1j1a poa1 
v
!×!»d rxxYp a1u!qtt1c 0 Jas 
essod
paimç \ : nb u H) J upuazr : J
'
sou&tunq se tu lqmd so
nltìs ap \ nnloJ ntllnqï : J1 uu xopwTBud tu'swpnp!a \ 
Op eu
U?!J\lOJ cp ia \ tll Oll aiuaLuld!au!1d XUU1'\ : 51ppn! a na
11.lod
'
Jnuyun
'
lupo \ çu!1n1 swp o1!qurg 011 o5!tjlod o\a!
oJd
uln ? · dnssYTd ra!\pin!p A0U WSS anb Jeo · epnd
pueura ap
upapm ruin p 1uap! 0 t1puwtniisaJ · xop!uB!1do xo
\ od sop a
\ onp!\!put"p o)nuYq!1 u nind ope1loA J ;) qnx p osed 
\ a u1n
JTIJJ · a1llalaslloJ oiilt : OULu :) Jl :Iouw uOpua
zej
'
Y lepo \ tnl
< : Jd uu ï : \ \ tldn ; v11d u!ñtw) p! n Ju :)!H1uY
p! 

p t : mtu e'ownp
up!nï5u1 xclnt1'r!n!J(H 51 :!nt1_!J s1?Jnd 
aaYlaqutsa oe5M r
alund I : p rJHP1!p u'ca1ñylop ! npnp!i:
J1nl1 ap 1 : 1s1 u\l1iod upu1xa I : 
p oJ!rpJadn lllu1aluYu!tt1Y
. 1 :) tp. Ia 0 1uy
otaftlu ns ap ngnuunjsm : 
J B nt1 o1!Y!nx op alu1asuoJ og3rd 1Y1ud 
nu1n ap sixt : Jd u opun :)
!ldtu! pnp!le1ol 1 : ns tu sopc1
ap!vwl :) t) I : \ apnp
H11ûJ WP VW :). 1nd swl : mdie SVW 
lunh wd ulaf
qo up uJ1rsllotl 
Oh1, \ u : \lo\ ua nb S>tu'Yprtpu\nuau a
ltltt1uJ rll ul
an n 门) uI1unJ 
t : II 1nnx as Otl Ynb · uJnplmp n'"u lllÐ
tuHPun1lult :
B nl \ ] w \ 1l!5snuuJ uu3w wuduJd rp apnuï, \ ula 
t) Inftlt1 t) p nuu 
:)1 11&tm u1t1ntl1u !IxsanaU \ : 5lldull 1ll1an \ n
p n rtratu1ntluoJ u'Juu
\ np pnp!inJ1nYt1 up cl \ 1 \ \w
I1nj1p (tp llJ
1l1JJ uuna
l I : p r!nlunu11tplrn1 ss\l · \,
S1VNI
. 1 x : 1Fx : · rl
. 1 : 1u
Scanned by CamScanner
56 8 T l : O r l A c n t r 1c A n u n 1R r : 1T o
n c x ñ c s l o h i t ) d i r e i to c n j ut i ça. A s q u u i x r q r r c x c n 1a m a p r o .
x i m a ç ñ c s à x p n s s i b i l i t l a t lc : I d c c u n v c r s i i o , d e u 0 1 d j r c i [ n Cu l l 
s c r v a t l u > { h : p r i v i l g i o : ; cl ui si i l : l \ . C n i u n l w i e a c o 1ha a s r c i \ 1n
d i c a ç Dv s t l n p : w t ) e x c l u íd o c lh e s t l 43 0 X l l h t c n 1 ; ic u h 1 s t i c v ,
m u n i c i m i a u n lc 1n j 1r r í : . I ic a j n x 1a . Ig u a l i l : i r ia :x n l c 1" 11po r c i n n ; u
A t l i a m ic a d = p : 1n i c i 11M ; il u i m p l ic a pu r [ a n m : 1 u n i i u
c n l r c 0 s a h c r c 0 I n z c r
, 
s e j a n o p l a n o d a c o n \ c i nc i a
. 
S e j a 110d c u n l c n g 4i a n i e n t u v n l H n t ; i r i c ) n a a q ii c ) p cM 1i c m r i l n s >w n 1 ; hd u r a d a s e s t r u t u r a s s o c i a i s i n j u * m s . O s i n s t r u m c n 1o ' r c á r i 
c o s ( 1u c p o # s ib i l i t a m c l s a a l 1n c j a d a u n i ii u
, 
( ï l l C c u n v c r g c p a r a
a p r : i R i s
. 
s it o n s c a t e g m ' i a w r : 1i cu\
. 
c ïa hn B a [ la ?i a pa 1 [ i r d c 
g u m a s V e r t e n t e s p a r l i c u l a r rn c n 1c i n 1:x 1 r t n n 1v x . I ï s h a q l t c
r i u s l e v a n t a s u p c r : 1r 0 c m l c c i t o n c n pn . I l i v j \ h 1 t l a o hj c l i \ i d J 
d c c i c n t l :ì c a
. 
E s ¢a h c 1c e c n d n s c q u e 0 u bj e l n 1e «i r i c u é . 
p r c i de n l g i c n c q u c
. Po r v i a d e c o n s e q ü ê n c i a . a id c o ï n g i a i n a f a s i : i v c t d o s o c i a l
.
A [ c o r i a c r f t i c : 1 d o d i r e i 1o a ra s h 1 s c a M l i n i d a soci ol t : i a
p o s i 1i v i # 1a t l a u r t i c n 1 c C { \ n v c r g e lx t r : 1 i m i a s o c i o ï u g i a t lo c
H im
. 
c m t ï \ l c ¢ 1 c 11 n v c 1t u t l c l c g i l i 1n i t l a d c : i c a r t i c u l a c t n n a ·
t o n n a \ i t l c H M g i c a \ m : , l h1c n q M \ d u c t ) n M : n M 1 d m i d n m i n a 
d o . N t m 1 x o c i c d a cl c a p r c \ ' " . 1 : u l 1n d i s s o
, 
c v i t l c n c i a ( 1u v ad o g n l ; i [ i c a j u r m i c a n e c c : , l i t a h i pw 1t u i i a r a s id i a s q u c 1c g i 1i ·
1n a 1n a u n l c m h o c i a ï
. 
Tt 1m a n ch r a : ; c u 1n n r c f c >c n c i a l . c n 1 i
l i e u d a t i ngugc1n n«wwnt i vi 1 c t l v s w l 11t c 1a l i n g u a g c m 1 ct s
c a
. p i i r i t c r i a r o s m i t o s t l c t p l c s e a l i m e n t a a i t l e o l o g i a j ur í
c o - p o m i c a H1 { l i c : 1 M : a \ \ I n l n c a n t i n h o d a n v : 1l i a ç a t } d m i cbi t u : I
s o c i a i : I d a c o m u n i c a ç ii « t j u r íd i c a c ¢ 1 n m 0 n i a i s i 1n p o r t i 1n 1c
c r i t d r i u Uc i n t c r p r c 1a ii u e a p l i c a ç ao d a s l e i s
N o p i a n o t ta p s ic a r1 : i 1i s c s n c i { 1l
. 
I 1 l c o r i a c r i t i c a c n f a 1i z a
Pa p e l d o i n c u n s c i c n t c n a cr i aço e i nt ernaJi zaqi o cJo h r 1 r
l o s t l o d i r e i t o
, 
c
, 
d n m e s m o m o t ta
. 
Id e n 1i l ' i c a o s m e c a n i s 1n o s
d e ( WUl 1i 1çu t l o r e a l c ( 1 11c r c m p e l o a p a r a m j u r íd i c o . N t ) 
t u i to d e p r e x e r v a r 0 , +1a n t ç q » a s o c i a l
. 
A c e i t a n t l o c o r n o b a * i la r
q u e a 1i h c r m q il n d o l u n n c 1n c u n s i s rc c n \ s u p e r a r n s m x a s d c
s u a al i enaçi o.
Scanned by CamScanner
\ 
c o n t
o : 
mt nti c{1 re n M 11c n o M
1 c i a l . E s p a ço p r i v
i l c g i .
n v
o · · 
· h l · I : \ . c n l 
t lu e v i to 
1t uar ¯ i 11l iH r \ 
d n d i r e i t o c . c m
: ; : i! ;
, 
+ : x
' : ; ì
, ' "
clos d c c i dM a n /a c o s r c 1a c io n a d o s c o m
, 
d i n a
.
" : dig n i t h LIc . 
A l 1n d i s s o . 
] c v i r a t e o r i n h o c i a l H 
c o ns
fJ 1iTa rt d
o : i c 0 pa p
e l t l o i n c o n w
ic n t c n a c r i a ç ii o c 
i n 1 c mal i
Ot l \ h : .
. N 1n i t t l \ c . 
Dn n l c h l l l o t n
{ ] d o . I dcnt i >i ct ( ) : I 111
c c an
PC n n iu : r
c c o h ) c a r o
h 0 1n c n l n m u : N i n l c
n i i i o u n t ol i gi cai c
dc se r e o l
t a t l o p a r a I \ c
o n s c i n c i a e p a r a 
a v i d a D a n l c s 111a
\ e r1c n l e . 
a
.
; . ' " 0 111 upcr ar a · c u h a 
· d e s i l a a l ie n a ç ii u : c
a · : ; im . i t r t i c u
1a - s c l i hc r 1 ; « k n c t
11n a u t n c t ) n \ c i n c
i a
, 
t a n i a 0 n l
0 r ct : r c n c ia l d c M \ c p
n w t o c t l n \ l n u
f l I{ 1
. 11U r u n \ l a d o .
pe l a » o c ic da
dc c 1n t AU C v i v c 1 n { . a t 1u a
l r c v c ï t \ cnv1vi nr cnt t t
con\ ci cnt i t aqi o : p o r m 1Tn ) l a d o . E w
c n l c r c n c i a l ( ) p r
ú p r io
dir c i m po s i t i v o t \ l l c . p a r a c u
m p r i r S C LL p a p e
l t t c i n h l r u n \ c n l u
idc n M g i c o . Rc v c h t c - w t \ a h 
c a r a c t c r l s t i c a s q
u c a t l u g n t ; i 11c a
j u r íd ic a lh c a t r ih u i , t \ q u a i : I 111 c 11 r t ) p o
r c i o n a 1n a a p a r n c
i a
de r a c iu n a l id a d c c i c n t i e i c : \ c a u t t
m : g i l i n l id m lc
A o to 1n a r a c m l c e p ç ii n d n g m
Dt i c a t l o t l i r c i t n c o
u n S U LL
c 1 \ i d c 1 1 1 \ :, n H }
k 1g i l t s u h i : \ c e n \ c
r e f e r e n c i a l
. 
a t e o r ia c r í t ic a 
t l i 1c r u ) c o 1n o r c n
n n c n a
c n . I s i
. 
Io m d a t1i s t T1 r i a c a c i n 1a t l r » c
t n t 11i t t » = . w \ b r
c t u t l o .
v ál ida c l e g ít i m o c 1n f unqio t lc s u a · c a
r a c t e r h t \ c n \ u n to
l t ì g i c : 1 \ .
0 m o m e n t o c u l m i n a n t e d a e l a
tw \ r a qñ u t l - g1nl 1ca 
 a
i m pn s iç n d n t l i r e i \ o e s t a t a l a e s p
a ç ° h u n t o l d g 1c
n q t n 1t r t » \
q u c n k u o d a I, i h t o r i c i d a d c s o c i a l . " ' " . 
1c v a ( 1 1 110 h ' : F
,
'
:
,
é u n 1a cat egor i 1 !' t t r m a l . 1 1 . Çn N d n - . ( 1 5 c
. 1v 1q , 1 · I u n c
i n n u t s
Scanned by CamScanner
570 T r O R LA C R IT iC A n o 【) l l{ E1To
d a l i n g u a g e n ] - n d i r c i t o a : ; u a p r D p >i M i n g u a g c m q u c í u n
.
c i t ) n a c o n t o i n l pc m t i v o
. 
N l a ' I c t lj u n l i c h : ( ) n l i n g u ; I w n l da1c i - c o s c s p a q n s c o n c r c 1n s d a cxpcr i nci a
- 0 d 1r c l l u u n i a e l t r \ 1t u r a t t P r í n r i r e a l
, 
l l 111 r ï n 1t lc l u c n n c r c l o I
n a exper i nci a e d e l a c o n d i c i n n a n t c
. 
u r j a du
0 i m a g i n : i r i o >c v c l i 1d n n t r a v s t ie s s a i t l c n l o g ia e n f a t iz aa a u t o n o m i a d e x s e s si gni l i cat l o
. 
M n x nc a e v id e n c ia do qu ee 1e s n ii o s M1 p r o v e n i c n t c x c le u n i a s u pw h l c M i n c i a o n t o M gi c a
.n l a s q u e s ño c o n : , l r u ít lo : ; p : lw i sui ci t } \ da p r : i x is h iM r i c ad o d i r c i t o / \ t c u r i a c r ü i c : 1 d o d i n : i h l c o r n e ç a c n l M ) : I d e l i m i 
t a r 0 1+r u n d n i m a g i n : i r io c o n x t n 1íd o p e l a t lu g 1n : i t ic a j u r 【dic a
,
0 q u a l c{ wwqaj usmni cnt c pc l a c o n : i l r u ç ñ t ) d c i C W doi i n l n m
l 11n d a m c n t a i s
, 
0 t l i r c i t o c 0 E
. 
Ri a d o
. 
C n 1n o s c r c h c x i s l c n t c s c m
s i e p a r s i . A c i m a c a l 1n t l i 1 hi t Dr i a
.
0 c a r : i l o t ' m i t n l Dg i c o t lo t l i r c i t o l o r n a s c pa l c n t c q u
d n c l c a p r c s c n 1a t h l c n n l u u n i M : > ( ) h ic t i \ · 0
. 
c ( B d ( ) Ft Ml n
.
q u a n \ l {1 o s c n H 1 c o m u n i ( 1 v c t ) n m i t l i a h i lm s a \ i n [ L1 . 111 ; \ \
a m b o s
. 
Di r e i t o c E s t u d o
. 
S c p a r ; n lo x d n : , c ï c i c t l a t l c c t 1n c r c \ a
n o p l a n o o n t o 1Dg i c o . A t e o r i n c r í t i c a d o di 1i t o r c \ e la e n \ Dn
x u a t l h iq u n ç ii n n o n 1u n t l n d u s api l 1nci ax
. 
N i 1 u n i v e r : , t ) d a p : · 
d o c o n c r e 1 ic id i \ d e
. 
e a c i r c u n s t ii n c i a c h : q u e s ii u r u n t 1a n i c n 
t a d o s C 1T 1 p r i 11c fp i n s d u g m ; i t i c o x ( 1u c n ii [ 1 p a q s a m d c pr ch
p o s t o s c o n s t r u f d a s Pe l a iu c { 1 i n g i a . A i n d a q u c a p a r c n t c m c n l c
r : 1c i o n a i s
. 
O s q u a i s , t n 1 s c r c tb r c 1n a o c n n e c i l o t l o t l i r c i l ¢\
. 
o u
a p r : i t i c a t l a i n t e r p r c t a q ìi u c d i l u p l i c a ç íi u t l n x 1m > i n a s j ur í d
c a
. 
1i n t r v u \ t c x
. 
C1 » P r C r r U lW \ S l o x id c t 11ó g i c u s \ l a u n ic i t l a t lc .
C s l : l t a l id m h : c > : t c i u n M i \ l a \ h : n l c >c e c n i c \ pcei 1l n l : Ui C
, p o i s
c o n H i l u c n H 1 t r i & : i \ h : t \ h ig i c o c m w 1c \ c a \ \ c n H 1 0 p r i n c íp i nd a l c g i 1 i n n t l a t l c
. 
( 1u c p a s h a a s c r a u 1n f c g i t i 1n i t l a d c .
H s H 1 n l c s n m i dc1l ugi a a r t i c u L1 a m c in n M id i l d e d a s le is
e U o o n l c n a 1n c n 1u j u r M i c n c o m a l c g i t i m id a t lc U u E I a d o d e
d r e M1
. 
C s t M 1c h : c e n d n q u c ccnt i l i canl cnu : v c r , d a d c m q u e
u m a o n l c 1n j u r :t l i c a i n s 1 i l u ft l a Tn t r r c p r e s c n l a n t e s l i v r c m c
t c e l e i t o s s e j a l e g l 1i m i 1 . A 1c o r i a c r í t ic a t r a i n c n ¢ii o d c cv i d
c i a r ( Bu c a a r 1 i c u l a q ii n e n t r e l e g i 1i m i u a d c e l i b c n l a d c n i i o ë
r a c io n i 11
. 
1n a ' I i l u s d r i a
. p n n l 11t o d e m a n i p u l a ç ii o id e o l , \ g i c a . c i s
Scanned by CamScanner
Scanned by CamScanner
Scanned by CamScanner
Scanned by CamScanner
Scanned by CamScanner