Baixe o app para aproveitar ainda mais
Prévia do material em texto
1073 We are not just surrounded by energy and vibration; we are energy and vibration. One of the best-known of all physics equations, e = mc2, points to a link between energy and matter. Matter is mostly composed of space that contains (or perhaps gives rise to) a smattering of subatomic particles/waves that influence one another through mysterious forces of attraction and repulsion. The nature of the interconnections of energy, physical reality, and consciousness is one of the great mysteries of our times. Quantum physics offers some tantalizing hints about these relationships, but we still have a great deal to learn. How do these concepts of physics—vibrations, fields, and energy—inform healing? Dozens, if not hundreds, of different cultures and traditions have terms referring to life energy, which includes vital forces that are closely linked to consciousness and animate everything that is alive. Terms used to name this force include chi, prana, pneuma, fohat, mana, and orgone. Throughout human history, people from different cultures and civilizations spanning the globe have suggested that it is possible to both perceive and manipulate this life force. In fact, what we refer to as our “conventional medicine” is something of a historical and geographical anomaly in the grander scheme. The term “biofield therapy” was coined in a 1992 National Institutes of Health (NIH) report,1 but energy medicine therapies are not new; they have been practiced for millennia. It is important that integrative clinicians be familiar with them. This chapter reviews key concepts of energy medicine and describes some of the most commonly used biofield therapies. Key research findings related to these healing approaches are summarized here and ways for clinicians to work collaboratively with energy medicine practitio- ners are suggested. The final section describes exercises you can try yourself. One caveat: Energy medicine is perhaps one of the most mysterious and controversial of all forms of ther- apy. An energy medicine practitioner once stated that as an African American, homosexual woman who practices reiki, she has been unpleasantly surprised to find that the most discrimination she has encountered in her adult life has not been linked to race, sexual orientation, or being a female, but rather to her energy medicine practice. Even for some of the most objective scientists, the topic of energy medicine strikes a highly emotional chord. A 1998 volume of JAMA went so far as to conclude that findings from a child’s school science project (which investigated one Therapeutic Touch (TT) practitioner’s ability to sense the presence of the child’s hands) offered “unrefuted evidence that the claims of TT are groundless and that further professional use is unjustified.”2 As integrative medicine providers explore the use of these therapies, the concept of “scope of practice” takes on a new meaning. At some point, every integrative pro- vider has to determine his or her stance regarding the validity and utility of these approaches. Patients will most certainly inquire about them. Whatever you decide about how biofield therapies fit (or do not fit) into your prac- tice, you should be able to discuss them knowledgeably with your patients. A second caveat: A textbook chapter can offer only a taste of this varied and complex array of therapies. Trying to understand energy medicine solely by reading about it is akin to trying to grasp Beethoven’s work by reading his biography instead of listening to his compositions or getting a sense of Van Gogh’s Starry Night without being able to look at it. In other words, you are strongly encour- aged to learn and explore through direct experience! Truly learning about human energetic therapies requires one to experience them firsthand. DEFINING ENERGY MEDICINE The National Center for Complementary and Alterna- tive Medicine, now the National Center for Comple- mentary and Integrative Health (NCCIH), originally classified human energetic therapies as one of five main categories of complementary medicine.3 They fur- ther classified them based on whether the energy being manipulated by practitioners was measurable (“verita- ble”) as opposed to subtle (“putative”). Because of politi- cal pressures, the NCCIH has scaled back on its support to biofield research or coverage of energy medicine in its web materials. Because there is some debate on whether certain types of subtle energy can be measured, the dis- tinction between veritable and putative may not be as helpful. In a well-done 2015 review of clinical studies of energy medicine featured in a themed edition of Global Advances in Health and Medicine, biofield therapies were defined as “noninvasive, practitioner-mediated therapies that explicitly work with the biofield of both the practi- tioner and client to stimulate a healing response in the client.”4 The biofield was defined in the same article as “endogenously generated fields, which may play a signifi- cant role in information transfer processes that contrib- ute to an individual’s state of mental, emotional, physical, and spiritual well-being.” According to 2002–12 data from the Centers for Dis- ease Control, a consistent 0.5% of the U.S. population C H A P T E R 1 1 6 Biofield Therapies J. Adam Rindfleisch, MPhil, MD Descargado para Daniela Alexandra Perez Diaz (dani.perez9009@gmail.com) en University Foundation Juan N Corpas de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en agosto 03, 2020. Para uso personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados. PART III Tools for Your PracTice1074 had used some form of energy medicine in the past year.3 The 2012 National Health Interview Survey found that more than 3.7 million U.S. adults have visited an energy medicine practitioner at some point and 1.5 million reported receiving a biofield therapy in the past year.5 Surveys may underestimate the use of energy medicine because practitioners of other modalities, such as mas- sage therapists, chiropractors, and naturopathic doctors, commonly blend energy medicine into their practices without labeling what they are doing as energy medicine per se. Research is limited on the use of energy medi- cine in hospitals, but a 2005 study reported that more than 50 U.S. hospitals and clinics formally offered energy medicine.6 Many different schools, or styles, of human energetic therapies exist, especially if one includes the various sha- manic techniques that have arisen in many of the world’s indigenous cultures. The Encyclopedia of Energy Medi- cine identifies nearly 50 popular approaches used in the United States.7 Although various approaches to energy medicine may work with different aspects, or parts, of the energy field or may enlist different techniques for manipulating or maneuvering energy, most share some common aspects, including the following:8 • They assume the presence of an energetic anatomy or pattern that has an influence on health. Examples include the chakra system, the aura, and the meridian system used in acupuncture. Some schools of thought propose the existence of several different layers, or levels, of the energy body, each with unique char- acteristics. Because the chakra system is intrinsic to most techniques and is often referenced by integrative medicine practitioners, it is described in more detail in Table 116.1. • Patterns in the energy body may precede or cause physical problems. They may also be linked to emo- tional, mental, social, or spiritual issues. • Most energy practitioners enlist one or more meth- ods of perceiving the energy field. For example, some practitioners claim to see it, some feel it through touch, some enlist the use of pendulums or other dowsing techniques to assess it, and some report being guided by intuition or direct knowing. Manyenlist the assistance of “helper” energies in their work. • Many healers have experienced a health crisis (taken the healer’s journey) themselves that precipitated their foray into energy healing. • Energy is said to respond to intention. Practitioners may manipulate energy through any number of means, which may include healing rituals, hands-on tech- niques, visualization exercises, or nonlocal (distant) healing practices. Table 116.2 lists various forms of human energetic therapies, with key websites for each. Although styles and forms of biofield therapies are myriad, many of them share common elements. TABLE 116.1 The Chakras Chakra Name(s)a Location in the Body Color Associated Issues First (root) Base of spine Red Physical health and security, materialism, body awareness Second Lower abdomen, just below umbilicus Orange Emotions, especially toward oneself, reproduction, creativity (in some traditions) Third Solar plexus (just below xyphoid) Yellow Mental well-being, logic, will, sense of control Fourth Heart area, but in midline rather than to the left Green (sometimes rose) Connections to others, relationships, forgiveness, compassion Fifth Throat Blue (sometimes turquoise) Self-expression, creative pursuits, speaking one’s truth Sixth (third eye) Center of forehead Indigo or violet Vision, perception, intuition, dreams Seventh (crown) Top and center of scalp Purple or white Spirituality, connection with a higher power, unity Eighth and higher Vary greatly among traditions; some describe an eighth chakra 6–12 inches over the seventh chakra and a ninth chakra 6–12 inches below the feet Varies (the one below the feet is said to be brown) Variable; eighth chakra sometimes described as a point where the boundaries of an individual begin to disappear; in some traditions, linked to the collective consciousness or past lives; ninth chakra may be tied to grounding, connection with the earth For more information on how energetic anatomy is conceptualized in different traditions, see the various websites listed in Table 116.2. aNames, numbers of chakras, and locations vary among different traditions. In Indian traditions, each chakra from 1 to 7 has an associ- ated sound (lam, vam, ram, yam, ham, am, and om, respectively), as well as a musical key (the first starts with C and the others follow up the scale). Each chakra is linked to different glands as well; this often guides how energy medicine practitioners work with different conditions. In some traditions, the glands are, from chakras 1 to 7, the adrenals, gonads, pancreas, thymus, thyroid, pituitary, and pineal, respectively. Some traditions ascribe adrenals to the third and some link the prostate to the first. Descargado para Daniela Alexandra Perez Diaz (dani.perez9009@gmail.com) en University Foundation Juan N Corpas de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en agosto 03, 2020. Para uso personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados. 116 Biofield Therapies 1075 TABLE 116.2 Energy Healing Modalities: Descriptions and Key Websitesa Energy Modality Description and Related Websitea Acupuncture and acupressure Needles are inserted into points said to be located along different meridians, or energy channels, within the body. In electroacupuncture, electricity is passed through the needles. http://www. yinyanghouse.com/. Look at the “Theory” section on the website. Barbara Brennan School of Healing This approach focuses on energy healing according to detailed descriptions of energy anatomy and flow. Many schools of healing are based on the experiences or techniques of a specific individual, and this is one example. http://www.barbarabrennan.com/ Crystal therapy and gem therapy Minerals are used to influence the energy field. Different stones are believed to have specific vibrational properties. http://www.livescience.com/40347-crystal-healing.html Emotional freedom techniques and thought field therapy These methods were created by Gary Craig and Roger Callahan, respectively. Tapping of various meridian points is said to release stored negative emotional energy. http://www.emofree.com/ and http://www.rogercallahan.com/index.php (highly commercial) Energy psychology Offered by mental health professionals who combine various forms of psychotherapy with energy medicine approaches. http://www.energypsych.org Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) Rapid alternation of eye movements from left to right and tapping of specific groups of points on the body are used in various patterns to release energy-based problems. http://www.emdr.com/ Flower essences Various flower extracts are said to influence people according to the nature or energy of the extracts’ plants of origin, http://www.bachcentre.com/. See the remedies section. Healing touch Developed in the 1980s by Janet Mentgen, RN, this method is based on principles used in therapeutic touch and other such techniques. Extensive instruction and training are required for certification. See the “Research/Integrative Health” section. http://www. healingtouchinternational.org/ Homeopathy Created by Samuel Hahnemann in 1796, this approach uses highly diluted solutions said to hold the vibrational principle of a given remedy, which is carefully tailored after a detailed evaluation of a person’s symptoms. http://www.homeopathic.org/ Jin shin jyutsu Developed by Jiru Murai in the early 1900s and brought to the West by Mary Burmeister in the 1960s, this method focuses on the use of 26 safety energy locks to unlock energy flow. http:// www.jsjinc.net/ Johrei Founded by Mokichi Okada, who envisioned a “paradise on earth” brought about through energetic detoxification and adherence to seven key principles. Does not involve direct physical touch. http://www.johreifoundation.org Matrix energetics This system of “consciousness technology” was created by Richard Bartlett, DC, ND. It holds that anyone can be a healer through manipulating the matrix of information that is the foundation on which a person’s reality is built. http://www.matrixenergetics.com/ Polarity therapy Based on the work of Randolph Stone, this approach combines diet, exercise, and other techniques to optimize the health of the energy field. http://www.polaritytherapy.org/ Pranic healing Systematized by Choa Kok Sui and tied to Arhatic yoga, this method involves visualizing colors and directing them through different techniques. http://www.pranichealing.org/ Qigong This technique enlists various precise body movements to alter one’s capacity to store and manipulate qi, or energy. http://www.qigonginstitute.org/main_page/main_page.php Quantum-touch In this system created by Richard Gordon, energy is directed through intention, breathwork, and other techniques, with a strong focus on musculoskeletal issues, among others. http://www. quantumtouch.com/ Reflexology Certain parts of the feet, believed to be correlated with various body parts, are massaged or treated with essential oils. http://www.reflexology-usa.org/ Reiki This technique originated in Japan with Mikao Usui. Trainees are given attunements said to allow them to pass universal healing energy through them to others. Many different schools exist. http://www.reiki.org Shamanic healing This modality is often classed as spiritual, rather than energetic. The healer intuitively determines the source of a health problem and enlists rituals, helpful spirits, journeys to the spirit world, or other techniques to bring about healing. Hundreds of shamanic traditions exist. https://www. shamanism.com Therapeutic touch This technique was developed in the 1970s by Dolores Krieger, a nurse, and Dora Kunz. Gentle touch is used to influence the biofield. http://www.therapeutictouch.org/ Zero balancing Created by Fritz Smith, MD, in the 1970s, this method holds that gentle touch and tractioncan balance energy at a “zero point,” a place where the energetic and physical bodies are aligned. http://www.zerobalancing.com aTable based, in part, on data from Rindfleisch JA. Biofield therapies: energy medicine and primary care. Prim Care. 2010;27:165–179. This list is by no means comprehensive. For instance, prayer and spiritual healing are also classified by some investigators as human ener- getic therapies. All websites accessed 12.15.15. Descargado para Daniela Alexandra Perez Diaz (dani.perez9009@gmail.com) en University Foundation Juan N Corpas de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en agosto 03, 2020. Para uso personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados. http://www.yinyanghouse.com/ http://www.yinyanghouse.com/ http://www.barbarabrennan.com/ http://www.livescience.com/40347-crystal-healing.html http://www.emofree.com/ http://www.rogercallahan.com/index.php http://www.energypsych.org http://www.emdr.com/ http://www.bachcentre.com/ http://www.healingtouchinternational.org/ http://www.healingtouchinternational.org/ http://www.homeopathic.org/ http://www.jsjinc.net/ http://www.jsjinc.net/ http://www.johreifoundation.org http://www.matrixenergetics.com/ http://www.polaritytherapy.org/ http://www.pranichealing.org/ http://www.qigonginstitute.org/main_page/main_page.php http://www.quantumtouch.com/ http://www.quantumtouch.com/ http://www.reflexology-usa.org/ http://www.reiki.org https://www.shamanism.com https://www.shamanism.com http://www.therapeutictouch.org/ http://www.zerobalancing.com PART III Tools for Your PracTice1076 ENERGY MEDICINE RESEARCH Through technology, we routinely perceive and manip- ulate various forms of energy. Our smartphones and televisions can pick up precise frequencies from among thousands that bounce through the atmosphere. West- ern medicine relies on energetic properties of the body to obtain electrocardiograms (ECGs), electroencephalo- grams (EEGs), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans, computed tomography (CT) scans, x-ray studies, and many other tests. All these devices are powered by elec- tricity, another form of energy. Research has shown that human energetic therapies can pos- itively influence outcomes in numerous circumstances, but much remains to be learned about the mechanism of action, the differences among different energy modalities in their effect, and the best ways to integrate these approaches into other types of healing practices. We are aware that energy fields of different individ- uals interact. When people are near one another, each one’s EEG patterns can reflect in the others; to use the quantum physics term, their patterns entrain.9 A 1994 study reported that, for some pairs of people who knew each other and had a certain degree of rapport, one per- son’s brain seemed to instantaneously relay informa- tion to another’s over a distance.10 This was the case even when the people were in different rooms and one of those rooms was an electromagnetically impenetrable (Faraday) chamber. Investigators reported that flashing lights viewed by one subject influenced the EEG for the ophthalmic region of the brain of his or her partner in the sealed room.9 This study was heavily criticized, but a 2004 study reported similar findings.10 What is the status of energy medicine research? The current body of research on human energetic therapies is relatively small but steadily growing, and some fascinat- ing discoveries have been made. The following three important suppositions related to energetic therapies need to be validated for energy medicine to be considered plausible from a scientific standpoint: 1. Subtle energy exists, and it has scientifically validated mechanisms of action through which it influences biological systems. 2. People can perceive and manipulate this energy. 3. Manipulating this energy has clinically important, beneficial effects on health. Fascinating studies have explored suppositions 1 and 2, with remarkable results that raise more questions than they answer. Quantum biology, biophoton emissions studies, macroscopic quantum effects, and an array of novel measurement devices have offered insights into the mechanism of action of energy therapies.11,12 Other research indicates that test subjects can influence ran- dom number generators and gather information about distant, unseen objects or events that will occur in the near future better than what would be predicted by chance alone.9,13 As for the supposition 3 that energy therapies have clinically meaningful effects, the body of research is slowly growing. For instance, a study conducted in Hawaii found that 11 energy practitioners were able to alter brain activity on functional MRI scans. They were asked to select someone with whom they felt a close con- nection, and then, once they were separated from their partners by hundreds of miles, they were asked to send “distant intentionality” at random 2-minute intervals. The recipients were blinded to the timing of these trans- missions. Functional MRI findings indicated that activ- ity levels in several areas of the brains of the recipients changed precisely at the time the healers were sending their intentions (p = .0000127).14 A 2014 review was unable to pinpoint any specific physiological changes in biofield therapists, such as alter- ations in biomarker levels in their blood, related to being in a “healing state.”15 Table 116.3 summarizes some of the key clinical studies of the effectiveness of human energetic thera- pies focusing primarily on meta-analyses and systematic reviews.4,16-43 The most commonly studied therapies are healing touch, reiki, and therapeutic touch. GUIDELINES FOR MAKING AN ENERGY MEDICINE REFERRAL The keys to making an appropriate referral to an energy medicine practitioner are in many ways similar to those when one refers to any sort of nonbiomedical or “com- plementary,” practitioner: 1. Know the practice and the practitioner. This not only includes knowing in general about the nature of the modality practiced but also means being aware of the practitioner’s qualifications and training. How willing is the practitioner to work collaboratively with West- ern medicine practitioners? Both innate talent and the amount of experience influence a given healer’s effec- tiveness.8 The best way to get to know providers is to experience their practice as a client. 2. Know when to refer. Many energy medicine prac- titioners suggest that any patient-related concern is “fair game” when someone is referred for energy work. However, keep in mind that not all providers work according to the Western medicine diagnostic categories. Trust your instincts as the referral pro- vider. According to many practitioners, biofield ther- apies are especially worthy of consideration for the following: • People with generally heightened sensitivity. These people are often uncomfortable with crowds; highly intuitive; finely attuned to the feelings of others; or very sensitive to foods, medications, or environmental pathogens. • People with a history of severe emotional traumas • People with pain (physical or otherwise) • People with fatigue or a sense that they can never “keep their energy in.” This can include those who are constantly giving to or supporting others and not tak- ing time for their own needs. Descargado para Daniela Alexandra Perez Diaz (dani.perez9009@gmail.com) en University Foundation Juan N Corpas de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en agosto 03, 2020. Para uso personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados. 116 Biofield Therapies 1077 TABLE 116.3 Summary of Key Systematic Reviews, Meta-Analyses, and Randomized Controlled Trials Relating to the Clinical Efficacy of Human Energetic Therapies Focus of Studies FindingsGeneral Reviews • A 2015 review reported that more than 30 trials have now been done focusing on energy medicine and pain.4 Although energy medicine seems to decrease pain intensity, the review noted that therapeutic effects are less clear when certain pain measurement instruments are used. The same review noted that more than 15 stud- ies of biofield therapies for cancer exist, mostly focused on the treatment of adjunctive symptoms.4 Results were most favorable where depression and fatigue were concerned, but only a few studies found benefit. A 2011 review concluded that energy medicine had no benefit in the treatment of pain based on the findings of 6 quantitative and 2 qualitative studies,16 and a 2014 review came to the same conclusions.17 • A 2015 review of 30 palliative care-related studies published from 2008–13 concluded research “supports the use of biofield therapies in relieving pain, improving QOL and well-being, and reducing psychological symp- toms of stress.”18 • A 2015 review of biofield therapy studies that focused on nonhuman subjects (plants and cell cultures) found that biofield therapies led to a significant improvement in well-being relative to controls.19 • A 2010 systematic review of 67 studies concluded that biofield therapies “…are promising complementary interventions for reducing pain intensity in numerous populations, reducing anxiety for hospitalized popula- tions, and reducing agitated behaviors in dementia, beyond what may be expected from standard treatment or nonspecific effects. Effects on long-term clinical outcomes are less clear, and more systematic research is needed.”20 • A 2008 Cochrane Review evaluated findings for 1153 patients in 5 healing touch, 15 therapeutic touch, and 5 reiki trials to determine whether touch therapies were helpful for pain. Pain was reduced by an average of 0.83 points on the 10-point pain rating scale, with a 95% confidence interval of −1.16 to −0.5. The investigators concluded that “touch therapies may have a modest effect on pain relief.”21 • A 2003 research survey reviewed 2200 published reports related to spiritual healing, energy, medicine, and the effects of mental intention. Findings were summarized as follows:22,23 • 75% of 130 studies on the link between religious/spiritual practices and health showed positive findings, but the overall study quality was poor. Nearly all the research was observational. • 11 out of 19 trials of energy healing involving 1122 people reported positive effects (Cohen’s D ef- fect of 0.6). Overall research quality was judged as fair (Jadad score, 3–4 out of 5). Most trials involved Therapeutic Touch. Healing Touch • A 2011 systematic review of 5 out of 332 reviewed studies concluded that “Though the studies support the potential clinical effectiveness of Healing Touch in improving health-related quality of life in chronic disease management, more studies are required given that even the studies included with high-quality scores had limitations.”24 • A trial conducted in 2011 found that a combination of Healing Touch and guided imagery reduced PTSD symptoms in a group of 123 returning active duty military personnel.25 • A 2004 review concluded that although 30 available studies of Healing Touch did not allow for generalized conclusions, the technique holds promise.26 • A 2010 pilot study found that Healing Touch lowered stress and improved heart rate variability in 9 pediatric oncology patients.27 • Vitality, pain, and physical functioning was improved in a group of 78 women with gynecological cancers who were undergoing radiation therapy.28 • Healing Touch decreased anxiety and length of stay in patients recovering from coronary bypass surgery, but it led to no change in pain medication or antiemetic use or atrial fibrillation incidence.29 Reiki • A 2015 Cochrane review found that there was insufficient evidence to confirm whether or not Reiki is benefi- cial in people above the age of 16 years with anxiety or depression.30 • A 2014 review compiled effect sizes from 12 articles that met criteria and concluded that Reiki has beneficial effects in pain and anxiety. 31 • A 2011 randomized controlled trial found that reiki had a significant positive effect on the mood of anxious or depressed students that lasted for 5 weeks.32 • A 2009 review that included 12 studies found that 9 of them reported significant therapeutic effects of Reiki, but 11 of the 12 studies were ranked as poor quality based on the Jadad score.33 • A 2010 study conducted in a Yale University cardiology ward found that heart rate variability and positive emotional status improved markedly with the provision of Reiki to patients, as compared with patients in the control group or those who listened to meditative music.34 • Review of study data through 2007 concluded that the benefit of Reiki “remains unproven.”35 • A review by Vitale in 2007 held that the Reiki literature includes one of four studies with significant findings for stress and depression, one study with significant findings for acute pain, and one of three studies that showed benefit for chronic pain.36 Therapeutic Touch • A 2014 Cochrane Review found therapeutic touch not helpful for acute wound healing.37 A 2010 study found that therapeutic touch improved pain and fatigue in a study of 90 patients undergoing chemotherapy.38 • A 2010 study of 21 postoperative patients found that therapeutic touch significantly decreased pain, cortisol, and natural killer cell levels.39 • A 2007 Cochrane Review did not find any good-quality studies to assess the general effect of therapeutic touch on anxiety.40 • A 2008 review concluded that therapeutic touch does reduce pain and anxiety in patients with cancer.41 • Therapeutic touch was found to decrease behavioral symptoms in people with dementia.42 In a subsequent study of a group of 64 residential patients, this technique was found to decrease restlessness and cortisol variability significantly.43 Descargado para Daniela Alexandra Perez Diaz (dani.perez9009@gmail.com) en University Foundation Juan N Corpas de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en agosto 03, 2020. Para uso personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados. PART III Tools for Your PracTice1078 • Those who seem “starved for energy.” This group in- cludes those patients who leave a provider completely drained at the end of a visit. • Anyone who lacks focus or seems “ungrounded.” • Patients suffering from an array of nonspecific or un- related complaints or whose symptoms cannot be eas- ily explained from a biomedical perspective • Patients whose chief complaints have something of a supernatural or paranormal bent. Again, the integra- tive providers’ belief system will guide how they ap- proach such concerns. 3. Be aware of safety concerns. Energy medicine has a very low risk of negative effects or outcomes, although one must use caution about relying on human energet- ic therapies to the exclusion of conventional, poten- tially lifesaving interventions, especially during life- threatening emergencies or when dealing with severe physical trauma. In addition, patients with psychosis may not do well with energetic approaches. The use of energy medicine can be considered to maintain health or to treat practically any condition, with minimal adverse effects. Caution is recommended for use in people with a history of psychosis or when it could lead to a delay in potentially life-saving allopathic interventions. 4. Obtain feedback from the recipients of the care. Are people getting better after you refer them? Is healing occurring? INCORPORATING ENERGY MEDICINE APPROACHES INTO ONE’S OWN PRACTICE As with any approach to healing, practitioners must find appropriate mentorship when adopting new techniques. However, energymedicine is an approach that can be attempted by anyone. Many practitioners teach the fam- ily members or friends of an ill person techniques that they can practice with their loved ones themselves. The exercises in this chapter are starting points. As you gain experience, create your own, tailoring to the needs of your specific practice. Explore and have fun! As you experiment with these exercises, keep in mind that a health care provider should not “take on” the energy of others nor is it appropriate for him or her to feel that personal energy is lost during energy work with another person. Always ask for permission before doing one of these exercises with someone. Be sure to allow the recipient of the practice to have sufficient time to recover afterward; some people move into a trancelike state as they work with these techniques. Persons famil- iar with interactive guided imagery and mindfulness practices will note that many energy exercises contain elements of both. The following four practices can be readily incorpo- rated into a patient encounter: 1. Sensing the biofield 2. Grounding 3. Charging up your energy 4. Setting appropriate boundaries 5. Draining away a symptom Sensing the Biofield According to energy medicine practitioners, the bio- field may be perceived in a variety of ways. While it is not clear whether people who claim to see energy actu- ally experience their visuals due to photons striking their retinas or kinesthetic people sense an actual vibration or temperature change that triggers their sense of touch, it is nevertheless common for people to report that they interpret their awareness of energy medicine through one or more senses or through emotions and feelings. That said, some people report that they have a “direct know- ing” of information that does not come through one of their five senses. • With light levels low, face your partner while they sit in front of a monochromatic background. Look past them to a focal point a few feet behind them. Note any senses, especially in your peripheral vision, of light distortions (blurriness), colors, or sparks. • Next, tune into your sense of hearing. As you face your partner, do you notice any sounds, hear words or mu- sic, or pick up on any other auditory imagery? • Take your partner’s hands in yours. What do you no- tice through your sense of touch? People who sense energy through touch often report temperature changes, vibrations, or tingling. • Bring your attention to your heart area. What do you notice as you focus on your emotions? What is your partner feeling, or what feelings arise for you? • Take time to share your impressions with your part- ner. Trade places, and have them do the same for you. Grounding This exercise can be used when people seem overly dis- tracted by their emotions or too much “in their head,” thinking about an issue but not remaining aware in other ways. Grounding can be helpful for bringing someone into the present moment or into a more enhanced aware- ness of their physical state. It is also good for people who tend to go off on tangents in conversation. This exercise can be useful for providers before, between, or follow- ing encounters with patients. Caution: Some people cope with pain or suffering by not being grounded; this exer- cise may be stressful to them. • Remove your footwear as able. Socks are permissible. • Sit up or lie straight. If possible, the soles of your feet should be kept in contact with the floor. • Keep your legs and arms uncrossed, if possible. • After a few slow, deep breaths, bring all your attention to the soles of the feet. Imagine the breath moving in and out through them. Continue until this feels com- fortable. If you feel any resistance, simply note it and continue to breathe. Descargado para Daniela Alexandra Perez Diaz (dani.perez9009@gmail.com) en University Foundation Juan N Corpas de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en agosto 03, 2020. Para uso personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados. 116 Biofield Therapies 1079 • Feel, visualize, or imagine the outward breath that the feet are extending into the ground like the roots of the tree, slowly spreading through the soil. Sense how these roots add stability and a sense of connection with the earth. • With each inward breath, feel, visualize, or imagine energy flowing into the feet through those roots, the way that nutrients and water flow into a tree. Let the energy move into the body up through the feet and to wherever it is needed. • Continue this exercise for at least 20 breaths. • It may be helpful to follow this exercise with an over- all body scan, in which a person is asked to tune in sequentially, without judging or analyzing, to various parts of the body. (e.g., “Focus on your left toes…then your left foot…then the ankle…knee…thigh”) Charging Up Your Energy Many variations of this exercise exist. It can be done by anyone who is feeling fatigued or weary as well as by someone intending to share energy with another person. The best approach always is to maintain your own energy level and allow additional energy to flow through to oth- ers without ever feeling that you are losing your own energy in the process. • In a place that feels safe, assume a comfortable posi- tion and close your eyes. You may find it helpful to place your hands on your lap, with the palms facing upward. • Bring your awareness to the breath, and take several deep breaths. • When you inhale, begin by imagining white light mov- ing in through the soles of the feet and up through the body to the heart. • After the flow from the feet to the heart can be per- ceived, do the same with the top of the head, and imagine white light moving in, down through the cen- ter of the head, neck, and chest, to the heart. • Continue this process, and allow the heart to fill and overflow with the white light. Thinking about what- ever fills your heart with the strongest sense of joy, compassion, love, or enthusiasm is often helpful. • Once the heart feels full, it should remain so through the rest of the exercise. Repeat the previous steps if the heart does not continue to feel full. • As the heart overflows, send the white light (or, if pre- ferred, the feeling of love or compassion) from the heart and down the arms into the hands. This energy is ready to be shared with another part of your own body by placing the palms over wherever extra energy is desired. It may also be shared with another person, with permission. Setting Appropriate Boundaries This exercise is especially helpful to people who feel overwhelmed by the energy, emotions, or simply the physical presence of others. It may be useful for people with fibromyalgia, whose senses are heightened to a point of causing dysfunction, or for people with chronic fatigue, whose energy seems to leak out of them in a way they cannot control. This practice may also be useful for people who feel as though others are somehow draining their energy. It can help a person feel less defensive or adversarial. • Ideally, this exercise should be done at a time and place where you feel safe enough to close your eyes. • Take a moment to tune in to how you feel, right now. Do you feel drained? Tired? Overwhelmed? Where in the body do you have these feelings? Where do you feel vulnerable? • After several deep breaths, imagine yourself surround- ed by a clear, bright, white, force field. This force field surrounds you like a protective bubble that allows in only what you choose and deflects anything that is un- necessary or harmful away from you. • Strengthen the force field in any places where you feel vulnerable. • If desired, you can choose to maintain the knowledge of whatever bounces off the force field; understand thatyou can do this without it affecting you emotion- ally or energetically. • Imagine white light radiating from a point at the exact center of the bubble of force that clears out anything that does not belong inside the bubble. • Enhance the force field further by using additional imagery, sounds, or feelings that you associate with strength and well-being. Pause after adding each extra layer, and focus on the breath. • With practice, a person can rapidly move through this exercise before entering an uncomfortable environ- ment or facing a challenging interpersonal encounter. This exercise can also be good to be use on first awak- ening or when retiring for the night. Draining Away a Symptom Healing touch and other human energetic therapies often use this technique in various forms. This exercise can be helpful when a symptom can be localized to a specific area of the body. For example, a pain drain can be used for headaches or joint pain. Practitioners can also ask those experiencing emotional pain about where in the body they feel it the most. • Close your eyes and focus on the part of the body where you feel the pain, discomfort, or imbalance most strongly. • Describe what you notice there. Does it have a color? Is it an image? A memory? What sound do you hear when you tune into this area? What is the temperature of this area, and how does it feel compared with the rest of your body? • Take some time to focus your awareness on the dis- comfort. This can be distressing, given that we may spend time trying to avoid, ignore, or control our symptoms. Just observe. Stay as neutral as possible. • Now, focus on how the area should be. At its healthi- est, how does it look, sound, and feel? Take time to develop a strong sense of this. Again, stay objective. • With each exhalation, envision the symptom—all that you noticed about it—being exhaled. Some people let it leave with the breath, and others release it into the ground through the bottoms of their feet. Some Descargado para Daniela Alexandra Perez Diaz (dani.perez9009@gmail.com) en University Foundation Juan N Corpas de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en agosto 03, 2020. Para uso personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados. PART III Tools for Your PracTice1080 people release it in the form of emotions that arise. For others, it just seems to fade away. • With each inhalation, breathe in your sense of how the part of your body receiving your attention can feel at its healthiest, at its most whole. Draw in the imagery related to health that you generated for this location. This can come in with the breath, through the top of the head, through the bottoms of the feet, or in any other way that seems appropriate. As a provider present with someone doing this exer- cise, you can often enhance the experience by placing your hand on or near the part of the patient’s body that is receiving attention. If it seems appropriate, you may envision sending what is required through yourself. Use the steps outlined in the grounding exercise to ensure that you are not giving your own energy, but rather letting it flow into and through you, as though you are an antenna. Similarly, if you, the provider, feel comfortable doing so, you may feel or see the symptom being released from the person being healed into your hands. If this occurs, simply intend that whatever is released be deflected away from both the patient and you into the ground. If you choose to try energy medicine exercises with those who seek your care, feel free to experiment. Shape these or other exercises as you find appropriate, and develop some of your own. If you find the foregoing exercises helpful, you may want to consider some of the following resources, which offer other useful exercises and ways of conceptualizing human energetic therapies: • Brennan BA. Hands of Light: A Guide to Healing Through the Human Energy Field. New York: Bantam Dell; 1993. • Brennan BA. Light Emerging: The Journey of Personal Healing. New York: Bantam Dell; 1993. • Bruyere RL. Wheels of Light: Chakras, Auras, and the Healing Energy of the Body. New York: Fireside; 1994. • Dale C. The Subtle Body: An Encyclopedia of Your Ener- getic Anatomy. Boulder, CO: Sounds True; 2009. • Dale C. The Subtle Body Practice Manual: A Compre- hensive Guide to Energy Healing. Boulder, CO: Sounds True; 2013. • Eden D. Energy Medicine for Women: Aligning Your Body’s Energies to Boost Your Health and Vitality. New York: Tarcher Penguin; 2008. • Eden D. Energy Medicine: Balancing Your Body’s Ener- gies for Optimal Health, Joy, and Vitality. New York: Tarcher Penguin; 2008. • Gordon R. Quantum Touch: The Power to Heal. 3rd ed. Berkeley, CA: North Atlantic Books; 2006. • Ingerman S. Shamanic Journeying: A Beginner’s Guide. Boulder, CO: Sounds True; 2008. • Myss CM. Anatomy of the Spirit: The Seven Stages of Power and Healing. New York: Random House; 1996. • Weil A, Chiasson AM. Self-Healing with Energy Medi- cine (Self Healing CD Series). Boulder, CO: Sounds True; 2009. Key Web Resourcesa International Society for the Study of Subtle Energies and Energy Medicine: Group devoted to the study of energy medicine that publishes a newslet- ter and hosts annual conferences focused on energy medicine http://www. issseem.org/ Alternative Medicine Foundation resource guide on energy work: Provides descriptions, links, and introductory readings for a number of different energy medicine modalities. http://amfoun- dation.org/ energywork. htm Institute of Noetic Sciences: Group dedi- cated to the study of consciousness and energetic, founded by astronaut Edgar Mitchell http://www. noetic.org/ aSee also the websites listed in Table 116.2. REFERENCES References are available online at ExpertConsult.com. Descargado para Daniela Alexandra Perez Diaz (dani.perez9009@gmail.com) en University Foundation Juan N Corpas de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en agosto 03, 2020. Para uso personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados. http://www.issseem.org/ http://www.issseem.org/ http://amfoundation.org/energywork.htm http://amfoundation.org/energywork.htm http://amfoundation.org/energywork.htm http://amfoundation.org/energywork.htm http://www.noetic.org/ http://www.noetic.org/ http://ExpertConsult.com 1080.e1 REFERENCES 1. Rubik B, Pavek R, Greene E, Laurence D, Ward R, Al E: Manual healing methods. In Rubik B, et al., editors: Alternative medicine: expanding medical horizons: a report to the National Institutes of Health on alternative medical systems and practices in the United States, vol. 1005. Washington, DC, US Government Printing Office, pp 113–157. 2. Rosa L, Rosa E, Sarner L, Barrett S: A close look at therapeutic touch, JAMA 279(13):1005–1010, 1998. 3. brainline.org Energy Medicine: An overview. http://www.brain- line.org/content/2009/06/energy-medicine-an-overview_pageall. html; Accessed 15.02.12. 4. Jain S, Hammerschlag R, Mills P, et al.: Clinical studies of biofield therapies: summary, methodological challenges, and recommenda- tions. Global Adv Health Med 4(Suppl):58–66, 2015. 5. US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National health interview survey: 2012 data release. http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nhis/ nhis_2012_data_release.htm. 2012 National Health Interview Sur- vey (NHIS) Adult Complementary and Alternative Medicine Pub- lic Use File, 2013. Accessed 15.12.15. 6. DiNucci EM: Energy healing: a complementary treatment for orthopaedic and other conditions, Orthop Nurs 24:259–269, 2005. 7. Thomas L: The encyclopedia of energy medicine, Minneapolis, MN, 2010, Fairview Press. 8. Cassidy CM: What does it mean to practice an energy medicine? J Altern Complement Med 10:79–81,2004. 9. Schwartz GE, Simon WL: The energy healing experiments: science reveals our natural power to heal, New York, 2007, Atria Books. 10. Zylberbaum JG, Delaflor M, Attie L, Goswami A: The Einstein- Podolsky-Rosen paradox in the brain: the transferred potential, Phys Essays 7:422–428, 1994. 11. Oschman JL: Energy medicine: the scientific basis, New York, 2002, Churchill Livingstone. 12. Kafatos MC, Chevalier G, Chopra D, Hubacher J, Kak S, Theises ND: Biofield science: current physics perspectives, Global Adv Health Med 4(Suppl):25–34, 2015. 13. Bem DJ: Feeling the future: experimental evidence for anomalous retroactive influences on cognition and affect, J Pers Soc Psychol 100:407–425, 2011. 14. Achterberg J, Cooke K, Richards T: Evidence for correlations between distant intentionality and brain function in recipients: a functional magnetic resonance imaging analysis, J Altern Comple- ment Med 11:965–971, 2005. 15. Baldwin AL, Hammerschlag R: Biofield-based therapies: a system- atic review of physiological effects on practitioners during healing, Explore 10:150–161, 2014. 16. Agdal R, Hjelmborg JvB, Johannessen H: Energy healing for can- cer: a critical review, Forsh Komplementmed 18:146–154, 2011. 17. Gonella SG, Garrina L, Dimonte V: Biofield therapies and cancer related symptoms: a review, Clin J Oncol Nurs 18(5): 568–576, 2014. 18. Hennaghan AM, Schnyer RN: Biofield therapies for symptomatic management in palliative care and end-of-life, Am J of Hosp Palliat Med 32(1):90–100, 2015. 19. Roe CA, Sonnex C, Roxburgh EC: Two meta-analysis of noncon- tact healing studies, Explore 11:11–23, 2015. 20. Jain S, Mills PJ: Biofield therapies: helpful or full of hype? A best evidence synthesis, Int J Behav Med 17:1–16, 2010. 21. So PS, Jiang Y, Qin Y: Touch therapies for pain relief in adults, Cochrane Database Syst Rev (4):CD006535, 2008. 22. Jonas WB, Crawford CC: Science and spiritual healing: a critical review of spiritual healing, “energy medicine,” and intentionality, Altern Ther Health Med 9:56–61, 2003. 23. Jonas WB, Crawford CC: Healing, intention and energy medicine: science, research methods, and clinical implications, Philadelphia, 2003, Churchill Livingstone. 24. Anderson JG, Taylor AG: Effects of healing touch in clinical prac- tice: a systematic review of randomized clinical trials, J Holist Nurs 29(3):221–228, 2011. 25. Jain S, McMahon GF, Hasen P, et al.: Healing touch with guided imagery for PTSD in returning active duty military: a randomized controlled trial, Mil Med 177(9):1015–1021, 2012. 26. Wardell DW, Weymouth KF: Review of studies of healing touch, J Nurs Scholarsh 36:147–154, 2004. 27. Kemper KJ, Fletcher NB, Hamilton CA, McLean TW: Impact of healing touch on pediatric oncology outpatients: pilot study, J Soc Integr Oncol 7:12–18, 2009. 28. Cook CA, Guerrerio JF, Slater VE: Healing touch and quality of life in women receiving radiation treatment for cancer: a random- ized controlled trial, Altern Ther Health Med 10:34–40, 2004. 29. MacIntyre B, Hamilton J, Fricke T: The efficacy of healing touch in coronary artery bypass surgery recovery: a randomized clinical trial, Altern Ther Health Med 4:24–32, 2008. 30. Joyce J, Herbison GP: Reiki for depression and anxiety, Cochrane Database of Syst Rev (4):CD006833, 2015. 31. Thrane S, Cohen SM: Effect of Reiki therapy on pain and anxiety in adults: an in-depth literature review of randomized trials with effect size calculations, Pain Manag Nurs 15(4):897–908, 2014. 32. Bowden D, Goddard L, Gruzelier J: A randomized controlled sin- gle-blind trial fo the efficacy of reiki at benefitting mood and well- being, Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 2011:381862, 2011. 33. vanderVaart S, Gijsen VM, de Wildt SN, Koren G: A systematic review of the therapeutic effects of Reiki, J Altern Complement Med 15:1157–1169, 2009. 34. Friedman RSC, Burg MM, Miles P, et al.: Effects of Reiki on auto- nomic activity early after acute coronary syndrome, J Am Coll Car- diol 56:995–996, 2010. 35. Lee MS, Pittler MH, Ernst E: Effects of Reiki in clinical practice: a systematic review of randomized clinical trials, Int J Clin Pract 62:947–954, 2008. 36. Vitale A: An integrative review of reiki touch therapy research, Holist Nurs Pract 21:167–179, 2007. 37. O’Mathuna DP, Ashford RL: Therapeutic touch for healing acute wounds, Cochrane Database Syste Rev 7:CD002766, 2014. 38. Aghabati N, Mohammadi E, Esmaiel Z: The effect of therapeutic touch on pain and fatigue of cancer patients undergoing chemo- therapy, Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 7:375–381, 2010. 39. Coakley AB, Duffy ME: The effect of therapeutic touch on postop- erative patients, J Holist Nurs 28:193–200, 2010. 40. Robinson J, Biley FC, Dolk H: Therapeutic touch for anxiety dis- orders, Cochrane Database Syst Rev (3):CD006240, 2007. 41. Jackson E, Kelley M, McNeil P: Does therapeutic touch help reduce pain and anxiety in patients with cancer? Clin J Oncol Nurs 12:113–120, 2008. 42. Wood DL, Craven RF, Whitney J: The effect of therapeutic touch on behavioral symptoms of persons with dementia, Altern Ther Health Med 11:66–74, 2005. 43. Woods DL, Beck C, Sinha K: The effect of therapeutic touch on behavioral symptoms and cortisol in persons with dementia, Fosrch Komplementmed 16:181–189, 2009. Descargado para Daniela Alexandra Perez Diaz (dani.perez9009@gmail.com) en University Foundation Juan N Corpas de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en agosto 03, 2020. Para uso personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados. http://www.brainline.org/content/2009/06/energy-medicine-an-overview_pageall.html http://www.brainline.org/content/2009/06/energy-medicine-an-overview_pageall.html http://www.brainline.org/content/2009/06/energy-medicine-an-overview_pageall.html http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nhis/nhis_2012_data_release.htm http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nhis/nhis_2012_data_release.htm 116 - Biofield Therapies Defining Energy Medicine Energy Medicine Research Sensing the Biofield Grounding Charging Up Your Energy Setting Appropriate Boundaries Draining Away a Symptom
Compartilhar