Premissas Metodológicas e Conceituais para Compreender o Controle de Constitucionalidade

Prévia do material em texto

!"#$%%&%'(")*+*,-.$/&%'"'0*1/"$)2&$%'3&!&'0*#3!""1+"!'*'0*1)!*,"'+"'0*1%)$)2/$*1&,$+&+" 4
 !"#$%%&% '"()*)+,-$.&% " /)0."$(1&$% 2&!&
/)#2!""0*"! ) /)0(!)+" *" /)0%($(1.$)0&+$*&*"
 !$0.32$)456%$.)474%12!"#&.$&4*&4.)0%($(1$89)
 *+"'%"!'&1&,$%&+&'&'3&!)$!'+"'+2&%'-3)$/&%'5'+"3"1+"'+"'/*#*'%"'&6*!+&'&'0*1%)$)2$78*
9*!#&,
:2&1+*'&1&,$%&#*%'*'+$!"$)*'&'3&!)$!'+&'-)$/&'+"';&1%
<",%"1'=')"*!$&'32!&'+*'+$!"$)*'5'3$!>#$+"'<",%"1$&1&?
0*1%)$)2$78*'/*#*'3*1)*'#&$%'","@&+*'+*
*!+"1&#"1)*'A2!B+$/*C'+*'D2&,'%"'+"%3!"1+"'&%'+"#&$%
1*!#&%
(21+*'1*!#&)$@*'E$"!&!D2$F&+*
G',"$'"1/*1)!&'H21+&#"1)*'+"'@&,$+&+"'1&'0*1%)$)2$78*
I"$'3*+"'%"!'/*1%)$)2/$*1&,'*2'$1/*1%)$)2/$*1&,C'AJ'2#
K"/!")*'3*+"'%"!',".&,'*2'$,".&,C'+&+&'&%'+"@$+&%
3*%$7L"%'E$"!J!D2$/&%
/)0%($(1$89)4:4;"$4:4<".!"()
M%3N/$"'+"'%$%)"#&'E$"!&!D2$F&+*'+"')"O)*%'1*!#&)$@*%C'1*
D2&,'&'@&,$+&+"'+"'&,.21%'+"/*!!"'+&'%2&'/*1/*!+>1/$&
/*#'*')"*!'+"'2#')"O)*'1*!#&)$@*'D2"',E"'%"!@"'/*#*
!"H"!P1/$&'"',E"'N'%23"!$*!
Q*!6"!)*'R*66$*'5'H&,&'+&'@&,$+&+"'+"'2#')"O)*'"'H&F
!"H"!P1/$&'&'3&!)$!'+"'%"2'3*%$)$@$%#*'&'*2)!*%')&1)*%')"O)*%
+&%'D2&$%'%"'+"%3!"1+"'&'@&,$+&+"'+"'*2)!*
%"#3!"'%"'@&$'/E".&!'1&'/*1%)$)2$78*'5'N'&'0)!#&4*&%
0)!#&%
(&)"!$&,'*2'S26%)&1/$&,
T"O)*'/*1%)$)2/$*1&,'/*1%&.!&'2#'/*1A21)*'+"'@&,*!&7L"%'"
H$1%
 *1)*'+"'@$%)&'3!$1/B3$*,-.$/*
 *+"!'/*1%)$)2$1)"'5'/&3&/$+&+"'+"'",&6*!&!C'+"'H&F"!'2#&
/*1%)$)2$78*'5'/&3&/$+&+"'+"'"%)&6","/"!'2#&'1*@&'*!+"#
/*1%)$)2/$*1&,C'/*#')2+*'D2"'$%%*'$#3,$/&
2#&'1*@&'*!+"#'/*1%)$)2/$*1&,'$#3,$/&'2#&'1*@&
*!+"#'A2!B+$/&C'"/*1U#$/&C'&+#$1$%)!&)$@&
2#&'1*@&'*!+"#'"'1*@*%'#&1+&)*%'"'H*!#&%'+"
/*#3*%$78*'+*',".$%,&)$@*'"'+*'A2+$/$J!$*
V'3*+"!'/*1%)$)2$1)"C'D2&1+*'H*!#&'2#&'1*@&'*!+"#
/*1%)$)2/$*1&,C'!"@*,2/$*1&')*+&'&'@$+&'+*'"%)&+*'"'%2&
!",&78*'/*#'*%'%"!"%'E2#&1*%?
18*'EJ'H*!7&'D2"'18*'"%)"A&'%26*!+$1&+&'W
/*1%)$)2$78*
=+"#"0()%4("+")+,-$.)%>4?$0%
=+"#"0()%4&@$)+,-$.)%>4A&+)!"%
2#&'1*@&'*!+"#'$#3,$/&'H$1%'"'@&,*!"%?'3!"/$%&'H&F"!
"%/*,E&%C'*37L"%C'+"/$+$!
/*1%)$)2$78*'N'2#&'/*1%)!278*'/*,")$@&
X1/*1%)$)2/$*1&,$+&+"'H*!#&,Y')"O)*'1*!#&)$@*'$1H!&/*1%)$)2/$*1&,'"%)J'"#'/*1)!&+$78*'+*')"O)*'/*1%)$)2/$*1&,
X1/*1%)$)2/$*1&,$+&+"'#&)"!$&,Y'/*1)!&+$78*'W%'@&,*!&7L"%'"'H$1%'"%)&6","/$+*%'3",&'0*1%)$)2$78*?'*37L"%'/*1%)$)2/$*1&$%
+"%*6"+"/$+&%
:2&1+*'H&F'/*1)!*,"'+"'/*1%)$)2/$*1&,$+&+"'18*'%"'3*+"')"!'2#&'H*!#&78*'3!"/J!$&Z'Q8*'3*+"'%$#3,"%#"1)"'+$F"!'D2"'O
+$F'"O&)&#"1)"'/*1)!J!$*'W',$)"!&,$+&+"'+*')"O)*'/*1%)$)2/$*1&,?
G3!"1+"!'/*1)!*,"'$#3,$/&'"#'&3!"1+"!'&'$1)"!3!")&!C'&'&!.2#"1)&!C'&'/*#3!""1+"!'D2"'D2&1+*'"%)&#*%'&'H&,&!'"#'+"H"%&'+&
/*1%)$)2$78*C'18*'N'2#'"O"!/B/$*'HJ/$,?
["D2"!'&!.2#"1)&78*'"'/*#3!""1%8*'+&%'3&,&@!&%'1*')"O)*'/*1%)$)2/$*1&,C'18*'N'D2"%)8*'&2)*#J)$/&
 !"#$%%&%'(")*+*,-.$/&%'"'0*1/"$)2&$%'3&!&'0*#3!""1+"!'*'0*1)!*,"'+"'0*1%)$)2/$*1&,$+&+" \
MO"#3,*Y'ST9'3".&'&,.2#&%',"$%'"'+")"!#$1&'&'$1)"!3!")&78*'D2"'+"@"'%"!'H"$)&C'"O/,2$1+*'&%'+"#&$%'5'$1)"!3!")&78*
/*1%)$)2/$*1&,
<"4B1"4"%(&#)%4&4?&+&!C
D1&0*)4%"4*$E4"#4.)0(!)+"4*"4.)0%($(1.$)0&+$*&*"F4"%(64%"4?&+&0*)40)4B1"C
0,N#"!%*1'0,]@"Y'9$%/&,$F&78*'G6%)!&)&'+"'0*1%)$)2/$*1&,$+&+"
!"H"!"^%"'W'/*1)!*,"'+"'/*1%)$)2/$*1&,$+&+"
_$,#&!'9"!!"$!&'("1+"%Y'`2!$%+$78*'0*1%)$)2/$*1&,
!"H"!"^%"'W'/*1)!*,"'+"'/*1%)$)2/$*1&,$+&+"
V2)!*%'&2)*!"%'%"'!"H"!"#'+"'#&1"$!&'."1N!$/&'/*#*'K"H"%&'+&'0*1%)$)2$78*
$#3"+$!'*%'&)&D2"%'H!"D2"1)"#"1)"'a$1H",$F#"1)"b'H"$)*%'W'/*1%)$)2$78*
G4B1"4%"4"%(64*"?"0*"0*)4H4&4%12!"#&.$&4*&4/)0%($(1$89)
Q8*'"%)&#*%'H&F"1+*'2#'"O"!/B/$*'#&)"#J)$/*C')"#'&'@"!'/*#'&%'*37L"%'/*1%)$)2/$*1&$%
c' G3!"1+"!'&'&!.2#"1)&!'%*6!"'&'/*1%)$)2/$*1&,$+&+"'N'H21+&#"1)&,'3&!&'3!"%"!@&78*'+*')$3*'+"'M%)&+*C'+"'*!+"#
"/*1U#$/&C'+*%'+$!"$)*%'H21+&#"1)&$%'"C'"#'."!&,C'+*'/*1A21)*'+"'*37L"%'D2"'*'/*1%)$)2$1)"'H"F'"#'dd
T!&)&^%"'+&'+"H"%&'+&'/*1%)$)2$78*C'2#&'/*1%)$)2$78*'&#"&7&+&
 &!("4*&4$*"$&4B1"4&4/)0%($(1$89)4H4%12!"#&
 !"/$%&'D2"'%"A&'!3-$*&45'H21+&#"1)&,'3&!&'D2"'%"'H&7&'/*1)!*,"'+"'/*1%)$)2/$*1&,$+&+"
[$.$+"F'/*1%)$)2/$*1&,Y
G'!"H*!#&'+&'0*1%)$)2$78*'!"D2"!'+"'2#'3!*/"+$#"1)*'#2$)*'#&$%'+$H$/2,)*%*'D2"'*'3!*/"%%*'"%)&6","/$+*'3&!&'/*1%)!2$!'&',"$
*!+$1J!$&
 !)?"%%)!4I1$+J"!#"4K&*"14L!&1M)>4*$E4B1"4&4/N45!&%$+"$!&4H4%$#4!3-$*&
 &!&,",*'"1)!"'3!*/"%%*'+"'",&6*!&78*'+"'"#"1+&'"'3!*/"%%*'+"'",&6*!&78*'+"',"$'*!+$1J!$&
e'/!$)N!$*%Y
X1$/$&)$@& T2!1*%'+"'f*)&78* :2-!21%'+"'f*)&78*
S"'*'3!*/"%%*'3&!&'",&6*!&78*'+"'"#"1+&'H*!'#&$%'+$H$/2,)*%*'1*%')!P%'/!$)N!$*%C'&'0*1%)$)2$78*'6!&%$,"$!&'N'!B.$+&
G!)$.*'ghC'0*1%)$)2$78*'9"+"!&,
0*1%)$)2$78*'("@(1&+4a"%/!$)&b'i'!"+2F$+&'&')"O)*
O"."%%6!$)4,!-9)4.)#4.&2&.$*&*"42&!&4*".+&!&!4$0.)0%($(1.$)0&+$*&*"4.)#4"%(&(1!&4/)0%($(1.$)0&+
(&$%'2#'!"D2$%$)*'3&!&'%"'H&F"!'/*1)!*,"
M%%"'-!.8*'+"@"')"!'"%)&)2!&'/*1%)$)2/$*1&,C'18*'3*+"'%"!'/!$&+*'3*!'I"$
G'H2178*'+"'.2&!+&!'&'09'+"@"'@$!'+$!")&#"1)"'+&'09'5'D2"#C'/*#*
:2&,D2"!'A2$F'3*+"'+"/,&!&!'&'$1/*1%)$)2/$*1&,$+&+"C'&'D2"%)8*'N'*'"H"$)*'D2"'3!*+2F