Baixe o app para aproveitar ainda mais
Prévia do material em texto
Aula 01 Raciocínio Lógico p/ TST 2017 (Técnico Judiciário) - Com videoaulas Professor: Arthur Lima Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ?�� $8/$�����/Ï*,&$�'(�352326,d®(6� � 680È5,2� 3È*,1$� ���7HRULD� ��� ���5HVROXomR�GH�TXHVW}HV� ��� ���/LVWD�GDV�TXHVW}HV�DSUHVHQWDGDV�QD�DXOD�� ��� ���*DEDULWR� ��� � 2Oi�� � +RMH�FRPHoDPRV�R�HVWXGR�GR�VHJXLQWH�DVVXQWR�� � &RPSUHHQVmR�GR�SURFHVVR�OyJLFR�TXH��D�SDUWLU�GH�XP�FRQMXQWR�GH� KLSyWHVHV��FRQGX]��GH�IRUPD�YiOLGD��D�FRQFOXV}HV�GHWHUPLQDGDV�� � &RVWXPR� FKDPDU� HVWHV� WHPDV� VLPSOHVPHQWH� GH� ³OyJLFD� SURSRVLFLRQDO´�� RX� ³OyJLFD� GH� SURSRVLo}HV´�� 'HGLFDUHPRV� D� SUy[LPD� DXOD� SDUD�UHIRUoDU�R�VHX�HQWHQGLPHQWR�VREUH�RV�DVVXQWRV�TXH�LQLFLDUHPRV�KRMH��� � /HPEUH�VH�GH�VHJXLU�PHX�,QVWDJUDP��RQGH�SRVWR�GLFDV�GLiULDV�SDUD� FRPSOHPHQWDU�VXD�SUHSDUDomR�� ZZZ�LQVWDJUDP�FRP�3URI$UWKXU/LPD�� �#3URI$UWKXU/LPD�� � ���7(25,$� ����,QWURGXomR� � 3DUD�FRPHoDU�HVWH�DVVXQWR��YRFr�SUHFLVD�VDEHU�TXH�XPD�SURSRVLomR� p�XPD�RUDomR�GHFODUDWLYD�TXH�DGPLWD�XP�YDORU�OyJLFR��9�±�YHUGDGHLUR�RX�)� ±�IDOVR���([���$�EROD�p�D]XO��9HMD�TXH�QmR�H[LVWH�PHLR�WHUPR��RX�D�EROD�p� UHDOPHQWH�GH�FRU�D]XO��WRUQDQGR�D�SURSRVLomR�YHUGDGHLUD��RX�D�EROD�p�GH� RXWUD�FRU��VHQGR�D�SURSRVLomR�IDOVD��2EVHUYH�TXH�QHP�WRGD�IUDVH�SRGH�VHU� FRQVLGHUDGD�XPD�SURSRVLomR��3RU�H[HPSOR��D�H[FODPDomR�³%RP�GLD�´�QmR� SRGH�VHU�FODVVLILFDGD�FRPR�YHUGDGHLUD�RX�IDOVD��2�PHVPR�RFRUUH�FRP�DV� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ?�� IUDVHV�³4XDO�R�VHX�QRPH"´�RX�³9i�GRUPLU´��TXH�WDPEpP�QmR�WrP�XP�YDORU� OyJLFR� �9� RX� )��� 1R� HVWXGR� GH� OyJLFD� GH� DUJXPHQWDomR�� XVDPRV� OHWUDV�� �SULQFLSDOPHQWH�S��T�H�U��SDUD�VLPEROL]DU�XPD�SURSRVLomR��� � e� LPSRUWDQWH� WDPEpP� FRQKHFHU� DOJXQV� SULQFtSLRV� UHODWLYRV� jV� SURSRVLo}HV��2�SULQFtSLR�GD�QmR�FRQWUDGLomR�GL]�TXH�XPD�SURSRVLomR�QmR� SRGH�VHU��DR�PHVPR�WHPSR��9HUGDGHLUD�H�)DOVD��2X�XPD�FRLVD�RX�RXWUD�� -i� R� SULQFtSLR� GD� H[FOXVmR� GR� WHUFHLUR� WHUPR� GL]� TXH� QmR� Ki� XP� PHLR� WHUPR� HQWUH�9HUGDGHLUR� RX� )DOVR�� 3RUWDQWR�� VH� WHPRV� XPD� SURSRVLomR� S� �H[HPSOR��³��PDLV���QmR�p�LJXDO�D��´���VDEHPRV�TXH�� �� VH�HVVD� IUDVH�p�YHUGDGHLUD��HQWmR�HOD�QmR�SRGH�VHU� IDOVD��H�YLFH�YHUVD� �QmR�FRQWUDGLomR���H� ��QmR�p�SRVVtYHO�TXH�HVVD� IUDVH� VHMD� ³PHLR�YHUGDGHLUD´�RX� ³PHLR� IDOVD´�� HOD�GHYH�VHU�VRPHQWH�9HUGDGHLUD�RX�VRPHQWH�)DOVD��H[FOXVmR�GR�WHUFHLUR� WHUPR��� � 8PD� REVHUYDomR� LPSRUWDQWH�� QmR� VH� SUHRFXSH� WDQWR� FRP� R� FRQWH~GR�GD�SURSRVLomR��4XHP�QRV�GLUi�VH�D�SURSRVLomR�p�YHUGDGHLUD�RX� IDOVD�p�R�HQXQFLDGR�GR�H[HUFtFLR��$R�UHVROYHU�H[HUFtFLRV�YRFr�YHUi�TXH��D� SULQFtSLR�� FRQVLGHUDPRV� WRGDV� DV� SURSRVLo}HV� IRUQHFLGDV� FRPR� VHQGR� YHUGDGHLUDV�� D�PHQRV� TXH�R� H[HUFtFLR� GLJD� R� FRQWUiULR�� 6H� XP� H[HUFtFLR� GLVVHU�TXH�D�SURSRVLomR�³������ ��´�p�9HUGDGHLUD��YRFr�GHYH�DFHLWDU�LVVR�� DLQGD�TXH�VDLED�TXH�R�FRQWH~GR�GHOD�QmR�p�UHDOPHQWH�FRUUHWR��,VWR�SRUTXH� HVWDPRV�WUDEDOKDQGR�FRP�/yJLFD�IRUPDO�� 9HMDPRV�GXDV�SURSRVLo}HV�H[HPSOLILFDWLYDV�� S��&KRYH�DPDQKm�� T��(X�YRX�j�HVFROD�� � 1RWH�TXH��GH�IDWR��S�H�T�VmR�GXDV�SURSRVLo}HV��SRLV�FDGD�XPD�GHODV� SRGH�VHU�9HUGDGHLUD�RX�)DOVD��� � 'XDV� RX� PDLV� SURSRVLo}HV� SRGHP� VHU� FRPELQDGDV�� FULDQGR� SURSRVLo}HV�FRPSRVWDV��XWLOL]DQGR�SDUD�LVVR�RV�RSHUDGRUHV�OyJLFRV��9DPRV� FRQKHFr�ORV� HVWXGDQGR� DV� SULQFLSDLV� IRUPDV� GH� SURSRVLo}HV� FRPSRVWDV�� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ?�� 3DUD� LVVR�� XVDUHPRV� FRPR� H[HPSOR� DV� GXDV� SURSRVLo}HV� TXH� Mi� YLPRV� DFLPD��9HMDPRV�FRPR�SRGHPRV�FRPELQi�ODV�� �� D��&RQMXQomR� �³H´��� WUDWD�VH� GH� XPD� FRPELQDomR� GH� SURSRVLo}HV� XVDQGR�R�RSHUDGRU� OyJLFR�³H´��RX�VHMD��GR� WLSR�³S�H�T´��3RU�H[HPSOR�� ³&KRYH� DPDQKm� H� HX� YRX� j� HVFROD´�� 8WLOL]DPRV� R� VtPEROR� A� SDUD� UHSUHVHQWDU� HVWH� RSHUDGRU�� 2X� VHMD�� DR� LQYpV� GH� HVFUHYHU� ³S� H� T´�� SRGHPRV�HVFUHYHU�³ S T ´�� 9HMD� TXH�� DR� GL]HU� TXH� ³&KRYH� DPDQKm� H� HX� YRX� j� HVFROD´�� HVWRX� DILUPDQGR� TXH� DV� GXDV� FRLVDV� DFRQWHFHP� �FKRYHU� H� LU� j� HVFROD��� (P� RXWUDV�SDODYUDV��HVWD�SURSRVLomR�FRPSRVWD�Vy�SRGH�VHU�9HUGDGHLUD�VH�DV� GXDV� SURSRVLo}HV� VLPSOHV� TXH� D� FRPS}HP� IRUHP� YHUGDGHLUDV�� LVWR� p�� DFRQWHFHUHP��6H�FKRYHU�H��PHVPR�DVVLP��HX�QmR� IRU�j�HVFROD��VLJQLILFD� TXH� D� FRQMXQomR� DFLPD� p� )DOVD�� 'D� PHVPD� IRUPD�� VH� QmR� FKRYHU� H� PHVPR� DVVLP� HX� IRU� j� HVFROD�� D� H[SUHVVmR� DFLPD� WDPEpP� p� )DOVD��� 3RUWDQWR��SDUD�DQDOLVDU�VH�D�SURSRVLomR�FRPSRVWD�p�9HUGDGHLUD�RX�)DOVD�� GHYHPRV�ROKDU�FDGD�XPD�GDV�SURSRVLo}HV�TXH�D�FRPS}HP��-i�YLPRV�TXH� VH� S� DFRQWHFH� �S� p� 9HUGDGHLUD�� H� T� DFRQWHFH� �T� p� 9HUGDGHLUD��� D� H[SUHVVmR�S�H�T�p�9HUGDGHLUD��(VWD�p�D�SULPHLUD�OLQKD�GD�WDEHOD�DEDL[R��-i� VH�S�DFRQWHFH��9���LVWR�p��VH�FKRYH��H�T�QmR�DFRQWHFH��)���RX�VHMD��HX�QmR� YRX�j�HVFROD��D�H[SUHVVmR�LQWHLUD�WRUQD�VH�IDOVD��,VWR�WDPEpP�RFRUUH�VH�S� QmR�DFRQWHFH��)��H�T�DFRQWHFH��9���(VWDV�VmR�DV�GXDV�OLQKDV�VHJXLQWHV�GD� WDEHOD� DEDL[R�� )LQDOPHQWH�� VH� QHP� S� QHP� T� DFRQWHFHP� �DPEDV� VmR� )DOVDV���D�H[SUHVVmR�LQWHLUD�WDPEpP�VHUi�IDOVD��9HMD�HVWD�WDEHOD�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�S� �³&KRYH�DPDQKm´�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�T� �³(X�YRX�j�HVFROD´�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�S�H�T� � S T �� 9� 9� 9� 9� )� )� )� 9� )� )� )� )� � Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ?�� $� WDEHOD� DFLPD� p� FKDPDGD� GH� WDEHOD�YHUGDGH� GD� SURSRVLomR� FRPELQDGD�³S�H�T´��1HVWD�WDEHOD�SRGHPRV�YLVXDOL]DU�TXH�D�~QLFD�IRUPD�GH� WRUQDU� D� SURSRVLomR� YHUGDGHLUD� RFRUUH� TXDQGR� WDQWR� S� TXDQWR� T� VmR� YHUGDGHLUDV�� (� TXH�� SDUD� GHVPHQWL�OD� �WRUQDU� WRGD� D� SURSRVLomR� IDOVD��� EDVWD� SURYDU� TXH� SHOR� PHQRV� XPD� GDV� SURSRVLo}HV� TXH� D� FRPS}HP� p� IDOVD�� � E��'LVMXQomR��³RX´���HVWD�p�XPD�FRPELQDomR�XVDQGR�R�RSHUDGRU�³RX´�� LVWR� p�� ³S� RX� T´� �WDPEpP� SRGHPRV� HVFUHYHU� S T ��� ([��� ³&KRYH� DPDQKm�RX�HX�YRX�j�HVFROD´��� 9HMD�TXH��DR�GL]HU�HVWD� IUDVH��HVWRX�DILUPDQGR�TXH�SHOR�PHQRV�XPD� GDV�FRLVDV�YDL�DFRQWHFHU��FKRYHU�DPDQKm�RX�HX�LU�j�HVFROD��6H�XPD�GHODV� RFRUUHU��Mi�HVWRX�GL]HQGR�D�YHUGDGH��LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWH�GD�RXWUD�RFRUUHU� RX�QmR��$JRUD��VH�QHQKXPD�GHODV�DFRQWHFHU��QmR�FKRYHU�H��DOpP�GLVVR�� HX�QmR�IRU�j�HVFROD���D�PLQKD�IUDVH�HVWDUi�IDOVD��$�WDEHOD�DEDL[R�UHVXPH� HVWDV�SRVVLELOLGDGHV�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�S� �³&KRYH�DPDQKm´�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�T� �³(X�YRX�j�HVFROD´�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�S�RX� T� � S T �� 9� 9� 9� 9� )� 9� )� 9� 9� )� )� )� � &RPR�YRFr�SRGH�YHU�QD�FROXQD�GD�GLUHLWD��D�~QLFD�SRVVLELOLGDGH�GH� XPD�'LVMXQomR�GR� WLSR�S�RX�T�VHU� IDOVD�RFRUUH�TXDQGR�WDQWR�S�TXDQWR�T� QmR�DFRQWHFHP��LVWR�p��VmR�IDOVDV��� � 7DOYH]�YRFr�WHQKD�HVWUDQKDGR�D�SULPHLUD�OLQKD�GD�WDEHOD��1D�OtQJXD� SRUWXJXHVD�� ³RX´� p� XWLOL]DGR� SDUD� UHSUHVHQWDU� DOWHUQDWLYDV� H[FOXGHQWHV� HQWUH�VL��LVWR�p��Vy�XPD�FRLVD�SRGHULD�DFRQWHFHU��FKRYHU�RX�HQWmR�HX�LU�j� HVFROD��� $VVLP�� WDOYH]� YRFr� HVSHUDVVH�TXH�� FDVR� S� IRVVH� YHUGDGHLUD� H�T� WDPEpP� IRVVH� YHUGDGHLUD�� D� IUDVH� LQWHLUD� VHULD� IDOVD�� 9HMD� TXH� LVWR� QmR� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ?�� RFRUUH� DTXL�� 9HUHPRV� LVVR� QR� SUy[LPR� LWHP�� DR� HVWXGDU� D� GLVMXQomR� H[FOXVLYD���� F�� 'LVMXQomR� H[FOXVLYD� �2X� H[FOXVLYR��� HVWD� p� XPD� FRPELQDomR� GR� WLSR�³RX�S�RX�T´��VLPEROL]DGD�SRU� S T ���([���³2X�FKRYH�DPDQKm�RX� HX�YRX�j�HVFROD´�� $TXL�� DR� FRQWUiULR� GD� 'LVMXQomR� TXH� YLPRV� DFLPD�� D� SURSRVLomR� FRPSRVWD� Vy� p� YHUGDGHLUD� VH� XPD� GDV� SURSRVLo}HV� IRU� YHUGDGHLUD� H� D� RXWUD�IRU�IDOVD��,VWR�p��VH�HX�GLJR�³2X�FKRYH�DPDQKm�RX�HX�YRX�j�HVFROD´�� SRUpP�DV�GXDV� FRLVDV�RFRUUHP��DPDQKm�FKRYH�H��DOpP�GLVVR��HX�YRX�j� HVFROD���D� IUDVH�VHUi�IDOVD�FRPR�XP�WRGR��9HMD�DEDL[R�D�WDEHOD�YHUGDGH� GHVWH� RSHUDGRU� OyJLFR�� FKDPDGR� PXLWDV� YH]HV� GH� ³2X� H[FOXVLYR´�� HP� RSRVLomR�DR�³RX´�DOWHUQDWLYR�TXH�YLPRV�DFLPD�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�S� �³&KRYH�DPDQKm´�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�T� �³(X�YRX�j�HVFROD´�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�2X�S� RX�T� � S T �� 9� 9� )� 9� )� 9� )� 9� 9� )� )� )� � 0DUTXHL� HP�YHUPHOKR�D� ~QLFD�PXGDQoD�TXH� WHPRV�HP� UHODomR�DR� FDVR�DQWHULRU�� � G��&RQGLFLRQDO� �LPSOLFDomR��� XPD� FRQGLFLRQDO� p� XPD� FRPELQDomR� GR� WLSR� ³VH� S�� HQWmR� T´� �VLPEROL]DGD� SRU� S To ��� 8VDQGR� R� QRVVR� H[HPSOR��SRGHPRV�PRQWDU�D�SURSRVLomR�FRPSRVWD�³6H�FKRYH�DPDQKm�� HX�YRX�j�HVFROD´�� (VWD� p� D� SURSRVLomR� FRPSRVWD� PDLV� FRPXP�HP�SURYDV�GH� FRQFXUVR�� &KDPDPRV� HVWH� FDVR� GH� &RQGLFLRQDO� SRUTXH� WHPRV� XPD� FRQGLomR� �³VH� FKRYH� DPDQKm´�� TXH�� FDVR� YHQKD� D� RFRUUHU�� ID]� FRP� TXH� DXWRPDWLFDPHQWH� D� VXD� FRQVHTXrQFLD� �³HX� YRX� j� HVFROD´�� WHQKD� TXH� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ?�� DFRQWHFHU�� ,VWR� p�� VH� S� IRU� 9HUGDGHLUD�� LVWR� REULJD� T� D� VHU� WDPEpP� 9HUGDGHLUD��� 6H� D� FRQGLomR� S� �³VH� FKRYH� DPDQKm´�� QmR� RFRUUH� �p� )DOVD��� T� SRGH� RFRUUHU��9��RX�QmR��)���H�DLQGD�DVVLP�D�IUDVH�p�9HUGDGHLUD��3RUpP�VH�D� FRQGLomR�RFRUUH��S�p�9��H�R�UHVXOWDGR�QmR�RFRUUH��T�p�)���HVWDPRV�GLDQWH� GH� XPD� SURSRVLomR� FRPSRVWD� TXH� p� )DOVD� FRPR� XP� WRGR�� 7XGR� R� TXH� GLVVHPRV�DFLPD�OHYD�D�HVWD�WDEHOD�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�S� �³&KRYH�DPDQKm´�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�T� �³(X�YRX�j�HVFROD´�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�6H�S�� HQWmR�T�� S To �� 9� 9� 9� 9� )� )� )� 9� 9� )� )� 9� �� H��%LFRQGLFLRQDO� �³VH� H� VRPHQWH� VH´��� XPD� ELFRQGLFLRQDO� p� XPD� FRPELQDomR�GR� WLSR� ³S� VH�H� VRPHQWH� VH�T´� �VLPEROL]DGD�SRU� S Tl ��� ([���³&KRYH�DPDQKm�VH�H�VRPHQWH�VH�HX�YRX�j�HVFROD´��� � 4XDQGR� DOJXpP� QRV� GL]� D� IUDVH� DFLPD�� HOD� TXHU� GL]HU� TXH�� QHFHVVDULDPHQWH�� DV� GXDV� FRLVDV� DFRQWHFHP� MXQWDV� �RX� HQWmR� QHQKXPD� GHODV� DFRQWHFH���$VVLP�� VDEHQGR�TXH� DPDQKm� FKRYH�� Mi� VDEHPRV�TXH�D� SHVVRD�YDL�j�HVFROD��'D�PHVPD�IRUPD��VDEHQGR�TXH�D�SHVVRD�IRL�j�HVFROD�� HQWmR� VDEHPRV� TXH� FKRYHX�� 3RU� RXWUR� ODGR�� VDEHQGR� TXH� QmR� FKRYHX�� VDEHPRV�DXWRPDWLFDPHQWH�TXH�D�SHVVRD�QmR�IRL�j�HVFROD��� � 1RWH�� SRUWDQWR�� TXH� D� H[SUHVVmR� S Tl � Vy� p� YHUGDGHLUD� TXDQGR� WDQWR�S�TXDQWR�T�DFRQWHFHP��VmR�9HUGDGHLUDV���RX�HQWmR�TXDQGR�DPEDV� QmR� DFRQWHFHP� �VmR� )DOVDV��� 6H� RFRUUHU� RXWUR� FDVR� �FKRYHU� H� D� SHVVRD� QmR� IRU� j� HVFROD�� SRU� H[HPSOR��� D� H[SUHVVmR� S Tl p� )DOVD�� ,VVR� HVWi� UHVXPLGR�QD�WDEHOD�DEDL[R�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�S� �³&KRYH�DPDQKm´�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�T� �³(X�YRX�j�HVFROD´�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�S�VH� H�VRPHQWH�VH�T� � S Tl �� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ?�� 9� 9� 9� 9� )� )� )� 9� )� )� )� 9� � 1RYDPHQWH�� PDUTXHL� HP� YHUPHOKR� D� ~QLFD� FRLVD� TXH� PXGRX� HP� UHODomR�j�FRQGLFLRQDO� S To �� � � 3DUD� LOXVWUDU� FRPR� DV� WDEHODV�YHUGDGH� SRGHP� VHU� FREUDGDV� HP� SURYD��YHMD�HVWD�TXHVWmR��TXH�H[SORUD�D�WDEHOD�GD�&RQGLFLRQDO��� � ���)&&� ±� 757�%$� ±� ������ 'HYLGR� j� SUR[LPLGDGH� GDV� HOHLo}HV�� IRL� GHFLGLGR� TXH� RV� WULEXQDLV� HOHLWRUDLV� GHYHULDP� IXQFLRQDU�� HP� UHJLPH� GH� SODQWmR�� GXUDQWH� XP� GHWHUPLQDGR� GRPLQJR� GR� DQR�� (P� UHODomR� D� HVVH� SODQWmR��IRL�GLYXOJDGD�D�VHJXLQWH�RULHQWDomR�� ³6H�WRGRV�RV�SURFHVVRV�IRUHP�DQDOLVDGRV�DWp�jV����KRUDV��HQWmR�R�SODQWmR� VHUi�ILQDOL]DGR�QHVVH�KRUiULR�´� &RQVLGHUH�TXH�D�RULHQWDomR�IRL�FXPSULGD�H�TXH�R�SODQWmR�Vy�IRL�ILQDOL]DGR� jV����KRUDV��(QWmR��SRGH�VH�FRQFOXLU�TXH��QHFHVVDULDPHQWH�� �$��QHQKXP�SURFHVVR�IRL�DQDOLVDGR�DWp�jV����KRUDV�� �%��WRGRV�RV�SURFHVVRV�IRUDP�DQDOLVDGRV�DWp�jV����KRUDV�� �&��SHOR�PHQRV�XP�SURFHVVR�WHUPLQRX�GH�VHU�DQDOLVDGR�jV����KRUDV�� �'��WRGRV�RV�SURFHVVRV�IRUDP�DQDOLVDGRV�DWp�jV����KRUDV�� �(��SHOR�PHQRV�XP�SURFHVVR�QmR�IRL�DQDOLVDGR�DWp�jV����KRUDV�� 5(62/8d2�� � 7HPRV�QR�HQXQFLDGR�XPD�FRQGLFLRQDO�SÆT�RQGH�� S� �WRGRV�RV�SURFHVVRV�IRUHP�DQDOLVDGRV�DWp�jV����KRUDV� T� �R�SODQWmR�VHUi�ILQDOL]DGR�QHVVH�KRUiULR� � � 2FRUUH�TXH�R�SODQWmR�Vy�IRL� ILQDOL]DGR�jV����KRUDV��RX�VHMD��T�p�)�� 3DUD� PDQWHU� D� FRQGLFLRQDO� SÆT� YHUGDGHLUD�� p� SUHFLVR� TXH� S� VHMD� )� WDPEpP��$ILQDO�� ROKDQGR�D� WDEHOD�YHUGDGH�GD� FRQGLFLRQDO��TXDQGR�T�p�)� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ?�� QmR� SRGHPRV� GHL[DU� TXH� S� VHMD� 9�� SRLV� QHVWH� FDVR� D� FRQGLFLRQDO� VHULD� IDOVD�� 3� 4� S To � 9� 9� 9� 9� )� )� )� 9� 9� )� )� 9� � � $VVLP��FRPR�S�p�)��HQWmR�SHOR�PHQRV�XP�SURFHVVR�QmR�IRL�DQDOLVDGR� DWp�DV����KRUDV�� 5HVSRVWD��(� � � ,03257$17(��6DLED�TXH�³H´��³RX´��³RX������RX���´��³VH�����HQWmR���´�� ³VH� H� VRPHQWH� VH´� VmR� DV� IRUPDV� EiVLFDV� GRV� FRQHFWLYRV� FRQMXQomR�� GLVMXQomR�� GLVMXQomR� H[FOXVLYD�� FRQGLFLRQDO� H� ELFRQGLFLRQDO�� (QWUHWDQWR�� YiULDV�TXHVW}HV�H[SORUDP�IRUPDV�³DOWHUQDWLYDV´�GH�VH�H[SUHVVDU�FDGD�XPD� GHVVDV� SURSRVLo}HV� FRPSRVWDV�� $R� ORQJR� GDV� TXHVW}HV� TXH� UHVROYHUPRV� QHVVD�H�QD�SUy[LPD�DXOD��YRFr�DSUHQGHUi�D� OLGDU�FRP�HVWDV�DOWHUQDWLYDV�� 9HMD�RV�FDVRV�TXH�FRQVLGHUR�PDLV�LPSRUWDQWHV�� � ��&RQHFWLYR�³PDV´�FRP� LGHLD�GH�FRQMXQomR� �³H´��� ([���&KRYH��PDV� YRX�j�HVFROD��2EVHUYH�TXH�TXHP�GL]�HVWD�IUDVH�HVWi�DILUPDQGR�TXH�GXDV� FRLVDV�DFRQWHFHP���� �FKRYH��H��� �YRX�j�HVFROD��1R�HVWXGR�GD� OyJLFD�� LVWR�p�R�PHVPR�TXH�GL]HU�³&KRYH�H�YRX�j�HVFROD´��3RUWDQWR��R�³PDV´�HVWi� VHQGR�XVDGR�SDUD�IRUPDU�XPD�FRQMXQomR�� � �� &RQHFWLYR� ³RX´� SUHFHGLGR� SRU� YtUJXOD�� FRP� LGHLD� GH� ³RX� H[FOXVLYR´��([���&KRYH��RX�YRX�j�HVFROD��$TXL�D�SDXVD�FULDGD�SHOD�YtUJXOD� QRV�SHUPLWH�GHSUHHQGHU�TXH�DSHQDV�XPD�FRLVD�RFRUUH��RX�FKRYH��RX�YRX� j� HVFROD�� $VVLP�� WHPRV�XPD� IRUPD� DOWHUQDWLYD� GH� UHSUHVHQWDU� R� ³RX� ����� RX���´�TXH�HVWXGDPRV�QD�GLVMXQomR�H[FOXVLYD�� � �� &RQGLFLRQDO� XWLOL]DQGR� ³4XDQGR���´� RX� ³7RGD� YH]� TXH���´�� ([HPSORV���� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ?�� ���4XDQGR�FKRYH��YRX�j�HVFROD�� ���7RGD�YH]�TXH�FKRYH�YRX�j�HVFROD�� � 9HMD� TXH� QRV� GRLV� FDVRV� DFLPD� WHPRV� IRUPDV� DOWHUQDWLYDV� GH� DSUHVHQWDU�XPD�FRQGLomR��³FKRYH´��TXH�OHYD�D�XPD�FRQVHTXrQFLD��³YRX�j� HVFROD´���3RUWDQWR��HVWDV�VmR�IRUPDV�DOWHUQDWLYDV�DR�FOiVVLFR�³VH������HQWmR� ���´�GD�FRQGLFLRQDO�� �� 8VR� GR� ³���RX����� PDV� QmR� DPERV´� FRP� LGHLD� GH� GLVMXQomR� H[FOXVLYD�� ([��� ³-RJR� EROD� RX� FRUUR�� PDV� QmR� DPERV´�� 5HSDUH� TXH� D� SULPHLUD� SDUWH� GHVVD� IUDVH� p� XPD� GLVMXQomR� FRPXP� �LQFOXVLYD��� PDV� D� H[SUHVVmR�³PDV�QmR�DPERV´�H[FOXL�R�FDVR�RQGH�³MRJR�EROD´�p�9�H�³FRUUR´� WDPEpP� p� 9�� ,VWR� p�� SDVVDPRV� D� WHU� XPD� GLVMXQomR� H[FOXVLYD�� $OJXQV� DXWRUHV�HQWHQGHP�TXH�Vy�WHPRV�GLVMXQomR�H[FOXVLYD�VH�D�H[SUHVVmR�³PDV� QmR� DPERV´� HVWLYHU� SUHVHQWH� �DLQGD� TXH� WHQKDPRV� ³RX����� RX� ���´��� PDV� LVVR�QmR�SRGH�VHU�FRQVLGHUDGR�XPD�YHUGDGH�DEVROXWD��7UDEDOKDUHPRV�HVVH�SUREOHPD�DR�ORQJR�GDV�TXHVW}HV�� � � 6REUH�SURSRVLo}HV�FRPSRVWDV��YHMD�XPD�TXHVWmR�LQWURGXWyULD�� � ���)&&�±�,&06�63�±�������&RQVLGHUH�D�SURSRVLomR�³3DXOD�HVWXGD��PDV� QmR�SDVVD�QR�FRQFXUVR´��1HVVD�SURSRVLomR��R�FRQHFWLYR�OyJLFR�p��� D��FRQGLFLRQDO� E��ELFRQGLFLRQDO� F��GLVMXQomR�LQFOXVLYD� G��FRQMXQomR� H��GLVMXQomR�H[FOXVLYD� 5(62/8d2�� � 9LPRV�ORJR�DFLPD�TXH�R�³PDV´�SRGH�VHU�XWLOL]DGR�SDUD�UHSUHVHQWDU�R� FRQHFWLYR�FRQMXQomR��³H´���'R�SRQWR�GH�YLVWD�OyJLFR��D�IUDVH�³3DXOD�HVWXGD� H�QmR�SDVVD�QR�FRQFXUVR´�WHP�R�PHVPR�YDORU�GD�IUDVH�GR�HQXQFLDGR��,VWR� SRUTXH� R� DXWRU� GD� IUDVH� TXHU� GL]HU�� EDVLFDPHQWH�� TXH� GXDV� FRLVDV� VmR� YHUGDGHLUDV�� ��3DXOD�HVWXGD� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� ��3DXOD�QmR�SDVVD�QR�FRQFXUVR� � 3RUWDQWR��WHPRV�XPD�FRQMXQomR��OHWUD�'���� $R� HVWXGDU� 3RUWXJXrV�� YRFr� YHUi� TXH� R� ³PDV´� WHP� IXQomR� DGYHUVDWLYD��,VWR�p��R�DXWRU�GD�IUDVH�QmR�TXHU�GL]HU�DSHQDV�TXH�DV�GXDV� FRLVDV�VmR�YHUGDGHLUDV��(OH�XVD�R�³PDV´�SDUD�UHVVDOWDU�R�IDWR�GH�TXH�HVVDV� FRLVDV� VmR�� HP� WHVH�� RSRVWDV� HQWUH� VL� �HVSHUD�VH�TXH�TXHP�HVWXGD� VHMD� DSURYDGR���3RU�PDLV�LPSRUWDQWH�TXH�VHMD�HVWH�GHWDOKH�VHPkQWLFR�QDTXHOD� GLVFLSOLQD��DTXL�QD�/yJLFD�3URSRVLFLRQDO�GHYHPRV�WUDWDU�HVWDV�SURSRVLo}HV� FRPR�VHQGR�HTXLYDOHQWHV�� 5HVSRVWD��'� � ����1HJDomR�GH�SURSRVLo}HV�VLPSOHV� � 5HSUHVHQWDPRV� D� QHJDomR� GH� XPD� SURSRVLomR� VLPSOHV� ³S´� SHOR� VtPEROR� ³aS´� �OHLD� QmR�S��7DPEpP�SRGHPRV�XVDU� D�QRWDomR� S �� TXH�p� PHQRV�XVXDO��6DEHPRV�TXH�R�YDORU�OyJLFR�GH�³S´�H�³aS´�VmR�RSRVWRV��LVWR� p��VH�S�p�XPD�SURSRVLomR�YHUGDGHLUD��aS�VHUi�IDOVD��H�YLFH�YHUVD�� � 4XDQGR� WHPRV� XPD� SURSRVLomR� VLPSOHV� �SRU� H[��� ³&KRYH� DJRUD´�� ³7RGRV�RV�QRUGHVWLQRV�VmR�IRUWHV´��³$OJXP�EUDVLOHLUR�p�PLQHLUR´���SRGHPRV� QHJDU�HVVD�SURSRVLomR�VLPSOHVPHQWH�LQVHULQGR�³1mR�p�YHUGDGH�TXH���´�HP� VHX�LQtFLR��9HMD�� ��1mR�p�YHUGDGH�TXH�FKRYH�DJRUD� ��1mR�p�YHUGDGH�TXH�WRGRV�RV�QRUGHVWLQRV�VmR�IRUWHV� ��1mR�p�YHUGDGH�TXH�DOJXP�EUDVLOHLUR�p�PLQHLUR� � (QWUHWDQWR�� QD� PDLRULD� GRV� H[HUFtFLRV� VHUmR� VROLFLWDGDV� RXWUDV� IRUPDV�GH�QHJDU�XPD�SURSRVLomR��3DUD�GHVFREULU�D�QHJDomR��EDVWD�YRFr�VH� SHUJXQWDU�� R� TXH� p� R� 0Ë1,02� TXH� HX� SUHFLVDULD� ID]HU� SDUD� SURYDU� TXH� HVWD�IUDVH�p�PHQWLUD"�6H�YRFr�IRU�FDSD]�GH�GHVPHQWL�OD��YRFr�VHUi�FDSD]� GH�QHJi�OD��� � 6H� -RmR� QRV�GLVVH�TXH� ³&KRYH�DJRUD´�� EDVWDULD� FRQILUPDU�TXH�QmR� HVWi� FKRYHQGR� DJRUD� SDUD� GHVPHQWL�OR�� 3RUWDQWR�� D� QHJDomR� VHULD� VLPSOHVPHQWH�³1mR�FKRYH�DJRUD´�� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� � (QWUHWDQWR�� FDVR� -RmR� QRV� GLJD� TXH� ³7RGRV� RV� QRUGHVWLQRV� VmR� IRUWHV´�� EDVWDULD� HQFRQWUDUPRV�XP�~QLFR� QRUGHVWLQR� TXH�QmR� IRVVH� IRUWH� SDUD� GHVPHQWL�OR�� 3RUWDQWR�� D� QHJDomR� GHVWD� DILUPDomR� SRGH� VHU�� HQWUH� RXWUDV�SRVVLELOLGDGHV�� ��³3HOR�PHQRV�XP�QRUGHVWLQR�QmR�p�IRUWH´� ��³$OJXP�QRUGHVWLQR�QmR�p�IRUWH´� ��³([LVWH�QRUGHVWLQR�TXH�QmR�p�IRUWH´� � -i�VH�-RmR�QRV�GLVVHVVH�TXH�³$OJXP�QRUGHVWLQR�p�IRUWH´��EDVWD�TXH� XP� ~QLFR� QRUGHVWLQR� VHMD� UHDOPHQWH� IRUWH� SDUD� TXH� D� IUDVH� GHOH� VHMD� YHUGDGHLUD�� 3RUWDQWR�� DTXL� p� PDLV� GLItFLO� GHVPHQWL�OR�� SRLV� SUHFLVDUtDPRV� DQDOLVDU�WRGRV�RV�QRUGHVWLQRV�H�PRVWUDU�TXH�QHQKXP�GHOHV�p�IRUWH��$VVLP�� D�QHJDomR�VHULD��HQWUH�RXWUDV�SRVVLELOLGDGHV�� ��³1HQKXP�QRUGHVWLQR�p�IRUWH´� ��³1mR�H[LVWH�QRUGHVWLQR�IRUWH´� � � $� WDEHOD� DEDL[R� UHVXPH� DV� SULQFLSDLV� IRUPDV� GH� QHJDomR� GH� SURSRVLo}HV�VLPSOHV��9HMD�TXH��DVVLP�FRPR�YRFr�SRGH�XVDU�DV�GD�FROXQD� GD�GLUHLWD�SDUD�QHJDU� IUDVHV� FRP�DV�H[SUHVV}HV�GD�FROXQD�GD�HVTXHUGD�� YRFr�WDPEpP�SRGH�ID]HU�R�FRQWUiULR��� �3URSRVLomR�³S´� 3URSRVLomR�³aS´� 0HX�JDWR�p�SUHWR� 0HX�JDWR�QmR�p�SUHWR� 7RGRV�JDWRV�VmR�SUHWRV� $OJXP�SHOR�PHQRV�XP�H[LVWH�JDWR� �TXH��QmR�p�SUHWR� 1HQKXP�JDWR�p�SUHWR� $OJXP�SHOR�PHQRV�XP�H[LVWH�JDWR� �TXH��p�SUHWR� � � 1RWH�DLQGD�TXH�a�aS�� �S��LVWR�p��D�QHJDomR�GD�QHJDomR�GH�S�p�D� SUySULD�SURSRVLomR�S��,VWR�p��QHJDU�GXDV�YH]HV�p�LJXDO�D�IDODU�D�YHUGDGH�� ([��� ³1mR� p� YHUGDGH� TXH� PHX� JDWR� QmR� p� SUHWR´� Æ� HVWD� IUDVH� p� HTXLYDOHQWH�D�³0HX�JDWR�p�SUHWR´�� � 9HMD� DEDL[R� XPD� TXHVWmR� LQLFLDO� VREUH� QHJDomR� GH� SURSRVLo}HV� VLPSOHV��� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� � ���)&&� ±� %DQFR� GR� %UDVLO� ±� ������ 8P� MRUQDO� SXEOLFRX� D� VHJXLQWH� PDQFKHWH�� ³7RGD�$JrQFLD�GR�%DQFR�GR�%UDVLO�WHP�GpILFLW�GH�IXQFLRQiULRV�´� 'LDQWH�GH�WDO�LQYHUGDGH��R�MRUQDO�VH�YLX�REULJDGR�D�UHWUDWDU�VH��SXEOLFDQGR� XPD� QHJDomR� GH� WDO� PDQFKHWH�� 'DV� VHQWHQoDV� VHJXLQWHV�� DTXHOD� TXH� H[SUHVVDULD�GH�PDQHLUD�FRUUHWD�D�QHJDomR�GD�PDQFKHWH�SXEOLFDGD�p�� D��4XDOTXHU�$JrQFLD�GR�%DQFR�GR�%UDVLO�QmR�WrP�GpILFLW�GH�IXQFLRQiULRV� E��1HQKXPD�$JrQFLD�GR�%DQFR�GR�%UDVLO�WHP�GpILFLW�GH�IXQFLRQiULRV� F��$OJXPD�$JrQFLD�GR�%DQFR�GR�%UDVLO�QmR�WHP�GpILFLW�GH�IXQFLRQiULRV� G�� ([LVWHP� $JrQFLDV� FRP� GpILFLW� GH� IXQFLRQiULRV� TXH� QmR� SHUWHQFHP� DR� %DQFR�GR�%UDVLO� H��2�TXDGUR�GH�IXQFLRQiULRV�GR�%DQFR�GR�%UDVLO�HVWi�FRPSOHWR� 5(62/8d2�� � 2OKDQGR� D� PDQFKHWH� SXEOLFDGD� SHOR� MRUQDO�� EDVWDULD� TXH� XP� OHLWRU� FRQVWDWDVVH�TXH�HP�SHOR�PHQRV�XPD�DJrQFLD�GR�%%�QmR�Ki�GpILFLW�H�HOH�Mi� WHULD� DUJXPHQWR� VXILFLHQWH� SDUD�GHVPHQWLU� R� MRUQDO�� DILQDO� R� MRUQDO� WLQKD� GLWR� TXH� WRGDV� DV� DJrQFLDV� SRVVXHP� GpILFLW�� 8PD� IRUPD� GHVVH� OHLWRU� H[SUHVVDU�VH�VHULD�GL]HQGR�� ³3HOR�PHQRV�XPD�DJrQFLD�GR�%%�QmR�WHP�GpILFLW�GH�IXQFLRQiULRV´�� � 8PD�RXWUD�IRUPD�GH�GL]HU�HVWD�PHVPD�IUDVH�VHULD�� ³$OJXPD�DJrQFLD�GR�%%�QmR�WHP�GpILFLW�GH�IXQFLRQiULRV´�� � 3RUWDQWR�� HVVD� IRL� D� IUDVH� TXH� R� MRUQDO� SUHFLVRX� XVDU� SDUD� D� UHWUDWDomR��QHJDomR��GD�DQWHULRU�� 5HVSRVWD��&� � ����1HJDomR�GH�SURSRVLo}HV�FRPSRVWDV� � 4XDQGR� WHPRV� DOJXPD� GDV� SURSRVLo}HV� FRPSRVWDV� �FRQMXQomR�� GLVMXQomR�� GLVMXQomR� H[FOXVLYD�� FRQGLFLRQDO� RX� ELFRQGLFLRQDO��� SRGHPRV� XWLOL]DU�R�PHVPR�WUXTXH�SDUD�REWHU�D�VXD�QHJDomR��EXVFDU�XPD�IRUPD�GH� GHVPHQWLU� TXHP� HVWLYHVVH� IDODQGR� DTXHOD� IUDVH�� 9HMDPRV� DOJXQV� H[HPSORV�� � Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� D��&RQMXQomR��³&KRYH�KRMH�H�YRX�j�SUDLD´��6H�-RmR�QRV�GL]�HVVD�IUDVH��HOH� HVWi� DILUPDQGR� TXH� DV� GXDV� FRLVDV� GHYHP� RFRUUHU� �VH� WLYHU� G~YLGD�� UHWRUQH� j� WDEHOD�YHUGDGH� GD� FRQMXQomR��� ,VWR� p�� SDUD� GHVPHQWL�OR�� EDVWDULD�SURYDU�TXH�SHOR�PHQRV�XPD�GHODV�QmR�RFRUUH��,VWR�p��D�SULPHLUD� FRLVD�QmR�RFRUUH�RX�D�VHJXQGD�FRLVD�QmR�RFRUUH��RX�PHVPR�DV�GXDV�QmR� RFRUUHP���9HMD�TXH�SDUD� LVVR�SRGHPRV�XVDU�XPD�GLVMXQomR��QHJDQGR�DV� GXDV�SURSRVLo}HV�VLPSOHV�FRPR�DSUHQGHPRV�QR�LWHP�DQWHULRU��³1mR�FKRYH� KRMH�RX�QmR�YRX�j�SUDLD´��'D�PHVPD� IRUPD��VH� -RmR� WLYHVVH�GLWR� ³7RGR� QRUGHVWLQR�p� IRUWH�H�QHQKXP�JDWR�p�SUHWR´��SRGHUtDPRV�QHJDU�XWLOL]DQGR� XPD�GLVMXQomR��QHJDQGR�DV�GXDV�SURSRVLo}HV�VLPSOHV��³$OJXP�QRUGHVWLQR� QmR�p�IRUWH�RX�DOJXP�JDWR�p�SUHWR´�� � E��'LVMXQomR��³&KRYH�KRMH�RX�YRX�j�SUDLD´��(VVD�DILUPDomR�p�YHUGDGHLUD� VH� SHOR� PHQRV� XPD� GDV� SURSRVLo}HV� VLPSOHV� IRU� YHUGDGHLUD�� � 3RUWDQWR�� SDUD�GHVPHQWLU�TXHP�D�GLVVH��SUHFLVDPRV�SURYDU�TXH�DV�GXDV�FRLVDV�QmR� DFRQWHFHP��LVWR�p��DV�GXDV�SURSRVLo}HV�VmR�IDOVDV��$VVLP��D�QHJDomR�VHULD� XPD� FRQMXQomR�� ³1mR� FKRYH� KRMH� H� QmR� YRX� j� SUDLD´�� -i� D� QHJDomR� GH� ³7RGR� QRUGHVWLQR� p� IRUWH� RX� QHQKXP� JDWR� p� SUHWR´� VHULD� ³$OJXP� QRUGHVWLQR�QmR�p�IRUWH�H�DOJXP�JDWR�p�SUHWR´��� F��'LVMXQomR� H[FOXVLYD�� ³2X� FKRYH� KRMH� RX� YRX� j� SUDLD´�� � 5HFRUUHQGR� j� WDEHOD�YHUGDGH�� YRFr� YHUi�TXH�D� GLVMXQomR�H[FOXVLYD� Vy� p� YHUGDGHLUD� VH� XPD�� H� DSHQDV� XPD� GDV� SURSRVLo}HV� p� YHUGDGHLUD�� VHQGR�D� RXWUD� IDOVD�� $VVLP��VH�PRVWUiVVHPRV�TXH�DPEDV�VmR�YHUGDGHLUDV��RX�TXH�DPEDV�VmR� IDOVDV��HVWDUtDPRV�GHVPHQWLQGR�R�DXWRU�GD�IUDVH��3DUD�LVVR��SRGHPRV�XVDU� XPD� ELFRQGLFLRQDO�� ³&KRYH� KRMH� VH� H� VRPHQWH� VH� HX�YRX� j� SUDLD´�� 9HMD� TXH� HVWD� IUDVH� LQGLFD� TXH� RX� DFRQWHFHP� DV� GXDV� FRLVDV� �FKRYHU� H� LU� j� SUDLD��RX�QmR�DFRQWHFH�QHQKXPD�GHODV��� G�� &RQGLFLRQDO�� ³6H� FKRYH� KRMH�� HQWmR� YRX� j� SUDLD´�� /HPEUD�VH� TXH� D� FRQGLFLRQDO� Vy�p� IDOVD�FDVR�D�FRQGLomR� �S��VHMD�YHUGDGHLUD�H�R� UHVXOWDGR� �T�� VHMD� IDOVR"� 3RUWDQWR�� p� MXVWDPHQWH� LVVR� TXH� GHYHUtDPRV� SURYDU� VH� TXLVpVVHPRV� GHVPHQWLU� R� DXWRU� GD� IUDVH�� $� VHJXLQWH� FRQMXQomR� QRV� SHUPLWH�QHJDU�D�FRQGLFLRQDO��³&KRYH�KRMH�H�QmR�YRX�j�SUDLD´��� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� � H��%LFRQGLFLRQDO�� ³&KRYH�KRMH�VH�H�VRPHQWH�VH�YRX�j�SUDLD´��2�DXWRU�GD� IUDVH� HVWi� DILUPDQGR� TXH� DV� GXDV� FRLVDV� �FKRYHU� H� LU� j� SUDLD�� GHYHP� RFRUUHU� MXQWDV�� RX� HQWmR� QHQKXPD� GHODV� SRGH� RFRUUHU�� 3RGHPRV� GHVPHQWL�OR�SURYDQGR�TXH�XPD�GDV�FRLVDV�RFRUUH��p�YHUGDGHLUD��HQTXDQWR� D�RXWUD�QmR��p� IDOVD���$�GLVMXQomR�H[FOXVLYD�QRV�SHUPLWH� ID]HU� LVVR�� ³2X� FKRYH�KRMH��RX�YRX�j�SUDLD´��� � 9HMD� QD� WDEHOD� DEDL[R� DV� SULQFLSDLV� IRUPDV� GH� QHJDomR� GH� SURSRVLo}HV�FRPSRVWDV�� 3URSRVLomR�FRPSRVWD� 1HJDomR� &RQMXQomR�� S T �� ([���&KRYH�KRMH�H�YRX�j�SUDLD� 'LVMXQomR��a aS T �� ([���1mR�FKRYH�KRMH�RX�QmR�YRX�j�SUDLD� 'LVMXQomR�� S T �� ([���&KRYH�KRMH�RX�YRX�j�SUDLD� &RQMXQomR��a aS T �� ([���1mR�FKRYH�KRMH�H�QmR�YRX�j�SUDLD� 'LVMXQomR�H[FOXVLYD�� S T �� ([���2X�FKRYH�KRMH�RX�YRX�j�SUDLD� %LFRQGLFLRQDO�� S Tl �� ([���&KRYH�KRMH�VH�H�VRPHQWH�VH�YRX�j�SUDLD� &RQGLFLRQDO�� S To �� ([���6H�FKRYH�KRMH��HQWmR�YRX�j�SUDLD� &RQMXQomR�� aS T �� ([���&KRYH�KRMH�H�QmR�YRX�j�SUDLD� %LFRQGLFLRQDO�� S Tl �� ([���&KRYH�KRMH�VH�H�VRPHQWH�VH�YRX�j� SUDLD�� 'LVMXQomR�H[FOXVLYD�� S T �� ([���2X�FKRYH�KRMH�RX�YRX�j�SUDLD� � � 2XWUD� IRUPD� GH� QHJDU� D� ELFRQGLFLRQDO� p� HVFUHYHQGR� RXWUD� ELFRQGLFLRQDO��SRUpP�QHJDQGR�XPD�GDV�SURSRVLo}HV�VLPSOHV��3RU�H[HPSOR�� laS T �p�XPD�IRUPD�DOWHUQDWLYD�GH�QHJDU� S Tl ��(VWD�QHJDomR�SRGH�VHU� HVFULWD�FRPR�³&KRYH�VH�H�VRPHQWH�VH�12�YRX�j�SUDLD��� � &RPHFH�D�H[HUFLWDU�D�QHJDomR�GH�SURSRVLo}HV�FRPSRVWDV�D�SDUWLU�GD� TXHVWmR�DEDL[R�� ���)&&�±�757����±�������&RQVLGHUH�D�VHJXLQWH�DILUPDomR�� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� 6H� -RVp� HVWXGD� FRP� SHUVLVWrQFLD�� HQWmR� HOH� ID]� XPD� ERD� SURYD� H� ILFD� VDWLVIHLWR�� 8PD�DILUPDomR�TXH�p�D�QHJDomR�GD�DILUPDomR�DFLPD�p� �$��-RVp�HVWXGD�FRP�SHUVLVWrQFLD�H�HOH�QmR�ID]�XPD�ERD�SURYD�H�HOH�QmR� ILFD�VDWLVIHLWR�� �%��-RVp�QmR�HVWXGD�FRP�SHUVLVWrQFLD�H�HOH�QmR�ID]�XPD�ERD�SURYD�RX�ILFD� VDWLVIHLWR�� �&��-RVp�HVWXGD�FRP�SHUVLVWrQFLD�RX�HOH�ID]�XPD�ERD�SURYD�RX�HOH�QmR�ILFD� VDWLVIHLWR�� �'��-RVp�HVWXGD�FRP�SHUVLVWrQFLD�H�HOH�QmR�ID]�XPD�ERD�SURYD�RX�HOH�QmR� ILFD�VDWLVIHLWR�� �(�� 6H� -RVp� ILFD� VDWLVIHLWR� HQWmR� HOH� IH]� XPD� ERD� SURYD� H� HVWXGRX� FRP� SHUVLVWrQFLD�� 5(62/8d2�� � 3DUD�QHJDU�D�FRQGLFLRQDO�SÆT��SRGHPRV�HVFUHYHU�D�FRQMXQomR�³S�H� aT´�� 1R� FDVR�� FRPR� D� FRQGLFLRQDO� p� ³6H� -RVp� HVWXGD� FRP� SHUVLVWrQFLD�� HQWmR�HOH�ID]�XPD�ERD�SURYD�H�ILFD�VDWLVIHLWR´��WHPRV�TXH�� S� �-RVp�HVWXGD�FRP�SHUVLVWrQFLD� T� �HOH�ID]�XPD�ERD�SURYD�H�ILFD�VDWLVIHLWR� � � 5HSDUH�TXH�T�p�XPD�SURSRVLomR�FRPSRVWD��GR�WLSR�FRQMXQomR��FXMD� QHJDomR�p�� aT� �HOH�12�ID]�XPD�ERD�SURYD�28�12�ILFD�VDWLVIHLWR� � � $VVLP��D�QHJDomR�GH�SÆT�p�³S�H�aT´��TXH�SRGH�VHU�HVFULWD�DVVLP�� � -RVp�HVWXGD�FRP�SHUVLVWrQFLD�(�12�ID]�XPD�ERD�SURYD�28�12�ILFD� VDWLVIHLWR� 5HVSRVWD��'� � � � Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� ����&RQVWUXomR�GD�WDEHOD�YHUGDGH�GH�SURSRVLo}HV�FRPSRVWDV� � $OJXQV� H[HUFtFLRV� SRGHP�H[LJLU� TXH� YRFr� VDLED� FRQVWUXLU� D� WDEHOD� YHUGDGH�GH�SURSRVLo}HV�FRPSRVWDV��3DUD�H[HPSOLILFDU��YHMD�D�SURSRVLomR� >�a � @$ % & �� $� SULPHLUD� FRLVD� TXH� YRFr� SUHFLVD� VDEHU� p� TXH� D� WDEHOD� YHUGDGH�GHVWD�SURSRVLomR� WHUi�VHPSUH��Q� OLQKDV��RQGH�Q�p�R�Q~PHUR�GH� SURSRVLo}HV�VLPSOHV�HQYROYLGDV��&RPR�Vy�WHPRV���SURSRVLo}HV�VLPSOHV��$�� %�H�&���HVWD�WDEHOD�WHUi�����RX�VHMD����OLQKDV�� � 3DUD� PRQWDU� D� WDEHOD� YHUGDGH� GH� XPD� H[SUHVVmR� FRPR� >�a � @$ % & ��GHYHPRV�FRPHoDU�FULDQGR�XPD�FROXQD�SDUD�FDGD�SURSRVLomR� H�� D� VHJXLU�� FRORFDU� WRGDV� DV� SRVVLELOLGDGHV� GH� FRPELQDo}HV� GH� YDORUHV� OyJLFRV��9�RX�)��HQWUH�HODV�� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� $� 9DORU�OyJLFR� GH�%� 9DORU�OyJLFR� GH�&� 9� 9� 9� 9� 9� )� 9� )� 9� 9� )� )� )� 9� 9� )� 9� )� )� )� 9� )� )� )� � � $JRUD�� QRWH� TXH� HP� >�a � @$ % & � WHPRV� R� WHUPR� a%� HQWUH� SDUrQWHVHV��'HYHPRV��SRUWDQWR��FULDU�XPD�QRYD�FROXQD�QD�QRVVD� WDEHOD�� LQVHULQGR� RV� YDORUHV� GH� a%�� /HPEUH�VH� TXH� RV� YDORUHV� GH� QmR�%� VmR� RSRVWRV�DRV�YDORUHV�GH�%��FRPSDUH�DV�FROXQDV�HP�DPDUHOR��� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� $� 9DORU�OyJLFR� GH�%� 9DORU�OyJLFR� GH�&� 9DORU�OyJLFR� GH�a%� 9� 9� 9� )� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� 9� 9� )� )� 9� )� 9� 9� 9� )� )� 9� )� 9� 9� )� )� 9� )� )� )� )� 9� 9� )� )� )� 9� � � $JRUD�TXH�Mi�WHPRV�RV�YDORUHV� OyJLFRV�GH�a%��H�WDPEpP�WHPRV�RV� GH� &�� SRGHPRV� FULDU� RV� YDORUHV� OyJLFRV� GD� H[SUHVVmR� HQWUH� FROFKHWHV�� >�a � @% & ��2EVHUYH�TXH�VH�WUDWD�GH�XPD�FRQMXQomR��³H´���TXH�Vy�WHP�YDORU� OyJLFR�9�TXDQGR�DPERV�RV�PHPEURV��QR�FDVR��a%�H�&��VmR�9�� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� $� 9DORU�OyJLFR� GH�%� 9DORU�OyJLFR� GH�&� 9DORU�OyJLFR� GH�a%� 9DORU�OyJLFR� GH� >�a � @% & � 9� 9� 9� )� )� 9� 9� )� )� )� 9� )� 9� 9� 9� 9� )� )� 9� )� )� 9� 9� )� )� )� 9� )� )� )� )� )� 9� 9� 9� )� )� )� 9� )� � � $JRUD�TXH� Mi� WHPRV� RV� YDORUHV� OyJLFRV� GH�$� H� WDPEpP�RV� YDORUHV� OyJLFRV� GH� >�a � @% & �� SRGHPRV� DQDOLVDU� RV� YDORUHV� OyJLFRV� GD� GLVMXQomR� >�a � @$ % & ��/HPEUH�VH�TXH�XPD�GLVMXQomR�Vy�p�)�TXDQGR�DPERV�RV�VHXV� PHPEURV�VmR�)��PDUTXHL�HVVHV�FDVRV�HP�DPDUHOR��� 9DORU� OyJLFR� GH�$� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� %� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� &� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� a%� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� >�a � @% & � 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� >�a � @$ % & � Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� 9� 9� 9� )� )� 9� 9� 9� )� )� )� 9� 9� )� 9� 9� 9� 9� 9� )� )� 9� )� 9� )� 9� 9� )� )� )� )� 9� )� )� )� )� )� )� 9� 9� 9� 9� )� )� )� 9� )� )� � � $VVLP�� SRGHPRV� RPLWLU� D� �� H� �� FROXQD�� GH� PRGR� TXH� D� WDEHOD� YHUGDGH�GD�H[SUHVVmR� >�a � @$ % & �p�� � � � 9DORU� OyJLFR� GH�$� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� %� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� &� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� >�a � @$ % & � 9� 9� 9� 9� 9� 9� )� 9� 9� )� 9� 9� 9� )� )� 9� )� 9� 9� )� )� 9� )� )� )� )� 9� 9� )� )� )� )� � � 9HMD� TXH� HVVD� WDEHOD� QRV� Gi� RV� YDORUHV� OyJLFRV� GD� H[SUHVVmR� >�a� @$ % & �SDUD�WRGRV�RV�SRVVtYHLV�YDORUHV�GDV�SURSRVLo}HV�VLPSOHV�TXH� D�FRPS}HP��$��%�H�&��� � ����7DXWRORJLD�H�FRQWUDGLomR� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� �� $R�FRQVWUXLU�WDEHODV�YHUGDGH�SDUD�H[SUHVV}HV��FRPR�IL]HPRV�DFLPD�� SRGHPRV�YHULILFDU�TXH�XPD�GHWHUPLQDGD�H[SUHVVmR�VHPSUH�p�YHUGDGHLUD�� LQGHSHQGHQWH� GRV� YDORUHV� OyJLFRV� GDV� SURSRVLo}HV� VLPSOHV� TXH� D� FRPS}HP�� 7UDWD�VH� GH� XPD� WDXWRORJLD�� 3RU� RXWUR� ODGR�� DOJXPDV� H[SUHVV}HV� SRGHP� VHU� VHPSUH� IDOVDV�� LQGHSHQGHQWH� GRV� YDORUHV� GDV� SURSRVLo}HV� TXH� D� FRPS}HP�� 1HVWH� FDVR�� HVWDUHPRV� GLDQWH� GH� XPD� FRQWUDGLomR��9HMDPRV�DOJXQV�H[HPSORV�� � D�� 9HMD� DEDL[R� D� WDEHOD�YHUGDGH� GH� aS S � �H[��� 6RX� ERQLWR� H� QmR� VRX� ERQLWR��� 3HOD� VLPSOHV� DQiOLVH�GHVVH�H[HPSOR�� Mi� YHPRV�XPD� FRQWUDGLomR� �QmR�Gi�SDUD�VHU�ERQLWR�H�QmR�VHU�DR�PHVPR�WHPSR���2OKDQGR�QD�FROXQD� GD�GLUHLWD�GHVVD�WDEHOD��YHPRV�TXH�HOD�p�IDOVD�SDUD�WRGR�YDORU�OyJLFR�GH�S�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�S� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH� aS� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH� aS S � 9� )� )� )� 9� )� 2EV��� QRWRX� TXH� HVVD� WDEHOD�YHUGDGH� SRVVXL� DSHQDV� GXDV� OLQKDV"� ,VVR� SRUTXH�WHPRV�DSHQDV���SURSRVLomR�VLPSOHV��S���H���� ���� E��9HMD�DEDL[R�D� WDEHOD�YHUGDGH�GH� aS S � �H[���6RX�ERQLWR�RX�QmR�VRX� ERQLWR��� 3HOD� VLPSOHV� DQiOLVH� GHVVH� H[HPSOR�� Mi� YHPRV� XPD� WDXWRORJLD� �HVVD� IUDVH� VHPSUH� VHUi� YHUGDGHLUD�� LQGHSHQGHQWH� GD� PLQKD� EHOH]D��� 2OKDQGR� QD� FROXQD� GD�GLUHLWD� GHVVD� WDEHOD�� YHPRV�TXH�HOD� p� YHUGDGHLUD� SDUD�WRGR�YDORU�OyJLFR�GH�S�� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH�S� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH� aS� 9DORU�OyJLFR�GH� aS S � 9� )� 9� )� 9� 9� � � 3UDWLTXH�R�TXH�GLVFXWLPRV�DWp�DTXL�DWUDYpV�GD�TXHVWmR�D�VHJXLU�� � ���)&&�±�,&06�63�±�������&RQVLGHUH�DV�DILUPDo}HV�DEDL[R�� ,��2�Q~PHUR�GH�OLQKDV�GH�XPD�WDEHOD�YHUGDGH�p�VHPSUH�XP�Q~PHUR�SDU�� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� ,,��$�SURSRVLomR�³ ��� ��� �� � ��� l � ´�p�IDOVD�� ,,,��6H�S�H�T�VmR�SURSRVLo}HV��HQWmR�D�SURSRVLomR�³ � � �a �S T To ´�p�XPD� WDXWRORJLD�� e�YHUGDGH�R�TXH�VH�DILUPD�$3(1$6�HP�� D��,�H�,,� E��,�H�,,,� F��,� G��,,� H��,,,� 5(62/8d2�� ,��2�Q~PHUR�GH�OLQKDV�GH�XPD�WDEHOD�YHUGDGH�p�VHPSUH�XP�Q~PHUR�SDU�� � 2�Q~PHUR�GH�OLQKDV�GH�XPD�WDEHOD�YHUGDGH�p��Q��RQGH�Q�p�R�Q~PHUR� GH� SURSRVLo}HV� VLPSOHV�� ,VWR� p�� �[�[����[��� Q� YH]HV�� (VWH� Q~PHUR� FHUWDPHQWH�p�GLYLVtYHO�SRU����LVWR�p��p�SDU��,WHP�9(5'$'(,52�� � ,,��$�SURSRVLomR�³ ��� ��� �� � ��� l � ´�p�IDOVD�� � 7HPRV�XPD�ELFRQGLFLRQDO�RQGH�D�SULPHLUD�SDUWH�p� IDOVD��SRLV����p� PDLRU� TXH� D� UDL]� TXDGUDGD� GH� ����� H� D� VHJXQGD� SDUWH� WDPEpP� p� IDOVD� �SRLV� �� ±� �� � ���� 1D� WDEHOD�YHUGDGH� GD� ELFRQGLFLRQDO�� YHMD� TXH� HVWD� SURSRVLomR�FRPSRVWD�p�YHUGDGHLUD�TXDQGR�WHPRV�)�l)��,WHP�)$/62�� � ,,,��6H�S�H�T�VmR�SURSRVLo}HV��HQWmR�D�SURSRVLomR�³ � � �a �S T To ´�p�XPD� WDXWRORJLD�� � 3DUD� DYDOLDU� VH� WHPRV� XPD� WDXWRORJLD�� YDPRV� FRQVWUXLU� D� WDEHOD� YHUGDGH�GHVWD�SURSRVLomR��5HSDUH�TXH�WHPRV���SURSRVLo}HV�VLPSOHV��S�H� T���GH�PRGR�TXH�D� WDEHOD�YHUGDGH� GD�SURSRVLomR� FRPSRVWD� WHUi���� ��� OLQKDV��$�WDEHOD��FRQVWUXtGD�GD�HVTXHUGD�SDUD�D�GLUHLWD��ILFD�DVVLP�� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� S� 9DORU�OyJLFR� GH�T� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� aT� 9DORU�OyJLFR� GH� � �S To �� 9DORU�OyJLFR� GH� � � �a �S T To � Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� 9� 9� )� 9� 9� 9� )� 9� )� 9� )� 9� )� 9� 9� )� )� 9� 9� 9� � � 'H� IDWR�� D� SURSRVLomR� � � �a �S T To � SRVVXL� YDORU� OyJLFR� 9� SDUD� TXDOTXHU� YDORU� GDV� SURSRVLo}HV� VLPSOHV� S� H� T�� ,VWR� p�� WHPRV� XPD� WDXWRORJLD��,WHP�9(5'$'(,52�� 5HVSRVWD��%� � ����(TXLYDOrQFLD�GH�SURSRVLo}HV�OyJLFDV� � 'L]HPRV�TXH�GXDV�SURSRVLo}HV�OyJLFDV�VmR�HTXLYDOHQWHV�TXDQGR�HODV� SRVVXHP�D�PHVPD�WDEHOD�YHUGDGH��&RPR�H[HPSOR��YDPRV�YHULILFDU�VH�DV� SURSRVLo}HV� S To �H�a aT So �VmR�HTXLYDOHQWHV�� � )DUHPRV� LVVR� FDOFXODQGR� D� WDEHOD� YHUGDGH� GDV� GXDV�� SDUD� SRGHU� FRPSDUi�ODV�� 0DV� LQWXLWLYDPHQWH� YRFr� Mi� SRGHULD� YHU� TXH� HODV� VmR� HTXLYDOHQWHV�� ,PDJLQH� TXH� S To � p� ³6H� FKRYH�� HQWmR� YRX� j� SUDLD´�� 6DEHPRV�TXH�VH�D�FRQGLomR��FKRYH��RFRUUH��QHFHVVDULDPHQWH�R�UHVXOWDGR� �YRX�j�SUDLD��RFRUUH��3RUWDQWR��VH�VRXEHUPRV�TXH�R�UHVXOWDGR�QmR�RFRUUHX� �QmR�YRX�j�SUDLD���LVVR�LPSOLFD�TXH�D�FRQGLomR�QmR�SRGH�WHU�RFRUULGR��QmR� FKRYH���,VWR�p��SRGHPRV�GL]HU�TXH�³6H�QmR�YRX�j�SUDLD��HQWmR�QmR�FKRYH´�� 2X�VHMD��a aT So �� � $� WDEHOD�YHUGDGH�GH� S To � HQFRQWUD�VH� DEDL[R�� &DOFXOH�D� VR]LQKR�� SDUD�H[HUFLWDU�� � � 9DORU� OyJLFR� GH�S� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� T� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� S To � 9� 9� 9� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� 9� )� )� )� 9� 9� )� )� 9� � � -i�D�WDEHOD�YHUGDGH�GH�a aT So �IRL�REWLGD�DEDL[R��� 9DORU� OyJLFR� GH�S� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� T� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� aT� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� aS� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� a aT So � 9� 9� )� )� 9� 9� )� 9� )� )� )� 9� )� 9� 9� )� )� 9� 9� 9� � � 5HSDUH� QD� FROXQD� GD� GLUHLWD� GH� FDGD� WDEHOD�� 3HUFHEHX� TXH� VmR� LJXDLV"� ,VVR� QRV� SHUPLWH� DILUPDU� TXH� DPEDV� DV� SURSRVLo}HV� FRPSRVWDV� VmR�HTXLYDOHQWHV�� � 9HMD�DLQGD�D�WDEHOD�YHUGDGH�GH�aS�RX�T�� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� S� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� T� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� aS� 9DORU� OyJLFR�GH� aS�RX�T� 9� 9� )� 9� 9� )� )� )� )� 9� 9� 9� )� )� 9� 9� � � 3HUFHED�TXH�D�WDEHOD�YHUGDGH�GH�aS�RX�T�p�LJXDO�jV�GXDV�DQWHULRUHV� �SÆT�H�aTÆaS���$VVLP��HVVDV���SURSRVLo}HV�VmR�HTXLYDOHQWHV�� � 1mR� XVHL� HVWH� H[HPSOR� j� WRD�� (OH� FDL� EDVWDQWH� HP� FRQFXUVRV�� SRUWDQWR� p� ERP� YRFr� JUDYDU�� � S To ��� �a aT So �� H� �aS� RX� T�� VmR� SURSRVLo}HV�HTXLYDOHQWHV���� � Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� � 9HMD� D� TXHVWmR� DEDL[R� SDUD� FRPHoDU� D� WUHLQDU� DV� HTXLYDOrQFLDV� OyJLFDV�� ���)&&� ±� 6(3/$1�3,� ±� ������ 6H� +HUiFOLWR� HVWi� FRQYLFWR� GH� TXH� R� PXQGR�HVWi�HP�SHUPDQHQWH�PXGDQoD��HQWmR�HOH�p�WULVWH��3RUWDQWR��VH� �$��+HUiFOLWR�p�WULVWH��R�PXQGR�HVWi�HP�SHUPDQHQWH�PXGDQoD�� �%�� +HUiFOLWR� QmR� HVWi� FRQYLFWR� GH� TXH� R� PXQGR� HVWi� HP� SHUPDQHQWH� PXGDQoD��HQWmR�HOH�p�WULVWH�� �&�� +HUiFOLWR� HVWi� FRQYLFWR� GH� TXH� R� PXQGR� HVWi� HP� SHUPDQHQWH� PXGDQoD��HQWmR�HOH�QmR�p�WULVWH�� �'��+HUiFOLWR�QmR�p� WULVWH�� HQWmR�HOH�QmR�HVWi� FRQYLFWR�GH�TXH�R�PXQGR� HVWi�HP�SHUPDQHQWH�PXGDQoD�� �(��+HUiFOLWR�p� WULVWH��HQWmR�HOH�QmR�HVWi�FRQYLFWR�GH�TXH�R�PXQGR�HVWi� HP�SHUPDQHQWH�PXGDQoD�� 5(62/8d2�� � 1R�HQXQFLDGR�WHPRV�D�FRQGLFLRQDO�SÆT�� HVWi�FRQYLFWR�Æ�p�WULVWH� � � 6DEHPRV� TXH� SÆT� p� HTXLYDOHQWH� D� aTÆaS�� (VVD� ~OWLPD� SRGH� VHU� HVFULWD�DVVLP�� 12�p�WULVWH�Æ�12�HVWi�FRQYLFWR� � � 7HPRV�HVVD�IUDVH�QD�DOWHUQDWLYD�'��VH�+HUiFOLWR�QmR�p�WULVWH��HQWmR� HOH�QmR�HVWi�FRQYLFWR�GH�TXH�R�PXQGR�HVWi�HP�SHUPDQHQWH�PXGDQoD�� � � 6H�QmR� WLYpVVHPRV�HQFRQWUDGR�R�JDEDULWR��SRGHUtDPRV� WHU� WHQWDGR� HQFRQWUDU� D� RXWUD� HTXLYDOrQFLD� ³PDQMDGD´� GD� FRQGLFLRQDO� SÆT�� TXH� p� D� GLVMXQomR�³aS�RX�T´��RX�VHMD�� 12�HVWi�FRQYLFWR�28�p�WULVWH� � 2X�PHOKRU�� +HUiFOLWR�QmR�HVWi�FRQYLFWR�GH�TXH�R�PXQGR�HVWi�HP�SHUPDQHQWH�PXGDQoD�28� HOH�p�WULVWH��5HVSRVWD��'� � � Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� ����&RQGLomR�QHFHVViULD�H�FRQGLomR�VXILFLHQWH�������������������������������������������������������������������������������� � 4XDQGR�WHPRV�XPD�FRQGLFLRQDO�SÆT��VDEHPRV�TXH�VH�D�FRQGLomR�S� DFRQWHFHU��FRP�FHUWH]D�R�UHVXOWDGR�T�GHYH�DFRQWHFHU��SDUD�TXH�SÆT�VHMD� XPD�SURSRVLomR�YHUGDGHLUD���3RUWDQWR��SRGHPRV�GL]HU�TXH�S�DFRQWHFHU�p� VXILFLHQWH�SDUD�DILUPDUPRV�TXH�T�DFRQWHFH��(P�RXWUDV�SDODYUDV��S�p�XPD� FRQGLomR�VXILFLHQWH�SDUD�T��� � 3RU�H[HPSOR��VH�GLVVHUPRV�³6H�FKRYH��HQWmR�R�FKmR�ILFD�PROKDGR´�� p�VXILFLHQWH�VDEHU�TXH�FKRYH�SDUD�DILUPDUPRV�TXH�R�FKmR� ILFD�PROKDGR�� &KRYHU� p� XPD� FRQGLomR� VXILFLHQWH� SDUD� TXH� R� FKmR� ILTXH� PROKDGR�� 3RU� RXWUR�ODGR��SRGHPRV�GL]HU�TXH�VHPSUH�TXH�FKRYH��R�FKmR�ILFD�PROKDGR��e� QHFHVViULR� TXH� R� FKmR� ILTXH� PROKDGR� SDUD� SRGHUPRV� DILUPDU� FKRYH�� 3RUWDQWR�� ³R� FKmR� ILFD� PROKDGR´� p� XPD� FRQGLomR� QHFHVViULD� SDUD� SRGHUPRV�GL]HU�TXH�FKRYH��VH�R�FKmR�HVWLYHVVH�VHFR��WHUtDPRV�FHUWH]D�GH� TXH�QmR�FKRYH���2X�VHMD��T�p�XPD�FRQGLomR�QHFHVViULD�SDUD�S�� � 5HVXPLGDPHQWH�� TXDQGR� WHPRV� XPD� FRQGLFLRQDO� SÆT�� SRGHPRV� DILUPDU�TXH�S�p�VXILFLHQWH�SDUD�T��H��SRU�RXWUR�ODGR��T�p�QHFHVViULD�SDUD�S�� � 3RU� RXWUR� ODGR�� TXDQGR� WHPRV� XPD� ELFRQGLFLRQDO� S Tl �� SRGHPRV� GL]HU� TXH� S� p� QHFHVViULD� H� VXILFLHQWH� SDUD� T�� H� YLFH�YHUVD�� 3DUD� D� SURSRVLomR�³&KRYH�VH�H�VRPHQWH�VH�R�FKmR�ILFD�PROKDGR´�VHU�YHUGDGHLUD�� SRGHPRV� GL]HU� TXH� p� SUHFLVR� �QHFHVViULR�� TXH� FKRYD� SDUD� TXH� R� FKmR� ILTXH�PROKDGR��1mR�p�GDGD�RXWUD�SRVVLELOLGDGH��(�p�VXILFLHQWH�VDEHU�TXH� FKRYH�SDUD�SRGHU�DILUPDU�TXH�R�FKmR�ILFD�PROKDGR��'D�PHVPD�IRUPD��p� VXILFLHQWH�VDEHU�TXH�R�FKmR�ILFRX�PROKDGR�SDUD�DILUPDU�TXH�FKRYHX��H�D� ~QLFD�SRVVLELOLGDGH�GH�WHU�FKRYLGR�p�VH�R�FKmR�WLYHU�ILFDGR�PROKDGR��LVWR�p�� R�FKmR�WHU�ILFDGR�PROKDGR�p�QHFHVViULR�SDUD�TXH�WHQKD�FKRYLGR�� � 9HMD�HVWD�TXHVWmR�� � ���)&&�±�%$&(1�±�������6HMDP�DV�SURSRVLo}HV�� S��DWXDomR�FRPSUDGRUD�GH�GyODUHV�SRU�SDUWH�GR�%DQFR�&HQWUDO� T��ID]HU�IUHQWH�DR�IOX[R�SRVLWLYR� 6H�S�LPSOLFD�HP�T��HQWmR�� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� D�� D� DWXDomR� FRPSUDGRUD� GH� GyODUHV� SRU� SDUWH� GR� %DQFR� &HQWUDO� p� FRQGLomR�QHFHVViULD�SDUD�ID]HU�IUHQWH�DR�IOX[R�SRVLWLYR� E�� ID]HU� IUHQWH� DR� IOX[R� SRVLWLYR� p� FRQGLomR� VXILFLHQWH� SDUD� D� DWXDomR� FRPSUDGRUD�GH�GyODUHV�SRU�SDUWH�GR�%DQFR�&HQWUDO� F�� D� DWXDomR� FRPSUDGRUD� GH� GyODUHV� SRU� SDUWH� GR� %DQFR� &HQWUDO� p� FRQGLomR�VXILFLHQWH�SDUD�ID]HU�IUHQWH�DR�IOX[R�SRVLWLYR� G��ID]HU�IUHQWH�DR�IOX[R�SRVLWLYR�p�FRQGLomR�QHFHVViULD�H�VXILFLHQWH�SDUD�D� DWXDomR�FRPSUDGRUD�GH�GyODUHV�SRU�SDUWH�GR�%DQFR�&HQWUDO� H�� D� DWXDomR� FRPSUDGRUD� GH� GyODUHV� SRU� SDUWH� GR� %DQFR� &HQWUDO� QmR� p� FRQGLomR�VXILFLHQWH�H�QHP�QHFHVViULD�SDUD�ID]HU�IUHQWH�DR�IOX[R�SRVLWLYR�� 5(62/8d2�� � 6H� SÆT��SRGHPRV�GL]HU� TXH�p� VXILFLHQWH�TXH�S�RFRUUD�SDUD�TXH�T� RFRUUD� �S� p� FRQGLomR� VXILFLHQWH� GH� T��� ,VWR� p�� D� DWXDomR� FRPSUDGRUD� p� FRQGLomR�VXILFLHQWH�SDUD�ID]HU�IUHQWH�DR�IOX[R�� 7DPEpP� SRGHPRV� GL]HU� TXH� FDVR� T� QmR� WHQKD� RFRUULGR�� QmR� p� SRVVtYHO�TXH�S� WHQKD�RFRUULGR��aTÆaS��� ,VWR�p��T�p�FRQGLomR�QHFHVViULD� GH� S�� ID]HU� IUHQWH� DR� IOX[R� p� FRQGLomR� QHFHVViULD� SDUD� D� DWXDomR� FRPSUDGRUD�� 5HVSRVWD��&�� �� ����6HQWHQoDV�DEHUWDV� � 6HQWHQoDV� DEHUWDV� VmR� DTXHODV� TXH� SRVVXHP� XPD� RX� PDLV� YDULiYHLV��FRPR�R�H[HPSOR�DEDL[R��GR�WLSR�SÆT��� ³6H��;�p�GLYLVtYHO�SRU����HQWmR�;�p�GLYLVtYHO�SRU��´� � � 7HPRV� D� YDULiYHO� ;� QHVVD� IUDVH�� TXH� SRGH� DVVXPLU� GLIHUHQWHV� YDORUHV��6H�;�IRU�LJXDO�D�����WHUHPRV��� ³6H����p�GLYLVtYHO�SRU����HQWmR����p�GLYLVtYHO�SRU��´� � � (VWD�IUDVH�p�YHUGDGHLUD��SRLV�S�p�9�H�T�p�9��6H�;� �����WHUHPRV�� ³6H����p�GLYLVtYHO�SRU����HQWmR����p�GLYLVtYHO�SRU��´� � Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� � (VWD�IUDVH�p�YHUGDGHLUD��SRLV�S�p�)�H�T�WDPEpP�p�)��-i�VH�;� ������� WHUHPRV�� ³6H����p�GLYLVtYHO�SRU����HQWmR������p�GLYLVtYHO�SRU��´� � � $JRUD�D�IUDVH�p�IDOVD��SRLV�S�p�9�H�T�p�)�� � 3RUWDQWR��TXDQGR�WHPRV�XPD�VHQWHQoD�DEHUWD��QmR�SRGHPRV�DILUPDU� GH�DQWHPmR�TXH�HOD�p�YHUGDGHLUD�RX�IDOVD��SRLV� LVVR�GHSHQGHUi�GR�YDORU� TXH� DV� YDULiYHLV� DVVXPLUHP�� $VVLP�� XPD� VHQWHQoD� DEHUWD� QmR� p� XPD� SURSRVLomR��Vy�VHUi�XPD�SURSRVLomR�DSyV�GHILQLUPRV�R�YDORU�GD�YDULiYHO���� � 7UDEDOKH�R�FRQFHLWR�GH�VHQWHQoDV�DEHUWDV�QD�TXHVWmR�D�VHJXLU�� � � � � � ���)&&� ±� %$+,$*È6� ±� ������ ³6H� D� VRPD� GRV� GtJLWRV� GH� XP� Q~PHUR� LQWHLUR�Q�p�GLYLVtYHO�SRU����HQWmR�Q�p�GLYLVtYHO�SRU��´��8P�YDORU�GH�Q�TXH� PRVWUD�VHU�IDOVD�D�IUDVH�DFLPD�p�� D����� E����� F����� G����� H����� 5(62/8d2�� � (VWDPRV�GLDQWH�GH�XPD�VHQWHQoD�DEHUWD��SRLV� WHPRV�XPD�YDULiYHO� �Q�� TXH�� GHSHQGHQGR� GH� VHX� YDORU�� SRGH� WRUQDU� D� SURSRVLomR� IDOVD� RX� YHUGDGHLUD�� � 2EVHUYH�TXH�D�SURSRVLomR�GR�HQXQFLDGR�p�XPD�FRQGLFLRQDO�� LVWR�p�� XPD�IUDVH�GR�WLSR�S�Æ�T��6DEHPRV�TXH�Vy�Ki�XPD�IRUPD�GD�FRQGLFLRQDO� VHU�IDOVD��VH�D�FRQGLomR��S��IRU�YHUGDGHLUD��PDV�DLQGD�DVVLP�R�UHVXOWDGR� �T��IRU�IDOVR��VH�ILFRX�HP�G~YLGD��YROWH�QD�WDEHOD�YHUGDGH�GD�FRQGLFLRQDO��� &RP�LVVR��YDPRV�DQDOLVDU�DV�DOWHUQDWLYDV�� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� Î�Q� �����D�VRPD�GH�VHXV�GtJLWRV�QmR�p�GLYLVtYHO�SRU���������� �����R� TXH�WRUQD�D�FRQGLomR�S�)DOVD��&RPR�D�FRQGLomR�p�IDOVD��R�UHVXOWDGR� �T��SRGH�VHU�YHUGDGHLUR�RX�IDOVR�TXH�D�IUDVH�FRQWLQXD�YHUGDGHLUD��$� WtWXOR�GH�FXULRVLGDGH��QRWH�TXH�QHVWH�FDVR�T�p�9HUGDGHLUD��SRLV����p� GLYLVtYHO�SRU����� Î�Q� �����D�VRPD�GRV�VHXV�GtJLWRV�p�GLYLVtYHO�SRU������� ����RX�VHMD�� S� p� 9HUGDGHLUD�� (QWUHWDQWR�� R� UHVXOWDGR� T� p� )DOVR�� SRLV� ��� QmR� p� GLYLVtYHO�SRU����3RUWDQWR��Q� ����WRUQD�D�SURSRVLomR�FRPSRVWD�)DOVD�� (VWH�p�R�JDEDULWR�� Î�Q� � ���� QHVWH� FDVR�� S� p� )DOVD� H� T� p� )DOVD�� &RP� LVVR�� D� IUDVH� p� 9HUGDGHLUD��SDUD�HVSDQWR�GDTXHOHV�QmR�DFRVWXPDGRV�FRP�R�HVWXGR� GD�/yJLFD�� Î�Q� � ���� QHVWH� FDVR�� S� H� T� VmR� 9HUGDGHLUDV�� WRUQDQGR� SÆT� 9HUGDGHLUD� Î�Q� �����LGHP�DR�DQWHULRU�� 5HVSRVWD��%��� � � $JRUD�p�KRUD�GH�SUDWLFDU�WXGR�R�TXH�YLPRV�DWp�DTXL��UHVROYHQGR�XPD� EDWHULD�GH�TXHVW}HV�� � � � � � � � � � � � Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� ���5(62/8d2�'(�48(67®(6� � ���)&&� ±� 6()$=�3(� ±� ������ 2EVHUYH� D� DILUPDomR� D� VHJXLU�� IHLWD� SHOR� SUHIHLWR�GH�XPD�JUDQGH�FDSLWDO�� 6H�D�LQIODomR�QmR�FDLU�RX�R�SUHoR�GR�yOHR�GLHVHO�DXPHQWDU��HQWmR�R�SUHoR� GDV�SDVVDJHQV�GH�{QLEXV�VHUi�UHDMXVWDGR�� 8PD�PDQHLUD�ORJLFDPHQWH�HTXLYDOHQWH�GH�ID]HU�HVWD�DILUPDomR�p�� �$�� 6H� D� LQIODomR� FDLU� H� R� SUHoR� GR� yOHR� GLHVHO� QmR� DXPHQWDU�� HQWmR� R� SUHoR�GDV�SDVVDJHQV�GH�{QLEXV�QmR�VHUi�UHDMXVWDGR�� �%��6H�D�LQIODomR�FDLU�RX�R�SUHoR�GR�yOHR�GLHVHO�DXPHQWDU��HQWmR�R�SUHoR� GDV�SDVVDJHQV�GH�{QLEXV�QmR�VHUi�UHDMXVWDGR�� �&��6H�R�SUHoR�GDV�SDVVDJHQV�GH�{QLEXV�IRU�UHDMXVWDGR��HQWmR�D� LQIODomR� QmR�WHUi�FDtGR�RX�R�SUHoR�GR�yOHR�GLHVHO�WHUi�DXPHQWDGR�� �'�� 6H� R� SUHoR� GDV� SDVVDJHQV� GH� {QLEXV� QmR� IRU� UHDMXVWDGR�� HQWmR� D� LQIODomR�WHUi�FDtGR�RX�R�SUHoR�GR�yOHR�GLHVHO�WHUi�DXPHQWDGR���(�� 6H� R� SUHoR� GDV� SDVVDJHQV� GH� {QLEXV� QmR� IRU� UHDMXVWDGR�� HQWmR� D� LQIODomR�WHUi�FDtGR�H�R�SUHoR�GR�yOHR�GLHVHO�QmR�WHUi�DXPHQWDGR�� 5(62/8d2�� � 7HPRV�D�SURSRVLomR�FRQGLFLRQDO�TXH�SRGH�VHU�VLQWHWL]DGD�DVVLP��� �LQIODomR�QmR�FDLU�RX�GLHVHO�DXPHQWDU��Æ�SDVVDJHP�UHDMXVWDGD� � � (VVD�SURSRVLomR�p�GR�WLSR��3�RX�4��Æ�5��RQGH�� 3� �LQIODomR�QmR�FDLU� 4� �GLHVHO�DXPHQWDU� 5� �SDVVDJHP�UHDMXVWDGD� � � (VVD�SURSRVLomR�p�HTXLYDOHQWH�D�a5Æa�3�RX�4���TXH�SRU�VXD�YH]�p� HTXLYDOHQWH�D�a5Æ��a3�H�a4���RQGH�� a3� �LQIODomR�FDLU� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� a4� �GLHVHO�12�DXPHQWDU� a5� �SDVVDJHP�12�6(5�UHDMXVWDGD� � (VFUHYHQGR�a5��!�a3�H�a4���WHPRV�� SDVVDJHP�QmR�VHU�UHDMXVWDGD�Æ��LQIODomR�FDL�H�GLHVHO�QmR�DXPHQWD�� � � 7HPRV�LVVR�QD�DOWHUQDWLYD�(�� 5HVSRVWD��(� � ���� )&&�±�6()$=�3(�±�������$QWHV�GD� URGDGD� ILQDO� GR� FDPSHRQDWR� LQJOrV� GH� IXWHERO�� XP� FRPHQWDULVWD� HVSRUWLYR� DSUHVHQWRX� D� VLWXDomR� GDV� GXDV� ~QLFDV� HTXLSHV� FRP� FKDQFHV� GH� VHUHP� FDPSHmV�� SRU� PHLR� GD� VHJXLQWH�DILUPDomR�� ³3DUD�TXH�R�$UVHQDO�VHMD�FDPSHmR��p�QHFHVViULR�TXH�HOH�YHQoD�VXD�SDUWLGD� H�TXH�R�&KHOVHD�SHUFD�RX�HPSDWH�D�VXD�´� 8PD� PDQHLUD� HTXLYDOHQWH�� GR� SRQWR� GH� YLVWD� OyJLFR�� GH� DSUHVHQWDU� HVWD� LQIRUPDomR�p��³3DUD�TXH�R�$UVHQDO�VHMD�FDPSHmR��p�QHFHVViULR�TXH�HOH� �$�� YHQoD� VXD�SDUWLGD� H� R�&KHOVHD�SHUFD� D� VXD�RX� TXH�HOH� YHQoD�D� VXD� SDUWLGD�H�R�&KHOVHD�HPSDWH�D�VXD�´� �%��YHQoD�VXD�SDUWLGD�RX�R�&KHOVHD�SHUFD�D�VXD�RX�TXH�HOH�YHQoD�D�VXD� SDUWLGD�RX�R�&KHOVHD�HPSDWH�D�VXD�´� �&��HPSDWH�VXD�SDUWLGD�H�R�&KHOVHD�SHUFD�D�VXD�RX�TXH�HOH�YHQoD�D�VXD� SDUWLGD�H�R�&KHOVHD�QmR�YHQoD�D�VXD�´� �'�� YHQoD� VXD� SDUWLGD� H� R� &KHOVHD� SHUFD� D� VXD� H� TXH� HOH� YHQoD� D� VXD� SDUWLGD�H�R�&KHOVHD�HPSDWH�D�VXD�´� �(�� YHQoD� VXD�SDUWLGD� RX�R�&KHOVHD�SHUFD� D� VXD�H�TXH�HOH� YHQoD�D� VXD� SDUWLGD�RX�R�&KHOVHD�HPSDWH�D�VXD�´� 5(62/8d2�� � $�SURSRVLomR�GR�HQXQFLDGR�SRGH�VHU�UHVXPLGD�DVVLP��� $UVHQDO�YHQoD�(��&KHOVHD�SHUFD�28�&KHOVHD�HPSDWH�� � � 6DEHPRV�TXH�D�SURSRVLomR�FRPSRVWD��S�(��T�28�U���p�HTXLYDOHQWH�D� ��S�(�T��28��S�(�U�����(VFUHYHQGR�HVVD�~OWLPD��WHUtDPRV�DOJR�FRPR��� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� �$UVHQDO�YHQoD�(�&KHOVHD�SHUFD��28��$UVHQDO�YHQoD�(�&KHOVHD�HPSDWH�� � � 7HPRV�LVVR�QD�DOWHUQDWLYD�$�� 5HVSRVWD��$� � ���� )&&� ±� 75)��� ±� ������ &RQVLGHUH� D� DILUPDomR�� 1HP� WRGDV� DV� H[LJrQFLDV� IRUDP� FXPSULGDV� RX� R� SURFHVVR� VHJXH� DGLDQWH�� 'R� SRQWR� GH� YLVWD�OyJLFR��XPD�DILUPDomR�HTXLYDOHQWH�j�DFLPD�p�� �$��6H�R�SURFHVVR� VHJXH�DGLDQWH��HQWmR�QHP� WRGDV�DV�H[LJrQFLDV� IRUDP� FXPSULGDV�� �%��2�SURFHVVR�QmR�VHJXH�DGLDQWH�H�WRGDV�DV�H[LJrQFLDV�IRUDP�FXPSULGDV�� �&�� 6H� WRGDV� DV� H[LJrQFLDV� IRUDP� FXPSULGDV�� HQWmR� R� SURFHVVR� VHJXH� DGLDQWH�� �'�� 6H� QHQKXPD� H[LJrQFLD� IRL� FXPSULGD�� HQWmR� R� SURFHVVR� QmR� VHJXH� DGLDQWH�� �(�� 1HP� WRGDV� DV� H[LJrQFLDV� IRUDP� FXPSULGDV� H� R� SURFHVVR� VHJXH� DGLDQWH�� 5(62/8d2�� 6DEHPRV�TXH�D�FRQGLFLRQDO�$Æ%�p�HTXLYDOHQWH�j�GLVMXQomR�³a$�RX� %´��$�IUDVH�GR�HQXQFLDGR�p�XPD�GLVMXQomR�³a$�RX�%´��RQGH�� a$� �QHP�WRGDV�DV�H[LJrQFLDV�IRUDP�FXPSULGDV� %� �R�SURFHVVR�VHJXH�DGLDQWH� � � 3RUWDQWR�� D� SURSRVLomR� $� p� LJXDO� D� ³WRGDV� DV� H[LJrQFLDV� IRUDP� FXPSULGDV´��H�D�FRQGLFLRQDO�$Æ%�p�� ³6H�WRGDV�DV�H[LJrQFLDV�IRUDP�FXPSULGDV��HQWmR�R�SURFHVVR�VHJXH� DGLDQWH´� 5HVSRVWD��&� � ���� )&&� ±� 757��� ±� ������ 'XUDQWH� XP� FRPtFLR� GH� VXD� FDPSDQKD� SDUD�R�*RYHUQR�GR�(VWDGR��XP�FDQGLGDWR�IH]�D�VHJXLQWH�DILUPDomR��� �� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� �³6H�HX�IRU�HOHLWR��YRX�DVIDOWDU�������TXLO{PHWURV�GH�HVWUDGDV�H�FRQVWUXLU� PDLV�GH�������FDVDV�SRSXODUHV�HP�QRVVR�(VWDGR�´�� �� �&RQVLGHUDQGR� TXH�� DSyV� DOJXP� WHPSR�� D� DILUPDomR� UHYHORX�VH� IDOVD�� SRGH�VH�FRQFOXLU�TXH��QHFHVVDULDPHQWH��� �$��R�FDQGLGDWR�QmR� IRL�HOHLWR�H�QmR� IRUDP�DVIDOWDGRV�������TXLO{PHWURV� GH�HVWUDGDV�QR�(VWDGR��� �%��R�FDQGLGDWR�QmR�IRL�HOHLWR��PDV�IRUDP�FRQVWUXtGDV�PDLV�GH�������FDVDV� SRSXODUHV�QR�(VWDGR���� �&��R�FDQGLGDWR�IRL�HOHLWR��PDV�QmR�IRUDP�DVIDOWDGRV�������TXLO{PHWURV�GH� HVWUDGDV�QR�(VWDGR��� �'�� R� FDQGLGDWR� IRL� HOHLWR� H� IRUDP� FRQVWUXtGDV� PDLV� GH� ������ FDVDV� SRSXODUHV�QR�(VWDGR��� �(�� QmR� IRUDP� DVIDOWDGRV� ������ TXLO{PHWURV� GH� HVWUDGDV� RX� QmR� IRUDP� FRQVWUXtGDV�PDLV�GH�������FDVDV�SRSXODUHV�QR�(VWDGR��� 5(62/8d2��� � 7HPRV�D�FRQGLFLRQDO�GR�WLSR�SÆ�T�H�U���� � �HX�IRU�HOHLWR��Æ��DVIDOWDU�����NP�H�FRQVWUXLU�PDLV�GH������FDVDV�� � � 2�~QLFR�FDVR�RQGH�HVVD�FRQGLFLRQDO�WHP�YDORU�OyJLFR�)DOVR�p�TXDQGR� WHPRV�9Æ)��RX�VHMD��TXDQGR�S�p�9��R�FDQGLGDWR�p�HOHLWR��H� ³T�H� U´�p�)�� 3DUD�TXH�³T�H�U´�VHMD�)��p�SUHFLVR�TXH�VXD�QHJDomR�VHMD�9��RX�VHMD��TXH� ³aT�RX�aU´�VHMD�9��2X�VHMD�� � ³QmR�DVIDOWDU�����NP�RX�QmR�FRQVWUXLU�PDLV�GH������FDVDV´� � � 3RUWDQWR��SDUD�TXH�D�IUDVH�GR�FDQGLGDWR��p�QHFHVViULR�TXH�� ��R�FDQGLGDWR�WHQKD�VLGR�HOHLWR��H� �� QmR� WHQKDP� VLGR� DVIDOWDGRV� ����NP� RX� QmR� WHQKDP� VLGR� FRQVWUXtGDV� PDLV�GH������FDVDV�� � Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� � 3RUWDQWR�� D� DOWHUQDWLYD� (� HVWi� FRUUHWD�� SRLV� p� SUHFLVR�� QHFHVVDULDPHQWH��TXH�R�TXH�HOD�DILUPD�VHMD�9HUGDGHLUR�� � �(�� QmR� IRUDP� DVIDOWDGRV� ������ TXLO{PHWURV� GH� HVWUDGDV� RX� QmR� IRUDP� FRQVWUXtGDV�PDLV�GH�������FDVDV�SRSXODUHV�QR�(VWDGR��� � � � 1DWXUDOPHQWH�� WDPEpP� VHULD� FRUUHWD� XPD� RSomR� GH� UHVSRVWD� GR� WLSR��� � ³2� FDQGLGDWR� IRL� HOHLWR� (� QmR� IRUDP� DVIDOWDGRV� ����� TXLO{PHWURV� GH� HVWUDGDV� RX� QmR� IRUDP� FRQVWUXtGDV� PDLV� GH� ����� FDVDV� SRSXODUHV� QR� (VWDGR´� � � 7DPEpP� VHULD� FRUUHWD� XPD� DILUPDomR� TXH� GLVVHVVH� TXH�� QHFHVVDULDPHQWH��³R�FDQGLGDWR�IRL�HOHLWR´��� 5HVSRVWD��(� � ���� )&&� ±� 757��� ±� ������ 8P� GLD� DQWHV� GD� UHXQLmR� DQXDO� FRP� RV� UHVSRQViYHLV� SRU� WRGDV� DV� IUDQTXLDV� GH� XPD� FDGHLD� GH� ODQFKRQHWHV�� R� GLUHWRU�FRPHUFLDO�UHFHEHX�XP�UHODWyULR�FRQWHQGR�D�VHJXLQWH�LQIRUPDomR���� � 7RGDV� DV� IUDQTXLDV� HQYLDUDP� R� EDODQoR� DQXDO� H� QHQKXPD� GHODV� WHYH� SUHMXt]R�QHVWH�DQR��� �� 0LQXWRV� DQWHV� GD� UHXQLmR�� SRUpP�� HOH� UHFHEHX� XPD� PHQVDJHP� HP� VHX� FHOXODU� HQYLDGD� SHOR� JHUHQWH� TXH� HODERURX� R� UHODWyULR�� UHODWDQGR� TXH� D� LQIRUPDomR�QmR�HVWDYD�FRUUHWD��'HVVD�IRUPD��R�GLUHWRU�S{GH�FRQFOXLU�TXH�� QHFHVVDULDPHQWH��� �$�� QHQKXPD� IUDQTXLD� HQYLRX� R� EDODQoR� DQXDO� H� WRGDV� HODV� WLYHUDP� SUHMXt]R�QHVWH�DQR��� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� �%�� DOJXPD� IUDQTXLD� QmR� HQYLRX� R� EDODQoR� DQXDO� H� WRGDV� HODV� WLYHUDP� SUHMXt]R�QHVWH�DQR��� �&��QHQKXPD�IUDQTXLD�HQYLRX�R�EDODQoR�DQXDO�RX�SHOR�PHQRV�XPD�GHODV� WHYH�SUHMXt]R�QHVWH�DQR���� �'�� QHP� WRGDV� DV� IUDQTXLDV� HQYLDUDP� R� EDODQoR� DQXDO� RX� WRGDV� HODV� WLYHUDP�SUHMXt]R�QHVWH�DQR���� �(��QHP�WRGDV�DV�IUDQTXLDV�HQYLDUDP�R�EDODQoR�DQXDO�RX�SHOR�PHQRV�XPD� GHODV�WHYH�SUHMXt]R�QHVWH�DQR��� 5(62/8d2��� � 6H� D� FRQMXQomR� ³7RGDV� DV� IUDQTXLDV� HQYLDUDP� R� EDODQoR� DQXDO� (� QHQKXPD�GHODV�WHYH�SUHMXt]R�QHVWH�DQR´�p�)$/6$��SRGHPRV�FRQFOXLU�TXH�D� VXD�QHJDomR�p�YHUGDGHLUD��(VWD�QHJDomR�p��� ³1HP�WRGDV�DV�IUDQTXLDV�HQYLDUDP�R�EDODQoR�DQXDO�28�DOJXPD�GHODV�WHYH�SUHMXt]R�QHVWH� DQR´� � � 7HPRV�XPD�YDULDomR�GLVWR�QD�DOWHUQDWLYD�(�� 5HVSRVWD��(� � ���� )&&�±�7-$3�±�������&RQVLGHUH�D�VHJXLQWH�GHFODUDomR��IHLWD�SRU�XP� DQDOLVWD� SROtWLFR� ILFWtFLR�� ³VH� R� SDUWLGR� 3� FRQVHJXLU� HOHJHU� 6HQDGRU� QR� (VWDGR�)�RX�QR�(VWDGR�*��HQWmR�WHUi�D�PDLRULD�QR�6HQDGR´�� $� SDUWLU� GD� GHFODUDomR� GR� DQDOLVWD�� p� FRUUHWR� FRQFOXLU� TXH�� QHFHVVDULDPHQWH��VH�R�SDUWLGR�3� �$��QmR� WLYHU�D�PDLRULD� QR�6HQDGR�� HQWmR�QmR� WHUi� FRQVHJXLGR� HOHJHU� R� VHQDGRU�QR�(VWDGR�*�� �%��WLYHU�D�PDLRULD�QR�6HQDGR��HQWmR�WHUi�FRQVHJXLGR�HOHJHU�R�VHQDGRU�QR� (VWDGR�*�� �&��WLYHU�D�PDLRULD�QR�6HQDGR��HQWmR�WHUi�FRQVHJXLGR�HOHJHU�R�VHQDGRU�QR� (VWDGR�)�� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� �'��QmR�FRQVHJXLX�HOHJHU�R�VHQDGRU�QR�(VWDGR�)��HQWmR�QmR�WHUi�D�PDLRULD� QR�6HQDGR�� �(��QmR�FRQVHJXLX�HOHJHU�R�VHQDGRU�QR�(VWDGR�*��HQWmR�QmR�WHUi�D�PDLRULD� QR�6HQDGR�� 5(62/8d2�� � 9DPRV�XVDU�DV�VHJXLQWHV�SURSRVLo}HV�VLPSOHV�� S� �R�SDUWLGR�3�FRQVHJXLU�HOHJHU�6HQDGRU�QR�(VWDGR�)� T� �R�SDUWLGR�3�FRQVHJXLU�HOHJHU�6HQDGRU�QR�(VWDGR�*� U� �R�SDUWLGR�3�WHUi�D�PDLRULD�QR�6HQDGR� � � 9HMD�TXH�D�IUDVH�GR�HQXQFLDGR�p�� �S�RX�T��Æ�U� � � (VWD�SURSRVLomR�p�HTXLYDOHQWH�D�� aU�Æ�a�S�RX�T�� � � (VWD�SURSRVLomR�p�R�PHVPR�TXH�� aU�Æ��aS�H�aT�� � 5HHVFUHYHQGR�HVWD�~OWLPD�� ³VH�R�SDUWLGR�3�QmR�WLYHU�D�PDLRULD�QR�6HQDGR��HQWmR�QmR�WHUi�FRQVHJXLGR� HOHJHU� R� VHQDGRU� QR� (VWDGR� )� H� QmR� WHUi� FRQVHJXLGR� HOHJHU� VHQDGRU� QR� (VWDGR�*´� � � $QDOLVDQGR�DV�DOWHUQDWLYDV�GH� UHVSRVWD��YHMD�TXH�D�$�HVWi�FRUUHWD�� $ILQDO��VH�R�SDUWLGR�3�QmR�WLYHU�PDLRULD��p�SRUTXH�HOH�QmR�HOHJHX�VHQDGRU� QR�HVWDGR�*��H�WDPEpP�QmR�HOHJHX�VHQDGRU�QR�HVWDGR�)��� 5HVSRVWD��$� ���� )&&�±�7-$3�±�������1R�%UDVLO��R�YRWR�p�REULJDWyULR�DSHQDV�SDUD�RV� EUDVLOHLURV�DOIDEHWL]DGRV�TXH� WrP�GH����D����DQRV��'H�DFRUGR�FRP�HVVD� LQIRUPDomR��VH�/Xt]D�p�XPD�EUDVLOHLUD�TXH�QmR�p�REULJDGD�D�YRWDU��HQWmR�� QHFHVVDULDPHQWH��/Xt]D� �$��p�DQDOIDEHWD�H�WHP�PHQRV�GH����DQRV�RX�PDLV�GH����� �%��p�DQDOIDEHWD�RX�WHP�PHQRV�GH����DQRV�RX�PDLV�GH����� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� �&��QmR�p�DQDOIDEHWD��PDV�WHP�PHQRV�GH����DQRV�� �'��p�DQDOIDEHWD��PDV�SRGH�WHU�GH����D����DQRV�� �(��WHP�PDLV�GH����DQRV��PDV�SRGH�QmR�VHU�DQDOIDEHWD�� 5(62/8d2�� � 2�HQXQFLDGR�QRV�PRVWUD�TXH�R�~QLFR�FDVR�RQGH�D�SHVVRD�p�REULJDGD� D�YRWDU�p�TXDQGR�HOD�SUHHQFKH�WRGDV�HVVDV�FRQGLo}HV�� ��p�DOIDEHWL]DGD� ��WHP�GH����D����DQRV� � � /RJR��VH�QmR�IRU�SUHHQFKLGD�TXDOTXHU�GHVVDV�FRQGLo}HV��RX�PHVPR� DV�GXDV���D�SHVVRD�QmR�p�REULJDGD�D�YRWDU��3RGHPRV�HVFUHYHU�� ³VH�D�SHVVRD�IRU�DQDOIDEHWD�28�HQWmR�HVWLYHU�IRUD�GD�IDL[D�������DQRV��HOD� QmR�p�REULJDGD�D�YRWDU´� � � 3DUD�HVWDU� IRUD�GD�IDL[D�GH�������DQRV��HOD�GHYH�WHU�PHQRV�GH���� RX�PDLV�GH����DQRV��2X�VHMD�� ³VH�D�SHVVRD�IRU�DQDOIDEHWD�28�WLYHU�PHQRV�GH����RX�PDLV�GH����DQRV��HOD� QmR�p�REULJDGD�D�YRWDU´�� � � $VVLP��SRGHPRV�FRQFOXLU�TXH�/Xt]D�p�DQDOIDEHWD�RX�WHP�PHQRV�GH� ���RX�PDLV�GH����DQRV��3RGH�DWp�VHU�TXH�HOD�FXPSUD�DV�GXDV�FRQGLo}HV� �VHMD�DQDOIDEHWD�H�WHQKD�PDLV�GH����DQRV��SRU�H[HPSOR���PDV�LVWR�QmR�p� QHFHVViULR�� SRLV� EDVWD� HOD� SUHHQFKHU� DOJXPD� GDV� FRQGLo}HV� SDUD� QmR� SUHFLVDU�YRWDU�� 5HVSRVWD��%� � ���� )&&�±�7-$3�±�������9RX�j�DFDGHPLD�WRGRV�RV�GLDV�GD�VHPDQD�H� FRUUR� WUrV� GLDV� QD� VHPDQD�� 8PD� DILUPDomR� TXH� FRUUHVSRQGH� j� QHJDomR� OyJLFD�GD�DILUPDomR�DQWHULRU�p� �$��1mR�YRX�j�DFDGHPLD�WRGRV�RV�GLDV�GD�VHPDQD�RX�QmR�FRUUR�WUrV�GLDV� QD�VHPDQD�� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� �%��9RX�j�DFDGHPLD�TXDVH�WRGRV�RV�GLDV�GD�VHPDQD�H�FRUUR�GRLV�GLDV�QD� VHPDQD�� �&�� 1XQFD� YRX� j� DFDGHPLD� GXUDQWH� D� VHPDQD� H� QXQFD� FRUUR� GXUDQWH� D� VHPDQD�� �'��1mR�YRX�j�DFDGHPLD�WRGRV�RV�GLDV�GD�VHPDQD�H�QmR�FRUUR�WUrV�GLDV�QD� VHPDQD�� �(��6H�YRX�WRGRV�RV�GLDV�j�DFDGHPLD��HQWmR�FRUUR�WUrV�GLDV�QD�VHPDQD�� 5(62/8d2�� � 7HPRV�D�FRQMXQomR�³S�H�T´��RQGH�� S� �9RX�j�DFDGHPLD�WRGRV�RV�GLDV�GD�VHPDQD� T� �FRUUR�WUrV�GLDV�QD�VHPDQD� � � � $�VXD�QHJDomR�p�³aS�RX�aT´��RX�VHMD�� ³1mR�YRX�j�DFDGHPLD�WRGRV�RV�GLDV�GD�VHPDQD�RX�QmR�FRUUR�WUrV�GLDV�QD� VHPDQD´� 5HVSRVWD��$� � ���� )&&�±�6$(%�%$�±�������5HQDWD�GLVVH�D�VHJXLQWH�IUDVH��³6H�/XFDV� YHQFHX�R�MRJR��HQWmR�'HQLV�QmR�FRPSDUHFHX´��/XFDV��LUDGR��DILUPRX�TXH�D� IUDVH� GLWD� SRU� 5HQDWD� QmR� HUD� YHUGDGHLUD�� 8PD� IUDVH�� TXH� GR� SRQWR� GH� YLVWD�OyJLFR��p�D�QHJDomR�GD�IUDVH�GLWD�SRU�5HQDWD�p�� �$��/XFDV�YHQFHX�R�MRJR�RX�'HQLV�YHQFHX�R�MRJR�� �%��'HQLV�QmR�FRPSDUHFHX�DR�MRJR�H�/XFDV�QmR�YHQFHX�� �&��/XFDV�YHQFHX�R�MRJR�H�'HQLV�FRPSDUHFHX�� �'��6H�/XFDV�QmR�YHQFHX�R�MRJR��HQWmR�'HQLV�FRPSDUHFHX�� �(��/XFDV�YHQFHX�R�MRJR�RX�'HQLV�FRPSDUHFHX�� 5(62/8d2�� � $� IUDVH�GLWD�SRU� 5HQDWD� p� XPD� � FRQGLFLRQDO�GR� WLSR�S��!T�� �$� VXD� QHJDomR�p�GDGD�SHOD�IUDVH��S�H�QmR�T���7HPRV�� S� ��/XFDV�YHQFHX�R�MRJR� T� ��'HQLV�QmR�FRPSDUHFHX� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� � � �'HVVD�IRUPD�D�IUDVH��S�H�QmR�T��p�VLPSOHVPHQWH�� ��/XFDV�YHQFHX�R�MRJR�H�'HQLV�FRPSDUHFHX�� 5HVSRVWD��&� ���� )&&�±�0(75Ð�63�±�������7RGRV�RV�PHFkQLFRV�VmR�LQWHOLJHQWHV�H� UHVROYHP�SUREOHPDV�� 8PD�DILUPDomR�TXH�UHSUHVHQWD�D�QHJDomR�OyJLFD�GD�DILUPDomR�DQWHULRU�p�� �$��QHQKXP�PHFkQLFR�p�LQWHOLJHQWH�H�UHVROYH�SUREOHPDV�� �%�� VH� XP� PHFkQLFR� QmR� p� LQWHOLJHQWH�� HQWmR� HOH� QmR� UHVROYH� TXDOTXHU� SUREOHPD�� �&��DOJXP�PHFkQLFR�QmR�p�LQWHOLJHQWH�RX�QmR�UHVROYH�SUREOHPDV�� �'�� WRGRV� RV� PHFkQLFRV� QmR� VmR� LQWHOLJHQWHV� RX� QLQJXpP� UHVROYH� SUREOHPDV�� �(��VH�XP�PHFkQLFR�UHVROYH�SUREOHPDV��HQWmR�HOH�p�LQWHOLJHQWH�� 5(62/8d2�� � 3DUD� QHJDU� R� TXH� IRL� DILUPDGR� QR� HQXQFLDGR�� EDVWD� HQFRQWUDUPRV� XP� PHFkQLFR� TXH� QmR� VHMD� LQWHOLJHQWH� RX� TXH� QmR� UHVROYD� SUREOHPDV��� 3RUWDQWR��XPD�IRUPD�GH�HVFUHYHU�D�QHJDomR�OyJLFD�GHVWD�IUDVH�p�� ��DOJXP�PHFkQLFR�QmR�p�LQWHOLJHQWH�RX�QmR�UHVROYH�SUREOHPDV�� 5HVSRVWD��&� � ���� )&&�±�757���±��������8P�YHUHDGRU�DILUPRX�TXH��QR�~OWLPR�DQR�� FRPSDUHFHX� D� WRGDV� DV� VHVV}HV� GD� &kPDUD� 0XQLFLSDO� H� QmR� HPSUHJRX� SDUHQWHV� HP� VHX� JDELQHWH�� 3DUD� TXH� HVVD� DILUPDomR� VHMD� IDOVD�� p� QHFHVViULR�TXH��QR�~OWLPR�DQR��HVVH�YHUHDGRU� �$�� WHQKD� IDOWDGR� HP� WRGDV� DV� VHVV}HV� GD� &kPDUD� 0XQLFLSDO� RX� WHQKD� HPSUHJDGR�WRGRV�RV�VHXV�SDUHQWHV�HP�VHX�JDELQHWH�� �%�� WHQKD� IDOWDGR� HP� SHOR� PHQRV� XPD� VHVVmR� GD� &kPDUD� 0XQLFLSDO� H� WHQKD�HPSUHJDGR�WRGRV�RV�VHXV�SDUHQWHV�HP�VHX�JDELQHWH�� �&�� WHQKD� IDOWDGR� HP� SHOR� PHQRV� XPD� VHVVmR� GD� &kPDUD� 0XQLFLSDO� RX� WHQKD�HPSUHJDGR�XP�SDUHQWH�HP�VHX�JDELQHWH�� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� �'�� WHQKD� IDOWDGR� HP� WRGDV� DV� VHVV}HV� GD� &kPDUD� 0XQLFLSDO� H� WHQKD� HPSUHJDGR�XP�SDUHQWH�HP�VHX�JDELQHWH�� �(�� WHQKD� IDOWDGR�HP�PDLV�GD�PHWDGH�GDV�VHVV}HV�GD�&kPDUD�0XQLFLSDO� RX�WHQKD�HPSUHJDGR�SHOR�PHQRV�XP�SDUHQWH�HP�VHX�JDELQHWH�� 5(62/8d2�� � 7HPRV� D� FRQGLFLRQDO� ³S� H� T´� TXH� SRGH� VHU� UHVXPLGD� SRU� ³FRPSDUHFHX�D�WRGDV�(�QmR�HPSUHJRX´��$�VXD�QHJDomR�p�GDGD�SRU�³aS�RX� aT´��TXH�SRGH�VHU� UHVXPLGD� FRPR� ³QmR�FRPSDUHFHX�D�SHOR�PHQRV�XPD�28�HPSUHJRX´��7HPRV�HVVD�~OWLPD�HVWUXWXUD�QD�DOWHUQDWLYD�&�� 5HVSRVWD��&� ���� )&&�±�757���±������� � /HLD�RV�$YLVRV� ,� H� ,,�� FRORFDGRV�HP�XP� GRV�VHWRUHV�GH�XPD�IiEULFD�� � $YLVR�,� 3UH]DGR� IXQFLRQiULR�� VH� YRFr� QmR� UHDOL]RX�R� FXUVR� HVSHFtILFR�� HQWmR� QmR� SRGH�RSHUDU�D�PiTXLQD�0�� � $YLVR�,,� 3UH]DGR� IXQFLRQiULR�� VH� YRFr� UHDOL]RX� R� FXUVR� HVSHFtILFR�� HQWmR� SRGH� RSHUDU�D�PiTXLQD�0�� � 3DXOR�� IXQFLRQiULR� GHVVH� VHWRU�� UHDOL]RX� R� FXUVR� HVSHFtILFR�� PDV� IRL� SURLELGR�� SRU� VHX� VXSHUYLVRU�� GH� RSHUDU� D� PiTXLQD� 0�� $� GHFLVmR� GR� VXSHUYLVRU� �$��RS}H�VH�DSHQDV�DR�$YLVR�,�� �%��RS}H�VH�DR�$YLVR�,�H�SRGH�RX�QmR�VH�RSRU�DR�$YLVR�,,�� �&��RS}H�VH�DRV�GRLV�DYLVRV�� �'��QmR�VH�RS}H�DR�$YLVR�,�QHP�DR�,,�� �(��RS}H�VH�DSHQDV�DR�$YLVR�,,�� 5(62/8d2�� � &DGD� DYLVR� p� XPD� FRQGLFLRQDO� SÆT� �� FXMR� UHVXPR� HQFRQWUD�VH� DEDL[R�� $YLVR�,���QmR�UHDOL]RX�Æ�QmR�SRGH� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� $YLVR�,,���UHDOL]RX�Æ�SRGH� � � 1R�FDVR�GR�IXQFLRQiULR�FLWDGR��WHPRV�TXH�³UHDOL]RX´�p�9��SRLV�HOH�IH]� R� FXUVR�� H� TXH� ³SRGH´� p� )� �SRLV� HOH� IRL� SURLELGR� GH� RSHUDU� D�PiTXLQD��� (VWD� FRPELQDomR� GH� YDORUHV� OyJLFRV� WRUQD� D� FRQGLFLRQDO� GR� DYLVR� ,� YHUGDGHLUD�� SRLV� WHPRV� )Æ9�� -i� D� FRQGLFLRQDO� GR� DYLVR� ,,� p� IDOVD�� SRLV� WHPRV�9Æ)��$VVLP��R�FDVR�GR�IXQFLRQiULR�RS}H�VH�DSHQDV�DR�DYLVR�,,��SRLV� WRUQD�HVWD�IUDVH�IDOVD�� 5HVSRVWD��(� � ���� )&&�±�3*(�%$�±������� $OLFH� LUi� DR� 3DtV�GDV�0DUDYLOKDV�TXDQGR� LPDJLQDU�RX�SHUGHU�R�PHGR��6H�$OLFH�SHUGHU�R�PHGR�� �$��$OLFH�QmR�LUi�DR�3DtV�GDV�0DUDYLOKDV��SRLV�QmR�YDL�LPDJLQDU�� �%��$OLFH�LUi�DR�3DtV�GDV�0DUDYLOKDV�� �&��$OLFH�YDL�QHFHVVDULDPHQWH�LPDJLQDU�� �'��$OLFH�QmR�LUi��WDPEpP��LPDJLQDU�� �(��$OLFH�QmR�YDL�LPDJLQDU�� 5(62/8d2��� � $� IUDVH� GR� HQXQFLDGR� p� XPD� FRQGLFLRQDO� XVDQGR� R� ³TXDQGR´�� (OD� SRGH�VHU�UHHVFULWD�DVVLP��SDUD�IDFLOLWDU�D�DQiOLVH�� 6H�LPDJLQDU�RX�SHUGHU�R�PHGR��HQWmR�$OLFH�LUi�DR�SDtV�GDV�PDUDYLOKDV� � � )RL�GLWR�TXH�$OLFH�SHUGHX�R�PHGR��&RP�LVVR��D�GLVMXQomR�³LPDJLQDU� RX� SHUGHU� R� PHGR´� p� 9HUGDGHLUD�� 8PD� YH]� TXH� RFRUUHX� D� FRQGLomR�� R� UHVXOWDGR�GHYH�DFRQWHFHU��2X�VHMD��$OLFH�,5È�DR�SDtV�GDV�PDUDYLOKDV�� 5HVSRVWD��%� � ���� )&&� ±� 03(�$0� ±� ������ 2� SURIHVVRU� GH� XPD� GLVFLSOLQD� H[SHULPHQWDO� GH� XP� FXUVR� GH� (QJHQKDULD� HVWDEHOHFHX� QR� LQtFLR� GR� VHPHVWUH�TXH��SDUD�VHU�DSURYDGR��XP�DOXQR�WHULD�GH�UHDOL]DU�SHOR�PHQRV��� GDV���H[SHULrQFLDV�SURSRVWDV�H� WHU�PpGLD�GH� UHODWyULRV�PDLRU�RX� LJXDO�D� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� �����&RPR�-XFD�IRL� UHSURYDGR�QHVVD�GLVFLSOLQD��SRGH�VH�FRQFOXLU�TXH�HOH�� QHFHVVDULDPHQWH�� �$�� UHDOL]RX� DSHQDV� �� H[SHULrQFLDV� H� WHYH� PpGLD� GH� UHODWyULRV�� QR� Pi[LPR��LJXDO�D������ �%��UHDOL]RX���RX�PHQRV�H[SHULrQFLDV�H�WHYH�PpGLD�GH�UHODWyULRV�LQIHULRU�D� ����� �&�� UHDOL]RX� PHQRV� GR� TXH� �� H[SHULrQFLDV� RX� WHYH� PpGLD� GH� UHODWyULRV� LQIHULRU�D������ �'��QmR�UHDOL]RX�TXDOTXHU�H[SHULrQFLD�� WHQGR�PpGLD�GH�UHODWyULRV� LJXDO�D� ����� �(��QmR�UHDOL]RX�TXDOTXHU�H[SHULrQFLD�RX�WHYH�PpGLD�GH�UHODWyULRV�PHQRU� RX�LJXDO�D������ 5(62/8d2��� � 9HMD� TXH� R� SURIHVVRU� HVWDEHOHFHX� GXDV� FRQGLo}HV� �UHDOL]DU� SHOR� PHQRV� �� GDV� �� H[SHULrQFLDV� H� WHU� PpGLD� GH� UHODWyULRV� PDLRU� RX� LJXDO� D� �����TXH��VH�UHVSHLWDGDV��OHYDP�DR�UHVXOWDGR��DSURYDomR���2X�VHMD��WHPRV� D�FRQGLFLRQDO�� 6H�UHDOL]DU�SHOR�PHQRV���GDV���H[SHULrQFLDV�H�WHU�PpGLD�GH�UHODWyULRV� PDLRU�RX�LJXDO�D������HQWmR�R�DOXQR�p�DSURYDGR� � � -XFD�IRL�UHSURYDGR��RX�VHMD��R�UHVXOWDGR�GD�FRQGLFLRQDO�QmR�RFRUUHX�� ,VVR� REULJD� D� FRQGLomR� �UHDOL]DU� SHOR� PHQRV� �� GDV� �� H[SHULrQFLDV� H� WHU� PpGLD� GH� UHODWyULRV� PDLRU� RX� LJXDO� D� ����� D� 12� WHU� RFRUULGR� WDPEpP�� 2EVHUYH� TXH�HVVD� FRQGLomR�p�XPD� FRQMXQomR�� 3DUD� HOD�QmR� WHU� RFRUULGR� �QmR�VHU�9���EDVWD�TXH�XPD�GDV�SURSRVLo}HV�VLPSOHV�TXH�D�FRPS}H�VHMD� )DOVD��3RUWDQWR�� �� -XFD� 12� UHDOL]RX� SHOR� PHQRV� �� GDV� �� H[SHULrQFLDV� 28� WHYH� PpGLD� LQIHULRU�D������ � � 2XWUD�IRUPD�GH�GL]HU�LVVR�p�� ��-XFD�UHDOL]RX�0(126�'(���H[SHULrQFLDV�28�WHYH�PpGLD�LQIHULRU�D������ � Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� � 7HPRV�LVVR�QD�DOWHUQDWLYD�&�� �&�� UHDOL]RX� PHQRV� GR� TXH� �� H[SHULrQFLDV� RX� WHYH� PpGLD� GH� UHODWyULRV� LQIHULRU�D������ 5HVSRVWD��&� � ���� )&&� ±� 757�%$� ±� ������ $QDOLVDQGR� D� WDEHOD� GH� FODVVLILFDomR� GR� FDPSHRQDWR� GH� IXWHERO� DPDGRU� GR� EDLUUR� DQWHV� GD� UHDOL]DomR� GD� ~OWLPD� URGDGD�� R� WpFQLFR� GR� 8QLmR� FRQFOXLX� TXH�� FDVR� VHX� WLPH� YHQFHVVH� VXD� ~OWLPD�SDUWLGD�RX�R�WLPH�GR�&DPLVD�QmR�JDQKDVVH�VHX�~OWLPR�MRJR��HQWmR� R� 8QLmR� VHULD� FDPSHmR�� 6DEHQGR� TXH� R� 8QLmR� QmR� VH� VDJURX� FDPSHmR�� SRGH�VH�FRQFOXLU�TXH��QHFHVVDULDPHQWH�� �$��R�&DPLVD�SHUGHX�VHX�MRJR�H�R�8QLmR�SHUGHX�R�VHX�� �%��R�&DPLVD�YHQFHX�VHX�MRJR�H�R�8QLmR�YHQFHX�R�VHX�� �&��R�&DPLVD�HPSDWRX�VHX�MRJR�H�R�8QLmR�HPSDWRX�RX�SHUGHX�R�VHX�� �'��R�&DPLVD�HPSDWRX�VHX�MRJR�H�R�8QLmR�YHQFHX�R�VHX�� �(��R�&DPLVD�YHQFHX�VHX�MRJR�H�R�8QLmR�HPSDWRX�RX�SHUGHX�R�VHX� 5(62/8d2�� � $� ³UHJUD´� GDGD� SHOR� HQXQFLDGR� SRGH� VHU� UHVXPLGD� QHVVD� FRQGLFLRQDO�� 6H�8QLmR�YHQFHU�RX�&DPLVD�QmR�YHQFHU��HQWmR�8QLmR�p�FDPSHmR� �S�RX�T��Æ�U��RQGH�� � S� �8QLmR�YHQFHU�� T� �&DPLVD�QmR�YHQFHU� U� �8QLmR�p�FDPSHmR� � &RPR�R�8QLmR�QmR�VH�VDJURX�FDPSHmR��YHPRV�TXH�U�p�)��,VVR�REULJD� D�FRQGLomR��S�RX�T��D�VHU�)�WDPEpP��$VVLP��D�QHJDomR�GH��S�RX�T��VHUi�9�� (VWD�QHJDomR�p�� a�S�RX�T�� �aS�H�aT� � (VFUHYHQGR� �aS� H� aT��� WHPRV�� R� 8QLmR� 12� YHQFHX� H� R� &DPLVD� 9(1&(8��7HPRV�HVVD�PHVPD�LGHLD�QD�DOWHUQDWLYD�(�� R�&DPLVD�YHQFHX�VHX�MRJR�H�R�8QLmR�HPSDWRX�RX�SHUGHX�R�VHX� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� 5HVSRVWD��(� � ���� )&&� ±� 757���D� ±� ������ 8PD� VHQKRUD� DILUPRX� TXH� WRGRV� RV� QRYHORV�GH� Om�JXDUGDGRV�QXPD�JDYHWD�VmR�FRORULGRV�H�QHQKXP�GHOHV� IRL� XVDGR��0DLV�WDUGH��HOD�SHUFHEHX�TXH�KDYLD�VH�HQJDQDGR�HP�UHODomR�j�VXD� DILUPDomR��R�TXH�SHUPLWH�FRQFOXLU�TXH� �$��H[LVWHP�QRYHORV�GH�Om�EUDQFRV�QD�JDYHWD�H�HOHV�Mi�IRUDP�XVDGRV�� �%��SHOR�PHQRV�XP�QRYHOR�GH�Om�GD�JDYHWD�QmR�p�FRORULGR�RX�DOJXP�GHOHV� IRL�XVDGR�� �&��SHOR�PHQRV�XP�QRYHOR�GH� Om�GD�JDYHWD�QmR�p�FRORULGR�RX�WRGRV�HOHV� IRUDP�XVDGRV�� �'��RV�QRYHORV�GH�Om�GD�JDYHWD�QmR�VmR�FRORULGRV�H�Mi�IRUDP�XVDGRV�� �(�� RV� QRYHORV� GH� Om� GD� JDYHWD� QmR� VmR� FRORULGRV� H� DOJXP� GHOHV� Mi� IRL� XVDGR�� 5(62/8d2�� � 6HQGR�S� �WRGRV�RV�QRYHORV�VmR�FRORULGRV�H�T� �QHQKXP�QRYHOR�IRL� XVDGR��D�DILUPDomR�GD�VHQKRUD�IRL�³S�H�T´��6H�HOD�VH�HQJDQRX��³S�H�T´�p� )DOVR��SRUWDQWR�D�VXD�QHJDomR�p�9HUGDGHLUD�� � $� QHJDomR� GH� ³S� H� T´� p� ³QmR�S� RX� QmR�T´�� $V� QHJDo}HV� GDV� SURSRVLo}HV�VLPSOHV�VmR�� 1mR�S� �DOJXP�QRYHOR�QmR�p�FRORULGR� 1mR�T� �DOJXP�QRYHOR�IRL�XVDGR� � 3RUWDQWR�� ³QmR�S�RX�QmR�T´� VHULD��$OJXP�QRYHOR�QmR�p� FRORULGR�RX� DOJXP�QRYHOR�IRL�XVDGR�� � 3RGHUtDPRV�XWLOL]DU�WDPEpP�D�H[SUHVVmR�³SHOR�PHQRV�XP´�QR�OXJDU� GH�³DOJXP´��&RP�LVVR��WHUtDPRV�D�UHVSRVWD�GD�OHWUD�%�� 5HVSRVWD��%� � ���� )&&� ±� $/(63� ±� ������ 'XUDQWH� XPD� VHVVmR� QR� SOHQiULR� GD� $VVHPEOHLD�/HJLVODWLYD��R�SUHVLGHQWH�GD�PHVD� IH]�D�VHJXLQWH�GHFODUDomR�� GLULJLQGR�VH�jV�JDOHULDV�GD�FDVD�� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^�WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� ³6H� DV� PDQLIHVWDo}HV� GHVUHVSHLWRVDV� QmR� IRUHP� LQWHUURPSLGDV�� HQWmR�HX�QmR�GDUHL�LQtFLR�j�YRWDomR´�� (VWD�GHFODUDomR�p�ORJLFDPHQWH�HTXLYDOHQWH�j�DILUPDomR�� D��VH�R�SUHVLGHQWH�GD�PHVD�GHX�LQtFLR�j�YRWDomR��HQWmR�DV�PDQLIHVWDo}HV� GHVUHVSHLWRVDV�IRUDP�LQWHUURPSLGDV� E�� VH� R� SUHVLGHQWH� GD� PHVD� QmR� GHX� LQtFLR� j� YRWDomR�� HQWmR� DV� PDQLIHVWDo}HV�GHVUHVSHLWRVDV�QmR�IRUDP�LQWHUURPSLGDV� F�� VH� DV� PDQLIHVWDo}HV� GHVUHVSHLWRVDV� IRUHP� LQWHUURPSLGDV�� HQWmR� R� SUHVLGHQWH�GD�PHVD�GDUi�LQtFLR�j�YRWDomR� G�� VH� DV� PDQLIHVWDo}HV� GHVUHVSHLWRVDV� FRQWLQXDUHP�� HQWmR� R� SUHVLGHQWH� GD�PHVD�FRPHoDUi�D�YRWDomR� H�� VH� DV� PDQLIHVWDo}HV� GHVUHVSHLWRVDV� QmR� FRQWLQXDUHP�� HQWmR� R� SUHVLGHQWH�GD�PHVD�QmR�FRPHoDUi�D�YRWDomR�� 5(62/8d2�� � 2EVHUYH�TXH�WHPRV�XPD�FRQGLFLRQDO�� S To ���RQGH�� S� �$V�PDQLIHVWDo}HV�GHVUHVSHLWRVDV�QmR�IRUHP�LQWHUURPSLGDV� T� �(X�QmR�GDUHL�LQtFLR�j�YRWDomR� � (VWD� p� XPD� SURSRVLomR� ³PDQMDGD´�� SRLV� VDEHPRV� TXH� HOD� p� HTXLYDOHQWH�D� a aT So ��H�WDPEpP�D�aS�RX�T��&RPR�aT�p�³HX�GDUHL�LQtFLR� j� YRWDomR´� H� aS� p� ³DV� PDQLIHVWDo}HV� GHVUHVSHLWRVDV� IRUDP� LQWHUURPSLGDV´��WHPRV�� � a aT So �� ³6H� HX� GHL� LQtFLR� j� YRWDomR�� HQWmR� DV� PDQLIHVWDo}HV� GHVUHVSHLWRVDV�IRUDP�LQWHUURPSLGDV´��� aS� RX� T�� ³$V� PDQLIHVWDo}HV� GHVUHVSHLWRVDV� IRUDP� LQWHUURPSLGDV� RX� HX� QmR�GHL�LQtFLR�j�YRWDomR´�� � � 5HSDUH� TXH� D� DOWHUQDWLYD� $� p� VLPLODU� j� H[SUHVVmR� a aT So � TXH� HVFUHYHPRV�DFLPD��VHQGR�HVWH�R�JDEDULWR�� 5HVSRVWD��$�� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� � ���� )&&���'12&6���������&RQVLGHUH�D�VHJXLQWH�SURSRVLomR�� ³6H� XPD� SHVVRD� QmR� ID]� FXUVRV� GH� DSHUIHLoRDPHQWR� QD� VXD� iUHD� GH� WUDEDOKR��HQWmR�HOD�QmR�PHOKRUD�R�VHX�GHVHPSHQKR�SURILVVLRQDO�´� 8PD�SURSRVLomR�ORJLFDPHQWH�HTXLYDOHQWH�j�SURSRVLomR�GDGD�p�� �$��e�IDOVR�TXH��XPD�SHVVRD�QmR�PHOKRUD�R�VHX�GHVHPSHQKR�SURILVVLRQDO� RX�ID]�FXUVRV�GH�DSHUIHLoRDPHQWR�QD�VXD�iUHD�GH�WUDEDOKR�� �%��1mR�p�YHUGDGH�TXH��XPD�SHVVRD�QmR� ID]�FXUVRV�GH�DSHUIHLoRDPHQWR� SURILVVLRQDO�H�QmR�PHOKRUD�R�VHX�GHVHPSHQKR�SURILVVLRQDO�� �&��6H�XPD�SHVVRD�QmR�PHOKRUD�VHX�GHVHPSHQKR�SURILVVLRQDO��HQWmR�HOD� QmR�ID]�FXUVRV�GH�DSHUIHLoRDPHQWR�QD�VXD�iUHD�GH�WUDEDOKR�� �'�� 8PD� SHVVRD� PHOKRUD� R� VHX� GHVHPSHQKR� SURILVVLRQDO� RX� QmR� ID]� FXUVRV�GH�DSHUIHLoRDPHQWR�QD�VXD�iUHD�GH�WUDEDOKR�� �(��8PD�SHVVRD�QmR�PHOKRUD�VHX�GHVHPSHQKR�SURILVVLRQDO�RX�ID]�FXUVRV� GH�DSHUIHLoRDPHQWR�QD�VXD�iUHD�GH�WUDEDOKR�� 5(62/8d2�� 1R� HQXQFLDGR� WHPSRV� XPD�SURSRVLomR� GR� WLSR�S�ĺ� T�� RQGH� S� H�T� VmR��UHVXPLGDPHQWH�� S� �SHVVRD�QmR�ID]�FXUVRV� T� �HOD�QmR�PHOKRUD� 9RFr�Mi�GHYH�WHU�GHFRUDGR�TXH�D�SURSRVLomR�aT�ĺ�aS�p�HTXLYDOHQWH� D� HOD�� 2XWUD� HTXLYDOHQWH� p� T� RX� aS�� 9HMDPRV� DV� HVWUXWXUDV� GH� FDGD� DOWHUQDWLYD�� � �$��e�IDOVR�TXH��XPD�SHVVRD�QmR�PHOKRUD�R�VHX�GHVHPSHQKR�SURILVVLRQDO� RX�ID]�FXUVRV�GH�DSHUIHLoRDPHQWR�QD�VXD�iUHD�GH�WUDEDOKR�� � $TXL�WHPRV�D�HVWUXWXUD��a�T�RX�aS�� � �%��1mR�p�YHUGDGH�TXH��XPD�SHVVRD�QmR� ID]�FXUVRV�GH�DSHUIHLoRDPHQWR� SURILVVLRQDO�H�QmR�PHOKRUD�R�VHX�GHVHPSHQKR�SURILVVLRQDO�� � a�S�H�T�� � Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� �&��6H�XPD�SHVVRD�QmR�PHOKRUD�VHX�GHVHPSHQKR�SURILVVLRQDO��HQWmR�HOD� QmR�ID]�FXUVRV�GH�DSHUIHLoRDPHQWR�QD�VXD�iUHD�GH�WUDEDOKR�� � T�ĺ�S� � �'�� 8PD� SHVVRD� PHOKRUD� R� VHX� GHVHPSHQKR� SURILVVLRQDO� RX� QmR� ID]� FXUVRV�GH�DSHUIHLoRDPHQWR�QD�VXD�iUHD�GH�WUDEDOKR�� � aT�RX�S� � �(��8PD�SHVVRD�QmR�PHOKRUD�VHX�GHVHPSHQKR�SURILVVLRQDO�RX�ID]�FXUVRV� GH�DSHUIHLoRDPHQWR�QD�VXD�iUHD�GH�WUDEDOKR�� T�RX�aS� � � � 9HMD�TXH�DSHQDV�QD�OHWUD�(�WHPRV�XPD�SURSRVLomR�QR�IRUPDWR�T�RX� aS��TXH�p�HTXLYDOHQWH�D�S�ĺ�T��(VWH�p�R�JDEDULWR��� � 9HMD�FRPR�p�LPSRUWDQWH�JUDYDU�D�HTXLYDOrQFLD�HQWUH�� S�ĺ�T� aT�ĺ�aS�� T�RX�aS� 6H� YRFr� QmR� VH� OHPEUDVVH� GLVVR�� WHULD� TXH� FRQVWUXLU� D� WDEHOD� YHUGDGH�GH�FDGD�SURSRVLomR�� 5HVSRVWD��(� � ���� )&&�±�6()$=�63�±�������&RQVLGHUH�DV�VHJXLQWHV�SUHPLVVDV�� S��(VWXGDU�p�IXQGDPHQWDO�SDUD�FUHVFHU�SURILVVLRQDOPHQWH�� T��2�WUDEDOKR�HQREUHFH�� $� DILUPDomR� ³6H� R� WUDEDOKR� QmR� HQREUHFH�� HQWmR� HVWXGDU� QmR� p� IXQGDPHQWDO� SDUD� FUHVFHU� SURILVVLRQDOPHQWH´� p�� FRP� FHUWH]D�� )$/6$� TXDQGR�� D��S�p�IDOVD�H�T�p�IDOVD�� E��S�p�YHUGDGHLUD�H�T�p�YHUGDGHLUD�� F��S�p�IDOVD�H�T�p�YHUGDGHLUD�� G��S�p�YHUGDGHLUD�H�T�p�IDOVD�� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� H��S�p�IDOVD�RX�T�p�IDOVD�� 5(62/8d2�� � 9HMD�TXH�D�DILUPDomR�GDGD�SHOR�HQXQFLDGR�p��³6H�QmR�T��HQWmR�QmR� S´��6y�Ki���IRUPD�GHVVD�FRQGLFLRQDO�VHU�)$/6$��VH�D�FRQGLomR��QmR�T��IRU� 9HUGDGHLUD��SRUpP�R�UHVXOWDGR��QmR�S��IRU�)DOVR��� � 3DUD�TXH�QmR�T�VHMD�9HUGDGHLUD��D�VXD�QHJDomR��T��GHYH�VHU�)DOVD�� (�SDUD�TXH�QmR�S�VHMD�)DOVD��D�VXD�QHJDomR��S��GHYH�VHU�9HUGDGHLUD�� � $VVLP��S�GHYH�VHU�9HUGDGHLUD�H�T�GHYH�VHU�)DOVD��� 5HVSRVWD��'� � � ���� )&&�±�0(75Ð�63�±�������&RQVLGHUH�DV�SURSRVLo}HV�VLPSOHV�� S��0DO\�p�XVXiULD�GR�0HWU{��H�T��0DO\�JRVWD�GH�GLULJLU�DXWRPyYHO� � $�QHJDomR�GD�SURSRVLomR�FRPSRVWD� aS T �p�� D��0DO\�QmR�p�XVXiULD�GR�0HWU{�RX�JRVWD�GH�GLULJLU�DXWRPyYHO� E��0DO\�QmR�p�XVXiULD�GR�0HWU{�H�QmR�JRVWD�GH�GLULJLU�DXWRPyYHO� F��1mR�p�YHUGDGH�TXH�0DO\�QmR�p�XVXiULD�GR�0HWU{�H�QmR�JRVWD�GH�GLULJLU� DXWRPyYHO� G��1mR�p�YHUGDGH�TXH��VH�0DO\�QmR�p�XVXiULD�GR�0HWU{��HQWmR�HOD�JRVWD�GH� GLULJLU�DXWRPyYHO� H�� 6H� 0DO\� QmR� p� XVXiULD� GR� 0HWU{�� HQWmR� HOD� QmR� JRVWD� GH� GLULJLU� DXWRPyYHO�� 5(62/8d2�� � 3ULPHLUDPHQWH��YHMD�TXH�aT��QHJDomR�GH�T��SRGH�VHU�HVFULWD�FRPR�� 0DO\�QmR�JRVWD�GH�GLULJLU�DXWRPyYHO�� � $VVLP��D�SURSRVLomR�S�H�QmR�T�� aS T ��p�� ³0DO\�p�XVXiULD�GR�0HWU{�H�0DO\�QmR�JRVWD�GH�GLULJLU�DXWRPyYHO´� � 4XHP�GL]�HVVD� IUDVH��HVWi�DILUPDQGR�TXH�DV�GXDV� LQIRUPDo}HV�VmR� YHUGDGHLUDV��LVWR�p��TXH�0DO\�p�XVXiULD�GR�0HWU{�H��WDPEpP��TXH�0DO\�QmR� JRVWD�GH�GLULJLU�DXWRPyYHO��,VWR�SRUTXH�HVWD�SURSRVLomR�FRPSRVWD�p�XPD� Z��/K�1E/K�>M'/�K ?D�d�D�d/�K�W ?�d^d� d�KZ/�����y�Z�1�/K^��KD�Ed��K^� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ� ?��ƵůĂ� ? ?��� WƌŽĨ 堀 �ƌƚŚƵƌ�>ŝŵĂ���������������������ǁǁǁ 堁ḁ?ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĂĐŽŶĐƵƌƐŽƐ ?ĐŽŵ ?ďƌ���������������������������� ? ?�� FRQMXQomR� �³H´��� TXH� Vy� p� YHUGDGHLUD� TXDQGR� DPERV� RV� ODGRV� VmR� YHUGDGHLURV��� 6H� TXLVpVVHPRV� GHVPHQWLU� �RX� QHJDU�� R� DXWRU� GD� IUDVH�� EDVWDULD� PRVWUDU�TXH�XP�GRV�ODGRV�QmR�p�YHUGDGHLUR��,VWR�p��EDVWDULD�SURYDU�TXH� 0DO\�QmR�p�XVXiULD�GR�0HWU{��RX�HQWmR�SURYDU�TXH�0DO\�JRVWD�GH�GLULJLU� DXWRPyYHO��3RUWDQWR��D�QHJDomR�GD�IUDVH�DFLPD�p�� ³0DO\�QmR�p�XVXiULD�GR�0HWU{�RX�0DO\�JRVWD�GH�GLULJLU�DXWRPyYHO´� �OHWUD�$�� � � 'H�XPD�PDQHLUD�PDLV�UiSLGD��EDVWDULD�YRFr�OHPEUDU�TXH�D�QHJDomR� GH� aS T �p�a a �a �S T ��LVWR�p��a S T ��� 5HVSRVWD��$�� � � � � ���� )&&�±�6()$=�63�±�������8PD�HPSUHVD�PDQWpP�D�VHJXLQWH�UHJUD� HP�UHODomR�D�VHXV�IXQFLRQiULRV�� 6H�XP�IXQFLRQiULR�WHP�PDLV�GH����DQRV�GH�LGDGH��HQWmR�HOH�GHYHUi��WRGR� DQR�� UHDOL]DU� SHOR� PHQRV� XP� H[DPH� PpGLFR� H� WRPDU� D� YDFLQD� FRQWUD� D� JULSH�� &RQVLGHUDQGR� TXH� HVVD� UHJUD� VHMD� VHPSUH� FXPSULGD�� p� FRUUHWR� FRQFOXLU� TXH��QHFHVVDULDPHQWH��VH�XP�IXQFLRQiULR�GHVVD�HPSUHVD�� D��DQXDOPHQWH�UHDOL]D�XP�H[DPH�PpGLFR�H�WRPD�D�YDFLQD�FRQWUD�D�JULSH�� HQWmR�HOH�WHP�PDLV�GH����DQRV�GH�LGDGH�� E�� WHP� ��� DQRV� GH� LGDGH�� HQWmR� HOH� QmR� UHDOL]D� H[DPHV� PpGLFRV� DQXDOPHQWH�RX�QmR�WRPD�D�YDFLQD�FRQWUD�D�JULSH��
Compartilhar