<div id="pf1" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="1"><div class="pc pc1 w0 h0"><img class="bi x0 y0 w1 h1" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/4cb09b61-4250-444d-ae0c-98af2d5728a1/bg1.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="t m0 x1 h2 y1 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Aula 13</div><div class="t m0 x2 h3 y2 ff1 fs1 fc1 sc0 ls1 ws3">Direito Constitucional p/ PC-MA (Delegado) Pós-edital</div><div class="t m0 x2 h4 y3 ff2 fs2 fc1 sc0 ls1 ws3">Professores: Equipe Ricardo e Nádia, Nádia Carolina, Ricardo Vale</div><div class="t m0 x3 h5 y4 ff2 fs3 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="c x4 y5 w2 h6"><div class="t m0 x5 h7 y6 ff3 fs4 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws0">`Ì<span class="blank _0"> </span>i`Ê Õ<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ã<span class="blank _0"> </span>}ÊÌ<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊv<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ài<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊÛi<span class="blank _0"> </span>ÀÃ<span class="blank _0"> </span> Ê <span class="blank _0"> </span>vÊ<span class="ff4"><span class="blank _0"> </span>v<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="blank _0"> </span>ÝÊ* <span class="blank _0"> </span>Ê<span class="blank _0"> </span>`<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ì <span class="blank _0"> </span>À</span><span class="ls0 ws1">ÊÊ</span><span class="fc3 ws2">Ü Ü Ü°Vi °V </span></div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf2" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="2"><div class="pc pc2 w0 h0"><img class="bi x0 y0 w1 h1" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/4cb09b61-4250-444d-ae0c-98af2d5728a1/bg2.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x0 y0 w0 h8"><div class="t m0 x6 h9 y7 ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 ha y8 ff6 fs5 fc4 sc0 ls1 ws3">Prof. Nádia Caro<span class="blank _1"></span>lina <span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="ff7 fs6 fc5">www.estrateg<span class="blank _1"></span>iaconcursos.com.b<span class="blank _1"></span>r <span class="ff5 fs5 fc4"> <span class="fc0 ws4">1</span> de <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="fc0">140 </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 hb y9 ff8 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="c x7 ya w3 hc"><div class="t m0 x2 hd yb ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls2">D<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">IREITO </span><span class="ls3">C<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">ONSTITUCIONAL </span><span class="ff9 ls4"></span><span class="fs7 ls5 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws5">PC-</span><span class="ls9 ws6">MA</span><span class="fs7 ls6 ws3"> </span><span class="ls7">-<span class="fs7 ls8 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws3">Teoria e Questões </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x7 he yc ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Prof<span class="fs8 ws7 v1">a</span><span class="ws3"> Nádia / Prof. Ricardo Vale </span></div><div class="t m0 x8 h9 yd ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="t m0 x9 hf ye ff9 fs9 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws8">A<span class="blank _1"></span><span class="fsa ws3">U<span class="blank _2"></span>L<span class="blank _1"></span>A<span class="blank _2"></span> <span class="blank _2"></span><span class="fs9 ws8"><span class="blank _2"></span><span class="ff7 ws3"> </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xa h10 yf ff9 fs9 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws8">C<span class="blank _1"></span><span class="fsa ws3">O<span class="blank _2"></span>N<span class="blank _1"></span>T<span class="blank _2"></span>R<span class="blank _2"></span>O<span class="blank _1"></span>L<span class="blank _2"></span>E<span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="blank _2"></span>D<span class="blank _1"></span>E<span class="blank _2"></span> <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="fs9 ws8">C<span class="blank _2"></span><span class="fsa ws9">O<span class="blank _1"></span>N<span class="blank _2"></span>S<span class="blank _2"></span>T<span class="blank _2"></span>IT<span class="blank _2"></span>U<span class="blank _2"></span>C<span class="blank _1"></span>I<span class="blank _2"></span>O<span class="blank _1"></span>N<span class="blank _2"></span>A<span class="blank _1"></span>L<span class="blank _2"></span>I<span class="blank _2"></span>D<span class="blank _2"></span>A<span class="blank _1"></span>D<span class="blank _2"></span>E<span class="blank _2"></span><span class="ff5 fs9 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y10 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Sumário </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y11 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Controle de Constitucionalidade <span class="blank _3"></span><span class="lsa wsa">...........................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span>2 </span></span></div><div class="t m0 xb h11 y12 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">1-Noções Básicas sobre o Controle de Constitucionalidade. <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="lsa wsb">..............<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span>2 </span></span></div><div class="t m0 xb h11 y13 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">2-Espécies de Inconstitucionalidade: <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="lsa wsc">................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span>5 </span></span></div><div class="t m0 xb h11 y14 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">3-Sistemas de Controle de Constitucionalidade: <span class="blank _5"></span><span class="lsa wsb">..............................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">12<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xb h11 y15 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">4-Momentos de Controle: <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="lsa wsd">.............................<span class="blank _1"></span>...................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">12<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xb h11 y16 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">5- Modelos de Controle de Constitucionalidade: <span class="blank _6"></span><span class="lsa wsb">..............................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">15<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xb h11 y17 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">6- Vias de Controle: <span class="blank _7"></span><span class="lsa wse">.........................................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">16<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xb h11 y18 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">7- Interpretação conforme à Constituição X Declaração Parcial de </div><div class="t m0 xb h11 y19 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">nulidade sem redução de texto. <span class="blank _3"></span><span class="lsa wsd">.......................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _6"></span><span class="lsa wsb">17<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xb h11 y1a ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">8- Controle Difuso: <span class="blank _2"></span><span class="lsa wsf">..........................................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">19<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y1b ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">8.1<span class="ls1 ws3">- Noções Gerais: <span class="blank _8"></span><span class="lsa wsa">.......................................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">19<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y1c ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">9.2<span class="ls1 ws3">- Legitimação Ativa: <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsd">.........................................<span class="blank _1"></span>.......................<span class="ls1 ws3">. <span class="blank _6"></span><span class="lsa wsb">19<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y1d ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">8.3<span class="ls1 ws3">- Objeto e Parâmetro de Controle: <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="lsa ws10">...........................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">20<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y1e ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">8.4<span class="ls1 ws3">- Controle Difuso nos Tribunais: <span class="blank _8"></span><span class="lsa ws11">...............................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">20<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y1f ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">8.5<span class="ls1 ws3">-Efeitos da Decisão: <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="lsa wsd">................................................................<span class="ls1 ws3">. <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">24<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y20 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">8.6<span class="ls1 ws3">- Atuação do Senado Federal: </span><span class="ws12">..................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _6"></span><span class="lsa wsb">26<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y21 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">8.7<span class="ls1 ws3">- Súmula Vinculante: <span class="blank _8"></span><span class="lsa wsd">................................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">28<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y22 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">8.8<span class="ls1 ws3">- Meios de Acesso ao Controle Difuso: <span class="blank _3"></span><span class="lsa ws13">......................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">31<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y23 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">8.9<span class="ls1 ws3">- Recurso Extraordinário: <span class="blank _7"></span><span class="lsa wsa">.........................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">31<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xb h11 y24 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">9- Controle Abstrato: <span class="blank _8"></span><span class="lsa wsa">....................................................................... <span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">34<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y25 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">9.1<span class="ls1 ws3">- Noções Gerais: <span class="blank _8"></span><span class="lsa wsa">.......................................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">34<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y26 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">9.2<span class="ls1 ws3">- Ação Direta de Inconstitucionalidade genérica (<span class="blank _1"></span>ADI):<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _7"></span><span class="lsa wsb">...........<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">35<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y27 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">9.3<span class="ls1 ws3">- Ação Direta de Inconstitucionalidade por Omissão (ADO): <span class="blank _9"></span><span class="lsa wsb">....<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">54<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y28 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">9.4<span class="ls1 ws3">-Ação Declaratória de Constitucionalidade (ADC): <span class="blank _2"></span><span class="lsa wsb">...................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">59<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y29 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">9.5<span class="ls1 ws3">- Arguição de Descumprimento de Preceito Fundamental </span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y2a ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">(ADPF): <span class="blank _5"></span><span class="lsa ws14">.........................................................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">64<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y2b ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">9.6<span class="ls1 ws3">- O Controle Abstrato de Constitucionalidade do Direito Estadual </span></div><div class="t m0 xc h11 y2c ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">e Municipal: <span class="blank _a"></span><span class="lsa ws15">...................................................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">72<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xb h11 y2d ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa ws3">10 <span class="ffb ls1 ws16">–</span><span class="ls1"> Estado de coisas inconstitucional </span><span class="ws17">............<span class="blank _1"></span>................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">76<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xb h11 y2e ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">11<span class="ls1 ws3">- Ação Direta de Inconstitucionalidade Interventiva: <span class="blank _2"></span><span class="lsa wsb">..................<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">77<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xb h11 y2f ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">12<span class="ls1 ws3">- Histórico do Controle de Constitucionalidade no Brasil: <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="lsa wsb">............<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _9"></span><span class="lsa wsb">79<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y30 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Questões Comentadas <span class="blank _3"></span><span class="lsa ws18">........................................................................ <span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _4"></span><span class="lsa wsb">82<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y31 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Lista de Questões <span class="blank _b"></span><span class="lsa ws19">.............................................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _6"></span><span class="lsa wsb">12<span class="ls1 ws3">2 </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x3 h5 y4 ff2 fs3 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="c x4 y5 w2 h6"><div class="t m0 x5 h7 y6 ff3 fs4 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws0">`Ì<span class="blank _0"> </span>i`Ê Õ<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ã<span class="blank _0"> </span>}ÊÌ<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊv<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ài<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊÛi<span class="blank _0"> </span>ÀÃ<span class="blank _0"> </span> Ê <span class="blank _0"> </span>vÊ<span class="ff4"><span class="blank _0"> </span>v<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="blank _0"> </span>ÝÊ* <span class="blank _0"> </span>Ê<span class="blank _0"> </span>`<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ì <span class="blank _0"> </span>À</span><span class="ls0 ws1">ÊÊ</span><span class="fc3 ws2">Ü Ü Ü°Vi °V </span></div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf3" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="3"><div class="pc pc3 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 y0 w1 h1" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/4cb09b61-4250-444d-ae0c-98af2d5728a1/bg3.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x0 y0 w0 h8"><div class="t m0 x6 h9 y7 ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 ha y8 ff6 fs5 fc4 sc0 ls1 ws3">Prof. Nádia Caro<span class="blank _1"></span>lina <span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="ff7 fs6 fc5">www.estrateg<span class="blank _1"></span>iaconcursos.com.b<span class="blank _1"></span>r <span class="ff5 fs5 fc4"> <span class="fc0 ws4">2</span> de <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="fc0">140 </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 hb y9 ff8 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="c x7 ya w3 hc"><div class="t m0 x2 hd yb ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls2">D<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">IREITO </span><span class="ls3">C<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">ONSTITUCIONAL </span><span class="ff9 ls4"></span><span class="fs7 ls5 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws5">PC-</span><span class="ls9 ws6">MA</span><span class="fs7 ls6 ws3"> </span><span class="ls7">-<span class="fs7 ls8 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws3">Teoria e Questões </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x7 he yc ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Prof<span class="fs8 ws7 v1">a</span><span class="ws3"> Nádia / Prof. Ricardo Vale </span></div><div class="t m0 x8 h9 yd ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y32 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Gabarito <span class="blank _7"></span><span class="lsa ws1a">...........................................................................................<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _6"></span><span class="lsa wsb">138<span class="ls1 ws3"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h9 y33 ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h9 y34 ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 xd h12 y35 ffa fs6 fc1 sc0 ls1 ws3">Controle de Cons<span class="blank _1"></span>tituciona<span class="blank _1"></span>lidade </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y36 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">1-Noções Básicas sobre o Controle de Constitucionalidade. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y37 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 lsa wsb">1.1<span class="ls1 ws3">-Conceito: </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y38 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Na <span class="blank _c"> </span>concepção <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>Hans <span class="blank _c"> </span>Kelsen, <span class="blank _c"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span>ordenamento <span class="blank _c"> </span>jurídico <span class="blank _c"> </span>é <span class="blank _c"> </span>composto <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>normas </div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 y39 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">que <span class="blank _d"> </span>estão <span class="blank _d"> </span>escalonadas <span class="blank _d"> </span>em <span class="blank _d"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">dif<span class="blank _0"> </span>erentes <span class="blank _d"> </span>níveis <span class="blank _d"> </span>hierárquicos<span class="blank _0"> </span></span><span class="v0">, <span class="blank _d"> </span>sendo <span class="blank _d"> </span>que <span class="blank _d"> </span>as </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y3a ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">normas <span class="blank _e"> </span>inferiores <span class="blank _e"> </span>retiram <span class="blank _e"> </span>seu <span class="blank _f"> </span><span class="ffa fc7">fundamento <span class="blank _e"> </span>de <span class="blank _e"> </span>validade<span class="blank _0"> </span></span> <span class="blank _e"> </span>das <span class="blank _e"> </span>normas </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y3b ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">superiores. <span class="blank _10"> </span>No <span class="blank _10"> </span>ápice <span class="blank _10"> </span>do <span class="blank _10"> </span>ordenamento <span class="blank _10"> </span>jurídico, <span class="blank _10"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"> </span>stá <span class="blank _10"> </span>a <span class="blank _10"> </span>Constituição, <span class="blank _10"> </span>que <span class="blank _10"> </span>é <span class="blank _10"> </span>a<span class="blank _0"> </span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y3c ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws16">norma-fundamento<span class="ffc fc0 ws3"> de todas as outras, que nela devem se apoiar. <span class="blank _0"> </span> </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 y3d ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Surge, e<span class="blank _0"> </span>ntão, o <span class="blank _11"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">princípio <span class="blank _0"> </span>da <span class="blank _0"> </span>supremacia <span class="blank _0"> </span>da <span class="blank _11"> </span>Constituição</span><span class="v0">, <span class="blank _0"> </span>que <span class="blank _0"> </span>se <span class="blank _0"> </span>baseia <span class="blank _0"> </span>na </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y3e ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">noção <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>que <span class="blank _12"> </span>todas <span class="blank _c"> </span>as <span class="blank _12"> </span>normas <span class="blank _c"> </span>do <span class="blank _12"> </span>sistema <span class="blank _c"> </span>jurídico <span class="blank _12"> </span>devem <span class="blank _c"> </span>ser <span class="blank _13"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 v0">verticalmente </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h14 y3f ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws16">compatíveis<span class="ffc fc0 ws3 v0"> <span class="blank _10"> </span>com <span class="blank _10"> </span>o <span class="blank _10"> </span>texto <span class="blank _10"> </span>constitucio<span class="blank _0"> </span>nal. <span class="blank _10"> </span> <span class="blank _10"> </span><span class="lsc">A <span class="blank _10"> </span></span></span><span class="fc6 v0">validade<span class="ffc fc0 ws3"> <span class="blank _10"> </span>de<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _10"> </span>uma <span class="blank _10"> </span>norma <span class="blank _10"> </span>está, </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y40 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">assim, diretamente relacionada à sua conformidade com a Constituiçã<span class="lsd ws1b">o.</span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y41 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">O <span class="blank _14"> </span>controle <span class="blank _14"> </span>de <span class="blank _14"> </span>constitucionalidade <span class="blank _14"> </span>consist<span class="blank _1"></span>e <span class="blank _14"> </span>justamente <span class="blank _14"> </span>na <span class="blank _14"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">aferição <span class="blank _14"> </span>da </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y42 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">validade <span class="blank _11"> </span>das <span class="blank _11"> </span>normas<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffc fc0 v0"> <span class="blank _11"> </span>face <span class="blank _11"> </span>à <span class="blank _11"> </span>Co<span class="blank _0"> </span>nstituição. <span class="blank _0"> </span>A <span class="blank _11"> </span>part<span class="blank _0"> </span>ir <span class="blank _11"> </span>desse <span class="blank _11"> </span>controle, <span class="blank _11"> </span>as <span class="blank _c"> </span>norm<span class="lsa">as </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y43 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">são <span class="blank _10"> </span>consideradas <span class="blank _10"> </span>inconstitucionais <span class="blank _10"> </span>/ <span class="blank _10"> </span>inválidas <span class="blank _10"> </span>(<span class="blank _0"> </span>quando <span class="blank _10"> </span>em <span class="blank _10"> </span>desacordo <span class="blank _10"> </span>com <span class="blank _10"> </span>a </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y44 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Carta <span class="blank _15"> </span>Magna) <span class="blank _15"> </span>ou <span class="blank _15"> </span>const<span class="blank _0"> </span>itucionais <span class="blank _15"> </span>/ <span class="blank _16"> </span>válidas <span class="blank _15"> </span>(quando <span class="blank _15"> </span>compatíveis <span class="blank _15"> </span>com<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _15"> </span>a </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y45 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Constituição). <span class="blank _d"> </span>Assim, <span class="blank _10"> </span>é<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _d"> </span>por <span class="blank _10"> </span>meio<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _d"> </span>d<span class="blank _1"></span>o <span class="blank _d"> </span>controle <span class="blank _d"> </span>de <span class="blank _10"> </span>consti<span class="blank _0"> </span>tucionalidade <span class="blank _10"> </span>q<span class="blank _0"> </span>ue <span class="blank _d"> </span>se </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y46 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">busca <span class="blank _10"> </span>fiscalizar <span class="blank _10"> </span>a <span class="blank _17"> </span>compatibilidade <span class="blank _10"> </span>vertical <span class="blank _17"> </span>das <span class="blank _10"> </span>normas <span class="blank _10"> </span>com <span class="blank _17"> </span>a <span class="blank _10"> </span>Constituição <span class="blank _10"> </span>e </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y47 ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws3">garantir a força normativa e a efetividade<span class="fc6"> <span class="ffc fc0">do texto constitucional<span class="lsc">. </span> </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y48 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls4 ws1c">No<span class="ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _18"> </span>Brasil, <span class="blank _d"> </span>por <span class="blank _18"> </span>influência <span class="blank _18"> </span>do <span class="blank _d"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"> </span>ireito <span class="blank _d"> </span>norte<span class="blank _0"> </span>-americano, <span class="blank _d"> </span>a<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _d"> </span>doutrina <span class="blank _18"> </span>majoritária </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y49 ffd fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">adotou <span class="blank _19"> </span>a <span class="blank _19"> </span>“<span class="ffa fc6">teoria <span class="blank _19"> </span>da<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _19"> </span>nulidade</span>” <span class="blank _19"> </span>a<span class="blank _0"> </span>o <span class="blank _19"> </span>tratar <span class="blank _19"> </span>dos <span class="blank _19"> </span>efeit<span class="blank _0"> </span>os <span class="blank _19"> </span>das <span class="blank _19"> </span>leis <span class="blank _19"> </span>ou <span class="blank _19"> </span>a<span class="blank _0"> </span>tos </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y4a ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">normativos <span class="blank _11"> </span>declarados <span class="blank _c"> </span>inconstitucionais. <span class="blank _11"> </span>Segundo <span class="blank _c"> </span>essa <span class="blank _11"> </span>te<span class="blank _0"> </span>oria, <span class="blank _11"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>declaração <span class="blank _11"> </span>de </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y4b ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _13"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>uma <span class="blank _1a"> </span>lei <span class="blank _13"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">afeta <span class="blank _13"> </span>o <span class="blank _12"> </span>plano <span class="blank _13"> </span>da <span class="blank _13"> </span>validade<span class="blank _0"> </span></span><span class="v0">, <span class="blank _12"> </span>o <span class="blank _13"> </span>que <span class="blank _13"> </span>significa </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 y4c ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">que <span class="blank _11"> </span>a <span class="blank _11"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">lei <span class="blank _11"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"> </span>eclarada <span class="blank _11"> </span>inconstitucional <span class="blank _c"> </span>é <span class="blank _11"> </span>nula <span class="blank _11"> </span>desde <span class="blank _11"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span>seu <span class="blank _11"> </span>nascimento<span class="blank _0"> </span></span><span class="v0"> <span class="blank _11"> </span>(ela </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y4d ffd fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">já “nasceu morta”). <span class="ffc"> </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y4e ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Por <span class="blank _12"> </span>ter <span class="blank _13"> </span>nascido <span class="blank _12"> </span>morta, <span class="blank _12"> </span>a<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _12"> </span>lei <span class="blank _13"> </span>inconstitucional <span class="blank _12"> </span>nunca <span class="blank _12"> </span>c<span class="blank _0"> </span>hegou <span class="blank _12"> </span>a <span class="blank _12"> </span>produzir <span class="blank _13"> </span>efeitos, </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y4f ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">pois <span class="blank _19"> </span>não <span class="blank _19"> </span>se <span class="blank _19"> </span>tornou <span class="blank _19"> </span>eficaz. <span class="blank _19"> </span>É <span class="blank _19"> </span>por <span class="blank _19"> </span>isso <span class="blank _19"> </span>que, <span class="blank _1b"> </span>em <span class="blank _1b"> </span>r<span class="blank _0"> </span>egra, <span class="blank _1b"> </span>a <span class="blank _19"> </span>declaração <span class="blank _19"> </span>de </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y50 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade opera <span class="ffa fc7 v0">efeitos <span class="blank _1c"> </span>retroat<span class="blank _0"> </span>ivos</span><span class="lsb v0"> <span class="ffd ls9 ws1d">(“</span><span class="ffe ls1">ex tunc<span class="ffd">”). <span class="ffc">Observe <span class="blank _1c"> </span>que, </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y51 ffd fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">para <span class="blank _c"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>“teoria <span class="blank _c"> </span>da <span class="blank _11"> </span>n<span class="blank _0"> </span>ulidade”, <span class="blank _11"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>dec<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffc">isão <span class="blank _c"> </span>que <span class="blank _c"> </span>declara <span class="blank _c"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _11"> </span>tem </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y52 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">natureza <span class="blank _1d"> </span>declaratória<span class="ffc fc0">. <span class="blank _1d"> </span>Ela <span class="blank _1d"> </span>reconhece, <span class="blank _1d"> </span>afinal, <span class="blank _1e"> </span>uma <span class="blank _1d"> </span>inconstitucionalidade </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y53 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">existente desde a origem. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y54 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Contrapondo-se <span class="blank _10"> </span>a <span class="blank _10"> </span>essa <span class="blank _10"> </span>teoria, <span class="blank _10"> </span>a<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _10"> </span>escola <span class="blank _10"> </span>austríaca <span class="blank _10"> </span>desenvolveu <span class="blank _10"> </span><span class="ffd">a <span class="blank _10"> </span>“<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">teoria <span class="blank _10"> </span>da </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h15 y55 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws16">anulabilidade<span class="ffd fc0 ws3 v0">”, <span class="blank _1a"> </span>segundo <span class="blank _1a"> </span>a <span class="blank _1a"> </span>qual <span class="blank _1a"> </span>a <span class="blank _1a"> </span>de<span class="blank _0"> </span>cla<span class="ffc">ração <span class="blank _1a"> </span>de <span class="blank _1a"> </span>inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _1a"> </span>da <span class="blank _1a"> </span>le<span class="blank _0"> </span>i </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y56 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">afeta <span class="blank _1a"> </span>o<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _1a"> </span>plano <span class="blank _10"> </span>d<span class="blank _1"></span>a <span class="blank _1a"> </span>eficácia<span class="ffc fc0">. <span class="blank _10"> </span>Isso <span class="blank _1a"> </span>significa <span class="blank _1a"> </span>que <span class="blank _10"> </span>a <span class="blank _1a"> </span>lei <span class="blank _1f"> </span></span>produziu <span class="blank _1f"> </span>seus <span class="blank _1a"> </span>efeitos </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y57 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws16">normalmente<span class="ffc fc0 ws3">, <span class="blank _10"> </span>até <span class="blank _17"> </span>o <span class="blank _17"> </span>momento <span class="blank _10"> </span>em <span class="blank _17"> </span>q<span class="blank _0"> </span>ue <span class="blank _10"> </span>é <span class="blank _17"> </span>declarada <span class="blank _10"> </span>inc<span class="blank _0"> </span>onstitucional. <span class="blank _10"> </span>Nesse </span></div><div class="t m0 x3 h5 y4 ff2 fs3 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="c x4 y5 w2 h6"><div class="t m0 x5 h7 y6 ff3 fs4 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws0">`Ì<span class="blank _0"> </span>i`Ê Õ<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ã<span class="blank _0"> </span>}ÊÌ<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊv<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ài<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊÛi<span class="blank _0"> </span>ÀÃ<span class="blank _0"> </span> Ê <span class="blank _0"> </span>vÊ<span class="ff4"><span class="blank _0"> </span>v<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="blank _0"> </span>ÝÊ* <span class="blank _0"> </span>Ê<span class="blank _0"> </span>`<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ì <span class="blank _0"> </span>À</span><span class="ls0 ws1">ÊÊ</span><span class="fc3 ws2">Ü Ü Ü°Vi °V </span></div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf4" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="4"><div class="pc pc4 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 y0 w1 h1" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/4cb09b61-4250-444d-ae0c-98af2d5728a1/bg4.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x0 y0 w0 h8"><div class="t m0 x6 h9 y7 ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 ha y8 ff6 fs5 fc4 sc0 ls1 ws3">Prof. Nádia Caro<span class="blank _1"></span>lina <span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="ff7 fs6 fc5">www.estrateg<span class="blank _1"></span>iaconcursos.com.b<span class="blank _1"></span>r <span class="ff5 fs5 fc4"> <span class="fc0 ws4">3</span> de <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="fc0">140 </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 hb y9 ff8 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="c x7 ya w3 hc"><div class="t m0 x2 hd yb ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls2">D<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">IREITO </span><span class="ls3">C<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">ONSTITUCIONAL </span><span class="ff9 ls4"></span><span class="fs7 ls5 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws5">PC-</span><span class="ls9 ws6">MA</span><span class="fs7 ls6 ws3"> </span><span class="ls7">-<span class="fs7 ls8 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws3">Teoria e Questões </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x7 he yc ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Prof<span class="fs8 ws7 v1">a</span><span class="ws3"> Nádia / Prof. Ricardo Vale </span></div><div class="t m0 x8 h9 yd ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y32 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">caso, <span class="blank _1f"> </span>a <span class="blank _1f"> </span>lei <span class="blank _1f"> </span>inconstitucional <span class="blank _1f"> </span>não <span class="blank _1f"> </span>será <span class="blank _1f"> </span>nula, <span class="blank _1f"> </span>mas <span class="blank _1f"> </span>sim <span class="blank _1f"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 ws16">anul<span class="blank _0"> </span>ável</span>. <span class="blank _1a"> </span>Para <span class="blank _10"> </span>a <span class="blank _1f"> </span>escola </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y58 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">austríaca, <span class="blank _15"> </span>a <span class="blank _15"> </span>declaração<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _15"> </span>de <span class="blank _15"> </span>inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _15"> </span>gera, <span class="blank _16"> </span>portanto, <span class="blank _16"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 v0">efeitos </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h14 y59 ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws16">prospectivos<span class="ffc fc0 ws3 v0"> <span class="ffd ls9 ws1d">(“</span><span class="ffe">ex nunc<span class="ffd">”). </span></span>A decisão terá <span class="ffa fc6">natureza constitutiva</span><span class="ls9">. </span> </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y5a ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Conforme <span class="blank _c"> </span>já <span class="blank _11"> </span>destacamos, <span class="blank _c"> </span><span class="ffd">no <span class="blank _11"> </span>Br<span class="blank _0"> </span>asil, <span class="blank _11"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>doutrina <span class="blank _c"> </span>majoritária <span class="blank _c"> </span>adotou <span class="blank _11"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>“teoria <span class="blank _c"> </span>da </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y5b ffd fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">nulidade”. <span class="blank _1b"> </span>Porém, <span class="blank _1b"> </span>com <span class="blank _20"> </span>o <span class="blank _1b"> </span><span class="ffc">passar <span class="blank _20"> </span>dos <span class="blank _1b"> </span>anos, <span class="blank _20"> </span>a<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _20"> </span>jurisprudência <span class="blank _20"> </span>e <span class="blank _1b"> </span>o <span class="blank _1b"> </span>próprio </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y5c ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">arcabouço <span class="blank _12"> </span>normativo <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">evoluíram <span class="blank _12"> </span>para <span class="blank _12"> </span>mitigar<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _12"> </span>(flexibilizar) <span class="blank _12"> </span>o <span class="blank _12"> </span>princípio <span class="blank _12"> </span>da </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y5d ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws16">nulidade<span class="ffc fc0 ws3 v0">. <span class="blank _21"> </span>Hoje, <span class="blank _21"> </span>existe <span class="blank _21"> </span>a <span class="blank _21"> </span></span><span class="fc7 v0">possibilidade<span class="ffc fc0 ws3"> <span class="blank _21"> </span>de <span class="blank _21"> </span>o <span class="blank _21"> </span>STF, <span class="blank _21"> </span>ao <span class="blank _21"> </span>declarar <span class="blank _21"> </span>a </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y5e ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>uma <span class="blank _12"> </span>lei, <span class="blank _c"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 v0">mo<span class="blank _0"> </span>dular <span class="blank _c"> </span>os <span class="blank _c"> </span>efeitos <span class="blank _c"> </span>da<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _c"> </span>decisão<span class="blank _0"> </span></span><span class="v0"> <span class="blank _c"> </span>por <span class="blank _c"> </span>ra<span class="blank _0"> </span>zões </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y5f ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">de segurança jurídica ou de excepcional in<span class="blank _1"></span>teresse<span class="blank _0"> </span> social<span class="ls9">. </span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y60 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Essa <span class="blank _12"> </span>técnica <span class="blank _12"> </span>permite <span class="blank _13"> </span>que <span class="blank _12"> </span>a <span class="blank _12"> </span>declaração <span class="blank _13"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>inconstitucional<span class="blank _0"> </span>idad<span class="blank _1"></span>e <span class="blank _12"> </span>tenha <span class="blank _12"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"> </span>ficácia </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y61 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">apenas <span class="blank _11"> </span>a <span class="blank _11"> </span>partir <span class="blank _11"> </span>do <span class="blank _c"> </span>seu <span class="blank _11"> </span>trânsito <span class="blank _11"> </span>em <span class="blank _11"> </span>julgado <span class="blank _11"> </span>o<span class="blank _0"> </span>u <span class="blank _11"> </span>de <span class="blank _11"> </span>outro <span class="blank _11"> </span>momento <span class="blank _11"> </span>que <span class="blank _11"> </span>venha <span class="blank _11"> </span>a </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y62 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">ser <span class="blank _18"> </span>fixado; <span class="blank _d"> </span>em <span class="blank _18"> </span>outras <span class="blank _18"> </span>palavras, <span class="blank _18"> </span>passa <span class="blank _18"> </span>a <span class="blank _18"> </span>ser <span class="blank _18"> </span>possível <span class="blank _18"> </span>que <span class="blank _18"> </span>a <span class="blank _d"> </span>declaração <span class="blank _18"> </span>de </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y63 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffb fc6">opere <span class="blank _c"> </span>efeitos <span class="blank _12"> </span>“ex <span class="blank _c"> </span>nunc”<span class="blank _0"> </span></span> <span class="blank _12"> </span>(efeitos <span class="blank _12"> </span>prospecti<span class="blank _1"></span>vos). <span class="blank _12"> </span>Mais <span class="blank _c"> </span>à </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y64 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">frente, <span class="blank _13"> </span>estudaremos <span class="blank _1a"> </span>isso <span class="blank _1a"> </span>tudo <span class="blank _1a"> </span>em <span class="blank _1a"> </span>det<span class="blank _0"> </span>alhes! <span class="blank _13"> </span>Por <span class="blank _1a"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"> </span>nquanto, <span class="blank _13"> </span>é <span class="blank _1a"> </span>importante <span class="blank _1a"> </span>que </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y65 ffd fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">você <span class="blank _20"> </span>saiba <span class="blank _20"> </span>apenas <span class="blank _20"> </span>que <span class="blank _20"> </span>a <span class="blank _20"> </span>“teoria <span class="blank _20"> </span>da <span class="blank _20"> </span>nulidade” <span class="blank _20"> </span>foi <span class="blank _20"> </span>flexibilizada <span class="blank _20"> </span>n<span class="ffc">o <span class="blank _20"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"> </span>ireito </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y66 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">brasileiro. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y67 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y68 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 lsa wsb">1.2<span class="ls1 ws3">- Pressupostos: </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y69 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Segundo <span class="blank _1a"> </span>a <span class="blank _1f"> </span>doutrina, <span class="blank _1a"> </span>são <span class="blank _1f"> </span>pressupostos <span class="blank _1f"> </span>do <span class="blank _1a"> </span>controle <span class="blank _1f"> </span>de <span class="blank _1f"> </span>consti<span class="blank _1"></span>tucionalidade: <span class="blank _1f"> </span><span class="ffa lsf ws1e">i)<span class="blank _0"> </span></span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y6a ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">existência <span class="blank _d"> </span>de <span class="blank _18"> </span>uma <span class="blank _18"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">Constituição <span class="blank _d"> </span>escrit<span class="blank _0"> </span>a <span class="blank _d"> </span>e <span class="blank _d"> </span>rígida<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _d"> </span></span><span class="lse v0">e<span class="ls9">; <span class="blank _18"> </span><span class="ffa ls1 ws16">ii<span class="blank _0"> </span>)</span><span class="ls1"> <span class="blank _d"> </span>existência <span class="blank _18"> </span>de <span class="blank _d"> </span>um </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y6b ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">mecanismo <span class="blank _d"> </span>de <span class="blank _18"> </span>fiscalização <span class="blank _18"> </span>das <span class="blank _18"> </span>leis<span class="ffc fc0">, <span class="blank _d"> </span>com <span class="blank _18"> </span>previsão <span class="blank _18"> </span>de, <span class="blank _18"> </span>pelo <span class="blank _d"> </span>menos, <span class="blank _1c"> </span>um </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y6c ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">órgão com competência para o exercício da atividade de c<span class="blank _1"></span>ontrole. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y6d ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">As <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">constituições <span class="blank _12"> </span>rígidas</span> <span class="blank _12"> </span>são <span class="blank _12"> </span>aquelas <span class="blank _12"> </span>que <span class="blank _12"> </span>somente <span class="blank _12"> </span>podem <span class="blank _12"> </span>ser <span class="blank _12"> </span>alteradas <span class="blank _12"> </span>por </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y6e ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws3">procedimento <span class="blank _12"> </span>mais <span class="blank _12"> </span>dificultoso<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffc fc0"> <span class="blank _12"> </span>do <span class="blank _12"> </span>que <span class="blank _13"> </span>o <span class="blank _12"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>elaboração <span class="blank _12"> </span>das <span class="blank _12"> </span>leis <span class="blank _12"> </span>ordinárias. </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y6f ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Da <span class="blank _12"> </span>rigid<span class="blank _1"></span>ez, <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">decorre <span class="blank _12"> </span>o <span class="blank _12"> </span>princípio <span class="blank _c"> </span>da <span class="blank _12"> </span>supremacia <span class="blank _12"> </span>formal</span><span class="v0"> <span class="blank _12"> </span>da <span class="blank _c"> </span>Constituição, <span class="blank _12"> </span>eis </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y70 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">que <span class="blank _22"> </span>o <span class="blank _22"> </span>legislador <span class="blank _22"> </span>ordinário <span class="blank _22"> </span>não <span class="blank _23"> </span>poderá <span class="blank _22"> </span>alterá<span class="blank _0"> </span>-la <span class="blank _22"> </span>por <span class="blank _22"> </span>simples <span class="blank _22"> </span>ato </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y71 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">infraconstitucional (cujo procedimento de elaboração é mai<span class="blank _1"></span>s simples). </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y72 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Para <span class="blank _12"> </span>que <span class="blank _13"> </span>essa <span class="blank _13"> </span>relação <span class="blank _13"> </span>fique <span class="blank _12"> </span>mais <span class="blank _13"> </span>clara, <span class="blank _13"> </span>basta <span class="blank _13"> </span>pensarmos <span class="blank _13"> </span>em <span class="blank _12"> </span>um <span class="blank _13"> </span>Estado <span class="blank _13"> </span>que </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y73 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">adote uma constituição <span class="blank _0"> </span>flexível. Ora, nesse <span class="blank _0"> </span>Estado, qualquer lei que for editada </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y74 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">terá <span class="blank _11"> </span>potencial <span class="blank _11"> </span>para <span class="blank _c"> </span>modificar <span class="blank _11"> </span>a <span class="blank _11"> </span>Constituição; <span class="blank _11"> </span>não <span class="blank _c"> </span>há, <span class="blank _11"> </span>portanto, <span class="blank _11"> </span>que <span class="blank _c"> </span>se <span class="blank _11"> </span>falar <span class="blank _11"> </span>na<span class="blank _0"> </span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y75 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">existência <span class="blank _1a"> </span>de <span class="blank _1a"> </span>contro<span class="blank _0"> </span>le <span class="blank _1a"> </span>de <span class="blank _1a"> </span>constitucionalidade <span class="blank _1f"> </span>em <span class="blank _1a"> </span>um <span class="blank _1a"> </span>sist<span class="blank _0"> </span>ema <span class="blank _1a"> </span>de <span class="blank _1a"> </span>constituição </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y76 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">flexível. A <span class="blank _0"> </span>rigidez <span class="blank _0"> </span>constitucional<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _0"> </span>é, assi<span class="blank _0"> </span>m, um <span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">pressuposto<span class="blank _0"> </span> para <span class="blank _0"> </span>a <span class="blank _0"> </span>existência </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h14 y77 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">do controle de constitucionalidade<span class="ffc fc0 lsc v0">. <span class="ls1"> </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y78 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Logo, <span class="blank _11"> </span>nos <span class="blank _11"> </span>pa<span class="blank _0"> </span>íses <span class="blank _11"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">Constituição <span class="blank _11"> </span>escrita <span class="blank _11"> </span>e <span class="blank _c"> </span>rígida</span><span class="v0">, <span class="blank _c"> </span>por <span class="blank _11"> </span>vigorar <span class="blank _11"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span>princípio <span class="blank _0"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"> </span>a </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y79 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">supremacia <span class="blank _20"> </span>formal <span class="blank _20"> </span>da <span class="blank _20"> </span>Constituição, <span class="blank _20"> </span>todas <span class="blank _20"> </span>as <span class="blank _20"> </span>demais <span class="blank _20"> </span>espécies <span class="blank _20"> </span>normativas </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y7a ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">devem <span class="blank _17"> </span>ser <span class="blank _d"> </span>compatíveis <span class="blank _17"> </span>com <span class="blank _17"> </span>as<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _17"> </span>normas <span class="blank _d"> </span>elaboradas <span class="blank _17"> </span>pelo<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _17"> </span>Poder <span class="blank _17"> </span>Constituinte<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ls9">, </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y7b ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">tanto <span class="blank _13"> </span>do <span class="blank _1a"> </span>ponto <span class="blank _1a"> </span>de <span class="blank _1a"> </span>vista <span class="blank _13"> </span>for<span class="blank _0"> </span>mal <span class="blank _13"> </span>(procedimenta<span class="blank _0"> </span>l), <span class="blank _1a"> </span>quanto <span class="blank _1a"> </span>material <span class="blank _13"> </span>(con<span class="blank _0"> </span>teúdo). </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y7c ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Isso <span class="blank _f"> </span>porque, <span class="blank _f"> </span>como<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _e"> </span>consequência <span class="blank _f"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"> </span>a <span class="blank _e"> </span>rigidez <span class="blank _f"> </span>const<span class="blank _0"> </span>itucional, <span class="blank _f"> </span>as <span class="blank _f"> </span>normas<span class="blank _0"> </span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y7d ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">constitucionais são hierarquicament<span class="blank _1"></span>e superior<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="lse ws1f">es</span> às demais. </div><div class="t m0 x3 h5 y4 ff2 fs3 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="c x4 y5 w2 h6"><div class="t m0 x5 h7 y6 ff3 fs4 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws0">`Ì<span class="blank _0"> </span>i`Ê Õ<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ã<span class="blank _0"> </span>}ÊÌ<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊv<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ài<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊÛi<span class="blank _0"> </span>ÀÃ<span class="blank _0"> </span> Ê <span class="blank _0"> </span>vÊ<span class="ff4"><span class="blank _0"> </span>v<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="blank _0"> </span>ÝÊ* <span class="blank _0"> </span>Ê<span class="blank _0"> </span>`<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ì <span class="blank _0"> </span>À</span><span class="ls0 ws1">ÊÊ</span><span class="fc3 ws2">Ü Ü Ü°Vi °V </span></div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf5" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="5"><div class="pc pc5 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 y0 w1 h1" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/4cb09b61-4250-444d-ae0c-98af2d5728a1/bg5.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x0 y0 w0 h8"><div class="t m0 x6 h9 y7 ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 ha y8 ff6 fs5 fc4 sc0 ls1 ws3">Prof. Nádia Caro<span class="blank _1"></span>lina <span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="ff7 fs6 fc5">www.estrateg<span class="blank _1"></span>iaconcursos.com.b<span class="blank _1"></span>r <span class="ff5 fs5 fc4"> <span class="fc0 ws4">4</span> de <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="fc0">140 </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 hb y9 ff8 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="c x7 ya w3 hc"><div class="t m0 x2 hd yb ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls2">D<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">IREITO </span><span class="ls3">C<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">ONSTITUCIONAL </span><span class="ff9 ls4"></span><span class="fs7 ls5 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws5">PC-</span><span class="ls9 ws6">MA</span><span class="fs7 ls6 ws3"> </span><span class="ls7">-<span class="fs7 ls8 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws3">Teoria e Questões </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x7 he yc ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Prof<span class="fs8 ws7 v1">a</span><span class="ws3"> Nádia / Prof. Ricardo Vale </span></div><div class="t m0 x8 h9 yd ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y32 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="c x6 y7e w4 h16"><div class="t m0 xe h11 y7f ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="c xf y7e w5 h16"><div class="t m0 x10 h11 y80 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">A <span class="blank _1f"> </span>doutrina <span class="blank _1f"> </span>reconhece <span class="blank _10"> </span>que, <span class="blank _10"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 ws16">excepcionalmente</span>, <span class="blank _1f"> </span>é <span class="blank _10"> </span>possível </div><div class="t m0 x10 h13 y81 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">que <span class="blank _12"> </span>exista <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">contr<span class="blank _0"> </span>ole <span class="blank _12"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>constitucionalidade <span class="blank _12"> </span>em <span class="blank _12"> </span>Estados </span></div><div class="t m0 x10 h11 y82 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">que <span class="blank _13"> </span>adotam <span class="blank _1a"> </span>uma <span class="blank _13"> </span>Constituição <span class="blank _1a"> </span>flexível<span class="ffc fc0 v0">, <span class="blank _1a"> </span>desde <span class="blank _13"> </span>que <span class="blank _1a"> </span>haja </span></div><div class="t m0 x10 h11 y83 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">vício <span class="blank _c"> </span>formal <span class="blank _12"> </span>na <span class="blank _c"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"> </span>laboração <span class="blank _12"> </span>da <span class="blank _c"> </span>norma. <span class="blank _12"> </span>Por <span class="blank _c"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"> </span>xemplo, <span class="blank _c"> </span>uma <span class="blank _c"> </span>lei </div><div class="t m0 x10 h11 y84 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">que é elaborada com desrespeito ao processo legislativo. </div></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y85 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">De <span class="blank _12"> </span>nad<span class="blank _1"></span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>ad<span class="blank _0"> </span>ianta, <span class="blank _12"> </span>todavia,<span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="blank _c"> </span>re<span class="blank _0"> </span>conhecer-se <span class="blank _12"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>supremacia <span class="blank _12"> </span>formal<span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="blank _c"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"> </span>a <span class="blank _12"> </span>Constituição </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y86 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">sem <span class="blank _13"> </span>que <span class="blank _13"> </span>ex<span class="blank _0"> </span>ista <span class="blank _13"> </span>um<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _13"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 v0">mecanismo <span class="blank _13"> </span>de <span class="blank _1a"> </span>fiscalização<span class="blank _0"> </span></span><span class="v0"> <span class="blank _13"> </span>da <span class="blank _13"> </span>compatibilidade <span class="blank _1a"> </span>vertical<span class="blank _0"> </span> </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 y87 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">das <span class="blank _11"> </span>normas. <span class="blank _c"> </span>Segundo <span class="blank _c"> </span>o <span class="blank _11"> </span>Prof. <span class="blank _c"> </span>Gilmar <span class="blank _11"> </span>M<span class="blank _0"> </span>endes, <span class="blank _11"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>Constituição <span class="blank _11"> </span>que <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">não <span class="blank _11"> </span>possuir </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y88 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">uma <span class="blank _c"> </span>garantia <span class="blank _c"> </span>para <span class="blank _c"> </span>anulação<span class="ffc fc0 v0"> <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>atos <span class="blank _11"> </span>inconstitucionais <span class="blank _c"> </span></span><span class="v0">deixaria <span class="blank _c"> </span>mesmo <span class="blank _c"> </span>de </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y89 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">ser <span class="blank _12"> </span>obrigatória<span class="ffc fc0 v0">.</span></div><div class="t m0 xa h17 y8a ffc fs8 fc0 sc0 ls10">1<span class="fs2 ls1 ws3 v2"> <span class="blank _12"> </span>Sua <span class="blank _12"> </span>força <span class="blank _12"> </span>normativa <span class="blank _12"> </span>restaria <span class="blank _12"> </span>completamente <span class="blank _12"> </span>prejudicada <span class="blank _12"> </span>e </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y8b ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">ela <span class="blank _c"> </span>não <span class="blank _c"> </span>passaria <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>mera <span class="blank _c"> </span>declaração <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>vontade <span class="blank _c"> </span>do <span class="blank _11"> </span>Pode<span class="blank _0"> </span>r <span class="blank _11"> </span>Constituinte.<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _c"> </span>Nesse </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y8c ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">sentido, <span class="blank _12"> </span>a <span class="blank _12"> </span>existência <span class="blank _13"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>um <span class="blank _12"> </span>mecanismo <span class="blank _12"> </span>de <span class="blank _13"> </span>fiscalização <span class="blank _12"> </span>da<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _12"> </span>constitucionalidade </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y8d ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">das leis garante a supremacia da Constituição. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 y8e ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">O <span class="blank _15"> </span>Poder <span class="blank _16"> </span>Constituinte <span class="blank _15"> </span>Originário <span class="blank _15"> </span>deve <span class="blank _16"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">definir <span class="blank _16"> </span>quais <span class="blank _15"> </span>serão <span class="blank _15"> </span>os <span class="blank _16"> </span>órgãos</span><span class="v0"> </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y8f ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">competentes para <span class="blank _0"> </span>decidir acerca <span class="blank _0"> </span>da <span class="blank _0"> </span>ocorrência ou <span class="blank _0"> </span>não de <span class="blank _0"> </span>ofensa à Co<span class="blank _0"> </span>nstituição </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y90 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">e <span class="blank _11"> </span>o<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _11"> </span>processo <span class="blank _c"> </span>pelo <span class="blank _c"> </span>qual <span class="blank _11"> </span>tal <span class="blank _c"> </span>decisão <span class="blank _c"> </span>será <span class="blank _c"> </span>formalizada. <span class="blank _c"> </span>O <span class="blank _c"> </span>órgão <span class="blank _c"> </span>competente <span class="blank _11"> </span>para </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y91 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">exercer <span class="blank _24"> </span>o <span class="blank _24"> </span>controle <span class="blank _24"> </span>de <span class="blank _25"> </span>constituci<span class="blank _1"></span>onalidade <span class="blank _25"> </span>pode <span class="blank _24"> </span>exercer <span class="blank _24"> </span>tanto <span class="blank _26"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">função </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y92 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws16">jurisdicional<span class="ffc fc0 ws3 v0"> <span class="blank _0"> </span>quanto <span class="blank _11"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">função <span class="blank _0"> </span>política<span class="blank _0"> </span></span>. <span class="blank _0"> </span>No <span class="blank _0"> </span>primeiro <span class="blank _11"> </span>caso, <span class="blank _0"> </span>integrará <span class="blank _0"> </span>a <span class="blank _0"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"> </span>strutura </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y93 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">do <span class="blank _d"> </span>Poder <span class="blank _d"> </span>Judiciário; <span class="blank _d"> </span>no <span class="blank _d"> </span>segundo, <span class="blank _d"> </span>integrará <span class="blank _d"> </span>a <span class="blank _d"> </span>estrutura <span class="blank _d"> </span>de <span class="blank _d"> </span>outro <span class="blank _18"> </span>Poder. <span class="blank _18"> </span>No </div><div class="t m0 x6 h15 y94 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Brasil, <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 v0">comp<span class="blank _0"> </span>ete <span class="blank _12"> </span>a<span class="blank _0"> </span>o <span class="blank _12"> </span>J<span class="blank _0"> </span>udiciário</span><span class="v0"> <span class="blank _13"> </span>exercer <span class="blank _13"> </span>o <span class="blank _12"> </span>controle <span class="blank _13"> </span>de <span class="blank _13"> </span>constitucionalidade <span class="blank _12"> </span>das </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y95 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">leis, <span class="blank _1c"> </span>embora <span class="blank _1c"> </span>haja a <span class="blank _1c"> </span>possibilidade <span class="blank _1c"> </span>de os <span class="blank _1c"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">demais Poderes, <span class="blank _1c"> </span>em situações </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y96 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws16">excepcionais<span class="ffc fc0 ls9 ws3 v0">, <span class="ls1">também realizarem esse<span class="blank _0"> </span> controle. </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y97 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 y98 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 lsa wsb">1.3<span class="ls1 ws3">-Origem do Controle de Constitucionalidade<span class="ffc fc0 v0">: </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y99 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 lsd ws3">O <span class="blank _20"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 ls1 v0">marco <span class="blank _27"> </span>histórico <span class="blank _27"> </span>inicial<span class="ffc fc0"> <span class="blank _20"> </span>do <span class="blank _27"> </span>controle <span class="blank _20"> </span>de <span class="blank _27"> </span>constitucionalidade <span class="blank _27"> </span>foi<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _27"> </span>o <span class="blank _27"> </span>caso<span class="blank _0"> </span> </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y9a ffe fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Marbury <span class="blank _0"> </span>vs <span class="blank _0"> </span>Madison<span class="ffc">, <span class="blank _0"> </span>julgado <span class="blank _0"> </span>em <span class="blank _0"> </span>1803 <span class="blank _0"> </span>nos <span class="blank _0"> </span>Estados U<span class="blank _0"> </span>nidos <span class="blank _0"> </span>pelo <span class="blank _0"> </span></span>Chief <span class="blank _0"> </span>of <span class="blank _0"> </span>Justice<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffc"> </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h15 y9b ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">John <span class="blank _11"> </span>Marshall. <span class="blank _c"> </span>Na <span class="blank _c"> </span>ocasião, <span class="blank _11"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span>juiz <span class="blank _c"> </span>John <span class="blank _c"> </span>Marshall <span class="blank _11"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 v0">afast<span class="blank _0"> </span>ou <span class="blank _11"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>aplicação <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _11"> </span>uma </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y9c ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws3">lei por considerá-la incompatível <span class="ffc fc0 v0">com a Cons<span class="blank _0"> </span>tituição, realizando o <span class="ffa fc6">controle </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 y9d ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws16">difuso<span class="ffc fc0 ws3 v0"> de constitucionalidade.<span class="fs8 ls10 v1">2</span> </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y9e ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">A <span class="blank _28"> </span>decisão <span class="blank _28"> </span>é <span class="blank _28"> </span>céleb<span class="blank _0"> </span>re, <span class="blank _28"> </span>pois <span class="blank _1e"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">não <span class="blank _28"> </span>havia <span class="blank _28"> </span>previsão</span><span class="v0">,<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _28"> </span>na <span class="blank _1e"> </span>Constituição <span class="blank _28"> </span>norte-</span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 y9f ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">americana, <span class="blank _11"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">para<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _c"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>realização <span class="blank _c"> </span>do <span class="blank _c"> </span>co<span class="blank _0"> </span>ntrole <span class="blank _11"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>constitucionalidade<span class="blank _0"> </span></span><span class="v0">. <span class="blank _c"> </span>Mesmo </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 ya0 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">assim, <span class="blank _12"> </span>o <span class="blank _12"> </span>juiz <span class="blank _13"> </span>John <span class="blank _12"> </span>Marshall <span class="blank _12"> </span>o <span class="blank _13"> </span>fez, <span class="blank _12"> </span>consolidando <span class="blank _12"> </span>a <span class="blank _13"> </span>supremacia <span class="blank _12"> </span>da <span class="blank _12"> </span>Constituição<span class="blank _0"> </span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 ya1 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">em relação às <span class="blank _0"> </span>demais normas jur<span class="blank _0"> </span>ídicas, bem como <span class="blank _0"> </span>o poder<span class="blank _0"> </span>-dever dos <span class="blank _0"> </span>juízes de </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 ya2 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">negar a aplicação às leis contrárias ao texto constitucional. </div><div class="t m0 x6 hb ya3 ff8 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _7"></span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h18 ya4 ff5 fsb fc0 sc0 ls1">1</div><div class="t m0 x11 h19 ya5 ff5 fsc fc0 sc0 ls11 ws3"> <span class="ffc ls1">MENDES, Gil<span class="blank _0"> </span>mar Fe<span class="blank _1"></span>rreira; BRANCO,<span class="blank _0"> </span> Paulo Gustavo Gonet, COELHO, I<span class="blank _1"></span>nocênci<span class="blank _0"> </span>a Mártires. </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h19 ya6 fff fsc fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Curso de Direito<span class="blank _0"> </span> Constitucional<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffc">, 5ª edi<span class="blank _0"> </span>ção. São Paulo: Sarai<span class="blank _0"> </span>va, 2010, pp. 1057.<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ff5"> </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h18 ya7 ff5 fsb fc0 sc0 ls1">2</div><div class="t m0 x11 h19 ya8 ff5 fsc fc0 sc0 ls12 ws3"> <span class="ffc ls1">Falaremos <span class="blank _11"> </span>ma<span class="blank _0"> </span>is <span class="blank _c"> </span>à <span class="blank _11"> </span>frent<span class="blank _0"> </span>e <span class="blank _11"> </span>sobr<span class="blank _0"> </span>e <span class="blank _11"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span>control<span class="blank _0"> </span>e <span class="blank _11"> </span>di<span class="blank _0"> </span>fuso <span class="blank _11"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>constitucionali<span class="blank _0"> </span>dade. <span class="blank _11"> </span>Por <span class="blank _c"> </span>ora, <span class="blank _11"> </span>b<span class="blank _0"> </span>asta <span class="blank _c"> </span>saber<span class="blank _11"> </span> </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h19 ya9 ffc fsc fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">que <span class="blank _10"> </span>esse <span class="blank _10"> </span>é <span class="blank _17"> </span>o <span class="blank _10"> </span>control<span class="blank _0"> </span>e <span class="blank _10"> </span> <span class="blank _10"> </span>de <span class="blank _10"> </span>consti<span class="blank _0"> </span>tucionali<span class="blank _0"> </span>dade <span class="blank _1f"> </span>que<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _1f"> </span>s<span class="blank _0"> </span>e <span class="blank _10"> </span>realiza <span class="blank _10"> </span>di<span class="blank _0"> </span>ante <span class="blank _1f"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"> </span>e <span class="blank _1f"> </span>u<span class="blank _0"> </span>m <span class="blank _10"> </span>caso <span class="blank _17"> </span>concreto </div><div class="t m0 x6 h1a yaa ffc fsc fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">submetido ao Pod<span class="blank _0"> </span>er Judiciári<span class="blank _0"> </span>o.<span class="fs5"> </span></div><div class="t m0 x3 h5 y4 ff2 fs3 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="c x4 y5 w2 h6"><div class="t m0 x5 h7 y6 ff3 fs4 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws0">`Ì<span class="blank _0"> </span>i`Ê Õ<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ã<span class="blank _0"> </span>}ÊÌ<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊv<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ài<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊÛi<span class="blank _0"> </span>ÀÃ<span class="blank _0"> </span> Ê <span class="blank _0"> </span>vÊ<span class="ff4"><span class="blank _0"> </span>v<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="blank _0"> </span>ÝÊ* <span class="blank _0"> </span>Ê<span class="blank _0"> </span>`<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ì <span class="blank _0"> </span>À</span><span class="ls0 ws1">ÊÊ</span><span class="fc3 ws2">Ü Ü Ü°Vi °V </span></div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf6" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="6"><div class="pc pc6 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 y0 w1 h1" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/4cb09b61-4250-444d-ae0c-98af2d5728a1/bg6.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x0 y0 w0 h8"><div class="t m0 x6 h9 y7 ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 ha y8 ff6 fs5 fc4 sc0 ls1 ws3">Prof. Nádia Caro<span class="blank _1"></span>lina <span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="ff7 fs6 fc5">www.estrateg<span class="blank _1"></span>iaconcursos.com.b<span class="blank _1"></span>r <span class="ff5 fs5 fc4"> <span class="fc0 ws4">5</span> de <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="fc0">140 </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 hb y9 ff8 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="c x7 ya w3 hc"><div class="t m0 x2 hd yb ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls2">D<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">IREITO </span><span class="ls3">C<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">ONSTITUCIONAL </span><span class="ff9 ls4"></span><span class="fs7 ls5 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws5">PC-</span><span class="ls9 ws6">MA</span><span class="fs7 ls6 ws3"> </span><span class="ls7">-<span class="fs7 ls8 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws3">Teoria e Questões </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x7 he yc ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Prof<span class="fs8 ws7 v1">a</span><span class="ws3"> Nádia / Prof. Ricardo Vale </span></div><div class="t m0 x8 h9 yd ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y32 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Outro <span class="blank _c"> </span>marco<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _c"> </span>histórico <span class="blank _12"> </span>importante <span class="blank _c"> </span>foi <span class="blank _12"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span>surgimento <span class="blank _12"> </span>do <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">controle <span class="blank _c"> </span>concentrado<span class="blank _0"> </span></span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yab ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">de <span class="blank _11"> </span>constitucionalidade<span class="ffc fc0 ls9">, <span class="blank _c"> </span><span class="ls1">que <span class="blank _11"> </span>apareceu, <span class="blank _11"> </span>pela <span class="blank _11"> </span>primeira <span class="blank _11"> </span>vez<span class="blank _0"> </span>, <span class="blank _11"> </span>na <span class="blank _11"> </span>Constituição <span class="blank _11"> </span>da </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y59 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Áustria <span class="blank _10"> </span>(chamada <span class="blank _d"> </span><span class="ffe ws20">Oktoberverfassung</span>), <span class="blank _17"> </span>promulgada <span class="blank _17"> </span>em <span class="blank _17"> </span>1920. <span class="blank _17"> </span>A <span class="blank _17"> </span>constituição </div><div class="t m0 x6 h15 yac ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">austríaca, <span class="blank _19"> </span>inspirada <span class="blank _19"> </span>nas<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _19"> </span>propostas <span class="blank _19"> </span>de <span class="blank _19"> </span>Hans<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _19"> </span>Kelsen, <span class="blank _28"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 v0">criou <span class="blank _28"> </span>um <span class="blank _19"> </span>Tribunal </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yad ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws16">Constitucional<span class="ffc fc0 ws3 v0">, <span class="blank _16"> </span>ó<span class="blank _0"> </span>rgão <span class="blank _14"> </span>encarregado <span class="blank _16"> </span>de <span class="blank _14"> </span>exercer<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _16"> </span>o <span class="blank _14"> </span>controle <span class="blank _14"> </span>abstrato <span class="blank _14"> </span>da </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yae ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">constitucionalidade das leis. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yaf ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Ao <span class="blank _0"> </span>contrário <span class="blank _0"> </span>do <span class="blank _0"> </span>sistema <span class="blank _0"> </span>americano <span class="blank _0"> </span>(no qual <span class="blank _0"> </span>qualquer <span class="blank _0"> </span>juiz <span class="blank _0"> </span>poderia <span class="blank _0"> </span>decidir <span class="blank _0"> </span>sobre </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y5e ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">a <span class="blank _11"> </span>constitucionalidade <span class="blank _c"> </span>das <span class="blank _11"> </span>leis), <span class="blank _c"> </span>o <span class="blank _11"> </span>sis<span class="blank _0"> </span>tema <span class="blank _11"> </span>instituído <span class="blank _c"> </span>pela <span class="blank _11"> </span>Constituição <span class="blank _c"> </span>austríaca </div><div class="t m0 x6 h15 yb0 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">outorgava <span class="blank _1e"> </span>tal <span class="blank _1d"> </span>competência <span class="blank _15"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">exclusi<span class="blank _1"></span>vamente <span class="blank _1d"> </span>a <span class="blank _1e"> </span>um<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _1e"> </span>ó<span class="blank _0"> </span>rgão <span class="blank _1e"> </span>jurisdicional </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yb1 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws16">especial<span class="ffc fc0 lsc ws3 v0">. <span class="blank _1c"> </span><span class="ls1">Esse órgão <span class="ffa fc7">não ju<span class="blank _1"></span>lgaria nenhuma pretensão concreta<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffc fc0">, mas </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yb2 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">apenas <span class="blank _1e"> </span>o <span class="blank _1e"> </span>problema <span class="blank _1d"> </span>abstrato <span class="blank _1e"> </span>de <span class="blank _1e"> </span>co<span class="blank _0"> </span>mpatibilidade <span class="blank _1e"> </span>lógica <span class="blank _1e"> </span>entre <span class="blank _1d"> </span>a <span class="blank _1e"> </span>lei <span class="blank _1d"> </span>e <span class="blank _1e"> </span>a </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yb3 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Constituição. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y63 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yb4 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">2-Espécies de Inconstitucionalidade: </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yb5 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">O <span class="blank _c"> </span>controle <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>constitucional<span class="blank _0"> </span>idade <span class="blank _c"> </span>tem <span class="blank _c"> </span>como <span class="blank _c"> </span>objetivo <span class="blank _c"> </span>final <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">avaliar <span class="blank _11"> </span>se <span class="blank _c"> </span>uma <span class="blank _c"> </span>l<span class="blank _0"> </span>ei </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 yb6 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">ou <span class="blank _10"> </span>ato <span class="blank _17"> </span>normativo<span class="ffc fc0 v0"> <span class="blank _10"> </span>do <span class="blank _10"> </span>Poder <span class="blank _17"> </span>Público <span class="blank _17"> </span><span class="ffa fc7">é <span class="blank _10"> </span>ou <span class="blank _10"> </span>não <span class="blank _17"> </span>inconstitucional</span>. <span class="blank _17"> </span>Havendo </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yb7 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">desconformidade <span class="blank _29"> </span>com <span class="blank _29"> </span>a <span class="blank _29"> </span>Constituição, <span class="blank _29"> </span>a <span class="blank _2a"> </span>norma <span class="blank _29"> </span>será <span class="blank _29"> </span>con<span class="blank _0"> </span>siderad<span class="blank _1"></span>a </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yb8 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucional e, portanto, inválida. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yb9 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">A <span class="blank _13"> </span>doutrina <span class="blank _1a"> </span>busca <span class="blank _13"> </span>cl<span class="blank _0"> </span>assificar, <span class="blank _13"> </span>segundo <span class="blank _1a"> </span>diferentes <span class="blank _13"> </span>critérios, <span class="blank _13"> </span>as <span class="blank _1a"> </span>variadas <span class="blank _1a"> </span>formas </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yba ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">de manifestação de inconstitucionalidade: </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 ybb ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 ybc ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls4 ws21">a)<span class="ffc ls1 ws3"> </span><span class="fc6 lse ws22">In<span class="ls1 ws3">constitucionalidade por ação e i<span class="blank _1"></span>nconstitucionalidade po<span class="blank _0"> </span>r omissão<span class="ffc fc0 ls9">: <span class="ls1"> </span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 ybd ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Na inconstitucionalidade por <span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 ls4 ws21 v0">ação</span><span class="v0">, o <span class="blank _0"> </span>desrespeito à <span class="blank _0"> </span>Constituição resulta <span class="blank _0"> </span>de uma </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 ybe ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws3">conduta <span class="blank _c"> </span>positiva<span class="ffc fc0"> <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>um <span class="blank _c"> </span>órgão <span class="blank _c"> </span>estatal. <span class="blank _11"> </span>Exem<span class="blank _0"> </span>plo: <span class="blank _11"> </span>ed<span class="blank _0"> </span>ição <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>uma <span class="blank _11"> </span>lei <span class="blank _c"> </span>contrária </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 ybf ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">à Constituição. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h15 yc0 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Na <span class="blank _1a"> </span>inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _1f"> </span>por <span class="blank _1a"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 ws16 v0">omissão</span><span class="ls9 v0">, <span class="blank _1f"> </span><span class="ls1">por <span class="blank _1a"> </span>sua <span class="blank _1a"> </span>vez<span class="blank _0"> </span>, <span class="blank _1a"> </span>verifica-se <span class="blank _1a"> </span>a <span class="blank _1f"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 ws16">inércia</span> <span class="blank _1a"> </span>do </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yc1 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">legislador frente a um dispositivo constitucional carente de <span class="blank _0"> </span>regulamentação por </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yc2 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">lei. Ocorr<span class="blank _0"> </span>e <span class="blank _27"> </span>quando <span class="blank _27"> </span>o <span class="blank _27"> </span>legislador permanece <span class="blank _27"> </span>o<span class="blank _0"> </span>misso <span class="blank _27"> </span>diante de <span class="blank _27"> </span>uma <span class="blank _27"> </span>norma </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yc3 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">constitucional <span class="blank _11"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>eficácia <span class="blank _11"> </span>limitada, <span class="blank _11"> </span>obst<span class="blank _0"> </span>ando <span class="blank _11"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span>exercício <span class="blank _11"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>direito. <span class="blank _c"> </span>Exemplo: <span class="blank _11"> </span>o </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yc4 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">art. 37, <span class="blank _0"> </span>VII, <span class="blank _0"> </span>CF/88 <span class="blank _0"> </span>exige <span class="blank _0"> </span>que seja <span class="blank _0"> </span>editada <span class="blank _0"> </span>lei <span class="blank _0"> </span>dispondo sobr<span class="blank _0"> </span>e o<span class="blank _0"> </span> direito <span class="blank _0"> </span>de <span class="blank _0"> </span>greve </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yc5 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">dos <span class="blank _1f"> </span>servidores <span class="blank _10"> </span>públicos. <span class="blank _1f"> </span>Como <span class="blank _10"> </span>até <span class="blank _1f"> </span>hoje <span class="blank _10"> </span>essa <span class="blank _1f"> </span>lei <span class="blank _10"> </span>não <span class="blank _1f"> </span>foi <span class="blank _10"> </span>elaborada, <span class="blank _1f"> </span>estamos </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yc6 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">diante de uma inconstitucionalidade por omissão. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yc7 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yc8 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls15 ws23">b)<span class="ffc ls13 ws3"> <span class="ffa fc6 ls1 v0">Inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _1b"> </span>ma<span class="blank _0"> </span>terial <span class="blank _1b"> </span>x <span class="blank _19"> </span>I<span class="blank _0"> </span>nconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _1b"> </span>for<span class="blank _0"> </span>mal</span><span class="ls14 v0"> <span class="ffa fc6 ls16">x </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yc9 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">Vício de decoro: </div><div class="t m0 x3 h5 y4 ff2 fs3 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="c x4 y5 w2 h6"><div class="t m0 x5 h7 y6 ff3 fs4 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws0">`Ì<span class="blank _0"> </span>i`Ê Õ<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ã<span class="blank _0"> </span>}ÊÌ<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊv<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ài<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊÛi<span class="blank _0"> </span>ÀÃ<span class="blank _0"> </span> Ê <span class="blank _0"> </span>vÊ<span class="ff4"><span class="blank _0"> </span>v<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="blank _0"> </span>ÝÊ* <span class="blank _0"> </span>Ê<span class="blank _0"> </span>`<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ì <span class="blank _0"> </span>À</span><span class="ls0 ws1">ÊÊ</span><span class="fc3 ws2">Ü Ü Ü°Vi °V </span></div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf7" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="7"><div class="pc pc7 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 y0 w1 h1" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/4cb09b61-4250-444d-ae0c-98af2d5728a1/bg7.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x0 y0 w0 h8"><div class="t m0 x6 h9 y7 ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 ha y8 ff6 fs5 fc4 sc0 ls1 ws3">Prof. Nádia Caro<span class="blank _1"></span>lina <span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="ff7 fs6 fc5">www.estrateg<span class="blank _1"></span>iaconcursos.com.b<span class="blank _1"></span>r <span class="ff5 fs5 fc4"> <span class="fc0 ws4">6</span> de <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="fc0">140 </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 hb y9 ff8 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="c x7 ya w3 hc"><div class="t m0 x2 hd yb ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls2">D<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">IREITO </span><span class="ls3">C<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">ONSTITUCIONAL </span><span class="ff9 ls4"></span><span class="fs7 ls5 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws5">PC-</span><span class="ls9 ws6">MA</span><span class="fs7 ls6 ws3"> </span><span class="ls7">-<span class="fs7 ls8 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws3">Teoria e Questões </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x7 he yc ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Prof<span class="fs8 ws7 v1">a</span><span class="ws3"> Nádia / Prof. Ricardo Vale </span></div><div class="t m0 x8 h9 yd ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y32 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">A <span class="blank _21"> </span>inconsti<span class="blank _1"></span>tucionalidade <span class="blank _21"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 ws16">material</span> <span class="blank _21"> </span>(ou <span class="blank _21"> </span>nomoestát<span class="blank _1"></span>ica)<span class="ffa ls17"> </span>ocorre <span class="blank _21"> </span>quando <span class="blank _21"> </span>o </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yab ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws3">conteúdo <span class="blank _1a"> </span>da <span class="blank _1f"> </span>lei <span class="blank _13"> </span>c<span class="blank _0"> </span>ontraria <span class="blank _1f"> </span>a <span class="blank _1a"> </span>Constituição<span class="ffc fc0 ls9">. <span class="blank _1f"> </span><span class="ls1">Seria <span class="blank _1a"> </span>o <span class="blank _1f"> </span>caso, <span class="blank _1a"> </span>por <span class="blank _1f"> </span>exemplo, <span class="blank _1a"> </span>de </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y59 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">uma <span class="blank _18"> </span>lei <span class="blank _18"> </span>q<span class="blank _0"> </span>ue <span class="blank _18"> </span>estabe<span class="blank _0"> </span>leça <span class="blank _18"> </span>que <span class="blank _1c"> </span>a <span class="blank _18"> </span>autoridade <span class="blank _1c"> </span>policial <span class="blank _18"> </span>poderá, <span class="blank _18"> </span>mediante <span class="blank _1c"> </span>ordem </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yac ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">judicial, <span class="blank _10"> </span>ingressar <span class="blank _d"> </span>na <span class="blank _10"> </span>casa <span class="blank _17"> </span>de <span class="blank _d"> </span>uma <span class="blank _10"> </span>pessoa <span class="blank _17"> </span>durante <span class="blank _17"> </span>o <span class="blank _17"> </span>pe<span class="blank _0"> </span>ríodo <span class="blank _10"> </span>noturno. <span class="blank _17"> </span>Ora, </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yca ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">sabemos <span class="blank _13"> </span>que <span class="blank _1a"> </span>a <span class="blank _1a"> </span>C<span class="blank _0"> </span>F/88 <span class="blank _1a"> </span>prevê <span class="blank _1a"> </span>que, <span class="blank _13"> </span>mesmo <span class="blank _1a"> </span>com <span class="blank _1a"> </span>ordem <span class="blank _1a"> </span>judicial, <span class="blank _13"> </span>o <span class="blank _1f"> </span>ingresso <span class="blank _13"> </span>na<span class="blank _0"> </span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yae ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">casa de uma pessoa sem o seu consentimento deve ocorrer durant<span class="blank _1"></span>e o dia. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yaf ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Assim, <span class="blank _1e"> </span>a <span class="blank _1e"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">l<span class="blank _0"> </span>ei <span class="blank _1e"> </span>será <span class="blank _1d"> </span>considerada <span class="blank _1e"> </span>inválida<span class="blank _0"> </span></span> <span class="blank _1e"> </span>mesmo <span class="blank _1d"> </span>que <span class="blank _1d"> </span>tenha <span class="blank _1e"> </span>obedecido </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y5e ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">fielmente <span class="blank _12"> </span>ao <span class="blank _12"> </span>processo <span class="blank _13"> </span>legislativo <span class="blank _12"> </span>preconizado <span class="blank _12"> </span>pela <span class="blank _12"> </span>Carta <span class="blank _12"> </span>Magna.<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="lsd">O <span class="blank _13"> </span></span><span class="ffa fc6 ws16 v0">conteúdo</span><span class="v0"> </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y5f ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">da <span class="blank _1f"> </span>lei <span class="blank _10"> </span>é, <span class="blank _1f"> </span>af<span class="blank _0"> </span>inal, <span class="blank _1f"> </span>contrário <span class="blank _10"> </span>à <span class="blank _1f"> </span>Const<span class="blank _0"> </span>ituição. <span class="blank _10"> </span>Cabe <span class="blank _10"> </span>destacar <span class="blank _1f"> </span>que <span class="blank _10"> </span>a <span class="blank _10"> </span>denominação </div><div class="t m0 x6 h15 ycb ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">nomoestática <span class="blank _c"> </span>se <span class="blank _c"> </span>dá<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _c"> </span>em <span class="blank _c"> </span>função <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span>vício <span class="blank _c"> </span>material <span class="blank _12"> </span>se <span class="blank _c"> </span>referir <span class="blank _c"> </span>à <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">substância <span class="blank _c"> </span>da </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yb2 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws16">norma<span class="ffc fc0 ws3 v0">, tendo caráter estático. </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 y62 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">A <span class="blank _1f"> </span>inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _10"> </span>material <span class="blank _10"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 v0">não <span class="blank _10"> </span>fica <span class="blank _10"> </span>caracterizad<span class="blank _0"> </span>a</span><span class="v0"> <span class="blank _1f"> </span>apenas<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _1f"> </span>se <span class="blank _10"> </span>fazendo </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y63 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">um <span class="blank _24"> </span>contraste <span class="blank _26"> </span>entre <span class="blank _26"> </span>a <span class="blank _24"> </span>lei <span class="blank _26"> </span>e <span class="blank _26"> </span>o <span class="blank _24"> </span>texto <span class="blank _26"> </span>constitucional. <span class="blank _24"> </span>Também <span class="blank _24"> </span>haverá </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 ycc ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _20"> </span>material<span class="ffc fc0"> <span class="blank _20"> </span>em <span class="blank _20"> </span>virtude <span class="blank _20"> </span>da <span class="blank _20"> </span>aferiç<span class="blank _0"> </span>ão <span class="blank _20"> </span>do <span class="blank _20"> </span></span><span class="fc7">excesso <span class="blank _20"> </span>do </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 ycd ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws3">poder <span class="blank _12"> </span>legislativo<span class="ffc fc0 lsc v0">. <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ls1">O <span class="blank _13"> </span>excesso <span class="blank _12"> </span>de <span class="blank _13"> </span>poder <span class="blank _12"> </span>legislativo <span class="blank _12"> </span>ocorre<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _12"> </span>quando <span class="blank _12"> </span>a<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _12"> </span>lei <span class="blank _13"> </span>não <span class="blank _12"> </span>é </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yce ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">compatível com <span class="blank _0"> </span>os <span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">fins constitucion<span class="blank _0"> </span>almente pr<span class="blank _0"> </span>evistos</span><span class="v0"> (desvio <span class="blank _0"> </span>de <span class="blank _0"> </span>poder) ou </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y3e ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">quando <span class="blank _1c"> </span>há <span class="ffa fc6 v0">violação ao princípio da proporcionalidade</span><span class="v0">, em <span class="blank _1c"> </span>suas duas </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y3f ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">vertentes: proibição de excesso e proibição de proteção defi<span class="blank _1"></span>ciente. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 ycf ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">A inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 ws16">formal</span><span class="ffa ls18"> </span>(ou nomodinâmica), <span class="blank _0"> </span>por s<span class="blank _0"> </span>ua vez, caracteriz<span class="blank _0"> </span>a-se </div><div class="t m0 x6 h14 yd0 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws20">pel<span class="lsd ws3">o <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 ls1 v0">desrespeito <span class="blank _12"> </span>ao <span class="blank _12"> </span>processo <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>elabora<span class="blank _0"> </span>ção <span class="blank _c"> </span>da<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _12"> </span>norma<span class="ffc fc0">, <span class="blank _12"> </span>preconizado <span class="blank _12"> </span>pela </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y42 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Constituição. <span class="blank _13"> </span>Como <span class="blank _1a"> </span>exemplo, <span class="blank _13"> </span>citamos <span class="blank _1a"> </span>a <span class="blank _1a"> </span>edição <span class="blank _13"> </span>de <span class="blank _1a"> </span>lei <span class="blank _13"> </span>proposta <span class="blank _13"> </span>por <span class="blank _1a"> </span>Deputado<span class="blank _0"> </span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yd1 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Federal, <span class="blank _1b"> </span>mas <span class="blank _1b"> </span>cuja <span class="blank _1b"> </span>iniciativa <span class="blank _1b"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"> </span>ra <span class="blank _1b"> </span>privativa <span class="blank _1b"> </span>do <span class="blank _1b"> </span>Presidente <span class="blank _1b"> </span>da <span class="blank _19"> </span>República. <span class="blank _19"> </span><span class="ls9">A </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yd2 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">denominação <span class="blank _1f"> </span>nomodinâmica <span class="blank _1f"> </span>se <span class="blank _10"> </span>dá <span class="blank _1f"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"> </span>m <span class="blank _1f"> </span>função <span class="blank _1f"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"> </span>e <span class="blank _10"> </span>o <span class="blank _1f"> </span>vício <span class="blank _1f"> </span>for<span class="blank _0"> </span>mal<span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="blank _1f"> </span>decorrer <span class="blank _10"> </span>da </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yd3 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">violação <span class="blank _28"> </span>ao <span class="blank _28"> </span>pr<span class="blank _0"> </span>oce<span class="blank _1"></span>sso <span class="blank _19"> </span>l<span class="blank _0"> </span>egislativo<span class="ffc fc0">, <span class="blank _28"> </span>o <span class="blank _1e"> </span>que <span class="blank _28"> </span>traz, <span class="blank _28"> </span>consigo, <span class="blank _28"> </span>uma <span class="blank _28"> </span>ideia <span class="blank _1e"> </span>de </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yd4 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">dinamismo, movimento. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yd5 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws3">A <span class="ls1">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _0"> </span>formal poderá <span class="blank _0"> </span>ser de <span class="ffa fc6">t<span class="blank _0"> </span>rês tipos</span></span>: <span class="ffa lsf ws1e">i)</span><span class="ls1"> <span class="blank _0"> </span>orgânica; <span class="ffa lsf ws1e">ii)</span> forma<span class="blank _0"> </span>l </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yd6 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">propriamente dita ou; <span class="ffa ws16">iii)</span> formal por violação a pressupostos objetivos do ato. </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 yd7 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">1)<span class="ffc ls19 ws3"> <span class="ffa fc6 ls1">Inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _2b"> </span>formal <span class="blank _2b"> </span>orgânica<span class="blank _0"> </span></span><span class="ls1">: <span class="blank _2b"> </span>decorre <span class="blank _2b"> </span>da </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 yd8 ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws3">inobservância <span class="blank _12"> </span>da <span class="blank _c"> </span>competência <span class="blank _12"> </span>legislativa<span class="ffc fc0"> <span class="blank _12"> </span>para <span class="blank _12"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>elaboração <span class="blank _12"> </span>do <span class="blank _12"> </span>at<span class="blank _1"></span>o. </span></div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 yd9 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Exemplo: <span class="blank _1a"> </span>lei <span class="blank _1a"> </span>munic<span class="blank _0"> </span>ipal <span class="blank _1a"> </span>que <span class="blank _1f"> </span>trata <span class="blank _1a"> </span>de <span class="blank _1f"> </span>direito <span class="blank _1a"> </span>penal <span class="blank _1a"> </span>será <span class="blank _1f"> </span>inconstitucional, </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 yda ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">por <span class="blank _18"> </span>ser<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _18"> </span>essa <span class="blank _1c"> </span>matéria <span class="blank _18"> </span>de <span class="blank _1c"> </span>competência <span class="blank _1c"> </span>privativa <span class="blank _18"> </span>da <span class="blank _18"> </span>Uniã<span class="blank _0"> </span>o <span class="blank _18"> </span>(art. <span class="blank _18"> </span>22, <span class="blank _1c"> </span>I, </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 ydb ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">CF/88). </div><div class="t m0 x12 h15 ydc ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 lsa wsb">2)<span class="ffc ls1a ws3"> <span class="ffa fc6 ls1 v0">Inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _1b"> </span>for<span class="blank _0"> </span>mal <span class="blank _1b"> </span>propr<span class="blank _0"> </span>iamente <span class="blank _1b"> </span>dita<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffc fc0">: <span class="blank _1b"> </span>decorre<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _1b"> </span>da </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 ydd ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws3">inobservância <span class="blank _13"> </span>do <span class="blank _13"> </span>pro<span class="blank _0"> </span>cesso <span class="blank _13"> </span>legislativo<span class="ffc fc0">, <span class="blank _1a"> </span>seja <span class="blank _13"> </span>na <span class="blank _13"> </span>f<span class="blank _0"> </span>ase <span class="blank _13"> </span>de <span class="blank _1a"> </span>iniciativa <span class="blank _13"> </span>ou </span></div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 yde ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">nas demais. </div><div class="t m0 x12 h15 ydf ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Se <span class="blank _18"> </span>o <span class="blank _1c"> </span>vício <span class="blank _18"> </span>ocorrer <span class="blank _1c"> </span>na <span class="blank _18"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">fase <span class="blank _1c"> </span>de <span class="blank _18"> </span>iniciativa<span class="blank _0"> </span></span><span class="v0">, <span class="blank _18"> </span>ter-<span class="lsa ws24">se</span>-á <span class="blank _1c"> </span>o <span class="blank _18"> </span>chamado <span class="blank _18"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">vício </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 ye0 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">formal <span class="blank _12"> </span>subjetivo<span class="ffc fc0 v0">. <span class="blank _13"> </span>É <span class="blank _12"> </span>o <span class="blank _12"> </span>caso, <span class="blank _13"> </span>por <span class="blank _12"> </span>exemplo, <span class="blank _12"> </span>de <span class="blank _13"> </span>iniciativa <span class="blank _12"> </span>parlamentar <span class="blank _13"> </span>de </span></div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 ye1 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">projeto <span class="blank _27"> </span>de <span class="blank _27"> </span>lei <span class="blank _27"> </span>que <span class="blank _27"> </span>modifique <span class="blank _27"> </span>os <span class="blank _27"> </span>efetivos <span class="blank _27"> </span>das <span class="blank _27"> </span>Forças <span class="blank _27"> </span>Armadas. <span class="blank _27"> </span>Essa </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 ye2 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">competência <span class="blank _12"> </span>é <span class="blank _12"> </span>exc<span class="blank _0"> </span>lusiva <span class="blank _12"> </span>(reservada) <span class="blank _12"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"> </span>o <span class="blank _12"> </span>Presidente <span class="blank _12"> </span>da<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _12"> </span>República, <span class="blank _12"> </span>sendo </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 ye3 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">este <span class="blank _12"> </span>o <span class="blank _12"> </span>ún<span class="blank _1"></span>ico <span class="blank _12"> </span>que <span class="blank _c"> </span>pode<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _12"> </span>inici<span class="blank _1"></span>ar <span class="blank _12"> </span>processo <span class="blank _12"> </span>legi<span class="blank _1"></span>slativo <span class="blank _12"> </span>sobre <span class="blank _c"> </span>a<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _12"> </span>matéria. <span class="blank _c"> </span>Caso </div><div class="t m0 x3 h5 y4 ff2 fs3 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="c x4 y5 w2 h6"><div class="t m0 x5 h7 y6 ff3 fs4 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws0">`Ì<span class="blank _0"> </span>i`Ê Õ<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ã<span class="blank _0"> </span>}ÊÌ<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊv<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ài<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊÛi<span class="blank _0"> </span>ÀÃ<span class="blank _0"> </span> Ê <span class="blank _0"> </span>vÊ<span class="ff4"><span class="blank _0"> </span>v<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="blank _0"> </span>ÝÊ* <span class="blank _0"> </span>Ê<span class="blank _0"> </span>`<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ì <span class="blank _0"> </span>À</span><span class="ls0 ws1">ÊÊ</span><span class="fc3 ws2">Ü Ü Ü°Vi °V </span></div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf8" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="8"><div class="pc pc8 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 y0 w1 h1" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/4cb09b61-4250-444d-ae0c-98af2d5728a1/bg8.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x0 y0 w0 h8"><div class="t m0 x6 h9 y7 ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 ha y8 ff6 fs5 fc4 sc0 ls1 ws3">Prof. Nádia Caro<span class="blank _1"></span>lina <span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="ff7 fs6 fc5">www.estrateg<span class="blank _1"></span>iaconcursos.com.b<span class="blank _1"></span>r <span class="ff5 fs5 fc4"> <span class="fc0 ws4">7</span> de <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="fc0">140 </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 hb y9 ff8 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="c x7 ya w3 hc"><div class="t m0 x2 hd yb ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls2">D<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">IREITO </span><span class="ls3">C<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">ONSTITUCIONAL </span><span class="ff9 ls4"></span><span class="fs7 ls5 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws5">PC-</span><span class="ls9 ws6">MA</span><span class="fs7 ls6 ws3"> </span><span class="ls7">-<span class="fs7 ls8 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws3">Teoria e Questões </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x7 he yc ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Prof<span class="fs8 ws7 v1">a</span><span class="ws3"> Nádia / Prof. Ricardo Vale </span></div><div class="t m0 x8 h9 yd ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 y32 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">contrário, <span class="blank _1c"> </span>o <span class="blank _1c"> </span>projeto sofrerá d<span class="blank _1"></span>e <span class="blank _1c"> </span>vício <span class="blank _1c"> </span>formal su<span class="blank _1"></span>bjetivo, i<span class="blank _1"></span>nsanável <span class="blank _1c"> </span>pela </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 y58 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">sanção do Presidente da República. </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 ye4 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Por <span class="blank _10"> </span>outro <span class="blank _17"> </span>lado, <span class="blank _10"> </span>caso <span class="blank _17"> </span>esse <span class="blank _10"> </span>vício <span class="blank _17"> </span>se <span class="blank _10"> </span>dê <span class="blank _17"> </span>nas <span class="blank _17"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">demais <span class="blank _10"> </span>fases</span> <span class="blank _17"> </span>do <span class="blank _17"> </span>processo </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 ye5 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">legislativo, <span class="blank _11"> </span>ter-<span class="lsa ws24">se</span>-á<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _11"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">vício <span class="blank _c"> </span>formal <span class="blank _11"> </span>objetivo</span><span class="v0">. <span class="blank _11"> </span>É <span class="blank _c"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span>caso, <span class="blank _11"> </span>por <span class="blank _c"> </span>exemplo, <span class="blank _11"> </span>de </span></div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 ye6 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">não <span class="blank _10"> </span>obediência <span class="blank _10"> </span>ao <span class="blank _d"> </span>quórum <span class="blank _10"> </span>de <span class="blank _10"> </span>vo<span class="blank _0"> </span>tação <span class="blank _10"> </span>de <span class="blank _17"> </span>emenda <span class="blank _10"> </span>constitucional <span class="blank _10"> </span>(três </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 ye7 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">quintos, em <span class="blank _20"> </span>dois <span class="blank _27"> </span>turnos, e<span class="blank _0"> </span>m c<span class="blank _0"> </span>ada <span class="blank _27"> </span>Casa <span class="blank _27"> </span>Legislativa<span class="blank _0"> </span>). <span class="blank _27"> </span>Nesse <span class="blank _27"> </span>caso, a<span class="blank _0"> </span> </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 ye8 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">emenda votada padecerá de vício formal objetivo. </div><div class="t m0 x12 h15 ye9 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">3) <span class="blank _15"> </span><span class="fc6 v0">Inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _15"> </span>formal <span class="blank _15"> </span>por <span class="blank _16"> </span>violação <span class="blank _15"> </span>a <span class="blank _15"> </span>pressupostos<span class="ffc"> </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 yea ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">objetivos <span class="blank _2c"> </span>do <span class="blank _2c"> </span>ato <span class="blank _2c"> </span>normativo<span class="ffc fc0 ls9 v0">: <span class="blank _2d"> </span><span class="ls1">decorre <span class="blank _2c"> </span>da <span class="blank _2c"> </span><span class="ffa fc7">inobservância <span class="blank _2c"> </span>de </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 yeb ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws3">pressupostos <span class="blank _1d"> </span>essenciais<span class="ffc fc0 v0"> <span class="blank _1d"> </span>para <span class="blank _1d"> </span>a <span class="blank _1d"> </span>edição <span class="blank _1d"> </span>de <span class="blank _1d"> </span>atos <span class="blank _15"> </span>legisl<span class="blank _1"></span>ativos. <span class="blank _1e"> </span>Por<span class="blank _0"> </span> </span></div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 y61 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">exemplo, <span class="blank _c"> </span>as <span class="blank _c"> </span>medidas <span class="blank _12"> </span>provisórias, <span class="blank _c"> </span>para <span class="blank _c"> </span>sere<span class="blank _0"> </span>m <span class="blank _c"> </span>editadas, <span class="blank _c"> </span>deverão <span class="blank _c"> </span>atender </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 y62 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">aos <span class="blank _12"> </span>requisit<span class="blank _1"></span>os <span class="blank _12"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>urgência <span class="blank _12"> </span>e <span class="blank _c"> </span>re<span class="blank _0"> </span>levância <span class="blank _c"> </span>(art. <span class="blank _12"> </span>62, <span class="blank _12"> </span>caput, <span class="blank _c"> </span>C<span class="blank _0"> </span>F). <span class="blank _12"> </span>Caso <span class="blank _c"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"> </span>sses </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 y63 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">requisitos <span class="blank _12"> </span>não <span class="blank _12"> </span>seja<span class="blank _0"> </span>m <span class="blank _12"> </span>atendidos, <span class="blank _12"> </span>haverá <span class="blank _13"> </span>inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _12"> </span>formal <span class="blank _12"> </span>por </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 y64 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">violação a pressupostos objetivos do ato normativo. </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 yec ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Outro exemplo que<span class="blank _0"> </span> podemos apontar <span class="blank _0"> </span>diz re<span class="blank _0"> </span>speito à criação de <span class="blank _0"> </span>municípios </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 yed ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">por <span class="blank _11"> </span>lei <span class="blank _0"> </span>estadual. <span class="blank _11"> </span>Há <span class="blank _11"> </span>alguns <span class="blank _11"> </span>requisitos <span class="blank _0"> </span>p<span class="blank _0"> </span>ara <span class="blank _0"> </span>isso <span class="blank _11"> </span>(art. <span class="blank _11"> </span>18, <span class="blank _c"> </span>§ <span class="blank _11"> </span>4º), <span class="blank _11"> </span>dentre <span class="blank _11"> </span>os </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 yee ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">quais <span class="blank _c"> </span>a <span class="blank _12"> </span>realização <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>um <span class="blank _c"> </span>plebiscito <span class="blank _c"> </span>com <span class="blank _12"> </span>as <span class="blank _c"> </span>populações <span class="blank _c"> </span>en<span class="blank _0"> </span>volvidas. <span class="blank _c"> </span>Caso </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 yef ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">a lei e<span class="blank _0"> </span>stadual crie um <span class="blank _0"> </span>Município sem a<span class="blank _0"> </span> re<span class="blank _0"> </span>alização prévia de um <span class="blank _0"> </span>plebiscito, </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 yf0 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">estaremos <span class="blank _d"> </span>novamente <span class="blank _d"> </span>diante <span class="blank _18"> </span>de <span class="blank _d"> </span>uma <span class="blank _18"> </span>inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _d"> </span>formal <span class="blank _d"> </span>por </div><div class="t m0 x12 h11 yf1 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">violação a pressupostos objetivos do ato normativo. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yf2 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">O <span class="blank _1f"> </span>Prof. <span class="blank _1a"> </span>Pedro <span class="blank _1f"> </span>Lenza <span class="blank _1a"> </span>defende, <span class="blank _1f"> </span>ainda, <span class="blank _1a"> </span>a <span class="blank _1f"> </span>tese <span class="blank _1f"> </span>da <span class="blank _10"> </span>inconstitu<span class="blank _1"></span>cionalidade <span class="blank _1a"> </span>de <span class="blank _1f"> </span>uma </div><div class="t m0 x6 h15 yf3 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">norma <span class="blank _d"> </span>em <span class="blank _d"> </span>razão <span class="blank _d"> </span>de <span class="blank _d"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">vício <span class="blank _d"> </span>de <span class="blank _d"> </span>decoro <span class="blank _d"> </span>parlamentar<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="lsa">. <span class="blank _d"> </span></span></span><span class="v0">Não <span class="blank _d"> </span>se <span class="blank _d"> </span>trata <span class="blank _d"> </span>de <span class="blank _d"> </span>uma </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yf4 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _2e"> </span>formal <span class="blank _2e"> </span>ou <span class="blank _2e"> </span>material, <span class="blank _2e"> </span>mas <span class="blank _2e"> </span>sim <span class="blank _2e"> </span>de <span class="blank _2e"> </span>uma </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yf5 ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _c"> </span>por <span class="blank _c"> </span>vício <span class="blank _11"> </span>na <span class="blank _c"> </span>formação <span class="blank _c"> </span>da <span class="blank _c"> </span>vontade<span class="ffc fc0"> <span class="blank _c"> </span>do <span class="blank _c"> </span>parlamentar, </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yf6 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">que votou em determinad<span class="blank _1"></span>o sentido em tro<span class="blank _0"> </span>ca do recebimento de propin<span class="blank _1"></span>a. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yf7 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Essa <span class="blank _11"> </span>tese <span class="blank _11"> </span>foi <span class="blank _11"> </span>desenvolvida <span class="blank _11"> </span>em <span class="blank _11"> </span>raz<span class="blank _0"> </span>ão <span class="blank _11"> </span>do <span class="blank _11"> </span>esquema <span class="blank _11"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>compra<span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="blank _11"> </span>de <span class="blank _11"> </span>votos <span class="blank _c"> </span>apurado </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yf8 ffd fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">pelo <span class="blank _11"> </span>STF <span class="blank _c"> </span>na <span class="blank _c"> </span>Ação <span class="blank _11"> </span>P<span class="blank _0"> </span>enal <span class="blank _11"> </span>nº <span class="blank _c"> </span>470 <span class="blank _c"> </span>(que <span class="blank _11"> </span>tratou <span class="blank _c"> </span>do <span class="blank _11"> </span>“Mensa<span class="blank _0"> </span>lão”) <span class="blank _11"> </span>e <span class="blank _c"> </span>tem <span class="blank _c"> </span>fundamento </div><div class="t m0 x6 h15 yf9 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">no <span class="blank _17"> </span>art. <span class="blank _d"> </span>55, <span class="blank _17"> </span>§ <span class="blank _17"> </span>1<span class="blank _0"> </span>º, <span class="blank _17"> </span>CF/88, <span class="blank _17"> </span>que<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _17"> </span>dispõe <span class="blank _d"> </span>que <span class="blank _d"> </span><span class="ffd ls1b">“</span><span class="fff fc6 v0">é <span class="blank _17"> </span>incompatível <span class="blank _17"> </span>com <span class="blank _d"> </span>o <span class="blank _17"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"> </span>ecoro </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yfa fff fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws16">parlamentar<span class="ffe fc0 ws3 v0">, <span class="blank _1a"> </span>além <span class="blank _13"> </span>dos <span class="blank _1a"> </span>casos <span class="blank _1a"> </span>definidos <span class="blank _1a"> </span>no <span class="blank _1a"> </span>regimento <span class="blank _1a"> </span>interno, <span class="blank _13"> </span>o <span class="blank _1f"> </span><span class="fff fc6">abuso <span class="blank _1a"> </span>das </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 yd9 fff fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws16">prerrogativas<span class="ffe fc0 ws3 v0"> asseguradas a membro do Congresso Nacional ou a <span class="fff fc6">percepção </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yfb fff fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">de vantagens indevidas<span class="ffd fc0 v0">”. <span class="ffc"> </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yfc ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yfd ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls4 ws21">c)<span class="fc6 ls1 ws3 v0"> Inconstitucionalidade Total e Parcial: </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yfe ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws3">A <span class="blank _c"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 ls1">inconstitucional<span class="blank _0"> </span>idade <span class="blank _c"> </span>total</span><span class="ls1"> <span class="blank _12"> </span>fica <span class="blank _c"> </span>caracterizada <span class="blank _c"> </span>quando <span class="blank _12"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span>ato <span class="blank _c"> </span>normativo <span class="blank _c"> </span>for </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 y79 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">considerado, <span class="ffa fc7 v0">e<span class="blank _1"></span>m sua <span class="blank _1c"> </span>totalidade<span class="ffc fc0">, in<span class="blank _1"></span>compatível <span class="blank _1c"> </span>com a C<span class="blank _1"></span>onstituição. <span class="blank _1c"> </span>Nesse </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yff ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">caso, <span class="blank _c"> </span>todo <span class="blank _12"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span>conteúdo <span class="blank _12"> </span>da <span class="blank _c"> </span>norma <span class="blank _c"> </span>padec<span class="blank _0"> </span>erá <span class="blank _12"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>vício. <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ls9">A <span class="blank _c"> </span></span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">inco<span class="blank _0"> </span>nstitucionalidade </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y100 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws16">parcial<span class="ffc fc0 ws3 v0">, <span class="blank _10"> </span>por <span class="blank _10"> </span>sua <span class="blank _10"> </span>vez, <span class="blank _10"> </span>ocorrerá <span class="blank _10"> </span>quando <span class="blank _10"> </span><span class="ffa fc7">apenas <span class="blank _10"> </span>parte</span> <span class="blank _10"> </span>do <span class="blank _10"> </span>ato <span class="blank _10"> </span>normativo <span class="blank _10"> </span>for </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y101 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">considerada inválida. </div><div class="t m0 x3 h5 y4 ff2 fs3 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="c x4 y5 w2 h6"><div class="t m0 x5 h7 y6 ff3 fs4 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws0">`Ì<span class="blank _0"> </span>i`Ê Õ<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ã<span class="blank _0"> </span>}ÊÌ<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊv<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ài<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊÛi<span class="blank _0"> </span>ÀÃ<span class="blank _0"> </span> Ê <span class="blank _0"> </span>vÊ<span class="ff4"><span class="blank _0"> </span>v<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="blank _0"> </span>ÝÊ* <span class="blank _0"> </span>Ê<span class="blank _0"> </span>`<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ì <span class="blank _0"> </span>À</span><span class="ls0 ws1">ÊÊ</span><span class="fc3 ws2">Ü Ü Ü°Vi °V </span></div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf9" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="9"><div class="pc pc9 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 y0 w1 h1" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/4cb09b61-4250-444d-ae0c-98af2d5728a1/bg9.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x0 y0 w0 h8"><div class="t m0 x6 h9 y7 ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 ha y8 ff6 fs5 fc4 sc0 ls1 ws3">Prof. Nádia Caro<span class="blank _1"></span>lina <span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="ff7 fs6 fc5">www.estrateg<span class="blank _1"></span>iaconcursos.com.b<span class="blank _1"></span>r <span class="ff5 fs5 fc4"> <span class="fc0 ws4">8</span> de <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="fc0">140 </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 hb y9 ff8 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="c x7 ya w3 hc"><div class="t m0 x2 hd yb ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls2">D<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">IREITO </span><span class="ls3">C<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">ONSTITUCIONAL </span><span class="ff9 ls4"></span><span class="fs7 ls5 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws5">PC-</span><span class="ls9 ws6">MA</span><span class="fs7 ls6 ws3"> </span><span class="ls7">-<span class="fs7 ls8 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws3">Teoria e Questões </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x7 he yc ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Prof<span class="fs8 ws7 v1">a</span><span class="ws3"> Nádia / Prof. Ricardo Vale </span></div><div class="t m0 x8 h9 yd ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y32 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Em regra, um <span class="ffa fc6">vício formal gera <span class="blank _27"> </span>a inconstitucionalidade total<span class="blank _0"> </span></span> do ato </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y58 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">normativo. <span class="blank _13"> </span>Or<span class="blank _0"> </span>a, <span class="blank _13"> </span>se<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _13"> </span>houve <span class="blank _1a"> </span>o <span class="blank _1f"> </span>desrespeito <span class="blank _13"> </span>ao <span class="blank _1a"> </span>pro<span class="blank _0"> </span>cesso <span class="blank _13"> </span>leg<span class="blank _0"> </span>islativo <span class="blank _13"> </span>ou <span class="blank _1a"> </span>mesmo <span class="blank _1f"> </span>à </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y102 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">repartição <span class="blank _0"> </span>de <span class="blank _11"> </span>competências, <span class="blank _0"> </span>o <span class="blank _11"> </span>ato <span class="blank _0"> </span>norma<span class="blank _0"> </span>tivo <span class="blank _0"> </span>restará <span class="blank _11"> </span>int<span class="blank _1"></span>eiramente <span class="blank _0"> </span>pre<span class="blank _0"> </span>judicado. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y103 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">A doutrina <span class="blank _0"> </span>considera, todav<span class="blank _0"> </span>ia, que <span class="blank _0"> </span>existe a <span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 ws16 v0">po<span class="blank _0"> </span>ssibilidade</span><span class="v0"> (excepcional) <span class="blank _0"> </span>de um </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yca ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">vício <span class="blank _e"> </span>formal <span class="blank _e"> </span>acarretar <span class="blank _14"> </span>a <span class="blank _f"> </span>inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _14"> </span>parcial<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffc fc0"> <span class="blank _e"> </span>de <span class="blank _e"> </span>um <span class="blank _e"> </span>ato </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yae ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">normativo. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yaf ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Suponha, <span class="blank _0"> </span>por <span class="blank _0"> </span>exemplo, <span class="blank _0"> </span>que <span class="blank _11"> </span>seja <span class="blank _0"> </span>ed<span class="blank _0"> </span>itada <span class="blank _0"> </span>uma <span class="blank _0"> </span>lei <span class="blank _0"> </span>o<span class="blank _0"> </span>rdinária <span class="blank _11"> </span>tratando <span class="blank _0"> </span>de <span class="blank _0"> </span>ma<span class="blank _0"> </span>téria </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y5e ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">típica <span class="blank _d"> </span>de <span class="blank _17"> </span>lei <span class="blank _d"> </span>ordinária, <span class="blank _d"> </span>mas <span class="blank _d"> </span>que, <span class="blank _17"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"> </span>m <span class="blank _d"> </span>um <span class="blank _17"> </span>de <span class="blank _d"> </span>seus <span class="blank _d"> </span>artigos, <span class="blank _d"> </span>trata <span class="blank _17"> </span>de <span class="blank _18"> </span>matéria </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yb0 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">reservada <span class="blank _28"> </span>à <span class="blank _28"> </span>lei <span class="blank _28"> </span>complementar. <span class="blank _28"> </span>Apesar <span class="blank _1e"> </span>de <span class="blank _28"> </span>possuir <span class="blank _19"> </span>v<span class="blank _0"> </span>ício <span class="blank _28"> </span>formal, <span class="blank _28"> </span>essa <span class="blank _28"> </span>lei </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y104 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">padecerá de inconstitucionalidad<span class="blank _1"></span>e parcial. <span class="blank _0"> </span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h15 y105 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">No <span class="blank _c"> </span>Brasil, <span class="blank _c"> </span>o <span class="blank _12"> </span>Poder <span class="blank _c"> </span>Judiciário <span class="blank _12"> </span>pod<span class="blank _1"></span>e <span class="blank _c"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">declar<span class="blank _0"> </span>ar <span class="blank _c"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _c"> </span>parcial<span class="blank _0"> </span></span><span class="v0"> </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y106 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">de <span class="blank _c"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">fração <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>artigo, <span class="blank _11"> </span>pará<span class="blank _0"> </span>grafo, <span class="blank _11"> </span>inciso, <span class="blank _c"> </span>alínea <span class="blank _c"> </span>ou <span class="blank _c"> </span>até <span class="blank _c"> </span>mesmo <span class="blank _c"> </span>sobre <span class="blank _c"> </span>uma </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y107 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">única <span class="blank _28"> </span>palavra <span class="blank _1e"> </span>ou <span class="blank _28"> </span>expressão<span class="ffc fc0 v0"> <span class="blank _1e"> </span>do <span class="blank _28"> </span>ato <span class="blank _1e"> </span>normativo. <span class="blank _28"> </span>Trata-se <span class="blank _1e"> </span>do <span class="blank _28"> </span>chamado </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 ycc ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws3">princípio da parcelaridade<span class="ffc fc0 ls9">. <span class="ls1"> </span></span></div><div class="c x6 y108 w6 h1b"><div class="t m0 x13 h11 y109 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="c x14 y108 w7 h1b"><div class="t m0 x10 h11 y10a ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">A <span class="blank _13"> </span>declaração <span class="blank _13"> </span>de <span class="blank _1a"> </span>inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _1a"> </span>parcial <span class="blank _1a"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">é <span class="blank _13"> </span>di<span class="blank _0"> </span>ferente </span></div><div class="t m0 x10 h11 y10b ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">do <span class="blank _13"> </span>veto <span class="blank _13"> </span>parcial <span class="blank _13"> </span>do<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _13"> </span>Presidente <span class="blank _13"> </span><span class="ffc fc0 v0">a <span class="blank _13"> </span>projeto <span class="blank _13"> </span>de <span class="blank _13"> </span>lei. <span class="blank _13"> </span>O <span class="blank _13"> </span>veto </span></div><div class="t m0 x10 h11 y10c ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">parcial deverá abranger <span class="blank _0"> </span>texto integral de <span class="blank _0"> </span>artigo, parágrafo, </div><div class="t m0 x10 h11 y10d ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">inciso <span class="blank _2c"> </span>o<span class="blank _0"> </span>u <span class="blank _2c"> </span>a<span class="blank _0"> </span>línea. <span class="blank _2d"> </span>Por <span class="blank _2d"> </span>sua <span class="blank _2d"> </span>vez,<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _2c"> </span>a <span class="blank _2f"> </span>declaração <span class="blank _2d"> </span>de </div><div class="t m0 x10 h11 y10e ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _17"> </span>parcial <span class="blank _10"> </span>pode <span class="blank _17"> </span>abranger <span class="blank _17"> </span>apenas <span class="blank _17"> </span>parte </div><div class="t m0 x10 h11 y83 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">de <span class="blank _1c"> </span>artigo, <span class="blank _18"> </span>parágrafo<span class="blank _0"> </span>, <span class="blank _18"> </span>inciso, <span class="blank _1c"> </span>alínea <span class="blank _1c"> </span>ou at<span class="blank _1"></span>é <span class="blank _1c"> </span>mesmo <span class="blank _1c"> </span>uma </div><div class="t m0 x10 h11 y10f ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">única palavra ou expressão. </div></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y110 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Cabe <span class="blank _c"> </span>destacar, <span class="blank _12"> </span>todavia, <span class="blank _c"> </span>que <span class="blank _c"> </span>a <span class="blank _12"> </span>declaração <span class="blank _c"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>in<span class="blank _1"></span>constitucionalidade <span class="blank _c"> </span>parcial <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">não </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 y111 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">poderá <span class="blank _17"> </span>modificar <span class="blank _10"> </span>o<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _10"> </span>sentido <span class="blank _17"> </span>e <span class="blank _17"> </span>o <span class="blank _17"> </span>alca<span class="blank _0"> </span>nce <span class="blank _10"> </span>da <span class="blank _17"> </span>lei<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffc fc0 v0">, <span class="blank _17"> </span>sob <span class="blank _17"> </span>pena <span class="blank _17"> </span>de <span class="blank _17"> </span><span class="ffa fc7">ofensa <span class="blank _d"> </span>à </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y112 ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws3">separação <span class="blank _10"> </span>dos <span class="blank _10"> </span>Poderes<span class="ffc fc0 ls9 v0">, <span class="blank _17"> </span><span class="ls1">princípio <span class="blank _10"> </span>q<span class="blank _0"> </span>ue <span class="blank _10"> </span>impede <span class="blank _10"> </span>o <span class="blank _10"> </span>Poder <span class="blank _17"> </span>Judiciário <span class="blank _10"> </span><span class="ls1e ws25">de</span> <span class="blank _10"> </span>atua<span class="blank _0"> </span>r </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y113 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">como <span class="blank _29"> </span>legislador <span class="blank _29"> </span>positivo. <span class="blank _29"> </span>Em <span class="blank _29"> </span>outras <span class="blank _29"> </span>palavras, <span class="blank _29"> </span>a <span class="blank _29"> </span>declaração <span class="blank _29"> </span>de </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y114 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _f"> </span>parcial <span class="blank _f"> </span>pode <span class="blank _e"> </span>r<span class="blank _0"> </span>ecair <span class="blank _f"> </span>até <span class="blank _f"> </span>mesmo <span class="blank _f"> </span>sobre <span class="blank _f"> </span>palavra <span class="blank _f"> </span>ou </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y115 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">expressão <span class="blank _c"> </span>isoladas, <span class="blank _c"> </span>mas <span class="blank _c"> </span>isso <span class="blank _12"> </span>não <span class="blank _c"> </span>poderá <span class="blank _c"> </span>subverter <span class="blank _c"> </span>por <span class="blank _12"> </span>c<span class="blank _1"></span>ompl<span class="blank _1"></span>eto <span class="blank _c"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span>sentido <span class="blank _c"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"> </span>a </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y116 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws20">norma.<span class="fs8 ls1c v1">3</span><span class="ws3"> </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y117 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y118 ffa fs2 fc0 sc0 ls15 ws23">d)<span class="fc6 ls1 ws3"> Inconstitucionalidade Direta e Indireta: </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y119 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Antes <span class="blank _30"> </span>de <span class="blank _30"> </span>explicarmos <span class="blank _2c"> </span>o <span class="blank _30"> </span>que <span class="blank _30"> </span>é <span class="blank _30"> </span>a <span class="blank _2c"> </span>inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _30"> </span>direta <span class="blank _30"> </span>e <span class="blank _30"> </span>a </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y11a ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _1a"> </span>indireta, <span class="blank _1a"> </span>é <span class="blank _1f"> </span>preciso <span class="blank _1a"> </span>re<span class="blank _0"> </span>lembrarmos <span class="blank _1a"> </span>a <span class="blank _1a"> </span>diferença <span class="blank _1a"> </span>entre <span class="blank _1a"> </span>atos </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y11b ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">normativos primários e secundários. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y11c ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Os <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">atos <span class="blank _12"> </span>normativ<span class="blank _1"></span>os <span class="blank _12"> </span>primários<span class="ffc fc0"> <span class="blank _12"> </span>são <span class="blank _c"> </span>aqueles <span class="blank _12"> </span>que <span class="blank _12"> </span>retiram <span class="blank _12"> </span>seu <span class="blank _c"> </span>fundamento <span class="blank _12"> </span>de </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y11d ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">validade diretamente do texto constitucional. Como exemplo, podemos <span class="blank _0"> </span>apontar </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y11e ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">as <span class="blank _1d"> </span>leis <span class="blank _15"> </span>ordinárias, <span class="blank _1d"> </span>leis <span class="blank _1d"> </span>complementares, <span class="blank _15"> </span>medidas <span class="blank _1e"> </span>provisórias <span class="blank _1d"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _1d"> </span>decretos </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y11f ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">legislativos. <span class="blank _11"> </span>Os <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">atos <span class="blank _11"> </span>nor<span class="blank _0"> </span>mativos <span class="blank _c"> </span>secundários</span><span class="v0">, <span class="blank _c"> </span>por <span class="blank _c"> </span>sua <span class="blank _c"> </span>vez, <span class="blank _c"> </span>não <span class="blank _c"> </span>retiram <span class="blank _c"> </span>seu </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 hb y120 ff8 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> <span class="blank _7"></span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h18 y121 ff5 fsb fc0 sc0 ls1">3</div><div class="t m0 x11 h19 y122 ff5 fsc fc0 sc0 ls1d ws3"> <span class="ffc ls1">MASSON, <span class="blank _10"> </span>Nathali<span class="blank _0"> </span>a. <span class="blank _1f"> </span><span class="fff">Manua<span class="blank _0"> </span>l <span class="blank _1f"> </span>de <span class="blank _10"> </span>Direito<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _1f"> </span>Constituc<span class="blank _0"> </span>ional</span>, <span class="blank _10"> </span>Ed. <span class="blank _10"> </span>Juspo<span class="blank _0"> </span>dium, <span class="blank _10"> </span>Salvador: <span class="blank _10"> </span>2013, </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h19 y123 ffc fsc fc0 sc0 ls1 ws26">pp.979.<span class="ff5 ws3"> </span></div><div class="t m0 x3 h5 y4 ff2 fs3 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="c x4 y5 w2 h6"><div class="t m0 x5 h7 y6 ff3 fs4 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws0">`Ì<span class="blank _0"> </span>i`Ê Õ<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ã<span class="blank _0"> </span>}ÊÌ<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊv<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ài<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊÛi<span class="blank _0"> </span>ÀÃ<span class="blank _0"> </span> Ê <span class="blank _0"> </span>vÊ<span class="ff4"><span class="blank _0"> </span>v<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="blank _0"> </span>ÝÊ* <span class="blank _0"> </span>Ê<span class="blank _0"> </span>`<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ì <span class="blank _0"> </span>À</span><span class="ls0 ws1">ÊÊ</span><span class="fc3 ws2">Ü Ü Ü°Vi °V </span></div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pfa" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="a"><div class="pc pca w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 y0 w1 h1" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/4cb09b61-4250-444d-ae0c-98af2d5728a1/bga.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x0 y0 w0 h8"><div class="t m0 x6 h9 y7 ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="t m0 x6 ha y8 ff6 fs5 fc4 sc0 ls1 ws3">Prof. Nádia Caro<span class="blank _1"></span>lina <span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="ff7 fs6 fc5">www.estrateg<span class="blank _1"></span>iaconcursos.com.b<span class="blank _1"></span>r <span class="ff5 fs5 fc4"> <span class="fc0 ws4">9</span> de <span class="blank _1"></span><span class="fc0">140 </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 hb y9 ff8 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="c x7 ya w3 hc"><div class="t m0 x2 hd yb ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls2">D<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">IREITO </span><span class="ls3">C<span class="fs7 ls1 ws3">ONSTITUCIONAL </span><span class="ff9 ls4"></span><span class="fs7 ls5 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws5">PC-</span><span class="ls9 ws6">MA</span><span class="fs7 ls6 ws3"> </span><span class="ls7">-<span class="fs7 ls8 ws3"> </span><span class="ls1 ws3">Teoria e Questões </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 x7 he yc ff7 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Prof<span class="fs8 ws7 v1">a</span><span class="ws3"> Nádia / Prof. Ricardo Vale </span></div><div class="t m0 x8 h9 yd ff5 fs5 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y32 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">fundamento <span class="blank _1b"> </span>de <span class="blank _1b"> </span>va<span class="blank _0"> </span>lidade <span class="blank _1b"> </span>diretamente <span class="blank _1b"> </span>da <span class="blank _1b"> </span>Co<span class="blank _0"> </span>nstituição, <span class="blank _1b"> </span>mas <span class="blank _1b"> </span>sim <span class="blank _1b"> </span>dos <span class="blank _19"> </span>atos </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y58 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">normativos <span class="blank _0"> </span>primários. <span class="blank _11"> </span>São <span class="blank _11"> </span>os <span class="blank _11"> </span>atos <span class="blank _0"> </span>infra<span class="blank _0"> </span>legais, <span class="blank _0"> </span>como, <span class="blank _11"> </span>por <span class="blank _11"> </span>exemplo, <span class="blank _0"> </span>os <span class="blank _11"> </span>decretos </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y102 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">executivos, que têm como função regulamentar as leis. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 ye5 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Quando <span class="blank _27"> </span>um <span class="blank _20"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 v0">ato <span class="blank _27"> </span>normat<span class="blank _0"> </span>ivo <span class="blank _27"> </span>primário <span class="blank _27"> </span>violar <span class="blank _27"> </span>a <span class="blank _20"> </span>Constituição</span><span class="v0">, <span class="blank _20"> </span>estaremos </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h13 ye6 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">diante <span class="blank _d"> </span>de <span class="blank _d"> </span>uma <span class="blank _d"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">inco<span class="blank _0"> </span>nstitucionalidade <span class="blank _17"> </span>direta<span class="blank _0"> </span></span><span class="v0">. <span class="blank _d"> </span>Nesse <span class="blank _d"> </span>caso, <span class="blank _d"> </span>há <span class="blank _d"> </span>uma <span class="blank _18"> </span>frontal </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y5c ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">incompatibilidade <span class="blank _1b"> </span>da <span class="blank _19"> </span>norma <span class="blank _19"> </span>com <span class="blank _19"> </span>o <span class="blank _19"> </span>texto <span class="blank _1b"> </span>da <span class="blank _19"> </span>Constit<span class="blank _0"> </span>uição. <span class="blank _1b"> </span>A <span class="blank _19"> </span>aferição <span class="blank _19"> </span>de </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y124 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">validade <span class="blank _20"> </span>da <span class="blank _1b"> </span>norma <span class="blank _20"> </span><span class="lse">é <span class="blank _1b"> </span></span>realizada <span class="blank _20"> </span>comp<span class="blank _0"> </span>arando-<span class="lsa">a <span class="blank _20"> </span></span><span class="ffa fc6 ws16 v0">diretamente</span><span class="v0"> <span class="blank _20"> </span>com <span class="blank _1b"> </span>o <span class="blank _1b"> </span>texto </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y5e ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">constitucional. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y125 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Por <span class="blank _12"> </span>out<span class="blank _1"></span>ro <span class="blank _12"> </span>lad<span class="blank _1"></span>o, <span class="blank _12"> </span>quando <span class="blank _c"> </span>um<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _c"> </span><span class="ffa fc7">ato<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _c"> </span>normat<span class="blank _0"> </span>ivo <span class="blank _c"> </span>secundário</span> <span class="blank _12"> </span>(como, <span class="blank _c"> </span>por <span class="blank _12"> </span>exemplo, </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yeb ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">um <span class="blank _31"> </span>decreto) <span class="blank _31"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 v0">violar<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _31"> </span>a <span class="blank _31"> </span>Constituição</span><span class="v0">, <span class="blank _31"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"> </span>staremos <span class="blank _31"> </span>diante <span class="blank _31"> </span>de <span class="blank _31"> </span>um<span class="blank _0"> </span>a </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y126 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _18"> </span>indireta <span class="ffc fc0">(reflexa). <span class="blank _18"> </span>Isso <span class="blank _1c"> </span>porque <span class="blank _18"> </span>os <span class="blank _1c"> </span>atos <span class="blank _18"> </span>normativos </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y106 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">secundários <span class="blank _f"> </span>não <span class="blank _25"> </span>retiram <span class="blank _25"> </span>seu <span class="blank _25"> </span>fundamento <span class="blank _f"> </span>de <span class="blank _25"> </span>validade <span class="blank _25"> </span>diretamente <span class="blank _f"> </span>da </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y107 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Constituição. <span class="blank _13"> </span>Assim<span class="blank _0"> </span>, <span class="blank _13"> </span>quando <span class="blank _1a"> </span>um<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _13"> </span>decreto <span class="blank _1a"> </span>exe<span class="blank _0"> </span>cutivo <span class="blank _13"> </span>violar <span class="blank _1a"> </span>a <span class="blank _1a"> </span>Co<span class="blank _0"> </span>nstituição <span class="blank _13"> </span>será </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y127 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">hipótese de inconstitucionalidade indi<span class="blank _1"></span>reta. <span class="blank _0"> </span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y128 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">É <span class="blank _13"> </span>importante <span class="blank _13"> </span>ressaltar <span class="blank _13"> </span>que, <span class="blank _13"> </span>para <span class="blank _13"> </span>o <span class="blank _13"> </span>ST<span class="blank _0"> </span>F, <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">só <span class="blank _13"> </span>existe <span class="blank _13"> </span>a <span class="blank _13"> </span>inco<span class="blank _0"> </span>nstitucionalidade </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y129 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws16">direta<span class="ffc fc0 ws3 v0">, <span class="blank _12"> </span>ou <span class="blank _c"> </span>seja<span class="blank _0"> </span>, <span class="blank _c"> </span>a <span class="blank _12"> </span>desconformidade <span class="blank _12"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>norma <span class="blank _12"> </span>primária <span class="blank _c"> </span>com <span class="blank _12"> </span>a <span class="blank _12"> </span>Consti<span class="blank _1"></span>tuição. <span class="blank _12"> </span>A </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y12a ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">chamada <span class="blank _12"> </span>inconstitucionalidad<span class="blank _1"></span>e <span class="blank _12"> </span>indireta, <span class="blank _12"> </span>em <span class="blank _12"> </span>que <span class="blank _12"> </span>um <span class="blank _12"> </span>ato <span class="blank _12"> </span>normativo <span class="blank _12"> </span>secund<span class="blank _1"></span>ário </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y12b ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">(um <span class="blank _1f"> </span>decreto <span class="blank _10"> </span>expedido <span class="blank _1f"> </span>pelo <span class="blank _10"> </span>Presidente <span class="blank _10"> </span>da <span class="blank _1f"> </span>República, <span class="blank _10"> </span>por <span class="blank _10"> </span>exemplo) <span class="blank _1f"> </span>ofend<span class="blank _0"> </span>e <span class="blank _17"> </span>a </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y12c ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Carta <span class="blank _11"> </span>Magna, <span class="blank _c"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">é <span class="blank _0"> </span>co<span class="blank _0"> </span>nsiderada <span class="blank _11"> </span>pelo <span class="blank _11"> </span>Pretório <span class="blank _c"> </span>Excelso <span class="blank _0"> </span>me<span class="blank _0"> </span>ra <span class="blank _11"> </span>ilegalidade<span class="blank _0"> </span></span><span class="v0">. <span class="blank _11"> </span>Isso </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h14 yd0 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">porque <span class="blank _c"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span><span class="ffa fc7 v0">norma <span class="blank _c"> </span>secundária <span class="blank _11"> </span>tem <span class="blank _c"> </span>sua <span class="blank _c"> </span>validade <span class="blank _c"> </span>aferida <span class="blank _c"> </span>a <span class="blank _c"> </span>partir <span class="blank _c"> </span>da <span class="blank _c"> </span>norma </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y42 ffa fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws16">primária<span class="ffc fc0 ws3 v0">, e não da Constituição, sendo a ofensa a esta apenas in<span class="blank _1"></span>direta. </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y12d ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">Há <span class="blank _32"> </span>que <span class="blank _32"> </span>se <span class="blank _32"> </span>mencionar <span class="blank _32"> </span>também <span class="blank _32"> </span>a <span class="blank _32"> </span>existência <span class="blank _2e"> </span>da <span class="blank _32"> </span>chamada </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y12e ffb fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _19"> </span>“por <span class="blank _19"> </span>arra<span class="blank _0"> </span>stamen<span class="blank _1"></span>to”<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffc fc0"> <span class="blank _19"> </span>(derivada, <span class="blank _19"> </span>consequencial <span class="blank _19"> </span>ou<span class="blank _0"> </span> </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y12f ffd fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">“por <span class="blank _33"> </span>atração”<span class="ffc">), <span class="blank _33"> </span>considerada <span class="blank _33"> </span>p<span class="blank _1"></span>or <span class="blank _33"> </span>alguns <span class="blank _33"> </span>autores <span class="blank _33"> </span>uma <span class="blank _33"> </span>espécie <span class="blank _33"> </span>d<span class="blank _1"></span>e </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y130 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade indireta. </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y131 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws3">A <span class="blank _12"> </span><span class="ffb fc7 ls1 v0">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _c"> </span>“por <span class="blank _12"> </span>arrastamento”<span class="ffc fc0"> <span class="blank _12"> </span>ocorrerá <span class="blank _c"> </span>quando <span class="blank _12"> </span>houver <span class="blank _c"> </span>uma </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yf8 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">relação de <span class="blank _1c"> </span>dependência ent<span class="blank _1"></span>re, pelo <span class="blank _1c"> </span>menos, du<span class="blank _1"></span>as normas: <span class="blank _1c"> </span>uma <span class="blank _1c"> </span>delas é a </div><div class="t m0 x6 h15 yf9 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">principal; <span class="blank _13"> </span>as <span class="blank _13"> </span>outras, <span class="blank _13"> </span>acessórias. <span class="blank _13"> </span>Se, <span class="blank _1a"> </span>em <span class="blank _13"> </span>um <span class="blank _13"> </span>determinado <span class="blank _13"> </span>processo<span class="blank _0"> </span>, <span class="blank _13"> </span>a <span class="blank _13"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">norma </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yfa ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">principal <span class="blank _22"> </span>for <span class="blank _22"> </span>declarada <span class="blank _22"> </span>inconstitucional<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffc fc0 v0">, <span class="blank _22"> </span>todas <span class="blank _22"> </span>as <span class="blank _22"> </span>normas <span class="blank _22"> </span>dela </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yd9 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">dependentes também deverão<span class="blank _0"> </span> ser consideradas inconstitu<span class="blank _1"></span>cionais. Veja: a<span class="blank _0"> </span>s </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 yda ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">normas <span class="blank _34"> </span>acessórias <span class="blank _34"> </span>sofrerão <span class="blank _34"> </span>consequências <span class="blank _34"> </span>da <span class="blank _34"> </span>declaração <span class="blank _34"> </span>de </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 ydb ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _35"> </span>da <span class="blank _34"> </span>norma <span class="blank _35"> </span>principal. <span class="blank _35"> </span>Elas <span class="blank _35"> </span>padecerão <span class="blank _35"> </span>da </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y132 ffd fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _30"> </span>“por<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _30"> </span>arrastame<span class="blank _0"> </span>nto” <span class="blank _30"> </span>(ou <span class="blank _2c"> </span>inconstitucionalid<span class="blank _1"></span>ade <span class="blank _2c"> </span>“por </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y133 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">reverberação nor<span class="ffd">mativa”). </span> </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y134 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">O <span class="blank _12"> </span>STF<span class="blank _1"></span> <span class="blank _c"> </span>já <span class="blank _12"> </span>teve <span class="blank _c"> </span>a <span class="blank _12"> </span>oportunidad<span class="blank _1"></span>e <span class="blank _12"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>se <span class="blank _12"> </span>manifestar <span class="blank _c"> </span>inúmeras <span class="blank _c"> </span>veze<span class="blank _0"> </span>s <span class="blank _c"> </span>no <span class="blank _12"> </span>senti<span class="blank _1"></span>do <span class="blank _c"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"> </span>e </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y135 ffd fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">declarar <span class="blank _1a"> </span>a <span class="blank _1f"> </span>inconstitucionalidade <span class="blank _1f"> </span>“por <span class="blank _1f"> </span>arrastamento” <span class="blank _1a"> </span>de <span class="blank _1f"> </span>certas <span class="blank _1f"> </span>normas<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="ffc">. <span class="blank _1a"> </span>Como<span class="blank _0"> </span> </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y136 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">exemplo, <span class="blank _11"> </span>podemos <span class="blank _c"> </span>apontar <span class="blank _11"> </span>o <span class="blank _c"> </span>caso <span class="blank _11"> </span>de <span class="blank _c"> </span>uma <span class="blank _11"> </span>lei <span class="blank _11"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"> </span>stadual <span class="blank _11"> </span>regulamentada <span class="blank _11"> </span>por <span class="blank _c"> </span>um </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y137 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">decreto <span class="blank _21"> </span>executivo. <span class="blank _30"> </span>Tendo <span class="blank _21"> </span>sido <span class="blank _30"> </span>a <span class="blank _21"> </span><span class="ffa fc6 v0">lei <span class="blank _21"> </span>co<span class="blank _0"> </span>nsiderada <span class="blank _21"> </span>inconstitucional, </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y138 ffa fs2 fc6 sc0 ls1 ws3">reconheceu-se <span class="blank _19"> </span>que <span class="blank _19"> </span>a <span class="blank _28"> </span>norma <span class="blank _19"> </span>dela <span class="blank _28"> </span>dependente<span class="ffc fc0 v0"> <span class="blank _28"> </span>(o<span class="blank _0"> </span> <span class="blank _19"> </span>decreto <span class="blank _19"> </span>executivo) </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y139 ffb fs2 fc7 sc0 ls1 ws3">deveria <span class="blank _c"> </span>ser <span class="blank _11"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"> </span>eclarada <span class="blank _c"> </span>inconstitucional <span class="blank _11"> </span>“po<span class="blank _0"> </span>r <span class="blank _c"> </span>arrastamento”<span class="ffc fc0 ls9">. <span class="blank _c"> </span><span class="ls1">A <span class="blank _c"> </span>técnica <span class="blank _c"> </span>se<span class="blank _0"> </span> </span></span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y56 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">justifica p<span class="blank _1"></span>elo fato <span class="blank _1c"> </span>de algumas <span class="blank _1c"> </span>normas guardarem í<span class="blank _1"></span>ntima relação <span class="blank _1c"> </span>entre si, </div><div class="t m0 x6 h11 y57 ffc fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws3">formando <span class="blank _c"> </span>uma <span class="blank _c"> </span>ver<span class="blank _0"> </span>dadeira <span class="blank _c"> </span><span class="ffa fc6">unidad<span class="blank _0"> </span>e <span class="blank _c"> </span>jurídica</span>. <span class="blank _c"> </span>Co<span class="blank _0"> </span>m <span class="blank _c"> </span>isso, <span class="blank _12"> </span>t<span class="blank _1"></span>orna-se <span class="blank _12"> </span>impossível <span class="blank _c"> </span>a </div><div class="t m0 x3 h5 y4 ff2 fs3 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws3"> </div><div class="c x4 y5 w2 h6"><div class="t m0 x5 h7 y6 ff3 fs4 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws0">`Ì<span class="blank _0"> </span>i`Ê Õ<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ã<span class="blank _0"> </span>}ÊÌ<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊv<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ài<span class="blank _0"> </span>iÊÛi<span class="blank _0"> </span>ÀÃ<span class="blank _0"> </span> Ê <span class="blank _0"> </span>vÊ<span class="ff4"><span class="blank _0"> </span>v<span class="blank _0"> </span><span class="blank _0"> </span>ÝÊ* <span class="blank _0"> </span>Ê<span class="blank _0"> </span>`<span class="blank _0"> </span>Ì <span class="blank _0"> </span>À</span><span class="ls0 ws1">ÊÊ</span><span class="fc3 ws2">Ü Ü Ü°Vi °V </span></div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div>
Compartilhar