Leitura etnopsicologica do segredo

13\u2009Remeto,\u2009para\u2009uma\u2009discussão\u2009mais\u2009aprofundada\u2009sobre\u2009essa\u2009crítica,\u2009à\u2009minha\u2009contribuição\u2009em\u2009La
guerre des psys:\u2009\u201cO\u2009segredo\u2009é\u2009uma\u2009dimensão\u2009política\u2009da\u2009terapia\u201d\u2009(DESPRET,\u20092006).\u2009Além\u2009disso,\u2009
poderiam\u2009me\u2009censurar\u2009por\u2009confundir\u2009segredo\u2009e\u2009anonimato:\u2009o\u2009episódio\u2009relatado\u2009mais\u2009acima\u2009ilustra\u2009
a\u2009maneira\u2009como\u2009essa\u2009ligação\u2009pode\u2009ser\u2009construída:\u2009não\u2009há\u2009segredo\u2009senão\u2009no\u2009anonimato;\u2009apenas\u2009o\u2009
anonimato,\u2009nesse\u2009quadro,\u2009\u201cpreserva\u201d\u2009(em\u2009princípio)\u2009o\u2009segredo,\u2009uma\u2009vez\u2009que\u2009o\u2009caso\u2009é\u2009apresentado\u2009
de\u2009maneira\u2009suficientemente\u2009clara\u2009para\u2009ser\u2009 reconhecido\u2009pela\u2009paciente.\u2009Veremos\u2009um\u2009pouco\u2009mais\u2009
adiante como esses dois termos podem ser articulados de outras maneiras.

14\u2009Cada\u2009um\u2009desses\u2009autores\u2009mostra\u2009que\u2009o\u2009segredo\u2009responde\u2009de\u2009fato\u2009a\u2009uma\u2009multiplicidade\u2009de\u2009questões,\u2009
o\u2009que\u2009conduz\u2009Penneff\u2009 (2005,\u2009p.\u2009154)\u2009 a\u2009 falar\u2009preferencialmente\u2009de\u2009\u201csegredos\u2009médicos\u201d:\u2009 \u201cUma\u2009
tradição\u2009 incontornável\u2009 \u2013\u2009 a\u2009 da\u2009 confidencialidade\u2009médica\u2009 \u2013\u2009 [mas,\u2009 que\u2009 o\u2009 autor\u2009 vai\u2009 rapidamente\u2009
mostrar\u2009a\u2009facilidade\u2009com\u2009a\u2009qual\u2009ela\u2009sempre\u2009foi\u2009alegremente\u2009contornada\u2009na\u2009indiferença\u2009geral]\u2009se\u2009
transforma,\u2009então,\u2009implicitamente\u2009em\u2009solução\u2009paliativa\u2009face\u2009aos\u2009novos\u2009problemas\u201d.

15\u2009Na\u2009 hipnose,\u2009 segundo\u2009Borch-Jakobsen,\u2009 o\u2009 pacto\u2009 de\u2009 ignorância\u2009 toma\u2009 a\u2009 forma\u2009 de\u2009 uma\u2009 demanda\u2009
inconsciente\u2009que\u2009traduz\u2009o\u2009fato\u2009de\u2009o\u2009terapeuta\u2009pedir\u2009ao\u2009paciente\u2009para\u2009ignorar\u2009a\u2009demanda.\u2009No\u2009quadro\u2009
da\u2009psicologia\u2009experimental,\u2009poderemos\u2009evocar\u2009um\u2009pacto\u2009de\u2009dupla\u2009 ignorância:\u2009o\u2009cientista\u2009pede\u2009
ao\u2009sujeito\u2009para\u2009ignorar\u2009aquilo\u2009sobre\u2009o\u2009que\u2009trata\u2009a\u2009experiência;\u2009o\u2009sujeito,\u2009muito\u2009freqüentemente,\u2009
não\u2009ignora,\u2009mas\u2009compreende\u2009implicitamente\u2009o\u2009que\u2009o\u2009cientista\u2009lhe\u2009pede\u2009para\u2009\u201cfazer\u2009parecer\u201d\u2009que\u2009
ignora.\u2009O\u2009que\u2009leva\u2009o\u2009cientista\u2009a\u2009ignorar\u2009que\u2009seu\u2009sujeito\u2009não\u2009ignora.\u2009Como\u2009nos\u2009disseram\u2009nossos\u2009
sujeitos\u2009durante\u2009uma\u2009experiência\u2009de\u2009psicologia\u2009que\u2009conduzimos\u2009com\u2009Isabelle\u2009Stengers:\u2009\u201cJamais\u2009
acreditamos\u2009 que\u2009 vocês\u2009 iriam\u2009 acreditar\u2009 que\u2009 nós\u2009 acreditaríamos\u2009 naquilo\u2009 que\u2009 vocês\u2009 disseram\u201d.\u2009
Essa\u2009experiência\u2009 foi\u2009o\u2009objeto\u2009de\u2009um\u2009curto\u2009documentário\u2009 retomando\u2009os\u2009diversos\u2009momentos\u2009do\u2009
procedimento,\u2009inclusive\u2009as\u2009entrevistas\u2009(DEMORCY;\u2009DESPRET;\u2009STENGERS,\u20091999).

16\u2009A\u2009fim\u2009de\u2009lembrar,\u2009a\u2009experiência\u2009de\u2009Milgram\u2009(1975)\u2009consistia\u2009em\u2009fazer\u2009os\u2009sujeitos\u2009acreditarem\u2009que\u2009
eles\u2009deviam\u2009eletrocutar\u2009outras\u2009pessoas\u2009em\u2009uma\u2009experiência\u2009de\u2009aprendizagem.\u2009Ler\u2009a\u2009apaixonante\u2009
pesquisa\u2009 conduzida\u2009 junto\u2009 aos\u2009 sujeitos\u2009 da\u2009 experiência,\u2009 40\u2009 anos\u2009 depois,\u2009 por\u2009 Ian\u2009 Parker\u2009 (2000),\u2009
descobrindo\u2009para\u2009sua\u2009grande\u2009perplexidade\u2009que\u2009muitos\u2009desses\u2009sujeitos\u2009haviam\u2009compreendido\u2009que\u2009
deviam\u2009participar\u2009de\u2009uma\u2009espécie\u2009de\u2009jogos\u2009de\u2009papéis,\u2009e\u2009\u201cpelo\u2009bem\u2009da\u2009ciência\u201d\u2009não\u2009haviam\u2009deixado\u2009
nada transparecer.

17\u2009Essa\u2009hipótese\u2009já\u2009havia\u2009sido\u2009formulada\u2009pelo\u2009psicólogo\u2009Carl\u2009Stumpf,\u2009colega\u2009de\u2009Pfungst,\u2009em\u2009uma\u2009
primeira\u2009pesquisa.\u2009O\u2009fato\u2009de\u2009Stumpf\u2009ter\u2009conduzido\u2009pesquisas\u2009a\u2009respeito\u2009de\u2009hipnose,\u2009não\u2009é\u2009sem\u2009
dúvida\u2009estranho\u2009a\u2009essa\u2009intuição.\u2009

18\u2009Poderíamos\u2009 evidentemente\u2009 considerar\u2009 para\u2009 dar\u2009 conta\u2009 do\u2009 contraste,\u2009 aquilo\u2009 que\u2009 propõe\u2009Mikkel\u2009
Borch-Jakobsen\u2009(2006b):\u2009quando\u2009se\u2009trata\u2009de\u2009objetos\u2009simples\u2009como\u2009os\u2009comportamentos\u2009próximos\u2009
das\u2009atividades\u2009perceptivas\u2009ou\u2009do\u2009reflexo,\u2009isto\u2009é,\u2009de\u2009atividades\u2009que\u2009escapam\u2009à\u2009vontade\u2009de\u2009sujeitos,\u2009
o\u2009experimentador\u2009poderia\u2009se\u2009sentir\u2009liberto\u2009das\u2009ameaças\u2009das\u2009expectativas.\u2009A\u2009maneira\u2009como\u2009Pfungst\u2009
distribui\u2009a\u2009opacidade\u2009e\u2009a\u2009visibilidade\u2009de\u2009suas\u2009experiências,\u2009da\u2009qual\u2009Wundt\u2009considera\u2009o\u2009problema,\u2009

Leitura\u2009etnopsicológica\u2009do\u2009segredo

Fractal:\u2009 Revista\u2009 de\u2009 Psicologia,\u2009 v.\u2009 23\u2009 \u2013\u2009 n.\u2009 1,\u2009 p.\u2009 5-28,\u2009 Jan./Abr.\u2009 2011\u2009 \u2009 \u2009 \u2009 \u2009 \u2009 \u2009 \u2009 \u2009 27

me\u2009parecem\u2009responder\u2009a\u2009outras\u2009questões.
19\u2009As\u2009informações\u2009a\u2009respeito\u2009da\u2009prática\u2009de\u2009Wundt\u2009são\u2009provenientes\u2009de\u2009Kurt\u2009Danziger,\u2009Constructing

the Subject.\u2009Cambridge\u2009:\u2009Cambridge\u2009University\u2009Press,\u20091990.
20\u2009Reencontraremos\u2009aqui\u2009a\u2009influência\u2009de\u2009William\u2009James\u2009(1998)\u2009e\u2009de\u2009seu\u2009pragmatismo.

referências

BARRETT,\u2009R.\u2009La Traite des fous:\u2009 la\u2009construction\u2009sociale\u2009de\u2009 la\u2009 schizophrénie.\u2009
Paris:\u2009Les\u2009Empêcheurs\u2009de\u2009penser\u2009en\u2009rond,\u20091998.

BORCH-JAKOBSEN,\u2009M.\u2009B.\u2009Folie à plusieurs.\u2009Paris:\u2009Les\u2009Empêcheurs\u2009de\u2009penser\u2009
en\u2009rond,\u20092002.

BORCH-JAKOBSEN,\u2009M.\u2009Constructivisme et psychanalyse:\u2009débat\u2009entre\u2009Mikkel\u2009
Borch-Jacobsen\u2009et\u2009Georges\u2009Fischman.\u2009Paris:\u2009Le\u2009Cavalier\u2009Bleu,\u20092006a.\u2009Debate\u2009
entre\u2009os\u2009dois\u2009autores\u2009animado\u2009por\u2009B.\u2009Granger

BORCH-JAKOBSEN,\u2009 M.\u2009 L\u2019inconscient\u2009 simulé.\u2009 In:\u2009 NATHAN,\u2009 T.\u2009 (Org.).\u2009 La
guerre des psys:\u2009manifeste\u2009 pour\u2009 une\u2009 psychothérapie\u2009 démocratique.\u2009 Paris:\u2009 Les\u2009
Empêcheurs\u2009de\u2009penser\u2009en\u2009rond,\u20092006b.\u2009p.\u200931-64.

CHAUVENET,\u2009A.;\u2009DESPRET,\u2009V.;\u2009LEMAIRE,\u2009J.\u2009M.\u2009Clinique de la reconstruction:
une\u2009expérience\u2009avec\u2009des\u2009réfugiés\u2009en\u2009ex-Yougoslavie.\u2009Paris:\u2009L\u2019Harmattan,\u20091996.

DANZIGER,\u2009K.\u2009Constructing the subject.\u2009 Cambridge:\u2009 Cambridge\u2009University,\u2009
1990.

DEMBO,\u2009T.\u2009The\u2009dynamic\u2009of\u2009Anger.\u2009Tradução\u2009inglesa\u2009de\u2009J.\u2009De\u2009Rivera.\u2009In:\u2009DE\u2009
RIVERA,\u2009J\u2009(Org.).\u2009Field theory as human science.\u2009New-York:\u2009Gardner,\u20091976.\u2009p.\u2009
324-422.\u2009

DEMORCY,\u2009D.;\u2009DESPRET,\u2009V.;\u2009STENGERS,\u2009 I.\u2009The\u2009Valins\u2009experiment:\u20091966-
1999.\u2009 In:\u2009EXPOSIÇÃO\u2009LABORATORIUM,\u2009 jun.\u2009 1999\u2009Anvers.\u2009 Laboratorium.\u2009
Anvers:\u2009[s.n.],\u20091999.

DESPRET,\u2009V.\u2009Ces\u2009émotions\u2009qui\u2009nous\u2009fabriquent.\u2009Paris\u2009:\u2009les\u2009Empêcheurs\u2009de\u2009penser\u2009
en\u2009rond,\u20091999.

DESPRET,\u2009V.\u2009Le\u2009secret\u2009est\u2009une\u2009dimension\u2009politique\u2009de\u2009la\u2009thérapie.\u2009In:\u2009NATHAN,\u2009
T.\u2009(Org.).\u2009La guerre des psys:\u2009manifeste\u2009pour\u2009une\u2009psychothérapie\u2009démocratique.\u2009
Paris:\u2009Les\u2009Empêcheurs\u2009de\u2009penser\u2009en\u2009rond,\u20092006.\u2009p.\u2009153-178.

DESPRET,\u2009V.\u2009Hans, le cheval qui savait compter.\u2009 Paris:\u2009 Les\u2009 Empêcheurs\u2009 de\u2009
penser\u2009en\u2009rond,\u20092004.

DESPRET,\u2009 V.\u2009 Ces émotions qui nous fabriquent:\u2009 ethnopsychologie\u2009 de\u2009
l\u2019authenticité.\u2009Paris:\u2009Les\u2009Empêcheurs\u2009de\u2009penser\u2009en\u2009rond,\u20091999.

Vinciane Despret

28\u2009 \u2009 \u2009 \u2009 \u2009 \u2009 \u2009 \u2009 \u2009 Fractal:\u2009 Revista\u2009 de\u2009 Psicologia,\u2009 v.\u2009 23\u2009 \u2013\u2009 n.\u2009 1, p.\u2009 5-28,\u2009 Jan./Abr.\u2009 2011

DUYCKAERT,\u2009F.\u2009Les fondements de la psychothérapie.\u2009Bruxelles:\u2009De\u2009boeck,\u2009
1999.

ELLENBERGER,\u2009H.\u2009Les Médecines de l\u2019âme.\u2009Paris:\u2009Fayard,\u20091995.

FOUCAULT,\u2009M.\u2009Histoire de la sexualitté 1:\u2009la\u2009volonté\u2009de\u2009savoir.\u2009Paris:\u2009Gallimard,\u2009
1976.

GOLDSTEIN,\u2009J.\u2009Consoler et classifier:\u2009l\u2019essor\u2009de\u2009la\u2009psychiatrie\u2009française.\u2009Paris:\u2009
Les\u2009Empêcheurs\u2009de\u2009penser\u2009en\u2009rond,\u20091997.

HACKING,\u2009I.\u2009Rewriting the soul.\u2009New\u2009Jersey:\u2009Princeton,\u20091995.

JAMES,\u2009W.\u2009La signification de la vérité.\u2009Tradução\u2009Collectif\u2009DHPI.\u2009Lausanne:\u2009
Antipodes,\u20091998.

KLEINMAN\u2009A.\u2009Patients and healers in the context of culture:\u2009 an\u2009exploration\u2009
of\u2009 the\u2009 borderland\u2009 between\u2009Anthropology,\u2009Medecine\u2009 and\u2009Psychiatry.\u2009Berkeley:\u2009
University\u2009of\u2009California,\u20091981.

LUTZ,\u2009C.\u2009La dépression est-elle universelle?.\u2009Paris:\u2009Les\u2009Empêcheurs\u2009de\u2009penser\u2009
en\u2009rond,\u20092004.

MELCHIOR,\u2009T.\u2009Guérir\u2009par\u2009la\u2009verité.\u2009In:\u2009NATHAN,\u2009T.\u2009(Org.).\u2009La guerre des psys:
manifeste\u2009 pour\u2009 une\u2009 psychothérapie\u2009 démocratique.\u2009 Paris:\u2009 Les\u2009 Empêcheurs\u2009 de\u2009
penser\u2009en\u2009rond,\u20092006.\u2009p.\u200965-100.

MILGRAM,\u2009S.\u2009Obedience to Authority.\u2009New\u2009York:\u2009Perennial\u2009books,\u20091975.

NATHAN,\u2009T.;\u2009STENGERS,\u2009I.\u2009Médecins et sorciers.\u2009Paris:\u2009Les\u2009Empêcheurs\u2009de\u2009
penser\u2009en\u2009rond,\u20091995.

NATHAN,\u2009T.\u2009Nous ne sommes pas seuls au monde.\u2009Paris:\u2009Les\u2009Empêcheurs\u2009de\u2009
penser\u2009en\u2009rond,\u20092001.

PARKER,\u2009I.\u2009Obedience.\u2009Granta: Shrink,\u2009Cambridge,\u2009v.\u200971,\u2009autumn.\u20092000.\u2009p.\u2009101-
125.

PENEFF,\u2009J.\u2009France malade de ses médecins.\u2009Paris:\u2009Les\u2009Empêcheurs\u2009de\u2009penser\u2009
en\u2009rond,\u20092005.

PIGNARRE,\u2009 P.\u2009Comment la dépression est devenue une épidémie.\u2009 Paris:\u2009 La\u2009
découverte,\u20092001.

Recebido\u2009em:\u2009setembro\u2009de\u20092010

Aceito\u2009em:\u2009dezembro\u2009de\u20092010