Buscar

Human Bone Manual

Faça como milhares de estudantes: teste grátis o Passei Direto

Esse e outros conteúdos desbloqueados

16 milhões de materiais de várias disciplinas

Impressão de materiais

Agora você pode testar o

Passei Direto grátis

Você também pode ser Premium ajudando estudantes

Faça como milhares de estudantes: teste grátis o Passei Direto

Esse e outros conteúdos desbloqueados

16 milhões de materiais de várias disciplinas

Impressão de materiais

Agora você pode testar o

Passei Direto grátis

Você também pode ser Premium ajudando estudantes

Faça como milhares de estudantes: teste grátis o Passei Direto

Esse e outros conteúdos desbloqueados

16 milhões de materiais de várias disciplinas

Impressão de materiais

Agora você pode testar o

Passei Direto grátis

Você também pode ser Premium ajudando estudantes
Você viu 3, do total de 485 páginas

Faça como milhares de estudantes: teste grátis o Passei Direto

Esse e outros conteúdos desbloqueados

16 milhões de materiais de várias disciplinas

Impressão de materiais

Agora você pode testar o

Passei Direto grátis

Você também pode ser Premium ajudando estudantes

Faça como milhares de estudantes: teste grátis o Passei Direto

Esse e outros conteúdos desbloqueados

16 milhões de materiais de várias disciplinas

Impressão de materiais

Agora você pode testar o

Passei Direto grátis

Você também pode ser Premium ajudando estudantes

Faça como milhares de estudantes: teste grátis o Passei Direto

Esse e outros conteúdos desbloqueados

16 milhões de materiais de várias disciplinas

Impressão de materiais

Agora você pode testar o

Passei Direto grátis

Você também pode ser Premium ajudando estudantes
Você viu 6, do total de 485 páginas

Faça como milhares de estudantes: teste grátis o Passei Direto

Esse e outros conteúdos desbloqueados

16 milhões de materiais de várias disciplinas

Impressão de materiais

Agora você pode testar o

Passei Direto grátis

Você também pode ser Premium ajudando estudantes

Faça como milhares de estudantes: teste grátis o Passei Direto

Esse e outros conteúdos desbloqueados

16 milhões de materiais de várias disciplinas

Impressão de materiais

Agora você pode testar o

Passei Direto grátis

Você também pode ser Premium ajudando estudantes

Faça como milhares de estudantes: teste grátis o Passei Direto

Esse e outros conteúdos desbloqueados

16 milhões de materiais de várias disciplinas

Impressão de materiais

Agora você pode testar o

Passei Direto grátis

Você também pode ser Premium ajudando estudantes
Você viu 9, do total de 485 páginas

Faça como milhares de estudantes: teste grátis o Passei Direto

Esse e outros conteúdos desbloqueados

16 milhões de materiais de várias disciplinas

Impressão de materiais

Agora você pode testar o

Passei Direto grátis

Você também pode ser Premium ajudando estudantes

Prévia do material em texto

I]Z
=jbVc�7dcZ
BVcjVa
This Page Intentionally Left Blank 
I]Z
=jbVc�7dcZ
BVcjVa
I^b�9#�L]^iZ
E^ZiZg�6#�;da`Zch
6bhiZgYVb��™��7dhidc��™��=Z^YZaWZg\��™��AdcYdc
CZl�Ndg`��™��Dm[dgY��™��EVg^h��™��HVc�9^Z\d�
�HVc�;gVcX^hXd��™��H^c\VedgZ��™��HnYcZn��™��Id`nd
6Xfj^h^i^dc�:Y^idg/�CVcXn�BVgV\^d\a^d
Egd_ZXi�BVcV\Zg/�7gVcYn�A^aan
6hhdX^ViZ�6Xfj^h^i^dc�:Y^idg/�@Zaan�HdccVX`
BVg`Zi^c\�BVcV\Zg/�A^cYV�7ZVii^Z
8dbedh^i^dc/�6�=^\]Zg�Edged^hZ�9Zh^\c�<gdje
8dkZg�Eg^ciZg/�E]dZc^m�8dadg
>ciZg^dg�Eg^ciZg/�I]Z�BVeaZ"KV^a�7dd`�BVcj[VXijg^c\�<gdje
:ahZk^Zg�6XVYZb^X�EgZhh
(%�8dgedgViZ�9g^kZ!�Hj^iZ�)%%!�7jga^c\idc!�B6�%&-%(!�JH6
*'*�7�HigZZi!�Hj^iZ�&.%%!�HVc�9^Z\d!�8Va^[dgc^V�.'&%&")).*!�JH6
-)�I]ZdWVaY¼h�GdVY!�AdcYdc�L8&M�-GG!�J@
I]^h�Wdd`�^h�eg^ciZY�dc�VX^Y"[gZZ�eVeZg#�����'�����
8deng^\]i��'%%*!�:ahZk^Zg�>cX#�
IZmi�VcY�^bV\Zh/��'%%*!�I^b�9#�L]^iZ���E^ZiZg�6gZcY�;da`Zch
;gdci�XdkZg�e]did\gVe]n/��'%%*!�E^ZiZg�6gZcY�;da`Zch���I^b�9#�L]^iZ!��
6aa�g^\]ih�gZhZgkZY#
Cd�eVgi�d[�i]^h�ejWa^XVi^dc�bVn�WZ�gZegdYjXZY�dg�igVchb^iiZY�^c�Vcn�[dgb�dg�Wn�Vcn�bZVch!�ZaZXigdc^X�
dg�bZX]Vc^XVa!�^cXajY^c\�e]didXden!�gZXdgY^c\!�dg�Vcn�^c[dgbVi^dc�hidgV\Z�VcY�gZig^ZkVa�hnhiZb!�l^i]dji�
eZgb^hh^dc�^c�lg^i^c\�[gdb�i]Z�ejWa^h]Zg�dg�Vji]dgh#
EZgb^hh^dch�bVn�WZ�hdj\]i�Y^gZXian�[gdb�:ahZk^Zg¼h�HX^ZcXZ���IZX]cdad\n�G^\]ih�9ZeVgibZci�^c�Dm[dgY!�
J@/�e]dcZ/�� ))��&-+*�-)(-(%!�[Vm/�� ))��&-+*�-*((((!�Z"bV^a/�eZgb^hh^dch5ZahZk^Zg#Xd#j`#��Ndj�bVn�Vahd�
XdbeaZiZ�ndjg�gZfjZhi�dc"a^cZ�k^V�i]Z�:ahZk^Zg�]dbZeV\Z��]iie/$$ZahZk^Zg#Xdb�!�Wn�hZaZXi^c\��¹8jhidbZg�
Hjeedgiº�VcY�i]Zc�¹DWiV^c^c\�EZgb^hh^dch#º
<YRbQbi�_V�3_^WbUcc�3QdQ\_WY^W�Y^�@eR\YSQdY_^�4QdQ
L]^iZ!�I#�9#��I^bdi]n�9#�
���I]Z�]jbVc�WdcZ�bVcjVa�$�Wn�I^b�9#�L]^iZ!�E^ZiZg�6#�;da`Zch#
�������e#�Xb#
���>H7C�%"&'"%--)+,")��XVhZWdjcY�/�Va`#�eVeZg���&#��=jbVc�h`ZaZidc¸>YZci^ÄXVi^dc¸
=VcYWdd`h!�bVcjVah!�ZiX#�'#��=jbVc�h`ZaZidc¸6cVanh^h¸=VcYWdd`h!�bVcjVah!�ZiX#�
(#��=jbVc�h`ZaZidc¸8aVhh^ÄXVi^dc¸=VcYWdd`h!�bVcjVah!�ZiX#�)#��=jbVc�gZbV^ch�
�6gX]VZdad\n�¸=VcYWdd`h!�bVcjVah!�ZiX#�*#��;dgZch^X�dhiZdad\n¸=VcYWdd`h!�bVcjVah!�ZiX#�
+#��;dgZch^X�Vci]gdedad\n¸=VcYWdd`h!�bVcjVah!�ZiX#��>#
;da`Zch!�E^ZiZg�6#�>>#�I^iaZ#�
��<C,%#L))�'%%*
��*..#.¼),""YX''
������������������������������������������������������������'%%*%&%&*)
2bYdYcX�<YRbQbi�3QdQ\_WeY^W�Y^�@eR\YSQdY_^�4QdQ�
6�XViVad\jZ�gZXdgY�[dg�i]^h�Wdd`�^h�VkV^aVWaZ�[gdb�i]Z�7g^i^h]�A^WgVgn
>H7C/��%"&'"%--)+,")
;dg�Vaa�^c[dgbVi^dc�dc�Vaa�:ahZk^Zg�6XVYZb^X�EgZhh�EjWa^XVi^dch�
k^h^i�djg�LZW�h^iZ�Vi�lll#Wdd`h#ZahZk^Zg#Xdb
Eg^ciZY�^c�i]Z�Jc^iZY�HiViZh�d[�6bZg^XV
%*�����%+����%,�����%-����%.�����&%����.�����-�����,�����+�����*�����)�����(����'����&
�
k
8dciZcih
@bUVQSU
#HAPTER��
9^db_TeSdY_^� !
&#&� =jbVc�DhiZdad\n� &�
&#'� 6�<j^YZ�id�i]Z�BVcjVa� '
&#(� GZhdjgXZh�[dg�i]Z�DhiZdad\^hi� *
&#)� >YZci^[n^c\�7dcZh� *
#HAPTER��
6YU\T�@b_SUTebUc�V_b�C[U\UdQ\�BU]QY^c� '
'#&� HZVgX]�� -
'#'� 9^hXdkZgn� -
'#(� :mXVkVi^dc�VcY�GZig^ZkVa� .
'#)� IgVchedgi� '%
#HAPTER��
5dXYSc�Y^�?cdU_\_Wi� "!
(#&� :i]^Xh�^c�;dgZch^X�DhiZdad\n� '&
� (#&#&� 7djcYVg^Zh�d[�:k^YZcXZ� ''
� (#&#'� I]Z�:meZgi�L^icZhh� '(
(#'� :i]^Xh�^c�6gX]Zdad\^XVa�DhiZdad\n� ')
� (#'#&� :i]^Xh�^c�8daa^h^dc� '*
� (#'#'� C6<EG6�VcY�>ih�:[[ZXih� '-�
� (#'#(� I]Z�;jijgZ� '-
k^
#HAPTER��
2_^U�2Y_\_Wi���FQbYQdY_^� #!
)#&� KVg^Vi^dc� (&
)#'� 6�;Zl�;VXih�VWdji�7dcZ� ((
)#(� 7dcZh�Vh�:aZbZcih�d[�i]Z�BjhXjadh`ZaZiVa�HnhiZb� ((
)#)� <gdhh�6cVidbn�d[�7dcZh� )%
)#*� BdaZXjaVg�HigjXijgZ�d[�7dcZ� )'
)#+� =^hidad\n�VcY�BZiVWda^hb�d[�7dcZ� )'
)#,� 7dcZ�<gdli]� )+
)#-� 7dcZ�GZeV^g� )-
#HAPTER��
@_cd]_bdU]�C[U\UdQ\�=_TYÍSQdY_^� $)
*#&� 7dcZ�;gVXijgZ� *%
*#'� 7dcZ�BdY^ÄXVi^dc�Wn�E]nh^XVa�6\Zcih� *'
� *#'#&� 8]Zb^hign� *'
� *#'#'� GdX`!�:Vgi]!�VcY�>XZ� *)
� *#'#(� 6WgVh^dc� *)
� *#'#)� ;^gZ� *)
*#(� 7dcZ�BdY^ÄXVi^dc�Wn�Cdc]jbVc�7^dad\^XVa�6\Zcih� **
� *#(#&� Cdc]jbVc�6c^bVa� **
� *#(#'� EaVci� *,
*#)� 7dcZ�BdY^ÄXVi^dc�Wn�=jbVch� *,
� *#)#&� 8ji�bVg`h!�8]de�bVg`h!�VcY�HXgVeZ�bVg`h� +%
� *#)#'� EZgXjhh^dc�BVg`h� +'
� *#)#(� Egd_ZXi^aZh� +'
#HAPTER��
1^Qd_]YSQ\�DUb]Y^_\_Wi� &'
+#&� EaVcZh�d[�GZ[ZgZcXZ� +,
+#'� 9^gZXi^dcVa�IZgbh� +-
� +#'#&� <ZcZgVa� +-
� +#'#'� IZZi]� +.
� +#'#(� =VcYh�VcY�;ZZi� +.
+#(� Bdi^dch�d[�i]Z�7dYn� +.
� +#(#&� <ZcZgVa� ,&
� +#(#'� =VcYh�VcY�;ZZi� ,'
+#)� <ZcZgVa�7dcZ�;ZVijgZh� ,'
� +#)#&� Egd_ZXi^dch�VcY�EVgih� ,(
� +#)#'� 9ZegZhh^dch� ,)
�
k^^
#HAPTER��
C[e\\� � '%
,#&� =VcYa^c\�i]Z�H`jaa� ,*
,#'� :aZbZcih�d[�i]Z�H`jaa� ,,
,#(� <gdli]�VcY�6gX]^iZXijgZ!�HjijgZh�VcY�H^cjhZh� -)
,#)� H`jaa�Dg^ZciVi^dc� -+
,#*� AZVgc^c\�8gVc^Va�H`ZaZiVa�6cVidbn� -,
,#+� ;gdciVa� -,
� ,#+#&� 6cVidbn� -,
� ,#+#'� <gdli]� .&
� ,#+#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� .&
� ,#+#)� H^Y^c\� .&
,#,� EVg^ZiVah� .'
� ,#,#&� 6cVidbn� .'
� ,#,#'� <gdli]� .)
� ,#,#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� .)
� ,#,#)� H^Y^c\� .)
,#-� IZbedgVah� .*
� ,#-#&� 6cVidbn� .*
� ,#-#'� <gdli]� .-
� ,#-#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� ..
� ,#-#)� H^Y^c\� ..
,#.�� 6jY^idgn�Dhh^XaZh� &%%
,#&%� DXX^e^iVa� &%%
� ,#&%#&� 6cVidbn� &%%
� ,#&%#'� <gdli]� &%(
� ,#&%#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &%)
� ,#&%#)� H^Y^c\� &%)
,#&&� BVm^aaVZ� &%)
� ,#&&#&� 6cVidbn� &%)
� ,#&&#'� <gdli]� &%+
� ,#&&#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &%,
� ,#&&#)� H^Y^c\� &%,
,#&'� EVaVi^cZh� &%,
� ,#&'#&� 6cVidbn� &%,
� ,#&'#'� <gdli]� &%.
� ,#&'#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &%.
� ,#&'#)� H^Y^c\� &%.
,#&(� KdbZg�� &%.
� ,#&(#&� 6cVidbn� &%.
� ,#&(#'� <gdli]� &&%
� ,#&(#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &&%
� ,#&(#)� H^Y^c\� &&%
,#&)� >c[Zg^dg�CVhVa�8dcX]VZ� &&&
� ,#&)#&� 6cVidbn�� &&&
k^^^
� ,#&)#'� <gdli]� &&&
� ,#&)#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &&&
� ,#&)#)� H^Y^c\� &&&
,#&*� :i]bd^Y� &&'
� ,#&*#&� 6cVidbn� &&'
� ,#&*#'� <gdli]� &&(
� ,#&*#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &&(
� ,#&*#)� H^Y^c\� &&(
,#&+� AVXg^bVah� &&(
� ,#&+#&� 6cVidbn� &&(
� ,#&+#'� <gdli]� &&)
� ,#&+#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &&)
� ,#&+#)� H^Y^c\� &&)
,#&,� CVhVah� � &&)
� ,#&,#&� 6cVidbn� &&)
� ,#&,#'� <gdli]� &&*
� ,#&,#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &&*
� ,#&,#)� H^Y^c\� &&*
,#&-� On\dbVi^Xh� &&*
� ,#&-#&� 6cVidbn� &&*
� ,#&-#'� <gdli]� &&+
� ,#&-#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &&+
� ,#&-#)� H^Y^c\� &&+
,#&.� He]Zcd^Y� &&,
� ,#&.#&� 6cVidbn� &&,
� ,#&.#'� <gdli]� &'&
� ,#&.#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &'&
� ,#&.#)� H^Y^c\� &'&
,#'%� BVcY^WaZ� &''
� ,#'%#&� 6cVidbn� &''
� ,#'%#'� <gdli]� &'+
� ,#'%#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &'+
� ,#'%#)� H^Y^c\� &'+
#HAPTER��
4U^dYdY_^� !"'
-#&� 9ZciVa�;dgb�VcY�;jcXi^dc� &',
-#'� 9ZciVa�IZgb^cdad\n� &'-
-#(� 6cVidbn�d[�V�Iddi]� &(%
-#)� Iddi]�>YZci^ÄXVi^dc� &(&
-#*� Id�L]^X]�8ViZ\dgn��8aVhh��9dZh�i]Z�Iddi]�7Zadc\4� &()
� -#*#&� >cX^hdgh� &()
� -#*#'� 8Vc^cZh� &()
^m
� -#*#(� EgZbdaVgh� &(+
� -#*#)� BdaVgh� &(+
-#+� >h�i]Z�Iddi]�EZgbVcZci�dg�9ZX^Yjdjh4� &(+
� -#+#&� 9^V\cdhi^X�8g^iZg^V� &(+
� -#+#'� HeZX^Va�8VhZh� &(+
-#,� >h�i]Z�Iddi]�Vc�JeeZg�dg�V�AdlZg4� &(-
� -#,#&� JeeZg�kZghjh�AdlZg�>cX^hdgh� &(.
� -#,#'� JeeZg�kZghjh�AdlZg�8Vc^cZh� &(.
� -#,#(� JeeZg�kZghjh�AdlZg�EgZbdaVgh� &)%
� -#,#)� JeeZg�kZghjh�AdlZg�BdaVgh� &)&
-#-� L]ZgZ�^c�i]Z�6gX]�>h�i]Z�Iddi]�AdXViZY4� &)'
� -#-#&� JeeZg�>cX^hdgh/�>&�kZghjh�>'� &)'
� -#-#'� AdlZg�>cX^hdgh/�>&�kZghjh�>'� &)'
� -#-#(� JeeZg�EgZbdaVgh/�E(�kZghjh�E)� &))
� -#-#)� AdlZg�EgZbdaVgh/�E(�kZghjh�E)� &))
� -#-#*� JeeZg�BdaVgh/�B&�kZghjh�B'�kZghjh�B(� &)+
� -#-#+� AdlZg�BdaVgh/�B&�kZghjh�B'�kZghjh�B(� &),
-#.� >h�i]Z�Iddi]�[gdb�i]Z�G^\]i�dg�i]Z�AZ[i�H^YZ4� &)-
� -#.#&� JeeZg�>cX^hdgh� &)-
� -#.#'� AdlZg�>cX^hdgh� &)-
� -#.#(� JeeZg�8Vc^cZh� &)-
� -#.#)� AdlZg�8Vc^cZh� &).
� -#.#*� JeeZg�EgZbdaVgh� &).
� -#.#+� AdlZg�EgZbdaVgh� &*%
� -#.#,� JeeZg�BdaVgh� &*'
� -#.#-� AdlZg�BdaVgh� &*'
#HAPTER��
8i_YT���FUbdURbQU� !%%
.#&� =nd^Y� � &**
� .#&#&� 6cVidbn� &**
� .#&#'� <gdli]� &*+
� .#&#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &*+
� .#&#)� H^Y^c\� &*+
.#'� <ZcZgVa�8]VgVXiZg^hi^Xh�d[�KZgiZWgVZ� &*+
� .#'#&� 6cVidbn� &*,
� .#'#'� <gdli]� &+'
.#(�8Zgk^XVa�KZgiZWgVZ� &+(
� .#(#&� >YZci^ÄXVi^dc� &+(
� .#(#'� HeZX^Va�8Zgk^XVa�KZgiZWgVZ� &+(
� .#(#(� H^Y^c\� &+.
.#)� I]dgVX^X�KZgiZWgVZ� &,%
� .#)#&� >YZci^ÄXVi^dc� &,%
m
� .#)#'� HeZX^Va�I]dgVX^X�KZgiZWgVZ� &,%
� .#)#(� H^Y^c\� &,+
.#*� AjbWVg�KZgiZWgVZ� &,+
� .#*#&� >YZci^ÄXVi^dc� &,+
� .#*#'� >YZci^[n^c\�AjbWVg�Edh^i^dc� &-%
� .#*#(� H^Y^c\� &-%
�
#HAPTER���
DX_bQh*�CdUb^e]���BYRc� !(!
&%#&� HiZgcjb� &-&
� &%#&#&� 6cVidbn� &-&
� &%#&#'� <gdli]� &-)
� &%#&#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &-)
� &%#&#)� H^Y^c\� &-*
&%#'� G^Wh� � &-*
� &%#'#&� 6cVidbn� &-*
� &%#'#'� HeZX^Va�G^Wh� &-,
� &%#'#(� <gdli]� &-,
� &%#'#)� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &-,
� &%#'#*� H^Y^c\� &.'
#HAPTER���
CX_e\TUb�7YbT\U*�3\QfYS\U���CSQ`e\Q� !)#
&&#&� 8aVk^XaZ� &.(
� &&#&#&� 6cVidbn� &.(
� &&#&#'� <gdli]� &.*
� &&#&#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� &.*
� &&#&#)� H^Y^c\� &.*
&&#'� HXVejaV� &.*
� &&#'#&� 6cVidbn� &.*
� &&#'#'� <gdli]� '%&
� &&#'#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� '%&
� &&#'#)� H^Y^c\� '%'
#HAPTER���
1b]*�8e]Ubec��BQTYec����E\^Q� " #
&'#&� =jbZgjh� '%-
� &'#&#&� 6cVidbn� '%-
m^
� &'#&#'� <gdli]� '&'
� &'#&#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� '&)
� &'#&#)� H^Y^c\� '&)
&'#'� GVY^jh�� '&)
� &'#'#&� 6cVidbn� '&)
� &'#'#'� <gdli]� '&*
� &'#'#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� '&*
� &'#'#)� H^Y^c\� '&+
&'#(� JacV� � '&.
� &'#(#&� 6cVidbn� '&.
� &'#(#'� <gdli]� ''%
� &'#(#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� ''%
� &'#(#)� H^Y^c\� '''
#HAPTER���
8Q^T*�3Qb`Q\c��=UdQSQb`Q\c����@XQ\Q^WUc� ""%
&(#&� 8VgeVah� ''-
� &(#&#&� HXVe]d^Y� ''.
� &(#&#'� AjcViZ� ''.
� &(#&#(� Ig^fjZigVa� '(%
� &(#&#)� E^h^[dgb� '(%
� &(#&#*� IgVeZo^jb��<gZViZg�BjaiVc\jaVg�� '(&
� &(#&#+� IgVeZod^Y��AZhhZg�BjaiVc\jaVg�� '(&
� &(#&#,� 8Ve^iViZ� '('
� &(#&#-� =VbViZ� '('
� &(#&#.� <gdli]� '((
� &(#&#&%� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� '((
&(#'� BZiVXVgeVah� '((
� &(#'#&� ;^ghi�BZiVXVgeVa��I]jbW�� '(+
� &(#'#'� HZXdcY�BZiVXVgeVa� '(+
� &(#'#(� I]^gY�BZiVXVgeVa� '(+
� &(#'#)� ;djgi]�BZiVXVgeVa� '(+
� &(#'#*� ;^[i]�BZiVXVgeVa� '(-
� &(#'#+� <gdli]� '(-
� &(#'#,� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� '(.
� &(#'#-� H^Y^c\� '(.
&(#(� =VcY�E]VaVc\Zh� '(.
� &(#(#&� Egdm^bVa�=VcY�E]VaVc\Zh� ')%
� &(#(#'� >ciZgbZY^ViZ�=VcY�E]VaVc\Zh� ')%
� &(#(#(� 9^hiVa�=VcY�E]VaVc\Zh� ')%
� &(#(#)� <gdli]� ')%
� &(#(#*� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� ')%
� &(#(#+� H^Y^c\� ')%
m^^
#HAPTER���
@U\fYS�7YbT\U*�CQSbe]��3_SSih����?c�3_hQU� "$!
&)#&� HVXgjb� ')&
� &)#&#&� 6cVidbn� ')&
� &)#&#'� <gdli]� '))
� &)#&#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� '))
� &)#&#)� H^Y^c\� ')*
&)#'� 8dXXnm� ')*
&)#(� Dh�8dmVZ� ')+
� &)#(#&� 6cVidbn� ')+
� &)#(#'� <gdli]� '*'
� &)#(#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� '*'
� &)#(#)� H^Y^c\� '*'
#HAPTER���
<UW*�6U]eb��@QdU\\Q��DYRYQ����6YRe\Q� "%%
&*#&� ;Zbjg�� '**
� &*#&#&� 6cVidbn� '**
� &*#&#'� <gdli]� '+,
� &*#&#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� '+,
� &*#&#)� H^Y^c\� '+,
&*#'� EViZaaV�� ',%
� &*#'#&� 6cVidbn� ',%
� &*#'#'� <gdli]� ',%
� &*#'#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� ',%
� &*#'#)� H^Y^c\� ',&
&*#(� I^W^V� � ',&
� &*#(#&� 6cVidbn� ',&
� &*#(#'� <gdli]� ',.
� &*#(#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� ',.
� &*#(#)� H^Y^c\� ',.
&*#)� ;^WjaV� � '-%
� &*#)#&� 6cVidbn� '-%
� &*#)#'� <gdli]� '-&
� &*#)#(� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� '-&
� &*#)#)� H^Y^c\� '-&
�
#HAPTER���
6__d*�DQbcQ\c��=UdQdQbcQ\c����@XQ\Q^WUc� "('
&+#&� IVghVah�� '.'
m^^^
� &+#&#&� IVajh� '.'
� &+#&#'� 8VaXVcZjh� '.)
� &+#&#(� 8jWd^Y� '.+
� &+#&#)� CVk^XjaVg� '.,
� &+#&#*� BZY^Va��;^ghi��8jcZ^[dgb� '.-
� &+#&#+� >ciZgbZY^ViZ��HZXdcY��8jcZ^[dgb� '.-
� &+#&#,� AViZgVa��I]^gY��8jcZ^[dgb� '.-
� &+#&#-� <gdli]� (%%
� &+#&#.� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� (%%
&+#'� BZiViVghVah� (%%
� &+#'#&� ;^ghi�BZiViVghVa� (%%
� &+#'#'� HZXdcY�BZiViVghVa� (%*
� &+#'#(� I]^gY�BZiViVghVa� (%*
� &+#'#)� ;djgi]�BZiViVghVa� (%*
� &+#'#*� ;^[i]�BZiViVghVa� (%*
� &+#'#+� <gdli]� (%+
� &+#'#,� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� (%+
� &+#'#-� H^Y^c\� (%+
&+#(� ;ddi�E]VaVc\Zh� (%+
� &+#(#&� Egdm^bVa�;ddi�E]VaVc\Zh� (%+
� &+#(#'� >ciZgbZY^ViZ�;ddi�E]VaVc\Zh� (%+
� &+#(#(� 9^hiVa�;ddi�E]VaVc\Zh� (%+
� &+#(#)� <gdli]� (%,
� &+#(#*� Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dc� (%,
� &+#(#+� H^Y^c\� (%-
#HAPTER���
?cdU_\_WYSQ\���4U^dQ\�@QdX_\_Wi� # )
&,#&� IgVjbV� (&'
� &,#&#&� ;gVXijgZ� (&'
� &,#&#'� 9^hadXVi^dc� (&)
� &,#&#(� 6gi^ÄX^Va�9Z[dgbVi^dc� (&)
� &,#&#)� IgZe]^cVi^dc�VcY�6bejiVi^dc� (&*
&,#'� >c[ZXi^djh�9^hZVhZh�VcY�6hhdX^ViZY�BVc^[ZhiVi^dch� (&,
� &,#'#&� DhiZdbnZa^i^h� (&-
� &,#'#'� EZg^dhi^i^h� (&-
� &,#'#(� IjWZgXjadh^h� (&-
� &,#'#)� IgZedcZbVa�>c[ZXi^dch� ('%
&,#(� 8^gXjaVidgn�9^hijgWVcXZh�VcY�=ZbVided^Zi^X�9^hdgYZgh� ('%�
&,#)� BZiVWda^X�VcY�=dgbdcVa�>bWVaVcXZ� ('(
� &,#)#&� HXjgkn� ('(
� &,#)#'� G^X`Zih� ('(
� &,#)#(� DhiZdedgdh^h� ('(
� &,#)#)� :cYdXg^cZ�9^hijgWVcXZh�VcY�9nheaVh^Vh� (')
m^k
&,#*� Ijbdgh� ('*
&,#+� 6gi]g^i^h� ('*
� &,#+#&� DhiZdVgi]g^i^h� ('*
� &,#+#'� G]ZjbVid^Y�6gi]g^i^h� (',
� &,#+#(� 6c`nadh^c\�HedcYna^i^h� ('-
&,#,� 9ZciVa�EVi]dad\n� ('-
� &,#,#&� 8Vg^Zh� ('.
� &,#,#'� 9ZciVa�=nedeaVh^V� ('.
� &,#,#(� EZg^dYdciVa�9^hZVhZ� ((%
� &,#,#)� 9ZciVa�8VaXjajh� ((%
� &,#,#*� 6gi^ÄX^Va�9ZciVa�BdY^ÄXVi^dc� ((&
&,#-� DXXjeVi^dc� ((&
#HAPTER���
<QR_bQd_bi�@b_SUTebUc���BU`_bdY^W� ###
&-#&� HZii^c\�� (((
&-#'� EgZhZgkVi^dc�� (()
&-#(� EgZeVgVi^dc�� ((*
&-#)� GZhidgVi^dc� ((-
&-#*� Hdgi^c\� ((.
&-#+� BZig^X�6Xfj^h^i^dc�VcY�6cVanh^h� ()%
&-#,� BdaZXjaVg�DhiZdad\n� ())
� &-#,#&� HVbea^c\� ()*
� &-#,#'� 9C6�VcY�E8G� ()+
� &-#,#(� 8dciVb^cVi^dc� (),
� &-#,#)� IVe]dcdbn�d[�9C6� (),
&-#-� BdaY^c\�VcY�8Vhi^c\� ()-
&-#.� E]did\gVe]n� ()-
� &-#.#&� :fj^ebZci� ().
� &-#.#'� :medhjgZ�VcY�;^ab��dg�di]Zg�gZXdgY^c\�bZY^V�� (*%
� &-#.#(� A^\]i^c\�VcY�HZije� (*&
� &-#.#)� AZ\Va�8dch^YZgVi^dch� (*'
&-#&%�GVY^d\gVe]n� (*(
&-#&&�B^XgdhXden� (*(
&-#&'�8dbeji^c\� (*)
&-#&(�GZedgi^c\� (**
&-#&)�8jgVi^dc� (*-
#HAPTER���
DXU�C[U\UdQ\�2Y_\_Wi�_V�9^TYfYTeQ\c���@_`e\QdY_^c
&.#&� 6XXjgVXn�VcY�EgZX^h^dc�d[�:hi^bVi^dc� (+%
mk
&.#'� ;gdb�@cdlc�id�Jc`cdlc� (+'
&.#(� :hi^bVi^dc�d[�6\Z� (+(
� &.#(#&� :hi^bVi^c\�HjWVYjai�6\Z�[gdb�9Zci^i^dc� (+)
� &.#(#'� :hi^bVi^c\�6Yjai�6\Z�[gdb�9Zci^i^dc� (+*
� &.#(#(� :hi^bVi^c\�6Yjai�6\Z�[gdb�8gVc^Va�HjijgZ�8adhjgZ� (+.
� &.#(#)� :hi^bVi^c\�HjWVYjai�6\Z�[gdb�Adc\"7dcZ�AZc\i]� (,(
� &.#(#*� :hi^bVi^c\�HjWVYjai�6\Z�[gdb�:e^e]nhZVa�8adhjgZ� (,(
� &.#(#+� :hi^bVi^c\�6Yjai�6\Z�[gdb�i]Z�EjW^X�Hnbe]nh^h�Hjg[VXZ� (,)
� &.#(#,� EVgijg^i^dc�8]Vc\Zh�Vi�i]Z�EjW^X�Hnbe]nh^h� (-%
� &.#(#-� :hi^bVi^c\�6Yjai�6\Z�[gdb�i]Z�6jg^XjaVg�Hjg[VXZ�d[�i]Z�>a^jb� (-%
� &.#(#.� :hi^bVi^c\�6Yjai�6\Z�[gdb�i]Z�HiZgcVa�G^W�:cY� (-&
� &.#(#&%�:hi^bVi^c\�6Yjai�6\Z�Wn�GVY^d\gVe]^X�6cVanh^h� (-&
� &.#(#&&�:hi^bVi^c\�6Yjai�6\Z�[gdb�7dcZ�B^XgdhigjXijgZ� (-&
� &.#(#&'�Bjai^[VXidg^Va�6\Z�:hi^bVi^dc� (-)
&.#)� 9ZiZgb^cVi^dc�d[�HZm� (-*
� &.#)#&� HZm^c\�i]Z�H`jaa�VcY�9Zci^i^dc� (-+
� &.#)#'� HZm^c\�i]Z�EdhiXgVc^Va�H`ZaZidc� (-,
&.#*� :hi^bVi^dc�d[�HiVijgZ� (.-
&.#+� :hi^bVi^dc�d[�6cXZhign� )%%
&.#,� >YZci^[n^c\�i]Z�>cY^k^YjVa� )%)
&.#-� 9^hXgZiZ�IgV^ih� )%+
� &.#-#&� 9ZciVa�CdcbZig^X�KVg^Vi^dc� )%,
� &.#-#'� 8gVc^Va�CdcbZig^X�KVg^Vi^dc� )%,
� &.#-#(� EdhiXgVc^Va�CdcbZig^X�KVg^Vi^dc� )&%
&.#.� :hi^bVi^c\�7^dad\^XVa�9^hiVcXZ� )&%
&.#&%�9^Zi� � )&&
&.#&&�9^hZVhZ�VcY�9Zbd\gVe]n� )&)
'LOSSARY� � )&.
!PPENDIX
� LZW�GZk^Zl� )',
"IBLIOGRAPHY� )'.
)NDEX�� � )*(
mk^
This Page Intentionally Left Blank 
mk^^
EgZ[VXZ
;dgZch^X�hX^Zci^hih!�aVl�Zc[dgXZbZci�eZghdccZa!�dhiZdad\^hih!�eVaZdcidad\^hih!�VcY�VgX]Zdad\^hih�[gZfjZcian�ZcXdjciZg�]jbVc�gZbV^ch�^c�i]Z^g�ldg`#�I]ZhZ�gZhZVgX]"
Zgh�XVc�jhZ�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch� id� ^ckZhi^\ViZ�Wdi]�i]Z�gZXZci�VcY�i]Z�VcX^Zci�eVhi#�;dg�
i]Zb!�Vc�^aajhigViZY�]jbVc�dhiZdad\n�bVcjVa�gZegZhZcih�Vc�^bedgiVci�idda�[dg�^YZci^"
ÄXVi^dc�VcY�VcVanh^h!�Wdi]�^c�i]Z�ÄZaY�VcY�^c�i]Z�aVWdgVidgn#
>c�i]Z�ÄZaY�hZii^c\!�egd[Zhh^dcVah�VcY�hijYZcih�VgZ�d[iZc�gZfj^gZY�id�Yd�[Vhi!�VXXjgViZ�
^YZci^ÄXVi^dc�l^i]dji�aVWdgVidgn�gZhdjgXZh#�I]^h�Wdd`�^h�YZh^\cZY�id�WZ�i]Z�eg^bVgn�
gZhdjgXZ�^c�i]Z�ÄZaY�hZii^c\/�V�hbVaaZg!�a^\]iZg!�VcY�bdgZ�YjgVWaZ�Wdd`�[dg�[dgZch^X�hX^"Zci^hih!� aVl� Zc[dgXZbZci� eZghdccZa!� VgX]Zdad\^hih!� dhiZdad\^hih!� oddVgX]Zdad\^hih!� VcY�
eVaZdVci]gdedad\^hih#
I]Z� ild"Y^bZch^dcVa� ^bV\Zh� ^c� i]^h�bVcjVa� VgZ�kVajVWaZ� iddah� ^c�ÄZaY� ^YZci^Ä"
XVi^dc!�^chigjXi^dc!�VcY�aZVgc^c\�^ckdak^c\�]jbVc�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch#�I]Zn�]VkZ�WZZc�
XVgZ[jaan�XgV[iZY�id�h]dl�V�bVm^bjb�Vbdjci�d[�VcVidb^XVa�^c[dgbVi^dc!�VcY�hXVaZY�
id�egdk^YZ�ZVhn�XdbeVg^hdc#�Dg\Vc^oZY�[dg�ZVhZ�d[�jhZ�Vh�V�bVcjVa!�i]^h�Wdd`�Zbe]V"
h^oZh�i]Z�WVh^Xh�l]^aZ�egdk^Y^c\�Vc�^cigdYjXi^dc�id�i]Z�]jbVc�h`ZaZidc�VcY�VXXZhh�id�V�
l^YZ�gVc\Z�d[�bdYZgc�ldg`�^c�]jbVc�dhiZdad\n#
L]ViZkZg�hjXXZhh�lZ�]VkZ�VX]^ZkZY�^c�YZkZade^c\�V�jhZ[ja�bVcjVa�lZ�dlZ�aVg\Zan�
id�i]Z�hijYZcih�VcY�XdaaZV\jZh�l]d�]VkZ�Y^a^\Zcian�jhZY�i]Z�Äghi�VcY�hZXdcY�ZY^i^dch�d[�
djg�iZmiWdd`!�=jbVc�DhiZdad\n¸i]Z�Y^gZXi�egZYZXZhhdg�d[�I]Z�=jbVc�7dcZ�BVcjVa#���
BVcn�XdaaZV\jZh�bVYZ�i]dhZ�kdajbZh�edhh^WaZ#�7^aa�LddYXdX`�Vi�6XVYZb^X�EgZhh�Äghi�
hj\\ZhiZY� i]Z� iZmi#�7gjXZ�AVi^bZg�VcY�AnbVc� ?ZaaZbV�d[� i]Z�8aZkZaVcY�BjhZjb�d[�
CVijgVa�=^hidgn�]ZaeZY�jh�id�dWiV^c�i]Z�=VbVcc"IdYY�edhiXgVc^Va�h`ZaZidc�^aajhigVi"
ZY�]ZgZ#�B^iX]Zaa�9Vn�Vhh^hiZY�^c�egdk^Y^c\�heZX^bZch�[dg�^aajhigVi^dch�[gdb�i]Z�Jc^"
kZgh^in�d[�i]Z�EVX^ÄX�HX]dda�d[�9Zci^hign¼h�6i`^chdc�8gVc^d"DhiZdad\^XVa�8daaZXi^dc�d[�
i]Z�6#L#�LVgY�BjhZjb#�I]Vc`h�\d�id�7dW�?dcZh�d[�7Zg`ZaZn¼h�BjhZjb�d[�KZgiZWgViZ�
Oddad\n�[dg�gZbdk^c\�i]Z�\gZVhZ�[gdb�i]Z�^aajhigViZY�h`ZaZidc#�;dg�[dgZch^X�VYk^XZ�VcY�
XdchjaiVi^dc�lZ�i]Vc`�G^X]VgY�I]dbVh�VcY�:aaZc�BddgZ#
I]Z�bVcjVa�^aajhigViZh�]jbVc�WdcZh�[gdb�VYY^i^dcVa�^chi^iji^dch�i]Vi�VgZ�\gViZ"
[jaan�VX`cdlaZY\ZY�]ZgZ!�eVgi^XjaVgan� i]Z�E]dZWZ�6eeZghdc�=ZVghi�BjhZjb�d[�6c"
i]gdedad\n�Vi�J#8#�7Zg`ZaZn��l]ZgZ�IL�^h�V�;VXjain�8jgVidg�#�LZ�\gViZ[jaan�VX`cdla"
ZY\Z�i]Z�Vhh^hiVcXZ�d[�i]Z�J#H#�6gbn�8ZcigVa�>YZci^ÄXVi^dc�AVWdgVidgn!�=VlV^^0�i]Z�;7>�
AVWdgVidgn�9^k^h^dc0�VcY�i]Z�6gbZY�;dgXZh�>chi^ijiZ�d[�EVi]dad\n#
I]Z�[daadl^c\�XdaaZV\jZh�]VkZ�\gVX^djhan�egdk^YZY�VXXZhh�id�^aajhigVi^kZ�bViZg^Va�
^c�i]Z�bVcjVa/�HjoVccZ�HjcY]dab�VcY�@Zci�A^\]i[ddi�d[�i]Z�Jc^kZgh^in�d[�8Va^[dgc^V�
6gX]VZdad\^XVa�GZhZVgX]�;VX^a^in!�AVggn�O^bbZgbVc�d[�i]Z�Jc^kZgh^in�d[�Hdji]�9V"
mk^^^
`diV!�9dj\�JWZaV`Zg�d[�i]Z�Hb^i]hdc^Vc�>chi^iji^dc!�?Zggn�;ZiiZgbVc�d[�LddYh�8Vc"
ndc�6gX]VZdad\^XVa�8dchjaiVcih!�<Zdg\Z�<^aa� d[� i]Z�Jc^kZgh^in� d[�Lndb^c\!�DlZc�
AdkZ_dn�d[�@Zci�HiViZ�Jc^kZgh^in!�VcY�HiZVYbVc�Je]Vb�d[�CZl�BZm^Xd�HiViZ�Jc^kZg"
h^in�`^cYan�\gVciZY�eZgb^hh^dc�id�gZeg^ci�i]Z^g�e]did\gVe]h�VcY�YgVl^c\h!�VcY�HXdii�
H^behdc�egdk^YZY�bjX]�]Zae�^c�dWiV^c^c\�^aajhigVi^kZ�bViZg^Va#�GZfjZhih�[dg�gZjhZ�d[�
i]Z�e]did\gVe]h�VcY�Vgildg`�^c�i]^h�Wdd`�h]djaY�WZ�bVYZ�Y^gZXian�id�i]Z�Vji]dgh!�dg!�
^c�i]Z�XVhZ�d[�XgZY^iZY�^aajhigVi^dch!�id�i]Z�^cY^k^YjVa�h��dg�^chi^iji^dc�h��^YZci^ÄZY�^c�
i]Z�Veegdeg^ViZ�Ä\jgZ�XVei^dc#
I]Z�[daadl^c\�XdaaZV\jZh�VcY�hijYZcih�Xdcig^WjiZY�^c�i]Z^g�dlc�lVnh�id�i]Z�bVc"
jVa!�VcY�i]Zn�VgZ�Vaa�\gViZ[jaan�VX`cdlaZY\ZY/�:a^oVWZi]�6\g^aaV!�B^X]VZa�7aVX`!�?dhZ�
B^\jZa�8VggZiZgd!�HjhVc�8]^c!�7g^VccZ�9Vc^Zah!�9Vk^Y�9Z<jhiV!�=Zcgn�<^aWZgi!�:j"
\ZcZ�=VbbZa!�LVaiZg�=Vgil^\!�7^aa�@^bWZa!�8aVg`�AVghZc!�?Zc^�BX@Z^\]Zc!�NdZa�GV`!�
<Vgn�G^X]VgYh!�VcY�HjhVc�HiVcYZc#�8]jX`�8gjbaZn�lVh�gZhedch^WaZ�[dg�bdk^c\�i]^h�
egd_ZXi�[gdb�^YZV�id�gZVa^in!�Vh�lZgZ�9Vk^Y�8ZaaV!�@Zaan�HdccVX`!�CVcXn�BVgV\^d\a^d!�
7gVcYn�A^aan!�VcY�8ViZ�7Vgg#�LZ�i]Vc`�Vaa�d[�i]Zb#�I]Z�=jbVc�7dcZ�BVcjVa�lVh�Vc�
^YZV�d[�L^aa^Vb�LddYXdX`� ^c� i]Z�ZVgan�&.-%h#�6�fjVgiZg"XZcijgn� aViZg!� ^i� ^h� Vc� ^YZV�
l]dhZ�i^bZ�]Vh�XdbZ#�Idhh�i]Z�bVcjVa�^c�ndjg�igjc`!�hj^iXVhZ!�\adkZ�XdbeVgibZci!�dg�
WVX`eVX`#��<ddY�]jci^c\#
�I^b�9#�L]^iZ
�E^ZiZg�6#�;da`Zch
m^m
This Page Intentionally Left Blank 
mm
This Page Intentionally Left Blank 
&
#HAPTER��
>cigdYjXi^dc
7dcZh�]VkZ�WZZc�ZcidbWZY� [dg�b^aa^dch�d[�nZVgh� ^c�hZY^bZcih� aZ[i�Wn�VcX^Zci�aV`Zh!�hlVbeh!�VcY�g^kZgh�i]Vi�dcXZ�YdiiZY�:i]^de^V¼h�6[Vg�9ZegZhh^dc#�IdYVn!�Vh�
Zgdh^dc�Xjih�^cid�i]ZhZ�VcX^Zci�aVnZgh!�i]Z�[dhh^ah�gZVX]�i]Z�WVggZc�6[Vg�hjg[VXZ!�d[iZc�
h]ViiZg^c\� ^cid� hbVaa!� \a^hiZc^c\!�bjai^XdadgZY� [gV\bZcih� d[�WdcZ� VcY� iZZi]#�I]^can�
hXViiZgZY�Vbdc\�i]Z�dhhZdjh�VcY�YZciVa�gZbV^ch�d[�i]djhVcYh�d[�XgdXdY^aZ!�ijgiaZ!�]^e"
edediVbjh!�\^gV[[Z!�XVgc^kdgZ!�WVWddc!�e^\!�]dghZ!�VciZadeZ!�VcY�di]Zg�Vc^bVah� [djcY�
^c�i]Z�hjg[VXZ�[dhh^a�VhhZbWaV\Zh�VgZ�i]Z�gZbV^ch�d[�eg^b^i^kZ�]jbVc�VcXZhidgh#�L]^aZ�
eVaZdcidad\^hih�hZVgX]�6[Vg�djiXgdeh�[dg�dhiZdad\^XVa�XajZh�VWdji�egZ]^hidg^X�]jbVc�
[dgb!� VgX]Zdad\^hih�jcXdkZg� i]Z�dhiZdad\^XVa� gZbV^ch�d[� i]Z� ^c]VW^iVcih�d[�=ZgXjaV"
cZjb�l]d�eZg^h]ZY�Vh�Bdjci�KZhjk^jh�ZgjeiZY!�Wjgn^c\�i]Zb�l^i]�i]Z^g�edhhZhh^dch#�
Dc�i]Z�di]Zg�h^YZ�d[�i]Z�\adWZ!�Vci]gdedad\^hih�egdWZ�^cid�V�gZXZci�\gVkZ�XdciV^c^c\�
h`ZaZiVa�eVgih�i]Vi�bVn�WZ�i]dhZ�d[�V�CVo^�lVg�Xg^b^cVa#
�����(UMAN�/STEOLOGY
6�i]gZVY�i]Vi�W^cYh�i]ZhZ�VcY�i]djhVcYh�d[�di]Zg�^ckZhi^\Vi^dch�^h�Xe]Q^�_cdU_\_Wi!�
i]Z�hijYn�d[�]jbVc�WdcZh#�I]Z�hX^Zci^hih�eZg[dgb^c\�i]Z�^ckZhi^\Vi^dch�Zbeadn�i]Z^g�
`cdlaZY\Z�d[�i]Z�]jbVc�h`ZaZidc�^c�gZXdkZg^c\�VcY�^ciZgegZi^c\�i]Z�WdcZh#�Djih^YZ�
d[� VcVidb^XVa� VcY�bZY^XVa� hX^ZcXZ!� i]ZgZ� VgZ� i]gZZ�bV^c� VgZVh� ^c�l]^X]�`cdlaZY\Z�
d[�]jbVc�dhiZdad\n�^h�d[iZc�Veea^ZY#�;^ghi!�dhiZdad\^XVa�ldg`�^h�d[iZc�V^bZY�Vi� ^YZc"
i^ÄXVi^dc� d[� i]Z� gZaVi^kZan� gZXZcian�YZXZVhZY� VcY� ^h� jhjVaan�YdcZ� ^c� V� aZ\Va� XdciZmi#�
I]^h�ldg`!�l]^X]�eZgiV^ch� id� i]Z�ejWa^X� [dgjb!�bdhi� d[iZc� V� Xdjgi� d[� aVl!� ^h� XVaaZY�
V_bU^cYS�_cdU_\_Wi!� V� Y^k^h^dc�d[� [dgZch^X� Vci]gdedad\n#�I]Z�di]Zg� ild� XdciZmih� ^c�
l]^X]�]jbVc�dhiZdad\^XVa�`cdlaZY\Z�^h�Xdbbdcan�Veea^ZY�VgZ�]^hidg^XVa#�I]Z�XdciZmi�
XVc�WZ�VcX^Zci�VcY�ejgZan�`Q\U_^d_\_WYSQ\!�Vh�[dg�i]Z�Ea^dXZcZ�egZ"XjaijgVa�]db^c^Yh�
d[�6[g^XV#�6aiZgcVi^kZan!� i]Z� XdciZmi� XVc�WZ� gZaVi^kZan� gZXZci!�eVgi� d[� Vc�QbSXU_\_WY�
SQ\� gZXdgY#�;dg� ZmVbeaZ!�]jbVc�WdcZh� gZXdkZgZY� [gdb� i]Z�6oiZX� XZciZgh� ^c�BZm^Xd�
lZgZ�X]gdc^XaZY�_jhi�V�[Zl�]jcYgZY�nZVgh�V\d�Wn�i]Z�HeVc^h]�Yjg^c\�i]Z�¹XdcfjZhiº�
d[�BZm^Xd#�DhiZdad\^XVa�VcVanh^h�d[�bViZg^Vah�[gdb�hjX]�XjaijgVa�XdciZmih�^h�gdji^cZan�
jcYZgiV`Zc� Vh� eVgi� d[� VgX]Zdad\^XVa� gZhZVgX]#�6gX]Zdad\^hih� XdcXZcigViZ� dc� XjaijgVa�
gZh^YjZh�d[�[dgbZg�]jbVc�dXXjeVi^dch!�Wji�i]Zn�hiVcY�id�\V^c�V�\gZVi�YZVa�d[�kVajVWaZ�
^c[dgbVi^dc�[gdb�i]Z�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch�d[�i]Z�VcX^Zci�^c]VW^iVcih#�>i�]Vh�gZXZcian�WZ"
XdbZ�[Vh]^dcVWaZ�id�gZ[Zg�id�i]Z�hijYn�d[�]jbVc�gZbV^ch�[gdb�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�XdciZmih�
Vh�RY_QbSXU_\_Wi#��=dlZkZg!�]jbVc�h`ZaZiVa�eVgih�VgZ�dcan�V�hbVaa�eVgi�d[�i]Z�W^dad\^"
� 8]VeiZg�&����>cigdYjXi^dc
XVa�gZbV^ch�X]VgVXiZg^o^c\�bdhi�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�h^iZh¸^cYZZY!�bdhi�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�h^iZh�
aVX`�]jbVc�gZbV^ch�Vaid\Zi]Zg�
I]Z� ^c[dgbVi^dc� i]Vi� ]jbVc� dg� egdid]jbVc� WdcZh� XVc� egdk^YZ�bV`Zh� i]Z� gZ"
XdkZgn� d[� WdcZh� V� Xg^i^XVaan� ^bedgiVci� VXi^k^in#� H`ZaZiVa� VcVidbn� �^cXajY^c\� iZZi]��
gZÅZXih� i]Z� XdbW^cZY� VXi^dc� d[� \ZcZh� VcY� Zck^gdcbZci#� I]Z� h`ZaZidc� [dgbh� i]Z�
[gVbZldg`� [dg� i]Z� WdYn!�l]ZgZVh� i]Z� iZZi]� [dgb� V� Y^gZXi� ^ciZg[VXZ� WZilZZc� i]Z� dg"
\Vc^hb� VcY� ^ih� Zck^gdcbZci#� 7dcZh� XVggn� ^c� i]Z^g� h]VeZ!� dg�]_b`X_\_Wi!� i]Z� h^\"
cVijgZ�d[� hd[i� i^hhjZh�l^i]�l]^X]� i]Zn�lZgZ� ZbWZYYZY�Yjg^c\� a^[Z¸i^hhjZh� ^cXajY"
^c\� bjhXaZh!� a^\VbZcih!� iZcYdch!� VgiZg^Zh!� cZgkZh!� kZ^ch!� VcY� dg\Vch#� I]ZhZ� hd[i� i^h"
hjZh� jhjVaan� Y^hVeeZVg� hddc� V[iZg� YZVi]#� I]Z� h`ZaZidc!� ]dlZkZg!� d[iZc� egZhZgkZh�
Zk^YZcXZ� d[� i]Z� [dgbZg� Zm^hiZcXZ� VcY� cVijgZ� d[� bVcn� d[� i]ZhZ� di]Zg� WdYn� eVgih#
7ZXVjhZ�i]Z�WdcZh�VcY�iZZi]�d[�i]Z�h`ZaZidc�VgZ�gZh^hiVci�id�bVcn�`^cYh�d[�YZXVn!�
i]Zn�d[iZc�[dgb�i]Z�bdhi�aVhi^c\�gZXdgY�d[�Vc�^cY^k^YjVa¼h�Zm^hiZcXZ#�>i�^h�edhh^WaZ�id�
Zhi^bViZ�Vc�^cY^k^YjVa¼h�V\Z!�hZm!�VcY�hiVijgZ�[gdb�i]Z�WdcZh�VcY�iZZi]#�HijYn�d[�i]Z�
h`ZaZidc�d[iZc�bV`Zh� ^i�edhh^WaZ� id�Y^hXZgc�V�kVg^Zin�d[�eVi]dad\^Zh� [gdb�l]^X]� i]Z�
^cY^k^YjVa�bVn�]VkZ�hj[[ZgZY#�6cVanh^h�d[�\gdjeh�d[�^cY^k^YjVah�bVn�d[[Zg�^ch^\]ih�^cid�
egZ]^hidg^X�edejaVi^dc�higjXijgZ!�W^dad\^XVa�V[Äc^i^Zh!�XjaijgVa�WZ]Vk^dgh!�VcY�eViiZgch�
d[�Y^hZVhZ#�I]Z�Zkdaji^dcVgn�]^hidgn�d[�]jbVc^in�^ihZa[�bVn�WZ� gZVY� [gdb�i]Z� [dhh^a�
gZXdgY¸V�gZXdgY�Xdbeg^h^c\�bdhian�iZZi]�VcY�WdcZh#�;^\jgZ�&#&�^aajhigViZh�i]Z�eaVXZ�
d[�dhiZdad\n�^c�gZaVi^dc�id�di]Zg�hX^Zci^ÄX�Y^hX^ea^cZh#
�����!�'UIDE�TO�THE�-ANUAL
I]Z�\dVa�d[�[dgZch^X�dhiZdad\n�d[iZc�^ckdakZh�^YZci^ÄXVi^dc�d[�Vc�jc`cdlc�^cY^k^YjVa#�
I]Z�egdXZhh�d[�eZghdcVaan�^YZci^[n^c\�i]Z�gZbV^ch�d[�i]Z�gZXZcian�YZVY�^cY^k^YjVa�^h�
XVaaZY� Y^TYfYTeQdY_^#� Id� cVggdl� i]Z� edhh^W^a^i^Zh!� i]Z� [dgZch^X� dhiZdad\^hi� Äghi� Vh"
XZgiV^ch�l]Zi]Zg� i]Z�gZbV^ch�VgZ�]jbVc�VcY� i]Zc�WZ\^ch� id�ZmeadgZ� i]Z� ^cY^k^YjVa�
X]VgVXiZg^hi^Xh!�hjX]�Vh�V\Z!�hZm!�VcY�hiVijgZ!�XdbeVg^c\�i]ZhZ�kVg^VWaZh�^c�i]Z�]deZh�d[�
dWiV^c^c\�Vc�ZmXajh^kZ�bViX]�l^i]�l]Vi�^h�`cdlc�VWdji�i]Z�b^hh^c\�^cY^k^YjVa#�I]Z�
&IGURE������DhiZdad\n�VcY�VhhdX^ViZY�hX^Zci^ÄX�Y^hX^ea^cZh#
(&#'����<j^YZ�id�i]Z�BVcjVa
]jbVc�dhiZdad\^hi�ldg`^c\�^c�Vc�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�XdciZmi�jhjVaan�XVccdi�eZg[dgb�hjX]�
eZghdcVa�^YZci^ÄXVi^dc#�GVi]Zg!�XdcXZgch�VgZ�l^i]�X]VgVXiZg^hi^Xh�d[�i]Z�^cY^k^YjVa�VcY�
l^i]�i]Z� ^ch^\]ih� i]Vi�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch�d[�bVcn�^cY^k^YjVah!�gZegZhZci^c\�W^dad\^XVa�
edejaVi^dch!�b^\]i�egdk^YZ�dc�Y^Zi!�]ZVai]!�W^dad\^XVa�V[Äc^in!�VcY�edejaVi^dc�]^hidgn#�
I]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�ldg`^c\� ^c�V�eVaZdcidad\^XVa� XdciZmi� �VcY�cdiZ� i]Vi�bVcn� [dhh^ah�d[�
Ea^dXZcZ�VcY�EaZ^hidXZcZ�V\Z�VgZ�[djcY�^c�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�XdciZmih��^h�Vahd�^ciZgZhiZY�^c�
jh^c\�i]Z�cdgbVaan�gVgZ�[dhh^a�gZbV^ch�d[�]jbVc�VcXZhidgh�VcY�di]Zg�gZaVi^kZh�id�aZVgc�
Vaa�i]ZhZ�i]^c\h�VcY�Vahd�id�Y^hXZgc�Zkdaji^dcVgn�gZaVi^dch]^eh#
H`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch�XVc�egdk^YZ�bZVc^c\[ja�XajZh�VWdji�i]Z�gZXZci�VcY�i]Z�VcX^Zci�
eVhi�id�Vaa�i]ZhZ�^ckZhi^\Vidgh#�Id�jhZ�i]ZhZ�XajZh!�dcZ�bjhi�bVhiZg�hdbZ�[jcYVbZciVah#�
I]Z�Äghi�ild�WVh^X�fjZhi^dch�i]Vi�Vcn�]jbVc�dhiZdad\^hi�bjhi�VchlZg�VWdji�V�WdcZ�
dg�XdaaZXi^dc�d[�WdcZh�l]Zi]Zg�^c�V�[dgZch^X!�VgX]Zdad\^XVa!�dg�eVaZdcidad\^XVa�XdciZmi�
VgZ/
� ™� 6gZ�i]Z�WdcZh�]jbVc4
� ™� =dl�bVcn�^cY^k^YjVah�VgZ�egZhZci4
L]Zi]Zg�i]Z�XdciZmi�^h�[dgZch^X!�VgX]Zdad\^XVa!�dg�eVaZdcidad\^XVa!�i]ZhZ�fjZhi^dch�
jhjVaan�bjhi� WZ� VchlZgZY�WZ[dgZ� [jgi]Zg� VcVanh^h� ^h� edhh^WaZ#�I]^h�bVcjVa!� V� \j^YZ�
id� ]jbVc� dhiZdad\n!� Zbe]Vh^oZh� i]Z� VcVidbn� d[� i]Z� ]jbVc� h`ZaZidc#� I]Z� h`ZaZiVa�
gZbV^ch�d[�hdbZ�di]Zg�Vc^bVah!�eVgi^XjaVgan�l]Zc�[gV\bZciVgn!�VgZ�d[iZc�Y^[ÄXjai�id�
Y^hi^c\j^h]�[gdb�]jbVc�WdcZh�VcY�iZZi]#�6ai]dj\]�i]ZgZ�VgZ�cd�\ZcZgVa�Y^[[ZgZcXZh�
i]Vi�ZchjgZ�Z[[ZXi^kZ�hdgi^c\�WZilZZc�]jbVc�VcY�cdc]jbVc�WdcZh!� i]Z�Äghi�hiZe�^c�
VchlZg^c\�i]Z�fjZhi^dc�d[�l]Zi]Zg�i]Z�WdcZh�VgZ�]jbVc�^h�id�WZXdbZ�[Vb^a^Vg�l^i]�
i]Z�]jbVc�h`ZaZidc�^c�Vaa�d[�^ih�bVcn�kVg^Vi^dch�^c�h]VeZ�VcY�h^oZ#�JWZaV`Zg��&.-.!�;^\#�
+(��^aajhigViZh�l]daZ�WdcZh�d[�bVbbVah�bdhi�d[iZc�Xdc[jhZY�l^i]�]jbVch!�Wji�i]^h�
Xdc[jh^dc� gVgZan� ^ckdakZh�l]daZ� WdcZh#� ;gV\bZciVgn� cdc]jbVc� gZbV^ch� VgZ�bdgZ�
egdWaZbVi^X�VcY�VgZ�ZcXdjciZgZY�bdgZ�[gZfjZcian#�DcXZ�V�[Vb^a^Vg^in�l^i]�i]Z�gVc\Z!�
dg�ZckZadeZ!�d[�kVg^Vi^dc�X]VgVXiZg^o^c\�i]Z�bdYZgc�]jbVc�heZX^Zh�^ h�VX]^ZkZY!�[jgi]Zg�
ldg`�^c�XdbeVgVi^kZ�dhiZdad\n�d[�Wdi]�Zmi^cXi�VcY�ZmiVci�bVbbVah�WZXdbZh�V�bjX]�
ZVh^Zg�iVh`#�L^i]�[jgi]Zg�XdbeVgVi^kZ�ldg`�XdbZh�bdgZ�ZmeZg^ZcXZ!�VcY�l^i]�i]Vi�Zm"
eZg^ZcXZ�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�^h�WZiiZg�VWaZ�id�bV`Z�i]Z�WVh^X�^YZci^ÄXVi^dch�gZfj^gZY#
>c[dgbVi^dc�dc�YZiZgb^c^c\�i]Z�V\Z!�hZm!�hiVijgZ!�VcY�^YZci^in�d[�h`ZaZidc^oZY�^c"
Y^k^YjVah� ^h� egdk^YZY� ^c� aViZg� X]VeiZgh� d[� i]Z�bVcjVa#�I]ZhZ� hZXdcY"aZkZa� fjZhi^dch�
VcY�bVcn�di]Zgh!� ^cXajY^c\� i]dhZ� VWdji�W^dbZX]Vc^XVa� XVeVW^a^in!� e]nad\ZcZi^X� gZ"
aVi^dch]^eh!�VcY�\Zd\gVe]^X�V[Äc^i^Zh!�]dlZkZg!�XVc�WZ�VchlZgZY�VXXjgViZan�dcan�V[iZg�
i]Z�ZaZbZcih�VcY�^cY^k^YjVah�]VkZ�WZZc�^YZci^ÄZY�XdggZXian#�Idd�d[iZc�i]Z�Äghi!�WVh^X�
^YZci^ÄXVi^dch�VgZ�dkZgadd`ZY�dg�]Vhi^an�eZg[dgbZY!�VcY�i]jh�Vcn�hjXXZZY^c\�VcVanhZh�
VgZ�Wj^ai�dc�lZV`�[djcYVi^dch#
8]VeiZgh�,·&+�[dgb�i]Z�XdgZ�d[�i]Z�Wdd`#�>c�i]ZhZ�X]VeiZgh�lZ�Xdch^YZg�dcZ�VcV"
idb^XVa� gZ\^dc�Vi�V� i^bZ!�WZ\^cc^c\�l^i]� i]Z�WdcZh�d[� i]Z� h`jaa#�6� hZeVgViZ�X]VeiZg�
VcY�[dgbVi�VgZ�ZbeadnZY�[dg�i]Z�YZci^i^dc#�LZ�^cigdYjXZ�8]VeiZgh�,·&+�l^i]�Wg^Z[�
VXXdjcih�d[�i]Z�e]nad\ZcZi^X�]^hidgn�d[�i]Z�WdYn�hZ\bZci�h��VcY�dhiZdad\^XVa�ZaZbZcih�
YZhXg^WZY�^ c�i]Z�X]VeiZg#�I]^h�VeegdVX]�hZih�i]Z�dhiZdad\^XVa�ZaZbZcih�^ c�V�WgdVY�Zkdaj"
i^dcVgn�[gVbZldg`#�I]ZhZ�^cigdYjXidgn�hiViZbZcih�VgZ�bdhian�YgVlc�[gdb�i]Z�ZmXZa"
aZci�[jcXi^dcVa�]jbVc�VcVidbn�iZmi�Wn�8Vgib^aa!�=naVcYZg!�VcY�H]VÅVcY��&.-,�!�VcY�
i]Z�^ciZgZhiZY�gZVYZg�bVn�ejghjZ�[jgi]Zg�YZiV^ah�i]ZgZ�VcY�^c�di]Zg�XdbeVgVi^kZ�iZmih�
� 8]VeiZg�&����>cigdYjXi^dc
hjX]�Vh�?Vgk^`��&.-%�#
>c� i]Z� YZhXg^ei^kZ�8]VeiZgh� �,·&+�!� ZVX]� WdcZ� ^h� h]dlc� ^cY^k^YjVaan!� ^c� kVg^djh�
k^Zlh!�Wn�bZVch�d[�e]did\gVe]h#�;dg�ZVhZ�d[�XdbeVg^hdc!�i]Z�hXVaZ�[dg�Vaa�^cY^k^YjVa�
WdcZh�^h�cVijgVa�h^oZ!�l]^aZ�iZZi]�VgZ�h]dlc�il^XZ�cVijgVa�h^oZ#�;dg�eV^gZY�WdcZh!�dcan�
i]Z� g^\]i� h^YZ� ^h� h]dlc�jcaZhh� di]Zgl^hZ� ^cY^XViZY#�Dg^ZciVi^dch� [dg� i]Z� Vgi^XjaViZY�
XgVc^V�VgZ�hiVcYVgY!�VcY�di]Zg�WdcZh�VgZ�^aajhigViZY�^c�dg^ZciVi^dch�h]dl^c\�i]Z�bdhi�
VcVidbn#�;dg�ZmVbeaZ!�i]Z�¹VciZg^dg�k^Zlº�d[�i]Z�[gdciVa�^ h�V�e]did\gVe]�d[�i]Z�VciZg^dg�
hjg[VXZ�d[�i]Vi�WdcZ#�9ZiV^ah�d[�i]Z�egZeVgVi^dc�VcY�e]did\gVe]n�d[�i]ZhZ�heZX^bZch�
VgZ�\^kZc�^c�L]^iZ�VcY�;da`Zch��'%%%�#
=jbVc�dhiZdad\n�iZmih�d[iZc�YZe^Xi�]jbVc�h`ZaZidch�VcY�i]Z^g�ZaZbZcih�Vh�^ [�i]Zn�
lZgZ� ^ciZgX]Vc\ZVWaZ#�HZih�d[� ^aajhigVi^dch�i]Vi�egdk^YZ�a^iiaZ�dg�cd�k^hjVa� ^c[dgbV"
i^dc�dc�i]Z�gZaVi^kZ�h^oZh�d[�Y^[[ZgZci�eVgih�d[�i]Z�h`ZaZidc�VgZ�hiVcYVgY#�;jgi]ZgbdgZ!�
WdcZh�VgZ�d[iZc�jchXVaZY�VcY$dg�YZg^kZY� [gdb�hZkZgVa� ^cY^k^YjVah� ^c� hjX]� ^aajhigV"
i^dch#�I]^h�hVXg^ÄXZh�VYY^i^dcVa�^c[dgbVi^dc�dc�egdedgi^dcVa^in�VcY�[dhiZgh�inedad\^"
XVa� i]dj\]i#�Id�gZbZYn� i]^h� h^ijVi^dc!�lZ�X]dhZ� i]Z� h`ZaZidc�d[�V� h^c\aZ� ^cY^k^YjVa�
id� ^aajhigViZ� Vaa� i]Z� ZaZbZcih� d[� i]Z� edhiXgVc^Va� h`ZaZidc#�6aa� edhiXgVc^Va� ZaZbZcih�
h]dlc�^c�i]Z�YZhXg^ei^kZ�X]VeiZgh�d[�i]^h�bVcjVa�VgZ�[gdb�V�h^c\aZ�bdYZgc�]jbVc�
^cY^k^YjVa!�=VbVcc"IdYY�heZX^bZc�cjbWZg�-*,!�V�ilZcin[djg"nZVg"daY�WaVX`�bVaZ�
l]d�hiddY�*�,��iVaa��&,%�Xb��VcY�lZ^\]ZY�&(-�aW��+'#+�`\�#�I]^h�h`ZaZidc�lVh�X]dhZc�
[dg�^ih�gZaVi^kZan�[Zl�jcjhjVa�[ZVijgZh��cdiZY�^c�i]Z�XVei^dch�[dg�ZVX]�ZaZbZci�!�Xdb"
eaZiZcZhh!� VcY� ZmXZaaZci�egZhZgkVi^dc#�6gi^XjaViZY� XgVc^Va� VcY� Vaa�YZciVa� heZX^bZch�
^aajhigViZY�^c�8]VeiZgh�,�VcY�-�VgZ�d[�gZXZci�BZhdVbZg^XVc�dg^\^c!�VcY�i]Z�Y^hVgi^Xj"
aViZY�WdcZh�d[�i]Z�XgVc^jb�VgZ�Vaa�[gdb�V�h^c\aZ�bdYZgc�^cY^k^YjVa�[gdb�Hdji]Zgc�
6h^V#�CdiZ�i]Vi�i]ZhZ�Y^hVgi^XjaViZY�XgVc^Va�WdcZh�VgZ�[gdb�V�&+"nZVg"daY�^cY^k^YjVa�
^c�l]^X]�i]Z�Wdcn�ZaZbZcih�XdjaY�WZ�Y^hVgi^XjaViZY�VcY�h]dlc�^ciVXi#�I]^h�ndjc\�
^cY^k^YjVa�]VY�cdi�[jaan�YZkZadeZY�Vaa�i]Z�bVg`Zgh�d[�XgVc^Va�gdWjhi^X^in�^aajhigViZY�
Wn�i]Z�Vgi^XjaViZY�h`jaa#
:VX]�YZhXg^ei^kZ�X]VeiZg�^h�dg\Vc^oZY�hnhiZbVi^XVaan#�I]Z�ZaZbZci�^h�Äghi�cVbZY�
VcY� ^ih� Vgi^XjaVi^dch� ^YZci^ÄZY#�JcYZg� i]Z� ¹6cVidbnº� hZXi^dc� [dg� ZVX]� ZaZbZci!� i]Z�
bV_dg�eVgih� VcY�dhiZdad\^XVaan� h^\c^ÄXVci� [ZVijgZh�d[� ZVX]� ZaZbZci� VgZ� ^YZci^ÄZY� ^c�
R_\T�ineZ[VXZ�VcY�YZhXg^WZY#
I]Z� [jcXi^dc�VcY� hd[i� i^hhjZ� gZaVi^dch� [dg�bdhi� higjXijgZh�VgZ� ^YZci^ÄZY� ^c� ^iVa^X�
ineZ[VXZ#�>i�^h�cdi�djg�^ciZci^dc�id�\^kZ�V�XdbeaZiZ�a^hi^c\�d[�bjhXaZ�dg^\^ch�VcY�^chZg"
i^dch#�>chiZVY!�lZ�egdk^YZ�YViV�dc�hd[i�i^hhjZ�id�bV`Z�[jcXi^dcVa�hZchZ�d[�Wdcn�[ZVijgZh�
l]^aZ�XdchiVcian�gZ^c[dgX^c\�i]Z�gZVa^in�d[�WdcZ�Vh�Vc� ^ciZ\gVa�eVgi�d[� i]Z�bjhXjad"
h`ZaZiVa�hnhiZb#
Dhh^ÄXVi^dc�d[�ZVX]�ZaZbZci�^h�Wg^ZÅn�Xdch^YZgZY�^c�i]Z�YZhXg^ei^kZ�X]VeiZgh�jcYZg�
V�hZXi^dc�XVaaZY�7b_gdX#�;jgi]Zg�YZiV^ah�dc�YZkZadebZci�d[�kVg^djh�ZaZbZcih�VgZ�egZ"
hZciZY�^c�8]VeiZg�&.#�I]Z�@_ccYR\U�3_^VecY_^�VcY�CYTY^W�hZXi^dch�egdk^YZ�^c[dgbV"
i^dc�id�XdbeaZbZci�i]Z�^aajhigVi^dch�VcY�Vaadl�Z[[ZXi^kZ�^YZci^ÄXVi^dc�d[�^hdaViZY�VcY�
[gV\bZciVgn�h`ZaZiVa�ZaZbZcih#
BZVhjgZbZcih�^c�i]^h�bVcjVa�VgZ�ZmegZhhZY�^c�i]Z�bZig^X�hnhiZb�Vh�^h�hiVcYVgY�^c�
dhiZdad\n#�8VgiZg��&.-%��egdk^YZh�V�\ddY�]^hidgn�d[�i]Z�:c\a^h]�VcY�bZig^X�hnhiZbh�[dg�
hijYZcih�jc[Vb^a^Vg�l^i]�bZig^X�iZgbh�dg�[dg�i]dhZ�l]d�gZbV^c�jcXdck^cXZY�d[�i]Z�bZig^X�hnhiZb¼h�ji^a^in�^c�bdYZgc�hX^Zci^ÄX�^ckZhi^\Vi^dc#
*&#(����GZhdjgXZh�[dg�i]Z�DhiZdad\^hi
�����2ESOURCES�FOR�THE�/STEOLOGIST
I]Z�bdhi� ^bedgiVci� h^c\aZ�gZhdjgXZ� [dg� i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi� ^h�V�XdaaZXi^dc�d[� h`ZaZiVa� gZ"
bV^ch#�>YZVaan!�i]Z�aVWdgVidgn�h]djaY�]VkZ�V�\gdli]�hZg^Zh�d[�h`ZaZidch�d[�^cY^k^YjVah�d[�
`cdlc�V\Z�id�VXXdbeVcn�bdjciZY�h`ZaZidch�d[�hZkZgVa�^cY^k^YjVah!�Vh�lZaa�Vh�ZaZbZci�
XdaaZXi^dch�^c�l]^X]�bVcn�^cY^k^YjVah�d[�`cdlc�hZm!�V\Z!�dXXjeVi^dc!�VcY�eVi]dad\n�
VgZ�gZegZhZciZY#�6�XdaaZXi^dc�d[�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch�[gdb�V�kVg^Zin�d[�bdYZgc�cdc]jbVc�
Vc^bVah�^h�Vahd�kZgn�^bedgiVci#�HX]ZjZg�VcY�7aVX`¼h�'%%%�VcY�'%%)�kdajbZh�VgZ�Zm"
XZaaZci�XdbeVc^dch�id�i]^h�bVcjVa#�I]Zn�egZhZci�ZmiZch^kZ�^aajhigVi^dch�d[�^bbVijgZ�
]jbVc�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch#
6h�ndj�ldg`�l^i]�]jbVc�WdcZh�VcY�iZZi]!�ValVnh�gZheZXi�i]Zb�Vh�dW_ZXih�d[�hX^"
Zci^ÄX�^cfj^gn#�>c�hdbZ�lVnh!�h`ZaZiVa�gZhdjgXZh�VgZ�a^`Z�Wdd`h�^c�V�a^WgVgn#�7dcZh�VcY�
iZZi]�]VkZ�i]Z�ediZci^Va!�^[�gZVY�XdggZXian!�id�^c[dgb�VWdji�i]Z�a^k^c\!�WgZVi]^c\�eZdeaZ�
id�l]db�i]Zn�dcXZ�WZadc\ZY#�IgZVi�i]ZhZ�gZbV^ch�l^i]�XVgZ0�hdbZ�d[�i]Zb�VgZ�[gV\^aZ�
VcY�Vaa�d[�i]Zb�VgZ�^ggZeaVXZVWaZ#
GZheZXi�Vcn�hnhiZb�d[�dg\Vc^oVi^dc�^c�l]^X]�ndj�ÄcY�h`ZaZiVa�bViZg^Va#�CZkZg�b^m�
WdcZh�VcY�iZZi]�d[�Y^[[ZgZci�^cY^k^YjVah!�ZkZc�[dg�V�h]dgi�i^bZ�dg�l^i]�i]Z�WZhi�d[�^ciZc"
i^dch#�GZbZbWZg�i]Vi�b^m^c\�d[�WdcZh�gZhjaih�^c�V�adhh�d[�XdciZmijVa�^c[dgbVi^dc¸Vc�
VXi^dc�i]Vi�^h�ediZci^Vaan�ZkZc�bdgZ�YZkVhiVi^c\�i]Vc�e]nh^XVa�WgZV`V\Z�d[�Vc�ZaZbZci#�
>c� i]Z� a^WgVgn!�]^hidgn�Wdd`h� h]ZakZY� ^cXdggZXian� ^c� i]Z�W^dad\n�hZXi^dc�WZXdbZ�jc"
VkV^aVWaZ�id�Vcn�]^hidg^Vc�l]d�l^h]Zh�id�Xdchjai�i]Zb#�7dcZh�gZh]ZakZY�^c�i]Z�lgdc\�
eaVXZ�VgZ�Vabdhi�^bedhh^WaZ�id�gZig^ZkZ#
;^cVaan!�gZheZXi�i]Z�eZdeaZ�l]d�XVbZ�WZ[dgZ�ndj�Wn�igZVi^c\�i]Z^g�WdcZh�l^i]�XVgZ#�
GZheZXi�i]Z�\ZcZgVi^dch�d[�hijYZcih�VcY�egd[Zhh^dcVah�l]d�l^aa�[daadl�ndj�Wn�`ZZe^c\�
i]Z�WdcZh�VcY�i]Z^g�egdkZc^ZcXZ�^ciVXi#
7ZndcY� i]Z� e]nh^XVa� eaVci� d[� i]Z� aVWdgVidgn!� `Zn� gZhdjgXZh� [dg� i]Z�]jbVc�dhiZ"
dad\^hi�]VkZ� igVY^i^dcVaan�WZZc�Zfj^ebZci!� heZX^bZch!�VcY�ejWa^XVi^dch#�I]Z�VYkZci�
d[�ZaZXigdc^X�ejWa^h]^c\�VcY�ZYjXVi^dcVa�hd[ilVgZ�VcY�i]Z�Zmeadh^dc�d[�gZhdjgXZh�dc�
i]Z�LdgaY�L^YZ�LZW�]Vh�YgVbVi^XVaan�ZmiZcYZY�gZhdjgXZh�VkV^aVWaZ�id�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi#�
I]ZhZ�bZY^V�VgZ�gVe^Yan�\gdl^c\!�Zkdak^c\!�VcY�kdaVi^aZ!�Wji�^i�^h�^bedgiVci�i]Vi�i]Z�dh"
iZdad\^hi�WZ�VlVgZ�d[�i]Zb#�I]Z�6eeZcY^m�gZegZhZcih�Vc�ViiZbei�id�^YZci^[n�VcY�VhhZhh�
i]Z�bdhi�hiVWaZ!�^bedgiVci!�VcY�jhZ[ja�lZW�h^iZh�eZgiV^c^c\�id�]jbVc�dhiZdad\n#
�����)DENTIFYING�"ONES
>c�WdcZ� ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc� ^i�eVnh� id�gZbZbWZg�i]Vi� i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�ValVnh�]Vh�Vc� ^ciVXi�
XdbeVgVi^kZ�h`ZaZidc�XadhZ�Vi�]VcY!�ZkZc�^c�gZbdiZ�ÄZaY�h^ijVi^dch#�I]Vi�h`ZaZidc�^h�
ZbWZYYZY� ^c�]^h� dg�]Zg� dlc�WdYn#� � >i� ^h� jhZ[ja� id� k^hjVa^oZ� VcY� ZkZc�`Q\`QdU� �[ZZa�
ndjg�dlc�WdcZh�i]gdj\]�i]Z�h`^c��i]Z�lVn�^c�l]^X]�Vc�^hdaViZY�h`ZaZiVa�ZaZbZci�b^\]i�
¹eaj\�^cidº�ndjg�dlc�WdYn#�I]^h�^h�eVgi^XjaVgan�igjZ�[dg�^YZci^[n^c\�VcY�h^Y^c\�iZZi]!�
l]^X]�VgZ�XdckZc^Zcian�ZmedhZY�^c�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi¼h�bdji]#�CZkZg�g^Y^XjaZ�Vc�dhiZdad"
\^hi�l]d�]daYh�V�gVY^jh�V\V^chi� i]Z�g^\]i� [dgZVgb�VcY�i]Zc�h]^[ih� ^i� id� i]Z� aZ[i� [dgZ"
Vgb�WZ[dgZ�^YZci^[n^c\�^i0�i]Vi�dhiZdad\^hi�l^aa�egdWVWan�h^YZ�i]Z�WdcZ�XdggZXian#�L]Zc�
^YZci^[n^c\�i]Z�h^YZ�d[�Vcn�^YZci^ÄZY�h`ZaZiVa�ZaZbZci!�Vaa�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�]Vh�id�Yd�^h�
� 8]VeiZg�&����>cigdYjXi^dc
ZhiVWa^h]�i]gZZ�VmZh�^c�heVXZ/�ide�id�Wdiidb!�h^YZ�id�h^YZ!�VcY�[gdci�id�WVX`#�6cVidb^XVa�
[ZVijgZh�d[�i]Z�WdcZ�l^aa�Vhh^hi�^ c�i]^h!�i]ZgZWn�egdk^Y^c\�i]Z�XajZh�cZXZhhVgn�[dg�XdggZXi�
^YZci^ÄXVi^dc�VcY�dg^ZciVi^dc#
6�hZXdcY�i^e�[dg�^ YZci^[n^c\�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch�^ ckdakZh�]^ZgVgX]^Zh�d[�YZX^h^dch#�7Z"
\^c�^YZci^[n^c\�V�WdcZ�Wn�YZX^Y^c\�l]^X]�ZaZbZcih�^i�XVccdi�WZ#�;dg�ZmVbeaZ!�V�gVY^jh�
[gV\bZci�XVccdi�WZ�V�XgVc^Va�WdcZ�dg�iddi]��l]^X]�ZmXajYZh�]jcYgZYh�d[�edhh^W^a^i^Zh�!�
V�i^W^V�dg�]jbZgjh��idd�hbVaa�!�V�bZiViVghVa��idd�W^\�!�dg�ZkZc�V�ÄWjaV��lgdc\�h]VeZ�#�Ndj�
l^aa�WZ�hjgeg^hZY�]dl�hddc�ndj�XVc�ZmXajYZ�Vaa�Wji�i]Z�XdggZXi�X]d^XZ�^[�ndj�VeegdVX]�
^YZci^ÄXVi^dc�^c�i]^h�lVn#
Cd�bViiZg�]dl�d[iZc�ndj�b^h^YZci^[n�V�WdcZ�dg�iddi]!�`ZZe�ign^c\#�9d�cdi�Xdc"
hiVcian�jhZ�i]Z�Vgi^XjaViZY�h`ZaZidc�dg�^ciVXi�h`jaa�Vh�V�XgjiX]#�I]ZgZ�^h�\gZVi�dhiZdad\^"
XVa�igji]�id�i]Z�^YZV�i]Vi�¹l^i]�ZkZgn�b^hiV`Z�lZ�bjhi�hjgZan�WZ�aZVgc^c\#º�Ign�id�aZVgc�
[gdb�ndjg�b^hiV`Zh#�Ign� id� ^YZci^[n� i]Z�`^cYh�d[�b^hiV`Zh�ndj�VgZ�bV`^c\#�6gZ�ndj�
bdhi�d[iZc�b^h^YZci^[n^c\�^bbVijgZ�heZX^bZch4�>[�hd!�hZi�dji�V�\gdli]�hZg^Zh�[dg�ZVX]�
h`ZaZiVa�ZaZbZci�VcY�hZZ�]dl�i]Z�h]VeZ�d[�i]Z�WdcZ�X]Vc\Zh�l^i]�\gdli]#�6gZ�ndj�]Vk"
^c\�igdjWaZ�l^i]�cdc]jbVc�h`ZaZiVa�eVgih4�>[�hd!�add`�Vi�V�gVc\Z�d[�]jbVc�kVg^Vi^dc�
id�\Zi�V�\ddY�^YZV�d[�]dl�bjX]�kVg^Vi^dc�id�ZmeZXi#�6gZ�ndj�h^bean�Xdc[jh^c\�dcZ�eVgi�
d[�i]Z�h`ZaZidc�[dg�Vcdi]Zg4�>[�hd!�add`�Vi�Vaa�i]Z�ZaZbZcih�^c�i]Z�h`ZaZidc�i]Vi�b^\]i�
b^b^X�ZVX]�di]Zg�l]Zc�[gV\bZciVgn�VcY�X]ZX`�i]Z�¹Edhh^WaZ�8dc[jh^dcº�hZXi^dch�^c�
i]Z�YZhXg^ei^kZ�X]VeiZgh�d[�i]^h�bVcjVa#�@ZZe�i]^h�bVcjVa�cZVgWn#�>i�^h�bjX]�ZVh^Zg�id�
XVggn�i]Vc�V�h`ZaZidc!�VcY�i]Z�a^[Z"h^oZ�e]did\gVe]h�^c�bVcn�k^Zlh�h]djaY�[VX^a^iViZ�
XdbeVg^hdch�VcY�^YZci^ÄXVi^dch#
,
#HAPTER��
;^ZaY�EgdXZYjgZh�[dg�
H`ZaZiVa�GZbV^ch
=jcYgZYh�d[�hijY^Zh�VWdji�]jbVc�dhiZdad\n�VgZ�ejWa^h]ZY�ZVX]�nZVg!�gVc\^c\�[gdb�^c^i^Va�VccdjcXZbZcih�d[�[dhh^a�Y^hXdkZg^Zh��L]^iZ�Zi�Va#!�'%%(��id�XdbegZ"
]Zch^kZ� igZVibZcih� ^ckdak^c\�bjai^eaZ�edejaVi^dch� �AVghZc!�'%%&�#�6aa� i]ZhZ� hijY^Zh�
WZ\^c�l^i]�ÄZaYldg`#�I]^h�X]VeiZg�^cigdYjXZh�egdXZYjgZh�jhZ[ja�^c�gZXdkZg^c\�h`ZaZiVa�
bViZg^Va#�I]Z�X]VeiZg�^ h�dg\Vc^oZY�^ c�Vc�Veegdm^bViZan�X]gdcdad\^XVa�bVccZg#�LZ�Äghi�
gZk^Zl�VheZXih�d[�Y^hXdkZgn�VcY�iZX]c^fjZh�d[�gZig^ZkVa�VcY�ZmXVkVi^dc#�I]Zc�lZ�Y^h"
Xjhh�igVchedgi�d[�h`ZaZiVa�bViZg^Va#�AVWdgVidgn�egdXZYjgZh�VcY�gZedgi^c\�VgZ�XdkZgZY�
^c�8]VeiZg�&-#
>c�ZkZgn�VheZXi�d[�dhiZdad\^XVa�VcVanh^h¸l]Zi]Zg�^c�i]Z�ÄZaY�dg�^c�i]Z�aVWdgVid"
gn¸Xdbbdc�hZchZ�^h�Xg^i^XVa#�>[�i]ZgZ�^h�Vcn�dcZ�dkZgg^Y^c\�gjaZ!�^i�^h�id�i]^c`�WZ[dgZ�
ndj�VXi#�I]ZgZ�^h�cd�h^c\aZ�[dgbjaV!�gZX^eZ!�dg�egdXZYjgZ�id�Veean�^c�ZkZgn�ÄZaY�h^ijV"
i^dc#�I]ZgZ�VgZ�h^bean�idd�bVcn�Y^[[ZgZci�Y^hXdkZgn�XdciZmih�VcY�idd�bjX]�egZhZgkV"
i^dcVa�kVg^Vi^dc�^ckdak^c\�dhiZdad\^XVa�gZbV^ch#�8ZbZiZgn�ZmXVkVi^dc�^h�Y^[[ZgZci�[gdb�
^hdaViZY�h`ZaZidc�ZmXVkVi^dc!�[dhh^a�WdcZh�VgZ�Y^[[ZgZci�[gdb�bdYZgc�dcZh!�[dgZch^X�XVhZh�
VgZ�Y^[[ZgZci�[gdb�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�egd_ZXih!�VcY�lViZgad\\ZY�Wjg^Va�XdcY^i^dch�VgZ�Y^[[Zg"
Zci�[gdb�bjbb^ÄZY�gZbV^ch�^c�i]Z�Yg^Zhi�YZhZgih#�I]ZgZ�VgZ!�]dlZkZg!�hdbZ�\ZcZgVa�
eg^cX^eaZh�i]Vi�Veean�^c�bdhi�^chiVcXZh�l]ZgZ�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch�VgZ�XdcXZgcZY#
>c�bdhi� [dgZch^X� ^ckZhi^\Vi^dch� ^ckdak^c\� dhiZdad\^XVa� gZbV^ch!� i]ZgZ� VgZ� d[ÄX^Va�
\dkZgcbZci�egdidXdah�id�WZ�[daadlZY#�;dg�ZmVbeaZ!�i]Z�8ZcigVa�>YZci^ÄXVi^dc�AVWdgV"
idgn�=VlV^^��J#H#�6gbZY�;dgXZh0�8>A=>�!�i]Z�6gbZY�;dgXZh�BZY^XVa�:mVb^cZg��6gbZY�
;dgXZh�>chi^ijiZ�d[�EVi]dad\n0�6;>E�!�VcY�i]Z�;ZYZgVa�7jgZVj�d[�>ckZhi^\Vi^dc�Vaa�]VkZ�
lg^iiZc�\j^YZh� [dg� i]Z�]VcYa^c\�d[�]jbVc�gZbV^ch#�D[iZc�iZgbZY�¹HDEh!º� i]ZhZ�VgZ�
hiVcYVgY�deZgVi^c\�egdXZYjgZh�i]Vi�\dkZgc�]dl�dhiZdad\^XVa�bViZg^Vah�VgZ�igZViZY�Wn�
eZghdccZa#�JhjVaan�i]ZhZ�gZbV^ch��d[iZc�YZÄcZY�Vh�]jbVc�W^dad\^XVa�i^hhjZ��Xdchi^ijiZ�
Zk^YZcXZ!�VcY�i]Z�ejgedhZ�d[�bVcn�d[�i]Z�egdXZYjgZh�^h�id�ZchjgZ�i]Z�^ciZ\g^in!�bV^c"
iZcVcXZ!�VcY�hZXjg^in�d[�i]Vi�Zk^YZcXZ#�HDEh�d[iZc�^cXajYZ�hXZcZ�egdXZYjgZh!�hVbea^c\�
egdXZYjgZh!� aVWdgVidgn� egdXZYjgZh!� gZedgi^c\� egdXZYjgZh!� hidgV\Z� egdXZYjgZh!� Zfj^e"
bZci�egdXZYjgZh!�VcY�hV[Zin�egdXZYjgZh#�I]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�h]djaY�WZXdbZ�[Vb^a^Vg�l^i]�
i]ZhZ�d[ÄX^Va�egdidXdah�VcY�egdXZYjgZh�l]ZcZkZg�^ckdakZY�^c�V�[dgZch^X�^ckZhi^\Vi^dc#��
H`^ccZg� VcY� XdaaZV\jZh� �'%%(�� egdk^YZ� kZgn� jhZ[ja� VcY� XdbegZ]Zch^kZ� \j^YZa^cZh�
[dg�dhiZdad\^XVa�ldg`�^c�bdYZgc�[dgZch^X�hZii^c\h!�eVgi^XjaVgan�i]dhZ�^ckdak^c\�bVhh�
\gVkZh#
� 8]VeiZg�'����;^ZaY�EgdXZYjgZh
�����3EARCH
DhiZdad\^XVa�gZbV^ch�bVn�WZ�Y^hXdkZgZY�^c�[dgZch^X!�VgX]Zdad\^XVa!�dg�eVaZdcidad\^XVa�XdciZmih�Z^i]Zg�Vh�V�gZhjai�d[�^ciZci^dcVa�egd[Zhh^dcVa�dg�VbViZjg�hjgkZn�dg�Vh�V�gZhjai�d[�
Vc�VXX^YZci#�>ciZci^dcVa�hZVgX]�bZi]dYdad\^Zh�kVgn�l^YZan!�[gdb�eVaZdcidad\^XVa�ZmeZ"
Y^i^dch�id�bjgYZg�dg�Y^hVeeZVgVcXZ�^ckZhi^\Vi^dch#�HdbZi^bZh�i]Z�hZVgX]�^h�aVg\Z"hXVaZ!�
V^bZY�Vi�gZXdkZgn�d[�hXViiZgZY�]db^c^Y�gZbV^ch�^c�aVg\Z�[dhh^a�ÄZaYh#�Di]Zg�i^bZh!�i]Z�
hZVgX]�XVc�WZ�kZgn�adXVa^oZY!�Vh�^c�i]Z�X]VggZY�gjWWaZ�d[�i]Z�7gVcX]�9Vk^Y^Vc�8db"
edjcY�^c�IZmVh��DlhaZn�Zi�Va#!�&..*�!�dg�dc�V�aVg\Zg�hXVaZ!�Vh�^c�i]Z�hZVgX]�[dg�b^a^iVgn�
B>6h�l^i]^c�YZXVYZh"daY�XgViZgh�XgZViZY�Wn�]^\]"heZZY�b^a^iVgn� ^beVXi� �=dh]dlZg!�
&..-�#�I]Z�kVg^Zin�d[�gZbdiZ"hZch^c\�Veea^XVi^dch�id�[dgZch^X�^ ckZhi^\Vi^dch�^ h�gZk^ZlZY�
Wn�9VkZcedgi��'%%&��VcY�7jX`��'%%(�!�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�hjgkZn�bZi]dYh�VgZ�gZk^ZlZY�Wn�
7Vcc^c\��'%%'�!�VcY�EZVghdc��'%%&��\^kZh�V�Xgdhh"XjaijgVa�dkZgk^Zl�d[�i]Z�VgX]Zdad\n�
d[�YZVi]�VcY�Wjg^Va#
HdbZi^bZh� gZbV^ch� [gdb� VgX]Zdad\^XVa� dg� ]^hidg^XVa� XZbZiZgn� XdciZmih�bVn� WZ�
Wgdj\]i�id�i]Z�ViiZci^dc�d[�aVl�Zc[dgXZbZci�V\Zcih�dg�bZY^XVa�ZmVb^cZgh�Vh�V�gZhjai�
d[�kVcYVa^hb�dg�cVijgVa�XVjhZh��7ZggnbVc�Zi�Va#!�&..&�#�Di]Zg�i^bZh!�[dgZch^X�dhiZdad"
\^hih� VgZ� ^ckdakZY� ^c� i]Z� hZVgX]� [dg� XaVcYZhi^cZ� \gVkZh�jh^c\�bZi]dYh� gVc\^c\� [gdb�
VZg^Va�e]did\gVe]h�id�igV^cZY�hXZci"YZiZXi^dc�Yd\h��;gVcXZ�Zi�Va#!�&..'!�@dbVg!�&...�#�
D[� XdjghZ!� cdi� Vaa� hZVgX]Zh� gZhjai� ^c� Y^hXdkZgn!� VcY� bVcn� V� eVaZdcidad\^hi� gZijgch�
Zbein"]VcYZY#�<Vgg^hdc��'%%(��egdk^YZh�V�jhZ[ja!�WgdVY�dkZgk^Zl�d[�\ZdVgX]Zdad\^XVa�
XdciZmih�^c�l]^X]�k^gijVaan�Vaa�dhiZdad\^XVa�gZbV^ch�b^\]i�WZ�gZXdkZgZY!�VcY�8dccdg�
VcY�HXdii� �'%%&�!�=V\ajcY� �'%%&�!�8g^hi� �'%%&�!�VcY�DlhaZn� �'%%&��gZk^Zl�i]Z�lVnh�
^c�l]^X]�VgX]Zdad\n�XVc�Vhh^hi�^c�[dgZch^X�^ckZhi^\Vi^dc#�HiZVYbVc��'%%(��egdk^YZh�Vc�
dkZgk^Zl�d[�hZVgX]^c\�^c�[dgZch^X�Vci]gdedad\n#�HZVgX]�bZi]dYh�l^aa�kVgn�l^YZan�^c�
dhiZdad\n�YZeZcY^c\�dc�i]Z�jc^fjZ�XdciZmi�d[�ZVX]�XVhZ!�Wji�dcXZ�Y^hXdkZgn�^h�bVYZ!�V�
\ZcZgVa�hZg^Zh�d[�hiZeh�^h�hZi�^c�bdi^dc#
�����$ISCOVERY
H`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch�VgZ�d[iZc�[djcY�Wn�VXX^YZci#�;dg�ZmVbeaZ!�]^`Zgh�VcY�XdchigjXi^dc�
XgZlh�d[iZc�ÄcY�dhiZdad\^XVa�bViZg^Va#�L]Zc�i]Zn�Yd!�i]Zn�jhjVaan�gZedgi�^i� id�adXVa�
aVl"Zc[dgXZbZci�Vji]dg^i^Zh#�7ZXVjhZ�i]ZgZ�VgZ�bVcn�bdgZ�Yd\!�]dghZ!�Xdl!�VcY�\dVi�
WdcZh�i]Vc�]jbVc�WdcZh�dc�i]Z�hjg[VXZ�d[�bdhi�aVcYhXVeZh!�i]ZhZ�VgZ�d[iZc�b^hiV`Zc�
[dg�]jbVc�WdcZh�Wn�aVneZghdch�VcY�VbViZjgh#�6�\ZcZgVa�gjaZ�[dg�i]Z�egVXi^X^c\�]j"
bVc�dhiZdad\^hi�^ h�id�VhhjbZ�i]Vi�aVl"Zc[dgXZbZci�eZghdccZa�l]d�d[iZc�Äghi�ZcXdjciZg�
hjX]�gZbV^ch��^cXajY^c\!�^c�hdbZ�XVhZh!�XdgdcZgh��VgZ�cdi�fjVa^ÄZY�id�gZcYZg�VXXjgViZ�
de^c^dch�dc�^hdaViZY!�[gV\bZciVgn�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch#�;dg�ZmVbeaZ!�eZi�gVWW^ih�i]Vi�eZg"
^h]ZY�^c�igV^aZg�]dbZ�ÄgZh�]VkZ�WZZc�^YZci^ÄZY�Wn�d[ÄX^Va�XdgdcZgh�Vh�]jbVc�^c[Vcih#�
;dgZch^X� ]jbVc� dhiZdad\^hih� jhjVaan� ZcXdjciZg� h^ijVi^dch� ^c� l]^X]�bdge]dad\^XVa�
^YZci^ÄXVi^dc�^h�ZVh^an�VXXdbea^h]ZY��Wji�hZZ�JWZaV`Zg�Zi�Va#!�&..&�#�=dlZkZg!�V�Xddg"
Y^cViZY�Z[[dgi�WZilZZc�e]nh^XVa�Vci]gdedad\^hih�VcY�aVl"Zc[dgXZbZci�heZX^Va^hih�Vi�V�
Xg^bZ�hXZcZ�^h�VWhdajiZan�ZhhZci^Va�[dg�i]Z�gZXdkZgn�d[�Vaa�VkV^aVWaZ�XajZh��Lda[!�&.-+0�
BVeaZh�VcY�7gdlc^c\!�&..)0�9^g`bVVi�VcY�6YdkVh^d!�&..,�#
Dc�WZ^c\�^ cigdYjXZY�id�h`ZaZiVa�bViZg^Va!�i]Z�]jbVc�dhiZdad\^hi�^ h�[VXZY�l^i]�i]gZZ�
Xg^i^XVa�fjZhi^dch/
.'#'����9^hXdkZgn
� ™�� >h�i]Z�bViZg^Va�]jbVc4
� ™�� =dl�bVcn�^cY^k^YjVah�VgZ�gZegZhZciZY4
� ™�� D[�l]Vi�Vci^fj^in�^h�i]Z�bViZg^Va4
:meZg^ZcXZ�^h�i]Z�bdhi�kVajVWaZ�XdbbdY^in�^c�VchlZg^c\�i]Z�Äghi�ild�fjZhi^dch#�
L]Zc�^c�Vcn�YdjWi!�Xdchjai�XdbeVgVi^kZ�h`ZaZiVa�bViZg^Va�dg�i]Z�^aajhigVi^dch�^c�i]^h�
bVcjVa#
I]Z�i]^gY�fjZhi^dc�^h�jhjVaan�bdgZ�Y^[ÄXjai�id�VchlZg�VXXjgViZan!�eVgi^XjaVgan�^[�
XdciZmijVa�^c[dgbVi^dc�^h�cdi�VkV^aVWaZ#�Id�\^kZ�Vc�VXXjgViZ�VchlZg�^i�^h�cZXZhhVgn�id�
Zc\V\Z�^c�V�a^iiaZ�YZiZXi^kZ�ldg`#�I]Z�XdcY^i^dc�d[�WdcZh�i]ZbhZakZh�YdZh�cdi�iZaa�kZgn�
bjX]�WZXVjhZ�i]Z�e]nh^XVa�XdcY^i^dc�d[�i]Z�WdcZh�^h�aVg\Zan�XdcigdaaZY�Wn�i]Z�e]nh^"
XVa� Zck^gdcbZci� ^c�l]^X]� i]Zn�lZgZ�YZedh^iZY#�7dcZ�lZVi]Zg^c\� VcY�YZiZg^dgVi^dc�
VgZ�VXXZaZgViZY�Wn�Y^gZXi�hjca^\]i!�]^\]�]ZVi!�ÅjXijVi^c\�iZbeZgVijgZ�VcY�]jb^Y^in!�
W^di^X�^cÅjZcXZh!�VcY�hd^a�VX^Y^in#�L]Zc�i]ZhZ�kVg^VWaZh�VgZ�]ZaY�id�V�b^c^bjb!�WdcZ�
YZiZg^dgVi^dc�XVc�egd\gZhh�kZgn�hadlan#�Id�VhhZhh�i]Z�Vci^fj^in�d[�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch��cdi�
^cY^k^YjVa�V\Z�Vi�YZVi]�!�^i�^h�cZXZhhVgn�id�\^kZ�eg^bVgn�Xdch^YZgVi^dc�id�i]Z^g�XdciZmi#�
=Vh�i]Z�h`ZaZidc�WZZc�gZXZcian�Y^hijgWZY4�L]Vi�`^cYh�d[�Vgi^[VXih�VeeZVg�l^i]�i]Z�gZ"
bV^ch4�;VahZ�iZZi]!�YZciVa�Äaa^c\h!�Xd^ch!�WZVYh!�ediiZgn!�Xd[Äc�cV^ah!�VcY�di]Zg�Zk^YZcXZ�
d[�bViZg^Va�XjaijgZ� �^[� gZVa�VhhdX^Vi^dc�XVc�WZ�ZhiVWa^h]ZY�l^i]� i]Z� h`ZaZiVa� gZbV^ch��
bVn�WZ�Xg^i^XVa�^c�YZiZgb^c^c\�i]Z�Vci^fj^in�d[�i]Z�WdcZh#�LZVg�d[�i]Z�iZZi]�XVc�hdbZ"
i^bZh�egdk^YZ�XajZh�id�i]Z�dg^\^c�d[�i]Z�h`ZaZiVa�bViZg^Va0�^c�bVcn�eaVXZh!�i]Z�iZZi]�d[�
gZXZcian�YZVY�^cY^k^YjVah�jhjVaan�h]dl�[Vg�aZhh�lZVg�i]Vc�i]Vi�hZZc�jcYZg�VWdg^\^cVa�
XdcY^i^dch#�7ZXVjhZ�XdciZmijVa�^ c[dgbVi^dc�^ h�hd�Xg^i^XVa�id�i]Z�VXXjgViZ�YZiZgb^cVi^dc�
d[�i]Z�Vci^fj^in�VcY�dg^\^c�d[�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch!�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�h]djaY�ValVnh�bV`Z�Zk"
Zgn�Z[[dgi�id�k^h^i�i]Z�Y^hXdkZgn�h^iZ�VcY�bV`Z�V�Äghi]VcY�VhhZhhbZci�VcY�gZXdgY�d[�i]Z�
YZedh^i^dcVa�]^hidgn�VcY�VhhdX^Vi^dch�d[�dhiZdad\^XVa�bViZg^Va#
�����%XCAVATION�AND�2ETRIEVAL
EgdeZg�ZkVajVi^dc�d[�Vcn�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch�cdgbVaan�gZfj^gZh�XdaaZXi^dc�d[�i]Z�WdcZh�
VcY�hjWhZfjZci�aVWdgVidgn�VcVanh^h#�Jedc�Y^hXdkZgn!�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi¼h�cVijgVa�^cXa^cV"
i^dc��eVgi^XjaVgan�l]Zc�i]Z�gZbV^ch�lZgZ�i]Z�dW_ZXi�d[�V�hZVgX]�VcY�ZheZX^Vaan�^[�i]Zn�
VgZ�]db^c^Y�[dhh^ah��^h�id�\Zi�i]Z�WdcZh�dji¸id�XdaaZXi�i]Zb#�I]^h�^bbZY^ViZ�hZeVgV"
i^dc�d[�i]Z�heZX^bZc�[gdb�^ih�XdciZmi�^h�i]Z�ldghi�higViZ\n#�I]Z�WdcZh�XVc�cd�adc\Zg�
¹lVa`�VlVnº�dc�i]Z^g�dlc#�7Z[dgZ�Y^hijgW^c\�i]Z�XdciZmi!�bdkZ�VlVn�[gdb�i]Z�h^iZ�VcY�
XVgZ[jaan�YZkZade�V�higViZ\n�[dg�gZXdgY^c\�VcY�gZXdkZgn#�>[�XZaZWgVi^dc�d[�V�eVaZdcid"
ad\^XVa�Y^hXdkZgn�^h�XVaaZY�[dg!�]daY�^i�d[["h^iZ#�@ZZe�cdcZhhZci^Va�eZghdccZa�d[["h^iZ#�Dc�
i]Z�h^iZ!�^i�^h�VYk^hVWaZ�id�h]dl�eVi^ZcXZ�VcY�gZhigV^ci!�l]^aZ�i]dj\]i[jaan�YZk^h^c\�Vc�
Veegdeg^ViZ� higViZ\n� id�ZmigVXi� i]Z� gZbV^ch�VcY�Vaa� XdciZmijVa� ^c[dgbVi^dc#�Lg^i^c\�
^begZhh^dch�Ydlc�^c�i]Z�[dgb�d[�ÄZaY�cdiZh�^h�cZXZhhVgn�VcY�]Zaeh�^c�i]^h�eaVcc^c\#
6[iZg�i]Z�i]g^aa�VcY�ZmX^iZbZci�d[�Y^hXdkZgn�]VkZ�VWViZY!�^i�^h�i^bZ�[dg�hZg^djh!�dW"
_ZXi^kZ�VhhZhhbZci�d[�i]Z�h^ijVi^dc#�I]Z�[daadl^c\�fjZhi^dch�h]djaY�WZ�XVgZ[jaan�Xdc"
h^YZgZY/�
� ™� L]Vi�VgZ�i]Z�eda^i^XVa�VcY�aZ\Va�XdchigV^cih�jcYZg�l]^X]�gZXdkZgn�bjhi�egdXZZY4�
<daYhiZ^c��&..*��egdk^YZh�Vc�^aajb^cVi^c\�XVhZ�hijYn�^c�i]^h�gZ\VgY#�DhiZdad\^hih�
�� 8]VeiZg�'����;^ZaY�EgdXZYjgZh
h]djaY�Xdc[Zg�l^i]�egd_ZXi�bVcV\ZbZci�id�ZchjgZ�i]Vi�Vaa�Veea^XVWaZ�aVlh�VgZ�[da"
adlZY�VcY�Vaa�XdcXZgcZY�eVgi^Zh�VgZ�^c[dgbZY#�>c�hdbZ�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�VcY�hdbZ�
[dgZch^X�^ckZhi^\Vi^dc�hXZcZh!�]VoVgYdjh�bViZg^Vah�l^aa�eaVn�V�gdaZ�^c�XdcY^i^dc^c\�
]dl�i]Z�ZmXVkVi^dc�VcY�gZig^ZkVa�egdXZZYh#
� ™�� >c�l]Vi�XdcY^i^dc�^h�i]Z�WdcZ4
� ™�� L]Vi�]Vh�]VeeZcZY�id�i]Z�WdcZ�Vh�^i�]Vh�WZZc�ZmedhZY4�=dl�]Vh�cVijgVa�dg�]j"
bVc"^cYjXZY�Zgdh^dc�jcXdkZgZY�VcY�hXViiZgZY�i]Z�WdcZ�VXgdhh�i]Z�aVcYhXVeZ4
� ™�� L]Vi�XdciZmijVa�^c[dgbVi^dc�^h�VkV^aVWaZ4
� ™�� L]Vi�dei^dch�VgZ�i]ZgZ�[dg�gZXdkZg^c\�i]Z�WdcZ4�8dch^YZg�i]Z�VkV^aVWaZ�i^bZ!�
aVWdg!�VcY�Zfj^ebZci#�6h�=dh]dlZg��&..-��cdiZh!�ÅZm^WaZ�ZmXVkVi^dc�higViZ\n�^h�V�
`Zn�XdbedcZci�d[�hjXXZhh[ja�gZXdkZgn#
;^\jgZh�'#&�i]gdj\]�'#&'�^aajhigViZ�hdbZ�VheZXih�d[�h`ZaZiVa�gZXdkZgn�^c�VgX]Zdad\^"
XVa�h^ijVi^dch#�BVnh��&..-�!�JWZaV`Zg��&.-.�!�VcY�L]^iZ�VcY�;da`Zch��'%%%��VgZ�hdjgXZh�
d[�VYY^i^dcVa�^ aajhigVi^dch#�8]VeiZg�&-�gZk^Zlh�heZX^Va�Xdch^YZgVi^dch�^ ckdak^c\�egZhZg"
&IGURE������6�e^dcZZg�Wjg^Va�[gdb�cZVg�i]Z�]^hidg^X�7dgYZVjm�IgVY^c\�Edhi!�hdji]ZVhiZgc�
Lndb^c\#�I]Z�\gVkZ!�l]^X]�hZZbZY�id�WZ�VhhdX^ViZY�l^i]�i]Z�igVY^c\�edhi�dg�i]Z�cZVgWn�
DgZ\dc�IgV^a!�lVh�[djcY�^c�&.-%�Wn�V�ÄZaY�VgX]Zdad\n�XgZl�jcYZg�i]Z�Y^gZXi^dc�d[�<Zdg\Z�<^aa#�
�AZ[i��DWa^fjZ�k^Zl�d[�i]Z�\gVkZ!�djia^cZY�Wn�i]Z�eZg^bZiZg�d[�i]Z�YVg`Zg�^c"Äaa^c\�hd^a#�I]Z�g^\]i�jacV�^h�ZmedhZY�cZVg�i]Z�jeeZg�ZcY�d[�i]Z�\gVkZ�Äaa^c\#�6gi^[VXih�[djcY�l^i]�i]Z�h`ZaZidc�
^cXajYZ�V�lZYY^c\�g^c\�VcY�VY_VXZci�WaVX`�g^c\�d[�bdjgc^c\�VcY�i]gZZ�Xd^ch#��G^\]i��I]Z�\gVkZ�
V[iZg�ZmXVkVi^dc��[gdb�<^aa�Zi�Va#!�&.-)�#�HZZc�^c�i]^h�e]did\gVe]�VgZ�i]Z�gZbV^ch�d[�Wddih�VcY�V�
l^YZ"Wg^bbZY�WaVX`�]Vi�dkZg�i]Z�[VXZ#�6�Y^heaVXZY�[gV\bZci�d[�g^\]i�gVY^jh�^h�eZYZhiVaZY�cZmi�
id�i]Z�g^\]i�eViZaaV#
&&'#(����:mXVkVi^dc�VcY�GZig^ZkVa
kVi^kZh!�W^dbdaZXjaVg�hVbea^c\!�VcY�egZXVji^dch#
I]Z�[daadl^c\�\ZcZgVa�hiZeh�h]djaY�WZ�iV`Zc�^c�i]Z�gZXdkZgn�d[�h`ZaZiVa�bViZg^Va/
� ™� >[�h`ZaZiVa�eVgih�]VkZ�WZZc�hXViiZgZY�Wn�Zgdh^dc!�bVg`�ZVX]�l^i]�V�e^c�ÅV\�VcY�Vh"
hZhh�i]Z�Y^hig^Wji^dc�id�egZY^Xi�l]ZgZ�bdgZ�e^ZXZh�b^\]i�WZ�[djcY#�
� ™� I]Z�dkZgg^Y^c\�XdcXZgc�^c�Vaa�ldg`�hjWhZfjZci�id�i]Z�Y^hXdkZgn�d[�i]Z�heZX^bZc!�
^c�i]Z�ÄZaY�dg�i]Z�aVWdgVidgn!�^h�id�Vaadl�cd�[jgi]Zg�YVbV\Z�id�dXXjg#�:mXVkVi^dc�
VcY�ZmigVXi^dc�YVbV\Z�id�dhiZdad\^XVa�gZbV^ch�^h�Xdbbdc�Wji�jccZXZhhVgn#�HiZeh�
h]djaY�WZ�iV`Zc�id�Xdchda^YViZ�[gV\^aZ�WdcZ�^c�h^ij��^c�eaVXZ��l^i]�egZhZgkVi^kZh!�^[�
egVXi^XVa#
� ™� AdhZ�Vh�a^iiaZ�^c[dgbVi^dc�Vh�edhh^WaZ!�ZheZX^Vaan�XdcXZgc^c\�S_^dUhd#�I]Z�gZbV^ch!�
l]Zi]Zg�^c�V�[dgZch^X�dg�Vc�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�XdciZmi!�VgZ�dcZ"d["V"`^cY#�I]Zn�VgZ�
cdcgZcZlVWaZ�gZhdjgXZh#�I]ZgZ�^h�dcan�dcZ�hjX]�WdcZ!�^cY^k^YjVa!�Wjg^Va!�dg�XZbZ"
iZgn!�l]^X]�bZVch�i]Vi�i]ZgZ�^h�dcan�dcZ�X]VcXZ�id�ZmigVXi�i]Z�gZbV^ch�XdbeaZiZan�
VcY�XdggZXian#�6Xi^dch�iV`Zc�Yjg^c\�gZXdkZgn�]VkZ�XdchZfjZcXZh�i]Vi�adc\�djia^kZ�
Vcn�^ckZhi^\Vidg!�gZcYZg^c\�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi¼h�gZhedch^W^a^in�V�lZ^\]in�dcZ#
� ™� DWiV^c�egdeZg�Zfj^ebZci�[dg�gZXdkZgn#�IVWaZ�'#&�^h�V�hjeean�VcY�Zfj^ebZci�
X]ZX`a^hi�i]Vi�dhiZdad\^hih�bVn�ÄcY�jhZ[ja�id�Xdchjai�WZ[dgZ�]ZVY^c\�^cid�i]Z�ÄZaY#�
Egdk^YZY�i]Vi�i]Z�WdcZh�VcY�i]Z^g�XdciZmi�VgZ�cdi�^bbZY^ViZan�_ZdeVgY^oZY!�gZXdk"
Zgn�h]djaY�WZ�YZaVnZY�jci^a�i]Z�egdeZg�iddah�VgZ�VkV^aVWaZ#�JhZ�ndjg�_jY\ZbZci�dc�
]dl�egZXVg^djh�i]Z�h^ijVi^dc�^h#
� ™� 7Z[dgZ�Y^hijgW^c\�i]Z�hXZcZ�bV`Z�lg^iiZc�VcY�e]did\gVe]^X�gZXdgYh�d[�ZkZgni]^c\�
^bedgiVci#�CZkZg�gZan�dc�bZbdgn#�>i�^h�d[iZc�jhZ[ja�id�ZhiVWa^h]�V�YVijb�ed^ci�
&IGURE������;gdciVa�k^Zl�d[�i]Z�
[gdci^ZghbVc¼h�h`jaa�ZmXVkViZY�
[gdb�i]Z�\gVkZ�h]dlc�^c�;^\jgZ�
'#&#�CdiZ�i]Z�XgVc^Va�\jch]di�
ldjcY�XVjhZY�Wn�V�#))"�dg�)*"XVa^"
WZg�lZVedc#�6�hZXdcY�eZg^bdgiZb�
\jch]di�ldjcY�id�i]Z�]^e�VcY�Vi�
aZVhi�i]gZZ�]ZVa^c\�g^W�[gVXijgZh�
lZgZ�cdiZY�Wn�i]Z�^ckZhi^\Vidgh#�
I]^h�^cY^k^YjVa!�V�bVaZ�l]d�egdW"
VWan�adhi�]^h�l^[Z�eg^dg�id�]^h�dlc�
YZVi]��^cY^XViZY�Wn�i]Z�WaVX`�g^c\�
cZmi�id�i]Z�lZYY^c\�WVcY�!�bdhi�
a^`Zan�lVh�h]di�^c�&-+.�dg�&-,%�
�[gdb�<^aa�Zi�Va#!�&.-)�#
�� 8]VeiZg�'����;^ZaY�EgdXZYjgZh
4ABLE������:fj^ebZci�VcY�Hjeea^Zh�[dg�DhiZdad\^XVa�;^ZaYldg`
I:6B�:FJ>EB:CI
8dbeVhh
IVeZ�bZVhjgZh
=VbbZgh��XVgeZciZg¼h�VcY�\Zdad\^XVa�
CV^ah�dg�hiV`Zh
Il^cZ��nZaadl�dg�l]^iZ�
A^cZ�aZkZah
H]dkZah�VcY�e^X`h!�VmZh�VcY�hVlh
IgdlZah!�WjX`Zih
9^\\^c\�egdWZh��YZciVa�VcY�WVbWdd�
7gjh]Zh��kVg^djh�h^oZh�VcY�hi^[[cZhhZh�
HXgZZch
BZiVa�YZiZXidg��[dgZch^X�XVhZh�
HiZe�aVYYZg
8VbZgV�ig^edY
8VbZgVh��k^YZd!�Y^\^iVa!�EdaVgd^Yœ!�Äab�
8VbZgV�ÅVh]�ViiVX]bZci�VcY�XVWaZ�gZaZVhZ
E]did�hXVaZ!�&-��\gVn�XVgY!�Y^gZXi^dcVa�Vggdl
E]did�^c[dgbVi^dc�WdVgY��Ygn�ZgVhZ�WdVgY�
Ea^Zgh!�lgZcX]Zh!�XjiiZgh!�ÄaZh
GdeZh!�iVgeVja^ch!�ÄZaY�jbWgZaaVh
6Zg^Va�e]did\gVe]h!�hiZgZd�e]did�k^ZlZg
IgVkZa�VcY�ZmXVkVi^dc�eZgb^ih
IVeZ�gZXdgYZg
EdgiVWaZ�iVWaZh�VcY�X]V^gh
7jh]�Xa^eeZgh
<adWVa�edh^i^dc^c\�^chigjbZci
AVeide�XdbejiZg�h�
I:6B�HJEEA>:H�
;^ab�VcY�egdiZXi^kZ�Äab�WV\h
8dbeVXi�ÅVh]�XVgYh��Y^\^iVa�bZY^V�
K^YZd�iVeZh
6jY^d�iVeZh
<ajZ
IVeZ��bVh`^c\!�\V[[Zg¼h!�igVcheVgZci�
E^c�;aV\h
EgZhZgkVi^kZ
HdakZci�[dg�egZhZgkVi^kZ
EVX`^c\�bViZg^Va
8dciV^cZgh��WdmZh!�WV\h!�k^Vah�
6ajb^cjb�[d^a
I^hhjZ�eVeZg
CZlheVeZg�[dg�lgVee^c\
CdiZWdd`h
Lg^i^c\�jiZch^ah��lViZgegdd[�lg^i^c\�jiZch^ah�
AVWZa^c\�eZch�VcY�^c`
7ViiZg^Zh��ÅVh]a^\]i�VcY�XVbZgV�
L^gZ
?VX`Zi^c\�hjeea^Zh
� EaVhiZg
� <VjoZ
� LViZg
6XZiViZ�h]ZZih
CV^a�eda^h]
Hng^c\Zh
E:GHDC6A�:FJ>EB:CI�
9^\\^c\�^chigjbZcih
EdX`Zi�`c^[Z!�hX^hhdgh
GVY^d
=VcY�aZch
;aVh]a^\]i!�ZmigV�WjaWh�VcY�WViiZg^Zh
8VbZgV!�Äab!�WViiZg^Zh!�ÅVh]!�aZchZh
BZVhjg^c\�iVeZ!�XVa^eZgh
E]did�WVX`\gdjcY!�XVWaZ�gZaZVhZ!�hXVaZ!�higVe
HbVaa�e]did�b^ggdgh
IgVkZa�YdXjbZcih��eVhhedgi!�i^X`Zih!�]ZVai]�
XZgi^ÄXViZ!�^chjgVcXZ�[dgbh!�eZgb^hh^dc�
aZiiZgh�
=Vi�VcY�WVcYVcVh!�\adkZh
IZci
Hjch]dlZg!�idlZa
EaViZ!�Xje!�jiZch^ah!�XVciZZc
HaZZe^c\�WV\�VcY�eVY
CZZYaZ�VcY�i]gZVY
HbVaa�egZeVgVi^dc�`^i
Hjc\aVhhZh!�ZmigV�\aVhhZh�dg�aZchZh
E:GHDC6A�HJEEA>:H�
BdcZn
Lg^i^c\�jiZch^ah!�cdiZWdd`!�XVaXjaVidg
AZch�XaZVc^c\�Åj^Y�VcY�eVeZgh
;^ab
>chi^iji^dcVa�aZiiZg]ZVY�VcY�ZckZadeZh
<V[[Zg¼h�iVeZ
BZY^X^cZh!�lViZg�ejg^ÄZg
EaVhi^X�WV\h
EZgbVcZci�^c`
BVg`^c\�eZch
GjWWZg�WVcYh!�eVeZg�Xa^eh
Id^aZig^Zh
HdVe�VcY�h]Vbedd
Iddi]Wgjh]�VcY�eVhiZ
HjchXgZZc!�a^e�WVab
>chZXi�gZeZaaZci�
&(
&IGURE������EgZ]^hidg^X
VgX]Zdad\^XVa�h^iZ�^c�
cdgi]Zgc�8Va^[dgc^V!�
WZ[dgZ�VcY�V[iZg�ZmXVkV"
i^dc#��Ide��I]Z�djia^cZh�
VcY�YVg`Zg�^cÄaa^c\h�
d[�X^gXjaVg�\gVkZ�e^ih�
XVc�WZ�hZZc�dc�i]Z�
Åddg�d[�i]Z�ZmXVkVi^dc�
igZcX]#�I]Z�hXVaZh�VgZ�
^c�^cX]Zh#��AZ[i��;aZmZY�
Wjg^Vah�lZgZ�gZkZVaZY�
l^i]^c�i]Z�ha^\]ian�
hjeZg^bedhZY�\gVkZ�
e^ih�d[�Wjg^Va�'#�=ZgZ!�
i]Z�ild�^cY^k^YjVah�^c�
i]^h�Wjg^Va�VgZ�h]dlc!�
Wdi]�ÅZmZY#�I]Z�hVbZ�
aVg\Z�hidcZ�VeeZVgh�^c�
i]Z�adlZg�aZ[i�XdgcZgh�
d[�i]Z�ild�e]did\gVe]h#
'#(����:mXVkVi^dc�VcY�GZig^ZkVa
�� 8]VeiZg�'����;^ZaY�EgdXZYjgZh
dc�i]Z�h^iZ�id�Xdcigda�V�\g^Y�aV^Y�dji�l^i]�hiV`Zh�VcY�XdgY�VXgdhh�i]Z�hjg[VXZ#�6aa�
gZXdkZgZY�dW_ZXih�XVc�WZ�gZaViZY�id�i]Z�\g^Y#�Lda[ ¼h��&.-+��VYk^XZ�dc�VeegdVX]^c\�
V�Xg^bZ�hXZcZ�l^i]�hXViiZgZY�bViZg^Va�Vh�^[�ndj�lZgZ�XaZVg^c\�V�b^cZÄZaY�^h�Veegd"
eg^ViZ�^c�i]^h�gZ\VgY#�>c�i]Z�eVhi!�V�EdaVgd^Yœ�XVbZgV�VcY�(*"bb�WaVX`"VcY"l]^iZ�
Äab�lZgZ�egVXi^XVa�VcY�Xdbbdc�hdaji^dch#�=dlZkZg!�Y^\^iVa�^bV\^c\�]Vh�aVg\Zan�
gZeaVXZY�Äab�^c�hjX]�h^ijVi^dch��hZZ�HZXi^dc�&-#.�#�L]Zi]Zg�jh^c\�Äab�dg�Y^\^iVa�
e]did\gVe]n!�dg�iVeZ�dg�Y^\^iVa�gZXdgY^c\!�ValVnh�XgZViZ�V�WVX`je�^c�XVhZ�d[�Zfj^e"
bZci�[V^ajgZ�dg�deZgVidg�b^hiV`Z#�6�hXVaZ�VcY�Y^gZXi^dcVa�Vggdl�h]djaY�WZ�^cXajY"
ZY�^c�Vaa�YgVl^c\h�VcY�e]did\gVe]h#�HjWhZfjZci�hiV\Zh�d[�i]Z�ZmXVkVi^dc�h]djaY�
WZ�e]did\gVe]ZY�[gdb�Vh�bVcn�Vc\aZh�Vh�Veegdeg^ViZ#�GZbdkZ�Vaa�iddah!�dWhXjg^c\�
gddih!�VcY�ajbeh�d[�ZVgi]�WZ[dgZ�e]did\gVe]^c\#�>[�a^\]i^c\�^h�V�egdWaZb!�eVgi^Xj"
aVgan�^c�Vc�ZmXVkVi^dc!�jhZ�V�l]^iZ�h]ZZi�dg�Vajb^cjb�[d^a�dc�XVgYWdVgY!�dg�V�ÅVh]�
ViiVX]bZci!�id�^aajb^cViZ�i]Z�heZX^bZc#�I]Z�`Zn�id�hjXXZhh[ja�e]did\gVe]n�^h�i]Z�
Xdcigda�d[�a^\]i#�>[�V�heZX^bZc�^h�d[�Xg^i^XVa�^bedgiVcXZ!�^i�^h�\ddY�id�bV`Z�V�k^YZd�
gZXdgY�d[�^i�[dg�iZVX]^c\!�aZXijg^c\!�XjgVidg^Va!�VcY�[dgZch^X�ejgedhZh#
� ™� 7Z\^c�egZhZgkVi^dc�bZVhjgZh�^[�cZXZhhVgn��[dg�]VgYZcZgh�VcY�di]Zg�egZhZgkVi^kZh!�
hZZ�8]VeiZg�&-�#
&IGURE������;aZmZY�Wjg^Va�d[�Vc�VYjai�VXXdbeVc^ZY�Wn�\gVkZ�\ddYh#�H]Zaa�WZVYh�VY]ZgZ�id�i]Z�
XgVc^jb!�hidcZh�VgZ�^c�i]Z�bdji]!�VcY�di]Zg�WZVYh�VcY�eZcYVcih�VgZ�hZZc�VgdjcY�i]Z�edhiXgV"
c^Va�h`ZaZidc#�EgZ]^hidg^X!�cdgi]Zgc�8Va^[dgc^V#�I]Z�hXVaZ�^h�^c�^cX]Zh#
&*'#(����:mXVkVi^dc�VcY�GZig^ZkVa
� ™� 8daaZXi�Vaa�WdcZ�ZmedhZY�dc�i]Z�hjg[VXZ!�ZkZc�[gV\bZcih�i]Vi�Yd�cdi�hZZb�id�WZ�
]db^c^Y#�GZbdkZ�ndjg�h]dZh�^[�cZXZhhVgn�VcY�\Zi�Ydlc�dc�ndjg�WZaan�[dg�V�XadhZ�
add`#�BV`Z�hjgZ�i]Z�a^\]i�^h�VYZfjViZ�WZ[dgZ�Yd^c\�i]^h#�>i�^h�id�ndjg�VYkVciV\Z�i]Vi�
gV^ch�]VkZ�lVh]ZY�i]Z�WdcZ�hjg[VXZ�XaZVc0�Vh�ndj�Y^hijgW�i]Z�hd^a�^i�WZXdbZh�bdgZ�
Y^[ÄXjai�id�gZXd\c^oZ�hbVaa�WdcZ�[gV\bZcih#�BdkZ�hadlan�VcY�XVgZ[jaan!�cdi�igVb"
ea^c\�gZbV^ch�dg�Vgi^[VXih�jcYZg[ddi#
� ™� HXgZZc�ZVgi]�[gdb�i]Z�VWYdb^cVa�gZ\^dc�d[�Vaa�h`ZaZidch�id�gZXdkZg�Y^ZiVgn�dg�[ZiVa�
h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch#�HXgZZc�Vaa�d[�i]Z�addhZ�hjg[VXZ�ZVgi]�aZ[i�dkZg�[gdb�ZVX]�h`ZaZidc#�
6�&#%"bb�bZh]�h^oZ��l^cYdl�hXgZZc��l^aa�gZXdkZg�bdhi�^bedgiVci�[gV\bZcih#
� � LViZg�lVh]�ZmXVkViZY�bViZg^Va�i]gdj\]�V�hXgZZc�id�bV`Z�i]Z�hbVaa�[gV\bZcih�
bdgZ�k^h^WaZ�VcY�ZVhn�id�gZXdkZg#�
� ™� ;dg�Wjg^Vah!�dg�di]Zg�Vgi^XjaViZY�^c�h^ij�bViZg^Va!�ZmedhZ�i]Z�WdcZh�dcZ�Vi�V�i^bZ#�>c�Vc�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�XdciZmi�^i�^h�^bedgiVci�id�gZXd\c^oZ�i]Vi�i]ZgZ�^h�V�kZgn�aVg\Z�
XjaijgVaan�YZiZgb^cZY�VcY�Zi]cd\gVe]^XVaan�dWhZgkZY�gVc\Z�d[�kVg^Vi^dc�^c�]j"
bVc�bdgijVgn�egVXi^XZ#�;dg�bdhi�Veea^XVi^dch!�]dlZkZg!�i]ZgZ�VgZ�hdbZ�\ZcZgVa�
`^cYh�d[�Wjg^Vah�id�l]^X]�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�h]djaY�WZ�VaZgi/�6�`bY]Qbi�Y^dUb]U^d�^h�
V�Wjg^Va�^c�l]^X]�Vaa�d[�i]Z�WdcZh�VgZ�^c�Vc�VcVidb^XVaan�¹cVijgVaº�VggVc\ZbZci#�
HjX]�Wjg^Vah�VgZ�hdbZi^bZh�XaVhh^ÄZY�VXXdgY^c\�id�l]Zi]Zg�i]Z�ZmigZb^i^Zh�VgZ�
ZmiZcYZY�dg�ÅZmZY#�I]ZgZ�VgZ�cd�cZVi�XViZ\dg^oVi^dch�]ZgZ!�VcY�dcZ�e]did\gVe]�^h�
&IGURE������EgZ]^hidg^X�XgZbVi^dc�ZmedhZY�Wn�Vc�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�ZmXVkVi^dc#�6hhdX^ViZY�l^i]�i]Z�
XgZbVi^dc�VgZ�dWh^Y^Vc�Vgi^[VXih#�I]Z�XgZbViZY�WdcZ�[gV\bZcih�VgZ�hZZc�^c�i]Z�VgZV�VWdkZ�i]Z�
A6H#�,�^cY^XVidg#�EgZ]^hidg^X!�cdgi]Zgc�8Va^[dgc^V#�I]Z�hXVaZ�^h�^c�^cX]Zh#
�� 8]VeiZg�'����;^ZaY�EgdXZYjgZh
ldgi]�bVcn�ldgYh�d[�YZhXg^ei^dc#�6�cUS_^TQbi�Y^dUb]U^d�^h�V�Wjg^Va�^c�l]^X]�
i]Z�WdcZh�d[�V�h`ZaZidc�VgZ�cdi�^c�V�¹cVijgVaº�VcVidb^XVa�gZaVi^dch]^e�Wji�]VkZ�
WZZc�\Vi]ZgZY�id\Zi]Zg�hdbZ�i^bZ�V[iZg�XdbeaZiZ�dg�eVgi^Va�Y^hVgi^XjaVi^dc�d[�i]Z�
h`ZaZidc�VcY�i]Zc�Wjg^ZY#�HdbZi^bZh�i]^h�Wjg^Va�Xdbeg^hZh�V�WjcYaZ�d[�WdcZh#�6�
]e\dY`\U�Y^dUb]U^d�^h�V�Wjg^Va�^c�l]^X]�bdgZ�i]Vc�dcZ�^cY^k^YjVa�^h�egZhZci#�
I]ZhZ�Wjg^Vah�^cXajYZ�dhhjVg^Zh!�Wjg^Va�jgch�XdciV^c^c\�bdgZ�i]Vc�dcZ�^cY^k^YjVa!�
VcY�V�kVg^Zin�d[�di]Zg�edhh^W^a^i^Zh#�3bU]QdY_^�^h�V�bdgijVgn�egVXi^XZ�^ckdak^c\�
i]Z�^ciZci^dcVa�Wjgc^c\�d[�i]Z�WdYn#�8gZbVi^dch�XVc�d[iZc�WZ�^c[dgbVi^kZ¸i]Z�
aZhh�Z[ÄX^Zci�i]Z�ÄgZ!�i]Z�bdgZ�^c[dgbVi^kZ�i]Z�heZX^bZc#�B^Xdoo^��&..&��gZk^Zlh�
bdgijVgn�egVXi^XZh�ldgaYl^YZ#
� ™� >c�Zmedh^c\�Wjg^Vah!�jhZ�Veegdeg^ViZ�iddah�VcY�jhZ�i]Zb�XVgZ[jaan#�9ZciVa�e^X`h�
VgZ�h]Vge�VcY�Z[ÄX^Zci!�Wji�i]Zn�XVc�ZVh^an�YVbV\Z�i]Z�WdcZ#�LddYZc�dg�WVbWdd�
iddah�bVn�hdbZi^bZh�WZ�hj^iVWaZ!�VcY�V�gVc\Z�d[�Wgjh]Zh�d[�kVg^djh�h^oZh�VcY�hi^[["
cZhh�^h�^cY^heZchVWaZ#�Ldg`�[gdb�i]Z�g^W�XV\Z�djilVgY�l]ZgZ�edhh^WaZ#�9d�cdi�jhZ�
i]Z�igdlZa�^c�V�hlZZe^c\�bdi^dc�jcaZhh�ndj�VgZ�Yd^c\�ZmeadgVidgn�ldg`#�Ign�id�
aZVkZ�WdcZh�hjeedgiZY�Vh�ndj�XaZVc!�Zmedh^c\�i]Z�[ddi�VcY�]VcY�WdcZh�aVhi#�LViX]�
[dg�hd^a�Xdadg�VcY�iZmijgZ�X]Vc\Zh!�gdYZci�VcY�gddi�Y^hijgWVcXZ!�bVi�^begZhh^dch!�
gdiiZY�kZ\ZiVi^dc!�lddY!�^chZXi�gZbV^ch!�X]VgXdVa!�VcY�VhhdX^ViZY�Vgi^[VXih�hjX]�
Vh�a^e�eaj\h�dg�WZVYh#�7Z�VaZgi�id�Vaa�hd[i�i^hhjZ�i]Vi�b^\]i�gZbV^c!�^cXajY^c\�]V^g!�
h`^c!�Äc\Zgeg^cih!�VcY�a^\VbZcih#�Lg^iZ�dgdi]Zgl^hZ�gZXdgY�ndjg�cdiZh0�bZbdgn�
l^aa�cdi�hj[ÄXZ#�GZXdgY�Vc\aZh�d[�ÅZm^dc!�i]Z�dg^ZciVi^dc�d[�i]Z�WdYn�VcY�]ZVY!�
i]Z�YZei]�d[�i]Z�WdcZh�[gdb�i]Z�hjg[VXZ�dg�i]Z�YVijb!�VcY�Vcn�di]Zg�XdciZmijVa�
YZiV^ah#�IV`Z�hd^a�hVbeaZh�l]ZgZ�Veegdeg^ViZ#�GZbZbWZg�i]Vi�Vaa�YZiV^ah�d[�XdciZmi�
h]djaY�WZ�gZiV^cZY�^c�Vc�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�dg�[dgZch^X�ZmXVkVi^dc#�>c�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�
h^ijVi^dch!�XdciZmi�d[iZc�n^ZaYh�i]Z�\gZViZhi�Vbdjci�d[�WZ]Vk^dgVa�^c[dgbVi^dc#�
:mXVkVi^dc�d[�V�h^iZ�YZhigdnh�^i!�VcY�XdciZmijVa�YViV�aZ[i�jcgZXdgYZY�VgZ�adhi�[dgZkZg#
&IGURE������8ZgZbdc^Va�WZVg�Wjg^Va#�I]gZZ�aVg\Z�VWVadcZ�h]Zaah�XdkZg�i]Z�h`jaa�d[�i]Z�WZVg#�
7ZXVjhZ�i]Z�WdcZh�d[�aVg\Z�bVbbVah�lZgZ�jhjVaan�Zmead^iZY�[dg�i]Z^g�cjig^i^kZ�kVajZ!�aVg\Z�
bVbbVa�WdcZh�[gdb�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�gZ[jhZ�YZedh^ih�VgZ�jhjVaan�kZgn�[gV\bZciVgn0�i]^h�XVhZ�^h�Vc�
dWk^djh�ZmXZei^dc#�EgZ]^hidg^X!�cdgi]Zgc�8Va^[dgc^V#
&,'#(����:mXVkVi^dc�VcY�GZig^ZkVa
� ™� HVbeaZh�[dg�W^dX]Zb^XVa�VcVanhZh�VcY�]^hidad\n��hZZ�8]VeiZg�&-��h]djaY�WZ�iV`Zc�
Vi�i]Z�ZVga^Zhi�i^bZ!�l^i]�XaZVc�iddah�VcY�\adkZh!�^c�hiZg^aZ�XdciV^cZgh!�id�Vkd^Y�
XdciVb^cVi^dc#�HZZ�C^ZahZc"BVgh]�Zi�Va#��'%%%��[dg�V�gZk^Zl�d[�]dl�WdcZ�YZ\gVYZh�
X]Zb^XVaan#
I]Z�VXijVa�gZbdkVa�d[�i]Z�WdcZh�i]ZbhZakZh�^h�dcZ�d[�i]Z�aVhi�hiZeh�d[�gZXdkZgn!�V[iZg�
ZmedhjgZ!�e]did\gVe]n!�VcY�YgVl^c\#�Id�V^Y�^c�i]Z^g�]VgYZc^c\!�aZi�i]Z�ZmedhZY�WdcZh�
Ygn�XdbeaZiZan�^c�Vc�VgZV�h]VYZY�[gdb�i]Z�hjc#�;gZZ�ZVX]�WdcZ�\Zcian¸Yd�cdi�jhZ�
[dgXZ#�:Vgi]� �bVig^m��bVn�WZ� aZ[i�dc�i]Z�i]^c�eVgih� �hXVejaV!�eZak^h�� id�Vkd^Y�YVbV\Z�
Yjg^c\�igVchedgi#�9d�cdi�ViiZbei�ÄcZ�XaZVc^c\�^c�i]Z�ÄZaY0�i]^h�h]djaY�WZ�eZg[dgbZY�
^c�h^ijVi^dch�l]ZgZ�a^\]i!�iddah!�lViZg!�Xdb[dgi!�VYk^XZ!�XdbeVgVi^kZ�bViZg^Va!�VcY�i^bZ�
VgZ�^c�\gZViZg�hjeean¸^c�di]Zg�ldgYh!�^c�i]Z�aVWdgVidgn#�IV`Z�ZVX]�WdcZ�dji�^cY^k^Yj"
Vaan�VcY�aVWZa�Vh�ndj�\d�Vadc\!�eVgi^XjaVgan�i]Z�g^Wh�VcY�kZgiZWgVZ#�@ZZe�g^\]i�VcY�aZ[i�
]VcYh!�[ZZi!�VcY�g^W�WdcZh�^c�hZeVgViZ�XdciV^cZgh#�@ZZe�jc[jhZY�Ze^e]nhZh�l^i]�i]Z^g�
VhhdX^ViZY�WdcZh#�7Z�dWhZgkVci�Vh�ndj�gZbdkZ�i]Z�ZaZbZcih!�lViX]^c\�[dg�[ZiVa�WdcZh!�
hZhVbd^Yh!�`^YcZn�VcY�\Vaa�WaVYYZg�hidcZh!�VcY�hbVaa�Vgi^[VXih#�HVkZ�ZkZgni]^c\!�ZkZc�^[�
ndj�i]^c`�i]Vi�^i�b^\]i�cdi�WZ�]jbVc#�>i�^h�ZVh^Zg�id�Yd�VXXjgViZ�^YZci^ÄXVi^dc�^c�i]Z�
aVWdgVidgn#�9d�cdi�Y^hgZ\VgY�^bbVijgZ�h`ZaZiVa�eVgih�dg�Y^hijgWZY�Wjg^Vah0�hjX]�Y^hgZ"
\VgY�l^aa�h`Zl�i]Z�XZbZiZgn�gZegZhZciVi^dch�VcY�jai^bViZan�]VkZ�Vc�VYkZghZ�Z[[ZXi�dc�
Vcn�YZbd\gVe]^X�gZXdchigjXi^dc#
6[iZg�gZbdkVa!�^[�i]Z�WdcZ�^h�hi^aa�lZi!�aZi�^i�Ygn�XdbeaZiZan�^c�i]Z�h]VYZ#�CZkZg�b^m�
i]Z�heZX^bZch�Yjg^c\�lVh]^c\�dg�eVX`^c\�Vi�i]Z�h^iZ#�HXgZZc�Vaa�ZVgi]�i]Vi�gZbV^ch�Vi�
i]Z�hedi�d[�i]Z�Wjg^Va!�lViX]^c\�[dg�WZVYh!�iZZi]!�VcY�di]Zg�^iZbh�i]Vi�bVn�]VkZ�WZZc�
b^hhZY�Vh�i]Z�aVg\Zg�WdcZh�lZgZ�gZbdkZY#
9ZX^h^dch�VWdji�lVh]^c\�d[�bViZg^Va�Vi�i]Z�gZXdkZgn�h^iZ�VgZ�WZhi�aZ[i�id�i]Z�_jY\Z"
&IGURE�����AND������6c�ZmiZcYZY�Wjg^Va�[gdb�i]Z�
egZ]^hidg^X�A^WWZc�h^iZ�^c�D]^d#�I]Z�ZmXVkVidg�
�aZ[i�!�]Vk^c\�XaZVgZY�i]Z�XZcigVa�eVgi�d[�i]^h�Wjg^Va!�
XVgZ[jaan�ZmedhZh�i]Z�]VcY�e]VaVc\Zh�l^i]�V�YZciVa�
egdWZ#�6[iZg�[jaa�gZXdgY^c\!�i]Z�VgX]Zdad\^hi��VWdkZ��
XVgZ[jaan�gZbdkZh�i]Z�jacV�VcY�]jbZgjh#�I]Z�g^Wh�
]VkZ�WZZc�ZmedhZY�[dg�e]did\gVe]^X�gZXdgY^c\�VcY�
YgVl^c\!�Wji�i]Zn�lZgZ�cdi�ZcYVc\ZgZY�Wn�jcYZgXji"
i^c\�Yjg^c\�ZmXVkVi^dc#
�� 8]VeiZg�'����;^ZaY�EgdXZYjgZh
bZci�d[�i]Z�^ckZhi^\Vidg#�6h�7gdi]lZaa��&.-&��cdiZh!�i]ZgZ�^h�\ZcZgVaan�cd�egdWaZb�^c�
YZX^Y^c\�VWdji�WdcZ�higZc\i]0�WdcZh�VgZ�cdi�\ZcZgVaan�YZXZei^kZ� ^c�i]^h�gZ\VgY#�>i� ^h�
jhjVaan�Zk^YZci�Yjg^c\�gZXdkZgn�l]Zi]Zg�i]Zn�VgZ�a^`Zan�id�Y^h^ciZ\gViZ�l]Zc�]VcYaZY#�
>[�lViZg�^h�VkV^aVWaZ�VcY�i]Z�WdcZ�^h�lZaa�egZhZgkZY!�^i�bVn�WZ�XdckZc^Zci�id�lVh]�eVgih�
d[�ZVX]�h`ZaZidc�^c�i]Z�ÄZaY�XVbe#�>i�^h�d[iZc�WZhi�id�gZbdkZ�i]Z�ZVgi]�[gdb�i]Z�XgVc^Va�
XVk^in�VcY�dgW^ih�l]^aZ�i]Z�hd^a�^h�hi^aa�YVbe#�9d�cdi�ign�id�gZXdchigjXi�WdcZh�^c�i]Z�
ÄZaY¸_jhi�`ZZe�i]Zb�id\Zi]Zg#
9ZX^h^dch�VWdji�i]Z�Veea^XVi^dc�d[�egZhZgkVi^kZh��HZXi^dc�&-#'��bjhi�WZ�bVYZ�Yjg"
^c\�ZmedhjgZ!�VcY�i]^h�Veea^XVi^dc�l^aa�d[iZc�WZ�cZXZhhVgn�WZ[dgZ�gZbdkVa�^h�edhh^WaZ#
6ajb^cjb�[d^a�^h�Vc�^cZmeZch^kZ�Wji�kZgn�Z[[ZXi^kZ�bViZg^Va�i]Vi�XVc�WZ�jhZY�id�
hiVW^a^oZ!�egdiZXi!�VcY�`ZZe�WdcZh�VcY�i]Z^g�eVgih�^c�eaVXZ�Yjg^c\�a^[i^c\�VcY�igVchedgi#�
EgZhh�i]Z�[d^a�Ägban�VgdjcY�Vaa�i]Z�WdcZ�VcY�bVig^m�^ggZ\jaVg^i^Zh#
HdbZ�^ckZhi^\Vidgh�jhZ�Wjg^Va�gZXdgY^c\�[dgbh#�I]ZhZ�XVc�WZ�jhZ[ja!�egdk^YZY�i]Vi�
XVji^dc� ^h�jhZY� ^c�YZiZgb^c^c\� hZm!� V\Z!� VcY�di]Zg� [ZVijgZh�d[iZc�egdbeiZY�Wn� hjX]�
[dgbh#�7Z�hjgZ�id�bVg`�i]ZhZ�YZiZgb^cVi^dch�d[�^YZci^in�Vh�egZa^b^cVgn�l]Zc�i]Zn�VgZ�
bVYZ�jcYZg�ÄZaY�XdcY^i^dch#
&IGURE������BVhh�\gVkZ�Vi�i]Z�egZ]^hidg^X�A^WWZc�h^iZ�XdciV^c^c\�i]Z�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch�d[�[djg�
X]^aYgZc�VcY�Vc�VYjai#�I]Z�aZ\h�VcY�[ZZi�d[�V�aViZg�ZmiZcYZY�VYjai�Wjg^Va�egdigjYZ�^cid�i]Z�
ZmXVkVi^dc�[gdb�i]Z�Wdiidb�d[�i]Z�e]did\gVe]#�HjX]�hjeZg^bedh^i^dc�d[�Y^[[ZgZci�Wjg^Va�ZkZcih�
^h�Xdbbdcan�ZcXdjciZgZY�^c�VWdg^\^cVa�XZbZiZg^Zh!�jhjVaan�WZXVjhZ�\gVkZh�lZgZ�cdi�bVg`ZY�
l^i]�eZgbVcZci�hjg[VXZ�bdcjbZcih#
&.
&IGURE�������:miZcYZY�Wjg^Va�d[�Vc�^bbVijgZ�^cY^k^YjVa�[gdb�i]Z�egZ]^hidg^X�A^WWZc�h^iZ#�
<gZVi�XVgZ�bjhi�WZ�iV`Zc�l^i]�hjX]�ndjc\�^cY^k^YjVah�id�gZXdkZg�i]Z�bVcn�jc[jhZY�WdcZh#
&IGURE�������7dcZh�d[�V�[Zijh�lZgZ�[djcY�l^i]^c�i]Z�eZak^X�XVk^in�d[�i]^h�[ZbVaZ�h`ZaZidc�[gdb�
i]Z�egZ]^hidg^X�A^WWZc�h^iZ#�I]Z�]jbZgjh!�g^Wh!�VcY�hXVejaV�d[�i]Z�[Zijh�VgZ�_jhi�VciZg^dg�id�i]Z�
hVXgd^a^VX�Vgi^XjaVi^dc#
'#(����:mXVkVi^dc�VcY�GZig^ZkVa
�� 8]VeiZg�'����;^ZaY�EgdXZYjgZh
�����4RANSPORT
L]Zc�ZmedhjgZ!�e]did\gVe]n!�VcY�YgVl^c\�VgZ�XdbeaZiZ!�i]Z�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch�XVc�WZ�gZbdkZY�[gdb�i]Z�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�XdciZmi#�>c�i]Z�[dgZch^X�XdciZmi�i]Z�YZX^h^dc�id�gZbdkZ�
^h�bVYZ�Wn�i]Z�X]^Z[�d[�i]Z�Xg^bZ�hXZcZ#�I]^h�WZ\^ch�V�¹X]V^c�d[�XjhidYnº�^c�l]^X]�i]Z�
dhiZdad\^hi�bjhi�eVgi^X^eViZ�VcY�YdXjbZci�^c�lg^i^c\��BZaWnZ�VcY�?^bZcZo!�&..,�#�>[�
i]Z�WdcZ�^h�lZaa"egZhZgkZY!�i]Z�ZaZbZcih�XVc�WZ�a^[iZY�^cY^k^YjVaan#�DcXZ�WdcZh�]VkZ�
WZZc�ZmigVXiZY�VcY�ÄZaY"XaZVcZY!�i]Zn�VgZ�gZVYn�[dg�eVX`^c\�VcY�igVchedgi�id�i]Z�aVWd"
gVidgn#�6kV^aVWaZ�kZ]^XaZh�VcY�eVX`^c\�bViZg^Vah�[dg�igVchedgi�kVgn�\gZVian#�IgVchedgi�
i]jh�YZeZcYh�dc�l]Vi� ^h�VkV^aVWaZ#�=dlZkZg!�jcYZg�Vaa�XdcY^i^dch!�dcZ�eg^bVgn�gjaZ�
h]djaY�ValVnh�WZ�dWhZgkZY/�9d�cdi�aZi�Vcn�bdgZ�YVbV\Z!�XdciVb^cVi^dc!�dg�b^m^c\�dXXjg#
DXXVh^dcVaan�^i�^h�cZXZhhVgn�id�gZbdkZ�i]Z�Wjg^Va�dg�^ih�eVgih�Vh�V�jc^i!�^c�V�hjeedgi"
^c\�WadX`�d[�bVig^m!�[dg�hijYn�dg�Y^heaVn#�Id�gZbdkZ�Vc�Zci^gZ�Wjg^Va!�Zbeadn�i]Z�eVaZ"
dcidad\^XVa�iZX]c^fjZ�d[�_VX`Zi^c\#�Id�Yd�i]^h!�Äghi�^hdaViZ�i]Z�heZX^bZc�dc�V�eZYZhiVa�d[�
ZVgi]#�8dkZg�^i�l^i]�hZkZgVa�aVnZgh�d[�lZi�i^hhjZ�eVeZg�l]ZgZ�i]Z�WdcZ�^h�ZmedhZY#�CZmi!�
jhZ�WjgaVe�WVcYV\Zh�hdV`ZY�^c�eaVhiZg�id�[dgb�V�XVhi�dg� _VX`Zi�VgdjcY�i]Z�heZX^bZc#�
GZ^c[dgXZ� i]^h� _VX`Zi� Vh� cZXZhhVgn�l^i]� higZc\i]Zc^c\� gdYh� d[�bZiVa� dg�lddY#�6[iZg�
i]Z�eaVhiZg�]Vh�]VgYZcZY!�jcYZgXji�i]Z�heZX^bZc�VcY�a^[i�^i�dji#�I]^h�^h�Vc�ZmeZch^kZ�
deZgVi^dc�^c�iZgbh�d[�bViZg^Va!�i^bZ!�VcY�eZghdccZa#�>i�gZfj^gZh�ZmeZg^ZcXZ�VcY�h]djaY�
WZ�jhZY�dcan�l]Zc�cZXZhhVgn#
DcXZ� i]Z�Wjg^Va�]Vh�WZZc� gZbdkZY!�lVh]ZY!� VcY�Yg^ZY!� i]Z�]VcYh!� [ZZi!� VcY� g^Wh�
h]djaY�WZ�WV\\ZY�Wn�h^YZ�VcY�i]Z�kZgiZWgVZ�Wn�ineZ#�AVWZa^c\� i]ZhZ�ZaZbZcih�Vi� i]Z�
i^bZ�d[�gZbdkVa�\gZVian� [VX^a^iViZh� aViZg� hdgi^c\� ^c� i]Z� aVWdgVidgn#�;^cZ�XaZVc^c\�VcY�
\aj^c\�h]djaY�WZ�aZ[i�[dg�i]Z�aVWdgVidgn#�AVWZa�Vaa�WV\h�VcY�WdmZh�jhZY�[dg�XdaaZXi^dc�
l^i]�lViZgegdd[�^c`#�EVeZg�WV\h�VgZ�egdcZ�id�YZiZg^dgVi^dc�^[�jhZY�[dg�adc\"iZgb�hidg"
V\Z!�Wji�i]Zn�WgZVi]Z�bd^hijgZ�VcY�VgZ�i]ZgZ[dgZ�WZiiZg�i]Vc�eaVhi^X�WV\h�[dg�edhi"Zm"
XVkVi^dc� hdgi^c\� VcY� igVchedgi�d[� h`ZaZiVa�bViZg^Va� i]Vi� gZiV^c� gZh^YjVa�bd^hijgZ#� >c�
igVchedgi!�`ZZe�i]Z�WdcZh�VlVn�[gdb�lViZg#�>i�^h�kZgn�^bedgiVci�id�XVgZ[jaan�aVWZa�VcY�
bV^ciV^c�dg\Vc^oVi^dc�l]Zc�i]Z�WdcZh�VgZ�ZmigVXiZY�[gdb�i]Z^g�XdciZmi�VcY�bdkZY�id�
i]Z�aVWdgVidgn#
L]Zc�eVX`^c\�WdcZh!�eVX`�i^\]ian�l^i]� adih�d[�eVYY^c\� �eaVhi^X�WV\h�dg�cZlheV"
eZg��id�Vkd^Y�bdkZbZci�^c�i]Z�XdciV^cZg#�EVX`�]ZVk^Zg!�YZchZg�WdcZh�Vi�i]Z�Wdiidb�d[�
XdciV^cZgh�VcY�i]Z�bdgZ�[gV\^aZ�WdcZh�hjX]�Vh�hXVejaV!�eZak^h!�VcY�XgVc^V�Vi�i]Z�ide#�7Z�
hjgZ�i]Vi�Vaa�WdcZh�hiVn�^c�i]Z^g�Vhh^\cZY�XdciV^cZgh�Yjg^c\�i]Z�_dhia^c\�i]Vi�^cZk^iVWan�
VXXdbeVc^Zh�igVchedgi#�7Z�eVgi^XjaVgan�XVgZ[ja�l^i]�i]Z�XgVc^jb!�l]dhZ�[VXZ�^h�[gV\^aZ#�
I]Z�XgVc^jb�VcY�bVcY^WaZ�h]djaY�ZVX]�WZ�eVX`ZY�hZeVgViZan!�VcY�XVgZ�h]djaY�WZ�iV`Zc�
id�ZchjgZ�i]Vi�iZZi]�Yd�cdi�Y^hadY\Z�[gdb�i]Z^g�hdX`Zih�Yjg^c\�igVchedgi#
&IGURE�������I]^h�[ZiVa�h`ZaZiVa�bViZg^Va�[gdb�
i]Z�egZ]^hidg^X�A^WWZc�h^iZ�gZegZhZcih�dcZ�
d[�i]Z�hbVaaZhi�Wjg^Vah�ZkZg�gZXdkZgZY#�<ddY�
egZhZgkVi^dc�XdbW^cZY�l^i]�\gZVi�XdcXZgc�
[dg�YZiV^a�Yjg^c\�ZmXVkVi^dc�bVYZ�i]Z�h`ZaZiVa�
XdaaZXi^dc�[gdb�i]^h�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�h^iZ�dcZ�d[�
i]Z�WZhi�VkV^aVWaZ�[dg�i]Z�hijYn�d[�egZ]^hidg^X�
YZbd\gVe]n��hZZ�8]VeiZg�&.�#�CVijgVa�h^oZ#
'&
#HAPTER��
:i]^Xh�^c�DhiZdad\n
:i]^Xh� ^h� i]Z� hijYn�d[� hiVcYVgYh�d[� XdcYjXi�VcY�bdgVa� _jY\bZci#�:i]^Xh� XVc�WZ�hZZc�Vh�V�hnhiZb�d[�kVajZh�i]Vi�heZX^[n�V�XdYZ�d[�XdcYjXi#�I]ZgZ�VgZ�bjai^eaZ�kVajZ�
hnhiZbh!�ZVX]�l^i]�YZÄc^i^dch�d[�l]Vi�^h�Xdch^YZgZY�g^\]i�VcY�lgdc\#�I]ZhZ�YZÄc^i^dch�
VgZ�XjaijgVa!�hd�l]Vi�b^\]i�WZ�Zi]^XVa�[dg�dcZ�hX^Zci^hi!�[dg�ZmVbeaZ!�b^\]i�WZ�jcZi]^XVa�
[dg�V�gZa^\^djh�aZVYZg#�9^[[ZgZci�Zi]^XVa�hnhiZbh�Xdaa^YZ�VXgdhh�i]Z�heZXigjb�d[�dhiZdad\^"
XVa�ZcYZVkdgh¸[gdb�i]Z�[dgZch^X!�id�i]Z�VgX]Zdad\^XVa!�id�i]Z�eVaZdcidad\^XVa#�:mXZa"
aZci�]^hidg^XVa�eZgheZXi^kZh�dc�i]Z�hjW_ZXi�d[�Zi]^Xh�^c�]jbVc�dhiZdad\n�VgZ�egdk^YZY�
Wn�LVa`Zg��'%%%��VcY�JWZaV`Zg��'%%%�#
Egd[Zhh^dcVah�l]d�hijYn�]jbVc�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch�VgZ�[gZfjZcian�XVaaZY�dc�id�bV`Z�
Zi]^XVa�_jY\ZbZcih#�I]^h�X]VeiZg�ZmVb^cZh�hdbZ�d[�i]Z�Zi]^XVa�hiVcYVgYh�eZXja^Vg�id�
dhiZdad\n�VcY�jc^kZghVaan�egVXi^XZY�Wn�dhiZdad\^hih#�;dg�hdbZ�dhiZdad\^XVa�^hhjZh�i]ZgZ�
VgZ�cd�ZVhn�VchlZgh�VcY�cd�egZhXg^WZY�XdYZh�d[�XdcYjXi�id�\j^YZ�i]Z�egVXi^i^dcZg��;^\"
jgZ�(#&�#
=jbVc�dhiZdad\^hih�VgZ�gdji^cZan�XVaaZY�dc�id�egVXi^XZ�^c�i]Z�\aVgZ�d[�i]Z�bZY^V�
hedia^\]i�VcY�l^i]^c�aZ\Va!�eda^i^XVa!�hdX^Va!�VcY�ZXdcdb^X�VgZcVh�l]ZgZ�hX^ZcXZ�bVn�
WZ�b^hXdchigjZY� VcY�b^hgZegZhZciZY#�L]Zi]Zg� i]Z� ^hhjZ� ^h� i]Z�cjbWZg� d[� eZg^h]ZY�
^cY^k^YjVah�^c�i]Z�7gVcX]�9Vk^Y^Vc�XdbedjcY�Vi�LVXd��DlhaZn�Zi�Va#!�&..*�!�i]Z�cV"
ijgZ�d[�igVjbV�id�i]Z�hdaY^Zgh�l]d�Y^ZY�l^i]�8jhiZg�Vi�i]Z�A^iiaZ�7^\�=dgc��HXdii�Zi�Va#!�
'%%'�!�dg�i]Z�V[Äc^i^Zh�d[�Vc�^cY^k^YjVa�l]d�Y^ZY�i]djhVcYh�d[�nZVgh�V\d�Vi�@ZccZl^X`�
�BdgZaa!�&..-�!�i]Z�]jbVc�dhiZdad\^hi�^h�dWa^\ZY�id�WZ�\j^YZY�Wn�[VXih�VcY�i]Z�hX^Zci^ÄX�
VeegdVX]�gVi]Zg�i]Vc�Wn�heZXjaVi^dc!�hjeZghi^i^dc!�ZXdcdb^Xh!�egZXdcXZei^dc!�dg�eda^i^"
XVa�ZmeZY^ZcXn#
�����%THICS�IN�&ORENSIC�/STEOLOGY
=jbVc�h`ZaZiVa� gZbV^ch�d[iZc�Ä\jgZ�egdb^cZcian� ^c� aZ\Va�bViiZgh#�DhiZdad\^hih� VgZ�
gdji^cZan�Vh`ZY�id�^YZci^[n�h`ZaZiVa�gZbV^ch¸id�YZiZgb^cZ�l]Zi]Zg�i]Zn�VgZ�]jbVc�
VcY!�^[�i]Zn�VgZ!�id�YZiZgb^cZ�i]Z�V\Z!�hZm!�^YZci^in!�VcY�Vci^fj^in�d[�i]Z�gZbV^ch#�>c[dg"
bVi^dc�^h�egdk^YZY�dc�]dl�i]ZhZ�YZiZgb^cVi^dch�bVn�WZ�bVYZ�[dg�Wdcn�gZbV^ch�^c�
8]VeiZg�&.#�HdbZi^bZh�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�^h�Vh`ZY�Wn�aVl"Zc[dgXZbZci�gZegZhZciVi^kZh�id�
bV`Z�^YZci^ÄXVi^dch!�V�gZedgi�^h�ÄaZY��hZZ�8]VeiZg�&-�!�VcY�i]Z�bViiZg�ZcYh�i]ZgZ#�Dc�
dXXVh^dc!�]dlZkZg!�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�WZXdbZh�bdgZ�YZZean�ZcbZh]ZY�^c�i]Z�aZ\Va�hnhiZb#
>c�bVcn�Xdjcig^Zh!�aVl�^h�egVXi^XZY�^c�Vc�VYkZghVg^Va�hnhiZb�^c�l]^X]�egdhZXji^c\�
VcY�YZ[ZchZ�ViidgcZnh�VcY�i]Z^g�iZVbh�hfjVgZ�d[[�^c�Xdjgih�d[�aVl#�I]ZgZ�VgZ�d[iZc�hZg^"
�� 8]VeiZg�(����:i]^Xh
djh�fjZhi^dch�d[�Xg^b^cVa^in�dg� ^c]Zg^iVcXZ�^ckdak^c\�^YZci^ÄXVi^dc�d[�i]Z�YZXZVhZY#�
I]Z�hiV`Zh�bVn�WZ�]^\]#�>c�hjX]�aZ\Va�V[[V^gh!�dhiZdad\^hih�bVn�WZ�gZiV^cZY�[dg�i]Z^g�Zm"
eZgi^hZ�VcY�iZhi^bdcn�Wn�Z^i]Zg�h^YZ#�;dg�i]ZhZ�VcY�di]Zg�gZVhdch!�i]Z�6bZg^XVc�6XVY"
Zbn�d[�;dgZch^X�HX^ZcXZh�]Vh�[dgbVaan�^cXdgedgViZY�e]nh^XVa�Vci]gdedad\n�Vh�dcZ�d[�
^ih�Y^hX^ea^cZh#
�������"OUNDARIES�OF�%VIDENCE
>c�Vaa�dhiZdad\^XVa�ldg`!�Wji�eVgi^XjaVgan�^c�[dgZch^X�dhiZdad\n!�^i�^h�^bedgiVci�[dg�i]Z�
VcVanhi�id�`ZZe�ild�i]^c\h�XaZVgan�^c�b^cY�Vi�Vaa�i^bZh#�;^ghi!�Vcn�XdcXajh^dc�YgVlc�^c�
Vc�dhiZdad\^XVa�gZedgi�bjhi�WZ�YZ[Zch^WaZ#�>c�di]Zg�ldgYh!�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�bjhi�egZeVgZ�
[dg�V�X]VaaZc\Z�Wn�Zbeadn^c\�i]Z�bdhi�hdjcY�VcY�je"id"YViZ�VcVani^XVa�bZi]dYh�VkV^a"
VWaZ#�HZXdcY!�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�h]djaY�ValVnh�Vkd^Y�hiZee^c\�WZndcY�i]Z�WdjcYVg^Zh�hZi�
Wn�i]Z�dhiZdad\^XVa�Zk^YZcXZ�^ihZa[#�>c�di]Zg�ldgYh!�]Z�dg�h]Z�^h�Vc�ZmeZgi�^c�dhiZdad\n�
VcY�cdi�cZXZhhVg^an�Vc�ZmeZgi�^c�Xg^b^cVa^hi^Xh!�eVi]dad\n!�idm^Xdad\n!�Zc\^cZZg^c\!�dg�
YZiZXi^kZ�ldg`#
I]Z�[dgZch^X�dhiZdad\^hi�bjhi�ValVnh�gZedgi�VcY�iZhi^[n�l^i]^c�i]Z�WdjcYh�d[�i]Z�
Wdcn�Zk^YZcXZ�VcY�VXXdgY^c\�id�i]Z�eg^cX^eaZh�d[� i]Z�hX^Zci^ÄX�Y^hX^ea^cZ�i]Vi�]Z�dg�
h]Z�gZegZhZcih#�I]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�h]djaY�Zmea^X^ian�YgVl�i]Z�ViiZci^dc�d[�Vaa�XdcXZgcZY�
eVgi^Zh� id� a^b^iVi^dch�d[� i]Z�Zk^YZcXZ� ^ihZa[� VcY� id�jcXZgiV^ci^Zh�VhhdX^ViZY�l^i]� i]Z�
^YZci^ÄXVi^dch�i]Vi�]VkZ�WZZc�eZg[dgbZY#
DcZ�ZmVbeaZ�hj[ÄXZh�id�h]dl�i]Z�igV\^X�idaa�i]Vi�XVc�WZ�iV`Zc�Wn�V�[V^ajgZ�id�dW"
hZgkZ�i]ZhZ�WVh^X�gjaZh#�I]Z�K^ZicVb�LVg�VcY�VhhdX^ViZY�XdcÅ^Xi�^c�Hdji]ZVhi�6h^V�gZ"
hjaiZY�^c�i]Z�YZVi]h�d[�]jcYgZYh�d[�i]djhVcYh�d[�eZdeaZ!�Vbdc\�l]db�lZgZ�6bZg^XVc�
&IGURE������1�Xe]Q^�VUdQ\�
c[e\\��>h�^i�g^\]i�dg�lgdc\�
[dg�i]^h�jcWdgc�^cY^k^YjVa¼h�
gZbV^ch�id�WZ�XjgViZY�^c�V�
bjhZjb4�9^[[ZgZci�eZdeaZ�
\^kZ�Y^[[ZgZci�VchlZgh�id�i]^h�
fjZhi^dc�YZeZcY^c\�dc�l]Vi�
Zi]^XVa�eZgheZXi^kZ�i]Zn�Wg^c\�
id�i]Z�^hhjZ#
'((#&����:i]^Xh�^c�;dgZch^X��DhiZdad\n
b^a^iVgn�eZghdccZa#�I]Z�6bZg^XVch�l]d�cZkZg�gZijgcZY!�VcY�l]dhZ�WdY^Zh�lZgZ�cdi�VX"
XdjciZY�[dg!�lZgZ�a^hiZY�Vh�B>6��b^hh^c\�^c�VXi^dc�#�I]^giZZc�bZc�VWdVgY�Vc�6bZg^XVc�68"&(%�\jch]^e�h]di�Ydlc�dkZg�AVdh�^c�&.,'�lZgZ�XdjciZY�Vbdc\�i]Z�B>6h#�DkZg�
iZc�nZVgh�aViZg�Vc�ZmXVkVi^dc�Vi�i]Z�XgVh]�h^iZ�gZXdkZgZY�*%!%%%�e^ZXZh�d[�WdcZ0�i]Z�aVg\"
Zhi�WdcZ�lVh�&(�Xb�adc\!�VcY�bdhi�[gV\bZcih�]VY�V�bVm^bjb�Y^bZch^dc�d[�VgdjcY�
&�Xb#�6[iZg�VcVanh^h�Wn�i]Z�J#H#�6gbn!�^i�lVh�VccdjcXZY�i]Vi�edh^i^kZ�^YZci^ÄXVi^dch�
]VY�WZZc�bVYZ�dc�VcVidbn�VadcZ!�VcY�i]Vi�Vaa�i]^giZZc�bZc�]VY�WZZc�VXXdjciZY�[dg�
Wn� i]ZhZ�WdcZ� [gV\bZcih#�I]Z� h`ZaZiVa� gZbV^ch�lZgZ� i]Zc� [dglVgYZY� id� i]Z� [Vb^a^Zh�
[dg�Wjg^Va#�GZaVi^kZh�d[�i]Z�XgZl�bZbWZgh�egZhhZY�i]Z�^hhjZ�d[� ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc!�VcY�Vc�
^cYZeZcYZci�^ckZhi^\Vi^dc�d[�i]ZhZ�WdcZh�lVh�bVYZ#�>i�WZXVbZ�XaZVg�i]Vi�i]Z�VcVanh^h!�
Vai]dj\]�YdcZ�Wn�egd[Zhh^dcVa�dhiZdad\^hih!�]VY�bVYZ�XdcXajh^dch�VWdji�V\Z!�hZm!�gVXZ!�
VcY�^cY^k^YjVi^dc�i]Vi�lZci�[Vg�WZndcY�i]Z�Zk^YZcXZ��<Zia^c!�&.-+�#
HX^ZcXZ!� [dgijcViZan!� ^h� hZa["XdggZXi^c\#� >c�XVhZh� a^`Z� i]^h�dcZ� i]Z� Zk^YZcXZ�XVc�WZ�
ZmVb^cZY�Wn�hZkZgVa�^ckZhi^\Vidgh�VcY�[Vjain�VcVanh^h�^h�i]ZgZWn�ZmedhZY#�>c�i]Z�bZVc"
i^bZ!�]dlZkZg!�i]Z�a^kZh�d[�bVcn�eZdeaZ�XVc�WZ�YZZean�V[[ZXiZY�Wn�i]Z�XdcXajh^dch�d[�i]Z�
dhiZdad\^hi!�l]d�XaZVgan�]Vh�V�gZhedch^W^a^in�id�gZheZXi�i]Z�a^b^ih�d[�i]Z�]VgY�Zk^YZcXZ#
�������4HE�%XPERT�7ITNESS
L^icZhhZh�^c�Xdjgi�egdXZZY^c\h�VgZ�hldgc�id�iZaa�i]Z�igji]!�i]Z�l]daZ�igji]!�VcY�cdi]"
^c\�Wji�i]Z�igji]#�I]Z�ZmeZgi�l^icZhh�^c�[dgZch^X�dhiZdad\n�bjhi�Vahd!�d[�XdjghZ!�VY]ZgZ�
id� i]ZhZ�gjaZh#�HZZ�@d\Vc� �&.,-�!�HiZlVgi� �&.,.�!�;ZYZg� �&..&�!�VcY�HiZVYbVc� �'%%(0�
HZXi^dc� >!� EZghdcVa� >YZci^ÄXVi^dc� VcY�AZ\Va�8dch^YZgVi^dch� d[� ;dgZch^X�6ci]gdeda"
d\n�8VhZldg`�^c�i]Z�Jc^iZY�HiViZh��[dg�[jgi]Zg�YZiV^ah�dc�ZmeZgi�iZhi^bdcn!�VcY�=VVX`�
�'%%(��[dg�Vc�dkZgk^Zl�d[�hX^ZcXZ�^c�i]Z�Xdjgih#�IZhi^bdcn�Wn�ZmeZgi�l^icZhh�hX^Zci^hih�
^h�dc�i]Z�^cXgZVhZ�^c�Xdjgih�d[�aVl�i]gdj\]dji�i]Z�ldgaY!�Vai]dj\]�Y^[[ZgZci�_jY^X^Va�
hnhiZbh�]VcYaZ� ZmeZgih� ^c�Y^[[ZgZci�lVnh#�;dg� ZmVbeaZ!� ^c�<ZgbVcn� i]Z� ZmeZgi�l^i"
cZhh�^h�XVaaZY�Wn�i]Z�Xdjgi!�l]ZgZVh�^c�i]Z�Jc^iZY�HiViZh�ZmeZgih�VgZ�d[iZc�gZiV^cZY�Wn�
aVlnZgh�dc�Z^i]Zg� h^YZ�d[� V� XVhZ#�IZhi^bdcn�Wn� hX^Zci^hih�bVn�]VkZ�YgVbVi^X� ^beVXi�
dc�i]Z�djiXdbZ�d[�V� _jY^X^Va�egdXZZY^c\!�eVgi^XjaVgan�l]Zc�i]Z�iZhi^bdcn�^h� hZZc�Vh�
Zi]^XVa�VcY�Vgi^XjaViZ�VcY�XdbZh�[gdb�V�eZghdc�ZmeZgi�^c�]^h�dg�]Zg�Y^hX^ea^cZ#�=daa^Zc�
�&..%��dWhZgkZh�i]Vi�hZkZgVa�bV_dg�egdWaZbh�hjggdjcY�hX^Zci^hih�hZgk^c\�Vh�ZmeZgi�l^i"
cZhhZh#�6bdc\�i]Z�bdhi�^bedgiVci�VgZ�i]Z�aVX`�d[�igV^c^c\�d[�bdhi�hX^Zci^hih�[dg�i]Z�
Xdjgigddb�hZii^c\!�i]Z�\gZVi�kVg^VcXZ�^c�i]Z�fjVa^ÄXVi^dch�d[�¹ZmeZgihº�VYb^iiZY�^cid�
i]Z�Xdjgigddb!�VcY�i]Z�egZhhjgZh�jedc�i]Z�hX^Zci^hi!�Wdi]�dkZgi�VcY�hjWiaZ!�id�VYdei�Vc�
VYkdXVXn�edh^i^dc�[dg�i]Z�h^YZ�eVn^c\�i]Z�W^aah#
;dg� ^cY^k^YjVa� dhiZdad\^XVa� ZmeZgi� l^icZhhZh� l]d� VgZ� Zi]^XVa!� lZaa"igV^cZY!� ZmeZ"
g^ZcXZY!�VcY�l]d�hiVn�l^i]^c�i]Z�WdjcYVg^Zh� ^bedhZY�Wn�i]Z�Zk^YZcXZ!�Vcn�d[� i]ZhZ�
egdWaZbh�VgZ�^ch^\c^ÄXVci#�Jc[dgijcViZan!�]^hidgn�]Vh�h]dlc�i]Vi�cdi�Vaa�ZmeZgih�]VkZ�
YZbdchigViZY�i]ZhZ�Viig^WjiZh#�8djgih�]VkZ�Y^[[ZgZci�hiVcYVgYh�[dg�VYb^ii^c\�hX^Zci^ÄX�
Zk^YZcXZ#�HiViZ�VcY�J#H#�Xdjgih� igVY^i^dcVaan� [daadlZY�i]Z�¹;gnZ�gjaZ!º�cVbZY�V[iZg�V�
aVcYbVg`�&.'(�YZX^h^dc#�I]^h�]ZaY�i]Vi�ZmeZgi�iZhi^bdcn�bjhi�WZ�WVhZY�dc�V�lZaa"gZX"
d\c^oZY�hX^Zci^ÄX�eg^cX^eaZ�dg�Y^hXdkZgn�i]Vi�^h�¹hj[ÄX^Zcian�ZhiVWa^h]ZY�id�]VkZ�\V^cZY�
\ZcZgVa�VXXZeiVcXZ�^c�i]Z�eVgi^XjaVg�ÄZaY�^c�l]^X]�^i�WZadc\h#º�I]Z�\ZcZgVa�VXXZeiVcXZ�
iZhi�^h�dcan�dcZ�d[�hZkZgVa�fjZhi^dch�i]Vi�XVc�]Zae�i]Z�Xdjgi�^c�ZkVajVi^c\�ZmeZgi�iZhi^"
bdcn#�I]Z�&..(�9VjWZgi�J#H#�HjegZbZ�8djgi�YZX^h^dc�hj\\Zhih�i]Vi�di]Zg�[VXidgh�id�
�� 8]VeiZg�(����:i]^Xh
Xdch^YZg�VgZ�l]Zi]Zg�V�bZi]dY�dg�iZX]c^fjZ�XVc�WZ��VcY�]Vh�WZZc��iZhiZY!�l]Zi]Zg�^i�
]Vh�WZZc�hjW_ZXiZY�id�eZZg�gZk^Zl�VcY�ejWa^XVi^dc!�VcY�l]Vi�i]Z�Zggdg�gViZh�VgZ#
I]Z�aViZ�6bZg^XVc�e]nh^XVa�Vci]gdedad\^hi�VcY�¹ZmeZgi�l^icZhhº�9g#�Adj^hZ�GdW"
W^ch��=VchZc!�&..(��bVn�hZgkZ�Vh�Vc�ZmVbeaZ#�GdWW^ch�lVh�V�hZa["Veed^ciZY�ZmeZgi�^c�
[ddieg^ci� ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc�l]d� iZhi^ÄZY�Vi�cjbZgdjh� ig^Vah� VWdji�]Zg� VW^a^i^Zh� id� ^cY^"
k^YjViZ�eZdeaZ�WVhZY�dc�^begZhh^dch�aZ[i�Wn�i]Z^g�h]dZh!�hdX`h!�dg�WVgZ�[ZZi#�H]Z�XaV^bZY�
i]Vi�]Zg�iZX]c^fjZh�VaadlZY�]Zg�id�iZaa�l]Zi]Zg�V�eZghdc�bVYZ�V�eVgi^XjaVg�eg^ci�Wn�
ZmVb^c^c\� Vcn� di]Zg� h]dZh� WZadc\^c\� id� i]Vi� ^cY^k^YjVa#� H]Z� hiViZY� i]Vi� [ddieg^cih�
lZgZ�WZiiZg�^cY^XVidgh�[dg�^YZci^[n^c\�eZdeaZ�i]Vc�Äc\Zgeg^cih#�Di]Zg�ZmeZgi�l^icZhhZh�
iZhi^ÄZY�dc�]Zg�WZ]Va[!�VcY�V\V^chi�]Zg!�Yjg^c\�V�[dgZch^X�XVgZZg�i]Vi�heVccZY�V�YZXVYZ�
VcY�hVl�bVcn�Xdck^Xi^dch#�Dcan�nZVgh�aViZg!�V[iZg�]Zg�YZVi]!�lZgZ�]Zg�iZX]c^fjZh�VcY�
XdcXajh^dch�ZmedhZY#�E]nh^XVa�Vci]gdedad\^hi�DlZc�AdkZ_dn�d[�@Zci�HiViZ�Jc^kZgh^in�
cdiZY!�¹H]Z�bVn�lZaa�]VkZ�WZa^ZkZY�l]Vi�h]Z�lVh�hVn^c\!�Wji�i]Z�hX^Zci^ÄX�WVh^h�d[�]Zg�
XdcXajh^dch�lVh�XdbeaZiZan�[gVjYjaZciº��e#�++�^c�=VchZc!�&..(�#
Id�]Zg�dlc�ZnZh!�VcY�id�i]Z�ZnZh�d[� i]Z�ViidgcZnh�l]d�gZiV^cZY�]Zg!�9g#�GdWW^ch�
lVh�VXi^c\�^c�V�egd[Zhh^dcVa�VcY�Zi]^XVa�bVccZg#�>c�i]Z�ZnZh�d[�di]Zg�hX^Zci^hih!�h]Z�lVh�
jcZi]^XVa#�>c�i]Z�ZcY!�]Zg�XdcXajh^dch�lZgZ�h]dlc�id�WZ�jcgZa^VWaZ!�Wji�nZVgh�d[�a^i^\V"
i^dc�lZgZ�^ckdakZY!�VcY�nZVgh�d[�^cXVgXZgVi^dc�gZhjaiZY�[gdb�Xdck^Xi^dch�V^YZY�Wn�]Zg�
^ciZgegZiVi^dch#
;dgZch^X�ZmeZgih�d[iZc�Y^hV\gZZ!�VcY�cdi�ValVnh�WZXVjhZ�dcZ�d[�i]Zb�^h�jcZi]^XVa�
dg�jcigV^cZY#�CdgYWn��&..'!�e#�&&&+��Vh`h!�¹=dl�XVc�lZ�jcYZghiVcY�i]Z�\gdjcYh�[dg�
\Zcj^cZ�Y^hV\gZZbZci�WZilZZc�ild�]dcZhi!�fjVa^ÄZY�[dgZch^X�ZmeZgih4º�=Z�Vg\jZh�i]Vi�
lZ�bjhi�Y^hi^c\j^h]�WZilZZc�hZZ^c\�VcY�dWhZgk^c\#�LZ�Vaa�hZZ!�Wji�lZ�dWhZgkZ�Y^[[ZgZci�
i]^c\h�WVhZY�dc�i]Z�XdciZmih�d[�djg�` cdlaZY\Z!�WZa^Z[h!�kVajZh!�VcY�\dVah#�CdgYWn�Vg\jZh�
Xdck^cX^c\an�i]Vi�^ i�^ h�i]Z�gdaZ�d[�i]Z�ZmeZgi�l^icZhh�id�gZÄcZ�i]Z�XdciZmi�d[�dWhZgkVi^dc�
WVhZY�dc�ZmeZgi�jcYZghiVcY^c\!�ValVnh�ZmVb^c^c\�]^YYZc�dWhZgkVi^dcVa�ZmeZXiVi^dch�
i]Vi�bVn� ^cÅjZcXZ� hjeea^ZY� ^ciZgegZiVi^dch#�I]Z�ZmeZgi�bjhi�ValVnh�WZ� hZa["Xg^i^XVa�
VcY�ValVnh�gZVYn�id�YZ[ZcY�l]Vi�bVn�ijgc�dji�id�WZ�i]Z�dcan�hjeedgiVWaZ�XdcXajh^dc�
¸i]Z�XdcXajh^dc�d[�¹>�Ydc¼i�`cdl#º�I]Z�ZmeZgi�hjeea^Zh�\ddY�gZVhdch�id�hjeedgi�i]Vi�
de^c^dc#�CdgYWn��e#�&&')��XdcXajYZh/�¹7di]�`cdl^c\�VcY�cdi�`cdl^c\�VgZ�^c[dgbZY�
edh^i^dch� gZVX]ZY�Wn�XVgZ[ja�Veea^XVi^dc�d[� hX^Zci^ÄXVaan�YZ[Zch^WaZ�bZi]dYh#�L]Zc�
i]Z�gZhjaih�d[�i]dhZ�bZi]dYh�Yd�cdi�Vaadl�jh�id�gVi^dcVaan�egZ[Zg�dcZ�XdcXajh^dc�dkZg�
Vc�VaiZgcVi^kZ!�lZ�bjhi�hZiiaZ�[dg�`cdl^c\�l]n�lZ�Yd�cdi�`cdl#º
�����%THICS�IN�!RCHEOLOGICAL�/STEOLOGY
I]ZgZ� ^h� V� hiVg`� XdcigVhi�WZilZZc� i]Z�l^YZan� VXXZeiZY�VcY�ZVh^an�YZa^cZViZY� Zi]^XVa�
VcY�aZ\Va�\j^YZa^cZh�[dg�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�ldg`^c\�^c�V�[dgZch^X�hZii^c\�VcY�i]Z�VbW^\j^"
i^Zh�d[�Zi]^Xh�VcY�aVl�i]Vi�]Vjci�i]Z�dhiZdad\^hi�ldg`^c\�^c�Vc�VgX]Zdad\^XVa�hZii^c\#�
:k^YZcXZ!� ad\^X!�gZVhdc!�VcY�i]Z�hX^Zci^ÄX�bZi]dY�VgZ�Vaa�]ZaY�^c�]^\]�ZhiZZb�^c�i]Z�
[dgZch^X�gZVab#�L]Zc�XaV^bh�d[�Zci^iaZbZci�ZciZg�i]Z�aZ\Va�hnhiZb!�[dg�ZmVbeaZ!�i]ZgZ�
^h�gVgZan�Vc�ViiZbei�id�¹WVaVcXZº�hX^Zci^ÄX�VcY�he^g^ijVa�Zk^YZcXZ¸i]Z�[dgbZg�iV`Zh�
egZXZYZcXZ#�I]^h�lVh�igVY^i^dcVaan�i]Z�XVhZ�^c�i]Z�gZVab�d[�hX^Zci^ÄX�VgX]Zdad\n#�Cdl!�
]dlZkZg!� i]Z� h^ijVi^dc� ^ckdak^c\�WdcZh� [gdb�VgX]Zdad\^XVa� XdciZmih� i]gdj\]dji� i]Z�
ldgaY�]Vh�WZXdbZ�XdbeaZm!�Åj^Y!� VbW^\jdjh!�eda^i^X^oZY!� VcY�Xdc[jh^c\�YjZ� id� i]Z�
egdbja\Vi^dc�d[�aVlh�i]Vi�V^b�id�gZYgZhh�l]Vi�VgZ�hZZc�Vh�gZa^\^djh�^ c_jhi^XZh�jcYZgiV`"
'*(#'����:i]^Xh�^c�6gX]Zdad\^XVa�DhiZdad\n
Zc�^c�i]Z�cVbZ�d[�hX^ZcXZ#�>i�^h�cZXZhhVgn�id�ZmVb^cZ�i]Z�XVjhZh�[dg�i]^h�h^ijVi^dc�VcY�id�
Xdch^YZg�hdbZ�d[�^ih�^bea^XVi^dch�[dg�dhiZdad\^XVa�gZhZVgX]�^ckdak^c\�]jbVc�gZbV^ch#
������%THICS�IN�#OLLISION
GZhZVgX]�^c�]jbVc�dhiZdad\n�cZXZhhVg^an�^ckdakZh�i]Z�hijYn�d[�]VgY�i^hhjZh�i]Vi�gZe"
gZhZci�eZdeaZ#�6�kVg^Zin�d[�a^k^c\�eZdeaZ�]VkZ�dW_ZXiZY�id�dhiZdad\^XVa�ZmXVkVi^dc�VcY�
gZhZVgX]#�6cVidb^XVa�hijYn�d[�i]Z�YZXZVhZY�]Vh�WZZc�XdcigdkZgh^Va�[gdb�^ih�kZgn�^cXZe"
i^dc#�:Vgan�VcVidb^hih�lZgZ�[dgXZY�id�gZig^ZkZ�VcY�Y^hhZXi�i]Z^g�XVYVkZgh�^c�hZXgZXn#�Id"
YVn!�Vh�ZkZgn�Äghi"nZVg�bZY^XVa�hijYZci�`cdlh!�gZbV^ch�d[�i]Z�YZVY�VgZ�k^iVa�gZhdjgXZh�

Continue navegando