Logo Passei Direto
Buscar

Ferramentas de estudo

Material
páginas com resultados encontrados.
páginas com resultados encontrados.

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Prévia do material em texto

Applied Catalysis A: General 221 (2001) 367–377
New developments in the production
of methyl methacrylate
Koichi Nagai∗
Basic Chemicals Research Laboratory, Sumitomo Chemical Co. Ltd., 5-1 Sobiraki-Cho, Niihama City, Ehime 792-0001, Japan
Abstract
Methyl methacrylate MMA can be produced in different ways based on C2–C4 hydrocarbon feedstocks. In the present review,
the recent commercialized and expected MMA technologies will be described and a comparison of these production routes
is given. Thereby, the catalyst development will be strongly emphasized. © 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Methyl methacrylate; Production; Hydrocarbons; Catalyst; Process
1. Introduction
Methyl methacrylate (MMA) is an important
monomer, which is widely used for producing acrylic
plastics (polymethyl methacrylate) or producing poly-
mer dispersions for paints and coatings. The world
production capacity has been almost doubled in past
15 years, and reached about 2.2 million tonnes per
year. The demand of MMA is still expected steady
growth in the future. Methacrylic polymer, which has
the characteristics of good transparency and weather
resistance, is used in many fields such as signboards,
building materials, vehicles and lighting equipments.
Methacrylic acid (MAA) and higher esters (such as
butyl methacrylate) derived from the acid, have not
been produced in a large quantity, but are useful
comonomers for various uses.
While Rohm & Haas Co. began to industrially pro-
duce a methacrylic ester (ethyl methacrylate) first in
1933, ICI reformed the Rohm’s method and commer-
cialized MMA in 1937 by the acetone cyanohydrine
(ACH) process, which most manufacturers in the
∗ Fax: +81-897-374003.
E-mail address: nagaik1@sc.sumitomo-chem.co.jp (K. Nagai).
world adopted even today. Although the ACH method
was the only industrial process until 1982 for man-
ufacturing MMA, there are problems of shortage of
toxic hydrogen cyanide (HCN) supply and of deal-
ing with the large quantities of ammonium bisulfate
waste. Till today, many efforts have been continu-
ously put into the development for placing this ACH
process.
New commercialized processes have been devel-
oped until now, such as (i) the direct oxidation process
which consists of catalytic, isobutylene or tert-butanol
(TBA) oxidation to methacrylic acid in two steps;
(ii) the methacrylonitrile (MAN) route by ammoxida-
tion of TBA; (iii) the BASF’s method which employs
ethylene, carbon monoxide and formaldehyde as raw
materials; (iv) the new ACH process by Mitsubishi
Gas Chemical Co. Inc., which does not generate acid
waste; and (v) the direct oxidative esterification of
methacrolein by Asahi Chemical Co. Ltd.
Most of these new processes have been developed
for an environmentally friendly production of MMA
and thereby the development of the catalysts was the
key technology. This review describes the recent com-
mercialized and expected MMA technologies empha-
sizing catalyst development.
0926-860X/01/$ – see front matter © 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII: S0 9 2 6 -860X(01 )00810 -9
368 K. Nagai / Applied Catalysis A: General 221 (2001) 367–377
2. Routes to MMA
The C2–C4 hydrocarbons can be thought as raw
materials for MMA. Fig. 1 shows many considerable
and examined routes to MMA, which includes conven-
tional the ACH process, and the industrialized routes
are emphasized by thick lines.
3. C2 routes
Ethylene can be used to produce MMA via pro-
pionaldehyde, propionic acid, or methyl propionate,
as shown in Fig. 1. The key step of this route is the
condensation reaction of such an intermediate with
formaldehyde to make methacrolein, MAA or MMA.
3.1. BASF’s process
One of the ethylene routes was developed by BASF,
and a 40,000 t per year MMA plant including 5000 t
per year MAA was built in Germany in 1989 [1].
In this route, MMA is made from ethylene via pro-
pionaldehyde, methacrolein and methacrylic acid as
follows:
CH2=CH2 + CO+ H2 → CH3CH2CHO
CH3CH2CHO+ HCHO
→
(CH3)2NH
CH2=CH(CH3)–CHO+ H2O
CH2=CH(CH3)–CHO
O2→CH2=CH(CH3)–COOH
CH3OH→ MMA
Before 1989, BASF had already produced pro-
pionaldehyde by hydroformylation of ethylene and
formaldehyde by using methanol. In addition to
these productions, they carried out new steps after
methacrolein synthesis to produce MMA. Propi-
onaldehyde reacts with formaldehyde in a pipe type
reactor in the presence of a secondary amine and an
acid. According to BASF patents [2,3], the yield of
methacrolein reaches nearly 99%. Amoco Co. carried
out this reaction in vapor phase over molecular sieves
[4] and disclosed that conversion of propionaldehide
was 57% with 98% selectivity to methacrolein.
The process for producing methacrylic acid and
MMA is the same process as for direct oxidation
of isobutylene, which will be mentioned below. The
BASF’s catalyst for methacrylic acid may be a similar
heteropoly acid to that developed in Japanese compa-
nies. Therefore, the improvement of the methacrolein
oxidation catalyst has been desired in this process. It
is noted that this process seems to meet the special
location and the availability of starting materials in
house of BASF, and is not thought to become a world
general MMA manufacturing method.
3.2. Other C2 routes
Propionic acid or methyl propionate routes have
been examined in many enterprises for a long time.
Propionic acid is produced by Reppe’s hydrocarbony-
lation reaction of ethylene for which metal carbonyl is
used as a catalyst, or by oxidation of propionaldehyde.
MAA or MMA is proposed by condensation reaction
with formaldehyde (or its derivatives such as methy-
lal). If one of these methods would be industrialized, it
could become a simple and excellent process because
of its fewer steps
CH3CH2COOH+ HCHO
→ CH2=CH(CH3)–COOH+ H2O
CH3CH2COOCH3 + HCHO
→ CH2=CH(CH3)–COOCH3 + H2O
There are many reaction examples carried out at
300–400 ◦C in vapor phase on a solid catalyst such
as a solid base or a solid acid. For example, Amoco
shows more than 91% selectivity to MAA with 39%
conversion of propionic acid on Cs/SiO2-SnO2, which
is one of the solid base catalysts [5]. Details of this
catalyst were reported [6,7]. Improvement of the
catalyst performance is described in a patent [8] by
Mitsubishi Rayon Co. Ltd., which shows 40.5% con-
version of propionic acid with 98.8% selectivity to
MAA on the catalyst Si-Cs-W-Ag-O. As for the solid
acid catalysts, Toagosei Co. Ltd., for example, gets
68% conversion of formaldehyde and 66% selectivity
to MAA on the catalyst V-P-O/Zr-Al-O [9]. A patent
by Daicel Co. [10] demonstrates that this reaction
proceeds in the presence of a Lewis acid catalyst in
liquid phase. According to that disclosure, equivalent
moles of aluminum propionate and 5 mol of formalde-
hyde, based on propionic anhydride were used. The
yield of MAA was 23.5% at 180 ◦C after 1 h.
K. Nagai / Applied Catalysis A: General 221 (2001) 367–377 369
Fig. 1. Routes to methyl methacrylate (MMA).
370 K. Nagai / Applied Catalysis A: General 221 (2001) 367–377
Recently, Research Triangle Institute, Eastman
Chemical and Bechtel announced that they collab-
orated on improving this process. Iodine-promoted
molybdenum carbonyl is used for hydrocarbonylation
of ethylene under a lower temperature and lower pres-
sure condition than that of the conventional catalyst.
A vapor phase condensation reaction is carried out
over Nb/SiO2 or Ta/SiO2 catalyst [11,12].
In view of industrialization, the productivity of each
reaction based on these C2 routes has not been suffi-
cient yet. The selectivity is fairly high, but the one-pass
conversion level is too low, and there is a problem such
that, the catalyst life is not so long. Therefore, great
improvement in catalyst performance is desirable.
4. C3 routes
4.1. New ACH processThe conventional ACH method is based on the C3
route. Acetone is a derivative of propylene, and is be-
ing produced large amounts as a co-product with phe-
nol, these days. On the other hand, large amounts of
HCN are also obtained as by-product in the produc-
tion of acrylonitrile. But, the main problems of this
ACH method is presently at the supply of HCN and
the large amount of ammonium bisulfate waste.
Mitsubishi Gas Chemicals has industrialized the
new improved ACH process in 1997 to solve these two
problems. In this process, first, acetone cyanohydrin
is hydrated to �-hydroxy isobutylamide with the man-
ganese oxide catalyst in absence of sulfuric acid, and
then is esterified by methylformate to provide methyl
�-hydroxy isobutylate. Methylformate becomes for-
mamide at this time, and then the formamide is de-
hydrated to give HCN, which is recycled in the ACH
preparation process. Methyl �-hydroxy isobutylate is
converted to MMA in a dehydration reactions
(CH3)2–C(OH)CN+H2O→(CH3)2–C(OH)CONH2
(CH3)2–C(OH)CONH2 + HCOOCH3
→ (CH3)2–C(OH)COOCH3 + HCONH2
(CH3)2–C(OH)COOCH3
→ CH2=C(CH3)COOCH3 + H2O
HCONH2 → HCN + H2O
Though the hydration reaction on MnO2 catalyst
had been known over many years, there were some
problems such as the catalyst life. Mitsubishi Gas
Chemicals improved the performance of the catalyst
by providing a new preparation method [13] or by
adding another catalyst component such as Sn or K
[14]. The key point of this process is that, the use of
sulfuric acid is avoided and the trans-esterification is
done without methanol but with methyl formate. As
for the catalyst used in this reaction, various catalysts
such as metal carbonyl compounds or alkaline metal
alcoholate (e.g. sodium methylate) are proposed. The
selectivity of this reaction reaches up to 99%. The last
dehydration process is carried out on zeolite catalyst
in gas phase. Though there were problems such as a
side reaction or a matter as to catalyst life, they were
solved by utilizing methanol and by adopting a fauja-
site zeolite [15]. Formamide produced in the esterifi-
cation process is also dehydrated to provide HCN on
a solid acid catalyst in gas phase.
Recently, Mitsubishi Gas Chemicals has proposed a
new route in which methyl �-hydroxy isobutylate and
ammonia are produced from the reaction of �-hydroxy
isobutylamide with methanol. The ammonia is recy-
cled to produce HCN by reacting with methanol and
O2 [16]
(CH3)2–C(OH)CONH2 + CH3OH
→ (CH3)2–C(OH)COOCH3 + NH3
CH3OH+ NH3 + O2 → HCN + 3H2O
One of disadvantage of the new ACH process is that
there are numbers of reaction steps, while the process
has many advantages such that the productivity of each
step are comparatively high, consumption of HCN is
reduced, and sulfuric acid is not used.
4.2. Isobutyric acid process
The route, in which MAA is made of propylene via
isobutyric acid, has been researched by Atochem and
Röhm, separately
CH2=CHCH3 + CO+ H2O→
HF
(CH3)2–CHCOOH
(CH3)2–CHCOOH+ 12 O2
→ CH2=C(CH3)COOH+ H2O
K. Nagai / Applied Catalysis A: General 221 (2001) 367–377 371
Isobutyric acid is synthesized by Koch reaction with
hydrogen fluoride as catalyst. An example of Koch re-
action is commercially realized to produce pivalic acid
from isobutylene. Propylene, carbon monoxide, water
and large quantities of hydrogen fluoride are mixed at
low temperature in a pipe reactor, which prevents back
mixing under adiabatic condition to obtain isobutyric
acid with few impurities. It is said that, the handling
problem of dangerous hydrogen fluoride and corrosion
problem were solved by the process as established.
A main problem of this route is present by the yield
in the oxidative dehydration reaction of isobutyric acid
and a matter as to the catalyst life. Fe-P-O mixed ox-
ides and Mo-P-O heteropoly acid have been examined
as catalysts. Mitsubishi Chemical found first that this
reaction proceeds well over a heteropoly acid which
consists of Mo-P-V-O [17]. An improvement has been
made by adding similar transition metals or alkaline
metal as used in catalysts for the methacrolein oxida-
tion. Also, in the catalyst based on Fe-P-O, various im-
provements were made, and the yield of methacryric
acid reached 83.6% as could be demonstrated by Ube
Industries Co.—a Fe-P-Co-Pb-O catalyst [18]. The
separation of isobutyric acid and methacrylic acid (or
both esters) is not easy, and therefore, the conversion
of isobutyric acid has to be as high as possible for sav-
ing energy. For industrialization of this route, a jump
is necessary in the catalyst performance concerning
productivity and life.
Isobutyricaldehyde can be oxidized to methacrylic
acid. That has been studied using a large amount
of the by-products in an oxo-process for producing
n-butric aldehyde. But, due to the improvements of
oxo-catalysts, e.g. the replacement of conventional
cobalt catalysts by newly developed rhodium cata-
lysts, the amount of iso by-product has been strongly
decreased. Therefore, the necessity of establishing
this MAA route may be diminished, in our days.
4.3. Methyl acetylene process
Shell developed a novel attractive process for pro-
ducing MMA from methyl acetylene (propyne) in
one-step.
CH≡≡CCH3 + CO+ CH3OH
→ CH2=C(CH3)COOCH3
In this method, methyl acetylene is used, while
acetylene is used for production of acrylic acid by
Reppe’s carbonylation. For manufacturing acrylic
acid, BASF has shut down their last Reppe acrylic
acid plant, and the direct oxidation method of propy-
lene completely takes the place of it. In so many
years, the effort has been made to get MMA from
methyl acetylene in the same way as acrylic acid, but
the yield of MMA was very low in case it has based
on the same catalyst and same condition. Palladium
catalyst was also known for this reaction, but its
application for MMA did not work sufficiently [19].
Shell found that this reaction proceeds with a good
yield in the presence of palladium acetate, organic
phosphine and protonic acids [20]. But the activity of
such catalysts was not sufficient. Then, Shell made a
great effort to improve the catalyst system, and as a
result, the yield reached 99.9%, in which 100,000 mol
of MMA were produced for 1 mol Pd per hour. This is
achieved by using, e.g. 2,6-bis-(biphenyl phosphino)
pyridine under mild non-corrosive condition at approx.
50 ◦C, and a CO pressure of about 1 MPa [21,22]. Con-
cerning this procedure, a detailed report was published
[23,24].
Methyl acetylene as the raw material for produc-
ing MMA could be obtained in an ethylene plant.
In a C3 stream from a naphtha cracker, a few per-
cents of methyl acetylene and alene (propadiene)
exist as by-products, and one million tonnes per
year of ethylene capacity is necessary for producing
40,000–50,000 t per year of MMA. Methyl acetylene
could be separated from the C3 stream by extraction
and distillation with DMF, and alene is isomerized to
methyl acetylene with K2O/Al2O3 catalyst [25].
Because of the few steps and extremely high cata-
lyst performance, this process would have many ad-
vantages at a place close to a big ethylene production
plant. It was reported that ICI paid a fee to Shell for
utilizing this technology.
5. C4 routes
In all of the C2 and C3 routes described above, a
methallyl carbon frame has to be formed by adding of
one or two carbon atoms using C1 compounds such
as CO, HCHO or HCN. In contrast, in C4 routes, the
isobutylene or tert-butanol carbon skeleton is used as
372 K. Nagai / Applied Catalysis A: General 221 (2001) 367–377
it is. The C4 routes have been commercially estab-
lished by Japanese companies where a new supply of
HCN could not be expected, and only low amounts
of isobutylene had been demanded, whereas western
countries have a great demand for it as a gasoline addi-
tive. Therefore, some Japanese companies have made
aneffort to develop new processes. The key factors of
these routes were the development of excellent cata-
lysts. Today in Japan, more than half of MMA pro-
duction capacity comes from C4 routes. Now, in addi-
tion to Japan direct oxidation plants are operating in
Korea, Singapore and Thailand.
5.1. Escambia process
A process using isobutylene as a raw material has
been commercially employed by Escambia Co. for a
short period of time. Isobutylene is oxidized to provide
�-hydroxy isobutyric acid by using N2O4 and nitric
acid at a low temperature of 5–10 ◦C in liquid phase.
After esterification and dehydration MMA is obtained.
However, this process does not seem to be economical
by favorable because the yield is not sufficient and
there are some problems such that large amounts of
nitric acid and NOx should be handled. In addition,
an explosion accident happened during the operation
in the plant. Therefore, this production was stopped in
1965.
5.2. C4 direct oxidation process
Realization of a direct gas phase oxidation process
starting from isobutylene for producing methacrylic
acid was delayed until 1982, i.e. about 10 years after
acrylic acid by direct oxidation of propylene. The
basis of three processes, which were developed exclu-
sively in Japan and proposed by Mitsubishi Rayon,
Japan Methacrylic Monomer (Sumitomo Chemical
and Nippon Shokubai) and Kyodo Monomer (Ku-
raray & Mitsui Chemical) seems to be similar to one
another.
The necessity of separation of isobutylene or
tert-butanol (TBA) from C4 stream of an ethylene
cracker or a FCC-unit, needed the development of new
catalyst technologies. Sumitomo Chemical obtains
high purity isobutylene via methyl tert-butylether
(MTBE) with a novel acid catalyst. The process of
Mitsubishi Rayon and Asahi Chemical produces TBA
from a C4 mixture in which a ion-exchange resin or
heteropoly acid solution is adopted as a catalyst.
Because MTBE is used today worldwide in large
quantities as a gasoline additive, the supply of isobuty-
lene from ethylene and FCC plants, or TBA as a
by-product in Oxiran process (propyleneoxide) is not
sufficient. Therefore, the dehydrogenation process of
isobutane has been conducted on a large scale, and
the oxidehydrogenation of isobutane or isomerization
of n-butenes have to be studied extensively. No mat-
ter how large quantities of MTBE are available in the
world, it seems too expensive to be used as a raw ma-
terial of MMA, because the price is based on a rather
expensive gasoline price. For this reason, the C4 direct
oxidation process might not be so popular worldwide.
The reactions by the direct oxidation method con-
sist of two-step oxidation of isobutylene or TBA with
air to produce methacrylic acid and esterification by
methanol to produce MMA
CH2=C–(CH3)2 (or (CH3)3C–OH)+ O2
→ CH2=C(CH3)–CHO+ H2O
CH2=C(CH3)–CHO+ 12 O2 → CH2=C(CH3)–COOH
CH2=C(CH3)–COOH+ CH3OH
→ CH2=C(CH3)–COOCH3 + H2O
There are two processes. One process (Mitsubishi
Rayon) consists of the separation of methacrolein from
the first-step oxidation gas, and another one (Japan
Methacrylic Monomer) consists of the direct intro-
duction of the first effluent gas to the second reactor
[26]. The flow diagram of the latter process is shown
in Fig. 2 [27]. The second reactor effluent, containing
MAA and unreacted methacrolein, is condensed to re-
cover MAA as an aqueous solution. Methacrolein is
recovered and is recycled to the second oxidation re-
actor. MAA is extracted from the solution with a sol-
vent and then is esterified to MMA with sulfuric acid
or an ion exchange resin as a catalyst. In this process,
MAA can be obtained also as an end product.
The key of the C4 direct oxidation process was the
development of high performance oxidation catalysts.
Concerning those catalysts, results of fundamental sci-
entific research and an enormous number of patents
are published. As in acrylic acid processes via direct
oxidation of propylene, two kinds of catalysts are used
K. Nagai / Applied Catalysis A: General 221 (2001) 367–377 373
Fig. 2. C4 Direct oxidation process (Japan methacrylic monomer) [27].
in this oxidation process, which consists of two steps:
the first-step is a catalytic oxidation of olefins and the
second-step is an oxidation of aldehydes.
A catalyst utilized in the first-step is a multi-
component oxide catalyst of Mo-Bi, which seems to
be one for propylene oxidization, and the second step
catalyst is a P-Mo heteropoly acid structure catalyst
that is different from the Mo-V catalyst for acrolein
oxidization. The reaction mechanism of isobutylene
oxidation is thought to be the same as that of propy-
lene oxidation, in which �-allyl adsorption species
and the role of lattice oxygen are employed. Most of
the first step catalysts developed for isobutylene ox-
idation are based on the modification of the famous
SOHIO Mo-Bi catalyst.
The important improvements of SOHIO catalyst
were achieved in Japan [28–30]. Even though the
acrolein yield was about 40% in an early stage, the
activity of such catalysts and the selectivity thereby
were improved greatly resulting in a yield of more
than 90% as obtained in the case of C3 route for
acrylic acid today. The basic catalyst components are
Mo-Bi-Fe-Co/Ni-A (A: an alkaline metal, an alkaline
earth and Tl), the same as in a propylene oxidation
catalyst, although the reactions differ in easiness.
When the propylene oxidation catalyst was used for
oxidizing isobutylene, the activity tended to be too
high, and therefore, the yield of methacrolein was low-
ered. The catalyst for oxidizing isobutylene has been
optimized by increasing the alkaline metal ratio in
the catalyst, and so on. The byproducts are CO, CO2,
formaldehyde, acetone, acetoaldehyde, formic acid,
acetic acid and many other oxygenated compounds.
Total yield of methacrolein plus methacrylic acid is
a little lower than that of acrolein plus acrylic acid.
In the propylene oxidation, a considerable quantity of
acrylic acid is formed even in the first reaction, while
in the isobutylene oxidation, rather a few amount of
374 K. Nagai / Applied Catalysis A: General 221 (2001) 367–377
methacrylic acid is formed. Because methacrolein has
an extra methyl group, the selectivity to MAA from
methacrolein would be worse and the produced MAA
will be easily burned out on the first-step catalyst. But,
the yield of methacrolein reached over 80%, which is
almost as the same level as that of acrolein. Recent
patents for the first oxidation step disclose methods
of catalyst preparation or methods by using catalyst
having a specific shape such as a ring type shape or a
convex shape [31,32], a reactivation method of dete-
riorated catalyst [33], or a method of filling different
catalysts into an inlet from an outlet of a reactor tube
for controlling a hot spot temperature [34].
The industrialization of C4 direct oxidation was de-
layed for a long period in comparison with that of C3
oxidation in acrylic acid, because the catalyst perfor-
mance of the second step was not sufficient. The cata-
lyst for acrolein oxidization (Mo-V multi-component
oxide) shows more than 95% of yield, which had also
been developed by the Japanese company Riken [35].
Even when this catalyst is used for the oxidization of
methacrolein as it is, the yield of MAA is very low.
The trial to improve the performance based on this
catalyst for methacrolein oxidization was not suc-
cessfully. SOHIO had already showed in 1957 that
Mo-P heteropoly acid is effective for this reaction.
After that (in the 1970s) a lot of patents to improve
the heteropoly acid catalysts performance were pub-
lished by many companies [36,37]. The heteropoly
acids used here has a Keggin structure [PMo12O40]3−
for its anion, and has different physico-chemical
properties from those of usual complex oxides. It
has a strong Brönsted acidityoriginated by a proton
as counter cation, and can moderate an oxidizing
power by Mo. The free 12-molybdo-phosphoric acid
(H3PMo12O40·nH2O) does not give such high yield,
and its fatal fault is the catalyst life time due to its
structure instability at the reaction temperature. The
substitution of a part of Mo with V, and the formation
of acidic salt with alkaline metals, are effective on
both the yield and the catalyst life. For the practi-
cal use of this heteropoly acid catalyst, the addition
of small quantity of other elements, or the control
of surface area and pore distribution of the catalyst
by various means in preparation methods have been
adopted.
Still, the performance level of this second step cata-
lyst is not sufficient. Selectivity is not high enough. A
space time yield is not satisfactory, and thereby the ser-
vice problem in the catalyst remains. This may be the
main reason why the C4 direct oxidation method could
not take a world decisive position in MMA processes
like C3 oxidation in acrylic acid. Therefore, many ef-
forts to improve the catalyst performance have been
continued. As for the components, almost all elements
in the periodic table are claimed in patents. Many ex-
aminations on raw materials of the catalyst, molding
methods, calcining procedures and so on are being
carried out, for example, a method of spray-drying af-
ter fast mixing solutions [38], hydrothermal treating
of mixed slurry [39], a method of molding by the ad-
dion of alcohols [40] and so on. The performance of
the heteropoly acid catalysts has been improved by
these steady efforts little by little. A superior catalyst
that would exceed the heteropoly acid catalyst now in
use, has not been found at present. For example, the
modified V-P-O catalyst known for producing maleic
anhydride, can get only about 45% yield [41].
Considering the fact that even in the case of
acrylonitrile or ethylene oxide processes which had
already been established, many efforts of catalyst im-
provement are being continued still now and steady
progress has been made, these efforts to improve
the catalyst performance are indispensable in the C4
direct oxidation process.
5.3. Methacrylonitrile (MAN) process
Asahi Chemical Co. developed and commercialized
a route via methacrylonitrile (MAN) for MMA pro-
duction in 1982
(CH3)3C–OH+ NH3 + 32 O2
→ CH2=C(CH3)CN + 4H2O
CH2=C(CH3)CN + H2SO4 + H2O
→ CH2=C(CH3)–CONH2 · H2SO4
CH2=C(CH3)–CONH · H2SO4 + CH3OH
→ CH2=C(CH3)COOCH3 + NH4HSO4
MAN can be produced by ammoxidation almost in
the same step as acrylonitrile, which is produced in
large quantities. Afterwards MAN has been hydrated
K. Nagai / Applied Catalysis A: General 221 (2001) 367–377 375
by sulflic acid to methacrylamide, the same process as
in conventional ACH was adopted. Because the yield
of MAN can be equal to that of acrylonitrile [42], the
total yield is superior to the above-described two-step
oxidation method. But, problems such as the forma-
tion of the ammonium bisulfate waste and the use of
ammonia, which should not be contained in the end
product still remain. Asahi Chemical seemed to adopt
this process mainly because of the small investment
cost by diversion in their acrylonitrile and ACH plants.
Asahi gave up the MAN based MMA process in 1998,
and switched over an oxidative esterification process
described below.
Mitsubishi Gas Chemicals proposed another im-
proved MAN route [43]. MAN is hydrated to
methacrylamide without using sulfuric acid and is
then esterified to obtain MMA by methylformate in
the same way as the new ACH process
CH2=C(CH3)CN + H2O → CH2=C(CH3)–CONH2
CH2=C(CH3)–CONH2 + HCOOCH3
→ CH2=C(CH3)COOCH3 + HCONH2
HCONH2 → NH3 + CO
In this process, the produced formamide is decom-
posed to ammonia and carbon monoxide, and the am-
monia and the carbon monoxide are recycled to MAN
step and methylformate step, respectively. This de-
composition can be carried out without catalyst or
with a solid base catalyst at high temperatures. Fur-
thermore, Mitsui Toatsu investigated the reaction to
get MMA or MAA from �-hydroxy isobutylamide or
methacrylamide on a solid acid catalyst of phosphoric
acid salt in gas phase [44,45].
5.4. Direct oxidative esterification process
Asahi Chemical established and started in 1998 a
new process based on direct oxidative esterification
of methacrolein, which does not produce by-products
such as ammonium bisulfate. The raw material is the
same tert-butanol as in the direct oxidation method.
In contrast with the direct oxidation process, this
new Asahi process has only two steps. Methacrolein
produced in the same way as in the direct oxidation
process by gas phase catalytic oxidation, is simulta-
neously oxidized and is esterified in liquid methanol
to get MMA directly. This process seems to be very
attractive and get much attention, because it has fewer
steps and gives better yield than that of the direct
oxidation process
CH2=C(CH3)–CHO+ CH3OH+ 12 O2
→ CH2=C(CH3)–COOCH3 + H2O
The attempts for oxidation or oxidative esteri-
fication of methacrolein in liquid phase had been
made for a long time. The method using hydro-
gen peroxide or peracetic acid had been known. As
for the oxidation with molecular oxygen, catalysts
containing Pd were known, but the yield obtained
was not sufficient. Asahi Chemical has developed
a new solid catalyst, which consists of Pd-Pb, and
got a high yield of 93% of MMA [46]. They stud-
ied the role of Pb, and revealed that the catalytic
active structure is in the Pd-Pb metal compound.
The reaction is done in a three-phase system, in
which air or oxygen is blown through the excess of
methanol in liquid phase in the presence of solid
catalyst in a slurry. The excess of methanol and the
unreacted methacrolein have to be recycled. A small
amount of propylene, methylformate, methacrylic
acid, methylisobutylate, methoxy-isobutylaldehyde
and so on, are formed as undesirable by-products.
Many patents about the recycle system and the pu-
rification process of MMA were published. They
admitted that in the early stage of development, there
were some difficulties in the productivity and the cat-
alyst life. A detailed study to improve the catalyst, for
example, a study of a catalyst carrier has been done,
and has established an excellent industrial catalyst
system [47–49].
5.5. Isobutane direct oxidation method
Though all processes as described above use alkenes
as raw materials, the usage of alkane is expected for
a next generation process. The raw materials for pro-
ducing maleic anhydride has been changing from ben-
zene or butenes to n-butane. BP America, Mitsubishi
Chemical and Asahi Chemical have announced a
propane route for producing acrylonitrile on a pilot
stage.
376 K. Nagai / Applied Catalysis A: General 221 (2001) 367–377
Table 1
Effect of total pressure and space velocity on oxidation of isobutanea
Tempera-
ture (◦C)
piC4 (kPa) SV (h−1) ptot (kPa) Conversion
iC4 (%)
Selectivity
MAA (%)
Yield MAA
(%)
Productivity MAA
(mmol h−1 g cat−1)
330 37 1025 100 7.6 57.4 4.4 0.74
354 37 2059 100 8.3 50.4 4.2 1.41
329 74 2041 200 7.1 55.5 3.9 1.33
332 100 2744 270 9.0 51.9 4.7 2.65
355 137 7605 370 12.0 43.8 5.3 6.60
a Conversions of isobutane, selectivities MAA and productivity to MAA at different space velocities and different total pressures.
Reaction conditions: iC4 = 37%, O2 = 37%, H2O = 15%, N2 = balance, cat.: Mo12V0.5P1.5As0.4Cu0.3Cs1.4Ox .
Isobutane is now utilized in large quantities for mak-
ing MTBE by dehydration to isobutylene, but if it
could be used for being oxidized directly in one-step
to obtain methacrylic acid, the process would be very
attractive
(CH3)3–CH+ 2O2
→ CH2=C(CH3)–COOH+ 2H2O
Rohm & Haas discovered at an early time that isobu-
tane can be oxidized to methacrylic acid with a het-
eropoly acid catalystwhich consists of Mo-P-Sb-O.
After that, Asahi Chemical, Sumitomo Chemical and
others showed that similar Mo-V-P heteropoly acid
catalysts to that used for methacrolein oxidation in
the isobutylene oxidation process, have a relatively
good performance [50,51]. The selectivity to MAA
plus methacroleine reaches more than 70%. But, when
isobutane conversion is increased, the selectivity falls
fairly linear. This is because the consecutive oxidation
rate of the produced MAA is much larger than the
rate of isobutane conversion. Though the conversion
is around 10%, a comparatively high productivity can
be attained. Table 1 shows the productivity enhance-
ment by increasing pressure and space velocity [52].
For industrialization, a short catalyst life would be a
big problem, and a development of high performance
catalyst would be a key factor.
In this reaction, one of three equivalent methyl
group of isobutane remains, another one is dehydrated
for providing a double bond and the other one of these
is converted for providing a carboxyl group, using
the same catalyst under same conditions. This kind of
catalysis is very interesting and challenging for cata-
lyst researchers, although it would be highly difficult.
6. Outlook
Many bulk-chemicals changed their manufacturing
processes into methods utilizing alkenes as a raw ma-
terial due to the appearance of petrochemicals in the
1950s. The development of the MMA process is a rare
case in which the first process developed in the 1930s
dominates its world production even today. But now,
several new methods have been realized mainly by
Japanese companies. The various processes described
above had to or will have to make jumps in catalysts
performances in order to rise up to an industrial eco-
nomically favorable level, though the reactions them-
selves have been studied for a long period. It will
be interesting to see which process will be the main
stream of the MMA manufacturing from now on. Cat-
alyst researchers all over the world are expected to
develop new catalysts for such a process and then the
commercialization will be verified.
References
[1] Chem. Eng-London, 28 June (1990) 15.
[2] F. Merger, H.J. Foerster, US Patent 4,408,079 (1982), to
BASF AG.
[3] G. Duembgen, G. Fouquet, R. Krabetz, E. Lucas, F. Merger,
F. Nees, US Patent 4,496,770 (1983), to BASF AG.
[4] G.P. Hagen, US Patent 4,433,174 (1984), to Standard Oil Co.
[5] R.A. Montag, S.T. McKenna, European Patent 255,395
(1988), to Amoco Corp.
[6] J.S. Yoo, Appl. Catal. A: Gen. 102 (1993) 215.
[7] O.H. Bailey, R.A. Montag, J.S. Yoo, Appl. Catal. A: Gen. 88
(1992) 163.
[8] M. Ookita, Japan Patent A 05-331,098 (1983), to Mitsubishi
Rayon Co.
K. Nagai / Applied Catalysis A: General 221 (2001) 367–377 377
[9] H. Niizuma, S. Kojima, H. Kato, T. Miki, T. Ito, M. Tsutomi,
Y. Murakami, A. Kazuma, European Patent 164,614 (1985),
to Toa Gosei Chemical Industry Co. Ltd.
[10] S. Oda, T. Nakano, R. Han, Japan Patent 06-048,977 (1994),
to Daisel Chem.
[11] J.J. Spivey, M.R. Gogate, J.R. Zoeller, R.D. Colberg, Ind.
Eng. Chem. Res. 36 (1997) 4600.
[12] M.R. Gogate, J.J. Spivey, J.R. Zoeller, G.N. Choi, S.S. Tam,
R.E. Tisher, R.D. Srivastava, in: Proceedings of the Annual
International Pittsburgh Coal Conference, PA, USA, 1996,
p. 559.
[13] S. Ebata, H. Hirayama, H. Higuchi, K. Kida, European Patent
412,310 (1991), to Mitsubishi Gas Chemical Co. Ltd.
[14] S. Ebata, H. Hirayama, T. Uchiyama, European Patent
418,512 (1991), to Mitsubishi Gas Chemical Co. Ltd.
[15] Y. Shima, T. Abe, H. Higuchi, European Patent 598,243
(1994), to Mitsubishi Gas Chemical Co. Ltd.
[16] K. Kida, European Patent 941,984 (1999), to Mitsubishi Gas
Chemical Co. Ltd.
[17] T. Otaki, H. Sakurada, M. Otake, F. Fijii, Japan Patent A
48-078,120 (1973), to Mitsubishi Chemical Co. Ltd.
[18] M. So, K. Odan, Japan Patent A 06-107,591 (1994), to Ube
Industries.
[19] N. Kawata, K. Honna, H. Sugahara, US Patent 4,055,721
(1977), to Idemitsu Kasan Co. Ltd.
[20] E. Drent, European Patent 186,228 (1986), to Shell
Internationale Research Maatschappij BV.
[21] P.A.A. Klusener, J.C.L. Suykerbuyk, P.A. Verbrugge,
European Patent 499,328 (1992), to Shell Internationale
Research Maatschappij BV.
[22] P.A.A. Klusener, E. Drent, H.A. Stil, P. Arnoldi, J.C.L.
Suykerbuyk, P.A. Verbrugge, European Patent 499,329
(1992), to Shell Internationale Research Maatschappij BV.
[23] E. Drent, P. Arnoldy, P.H. Budzelaar, J. Organometal. Chem.
475 (1994) 57.
[24] J. Keijsper, P. Arnoldy, M.J. Doyle, E. Drent, Recl. Trav.
Chim. Phys.-Bas. 115 (1996) 248.
[25] J. Hengeveld, P.B. de Blank, European Patent 539,628 (1993),
to Shell Internationale Research Maatschappij BV.
[26] N. Shimizu, H. Yoshida, G. Matsumoto, T. Abe, Energy Prog.
8 (1988) 169.
[27] Hydrocarbon Process, Nov. (1985) 148.
[28] S. Takenaka, Y. Kido, Y. Shimabara, M. Ogawa, US Patent
3,778,386 (1971), to Nippon Kayaku Co. Ltd.
[29] T. Shiraishi, S. Kishiwada, S. Shimizu, S. Honmaru, H.
Ichihashi, Y. Nagaoka, US Patent 3,928,462 (1975), to
Sumitomo Chemical Co. Ltd.
[30] T. Ohara, M. Ninomiya, I. Yanagisawa, M. Ueshima, M.
Takata, US Patent 3,799,978 (1975), to Nippon Shokubai
Kogyo Co. Ltd.
[31] T. Jinbo, T. Honda, M. Murakami, T. Matsuhisa, K. Kawahari,
N. Horiuchi, Japan Patent A 06-145,093 (1994), to Mitsui
Toatsu Chemicals, Inc.
[32] T. Shiotani, T. Kuroda, Japan Patent A 06-210,183 (1994),
to Mitsubishi Rayon Co.
[33] M. Ookita, S. Watanabe, Japan Patent A 05-184,945 (1993),
to Mitsubishi Rayon Co.
[34] H. Onodera, S. Ohno, I. Kurimoto, Y. Oaki, WO 91-08,185
(1991), to Nippon Shokubai Kogyo Co. Ltd.
[35] M. Yanagito, M. Kitahara, US Patent 3,567,772 (1971),
to Toa Gosei Chemical Industry Co. Ltd. and Rikagaku
Kenkyusho.
[36] S. Akiyama, H. Yamamoto, GB 1,487,765 (1975), to Nippon
Zeon Co. Ltd.
[37] M. Wada, M. Ueshima, I. Yanagisawa, M. Ninomiya, GB
1,492,185 (1975), to Nippon Shokubai Kogyo Co. Ltd.
[38] T. Honda, N. Horiuchi, A. Kitagawa, M. Murikami, K.
Kawahara, Japan Patent A 04-182,450 (1992), to Mitsui
Toatsu Chemicals Inc.
[39] K. Nagai, S. Hamano, Y. Nagaoka, T. Ui, Japan Patent
06-086,933 (1994), to Sumitomo Chemicals Co.
[40] H. Naito, M. Ohtani, M. Oh-kita, T. Kuroda, Japan Patent A
05-309,273 (1993), to Mitsubishi Rayon Co.
[41] S. Ono, Y. Asako, R. Aizawa, M. Kobayashi, Japan Patent
A 06-009,486 (1994), to Tosoh Corp.
[42] T. Katsumata, T. Dozono, European Patent 78,150 (1983), to
Asahi Chemical Industry Co. Ltd.
[43] K. Kida, H. Higuchi, H. Igarashi, H. Hirayama, Japan Patent
A 03-066,644 (1991), to Mitsubishi Gas Chemical Co. Ltd.
[44] M. Karasawa, T. Hiraiwa, S. Tokunoh, H. Kageyama, K.
Miyama, M. Inomata, Japan Patent A 06-234,696 (1993), to
Mitsui Toatsu Chemicals Inc.
[45] M. Karasawa, S. Tokunoh, Japan Patent A 06-234,701 (1993),
to Mitsui Toatsu Chemicals Inc.
[46] N. Tamura, Y. Fukuoka, S. Yamamatsu, Y. Suzuki, R. Mitsui,
T. Ibuki, GB 2,008,430 (1979), to Asahi Chemical Industry
Co. Ltd.
[47] T. Yamaguchi, S. Yamamatsu, Japan Patent A 09-052,044
(1997), to Asahi Chemical Industry Co. Ltd.
[48] T. Yamaguchi, S. Yamamatsu, Japan Patent A 09-192,495
(1997), to Asahi Chemical Industry Co. Ltd.
[49] M. Chono, S. Yamamatsu, T. Yamaguchi, K. Yokata, Japan
Patent A 10-114,708 (1998), to Asahi Chemical Industry Co.
Ltd.
[50] S. Yamamatsu, T. Yamaguchi, WO 90-14,325 (1990), to Asahi
Chemical Industry Co. Ltd.
[51] K. Nagai, Y. Nagaoka, H. Sato, M. Ohsu, European Patent
418,657 (1991), to Sumitomo Chemical Co. Ltd.
[52] G.P. Schindler, T. Ui, K. Nagai, Japan Patent A 2000-095,725,
to Japan Chemical Industry Association.
	New developments in the production of methyl methacrylate
	Introduction
	Routes to MMA
	C2 routes
	BASF's process
	Other C2 routes
	C3 routes
	New ACH process
	Isobutyric acid process
	Methyl acetyleneprocess
	C4 routes
	Escambia process
	C4 direct oxidation process
	Methacrylonitrile (MAN) process
	Direct oxidative esterification process
	Isobutane direct oxidation method
	Outlook
	References

Mais conteúdos dessa disciplina