Baixe o app para aproveitar ainda mais
Prévia do material em texto
Hydrobiologia vol. 60, 3, pag. 243-259, 1978 THE COLONIZATION OF CABORA BASSA, MOC(AMBIQUE, A NEW MAN-MADE LAKE, BY FLOATING AQUATIC MACROPHYTES W. J. BOND* & M. G. ROBERTS** Loxton, Hunting and Associates, P.O. Box 197, Gaberone, Botswana. Current Address: * Saasveld Forest Research Station, Private Bag 53I, George 6530. R.S.A. ** c/o Swakopmund High School, P.O. Box I87, Swakopmund 9160. SWA/Namibia Received December 13, 1977 Keywords: Eichhornia crassipes, Salvinia molesta, aquatic macrophytes, man-made lakes Abstract Eichhornia crassipes and Salvinia molesta, both notorious weeds, are present in the catchment of Cabora Bassa, a new man- made lake on the Zambezi River, Mocambique. Weed dispersal, controlled by wind and current (and indirectly by rate of lake filling and lake morphology) culminated in the distribution of mats in the eastern and western extremities with very small cover in central lake areas. Eichhornia offset produc- tion was initially very rapid later diminishing markedly with many plants showing symptoms of nutrient deficiency. Eichhor- nia completely dominated mat composition at the end of the year whilst Salvinia cover was negligible. Heavy drawdown in the middle of the year lead to destruction of nearly 50% of the weed mats. Whilst pre-drawdown levels were attained by the end of the year, there was no evidence for expected explosive population growth and extensive weed colonization in the filling phase. Introduction Cabora Bassa, a new man-made lake on the Zambezi River, Mozambique, began to fill on 5 December 974. Floating aquatic macrophytes are infamous for ex- plosive population growth an example of which is Sal- vinia molesta, D. S. Mitchell, at Lake Kariba, also on the Zambezi River. This plant, a fern, showed spectacular growth in the lake's formative years covering Iooo km2 Dr. W. Junk b.v. Publishers - The Hague, The Netherlands in the fourth year after closure (Mitchell, I970, 1973). The water hyacinth, Eichhornia crassipes, (Mart.) Solms, is a widespread pest of waterways in the warmer parts of the world and has been a serious problem in several African impoundments including the Jebel Aulia Dam, north Africa (Little, 966), Lake Mcllwaine on the Hunyani River, a tributary to the Zambezi (Davies et al., 1975) and Hartebeestpoort Dam, South Africa. The water hyacinth, Salvinia molesta, Pistia stratiotes L. and Azolla nilotica Decne ex Mett. were recorded in the catchment of Cabora Bassa during pre-impound- ment surveys (Macedo, 1974, Davis, Hall & Jackson, 1975) and were considered potential pests. Salvinia and Pistia are present throughout the Zambezi system while Eichhornia is present in both the Kafue River of Zambia and the Hunyani (= Panhame) River of Rhodesia, both of which are tributaries to the Zambezi above the new dam. Pre-impoundment assessments of the problem of aquatic weed infestation, based largely on experience at Kariba, predicted extensive and rapid colonization at Cabora Bassa. Davies et al. estimated a probable macro- phyte cover of 25-40% of the lake surface within two years of closure followed by a gradual decrease as nutrient levels stabilized. They predicted that Eichhornia would be the major pest and would dominate Salvinia. Extensive weed cover could interfere with hydro- electric installations and water transport, seriously af- fecting fishing, navigation and recreation (Little, 966; 243 Mitchell, 1974) with the additional danger of rapid spread of disease vectors on floating weed mats (Mitchell, 1974; Jackson & Davies, I976). Use of weed for soil improve- ment or livestock feed (Davies et al., 1975; Oliviera, I972) at Cabora Bassa is not, at the moment, a feasible propo- sition because of prohibitive harvesting and transport costs and the distance of agricultural settlements from the lake. Due to the possible disadvantages of these aquatic plants and the likelihood of their explosive development, a joint research and control project was started in the initial filling phase of the lake. The perennial input of floating macrophytes and the unlikelihood of complete control in the source countries, limits the possibility of overall weed control at Cabora Bassa. Instead strategic weed control, which included the use of floating barriers, herbicides, manual harvesting and biological agents was employed but is not further described here. A study of invasion of the lake by floating macrophytes was made and this paper records observations on aspects of immigration and colonization in 1975, the first year of the lake. Comparisons of weed ecology at Cabora Bassa and Kariba, both on the same river system and in a similar climate, may provide general insight into floating macrophyte biology in the large African impoundments. Morphology and Limnology Cabora Bassa, situated on the Middle Zambezi River, is smaller than lake Kariba which is some 500 kms up stream (Table I). The lake has five basins, the Mucan- gadze, Carinde, western and eastern Mucanha, Chicoa and Gorge Basins, from west to east respectively (Davies, Hall & Valente, 976; Bond et al., 1977), (Fig. I). The western basins are shallow and, in the lake's first year, showed riverine characteristics. The deeper eastern basins rapidly developed lentic features (Bond et al., 1977). At lake levels prevailing in 1975, basins were separated by marked constrictions caused by islands or promontaries. There is a marked difference in slope of northern and southern shores, the former, particularly in the Chicoa and Mucanha Basins, being generally steeply sloping whereas southern shores have a very gentle gradient. Since virtually no trees were cleared from the lake peri- meter, the southern shores were choked with a broad band of semi-submerged terrestial vegetation up to Fig. i. Lake Cabora Bassa, Mogambique, at mean retention level of 326 m AMSL. Basins are numbered from east to west respectively: -Gorge, 2 -Chicoa, 3a- Mucanha East, 3b - Mucanha West, 4 Carinde, 5- Mucangadze. Chicoa and Mucanha Basins are occasionally referred to collectively as the central basins. 244 5 kms wide, whereas, on the north bank this was gener- ally very narrow. Climate Meteorological data from Chicoa Velha, now sub- merged by the lake, are recorded in Table 2. There are three seasons: a dry-hot season from August to October, a hot-humid season from November to April, and a cold- dry season from May to July. Conditions generally ap- peared favorable for optimal growth by both Salvinia and Eichhornia although there seemed to be a possibility of high temperatures limiting growth rate for a part of the year. Prevailing winds are of considerable importance to weed dispersal being mostly south-easterly to southerly becoming more easterly in the western basins (Table 3). Wind direction is more variable in the summer months from November to February, especially preceding and during thunderstorms. During this period westerly and south-westerly winds are more frequent in the eastern TABLE 1 SOME COMPARATIVE DTA ON LAKES KARIBA AND CABORA BASSA FEATURE KARIBA Catchment Geographical position: Longitude Latitude (km2) Direction of main axis Direction of predominant wind Number of Basins Maximum depth (m) Mean depth (m) Maximum drawdown Maximum length Greatest width Length of shoreline Total area at capacity Maximum capacity Actual filling time (m) (km) (km) (km) (km2) (m3 ) years Ratio annual inflow to volume Important infestant aquatic macrophytes present in the system 409 600 260 40'E-293'E 16028'S-180°6'S SW-NE SE-NW 5 120 29,5 14 300 40 3155 5250 15,5x1010 4 1:3 1. Salvinia molesta 2. Pistia stratiotes CABORA BASSA 200 000 30025' E-32044' E 15029' S-16000' S SE-NW 5 151 26 36 250 38 1775 2739 7x1010 +/- 1 +/- 1:1 1. S. molesta 2. P. stratiotes 3. Azolla nilotica 4. Eichhornia crassipes 245 TABLE 2 1kXETiSOOLOGICAL DATA, CHICOA VLHA, CABOitA BASSA Chicoa Velha is now subnerged by the lake in the ChicoaBasin. Values are given as means per month for each season. Hot-Dry Hot-Humid Aug-Oct Nov-April Cold-Dry hiay-July Annual Mean Rainfall (mm) No. of rainy days Potential evapotranspiration (mm) Temperature °C Mean Max Mean in Mean Relative humidity basins and northerly, westerly and north-westerly winds in the western basins. Lake Filling and Limnological Characteristics Unlike Kariba, which took several years to fill, Cabora Bassa was filled very rapidly with the lake level rising to 314 m AMSL, only 12 m below full supply level, by early May, 1975. Lake level then dropped to 3 10 m by mid June and then very rapidly to 305 m AMSL by the end of July after which it continued to drop slowly and consistently to 302 m by December, 1975 (Fig. 2). For the greater part of the year lake waters remained homiothermal and well mixed partly as a result of the quantities of water released in drawdown. However, TABLE 3 WIND DIRECTION - Mean Annual Percentage of Recordings (1960-1968) N NE E SE S SW W NW Calm Chicoa Velha+ Zumbo+ + 4 7 8 37 22 11 10 1 2 2 27 35 5 1 2 3 24 Data extracted from tables in Hidroteonica Portuguesa, 1973 ean of four years of complete data Mean of six years of complete data 246 Season Month hs 1 134 35,4 18,4 27,7 53 100 7 165 35,1 20,7 28,2 65 1 o97 97 31,1 14,4 23,6 605 43 1681 34,2 18,5 26,9 61 -Lke Lvtl _ - - - - Ae. J J A S 0 N D DATE stratification developed in the eastern basins from mid- September becoming more pronounced and spreading westwards as far as the central Mucanha Basin by the end of the year. Hydrogen sulphide was present in the deeper WO0 eastern basins by November. Chemical content of sur- face waters showed little seasonal or spatial variation and was, in general, comparable with pre-impoundment ,0o 0 levels (Hall et al., 1976). Some chemical and physical 1200 = parameters of surface, open waters in the Gorge Basin are shown in Table 4. pH increased from 6,9 in July to 8,7 in ,000 November. Nitrates and ammonia also decreased as the 800 year progressed whereas there was some evidence for an increase in sulnhates. Fig. 2. Variation in Lake Level (elevation above sea level) and Surface Area (square kilometres) at Cabora Bassa in 1975. Mean retention level is 326 m AMSL. TABLE 4 CHEMICAL AND PHYSICAL PARAMETERS OF SURFACE, OPEN WATERS, GORGE BASIN Value Date 20/6 9/7 1/8 5/9 2/10 8/11 2/12 Ca mg 1-1 Mg mg 1-1 Na mg 1-1 K mg 1-1 NO3 mg 1-1 NO2 mg 1-1 NH3 mg 1-1 P04 mg 1-1 S04 mg 1 Fe mg 1-1 Yin mg 1-1 pH Conductivity inl S cm- 1 Temperature °C Stratification 10,8 3,2 8,0 4,3 4,1 12,7 2,2 1,1 0,03 2,0 0,5 0 7,0 5,5 6,9 2,0 0,3 0 - 10,0 - 9,0 - 4,9 - 5,5 - 4,6 6,4 6,9 - 2,0 2,3 2,0 0,16 0,06 0,06 0,1 0 0 0 - 0,16 0,22 0,46 0,02 0,06 0 - 0 3,7 0,14 0 0,10 0,07 Trace Traoe 0,03 1,15 - <0,1 - 6,9 - 101 7,0 104 - 9,6 - ~0,1 - 0,5 7,7 8,3 115 106 - 9,6 8,7 108 24,1 24,3 23,2 23,3 24,3 26,3 30,4 0 0 0 0 + +9 Dashes = no data available 0 = not detectable 310 305 300 295 290 285 28O 275 270 F M A H 0 8,0 115 + 247 __ _ ... _. __< o.r..._o. . I I II i I / Lake Colonization by Aquatic Macrophytes Mats of floating macrophytes in pools and slow flowing sections of the Zambezi River were displaced by annual Zambezi floods and transported down stream by strong currents. Plants from this source were first recorded at the dam wall six weeks after closure (24 January, 1975) when a mat of approximately 1500 m2 together with scattered mats of less than loo m2 accumulated in the vicinity of the barrage. Nine weeks after closure a nearly continuous band of weed had collected in the canopies of semi-submerged trees along the shores to a distance of 8 km upstream of the wall. At this stage very few plants were observed in the Chicoa Basin which was the first of the broad lake basins to fill. By March movement of weed mats had diminished and accretion by vegetative growth rather than addition of plants from the old riverine source predominated in areas east of Carinde. Location and area of mats are indicated in Table 5. Distribution and size of mats was recorded by aerial survey, flying at approximately ooo ft above lake level, and co-ordinating independent observations made by two or three observers on I 0 Ioo ooo scale maps. As a further check, the areas occupied by floating weed mats were estimated from extensive boat surveys. Weed distri- bution, in 1975, was discontinuous with fairly large popu- lations at the eastern and western lake extremities but only scattered mats in the central basins, mostly on the north bank. Rapid drawdown in July led to the destruc- tion of nearly 50% of the weed by stranding. Weed cover increased rapidly and within two months was at pre- drawdown levels. Offset production slowed from Sep- tember until the end of the year and the weed area re- mained static until the first floods in December carried weed from riverine sources into the western basins. Composition of the Weed Mat Marked changes in relative species abundance in the macrophyte communities took place during the course of the year. Subjective estimates of percentage cover of each species were made from boats driven into mats usually 5 to 6 metres from the lakeward edge. This method proved rapid and effective for smaller mats or narrow weed bands. No attempt was made at quantitative estimates of relative composition because of the severe difficulties of penetrating mats, particularly those with abundant TABLE 5 WEED AREA (HA) AND DISTRIBUTION BY BASIN. The ratio of mat area on north to south banks is presented in parentheses. Rapid drawdown in July depressed cover values while summer floods carried additional weed into the western basins in December. Approximately 50 ha of weeds were des- troyed by herbicides in the Gorge Basin. All weed in the Chiooa and Mucanha Basins was destroyed by herbicides and/or manual harvesting. GORGE CHICOA MUCANHA CARINDE ha N S ha N S ha N S ha N S MUCANGADZE TOTAL (ha) ha N S 70 (3:2) 2 (9:1) 10 (4:1) 20 (4:1) 200 (3:2) 5 (9:1) 12 (4:1) 45 (4:1) Drawdown150 (2:1) 1 (1:0) 4 (4:1) 12 (3l1) ept 260 (2:1) <0,2 (1:0) 2 (9:1) 13 (3:1) Dot 300 (2:1) 0,5 (1:0) 0,6 (1:1) 12 (3:1) ov 300 (2:1) 0,5 (1:0) 0 10 (4:1) ber 320 (7:3) 0 (1:0) O 12 (3:1) April June Rapid July Aug/Se Sept/C Oct/Nc Deceml 248 50 (3:2) 50 (3:2) 10 (3:1) 12 (3:1) 7 (3:1) 5 (4:1) 30 (3,2) 152 312 177 287 320 315 362 _> > __- DT.+ Eichhornia, by boat. Fig. 3 indicates changes in composi- tion expressed as % cover for weed mats in the eastern Mucangadze and Carinde Basins where small mats pre- dominated. The striking increase of Eichhornia during the year, at the expense of the other floating macrophytes, was typical of weed colonies throughout the lake. The marked decline of Salvinia is of particular interest as this is the first recorded instance of the association of these two species in a large man-made lake. Composition of mats was first noted on 24 January, I975, near the barrage. Eichhornia and Salvinia were present in approximately equal proportions of 40% each, w o .) with Pistia stratiotes covering the remaining 20%, Azolla nilotica was rare. The plants were associated with large mats of floating Phragmites mauritianus Kunth, dis- lodged from upstream river bank communities. These mixed composition mats were typical of lotic popula- tions. A successional sequence was recognized during the course of the year. Salvinia was usually rapidly supressed by explosive Pistia growth. Azolla remained competitive for a longer period (in some cases reaching 65% cover value) but it too was eventually supressed by Pistia. Scattered Eichhornia plants expanded very rapidly in stabilised mats and within a few months completely dominated Pistia. Phragmites declined very gradually as hornia ia igmites inia JUN (11) JUL (35) SEP (10) OCT (8) NOV (10) DATE ( No. OF MATS) Fig. 3. Changes in meanpercentage cover of Eichhornia crassipes, Pistia stratiotes, Phragmites mauritianus and Sal- vinia molesta in macrophyte communities of the Carinde and Mucangadze Basins from June to November, 1975. Cover was estimated subjectively (by the same observer throughout) as the vertical cover projection of each species and, because of community stratification, usually exceeded 100oo% for total cover value. Bars in the histogram represent mean % cover value whilst lines drawn through the bars represent the range. The numbers of mats used in each month- ly estimate is presented in parentheses. 249 the dead plants became waterlogged and sank, removing the growing platform of living plants. Extensive Salvinia mats were first observed in May, only in the Carinde Basin, behind a broad band of semi- submerged trees. Twigs and branches appear to have acted as a partial barrier to Eichhornia penetration. By July, however, both Pistia and Eichhornia were found to be growing vigorously in the area. A rapid drop in the lake level eliminated most of the colony and no further concentrations of Salvinia were seen. By the end of the year Salvinia was very rare in the lake and Eichhornia dominated all mats. Post-immigration Processes in Lake Colonization Processes of interest in lake colonization by floating macrophytes following initial invasion by immigration from external sources are: dispersal, growth (vegetative reproduction and biomass increment and factors af- fecting these) and mortality. Dispersal Dispersal controls the rate at which weeds spread around the lake perimeter, and the final location of 'permanent' floating weed mats. This process is important because weed control efforts are simplified and far less costly if the plants are geographically restricted. Wind was the most important dispersal agent over the greater part of the lake. South-easterly prevailing winds (Table 3) caused a concentration of floating macrophytes on the northern banks and limited eastward dispersal of weeds through the physical obstruction of the Carinde Narrows to the Mucanha Basin. Weed driven into the northern banks of the Chicoa and Mucanha Basins was rapidly destroyed by wave action except in very sheltered bays and estuaries. The southern bank of the Chicoa and Mucanha Basins, except for the extreme westerly section of the latter, remained weed free. The very rare mats driven into these shores, mostly by Zambezi currents in the western Mucanha Basin, were eradicated by manual removal to prevent their spread. Mats remained remarkably restricted to a particular area soon after lake filling when currents associated with filling ceased and, except for vegetative reproduction, mats were virtually static from June until mid Novem- ber, 1975. Wind direction is more variable during the summer months, from November to February, especially preced- ing and during thunderstorms. Weed that had remained stable for months was torn loose by strong winds and rough water preceding storms and, in the calms following storms, drifted on open water from which it was fre- quently dispersed to previously uncolonised areas. Stormy weather in December was the most potent factor in breaking up 'permanent' mats and this resulted in the first major expansion of weed along the lake shore lines since the lake levels had stabilised in July. This expansion was particularly noticeable in the Gorge Basin. In most cases mat fragments were driven back onto northern shores. Surface currents were important as a dispersal agent in the early months during filling, causing a concentration of weed in the eastern end of the lake. Observations in- dicated that only a slight current is needed to carry weed against an opposing wind. For example, a current of less than i km/h in the Mucangadze Basin swept weed east- wards against an opposing 18 km/h wind. From May onwards, however, surface currents caused by the Zam- bezi inflow could not be detected east of the Mucangadze Basin and weed dispersal was subsequently controlled by wind in the remaining basins. Rainy season flooding of the Zambezi River may carry weed beyond the Carinde Narrows into the lake but, as flood waters are cooler than lake waters, the former will probably sink beneath the latter and surface currents will remain limited to the inflow area in the extreme west. A seasonal cycle of dispersal in the rainy season (with attendant dangers of infestation of weed-free southern shores) followed by consolidation and stabilisation in the dry season may be expected in the future. Vegetative growth Experience in several tropical lakes has indicated a poor correlation between plant growth rates and nutrient analyses of the water (Mitchell, 1973). In Cabora Bassa high growth rates were recorded despite apparently low levels of nitrate, nitrite, ammonia and phosphate (Table 6). Potential growth of macrophytes in both colonised and weed free areas was recorded by observing growth rates in floating wooden quadrats placed in the lake. The plants studied were Eichhornia, Salvinia and Pistia, and they are dealt with separately below. Growth rates were measured as offset production for the waterhyacinth and Pistia and in terms of leaf number for Salvinia, thus discussion of growth is mostly limited to increase in numbers. 250 TABLE 6 EICHHORNIA CRASSIPES - GROWTH RATES Measured as Offset Production DT(days)1 X2 Nt 3 Habitat 18/5 to 27/6 6,12 18/5 to 27/6 5,67 12/7 to 14/8 5,68 12/7 to 14/8 5,83 8/9 to 20/10 8,94 8/9 to 20/10 10,7 5/11 to 20/12 5/11 to 20/12 Muoanha 1/9 to 21/10 1/9 to 21/10 17/9 to 21/10 21/10 to 6/11 Muoangadse and Carinde 4/7 to 4/7 to 4/7 to 30/8 to 30/8 to 24/9 to 24/9 to 16/11 to 16/11 to 13/10 to 13/10 to 30/8 30/8 26/7 2/12 2/12 16/11 16/11 2/12 2/12 10,8 12,2 9,5 27,4 14,9 12,0 20,2 21,6 26,0 19,5 20,7 ea 26/11 6,53 26/11 7,4- 1. D T = Doubling Time -= n2 RGR 2. X = daily factor of growth 3. Nt where t 90, No = 1 1,12 1,13 1,1297 1,1262 1,081 1,067 1,00 1.00 1,066 1,0583 1,076 1,0256 1,0474 1,0595 1,0347 1,0324 1,0268 1,0288 1,0344 1,00 1,00 1,1119 1,0981 26891 59849 58436 44197 1107 342 1 1 315 164 730 10 65 182 22 18 11 24 21 1 1 13993 4548 Deep water. Steep sloping shores to W n It IT I H II n II Tn nT I It I In II n II II n I I t Shallow gently sloping shore In I nI n Shallow estuarine 1n fn Sheltered sloping shore, 2,5m deep of11 t to I Exposed to waves, 10 m deep Shallow estuarine water, 4 m deep n n n n n Gently sloping, 4 m deep n it n 11 II It * n I n i I Sloping shore, 2,5 m deep In Is If II RGR l= n Nt - in No , where Nt = Number of plants at t time t (in days) and No Number of plants at initiation inorement in Nt = No.Xt 251 Basin Date Gorge _ _ _ ___~~~~~~~~~MIV Eichhornia crassipes: (i) Offset production. One or two small Eichhornia plants (5-6 lamina) were placed in each quadrat and the number of offsets record- ed at regular intervals. Trials were terminated when off- sets filled the quadrats to avoid distortion of rates due to overcrowding influences. Growth rate was expressed as X from Bock's (1969) formula Nt = N.Xt where No is the number of plants at time t (days) and X is the daily factor of growth increment. Relative growth rate and doubling time (Mitchell, 1974) were also calculated to aid comparison of Salvinia, Eichhornia and Pistia growth rates. Results are recorded in Table 6 and Fig. 4. Initial growth rates (trials began in May, 1975) were very high (Fig. 4) and were comparable with other areas in the world where Eichhornia is a pest plant (Perkins, 1972). Growth rates remained exponential and offset production was high until the end of August. During this period Eichhornia increased from less than to ha in January to 300 ha by the end of August in the Gorge Basin, despite the loss of nearly oo ha of weed during the drawdown in July. From mid-September offset production declined sharply in the quadrats. In trials inthe Gorge Basin initiated in November no increment was recorded. The weed colony in this Basin showed no perceptible increase in area until the end of the year. From October deficiency symptoms began to appear with yellow streaking of the lamina, necrosis of lamina tips and eventually death of the outer rosette of lamina and petioles. Growth rates in the Mucanha Basin were very much lower than the Gorge Basin though still sufficient to allow rapid mat expansion. A marked decline of offset production was recorded towards the end of October, following the trend in the Gorge. The Mucangadze and Carinde Basins showed very low growth rates in trials, except in October and November. These low rates were suprising since several quadrats had been placed in comparatively fertile, shallow water. These rates were confirmed by the fact that observations on the weed mats in these basins showed that there was no perceptible increase after drawdown in July. Before July very rapid growth had taken place in a shallow water section of the Carinde Basin, presumably at a time when growth rates corresponded to those in the Gorge Basin. Unfortunately no values for offset production are avail- able for this period. Increase in coverage of Eichhornia is primarily depen- dent on offset production as distinct from dry or wet U) U- U- 0L LL To - 12/7-14/ - -8 /9-20110 - - 5/11-20/12 / " K / 10 20 30 40 DAYS Fig. 4. Changes in growth rates during the first year of filling, measured as offset production, of Eichhornia crassipes in floating 2 m x 2 m quadrats in the Gorge Basin. Curves fitted by hand. weight increases. Cessation, or a marked decrease in off- set production was noted in growth trials when floating quadrats became filled with plants. In one trial, for example, 146 plants were recorded on 17 November, 213 offsets nine days later (an increase of 67) but only 218 off- sets (an increase of 5) 5 days later when the quadrat had filled with Eichhornia plants. Overcrowding thus depressed offset production but not necessarily biomass increase of individual plants. Bands of weed occupying lake margins only produced offsets on the open water fringes of the mats. Conse- quently potential for aereal increase of mats, particularly those anchored by semi-submerged trees, is limited to plants near open water. Breaking up of large mats by summer storms or, on a smaller scale, passage of boats could result in a faster colonization rate of open water because of the increased 'edge' available for offset produc- tion. This would partially offset slow growth rates ob- served in summer. Plants in the dense, inner sections of mats ceased offset production but continued to grow in bulk and height. This increase in individual plant biomass predominated 252 -- -- -- in the latter half of the year while offset production virtu- ally ceased. Consequently increase in area of mats was minimal. Eichhornia crassipes: (ii) Increase in individual plant biomass. Height above water level was used as an index of phyto- mass. The percentage cover of Eichhornia in each of five height classes was estimated subjectively in a number of weed mats in the Carinde and Mucangadze Basins between the end of August and the end of November (Fig. 5). The proportion of tall plants in the population in- creased markedly during this period, although the estimated area of the mats remained the same or dimin- ished. No migration of mats occurred. By the end of the year mats were dominated by tall plants, densely packed, with a very low potential for off- set production and thus a diminished capacity for expan- sion into suitable unoccupied habitats. Apparently differ- ent factors control offset production and individual phytomass increment (Bock, 1969), (the latter continued several months after the former had ceased). Eichhornia crassipes: (iii) Sexual reproduction. Eichhornia plants with both long and mid-styled flowers were present in the lake, the latter being by far the most common. Seed was produced but no seedlings were ob- served. Salvinia molesta: Salvinia growth rate was recorded as the increase in the 0 O 3018 (.4) 19/9 (6) 20/10 (5) 11/11 (5) 27/11 (5) DATE I No. OF MATS) Fig. 5. Size distribution (height) of Eichhornia crassipes populations in Carinde and Mucangadze Basins, 975. The histograms show mean percentage cover of five height categories of Eichhornia estimated subjectively by the same observer throughout. Lines drawn through histogram bars indicate the range of cover in each height category whilst the number of mats used for each estimate is in parenthesis after the date. 253 number of leaf pairs of healthy primary or secondary phase plants placed in floating quadrats in the lake. Means of the initial inoculum and those of the final har- vesting of plants were used to calculate doubling time. Trials were of shorter duration (I-2 weeks) than Eichhor- nia trials due to difficulties in retaining the plants in the quadrats and consumption of the plants by fish (proba- bly Distichodus spp.). Salvinia growth was similar to results obtained at Kariba (Mitchell and Turr, 1975) for mat-form plants which are, however, slower growing than open water col- onizing forms used at Cabora Bassa (Table 7). No decline of growth rates comparable to Eichhornia was recorded in the latter half of the year. The fastest doubling time of 3,9 days was recorded in shallow water in the Mucangadze Basin at the end of November, while a doubling time of 4,95 days was recorded in central Mucanha Basin in mid-October. The decline of Salvinia in weed mats (Fig. 3) does not appear to be due to infertile lake water or unfavorable climatic conditions since the weed grew exceptionally well at Kariba under similar conditions. It was probably due to competitive exclusion by the larger Eichhornia crassipes. Pistia stratiotes: Growth trials with Pistia were conducted from Septem- ber onwards. Growth rates were invariably very slow. Unfortunately no trials were made in the first half of the year when the plant was an aggressive coloniser and a major component of weed mats. The highest recorded rate was 2 offsets in 39 days or a doubling time of Io,9 days, in fertile waters in the Mucan- ha Basin. Most trials had very slow growth rates and several produced no offsets. The poor capacity for offset production partially ac- counts for Pistia's decline relative to Eichhornia. Mortality The main causes of mortality were wave action leading to physical destruction of plants on exposed shores, stranding and subsequent dessication following draw- down, and herbivore predation. Drawdown was the most potent mortality factor in the first year (Table 5). Rapid drawdown from May until early August (Fig. 2) left quan- tities of weed stranded on the banks. Small colonies in the central basins, which might otherwise have acted as potential foci for weed invasion, were destroyed. In the Gorge Basin nearly half the weed population, and in the Carinde Basin approximately 60 ha, were destroyed. Lake Kariba experienced no appreciable drawdown until five years after closure so that the critical stage of initial invasion by Salvinia suffered no serious draw- backs. Drawdown is the most potent weapon for weed TABLE 7 Salvinia molest: MEiEUN DOUBLING TIME (LEAF N.BER) IN DAYS, Gorge Basin, Cabora Bassa and Kariba+ Winter/Spring Cabora Bassa1 13,6 (n=2) Kariba2 14,3 Kariba3 Spring/Summer 11,0 (n=6) 13,2 Summer 7,4 (n=16) 8,2 13,8 (Jan-Feb) +Kariba data from itchell and Tur, 1975 1. Plants in quadrats in open water 2. Tagged, mat-form plants 3. Plants in quadrats in open water. 254 control but may have many repercussions on other as- pects of lake ecology, particularly as the lake matures (Bowmaker, 1973). Mitchell (1970, 1973) cites wave action as the major factor limiting the extent of Salvinia at Kariba. The size of waves is largely dependent on wind fetch which will, of course, increase when the water reaches full supply level. Even at low lakelevels, wave action destroyed a dense 50 m wide sudd of Phragmites and Eichhornia on an ex- posed shore in a little over two months. Small mats and isolated plants were destroyed within weeks of being driven onto exposed northern shores. Offset production was very slow in areas exposed to wave battering so that expansion of colonies beyond sheltered creeks and estu- aries was minimal on shores exposed to the prevailing south-easterly and easterly winds. Summer floods are likely to destroy large quantities of weed occurring in estuaries of drowned rivers (Mitchell, 1973) and wash surviving plants into open water, where most will be driven onto the exposed northern shores resulting in further mortality from wave action. Grazing of macrophytes by herbivors had very little effect on the total weed population but this factor may become more important in the future. Hippopotamus, baboon, vervet monkey, warthog and kudu were all ob- served eating Eichhornia, particularly in the dry season. Water fowl, such as Egyptian geese, fed to a limited ex- tent on stranded plants. Fish, particularly Distichodus schenga Peters, D. mos- sambicus Peters and possibly Sarotherodon mortimeri and Tilapia rendalli Boulenger utilised weeds to a limited extent. Loss of Salvinia by fish consumption curtailed many growth trials. Arthropods have been used for biological control of both Eichhornia and Salvinia. Paulinia acuminata De Geer (a grass hopper), Cyrtobagus singularis Hulst. (a Curculionid weevil) and Samea multiplicalis Guenee (a Pyralid moth) have all been released in the Zambezi Basin for Salvinia control (Bennett, I974). Paulinia acuminata was recovered in the Mucangadze Basin of Cabora Bassa in June, 1975, and again in October. It was not collected in the Gorge Basin where Salvinia was very scarce. An unidentified moth, possibly Samea, was wide- spread throughout the lake and helped check Salvinia growth. It was first collected in May and remained com- mon until the end of the year. The larvae cut leaves of Salvinia and pupated in a 'sandwich' made of two leaf portions. The presence of both these insects at such an early stage of Salvinia colonization bodes well for biological control of the weeds. Whereas neither insect could be expected to rapidly reduce a large existing weed population, their ef- fects on the growth of a small, expanding weed popula- tion may be considerable. Eichhornia was attacked by caterpillars of a single moth species. These fed on lamina and growth points of the plant and caused appreciable damage in September and October. They were, however, heavily parasitised by wasps and dipteran larvae and very few adults emerged from pupae. They are unlikely to be of importance in the future. The Curculionid weevil, Neochetina eichhorniae Warner and Orthogalumna terebrantis Wallwork, a mite, have been released in the Kafue River (Zambia) and in Rhodesia for Eichhornia control (Bennett in Mitchell, 1974). Ahmed (pers. comm. 1975) reports that no Neo- chetina has been recovered in the Kafue but that the mite is fairly common. Neither were seen at Cabora Bassa. Discussion Notable features of weed invasion at Cabora Bassa were the disjunct geographical distribution of the plants and the failure of expected explosive growth with cessation of Eichhornia offset production in the floating commu- nities and the very limited colonization by Salvinia. Floating macrophytes were concentrated in the ex- treme eastern and western parts of the lake (Table 5). Rapid filling led to a strong west-east current in the early months which carried weed to the dam wall. By the end of March the rate of change of lake level diminished (Fig. 2), the current ceased east of western Mucanha, and south-easterly winds blew weed onto the northern shores. Here most was destroyed by wave action leaving only a large concentration maintained in the west of the lake behind the physical barrier of the Carinde narrows by easterly winds. The effects of wind on wave action and dispersal were magnified by the rapid development of large stretches of open water due to high filling rates. The unexpectedly small area occupied by floating weeds at the end of I975 was due mostly to drawdown and cessation of offset production by Eichhornia towards the end of the year. Rapid drawdown (Fig. 2) ending in July stranded small mats remaining in the Chicoa and Mucanha Basins and curtailed weed colonization in these basins. Weed in the Gorge was reduced by 50o% and narrower bands near the Chicoa Basin were eradicated. Even greater proportions were stranded in the shallow 255 western basins. Recovery of surviving mats was, initially, considerable in the Gorge Basin but very limited in the west. However, offset production virtually ceased in the former area by the end of August and plant colonies re- mained static until the end of the year with most Eichhor- nia plants becoming streaked with yellow and later dying back from the tips of the laminae. No satisfactory explanation was found for this decline. Stratification of the Gorge, reflected by the development of thermoclines and oxyclines, began during the same period and lasted until the end of the year (Bond et al., in press, I977). Some chemical and physical parameters for this period are listed in Table 4. Temperature is unlikely to have limited growth except in shallow water in the summer months. (Temperatures of over 33°C were re- corded in sheltered waters in the Mucangadze Basin in November and probably inhibited growth here (Pen- found & Earle, 1948).) Light was probably adequate for Eichhornia growth but a shorter photoperiod in winter may account for some of the variation in seasonal growth rates as faster growth has been recorded in 8 hour daily photoperiods relative to 16 hour photoperiods (Bock, I969). pH ranges of 4 o 9 have been recorded by Bock (1966) and optima between 6 and 8 by Pariji (1934) in trials ranging from pH 4 to lo. pH exceeded 8 in surface waters from August onwards and values of more than 9 were recorded during the day in shallow, algae rich waters in the western basins at the start of the rainy season. High pH may therefore have had a limiting effect on Eichhor- nia growth rates. Overall nutritional requirements of Eichhornia crassi- pes are very low but the plant shows a strong response to NO 3 N in culture (Musil & Breen, 1977) and it seems probable that NO3 and possibly PO4 3 - normally limit growth under natural conditions. NO 3 showed a con- tinuous decline in water collected in the Gorge Basin (Table 4) and may be partly responsible for diminished growth rates. No significant variation in Ca++, Mg, Na+ or K+ was found during the year. Excesses or shortages of trace elements as suggested by yellowing of plant leaves, per- haps associated with stratification, may be the cause of decline in Eichhornia offset production but insufficient analyses are available for confirmation. Growth requirements of Salvinia molesta on Lake Kariba have been studied by Mitchell & Tur (I975). Growth rates are maximal at 30°C so that hot rainy season temperatures may limit growth. Light condi- tions, except under a canopy of taller plants such as Fich- hornia would be optimal. Nutrient deficiencies, particu- larly nitrogen and phosphorus, were considered the greatest limitation on potential growth rates of Salvinia at Kariba (Mitchell, 1973) and, since the water chemistry is similar (Bond et al., in press), are likely to be so at Cabora Bassa. If Eichhornia growth remains stagnant and Salvinia is not controlled by insects or wave action, Salvinia may yet prove to be a threat at Cabora Bassa. The dominance of Eichhornia in weed mats at the end of the year (Fig. 3) can be attributed to its initial growth rates. Whilst Eichhornia and Salvinia may have com- parable doubling times (Tables 6 and 7), the former has a greater capacity for rapid water surface coverage by virtue of the size of each offset. In addition exclusion of light by the Eichhornia canopy (plants up toI m high were recorded) probably limited Salvinia growth causing its decline in relative importance. Salvinia growth was also suppressed to some extent by arthropod and fish herbivores. Explosive growth of Salvinia in Lake Kariba has been well documented (Mitchell, I970, I973, 1975). Com- parisons of weed ecology in the two lakes may thus pro- vide further insight into the problems of floating macro- phytes in large impoundments. Climate over the two lakes is essentially similar (Harding, 1966, Begg, 1970, van der Lingen, 1973) al- though Cabora Bassa is somewhat hotter. The species composition of the problem macrophytes is similar except for the presence of Eichhornia crassipes at Cabora Bassa. However, differences between the lakes are pronounced both in their early history and their environmental set- tings. Cabora Bassa filled very rapidly whilst Kariba filled slowly with consequent effects on initial distribution of the weeds. Winds on Kariba blow across the lake axis, but on Cabora Bassa blow nearly parallel to it which, from dispersal patterns in the first year, suggest disparate patterns of invasion in the future. At Kariba very large areas of bush were cleared and burnt before filling where- as none was cleared at Cabora Bassa. This means that the weed will suffer less from wave action and be less mobile at Cabora Bassa. There are indications that Cabora Bassa will be more fertile than Kariba (Hall et al., 1976), but that the initial phase of high nutrient availability will be much shorter because of Cabora Bassa's rapid replacement time (Bond et al., in press). Growth potential for macrophytes may thus decline rapidly and Cabora Bassa may never reach 256 the high standing crop of Kariba. However, the potential for weed growth in the maturing phase of the lake may be far higher because of expected higher nutrient levels. Competition between Eichhornia and Salvinia, both aggressive weeds, did not occur in Kariba and may result in a less vigorous weed population in Cabora Bassa because of competition for limited resources. Mortality factors in the two lakes have operated in different ways. Kariba experienced its first major draw- down five years after closure. Waterlevel fluctuations were considerable in the first year at Cabora Bassa and eliminated much of the weed colony. For reasons de- scribed above invasion of weed from western riverine sources into weed free central basins will probably be slow at Cabora Bassa and thus the effects of early draw- downs may be persistent. Cabora Bassa also has a larger wind fetch which, in combination with a steep northern shore line, may result in greater mortality from wave ac- tion than occurs in Kariba, however, mortality may be limited in part by the protective bands of semi-sub- merged trees. Paulinia acuminata was released in Kariba more than a decade after lake closure. At Cabora Bassa Paulinia and other grazers of Salvinia were present in the invading weed population and are likely to limit its spread from the start. There was no evidence of serious arthropod infestation of Eichhornia but releases of insects in Zambia and Rhodesia will have an early effect on the weed if these animals do become established in the Kafue and Huny- ani rivers. Weed control was initiated at a very early stage at Cabora Bassa. Whilst the quantity of weed destroyed was relatively small, the removal of all plant mats in the central basins which were potential foci for exponential growth will doubtless have a significant effect on future colonization of the lake. No comparable control pro- gramme was carried out at Kariba in the early years of Salvinia invasion. A number of factors thus discourage comparisons of weed performance in the two lakes, and will be of varying importance at different stages of Cabora Bassa's history. Conclusion Experience at Cabora Bassa suggests that: Predictions of early colonization and subsequent growth of floating aquatic macrophytes in man-made lakes still cannot be made satisfactorily at the present time. In the case of Cabora Bassa there was no evidence of the generally expected explosive growth and high cover of floating macrophytes in the filling phase by the end of 1975. Location of aquatic weed colonies is a function of morphometry, wind speed and direction, and current. Analysis of wind and current patterns in relation to morphometry allows useful predictions of initial points of invasion. The influence of current and wind is modified by filling rates and lake morphology. Filling rates and drawdown can, theoretically, be adjusted to suit the needs of the biologist but, in practice, engineering con- siderations are likely to predominate in the early years. Weed mortality can be effected by control methods and drawdown. Control methods will be least costly and most effective in the early stages of colonization. Draw- down can disrupt biological communities, particularly as the lake matures (Bowmaker, 1973), but is possibly less harmful in the initial phase of lake development. Weed growth is effected by many variables, few of which can be predicted with any confidence before the lake fills. Mat composition will effect growth rates and can be assessed from pre-impoundment surveys of the lake catchment. Chemical composition of lake waters is a result of complex processes while the relevance of water analyses to plant growth is incompletely understood. Offset pro- duction is the main means of increase in water coverage for Eichhornia and appears to be physiologically distinct from increase in individual plant biomass. Laboratory growth studies seldom differentiate between the two processes. It thus seems likely that pre-impoundment predictions of floating macrophyte growth rates in large impoundments will remain 'rule of thumb' for some time to come. Summary i. Two notorious floating aquatic weeds, Salvinia moles- ta and Eichhornia crassipes, occur in the catchment of Cabora Bassa, a new man-made lake on the Zambezi River, Mocambique. Explosive population growth of either or both of these species was predicted during the initial filling phase of the lake. 2. Cabora Bassa, which is smaller than Lake Kariba, a large man-made lake also on the Zambezi River, has five basins seperated by islands and promontaries with steep northern but gently sloping southern shores in the central 257 basins. Prevailing winds are easterly to south-easterly blowing along the east-west axis except between Novem- ber and February when northerly and westerly winds are more common. 3. Lake filling (which commenced in December, 1974) was very rapid and surface currents carried large quan- tities of weed to the eastern outflow section of the lake. When lake levels stabilised macrophytes were concen- trated in the extreme east and west with scattered mats on northern shores of the central basins. 4. A narrow section of the western lake (the Carinde narrows) acted as a physical bottleneck to weed passage eastwards, particularly after surface currents ceased and easterly winds dominated plant dispersal. Mats remained largely stable in position until variable winds preceding thunderstorms at the end of the year lead to some re- distribution. The surface area of the lake covered by floating macrophytes never exceeded % in the first year of filling. 5. Initially Salvinia and Eichhornia were present in large quantities together with Pistia stratiotes. Salvinia was rapidly supressed by Pistia and both species by Eich- hornia a year after the dam closed. 6. Growth rates of three species was measured in floating enclosures as increment in offsets or leaves. Eichhornia grew very rapidly (doubling time ± 6 days) until September when rates diminished and, in the Gorge Basin, signs of nutrient deficiency developed. By the end of the year no offsets were being produced by this species. Increment in biomass, however, continued so that mats became dominated by tall central plants. No definite causes for the decline of offset production wereidentified. 7. Salvinia growth (increment in leaf number) was comparable to rates at Lake Kariba where it showed ex- plosive population growth. Its poor performance at Cabora Bassa is attributed to competition with Eichhor- nia in floating mats. 8. Rapid drawdown in July, I975, caused widespread stranding and death of floating plants and was the major mortality factor in the first year. Weed control by manu- al harvesting and herbicide spraying eliminated weed in the central basins and portions of the Gorge Basin. Pauli- nia acuminata, a grasshopper, and a moth, possibly Samea multiplicalis, were found on Salvinia molesta and the presence of these insect control agents at such an early stage may help control population increase. 9. Lake Kariba and Cabora Bassa, whilst in a similar climate and with similar water chemistry, differ in the events of lake filling, floating macrophyte species com- position, and morphometry suggesting that colonization by floating macrophytes will be dissimilar. to. It is concluded that dispersal and location of floating macrophytes at least in the early stages, can be predicted fairly well by a study of wind, current, lake morphometry and proposed filling events in man-made lakes but that growth rates and quantities of weed at any particular stage in a lakes history remains largely unpredictable. Acknowledgements We thank our colleagues N. Coe, G. Pitot and K. Rogers for assistance in data collection, Dr. D. Mitchell and Dr. Rose for advice and encouragement, the staff of Gabine- to do Plano do Zambeze and the Instituto Investigacao Agronomica de Moambique for arranging air flights, and Loxton, Hunting and Associates for laboratory analyses and their always helpful assistance. W. M. Bond provided invaluable assistance at all stages of the project. References Begg, G. W. 1970. Limnological observations on Lake Kariba during 1967 with emphasis on some special features. Limnol. Oceanogr. 25: 776-788. Bennett, F. D. 1974. Biological control, 99-106, in Aquatic Vege- tation and its use and control edited by D. S. Mitchell, Unesco. Bock, J. H. 1966. An ecological study of Eichhornia crassipes with special emphasis on its reproductive biology. Ph. D. Thesis, Univ. California, Berkeley. Bock, J. H. 1969. Productivity of the Water Hyacinth, Eichhornia crassipes (Mart) Solms. Ecology. 50: 461-4. Bond, W. J., Coe, N., Jackson, P. N. B. & Rogers, K. H. (in press). The limnology of Cabora Bassa, Moqambique, during its first year. Freshwater Biology. Bowmaker, A. P. 1973. Hydrophyte dynamics in Mwenda Bay, Lake Kariba. Kariba Studies. 3: 42-59. Davies, B. R., Hall, A. &Jackson, P. N. B. 1975. Some ecological aspects of the Cabora Bassa Dam. Biol. Conserv. 8: 189-201. Hall, A., Davies, B. R. & Valente, 1. 1976. Cabora Bassa: some preliminary physico-chemical and zooplankton pre-im- poundment results. Hydrobiologia (48) 1: 17-25. Harding, D. 1966. Lake Kariba, The hydrology and development of fisheries, in Man-Made Lakes, edited by R. H. Lowe- McConnell, 7-20 Academic, London. Hidrotecnica Portugesa 1973.lnstalacoes para navegacao na Albufeira de Cabora Bassa. Tomo 4. Gabinete do Plano do Zambeze, Lisboa. Jackson, P. B. N. & Davies, B. R. 1976. Cabora Bassa in its first year: some ecological aspects and comparisons. Rhodesia Science News. Io, No 5: 128-133. Lingen, M. 1. van der 1973. Lake Kariba: Early History and South Shore 132-142, in Man-Made Lakes: Their Problems 258 and Environmental Effects edited by W. C. Ackermann, G. F. White and E. B. Worthington. American Geophysical Union, Washington, D.C. Little, E. C. S. 1966. The invasion of man-made lakes by plants, in Man-Made Lakes, edited by R. H. Lowe-McConnell, 75-86, Academic, London. Macedo, J. de Aguiar 1974. Vegetacao aquatica em Cabora Bas- sa. Institute de investigacao agronomica de Moqambique. Memorias No. 5. Mitchell, D. S. 1970. Autoecological studies of Salvinia auricula- ta Aubl., Ph. D. thesis, Univ. of London. Mitchell, D. S. 1973. Aquatic weeds in Man-Made Lakes, 6o6- 61i, in Man-Made Lakes: Their Problems and Environmental Effects, edited by W. C. Ackermann, G. F. White and E. B. Worthington. American Geophysical Union, Washington, D.C. Mitchell, D. S. 1974. Editor, Aquatic Vegetation and its Use and Control. Unesco, Paris. Mitchell, D. S. & Tur, N. M. 1975. The rate of growth of Salvinia molesta (S. auriculata Auct.), in Laboratory and natural con- ditions. J. Appl. Ecol. 12: 213-225. Musil, C. F. & Breen, C. M. 1977. The application of growth kinetics to the control of Eichhornia crassipes through nutrient removal by chemical harvesting. Hydrobiologia. 53, 2: 167- 171. Oliveira, J. S. 1972. 'Zimofolia' Um novo alimento levedurizada. An. Inst. Sup. Agron., Lisbon. 32: 21-36. Parija, P. 1934. Physiological investigations on water hyacinth (Eichhornia crassipes) in Orisa with notes on some other aquatic weeds. Indian J. Agric. Science 4 (3): 399-429. Penfound, T. T. & Earle, W. T. 1948. The biology of the water hyacinth. Ecol. Monogr. 18: 447-72. Perkins, B. D. 1972. Potential for Waterhyacinth Management with biological agents. Procedings Annual Tall Timbers Con- ference on Ecological Animal Control by Habitat Manage- ment, 53-64. 259
Compartilhar