Baixe o app para aproveitar ainda mais
Prévia do material em texto
Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at https://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=tjar20 Journal of Apicultural Research ISSN: 0021-8839 (Print) 2078-6913 (Online) Journal homepage: https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/tjar20 Effects of Supernumerary Corpora Allata and Farnesol Compounds on Ovary Development in the Worker Honeybee Ber-Lin Chai & R. W. Shuel To cite this article: Ber-Lin Chai & R. W. Shuel (1970) Effects of Supernumerary Corpora Allata and Farnesol Compounds on Ovary Development in the Worker Honeybee, Journal of Apicultural Research, 9:1, 19-27, DOI: 10.1080/00218839.1970.11100240 To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/00218839.1970.11100240 Published online: 24 Mar 2015. Submit your article to this journal Article views: 3 View related articles Citing articles: 9 View citing articles https://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=tjar20 https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/tjar20 https://www.tandfonline.com/action/showCitFormats?doi=10.1080/00218839.1970.11100240 https://doi.org/10.1080/00218839.1970.11100240 https://www.tandfonline.com/action/authorSubmission?journalCode=tjar20&show=instructions https://www.tandfonline.com/action/authorSubmission?journalCode=tjar20&show=instructions https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/mlt/10.1080/00218839.1970.11100240 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/mlt/10.1080/00218839.1970.11100240 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/citedby/10.1080/00218839.1970.11100240#tabModule https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/citedby/10.1080/00218839.1970.11100240#tabModule 19 Journal of Apicultural Research 9(1) : 19-27 (1970) EFFECTS OF SUPERNUMERARY CORPORA ALLATA AND FARNESOL COMPOUNDS ON OVARY DEVELOPMENT IN THE WORKER HONEYBEE BER-LIN CHAI* AND R. w. SHUEL Department of Apiculture, University of Guelph, Guelph, Canada Manuscript received for publication 16 December 1969 Summary Implantation into a 4-day worker larva of corpora allata from a queen larva 3 or 4 days old was followed by a reduction in the extent of ovary regression in the prepupal and pupal stages. The average number of ovarioles in adults developing from treated larvae was increased by several times, but no oocytes developed. Corpora allata from a worker larva had no effect on ovary regression. Injection of farnesol or farnesyl methyl ether did not affect the number of ovarioles but did result in the development of oocytes. The prepupal period was lengthened both by supernumerary corpora allata from queen larvae and by farnesol compounds. Results were consistent with a hypothesis of endocrine control of retrogressive changes in the worker reproductive system. Introduction Queens and workers of the honeybee (Apis mel/ifera) differ strikingly in the develop- ment of their reproductive organs. Zander et al. (1916) reported appreciable differ- ences in ovary size as early as 48 hours. Wang and Shuel (1965), however, in an examination of large numbers of larvae whose ages had been estimated to within ±4 hours, found very little difference between queen and worker larvae with respect to ovary volumes or numbers of egg tubules before the completion of caste deter- mination (around 84 hours). Thereafter development is very rapid in the queen. At maturity each of her large pear-shaped ovaries contains some 160-180 egg tubules or ovarioles (Oertel, 1930). Reproductive development in the worker is arrested early in the fifth instar, and the ovaries regress during the prepupal and pupal stages (Zander et al., 1916). Egg tubules are reduced in number from more than 100 to 3 or 4 in each ovary, and the ovaries themselves are thin and shrunken (Oertel, 1916). The rest of the reproductive system appears equally rudimentary. Despite its rudimentary appearance, however, the reproductive system of the adult worker can become functional to a limited degree. When the supply of queen substance in the colony is lacking or deficient, oocytes may develop in the ovarioles of the worker, and she may lay a few unfertilized eggs (Ribbands, 1953). Although the retrogressive changes in the reproductive system of the worker honeybee can be ascribed to diet, the physiology of the changes has received little attention. Ligation experiments by l'Helias (1950, 1952), Schaller (1952) and Lukoschus (1955) have confirmed for the honeybee the classic pattern of endocrine control of metamorphosis. From the analogy between metamorphosis and poly- morphism (Wigglesworth, 1954) one might expect the latter, like the former, to be under endocrine control. Shuel and Dixon (1959, 1960) suggested that in the honey- bee the endocrine system mediates between diet and form, in the initiation of caste differences during the first 3 or 3-! days of larval life, and in the completion of these * Present Address: Department of Zoology, University of Toronto 20 differences in the post-determination period. During the period of caste determi- nation the likely candidate organ for the role of intermediary is the corpus allatum, the only endocrine organ in which conspicuous caste differences are visible (Canetti et al., 1964). Differences in other endocrine organs are apparent at 96 hours (Ritcey, 1969). Canetti et al. interpreted caste differences in size and appearance as indicative of greater activity in the corpora allata of the queen larva. In addition to their role in maintaining juvenile characters throughout insect larval moults, the corpora allata produce a secretion, believed to be identical with the juvenile hormone (Wigglesworth, 1964) which induces yolk formation in the adult female of Rhodnius prolixus (Wiggles- worth, 1936) and is involved in lipid and protein metabolism during ovary development in many insects (Pfeiffer, 1945; Strangways-Dixon, 1961; Highnam et al., 1963; Thomas & Nation, 1966). Juvenile hormone activity has been found in a number of chemicals, notably farnesol and its methyl ether derivative (Wigglesworth, 1963). Recently the juvenile hormone of Hyalophora cecropia has been identified as methyl 1 O-epoxy-7ethyl-3, ll-dimethyl-2, 6-tridecadienoate (Roller et al., 1967). To test the possibility that the retrogressive changes in worker ovaries are under endocrine control, we attempted to change the natural hormonal balance through implantation of supernumerary corpora allata or the injection of farnesol and its methyl ether into larvae 4 days old. As criteria of experimental effects we recorded changes in the appearance of the reproductive system and increases in numbers of ovarioles. We also recorded certain secondary data related to characteristic patterns of queen and worker development, i.e. patterns of cocoon spinning and larval orientation in the cell, and the duration of larval, prepupal, and pupal stages. Materials and Methods Collection of larvae and larval food Larvae were taken from colonies in the apiary during the summer months and from indoor flight rooms during cold weather. Queen larvae were obtained by transferring larvae 6-12 hours old from worker cells to artificial queen cups in nurse colonies. Fresh royal jelly and worker jelly were collected by aspiration from 3-day queen cells and 1- to 3-day worker cells respectively. Implantation of corpora a/lata The donor larvae were placed in a dissecting dish with the ventral side up, and the head was pushed forward by placing a pin across the neck. A drop of sterile saline* was placed on the head. The neck was cut open with a fine scalpel, exposing the corpora allata under the tentorium, and the corpora allata were cut loose with scissors and sucked up into a capillary tube. The host larva was cut at the second thoracic segment, the tip of the capillary inserted into the incision and the corpora allata discharged. The incision was sealed with agar heated to 60°C. Instruments used in the operation were sterilized with alcohol. The earliest age at which larvae could be operated was about 4 days, when theyweighed around 60 mg. Younger larvae died from injuries or bleeding. Sham- operated controls and untreated controls were included in each experiment. Injection of farnesol compounds Farnesyl methyl ether was prepared from 99·1 % commercial farnesol by the William- son synthesis (Hill & Kelly, 1944). Purified peanut oil was used as a carrier for * 0·9% saline containing 0·1 % penicillin, 0·1 % erythromycin and 0·15% phenolphthalein 21 both farnesol and its methyl ether. Injections were made into the intersegmental suture on either side of the mid-ventral line of the thorax, using a 50 jlg micrometer- driven syringe. Half-microlitre volumes containing 2·2 or 4·4 jlg of the farnesol compound were used. Larger doses of farnesol killed the larvae within a few days. Peanut oil alone was injected into the sham-operated controls. Post-operative care of larvae After surgical treatment larvae were placed in artificial beeswax cells in desiccators at 35°C and 97% relative humidity. They were fed either royal jelly or an amended worker jelly containing 120 mg per gram of glucose and fructose in equal parts. The composition of the latter diet is close to that of modified worker jelly, the diet of older worker larvae (Shuel & Dixon, 1959, 1968). We were not able to obtain enough modified worker jelly from 4-day worker cells. At the beginning of defaecation, larvae were washed with warm water, dried, and placed horizontally in 1 x 3-mm pupation cells capped with tissue paper. The relative humidity was reduced to 80% for pupation and to 60% thereafter. Examination of ovaries The fixative of Weaver and Thomas (1956) was used to preserve the material for dissection. A median longitudinal incision was made in the first four abdominal segments with a scalpel and fine tweezers, under a x 20 binocular dissecting micro- scope. The eight dorsal plates were removed to expose the adipose tissue, digestive organs and ovaries. The method described by Hess (1942) was followed for ovariole counts. Statistical methods As ovariole counts deviated from the normal distribution, the range being propor- tional to the mean, a logarithmic transformation (Steel & Torrie, 1960) was applied to the data before analysing them. Data on the relative duration of each developmental stage were changed to percentages and compared by the x2 test. Analysis of variance was used to evaluate treatment differences in total times to emergence. Results General appearance of the reproductive system Because of the difficulty of obtaining clear photographs, the ovaries of an adult bee developing from a worker larva fed on the worker jelly + sugar diet and implanted with a pair of corpora allata from a queen larva 3 days old are shown diagrammatically (Fig. 1 ), with ovaries of a normal untreated worker adult and a queen for comparison. There was a partial development of the ovaries in the treated individuals, though it was limited in comparison with development in a queen. No oocytes could be seen in the ovarioles. The spermatheca was rudimentary though somewhat larger than in the control groups. Development in individuals receiving corpora allata from queen larvae 4 days old was very similar. Ovaries in the unoperated and sham- operated bees were much reduced in size and hardly traceable among the surrounding tracheae. The ovarioles of larvae fed on royal jelly and implanted with queen corpora allata were longer and more closely packed than those fed on worker jelly and sugar. Like the latter, they contained no oocytes. 22 The ovaries of bees developing from larvae injected with farnesol or farnesyl methyl ether were much smaller than those of bees that had been given corpora allata implants, but-in contrast to the ovaries of the implanted bees--some of the ovarioles contained oocytes (Fig. 2), and were thus atypical of either caste. w ow Q FIG. 1. (left) Diagrams showing comparative ovary development in a normal adult worker (W), in an adult developed from a worker implanted with corpora allata from a 3-day queen larva (OW), and in an adult queen with fully matured ovaries (Q). FIG. 2. (right) Oocytes in ovarioles of worker honeybees developed from larvae injected with 4·4 Jlg of famesyl methyl ether. Ovariole counts Quantitative data on survival and ovariole development are recorded in Tables 1-4. Survival of operated bees was very poor. Operated individuals were especially sensitive to jarring or to slight changes in temperature at the time of the prepupal moult. Surgery without implantation was somewhat less injurious. Injection with farnesol also reduced survival, though not as drastically as surgery. Bees injected with the peanut oil carrier alone survived better than those receiving farnesol compounds. Numbers of ovarioles varied greatly in both treated and control groups. Despite this variability, it can be seen from Tables I and 2 that the average number of ovarioles was substantially higher in the groups receiving supernumerary corpora allata from queen larvae than in the untreated and sham-operated groups. Results with queen donors 3 and 4 days old were similar, but treatment with corpora allata from 3-day larvae produced more ovarioles. Implantation with corpora allata from 3-day worker larvae had little or no effect on the ovariole count (Table 3), nor did injection with farnesol or farnesyl methyl ether (Table 4). Control groups fed on royal jelly had more ovarioles than controls on the worker diet (means 18·8 and 9·5 respectively, P<0·005). Effects on other aspects of development Larvae receiving queen corpora allata discharged their faeces earlier than those in the control groups. The silk was light yellow, resembling the silk of queens more than that of workers. Control larvae lay on their backs facing the cell capping in the normal fashion 23 of workers (Jay, 1963), but treated larvae varied in their orientation. Some lay on their sides facing the capped end, whereas others faced the cell base. Similar variability was seen in larvae injected with farnesol compounds. Duration of development Bees receiving corpora allata from 3- or 4-day queen larvae entered the prepupal stage earlier than the controls, but they remained as prepupae longer, with the result TABLE l. Implantation of corpora allata from queen larvae into 4-day worker larvae fed on worker jelly with added sugar. No. ovarioles in adults Age No. No. Statistical of donor larvae surviving Mean Range significance 3 days 0: 815 8 71·9 ± 13-21 19-141 O>S,C S: 504 8 9·0 ± 2·89 1-28 P<0·005 C: 129 13 6·3 ± 1·39 2-13 4 days 0:224 5 35·2 ± 3·24 26-46 O>S,C S: 61 5 8·2 ± 1·90 4-16 P<0·005 C: 20 5 9·6 ± 1·97 2-15 0: operated; S: sham-operated control; C: unoperated control TABLE 2. Implantation of corpora allata from queen larvae into 4-day worker larvae fed on royal jelly. No. ovarioles in adults Age No. No. Statistical of donor larvae surviving Mean Range significance 3 days 0:229 4 72-5± 1·95 33-113 O>S,C S: 117 4 18·0 ± 8·95 2-48 P<0·025 C: 32 6 41·3 ± 20·40 3-92 4 days 0: 128 4 61·5 ± 16·07 19-120 O>S,C S: 33 4 10·8 ± 2-36 3-15 P<0·025 C: 12 5 13-4 ± 4·78 1-27 0: operated; S: sham-operated control; C: unoperated control 24 that the total time until emergence ofthe adult was longer than in the controls (Fig. 3). Implantation of corpora allata from worker larvae had no effect on the duration of development. The extension of the prepupal stage, and the total time to emergence, were especially pronounced in the injected bees, being about two days. In no instance was the length of the pupal stadium changed by the experimental treatment. In both operated and injected groups total developmental time was shorter on the royal jelly than on the worker jelly + sugar diet. TABLE 3. Implantation of corpora allata from 3-day worker larvae into 4-day worker larvae. No. ovarioles in adults No. No. StatisticalDiet larvae surviving Mean Range significance Worker jelly 0: 163 5 5·0 ± 1·03 1-10 with added S: 42 5 5·6 ± 1·05 2-11 P>0·10 sugar C: 25 5 4·1 ± 0·89 1-9 Royal jelly 0: 77 4 11·0 ± 1·06 7-16 S: 39 4 13·8 ± 1·42 6-21 P>O·IO C: 14 4 14·0 ± 0·78 10-17 0: operated; S: sham-operated control; C: unoperated control TABLE 4. Injection of farnesol and farnesyl methyl ether into 4-day worker larvae. No. ovarioles in adults No. No. Statistical Diet Treatment larvae surviving Mean Range significance Worker jelly 4·4 )lg 0: 30 4 6·3 ± 1·64 2-11 with added farnesol S: 15 4 10·0 ± 0·93 5-20 P>0·1 sugar C: lO 6 7·0 ± 1·38 2-11 Worker jelly 4·4 Jlg 0: 120 6 14·8 ± 3·10 6-26 with added farnesyl S: 35 6 6·2 ± 1·71 3-15 P>0·1 sugar methyl C: 10 6 5·8 ± 0·87 3-10 ether Royal jelly 4·4 )lg 0: 30 4 10·7 ± 3-80 1-9 farnesol S: 15 4 7·7 ± 2·11 3-14 P>0·1 C: 10 4 22·7 ± 8·33 3-48 Royal jelly 4·4 Jlg 0: 30 4 54·2 ± 14-40 29-103 farnesyl S: 15 4 47·5 ± 16·10 16-94 P>0·1 methyl C: 10 4 26·8 ± 13·70 4-73 ether ... z Ill ~ 15 ... ct Ill Ill: t- ., >- ct 5 Q QUEEN CORP. ALL . WORKER CORP. ALL. ' i 111111 ... 0 5 c Cl 0 5 c b 0 5 c c 0 5 c d 25 FARNESYL M. E. II 0 5 c • II 0 5 c f FIG. 3. Effect on duration of development stages in worker bees (L=larval, PP=prepupal, P=pupal) of the following: a, b - implanting 3-day queen corpora allata c, d - implanting 3-day worker corpora allata e, f - injecting 4·4 Jlg famesyl methyl ether O=operated; S=sham-operated; C=control WJS=worker jelly and sugar; RJ =royal jelly Statistical significances are: for total time to emergence of adults in a, e, f: O>S,C (P<O·OI) for relative duration of developmental stages in a, b, e, f: P<0·05 inc, d: P>O·IO Discussion and Conclusions Retrogression of the reproductive system of the worker honeybee normally begins about the fifth day of larval life, after the caste has been determined. Implantation of a pair of corpora allata from a queen larva 3 or 4 days old into a worker larva 4 days old reduced the degree of retrogressive development. Implantation of corpora allata from 3-day worker larvae failed to produce a like effect. One may infer from these observations (I) that the corpora allata of the queen are involved in the post- determination development of her reproductive system, and (2) that the corpora allata of the worker are less active in promoting reproductive development than 26 those of the queen. The histological evidence of Canetti et al. (1964) is thereby substantiated. The reduction in the usual retrogressive process in the workers was limited, however, to a partial development of only about one-quarter of the number of egg tubules normally found in the queen. Three possible reasons for the limited success of the experimental treatment come to mind: (I) the transplanted corpora allata had less than their normal in situ activity; (2) the ovaries of the host larvae had lost most of their capacity for progressive development at 4 days of age; (3) other en- docrine organs in the host larvae (whose activation may be essential for complete ovary development) may no longer have been competent at 4 days of age. Lukoschus (1952) observed a rapid development of the prothoracic glands in the queen around 4 days, and Ritcey (1969) observed a marked reduction in size of the neurosecretory cells of queen larvae-which she interpreted as indicating a massive release of neuro- secretion-around 96 hours. Possibly our operation came too late to precipitate a similar event in the host larvae. It is unfortunate that technical difficulties prevented an earlier operation. There is abundant evidence (reviewed by Shuel and Dixon, 1960) that the diet supplied to the queen or the worker cell during early larval life sets the stage for post- determination events. A comparison of ovary development in control groups fed on worker jelly - sugar and on royal jelly diets in both the corpora allata and the farnesol experiments indicates that some dietary influence persists into the post- determination period. The occurrence of ovary regression soon after the worker diet is modified by a large addition of honey is probably a coincidence rather than evidence of a cause-effect relationship. The qualitative difference between corpora allata and farnesol effects on ovary development-the first increasing ovariole number, the second stimulating oocyte maturation-is surprising, and it suggests that more than one hormone may be involved in the regulation of ovary development. Corpora allata implantation and farnesol injection had similar effects on the timing of the late developmental stages. Fukaya and Mitsuhashi (1961) found that farnesol prolonged the developmental period of Periplaneta americana from 17 to 30 days. The experimental effects on ovariole numbers are consistent with a hypothesis of endocrine control over retrogressive changes in the reproductive system of the worker honeybee. The fact that our treatments made worker larvae more queen- like in one respect (reproductive development) and less queen-like in another (length of the developmental period) underlines the complexity of the endocrine influence on caste development. Acknowledgements We are indebted to Dr. S. E. Dixon, Department of Zoology, University of Guelph, for the corpora allata implantation technique, and to Dr. M. V. Smith and Mr. A. Adie, Department of Apiculture, for help in procuring material. This work, which formed part of a thesis by the senior author for the M.Sc. degree, was supported by the Ontario Department of Food and Agriculture and the National Research Council of Canada. References BEAMENT, J. W. L., TREHERNE, J. E. & WIGGLESWORTH, V. B. (ed.) (1964) Advances in insect physiology. Volume 2. London : Academic Press 27 CANEITI, S. J., SHUEL, R. W. & DIXON, S. E. (1964) Studies in the mode of action of royal jelly in honeybee development. IV. Development within the brain and retrocerebral complex of female honeybee larvae. Can. J. Zoo/. 42 : 229-233 + 3 plates FUKAYA, M. & MITSUHASHI, J. (1961) [The activity of the corpora allata during the diapause.] Bull. natn. Inst. agric. Sci., Tokyo 13 In Japanese HEss, G. (1942) Ober den Einfluss der Weisellosigkeit und des Fruchtbarkeitsvitamins E auf die Ovarien der Bienenarbeiterin. (Ein Beitrag zur Frage der Regulationen im Bienenstaat). Beih. schweiz. Bienenztg 1(2) : 33-110 HIGHMAN, K. c., LUSIS, 0. & HILL, L. T. (1963) The role of the corpora allata during oocyte growth in the desert locust, Schistocerca gregaria Forsk. J. Insect Physiol. 9 : 587-596 HILL, G. A. & KELLY, L. (1944) Organic chemistry. Philadelphia: Blakiston Company JAY, S. G. (1963) The longitudinal orientation of larval honeybees (Apis mellifera) in their cells. Can. J. Zoo/. 41 : 717-723 + I plate L'HELIAS, C. (1950) Etude des glandes endocrines post-cerebrales et du cerveau de Ia larve d'Apis mellifica. Bull. Soc. zoo!. Fr. 77 : 191-195 LuKOSCHUS, F. (1952) Ober die Prothoraxdrlise der Honigbiene (Apis mellifica L.). Natunvissen- schaften 39(5) : 116 only --- (1955) Untersuchungen zur Metamorphose der Honigbienc (Apis mellifica L.). Insectes soc. 2(2) : 147-162 OERTEL, E. (1930) Metamorphosis in the honeybee. J. Morph. 50(2) : 295-339 PFEIFFER, I. W. (1945) Effect of the corpora allata on the metabolism of adult female grasshoppers. J. exp. Zoot. 99 : 183-233 RIBBANDS, R. (1953) The behaviour and social life of honeybees. London : Bee Research Associa- tion Ltd RITCEY, G. M. (1969) Histology of the endocrine system of the female honeybee larva, Apis mellifera L. University a/Guelph: M.Sc. Thesis RoLLER, H., DAHM, K. H., SWEELY, C. C. & TROST, B. M. (1967) The structure of the juvenile hormone. Angew. Chem. 6(2): 179-180 ScHALLER, F. (1952) Effets d'une ligature postcephalique sur le developpement des larves agees d'Apis mellifica L. Bull. Soc. zoo/. Fr. 77(2/3) : 195-204SHUEL, R. W. & DIXON, S. E. (1959) Studies in the mode of action of royal jelly in honeybee development. II. Respiration of newly emerged larvae on various substrates. Can. J. Zoot. 37 : 803-813 --- (1960) The early establishment of dimorphism in the female honeybee, Apis metlifera L. Insectes soc. 7(3) : 265-282 --- (1968) The importance of sugar for the pupation of the worker honeybee. J. apic. Res. 7(3) : 109-112 STEEL, R. G. D. & TORRIE, J. H. (1960) Principles and procedures of statistics. New York : McGraw Hill Book Company, Inc. STRANGWAYS-DIXON, J. (1962) The relationship between nutrition, hormones, and reproduction in the blowfly, Calliphora erythrocephala (Meig.). III. The corpus allatum in relation to nutrition, the ovaries, innervation, and the corpus cardiacum. J. exp. Bioi. 39(2) : 293-306 THOMAS, K. K. & NATION, J. L. (1966) RNA, protein and uric acid content of body tissues of Periplaneta americana (L.) as influenced by corpora allata during ovarian development. Bioi. Bull. 130(3) : 442-449 WANG, DER-1. & SHUEL, R. W. (1965) Studies in the mode of action of royal jelly in honeybee development. V. The influence of diet on ovary development. J. apic. Res. 4(3) : 149-160 WEAVER, N. & THoMAS, R. C. (1955) A fixative for use in dissecting insects. Stain Tech. 31 : 25-26 WIGGLF.SWORTH, V. B. (1936) The function of the corpus allatum in the-growth and reproduction of Rhodnius prolixus. Q. Jl microsc. Sci. 79 : 91-121 --- (1954) The physiology of insect metamorphosis. Cambridge: University Press --- (1963) The juvenile hormone effect of farnesol and some related compounds: quantitative experiments. J. Insect Physiol. 9 : 105-119 ZANDER, E., LosCHEL, F. & MEIER, K. (1916) Die Ausbildung des Geschlechtes bei der Honigbienc (Apis mellifica L.). Z. angew. Ent. 3 : 1-74
Compartilhar