<div id="pf1" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="1"><div class="pc pc1 w0 h0"><img class="bi x0 y0 w1 h1" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/5a5f0e60-95f7-466b-bd7d-79549058eda4/bg1.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y2 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x3 h3 y3 ff1 fs1 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo 639-STJ (01/02/2019) <span class="ff2 ws0">–</span> Márcio André Lopes Cavalcante | 1 </div><div class="t m0 x4 h4 y4 ff3 fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x5 h5 y5 ff4 fs3 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo comentado: </div><div class="t m0 x6 h5 y6 ff4 fs3 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo <span class="ls0">639</span>-STJ (</div><div class="t m1 x7 h6 y6 ff4 fs4 fc1 sc0 ls1 ws1">RESUMIDO</div><div class="t m0 x8 h5 y6 ff4 fs3 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">) </div><div class="t m0 x9 h2 y7 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Márcio André Lop<span class="blank _0"></span>es Cavalcante </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y8 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y9 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xa ya w3 h7"><div class="t m0 xb h8 yb ff5 fs5 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws5">DIREITO CIVIL </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yc ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 xc h9 yd ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">CONTRATOS </div><div class="t m0 xd h9 ye ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A abusividade de encargos acessórios do contrato não descaracteriza a mora </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yf ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y10 w4 ha"><div class="t m0 xf hb y11 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A abusividade de e<span class="blank _0"></span>ncargos <span class="blank _0"></span>acessórios do<span class="blank _0"></span> contrato não descaracteriza a mo<span class="blank _0"></span>ra. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y12 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">STJ. <span class="blank _1"> </span>2ª <span class="blank _1"> </span>Seçã<span class="blank _0"></span>o. <span class="blank _1"> </span>REsp <span class="blank _1"> </span>1.63<span class="blank _0"></span>9.259-SP, <span class="blank _1"> </span>Rel. <span class="blank _1"> </span>Min. <span class="blank _1"> </span>Pau<span class="blank _0"></span>lo <span class="blank _1"> </span>de <span class="blank _1"> </span>Tarso <span class="blank _2"> </span>Sanseverino, <span class="blank _2"> </span>julgado <span class="blank _2"> </span>em <span class="blank _1"> </span>12/12/2018<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y13 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">(recurso repetit<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo) (Info 639). </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y14 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Obs: <span class="blank _3"> </span>o <span class="blank _3"> </span>reconhecimento da abusividade <span class="blank _3"> </span>dos <span class="blank _3"> </span>encargos essenciais <span class="blank _3"> </span>exigidos no <span class="blank _3"> </span>período da <span class="blank _3"> </span>normalidade </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y15 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">contratual descarateriza a mora (STJ. 2ª Seç<span class="blank _3"> </span>ão. REsp 1061530/RS, Rel. Min. Nancy <span class="blank _3"> </span>Andrighi, julgado </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y16 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">em 22/10/2008).<span class="blank _0"></span> </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y17 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x10 h9 y18 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">SEGURO </div><div class="t m0 x11 h9 y19 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Ainda que contrato preveja a exclusão da cobertura em caso de embriaguez do segurado <span class="blank _3"> </span><span class="ls2">e </span></div><div class="t m0 x12 h9 y1a ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">mesmo que o acidente tenha sido causado por essa em<span class="blank _0"></span>briaguez<span class="blank _3"> </span>, a seguradora será obrigada a </div><div class="t m0 x13 h9 y1b ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">indenizar a vítima, já que essa cláusula é ineficaz perante terceiros </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y1c ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 hb y1d ff8 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Mudança de entendi<span class="blank _0"></span>mento! </div></div><div class="c xe y1e w4 hd"><div class="t m0 xf hb y1f ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">No <span class="blank _0"></span>contrato <span class="blank _0"></span>de <span class="blank _0"></span>seguro <span class="blank _0"></span>de automóvel,<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span>é l<span class="blank _0"></span>ícita a <span class="blank _0"></span>cláusula<span class="blank _0"></span> q<span class="blank _0"></span>ue excl<span class="blank _0"></span>ui a <span class="blank _0"></span>cobertura <span class="blank _0"></span>securitária <span class="blank _0"></span>par<span class="blank _0"></span>a </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y20 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">o caso de o <span class="blank _3"> </span>acidente de trânsito (sinistro) ter sido causado em decorrência da <span class="blank _3"> </span>embriaguez do </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y21 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">segurado. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y22 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">No entanto, esta cl<span class="blank _0"></span>áusula é ineficaz p<span class="blank _0"></span>erante terceiro<span class="blank _0"></span>s (garantia de respo<span class="blank _0"></span>nsabilidade civil).<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y23 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Isso <span class="blank _4"> </span>significa <span class="blank _4"> </span>que, <span class="blank _4"> </span>mesmo <span class="blank _5"> </span>que <span class="blank _4"> </span>contrato <span class="blank _4"> </span>preveja <span class="blank _5"> </span>a <span class="blank _4"> </span>exclusão <span class="blank _4"> </span>da <span class="blank _4"> </span>co<span class="blank _3"> </span>bertura <span class="blank _4"> </span>em <span class="blank _4"> </span>caso <span class="blank _4"> </span>de </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y24 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">embriaguez <span class="blank _6"> </span>do <span class="blank _6"> </span>segurado, <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>seguradora <span class="blank _6"> </span>será <span class="blank _6"> </span>obrigada <span class="blank _2"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>indenizar <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>vítima <span class="blank _6"> </span>(terceiro) <span class="blank _6"> </span>caso <span class="blank _6"> </span>o </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y25 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">acidente tenha sido<span class="blank _0"></span> causado <span class="blank _0"></span>pelo segurado emb<span class="blank _0"></span>riagado. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y26 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls3 ws2">Em<span class="ls1 ws5"> outras palavras<span class="blank _0"></span>, não se pode invoc<span class="blank _0"></span>ar essa cláus<span class="blank _0"></span>ula contra a vítima. </span></div><div class="t m0 xf hb y27 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Depois <span class="blank _2"> </span>de <span class="blank _1"> </span>indenizar <span class="blank _2"> </span>a <span class="blank _2"> </span>vít<span class="blank _3"> </span>ima, <span class="blank _2"> </span>a <span class="blank _2"> </span>seguradora <span class="blank _2"> </span>poderá <span class="blank _2"> </span>exigir <span class="blank _1"> </span>seu <span class="blank _1"> </span>direito <span class="blank _2"> </span>de <span class="blank _1"> </span>regresso <span class="blank _2"> </span>contra <span class="blank _2"> </span>o </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y28 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">segurado (causador do<span class="blank _0"></span> dano). </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y29 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A garantia de respo<span class="blank _0"></span>nsab<span class="blank _0"></span>ilidade civil não visa<span class="blank _0"></span> apenas pro<span class="blank _0"></span>teger o interesse econômico <span class="blank _7"> </span>do </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y2a ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">segurado tendo, tamb<span class="blank _0"></span>ém como <span class="blank _0"></span>objetivo preservar<span class="blank _0"></span> o interesse dos terc<span class="blank _0"></span>eiros prejudicados.<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y2b ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O <span class="blank _6"> </span>seguro<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _6"> </span>de <span class="blank _3"> </span>responsabil<span class="blank _0"></span>idade <span class="blank _6"> </span>civil <span class="blank _3"> </span>se <span class="blank _6"> </span>trans<span class="blank _0"></span>mudou <span class="blank _8"> </span>após <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>edição <span class="blank _8"> </span>do <span class="blank _8"> </span>Código <span class="blank _8"> </span>Civil <span class="blank _8"> </span>de <span class="blank _8"> </span>2002, <span class="blank _3"> </span>de </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y2c ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">forma <span class="blank _9"> </span>que <span class="blank _9"> </span>deixou <span class="blank _9"> </span>de <span class="blank _a"> </span>ser <span class="blank _9"> </span>apenas <span class="blank _9"> </span>uma <span class="blank _a"> </span>forma <span class="blank _9"> </span>de <span class="blank _9"> </span>reembolsar <span class="blank _9"> </span>as <span class="blank _9"> </span>indenizações <span class="blank _9"> </span>pagas <span class="blank _a"> </span>pelo<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y2d ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">segurado e passou a ser <span class="blank _3"> </span>também um meio de <span class="blank _3"> </span>proteção das vítimas, prestigi<span class="blank _3"> </span>ando, assim, a sua </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y2e ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">função social. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y2f ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _3"> </span>ini<span class="blank _0"></span>d<span class="blank _0"></span>ô<span class="blank _0"></span>n<span class="blank _0"></span>ea<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _3"> </span>a <span class="blank _3"> </span>ex<span class="blank _0"></span>cl<span class="blank _0"></span>u<span class="blank _0"></span>s<span class="blank _0"></span>ão<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _3"> </span>da cob<span class="blank _0"></span>e<span class="blank _0"></span>r<span class="blank _0"></span>tu<span class="blank _0"></span>r<span class="blank _0"></span>a de <span class="blank _3"> </span>re<span class="blank _0"></span>s<span class="blank _0"></span>po<span class="blank _0"></span>n<span class="blank _0"></span>s<span class="blank _0"></span>ab<span class="blank _0"></span>i<span class="blank _0"></span>l<span class="blank _0"></span>id<span class="blank _0"></span>a<span class="blank _0"></span>d<span class="blank _0"></span>e <span class="blank _3"> </span>c<span class="blank _0"></span>iv<span class="blank _0"></span>il<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _3"> </span>no<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _3"> </span>se<span class="blank _0"></span>g<span class="blank _0"></span>ur<span class="blank _0"></span>o de <span class="blank _3"> </span>au<span class="blank _0"></span>t<span class="blank _0"></span>o<span class="blank _0"></span>mó<span class="blank _0"></span>v<span class="blank _0"></span>e<span class="blank _0"></span>l <span class="blank _3"> </span>qu<span class="blank _0"></span>a<span class="blank _0"></span>n<span class="blank _0"></span>do<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _3"> </span>o </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y30 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">mo<span class="blank _0"></span>t<span class="blank _0"></span>o<span class="blank _0"></span>r<span class="blank _0"></span>is<span class="blank _0"></span>t<span class="blank _0"></span>a<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span>di<span class="blank _0"></span>r<span class="blank _0"></span>i<span class="blank _0"></span>g<span class="blank _0"></span>e <span class="blank _0"></span>e<span class="blank _0"></span>m<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span>e<span class="blank _0"></span>s<span class="blank _0"></span>ta<span class="blank _0"></span>d<span class="blank _0"></span>o<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span>d<span class="blank _0"></span>e <span class="blank _b"></span>em<span class="blank _b"></span>br<span class="blank _0"></span>ia<span class="blank _b"></span>gu<span class="blank _0"></span>ez<span class="blank _0"></span>,<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>vis<span class="blank _b"></span>to<span class="blank _0"></span> q<span class="blank _b"></span>ue<span class="blank _b"></span> s<span class="blank _b"></span>om<span class="blank _0"></span>en<span class="blank _b"></span>te <span class="blank _b"></span>pr<span class="blank _b"></span>ej<span class="blank _b"></span>udi<span class="blank _b"></span>car<span class="blank _b"></span>ia <span class="blank _b"></span>a<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>ví<span class="blank _0"></span>ti<span class="blank _b"></span>ma <span class="blank _b"></span>já<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span>pe<span class="blank _b"></span>nal<span class="blank _b"></span>iza<span class="blank _b"></span>da<span class="blank _0"></span>, </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y31 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">o<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _2"> </span>qu<span class="blank _b"></span>e <span class="blank _2"> </span>es<span class="blank _b"></span>va<span class="blank _0"></span>zi<span class="blank _0"></span>ar<span class="blank _b"></span>ia<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _1"> </span>a <span class="blank _2"> </span>f<span class="blank _0"></span>in<span class="blank _b"></span>ali<span class="blank _b"></span>da<span class="blank _0"></span>de<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _2"> </span>e <span class="blank _2"> </span>a <span class="blank _2"> </span>fu<span class="blank _b"></span>nç<span class="blank _0"></span>ã<span class="blank _0"></span>o <span class="blank _2"> </span>s<span class="blank _0"></span>oc<span class="blank _b"></span>ial<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _2"> </span>des<span class="blank _b"></span>sa<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _1"> </span>ga<span class="blank _b"></span>ran<span class="blank _b"></span>tia<span class="blank _b"></span>, <span class="blank _2"> </span>de<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _2"> </span>pro<span class="blank _b"></span>te<span class="blank _0"></span>çã<span class="blank _b"></span>o <span class="blank _2"> </span>do<span class="blank _b"></span>s <span class="blank _2"> </span>in<span class="blank _b"></span>te<span class="blank _0"></span>re<span class="blank _b"></span>ss<span class="blank _0"></span>es<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _1"> </span>do<span class="blank _b"></span>s </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y32 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">te<span class="blank _b"></span>rc<span class="blank _b"></span>eir<span class="blank _b"></span>os <span class="blank _b"></span>pr<span class="blank _0"></span>ej<span class="blank _b"></span>ud<span class="blank _0"></span>i<span class="blank _0"></span>ca<span class="blank _b"></span>dos<span class="blank _b"></span> à<span class="blank _0"></span> i<span class="blank _b"></span>nde<span class="blank _b"></span>niz<span class="blank _b"></span>aç<span class="blank _b"></span>ão<span class="blank _0"></span>, <span class="blank _b"></span>ao <span class="blank _b"></span>la<span class="blank _0"></span>do<span class="blank _b"></span> da<span class="blank _b"></span> p<span class="blank _0"></span>r<span class="blank _0"></span>o<span class="blank _0"></span>te<span class="blank _b"></span>ção<span class="blank _b"></span> p<span class="blank _0"></span>at<span class="blank _0"></span>r<span class="blank _0"></span>im<span class="blank _b"></span>on<span class="blank _0"></span>i<span class="blank _0"></span>al<span class="blank _0"></span> d<span class="blank _b"></span>o <span class="blank _0"></span>se<span class="blank _b"></span>gur<span class="blank _b"></span>ad<span class="blank _0"></span>o<span class="blank _0"></span>. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y33 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls4 ws3">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="blank _0"></span><span class="ls5 ws5">. <span class="blank _b"></span><span class="ls1">3ª<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>T<span class="blank _b"></span>urm<span class="blank _b"></span>a.<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>R<span class="blank _0"></span>Es<span class="blank _b"></span>p <span class="blank _b"></span>1<span class="blank _b"></span>.73<span class="blank _b"></span>8.2<span class="blank _b"></span>47<span class="blank _0"></span>-S<span class="blank _b"></span>C,<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>R<span class="blank _b"></span>el<span class="blank _0"></span>. <span class="blank _b"></span>M<span class="blank _b"></span>in<span class="blank _b"></span>. <span class="blank _b"></span>R<span class="blank _0"></span>ic<span class="blank _b"></span>ar<span class="blank _0"></span>do<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>V<span class="blank _b"></span>ill<span class="blank _b"></span>as<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>B<span class="blank _b"></span>ôa<span class="blank _0"></span>s <span class="blank _b"></span>C<span class="blank _b"></span>ue<span class="blank _0"></span>v<span class="blank _0"></span>a,<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>j<span class="blank _b"></span>ulg<span class="blank _b"></span>ad<span class="blank _0"></span>o <span class="blank _c"></span>em<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _c"></span>27<span class="blank _0"></span>/1<span class="blank _b"></span>1/<span class="blank _0"></span>20<span class="blank _b"></span>18<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>(<span class="blank _0"></span>In<span class="blank _b"></span>fo <span class="blank _c"></span>6<span class="blank _0"></span>39<span class="blank _b"></span>). </span></span></span></div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf2" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="2"><div class="pc pc2 w0 h0"><img class="bi x2 y34 w5 he" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/5a5f0e60-95f7-466b-bd7d-79549058eda4/bg2.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x14 hf y35 ff3 fs7 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="ff9 fs8 ls6">Informat<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo </span></div><div class="t m0 x15 h10 y36 ff9 fs8 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">comentado </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y37 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y38 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x3 h3 y3 ff1 fs1 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo 639-STJ (01/02/2019) <span class="ff2 ws0">–</span> Márcio André Lopes Cavalcante<span class="ls7"> </span>| 2 </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y39 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xa y3a w3 h7"><div class="t m0 x16 h8 yb ff5 fs5 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws5">DIREITO DO CONSU<span class="blank _0"></span>MIDOR </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y3b ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x17 h9 y3c ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">CLÁUSULAS ABUSIVAS E CONTRATOS BANCÁRIOS </div><div class="t m0 x18 h9 y3d ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É abusiva a previsão no contrato bancário de cobrança genérica </div><div class="t m0 x19 h9 y3e ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">por serviços prestados por terceiros </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y3f ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y40 w4 h11"><div class="t m0 xf hb y41 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É <span class="blank _9"> </span>abusiva a <span class="blank _9"> </span>cláusula <span class="blank _9"> </span>que <span class="blank _9"> </span>prevê <span class="blank _9"> </span>a <span class="blank _9"> </span>cobrança de <span class="blank _9"> </span>ressarcimento <span class="blank _9"> </span>de <span class="blank _9"> </span>serviços prestados <span class="blank _9"> </span>por </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y42 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">terceiros, sem a especif<span class="blank _b"></span>icação do serviço a s<span class="blank _0"></span>er efetivamente prestado.<span class="blank _b"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y15 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="blank _2"> </span><span class="ls8">2<span class="lsb">ª <span class="blank _1"> </span><span class="ls1">Seção. <span class="blank _1"> </span>REsp <span class="blank _2"> </span>1.578.553-SP, <span class="blank _2"> </span>Rel. <span class="blank _1"> </span>Min. <span class="blank _1"> </span>Paulo <span class="blank _2"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>Tarso <span class="blank _1"> </span>Sanseverino, <span class="blank _2"> </span>julgado <span class="blank _1"> </span>em <span class="blank _2"> </span>28/11/2018 </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xf hc y16 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">(recurso repetit<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo) (Info 639). </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y43 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x17 h9 y44 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">CLÁUSULAS ABUSIVAS E CONTRATOS BANCÁRIOS </div><div class="t m0 x1a h9 y45 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Em regra, o banco pode cobrar tarifa de avaliação do bem dado em garantia </div><div class="t m0 x1b h9 y46 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Em regra, o banco pode cobrar o ressarcimento de despesa com o registro do contrato </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y47 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y48 w4 h12"><div class="t m0 xf hb y49 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É <span class="blank _6"> </span>válida <span class="blank _2"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>tarifa <span class="blank _6"> </span>de <span class="blank _6"> </span>avaliação <span class="blank _6"> </span>do <span class="blank _6"> </span>bem <span class="blank _2"> </span>dado <span class="blank _6"> </span>em <span class="blank _6"> </span>garantia, <span class="blank _2"> </span>be<span class="blank _0"></span>m <span class="blank _6"> </span>como <span class="blank _2"> </span>da <span class="blank _8"> </span>cláusula <span class="blank _6"> </span>que <span class="blank _2"> </span>prevê <span class="blank _6"> </span>o </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y4a ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">ressarcimento de desp<span class="blank _b"></span>esa com o registro do c<span class="blank _0"></span>ontrato, ressalvadas<span class="blank _0"></span>: </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y4b ffa fs0 fc0 sc0 lsc ws5">• <span class="ff6 ls1">a abusividade da co<span class="blank _0"></span>brança por s<span class="blank _0"></span>erviço não efetivamen<span class="blank _0"></span>te prestado; <span class="lsd">e </span> </span></div><div class="t m0 xf hb y4c ffa fs0 fc0 sc0 lsc ws5">• <span class="ff6 ls1">a possibilidade de <span class="blank _0"></span>controle da o<span class="blank _0"></span>nerosidade excessiva, em c<span class="blank _0"></span>ada caso co<span class="blank _0"></span>ncret<span class="lse ws7">o.</span> </span></div><div class="t m0 xf hb y4d ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Tarifa <span class="blank _1"> </span>de <span class="blank _7"> </span>avaliação<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _7"> </span>do <span class="blank _2"> </span>bem <span class="blank _7"> </span>dado <span class="blank _1"> </span>em <span class="blank _7"> </span>gara<span class="blank _b"></span>n<span class="blank _3"> </span>tia: <span class="blank _1"> </span>valor <span class="blank _1"> </span>cobrado <span class="blank _7"> </span>do <span class="blank _1"> </span>banco <span class="blank _d"> </span>para <span class="blank _d"> </span>remunerar <span class="blank _d"> </span>o </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y4e ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">especialista que r<span class="blank _0"></span>ealiza a avaliaçã<span class="blank _0"></span>o do preço de mercado<span class="blank _0"></span> do bem dado e<span class="blank _0"></span>m garantia. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y34 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Ressarcimento <span class="blank _4"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"></span>e <span class="blank _4"> </span>despesa <span class="blank _4"> </span>com <span class="blank _4"> </span>o <span class="blank _4"> </span>registro<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _4"> </span>do <span class="blank _4"> </span>contrato: <span class="blank _4"> </span>valor <span class="blank _4"> </span>cobrado<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _4"> </span>pela <span class="blank _4"> </span>instituição<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y4f ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 lsf ws8">fi<span class="ls1 ws5">nanceira <span class="blank _b"></span>como ressar<span class="blank _0"></span>cimento <span class="blank _b"></span>pelos <span class="blank _0"></span>custos <span class="blank _b"></span>que <span class="blank _0"></span>o <span class="blank _0"></span>banco <span class="blank _b"></span>terá para <span class="blank _b"></span>fazer <span class="blank _b"></span>o registro <span class="blank _b"></span>do co<span class="blank _b"></span>n<span class="blank _3"> </span>trato<span class="blank _0"></span> </span></div><div class="t m0 xf hb y50 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">no <span class="blank _6"> </span>cartório <span class="blank _6"> </span>ou <span class="blank _2"> </span>no <span class="blank _6"> </span>DETRAN. <span class="blank _6"> </span>Ex: <span class="blank _2"> </span>despesas <span class="blank _6"> </span>para <span class="blank _6"> </span>registrar <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _2"> </span>alienação <span class="blank _6"> </span>fiduciária <span class="blank _6"> </span>de <span class="blank _6"> </span>veículo <span class="blank _2"> </span>no<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y31 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">DETRAN. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y51 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="blank _2"> </span><span class="ls8">2<span class="lsb">ª <span class="blank _1"> </span><span class="ls1">Seção. <span class="blank _1"> </span>REsp <span class="blank _2"> </span>1.578.553-SP, <span class="blank _2"> </span>Rel. <span class="blank _1"> </span>Min. <span class="blank _1"> </span>Paulo <span class="blank _2"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>Tarso <span class="blank _1"> </span>Sanseverino, <span class="blank _1"> </span>julgado <span class="blank _2"> </span>em <span class="blank _1"> </span>28/11/2018 </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xf hc y33 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">(recurso repetit<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo) (Info 639). </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y52 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y53 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x17 h9 y54 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">CLÁUSULAS ABUSIVAS E CONTRATOS BANCÁRIOS </div><div class="t m0 x1c h9 y55 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O banco não pode cobrar do consumidor o valor gasto </div><div class="t m0 x1d h9 y56 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">pela instituição com a comissão do correspondente bancário </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y57 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y58 w4 h13"><div class="t m0 xf hb y59 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É <span class="blank _e"> </span>abusiva <span class="blank _e"> </span>a <span class="blank _e"> </span>cláusula <span class="blank _e"> </span>q<span class="blank _0"></span>ue <span class="blank _e"> </span>prevê <span class="blank _e"> </span>o <span class="blank _e"> </span>ressarcimento <span class="blank _e"> </span>pelo <span class="blank _e"> </span>cons<span class="blank _0"></span>umidor <span class="blank _e"> </span>da <span class="blank _e"> </span>comissão<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _e"> </span>do </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y5a ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">correspondente <span class="blank _3"> </span>bancário,<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _8"> </span>em <span class="blank _8"> </span>contratos <span class="blank _3"> </span>celebrados <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _3"> </span>partir <span class="blank _8"> </span>de <span class="blank _8"> </span>25/02/2011<span class="blank _0"></span>, <span class="blank _8"> </span>data <span class="blank _3"> </span>de <span class="blank _8"> </span>entrada </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y5b ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">em <span class="blank _6"> </span>vigor <span class="blank _8"> </span>da <span class="blank _6"> </span>Resolução <span class="blank _8"> </span>CMN <span class="blank _6"> </span>3.954<span class="blank _0"></span>/2011, <span class="blank _8"> </span>sendo <span class="blank _6"> </span>válida <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>cláusula <span class="blank _8"> </span>n<span class="blank _3"> </span>o <span class="blank _8"> </span>período <span class="blank _8"> </span>ant<span class="blank _3"> </span>erior <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>essa </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y5c ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">resolução,<span class="blank _0"></span> ressalvado o controle da o<span class="blank _0"></span>nerosidade excessiva.<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y51 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="blank _2"> </span><span class="ls8">2<span class="lsb">ª <span class="blank _1"> </span><span class="ls1">Seção. <span class="blank _1"> </span>REsp <span class="blank _2"> </span>1.578.553-SP, <span class="blank _2"> </span>Rel. <span class="blank _1"> </span>Min. <span class="blank _1"> </span>Paulo <span class="blank _2"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>Tars<span class="blank _3"> </span>o <span class="blank _2"> </span>Sanseverino, <span class="blank _2"> </span>julgado <span class="blank _1"> </span>em <span class="blank _2"> </span>28/11/2018 </span></span></span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xf hc y33 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">(recurso repetit<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo) (Info 639). </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y5d ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x17 h9 y5e ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">CLÁUSULAS ABUSIVAS E CONTRATOS BANCÁRIOS </div><div class="t m0 x1e h9 y5f ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O banco não pode cobrar do consumidor o valo<span class="blank _0"></span>r gasto <span class="blank _3"> </span>com o registro do pré-gravame </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y60 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y61 w4 h14"><div class="t m0 xf hb y62 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É <span class="blank _0"></span>abusiva <span class="blank _b"></span>a cláusula <span class="blank _b"></span>que <span class="blank _b"></span>prevê o<span class="blank _0"></span> r<span class="blank _0"></span>essarcimento <span class="blank _b"></span>pelo <span class="blank _0"></span>consumidor <span class="blank _b"></span>da <span class="blank _0"></span>despesa <span class="blank _b"></span>com o <span class="blank _b"></span>registro <span class="blank _0"></span>do<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y63 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">pré-gravame, <span class="blank _3"> </span>em <span class="blank _8"> </span>contratos <span class="blank _3"> </span>celebrados <span class="blank _3"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>partir <span class="blank _8"> </span>de <span class="blank _8"> </span>25/02<span class="blank _0"></span>/2011, <span class="blank _3"> </span>data <span class="blank _8"> </span>de <span class="blank _8"> </span>entrada <span class="blank _8"> </span>em <span class="blank _3"> </span>vigor <span class="blank _8"> </span>da </div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf3" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="3"><div class="pc pc3 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 y64 w6 h15" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/5a5f0e60-95f7-466b-bd7d-79549058eda4/bg3.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x14 hf y35 ff3 fs7 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="ff9 fs8 ls6">Informat<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo </span></div><div class="t m0 x15 h10 y36 ff9 fs8 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">comentado </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y37 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y38 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x3 h3 y3 ff1 fs1 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo 639-STJ (01/02/2019) <span class="ff2 ws0">–</span> Márcio André Lopes Cavalcante<span class="ls7"> </span>| 3 </div></div><div class="c xe y65 w4 h16"><div class="t m0 xf hb y41 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Resolução <span class="blank _1"> </span>C<span class="blank _3"> </span>MN <span class="blank _d"> </span>3.954/201<span class="blank _0"></span>1, <span class="blank _d"> </span>sendo vál<span class="blank _0"></span>ida <span class="blank _d"> </span>a <span class="blank _7"> </span>cláusula <span class="blank _d"> </span>pactuada <span class="blank _d"> </span>no <span class="blank _d"> </span>período <span class="blank _d"> </span>anterior <span class="blank _7"> </span>a <span class="blank _d"> </span>essa </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y31 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">resolução,<span class="blank _0"></span> ressalvado o controle da o<span class="blank _0"></span>nerosidade excessiva.<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y51 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">STJ. <span class="blank _1"> </span>2ª <span class="blank _2"> </span>Seção. <span class="blank _2"> </span>REs<span class="blank _3"> </span>p <span class="blank _2"> </span>1.639.259-SP, <span class="blank _2"> </span>Rel. <span class="blank _1"> </span>Min. <span class="blank _1"> </span>Paulo <span class="blank _2"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>T<span class="blank _3"> </span>arso <span class="blank _2"> </span>Sanseverino, <span class="blank _2"> </span>julgado <span class="blank _2"> </span>em <span class="blank _1"> </span>12/12/2018 </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y33 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">(recurso repetit<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo) (Info 639). </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y66 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x17 h9 y67 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">CLÁUSULAS ABUSIVAS E CONTRATOS BANCÁRIOS </div><div class="t m0 x1f h9 y68 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Instituição financeira não pode exigir que o contratante faça um segur<span class="ls10">o </span> </div><div class="t m0 x1c h9 y69 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">como condição para a assinatura do contrato<span class="blank _0"></span> bancário </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y6a ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y6b w4 h17"><div class="t m0 xf hb y5b ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Nos <span class="blank _3"> </span>contratos <span class="blank _8"> </span>bancários <span class="blank _3"> </span>em <span class="blank _8"> </span>geral, <span class="blank _8"> </span>o <span class="blank _8"> </span>consumidor <span class="blank _3"> </span>não <span class="blank _8"> </span>pode <span class="blank _8"> </span>ser <span class="blank _8"> </span>compelido <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>contratar <span class="blank _3"> </span>seguro<span class="blank _3"> </span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y5c ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">com a instituição fi<span class="blank _0"></span>nanceira ou com s<span class="blank _0"></span>eguradora por el<span class="blank _0"></span>a indicada. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y6c ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">STJ. <span class="blank _1"> </span>2ª <span class="blank _2"> </span>Seção. <span class="blank _2"> </span>REs<span class="blank _3"> </span>p <span class="blank _2"> </span>1.639.259-SP, <span class="blank _2"> </span>Rel. <span class="blank _1"> </span>Min. <span class="blank _1"> </span>Paulo <span class="blank _2"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>T<span class="blank _3"> </span>arso <span class="blank _2"> </span>Sanseverino, <span class="blank _2"> </span>julgado <span class="blank _2"> </span>em <span class="blank _1"> </span>12/12/2018 </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y33 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">(recurso repetit<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo) (Info 639). </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y6d ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y6e ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c x20 y6f w7 h7"><div class="t m0 x16 h8 yb ff5 fs5 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws5">DIREITO PROCESSUA<span class="blank _b"></span>L CIVIL </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y70 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x21 h9 y71 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">TUTELA ANTECIPADA </div><div class="t m0 x11 h9 y72 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A tutela antecipada antecedente (art. 303 do CPC) somente se torna est<span class="blank _0"></span>ável se não houver </div><div class="t m0 x14 h9 y73 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">nenhum tipo de impugnação formulada<span class="blank _0"></span> pela parte contrária<span class="blank _3"> </span>, de forma que a mera contestação </div><div class="t m0 xa h9 y74 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">tem força de impedir a estabilização </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y75 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 hb y76 ff8 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Importante!!! </div></div><div class="c xe y77 w4 h18"><div class="t m0 xf hb y78 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O <span class="blank _6"> </span>CPC/2015 <span class="blank _6"> </span>inovou <span class="blank _2"> </span>na <span class="blank _6"> </span>ordem <span class="blank _6"> </span>ju<span class="blank _3"> </span>rídica <span class="blank _6"> </span>ao <span class="blank _6"> </span>trazer, <span class="blank _2"> </span>al<span class="blank _0"></span>ém <span class="blank _6"> </span>das <span class="blank _2"> </span>hipóteses <span class="blank _6"> </span>até <span class="blank _2"> </span>então <span class="blank _6"> </span>previstas <span class="blank _8"> </span>no </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y79 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">CPC/1973<span class="blank _0"></span>, <span class="blank _e"> </span>a <span class="blank _e"> </span>possib<span class="blank _0"></span>ilidade <span class="blank _e"> </span>de <span class="blank _e"> </span>concessão<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _e"> </span>de <span class="blank _f"> </span>tutela <span class="blank _f"> </span>antecipada <span class="blank _e"> </span>requerida <span class="blank _f"> </span>em <span class="blank _f"> </span>caráter </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y7a ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">antecedente, a <span class="blank _0"></span>teor do que dispõe o s<span class="blank _0"></span>eu art. 303<span class="blank _0"></span>. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y7b ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Uma <span class="blank _6"> </span>das <span class="blank _6"> </span>grandes <span class="blank _8"> </span>novidades <span class="blank _8"> </span>t<span class="blank _3"> </span>razidas <span class="blank _8"> </span>pelo <span class="blank _6"> </span>novo <span class="blank _8"> </span>CPC <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _2"> </span>res<span class="blank _b"></span>peito <span class="blank _6"> </span>do <span class="blank _6"> </span>tema <span class="blank _6"> </span>é <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>possibilidade <span class="blank _6"> </span>de </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y7c ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">estabilização <span class="blank _3"> </span>da <span class="blank _6"> </span>tutela <span class="blank _8"> </span>ant<span class="blank _3"> </span>ecipada <span class="blank _3"> </span>requerida <span class="blank _8"> </span>em <span class="blank _6"> </span>caráter <span class="blank _8"> </span>antecedente, <span class="blank _3"> </span>in<span class="blank _3"> </span>stituto <span class="blank _3"> </span>in<span class="blank _3"> </span>spirado <span class="blank _8"> </span>no </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y7d ff8 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws4">référé<span class="ff6 ws5"> <span class="blank _0"></span>do <span class="blank _0"></span>Direito fr<span class="blank _0"></span>ancês, <span class="blank _b"></span>que serve <span class="blank _b"></span>para abarca<span class="blank _0"></span>r aquela<span class="blank _0"></span>s <span class="blank _0"></span>situações <span class="blank _0"></span>em <span class="blank _0"></span>que ambas <span class="blank _b"></span>as par<span class="blank _0"></span>tes se </span></div><div class="t m0 xf hb y7e ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">contentam <span class="blank _a"> </span>com <span class="blank _10"> </span>a <span class="blank _a"> </span>simples <span class="blank _10"> </span>tutela <span class="blank _a"> </span>antecipada, <span class="blank _a"> </span>não <span class="blank _10"> </span>havendo <span class="blank _a"> </span>necessidade, <span class="blank _a"> </span>portanto, <span class="blank _10"> </span>de <span class="blank _a"> </span>se </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y7f ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">prosseguir <span class="blank _3"> </span>com <span class="blank _3"> </span>o <span class="blank _3"> </span>processo <span class="blank _8"> </span>até <span class="blank _3"> </span>uma <span class="blank _8"> </span>decisão <span class="blank _3"> </span>final <span class="blank _3"> </span>(sen<span class="blank _3"> </span>tença), n<span class="blank _3"> </span>os <span class="blank _3"> </span>termos <span class="blank _3"> </span>do <span class="blank _3"> </span>que <span class="blank _8"> </span>estabelece <span class="blank _3"> </span>o </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y80 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">art. 304<span class="blank _0"></span>, §§ 1º a 6º, do CPC/20<span class="blank _0"></span>15. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y81 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Assim, <span class="blank _a"> </span>segundo <span class="blank _9"> </span>o <span class="blank _a"> </span>art. <span class="blank _a"> </span>304, <span class="blank _a"> </span>não <span class="blank _a"> </span>havendo <span class="blank _a"> </span>recurso <span class="blank _a"> </span>contra <span class="blank _9"> </span>a <span class="blank _a"> </span>decisão <span class="blank _10"> </span>que <span class="blank _9"> </span>defe<span class="blank _3"> </span>riu <span class="blank _a"> </span>a <span class="blank _a"> </span>tutela </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y82 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">antecipada <span class="blank _10"> </span>requerida <span class="blank _a"> </span>em <span class="blank _10"> </span>caráter <span class="blank _10"> </span>antecedente, <span class="blank _a"> </span>a <span class="blank _10"> </span>referida <span class="blank _10"> </span>decisão <span class="blank _10"> </span>será <span class="blank _a"> </span>est<span class="blank _3"> </span>abilizada <span class="blank _a"> </span>e <span class="blank _10"> </span>o </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y83 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">processo será<span class="blank _0"></span> extinto, sem reso<span class="blank _0"></span>lução de mérito.<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y84 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">No<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _8"> </span>prazo<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _8"> </span>de <span class="blank _3"> </span>2 <span class="blank _8"> </span>anos<span class="blank _0"></span>, <span class="blank _3"> </span>porém<span class="blank _0"></span>, <span class="blank _3"> </span>con<span class="blank _0"></span>tad<span class="blank _0"></span>o <span class="blank _3"> </span>da <span class="blank _3"> </span>ciênc<span class="blank _0"></span>ia<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _8"> </span>da <span class="blank _3"> </span>deci<span class="blank _0"></span>sã<span class="blank _0"></span>o <span class="blank _8"> </span>qu<span class="blank _0"></span>e <span class="blank _8"> </span>ex<span class="blank _0"></span>ting<span class="blank _0"></span>uiu<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _8"> </span>o <span class="blank _8"> </span>pro<span class="blank _0"></span>cess<span class="blank _b"></span>o, <span class="blank _8"> </span>as <span class="blank _3"> </span>part<span class="blank _0"></span>es </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y85 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">po<span class="blank _0"></span>der<span class="blank _b"></span>ão <span class="blank _a"> </span>pleit<span class="blank _0"></span>ear<span class="blank _b"></span>, <span class="blank _10"> </span>per<span class="blank _0"></span>ante<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _10"> </span>o<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _10"> </span>me<span class="blank _0"></span>smo<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _10"> </span>Juí<span class="blank _0"></span>zo<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _10"> </span>que<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _10"> </span>pr<span class="blank _b"></span>ofer<span class="blank _b"></span>iu <span class="blank _10"> </span>a <span class="blank _a"> </span>deci<span class="blank _0"></span>são<span class="blank _b"></span>, <span class="blank _10"> </span>a <span class="blank _10"> </span>re<span class="blank _0"></span>vis<span class="blank _b"></span>ão, <span class="blank _a"> </span>refo<span class="blank _0"></span>rm<span class="blank _0"></span>a <span class="blank _a"> </span>ou </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y86 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">inv<span class="blank _0"></span>al<span class="blank _0"></span>ida<span class="blank _b"></span>ção <span class="blank _c"></span>da <span class="blank _b"></span>tutel<span class="blank _b"></span>a <span class="blank _b"></span>antec<span class="blank _0"></span>ip<span class="blank _0"></span>ada<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span>est<span class="blank _0"></span>ab<span class="blank _0"></span>il<span class="blank _0"></span>izad<span class="blank _b"></span>a, <span class="blank _b"></span>deve<span class="blank _0"></span>ndo<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>se <span class="blank _c"></span>vale<span class="blank _0"></span>r <span class="blank _b"></span>de <span class="blank _b"></span>aç<span class="blank _b"></span>ão <span class="blank _b"></span>autô<span class="blank _0"></span>nom<span class="blank _0"></span>a <span class="blank _b"></span>pa<span class="blank _0"></span>ra<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>esse<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span>fim<span class="blank _0"></span>. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y87 ffa fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É <span class="blank _b"></span>de se <span class="blank _b"></span>observar, <span class="blank _b"></span>porém, <span class="blank _b"></span>que, <span class="blank _b"></span>embora <span class="blank _0"></span>o <span class="blank _b"></span>caput do <span class="blank _c"></span>art. <span class="blank _0"></span>304 <span class="blank _b"></span>do <span class="blank _b"></span>CPC/2015 <span class="blank _b"></span>det<span class="blank _3"> </span>ermine <span class="blank _b"></span>que <span class="blank _b"></span>“a t<span class="blank _0"></span>utela </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y88 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">antecipada, <span class="blank _3"> </span>concedida <span class="blank _3"> </span>nos <span class="blank _8"> </span>termos <span class="blank _8"> </span>do <span class="blank _3"> </span>art. <span class="blank _8"> </span>303, <span class="blank _3"> </span>torna<span class="blank _3"> </span>-se <span class="blank _8"> </span>estável <span class="blank _3"> </span>se <span class="blank _8"> </span>da <span class="blank _8"> </span>decisão <span class="blank _3"> </span>que <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>conceder<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y89 ffa fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">não <span class="blank _1"> </span>for <span class="blank _1"> </span>in<span class="blank _3"> </span>terposto <span class="blank _1"> </span>o <span class="blank _1"> </span>re<span class="blank _3"> </span>spectivo <span class="blank _1"> </span>recurso”, <span class="blank _1"> </span>a <span class="blank _d"> </span>leitura <span class="blank _1"> </span>que <span class="blank _d"> </span>deve <span class="blank _d"> </span>ser <span class="blank _d"> </span><span class="ff6">feit<span class="blank _3"> </span>a <span class="blank _1"> </span>do <span class="blank _d"> </span>dispositivo <span class="blank _1"> </span>legal, </span></div><div class="t m0 xf hb y8a ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">tomando <span class="blank _10"> </span>como <span class="blank _4"> </span>bas<span class="blank _0"></span>e <span class="blank _4"> </span>u<span class="blank _0"></span>ma <span class="blank _10"> </span>interpretação <span class="blank _10"> </span>sistemática <span class="blank _4"> </span>e<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _4"> </span>tel<span class="blank _0"></span>eológica <span class="blank _10"> </span>do <span class="blank _10"> </span>in<span class="blank _3"> </span>stituto, <span class="blank _10"> </span>é <span class="blank _4"> </span>q<span class="blank _0"></span>ue <span class="blank _10"> </span>a </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y8b ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">estabilização <span class="blank _9"> </span>somente <span class="blank _9"> </span>ocorrerá <span class="blank _9"> </span>se <span class="blank _a"> </span>não <span class="blank _9"> </span>houver <span class="blank _a"> </span>qualquer <span class="blank _9"> </span>tipo <span class="blank _a"> </span>de <span class="blank _a"> </span>impugnação<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _9"> </span>pela <span class="blank _a"> </span>parte </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y8c ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">contrária, <span class="blank _11"> </span>sob <span class="blank _11"> </span>pena <span class="blank _11"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>se <span class="blank _11"> </span>estimular <span class="blank _11"> </span>a <span class="blank _11"> </span>in<span class="blank _3"> </span>terposição<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _11"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>agravos <span class="blank _11"> </span>de <span class="blank _12"> </span>instrumento, </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y14 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">sobrecarr<span class="blank _0"></span>egando <span class="blank _3"> </span>desnecessariamente os <span class="blank _3"> </span>Tribunais, <span class="blank _3"> </span>além <span class="blank _3"> </span>do <span class="blank _3"> </span>ajuizamento <span class="blank _3"> </span>da <span class="blank _3"> </span>ação <span class="blank _3"> </span>autônoma, </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y15 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">prevista no <span class="blank _9"> </span>art. <span class="blank _9"> </span>304, § <span class="blank _9"> </span>2º, <span class="blank _9"> </span>do <span class="blank _9"> </span>CPC/2015, a <span class="blank _9"> </span>fim <span class="blank _9"> </span>de <span class="blank _9"> </span>rever, reformar <span class="blank _9"> </span>ou <span class="blank _9"> </span>invalidar a <span class="blank _9"> </span>tutela </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y16 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">antecipada estab<span class="blank _0"></span>ilizada. </div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf4" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="4"><div class="pc pc4 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 y8d w6 h19" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/5a5f0e60-95f7-466b-bd7d-79549058eda4/bg4.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x14 hf y35 ff3 fs7 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="ff9 fs8 ls6">Informat<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo </span></div><div class="t m0 x15 h10 y36 ff9 fs8 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">comentado </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y37 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y38 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x3 h3 y3 ff1 fs1 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo 639-STJ (01/02/2019) <span class="ff2 ws0">–</span> Márcio André Lopes Cavalcante<span class="ls7"> </span>| 4 </div></div><div class="c xe y8e w4 h1a"><div class="t m0 xf hb y8f ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">No ca<span class="blank _0"></span>so concreto <span class="blank _0"></span>analisado <span class="blank _0"></span>pelo STJ, <span class="blank _0"></span>a empresa ré <span class="blank _b"></span>n<span class="blank _3"> </span>ão interpôs <span class="blank _b"></span>agravo de instrumento <span class="blank _0"></span>contra </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y90 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">a <span class="blank _1"> </span>decisão <span class="blank _1"> </span>que <span class="blank _1"> </span>deferiu <span class="blank _1"> </span>o <span class="blank _1"> </span>pedido <span class="blank _1"> </span>de <span class="blank _1"> </span>antecipação<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _1"> </span>dos <span class="blank _1"> </span>efeitos <span class="blank _1"> </span>da <span class="blank _1"> </span>tutela <span class="blank _1"> </span>requerida <span class="blank _1"> </span>em <span class="blank _1"> </span>caráter </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y91 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">antecedente, <span class="blank _8"> </span>mas <span class="blank _6"> </span>apresentou <span class="blank _8"> </span>contestação, <span class="blank _8"> </span>na <span class="blank _6"> </span>qual <span class="blank _8"> </span>pleiteou, <span class="blank _6"> </span>inclusive, <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>revogação <span class="blank _8"> </span>da <span class="blank _6"> </span>tutela </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y92 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">provisória <span class="blank _8"> </span>concedida. <span class="blank _8"> </span>Diante <span class="blank _6"> </span>disso, <span class="blank _8"> </span>o <span class="blank _6"> </span>Tribunal <span class="blank _8"> </span>considerou <span class="blank _6"> </span>que <span class="blank _6"> </span>não <span class="blank _8"> </span>houve <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>estabilização <span class="blank _8"> </span>da </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y93 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">tutela <span class="blank _9"> </span>antecipada, devendo, <span class="blank _9"> </span>por <span class="blank _9"> </span>isso, <span class="blank _9"> </span>o <span class="blank _9"> </span>feito <span class="blank _9"> </span>prosseguir <span class="blank _9"> </span>normalmente <span class="blank _9"> </span>até <span class="blank _a"> </span>a <span class="blank _9"> </span>prolação da </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y94 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">sentença. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y95 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A <span class="blank _4"> </span>ideia <span class="blank _10"> </span>central <span class="blank _10"> </span>do <span class="blank _4"> </span>instituto <span class="blank _10"> </span>é <span class="blank _4"> </span>q<span class="blank _0"></span>ue, <span class="blank _4"> </span>apó<span class="blank _0"></span>s <span class="blank _10"> </span>a <span class="blank _4"> </span>concessão <span class="blank _10"> </span>da <span class="blank _4"> </span>tutela <span class="blank _10"> </span>antecipada <span class="blank _10"> </span>em <span class="blank _4"> </span>car<span class="blank _0"></span>áter </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y96 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">antecedente, nem o auto<span class="blank _0"></span>r nem o réu tenham interesse no prossegui<span class="blank _0"></span>mento do feito, isto é, não<span class="blank _b"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y97 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">queiram <span class="blank _1"> </span>uma <span class="blank _d"> </span>decisão <span class="blank _1"> </span>com <span class="blank _1"> </span>cognição <span class="blank _1"> </span>exauriente <span class="blank _1"> </span>do <span class="blank _d"> </span>Poder <span class="blank _1"> </span>Judiciário, <span class="blank _1"> </span>apt<span class="blank _3"> </span>a <span class="blank _1"> </span>a <span class="blank _d"> </span>produzir <span class="blank _1"> </span>coisa </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y98 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">julgada material.<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y99 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Por essa razão, é <span class="blank _3"> </span>que, apesar de o caput <span class="blank _3"> </span>do art. <span class="blank _3"> </span>304 do CPC/201<span class="blank _3"> </span><span class="ffa">5 falar <span class="blank _3"> </span>em “recurso”, a leitura </span></div><div class="t m0 xf hb y9a ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">que <span class="blank _8"> </span>deve <span class="blank _8"> </span>ser <span class="blank _8"> </span>feita <span class="blank _8"> </span>do <span class="blank _6"> </span>dispositivo <span class="blank _8"> </span>legal, <span class="blank _3"> </span>t<span class="blank _3"> </span>omando<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _8"> </span>como <span class="blank _8"> </span>base <span class="blank _8"> </span>uma <span class="blank _6"> </span>interpretação<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _8"> </span>sistemática <span class="blank _8"> </span>e </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y9b ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">teleológica <span class="blank _3"> </span>do <span class="blank _3"> </span>instituto, <span class="blank _3"> </span>é <span class="blank _8"> </span>que <span class="blank _3"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>estabilização <span class="blank _3"> </span>somente <span class="blank _8"> </span>ocorrerá <span class="blank _3"> </span>se <span class="blank _3"> </span>não <span class="blank _8"> </span>houver <span class="blank _3"> </span>qualquer <span class="blank _3"> </span>tipo </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y9c ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">de impugnação p<span class="blank _0"></span>ela parte contrár<span class="blank _0"></span>ia. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y16 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">STJ<span class="blank _0"></span>. <span class="blank _b"></span>3ª <span class="blank _b"></span>Tur<span class="blank _0"></span>ma.<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>REsp <span class="blank _b"></span>1.7<span class="blank _b"></span>60.966<span class="blank _0"></span>-SP<span class="blank _0"></span>, <span class="blank _b"></span>Rel<span class="blank _0"></span>. <span class="blank _b"></span>Min.<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>Marco <span class="blank _b"></span>Aur<span class="blank _0"></span>éli<span class="blank _0"></span>o <span class="blank _b"></span>Bell<span class="blank _b"></span>izze, <span class="blank _b"></span>ju<span class="blank _0"></span>lg<span class="blank _0"></span>ad<span class="blank _0"></span>o <span class="blank _0"></span>em <span class="blank _b"></span>04/<span class="blank _0"></span>12/<span class="blank _0"></span>20<span class="blank _0"></span>18 <span class="blank _b"></span>(I<span class="blank _0"></span>nfo<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>639)<span class="blank _0"></span>. </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y9d ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x22 h9 y9e ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">TÉCNICA DE AMPLIAÇÃO DO COLEGIADO </div><div class="t m0 x23 h9 y9f ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A técnica de ampliação de julgame<span class="blank _0"></span>nto <span class="blank _3"> </span>(art. 942 do CPC/2015) deve ser utilizada quando o </div><div class="t m0 xe h9 ya0 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">resultado da apelação for não unânime<span class="blank _0"></span>, independentemente de ser julgamento que reforma o<span class="blank _8"> </span><span class="ls11">u </span></div><div class="t m0 x24 h9 ya1 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">mantém a sentença impugnada </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 ya2 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 hb ya3 ff8 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Importante!!! </div></div><div class="c xe ya4 w4 h12"><div class="t m0 xf hb y49 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Assim como oco<span class="blank _0"></span>rria com os embargos infringe<span class="blank _0"></span>ntes, para a apl<span class="blank _0"></span>icação da técnica de julgamento<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y4a ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">do art. 94<span class="blank _0"></span>2 do CPC exige-se que a sen<span class="blank _0"></span>tença tenha sido<span class="blank _0"></span> reformada no julg<span class="blank _0"></span>amento da apelaçã<span class="blank _0"></span>o? </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y4b ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">NÃO. A <span class="blank _b"></span>t<span class="blank _3"> </span>écnica do <span class="blank _b"></span>ju<span class="blank _3"> </span>lgamento <span class="blank _b"></span>ampliado vale ta<span class="blank _0"></span>mbém para <span class="blank _b"></span>sentença mantida pelo <span class="blank _b"></span>Tribunal no </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ya5 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">julgamento da a<span class="blank _0"></span>pelação por decisão<span class="blank _0"></span> não unânime. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ya6 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A <span class="blank _2"> </span>técnica <span class="blank _6"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>ampliação <span class="blank _2"> </span>de <span class="blank _6"> </span>ju<span class="blank _3"> </span>lgame<span class="blank _0"></span>nto <span class="blank _2"> </span>previs<span class="blank _0"></span>ta <span class="blank _2"> </span>no <span class="blank _2"> </span>art. <span class="blank _2"> </span>942<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _2"> </span>do <span class="blank _2"> </span>CPC/201<span class="blank _0"></span>5 <span class="blank _2"> </span>deve <span class="blank _2"> </span>ser <span class="blank _6"> </span>utilizada </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ya7 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">quando o resultado da apelação for não unânime, independenteme<span class="blank _0"></span>nte de ser julgamento que </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ya8 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">reforma ou mant<span class="blank _0"></span>ém a sentença i<span class="blank _0"></span>mpugnada. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ya9 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Assim, <span class="blank _c"></span>o <span class="blank _b"></span>que <span class="blank _b"></span>importa <span class="blank _b"></span>é <span class="blank _b"></span>que <span class="blank _b"></span>a <span class="blank _b"></span>decisão <span class="blank _b"></span>que <span class="blank _b"></span>julgou <span class="blank _c"></span>a<span class="blank _3"> </span> <span class="blank _b"></span>apelação <span class="blank _c"></span>ten<span class="blank _3"> </span>ha <span class="blank _b"></span>sido <span class="blank _c"></span>por <span class="blank _b"></span>maioria <span class="blank _b"></span>(julgamento </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yaa ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">não unânime), não i<span class="blank _0"></span>mportando q<span class="blank _0"></span>ue a sentença t<span class="blank _0"></span>enha sido mantida o<span class="blank _0"></span>u reformada. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y31 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Obs: <span class="blank _b"></span>cuidado <span class="blank _0"></span>com <span class="blank _b"></span>as <span class="blank _0"></span>hipóteses <span class="blank _b"></span>de ca<span class="blank _0"></span>bimento <span class="blank _b"></span>do <span class="blank _b"></span>art. 9<span class="blank _0"></span>42 <span class="blank _b"></span>do CP<span class="blank _0"></span>C <span class="blank _0"></span>nos <span class="blank _b"></span>casos <span class="blank _0"></span>de <span class="blank _b"></span>acórdão <span class="blank _0"></span>que <span class="blank _b"></span>julga </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y32 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">agravo de instrume<span class="blank _0"></span>nto e ação r<span class="blank _0"></span>escisória. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y33 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">STJ. 4ª Turm<span class="blank _0"></span>a. REsp 1.733<span class="blank _0"></span>.820-SC, Rel. Min. L<span class="blank _b"></span>uis Felipe Salomão, julg<span class="blank _0"></span>ado em 0<span class="blank _0"></span>2/10/2018 (Inf<span class="blank _0"></span>o 639). </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yab ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x25 h9 yac ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">AÇÃO RESCISÓRIA </div><div class="t m0 x26 h9 yad ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O pedido de rescisão da sentença, em vez do acórdão que a substituiu, nã<span class="blank _0"></span>o conduz à </div><div class="t m0 x1a h9 yae ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">impossibilidade jurídica do pedido, co<span class="blank _0"></span>nstitu<span class="blank _3"> </span>indo mera irregularidade forma<span class="blank _0"></span>l<span class="blank _3"> </span> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h9 yaf ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe yb0 w4 h1b"><div class="t m0 xf hb yb1 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O <span class="blank _b"></span>autor <span class="blank _0"></span>da <span class="blank _b"></span>ação <span class="blank _0"></span>rescisória <span class="blank _b"></span>pediu <span class="blank _b"></span>a <span class="blank _0"></span>rescisão <span class="blank _b"></span>da <span class="blank _0"></span>sentença. <span class="blank _b"></span>Ocorre <span class="blank _b"></span>que <span class="blank _b"></span>essa <span class="blank _b"></span>sentença <span class="blank _b"></span>já ha<span class="blank _0"></span>via <span class="blank _b"></span>sido </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y2d ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">confirmada <span class="blank _3"> </span>pelo <span class="blank _3"> </span>Tribunal de <span class="blank _8"> </span>Justiça <span class="blank _3"> </span>em <span class="blank _3"> </span>sede <span class="blank _3"> </span>de <span class="blank _3"> </span>apelação. <span class="blank _3"> </span>Logo, <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _3"> </span>ação <span class="blank _3"> </span>rescisória <span class="blank _3"> </span>deveria <span class="blank _3"> </span>ter </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y2e ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">pedido <span class="blank _3"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>rescisão <span class="blank _3"> </span>do <span class="blank _3"> </span>acórdão <span class="blank _3"> </span>do <span class="blank _3"> </span>TJ. <span class="blank _8"> </span>Esse <span class="blank _3"> </span>vício, <span class="blank _8"> </span>contudo, <span class="blank _3"> </span>constitui-se <span class="blank _3"> </span>em <span class="blank _8"> </span>mera <span class="blank _3"> </span>irregularidade<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yb2 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">formal, <span class="blank _8"> </span>de <span class="blank _6"> </span>modo <span class="blank _6"> </span>que <span class="blank _8"> </span>o <span class="blank _6"> </span>Tribunal <span class="blank _6"> </span>não <span class="blank _6"> </span>deverá <span class="blank _8"> </span>extinguir <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>ação <span class="blank _8"> </span>rescisória <span class="blank _6"> </span>por <span class="blank _8"> </span>imp<span class="blank _3"> </span>ossibilidade </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yb3 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">jurídica do pedido,<span class="blank _0"></span> devendo superar o<span class="blank _0"></span> vício e enfr<span class="blank _0"></span>entar o mérito. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y31 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Esse entendimen<span class="blank _0"></span>to é refor<span class="blank _0"></span>çado atualmente pela <span class="blank _0"></span>previsão do ar<span class="blank _0"></span>t. 968, §<span class="blank _0"></span>§ 5º e 6º do CPC/2<span class="blank _0"></span>015. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y51 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="blank _8"> </span><span class="ls1">3ª <span class="blank _6"> </span>Turma. <span class="blank _6"> </span>REsp <span class="blank _8"> </span>1.569.948-AM, <span class="blank _6"> </span>Rel. <span class="blank _6"> </span>Min. <span class="blank _6"> </span>Paulo <span class="blank _8"> </span>de <span class="blank _8"> </span>T<span class="blank _3"> </span>arso <span class="blank _6"> </span>Sanseverino, <span class="blank _8"> </span>julgado <span class="blank _8"> </span>em <span class="blank _6"> </span>11/1<span class="blank _3"> </span>2/2018 </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xf hc y33 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">(Info 639). </div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf5" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="5"><div class="pc pc5 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 yb4 w6 h1c" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/5a5f0e60-95f7-466b-bd7d-79549058eda4/bg5.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x14 hf y35 ff3 fs7 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="ff9 fs8 ls6">Informat<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo </span></div><div class="t m0 x15 h10 y36 ff9 fs8 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">comentado </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y37 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y38 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x3 h3 y3 ff1 fs1 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo 639-STJ (01/02/2019) <span class="ff2 ws0">–</span> Márcio André Lopes Cavalcante<span class="ls7"> </span>| 5 </div><div class="t m0 x27 h9 yb5 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">AGRAVO DE INSTRUMENTO </div><div class="t m0 x28 h9 yb6 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O rol do art. 1.015 do CPC/2015 é de taxatividade mitigada </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yb7 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 hb yb8 ff8 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Importante!!! </div></div><div class="c xe ye w4 h1d"><div class="t m0 xf hb yb9 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O <span class="blank _0"></span>rol <span class="blank _b"></span>do art. <span class="blank _0"></span>1.015 <span class="blank _b"></span>do CPC é <span class="blank _b"></span>de taxatividad<span class="blank _0"></span>e <span class="blank _0"></span>mitigada, <span class="blank _b"></span>por isso<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span>admite a <span class="blank _b"></span>interposição <span class="blank _0"></span>de <span class="blank _0"></span>agravo </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y11 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">de <span class="blank _1"> </span>in<span class="blank _3"> </span>strume<span class="blank _0"></span>nto <span class="blank _d"> </span>quando <span class="blank _1"> </span>verificada <span class="blank _1"> </span>a <span class="blank _1"> </span>urgên<span class="blank _3"> </span>cia <span class="blank _1"> </span>decorrente <span class="blank _1"> </span>da <span class="blank _d"> </span>inutilidade <span class="blank _1"> </span>do <span class="blank _d"> </span>julgamento <span class="blank _1"> </span>da </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ya9 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">questão no recurso<span class="blank _0"></span> de apelação<span class="blank _0"></span>. </div><div class="t m0 xf h2 y13 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="ls1">Corte <span class="blank _3"> </span>Especial.<span class="ff1 ls12"> </span>REsp 1.704.520-MT, <span class="blank _3"> </span>Rel. Min. <span class="blank _3"> </span>Nancy <span class="blank _3"> </span>Andrighi, <span class="blank _3"> </span>julgado em <span class="blank _3"> </span>05/12/2018 <span class="blank _3"> </span>(recurso<span class="blank _0"></span> </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xf hc y42 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">repetitivo) (Info 6<span class="blank _0"></span>39). </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y15 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Obs: a tese jurídica fixada e acima explicada soment<span class="blank _0"></span>e se aplica às decisões interlocutória<span class="blank _0"></span>s proferidas<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y16 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">após a publicação do RE<span class="blank _b"></span>sp 1704520/MT, o que oco<span class="blank _0"></span>rreu no DJe 19/12/2<span class="blank _0"></span>018. </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yba ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 ybb ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xa ybc w3 h1e"><div class="t m0 x29 h8 ybd ff5 fs5 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws5">DIREITO PENAL<span class="blank _0"></span> </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 ybe ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2a h9 ybf ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">DOSIMETRIA DA PENA </div><div class="t m0 x2b h9 yc0 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Condenações anteriores transitadas em julgado não podem </div><div class="t m0 x2c h9 yc1 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">ser utilizadas como conduta social desfavoráve<span class="blank _0"></span>l<span class="blank _3"> </span> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yc2 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe yc3 w4 h1f"><div class="t m0 xf hb yc4 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A <span class="blank _2"> </span>circunstância <span class="blank _6"> </span>ju<span class="blank _3"> </span>dicial <span class="blank _2"> </span><span class="ffa ls13">“</span>condu<span class="blank _0"></span>ta <span class="blank _2"> </span>social<span class="ffa ls13">”</span>, <span class="blank _2"> </span>prevista <span class="blank _6"> </span>no <span class="blank _2"> </span>art. <span class="blank _2"> </span>59 <span class="blank _2"> </span>do <span class="blank _2"> </span>Código <span class="blank _2"> </span>Penal,<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _2"> </span>representa <span class="blank _2"> </span>o </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yc5 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">comportamento <span class="blank _6"> </span>do <span class="blank _2"> </span>agente <span class="blank _6"> </span>no <span class="blank _2"> </span>meio <span class="blank _2"> </span>familiar<span class="blank _0"></span>, <span class="blank _6"> </span>n<span class="blank _3"> </span>o <span class="blank _2"> </span>amb<span class="blank _0"></span>iente <span class="blank _2"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>trabal<span class="blank _0"></span>ho <span class="blank _2"> </span>e <span class="blank _6"> </span>no <span class="blank _2"> </span>relacionamento </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yc6 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">com outros indivíduos<span class="blank _0"></span>. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yc7 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Os <span class="blank _2"> </span>antecede<span class="blank _0"></span>ntes <span class="blank _2"> </span>so<span class="blank _0"></span>ciais <span class="blank _2"> </span>do <span class="blank _6"> </span>réu <span class="blank _2"> </span>não <span class="blank _6"> </span>se <span class="blank _2"> </span>confundem <span class="blank _2"> </span>com <span class="blank _6"> </span>os <span class="blank _2"> </span>seus <span class="blank _6"> </span>ant<span class="blank _3"> </span>ecedentes <span class="blank _6"> </span>criminais. <span class="blank _2"> </span>São<span class="blank _b"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yc8 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">circunstâncias dis<span class="blank _0"></span>tintas, c<span class="blank _0"></span>om regramentos pr<span class="blank _0"></span>óprios. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yc9 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Assim, não se mostra<span class="blank _0"></span> correto o magistrado utilizar<span class="blank _0"></span> as condenações ante<span class="blank _0"></span>riores transitadas e<span class="blank _0"></span>m </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yca ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">julgado como <span class="ffa ls13">“</span>con<span class="blank _0"></span>duta social<span class="blank _0"></span> desfavorá<span class="lsd ws9">vel<span class="ffa ls13">”</span></span>. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ycb ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Não <span class="blank _10"> </span>é <span class="blank _4"> </span>possível <span class="blank _10"> </span>a <span class="blank _4"> </span>utilização <span class="blank _10"> </span>de <span class="blank _4"> </span>condenações<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _10"> </span>ant<span class="blank _3"> </span>eriores <span class="blank _10"> </span>com <span class="blank _4"> </span>trâns<span class="blank _0"></span>ito <span class="blank _4"> </span>em <span class="blank _10"> </span>julgado <span class="blank _10"> </span>como </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ycc ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">fundamento para <span class="blank _0"></span>negativar a c<span class="blank _0"></span>onduta social. </div><div class="t m0 xf h2 ycd ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">STF. 2ª Turma.<span class="ff1 ls14"> </span>R<span class="blank _0"></span>HC 130132, Rel. M<span class="blank _0"></span>in. Teori Zava<span class="blank _0"></span>scki, julgado em 10/5/<span class="blank _0"></span>2016 (Info 825). </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y9c ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">STJ. 5ª Turma. HC <span class="blank _0"></span>475.436/P<span class="blank _0"></span>E, Rel. Min. Ribeiro Da<span class="blank _0"></span>ntas, julgado em 13/<span class="blank _b"></span>12/2018. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y16 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">STJ<span class="blank _0"></span>. 6<span class="blank _b"></span>ª Tu<span class="blank _0"></span>rma<span class="blank _0"></span>. R<span class="blank _b"></span>Esp 1<span class="blank _b"></span>.760.<span class="blank _b"></span>972-M<span class="blank _b"></span>G, R<span class="blank _0"></span>el.<span class="blank _0"></span> M<span class="blank _0"></span>in.<span class="blank _0"></span> Se<span class="blank _b"></span>basti<span class="blank _0"></span>ão<span class="blank _0"></span> R<span class="blank _0"></span>eis <span class="blank _b"></span>Júni<span class="blank _0"></span>or,<span class="blank _0"></span> j<span class="blank _b"></span>ulga<span class="blank _0"></span>do <span class="blank _0"></span>em <span class="blank _b"></span>08/11<span class="blank _0"></span>/20<span class="blank _0"></span>18<span class="blank _0"></span> (<span class="blank _0"></span>Inf<span class="blank _0"></span>o <span class="blank _0"></span>639<span class="blank _b"></span>). </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yce ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2d h9 ycf ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">CRIMES CONTRA A ORDEM TRIBUTÁRIA </div><div class="t m0 x2e h9 yd0 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Não pratica o crime do art. 3º, III, da Lei 8.137/9<span class="blank _0"></span>0 o a<span class="blank _3"> </span>uditor fiscal que corrige minuta de </div><div class="t m0 x2e h9 yd1 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">impugnação administrativa que posteriormente é<span class="blank _0"></span> ajuizada <span class="blank _3"> </span>na Administração Tributária </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yd2 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe yd3 w4 h17"><div class="t m0 xf hb y5b ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É <span class="blank _1"> </span>atípica <span class="blank _1"> </span>a <span class="blank _1"> </span>conduta <span class="blank _2"> </span>de <span class="blank _1"> </span>agente <span class="blank _1"> </span>público <span class="blank _1"> </span>que <span class="blank _1"> </span>procede <span class="blank _1"> </span>à <span class="blank _1"> </span>prévia <span class="blank _1"> </span>correção <span class="blank _2"> </span>quanto <span class="blank _1"> </span>aos <span class="blank _1"> </span>aspectos </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y42 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">gramatical, <span class="blank _8"> </span>estilístico <span class="blank _8"> </span>e <span class="blank _8"> </span>técnico <span class="blank _8"> </span>das <span class="blank _6"> </span>impugnações <span class="blank _3"> </span>administrativas, <span class="blank _8"> </span>não <span class="blank _8"> </span>configurando <span class="blank _8"> </span>o <span class="blank _8"> </span>crime </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y9c ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">de advocacia admi<span class="blank _0"></span>nistrativa perante a A<span class="blank _0"></span>dministração<span class="blank _0"></span> Fazendári<span class="ls15 wsa">a.</span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y16 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">S<span class="blank _0"></span>T<span class="blank _0"></span>J<span class="blank _b"></span>. <span class="blank _b"></span>6<span class="blank _0"></span>ª<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>T<span class="blank _0"></span>u<span class="blank _0"></span>r<span class="blank _b"></span>ma<span class="blank _b"></span>. <span class="blank _b"></span>R<span class="blank _b"></span>Es<span class="blank _0"></span>p<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span>1<span class="blank _0"></span>.<span class="blank _0"></span>7<span class="blank _b"></span>70<span class="blank _b"></span>.4<span class="blank _b"></span>44<span class="blank _b"></span>-D<span class="blank _b"></span>F,<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>Re<span class="blank _b"></span>l<span class="blank _0"></span>. <span class="blank _c"></span>Mi<span class="blank _0"></span>n<span class="blank _b"></span>. <span class="blank _b"></span>A<span class="blank _0"></span>n<span class="blank _b"></span>to<span class="blank _b"></span>ni<span class="blank _b"></span>o <span class="blank _c"></span>Sa<span class="blank _b"></span>ld<span class="blank _b"></span>an<span class="blank _b"></span>ha<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span>P<span class="blank _b"></span>al<span class="blank _b"></span>he<span class="blank _b"></span>ir<span class="blank _b"></span>o<span class="blank _0"></span>, <span class="blank _b"></span>j<span class="blank _b"></span>ul<span class="blank _b"></span>g<span class="blank _0"></span>ad<span class="blank _b"></span>o<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>e<span class="blank _0"></span>m<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>08<span class="blank _b"></span>/<span class="blank _0"></span>1<span class="blank _0"></span>1<span class="blank _0"></span>/<span class="blank _0"></span>2<span class="blank _b"></span>01<span class="blank _b"></span>8 <span class="blank _b"></span>(<span class="blank _0"></span>I<span class="blank _0"></span>n<span class="blank _b"></span>fo<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>6<span class="blank _0"></span>3<span class="blank _b"></span>9)<span class="blank _b"></span>. </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yd4 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yd5 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yd6 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yd7 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yd8 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yd9 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf6" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="6"><div class="pc pc6 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 yda w6 h20" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/5a5f0e60-95f7-466b-bd7d-79549058eda4/bg6.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x14 hf y35 ff3 fs7 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="ff9 fs8 ls6">Informat<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo </span></div><div class="t m0 x15 h10 y36 ff9 fs8 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">comentado </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y37 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y38 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x3 h3 y3 ff1 fs1 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo 639-STJ (01/02/2019) <span class="ff2 ws0">–</span> Márcio André Lopes Cavalcante<span class="ls7"> </span>| 6 </div><div class="t m0 x2d h9 yb5 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">CRIMES CONTRA A ORDEM TRIBUTÁRIA </div><div class="t m0 x5 h9 yb6 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A SV 24 pode ser aplicada a fatos anteriores à sua edição </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yb7 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 hb yb8 ff8 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Importante!!! </div></div><div class="c xe ydb w4 h21"><div class="t m0 xf hb ya8 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A Súmula Vincula<span class="blank _0"></span>nte 24 tem aplicação<span class="blank _0"></span> aos fatos o<span class="blank _0"></span>corridos anteriorment<span class="blank _0"></span>e à sua edição. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ya9 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Como <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _2"> </span>SV <span class="blank _8"> </span>24 <span class="blank _2"> </span>representa <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>mera <span class="blank _2"> </span>consol<span class="blank _0"></span>idação <span class="blank _6"> </span>da <span class="blank _2"> </span>interpr<span class="blank _0"></span>etação <span class="blank _6"> </span>judicial <span class="blank _6"> </span>que <span class="blank _6"> </span>já <span class="blank _2"> </span>era <span class="blank _6"> </span>adotada </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yaa ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">pelo <span class="blank _1"> </span>STF <span class="blank _1"> </span>e <span class="blank _1"> </span>pelo <span class="blank _1"> </span>STJ <span class="blank _1"> </span>mesmo <span class="blank _1"> </span>ant<span class="blank _3"> </span>es <span class="blank _1"> </span>da <span class="blank _1"> </span>sua <span class="blank _1"> </span>edição, <span class="blank _2"> </span>ent<span class="blank _3"> </span>ende-se <span class="blank _1"> </span>que <span class="blank _1"> </span>é <span class="blank _1"> </span>possível <span class="blank _1"> </span>a <span class="blank _1"> </span>aplicação <span class="blank _1"> </span>do </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ycd ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">enunciado para fatos<span class="blank _0"></span> ocor<span class="blank _0"></span>ridos anteriormente à <span class="blank _0"></span>sua publicação. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y32 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">STF. 1ª Turma. RHC <span class="blank _b"></span>122774/RJ, Rel. Min. Dias Toff<span class="blank _0"></span>oli, julgado em 19/5/20<span class="blank _b"></span>15 (Info 786). </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y33 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="ls8">3<span class="lsb">ª <span class="ls1">Seção. ERE<span class="blank _0"></span>sp 1.318.662-PR, Rel. M<span class="blank _b"></span>i<span class="blank _3"> </span>n. Felix F<span class="blank _0"></span>ischer, julgado e<span class="blank _0"></span>m 28/11/2018 (Info <span class="blank _0"></span>639). </span></span></span></span></span></div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 ydc ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 ydd ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c x2f yde w8 h7"><div class="t m0 x30 h8 yb ff5 fs5 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws5">DIREITO PROCESSUA<span class="blank _b"></span>L PENAL </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 ydf ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x31 h9 ye0 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">FORO POR PRERROGATIVA DE FUNÇÃO </div><div class="t m0 x20 h9 ye1 ff5 fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Crime cometido por Desembargador </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 ye2 ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 hb ye3 ff8 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Importante!!! </div></div><div class="c xe ye4 w4 h22"><div class="t m0 xf hb ye5 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O <span class="blank _8"> </span>Superior <span class="blank _8"> </span>Tribunal <span class="blank _8"> </span>de <span class="blank _8"> </span>Justiça <span class="blank _6"> </span>é <span class="blank _8"> </span>o <span class="blank _8"> </span>tribunal <span class="blank _6"> </span>competen<span class="blank _0"></span>te <span class="blank _8"> </span>para <span class="blank _8"> </span>o <span class="blank _6"> </span>julgamento <span class="blank _8"> </span>nas <span class="blank _8"> </span>hipóteses <span class="blank _8"> </span>em </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y4c ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">que, não <span class="blank _9"> </span>fosse a prerrogativa de <span class="blank _9"> </span>foro (art. 105, I, <span class="blank _9"> </span>da <span class="blank _9"> </span>CF/88), o des<span class="blank _3"> </span>embargador acusado </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ye6 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">houvesse de <span class="blank _d"> </span>responder <span class="blank _7"> </span>à ação <span class="blank _d"> </span>pen<span class="blank _3"> </span>al <span class="blank _7"> </span>perante juiz <span class="blank _d"> </span>de primeiro <span class="blank _7"> </span>grau vinculado <span class="blank _7"> </span>ao <span class="blank _7"> </span>mesmo </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ye7 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">tribunal. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ye8 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Assim, mesmo <span class="blank _0"></span>que o cr<span class="blank _0"></span>ime cometido <span class="blank _0"></span>pelo Dese<span class="blank _0"></span>mbargador não es<span class="blank _b"></span>t<span class="blank _3"> </span>eja relacio<span class="blank _0"></span>nado com as <span class="blank _0"></span>suas<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ye9 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">funções, <span class="blank _8"> </span>ele <span class="blank _8"> </span>será <span class="blank _8"> </span>julgado <span class="blank _8"> </span>pelo <span class="blank _8"> </span>STJ <span class="blank _8"> </span>se <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>remessa <span class="blank _8"> </span>para <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>1ª <span class="blank _6"> </span>instância <span class="blank _8"> </span>significar <span class="blank _8"> </span>que <span class="blank _6"> </span>o <span class="blank _8"> </span>réu <span class="blank _8"> </span>seria </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yaa ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">julgado por um juiz d<span class="blank _0"></span>e primeiro gr<span class="blank _0"></span>au vinculado ao<span class="blank _0"></span> mesmo tribunal que <span class="blank _0"></span>o Desembargador. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y31 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A <span class="blank _8"> </span>manutenção <span class="blank _3"> </span>do <span class="blank _8"> </span>julgamento <span class="blank _3"> </span>no <span class="blank _8"> </span>STJ <span class="blank _8"> </span>tem <span class="blank _8"> </span>por <span class="blank _3"> </span>objetivo <span class="blank _8"> </span>preservar <span class="blank _3"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>isenção <span class="blank _8"> </span>(imparcialidade <span class="blank _3"> </span>e </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y32 ff6 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">independência<span class="blank _0"></span>) do órgão julgador<span class="blank _0"></span>. </div><div class="t m0 xf h2 y33 ff7 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls4 ws3">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="blank _0"></span><span class="ls5 ws5">. <span class="ls1">Co<span class="blank _b"></span>rt<span class="blank _b"></span>e E<span class="blank _b"></span>sp<span class="blank _0"></span>ec<span class="blank _b"></span>ial<span class="blank _b"></span>.<span class="ff1"> <span class="blank _0"></span><span class="ff7">QO<span class="blank _b"></span> n<span class="blank _0"></span>a <span class="blank _0"></span>A<span class="blank _0"></span>Pn<span class="blank _b"></span> 8<span class="blank _0"></span>78<span class="blank _b"></span>-D<span class="blank _0"></span>F,<span class="blank _b"></span> R<span class="blank _0"></span>el<span class="blank _b"></span>. <span class="blank _0"></span>Mi<span class="blank _0"></span>n.<span class="blank _b"></span> B<span class="blank _0"></span>en<span class="blank _b"></span>ed<span class="blank _0"></span>it<span class="blank _b"></span>o <span class="blank _0"></span>G<span class="blank _0"></span>on<span class="blank _b"></span>çal<span class="blank _b"></span>ve<span class="blank _b"></span>s, <span class="blank _0"></span>j<span class="blank _0"></span>ul<span class="blank _b"></span>gad<span class="blank _b"></span>o <span class="blank _0"></span>e<span class="blank _0"></span>m <span class="blank _0"></span>21<span class="blank _b"></span>/1<span class="blank _b"></span>1/<span class="blank _0"></span>20<span class="blank _b"></span>18 <span class="blank _b"></span>(In<span class="blank _b"></span>fo<span class="blank _b"></span> 63<span class="blank _b"></span>9)<span class="blank _0"></span>. </span></span></span></span></span></div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yea ff1 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf7" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="7"><div class="pc pc7 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 yeb w1 he" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/5a5f0e60-95f7-466b-bd7d-79549058eda4/bg7.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y2 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x3 h3 y3 ffb fs1 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo 640-STJ (15/02/2019) <span class="ffc ws0">–</span> Márcio André Lopes Cavalcante | 1 </div><div class="t m0 x4 h4 y4 ffd fs2 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x5 h5 y5 ffe fs3 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo comentado: </div><div class="t m0 x6 h5 y6 ffe fs3 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo <span class="ls0">640</span>-STJ (</div><div class="t m1 x7 h6 y6 ffe fs4 fc1 sc0 ls1 ws1">RESUMIDO</div><div class="t m0 x8 h5 y6 ffe fs3 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">) </div><div class="t m0 x9 h2 y7 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Márcio André Lop<span class="blank _0"></span>es Cavalcante </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y8 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y9 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xa ya w3 h7"><div class="t m0 x16 h8 yb fff fs5 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws5">DIREITO CONSTITUCI<span class="blank _0"></span>ONAL </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yc ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x22 h9 yd fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">DIREITOS E GARANTIAS FUNDAMENTAIS </div><div class="t m0 x32 h9 ye fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O STJ não pode determinar que as companhias aéreas ofereçam transporte gratuito para </div><div class="t m0 x26 h9 yec fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">pessoas com deficiência com base em um exercício hermenêutico da Lei nº 8.899/94 </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yed ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe yee w4 h23"><div class="t m0 xf hb yef ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A <span class="blank _2"> </span>Lei <span class="blank _1"> </span>nº <span class="blank _2"> </span>8.899/94 <span class="blank _2"> </span>previu <span class="blank _2"> </span>que <span class="blank _1"> </span>as <span class="blank _2"> </span>pessoas <span class="blank _1"> </span>com <span class="blank _2"> </span>deficiência <span class="blank _2"> </span>possuem <span class="blank _2"> </span>direito <span class="blank _2"> </span>à <span class="blank _1"> </span>gratuidade <span class="blank _2"> </span>no </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yf0 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls17 wsb">tr<span class="ls1 ws5">ansporte <span class="blank _b"></span>coletivo <span class="blank _b"></span>interestadual.<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>Est<span class="blank _3"> </span>a <span class="blank _b"></span>Lei <span class="blank _b"></span>foi r<span class="blank _0"></span>egulamentada<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>pela P<span class="blank _0"></span>ortaria <span class="blank _b"></span>Interministerial <span class="blank _b"></span>nº<span class="blank _0"></span> </span></div><div class="t m0 xf hb ye5 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">003/200<span class="blank _0"></span>1, <span class="blank _a"> </span>que, <span class="blank _a"> </span>no <span class="blank _a"> </span>entanto, <span class="blank _9"> </span>afirmou <span class="blank _a"> </span>que <span class="blank _a"> </span>apenas <span class="blank _a"> </span>as <span class="blank _a"> </span>empresas <span class="blank _9"> </span>de <span class="blank _a"> </span>t<span class="blank _3"> </span>ransporte <span class="blank _9"> </span>rodoviário, </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y4c ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">ferroviário e aquaviário teriam o dever de oferecer essa gratuidade. Houve, assim, uma<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ye6 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">omissão quanto a<span class="blank _0"></span>o transporte aéreo.<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y4e ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O <span class="blank _0"></span>MP <span class="blank _0"></span>propôs <span class="blank _b"></span>ação civil <span class="blank _b"></span>pública na <span class="blank _b"></span>qual pretendia <span class="blank _b"></span>garantir a <span class="blank _b"></span>gratuidade também <span class="blank _b"></span>no trans<span class="blank _0"></span>porte </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ye8 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">aéreo. <span class="blank _b"></span>Ao julgar <span class="blank _b"></span>um recurso<span class="blank _0"></span> neste <span class="blank _b"></span>processo, <span class="blank _0"></span>o <span class="blank _0"></span>STJ <span class="blank _0"></span>afirmou <span class="blank _b"></span>que não <span class="blank _b"></span>poderia conceder <span class="blank _b"></span>o pedido.<span class="blank _b"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb ye9 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Isso porq<span class="blank _0"></span>ue: </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y50 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O <span class="blank _13"> </span>STJ <span class="blank _13"> </span>não <span class="blank _13"> </span>possui <span class="blank _13"> </span>competência <span class="blank _5"> </span>constitucional <span class="blank _13"> </span>para <span class="blank _13"> </span>ampliar<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _13"> </span>os <span class="blank _13"> </span>modais <span class="blank _13"> </span>de <span class="blank _13"> </span>transporte </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yf1 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">interestadual <span class="blank _2"> </span>submetidos <span class="blank _2"> </span>ao <span class="blank _1"> </span>regime <span class="blank _1"> </span>da <span class="blank _d"> </span>gratuidade <span class="blank _2"> </span>prevista <span class="blank _1"> </span>na <span class="blank _1"> </span>Lei <span class="blank _1"> </span>nº <span class="blank _1"> </span>8.899/94<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _1"> </span>e <span class="blank _1"> </span>nos <span class="blank _1"> </span>atos </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yf2 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">normativos secun<span class="blank _0"></span>dários que a <span class="blank _0"></span>regulamentam. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc yf3 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="ls1">4ª Tur<span class="blank _0"></span>ma. REsp 1.155<span class="blank _0"></span>.590-DF, Rel. Min. Mar<span class="blank _0"></span>co Buzzi, julgado e<span class="blank _0"></span>m 27/11/<span class="blank _0"></span>2018 (Info 640). </span></span></span></div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yf4 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 yf5 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xa yf6 w3 h7"><div class="t m0 x16 h8 yb fff fs5 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws5">DIREITO ADMINIST<span class="blank _0"></span>RATIVO </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h24 yf7 ffb fs9 fc0 sc0 ls16 ws5"> <span class="fff fs6 ls1 v1">RESPONSABILIDADE CIVIL DO ESTADO </span></div><div class="t m0 x6 h9 yf8 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Concessionária de rodovia não responde civilme<span class="blank _0"></span>nte por roubo e sequestro </div><div class="t m0 x2 h24 yf9 ffb fs9 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h25 yfa ff12 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Importante!!! </div></div><div class="c xe yfb w4 h26"><div class="t m0 xf hb y27 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Concessionária <span class="blank _3"> </span>de <span class="blank _8"> </span>rodovia <span class="blank _3"> </span>não <span class="blank _8"> </span>responde <span class="blank _3"> </span>por <span class="blank _8"> </span>roubo <span class="blank _3"> </span>e <span class="blank _8"> </span>sequestro <span class="blank _8"> </span>ocorridos <span class="blank _3"> </span>nas <span class="blank _8"> </span>dependência<span class="blank _0"></span>s </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y28 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">de estabelecime<span class="blank _0"></span>nto por ela mant<span class="blank _0"></span>ido para a utiliza<span class="blank _0"></span>ção de usuários. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y29 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A <span class="blank _8"> </span>segurança <span class="blank _8"> </span>que <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>concessionária <span class="blank _8"> </span>deve <span class="blank _3"> </span>fornecer <span class="blank _8"> </span>aos <span class="blank _8"> </span>usuários <span class="blank _8"> </span>diz <span class="blank _8"> </span>respeito <span class="blank _8"> </span>ao <span class="blank _8"> </span>bom <span class="blank _8"> </span>estado <span class="blank _8"> </span>de </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y2a ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">conservação e <span class="blank _7"> </span>sinalização <span class="blank _7"> </span>da rodovia. Não<span class="blank _0"></span> tem, contudo, co<span class="blank _0"></span>mo a concessio<span class="blank _b"></span>n<span class="blank _3"> </span>ária garantir<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yfc ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">segurança <span class="blank _10"> </span>privada <span class="blank _a"> </span>ao <span class="blank _10"> </span>longo <span class="blank _10"> </span>da <span class="blank _10"> </span>estrada, <span class="blank _a"> </span>mesmo <span class="blank _10"> </span>que <span class="blank _10"> </span>seja <span class="blank _a"> </span>em <span class="blank _10"> </span>postos <span class="blank _10"> </span>de <span class="blank _10"> </span>pedágio <span class="blank _10"> </span>ou <span class="blank _a"> </span>de </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yfd ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">atendimento ao<span class="blank _0"></span> usuário. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y2d ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O roubo com emprego de arma de <span class="blank _3"> </span>fogo é considerado um fato <span class="blank _3"> </span>de terceiro equiparável a força </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y2e ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">maior, que <span class="blank _3"> </span>exclui o <span class="blank _3"> </span>dever de indenizar. Trata<span class="blank _3"> </span>-se de <span class="blank _3"> </span>fato inevitável e irresistível e, <span class="blank _3"> </span>assim, gera </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yb2 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">uma impossibilidad<span class="blank _0"></span>e absoluta de não oco<span class="blank _0"></span>rrência do <span class="blank _0"></span>dano. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y30 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="ls1">3ª Tur<span class="blank _0"></span>m<span class="ls18 wsc">a.</span> REsp 1.749<span class="blank _0"></span>.941-PR, Rel. Min. Nan<span class="blank _0"></span>cy Andrighi, julgad<span class="blank _0"></span>o em 04/12/2018 (<span class="blank _0"></span>Info 640). </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xf hc yfe ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Cuidado. <span class="blank _8"> </span>O <span class="blank _6"> </span>ST<span class="blank _3"> </span>F <span class="blank _6"> </span>já <span class="blank _6"> </span>reconh<span class="blank _0"></span>eceu <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>responsab<span class="blank _0"></span>ilidade <span class="blank _8"> </span>civil <span class="blank _2"> </span>d<span class="blank _0"></span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>concessionária<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _6"> </span>que <span class="blank _6"> </span>administra <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>rodovia </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y51 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">por <span class="blank _b"></span>FURTO oc<span class="blank _0"></span>orrido <span class="blank _b"></span>em seu <span class="blank _b"></span>pátio: <span class="blank _0"></span>STF. <span class="blank _b"></span>1ª <span class="blank _0"></span>Turma. <span class="blank _b"></span>RE 598356/<span class="blank _0"></span>SP, <span class="blank _0"></span>Rel. <span class="blank _b"></span>Mi<span class="blank _3"> </span>n. <span class="blank _b"></span>Marco A<span class="blank _0"></span>urélio, <span class="blank _b"></span>julgado <span class="blank _0"></span>em<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y33 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">8/5/2018 (Info 90<span class="blank _0"></span>1). </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y1e ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf8" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="8"><div class="pc pc8 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x2 yff w5 h27" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/5a5f0e60-95f7-466b-bd7d-79549058eda4/bg8.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x14 hf y35 ffd fs7 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="ff13 fs8 ls6">Informat<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo </span></div><div class="t m0 x15 h10 y36 ff13 fs8 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">comentado </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y37 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y38 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x3 h3 y3 ffb fs1 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo 640-STJ (15/02/2019) <span class="ffc ws0">–</span> Márcio André Lopes Cavalcante<span class="ls7"> </span>| 2 </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y39 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xa y3a w3 h7"><div class="t m0 xb h8 yb fff fs5 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws5">DIREITO CIVIL </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y3b ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x9 h9 y3c fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">PROPRIEDADE INTELECTUAL </div><div class="t m0 x33 h9 y3d fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O ECAD pode fixar critério diferenciado para va<span class="blank _0"></span>loração de obras de <span class="blank _3"> </span>background </div><div class="t m0 x5 h9 y3e fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">(música de fundo) veiculadas em programas de televisão </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y3f ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y100 w4 h28"><div class="t m0 xf hb y101 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O <span class="blank _0"></span>Escritório <span class="blank _b"></span>Central de <span class="blank _b"></span>Arrecadação <span class="blank _b"></span>e Distribui<span class="blank _0"></span>ção - <span class="blank _b"></span>ECAD po<span class="blank _0"></span>de <span class="blank _0"></span>definir <span class="blank _b"></span>critérios difere<span class="blank _0"></span>nciado<span class="blank _0"></span>s </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y102 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">para distribuição de <span class="blank _3"> </span>valores de <span class="blank _3"> </span>direitos autorais de <span class="blank _3"> </span>acordo com <span class="blank _3"> </span>os diversos <span class="blank _3"> </span>tipos de <span class="blank _3"> </span>exibição </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y103 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">de <span class="blank _b"></span>músicas <span class="blank _b"></span>inseridos <span class="blank _b"></span>no <span class="blank _b"></span>contexto <span class="blank _b"></span>de <span class="blank _b"></span>obras <span class="blank _b"></span>audiovisuais, <span class="blank _b"></span>como <span class="blank _b"></span>nas <span class="blank _b"></span>chamadas <span class="blank _b"></span>músicas <span class="blank _b"></span>de <span class="blank _b"></span>fundo </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y104 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls19">(<span class="ff12 ls1 ws4">background<span class="blank _0"></span><span class="ff10 ls1a wsd">).<span class="ls1 ws5"> </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xf hc y105 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">STJ. 3ª Turma. RE<span class="blank _0"></span>sp 1331103/RJ<span class="blank _0"></span>, Rel. Min. Nancy A<span class="blank _b"></span>ndrighi, julgado em 23/04/2013. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y33 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="ls1">4ª Tur<span class="blank _0"></span>ma. REsp 1.552<span class="blank _0"></span>.227-RJ, Rel. Min. Ma<span class="blank _0"></span>ria Isabel Gallott<span class="blank _0"></span>i, julgado em 2<span class="blank _0"></span>7/11/2018 (Info 640)<span class="blank _0"></span>. </span></span></span></div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y106 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x10 h9 y107 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">SEGURO </div><div class="t m0 x34 h9 y108 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A seguradora não pode se recusar a contratar seguro com o consumidor </div><div class="t m0 x35 h9 y109 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">que tenha restrição de crédito se ele se comprometer a pagar à vista </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y10a ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y10b w4 h11"><div class="t m0 xf hb y41 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A <span class="blank _9"> </span>seguradora <span class="blank _a"> </span>não <span class="blank _9"> </span>pode <span class="blank _a"> </span>recusar <span class="blank _9"> </span>a <span class="blank _9"> </span>contratação <span class="blank _9"> </span>de <span class="blank _a"> </span>seguro <span class="blank _a"> </span>a <span class="blank _9"> </span>quem <span class="blank _a"> </span>se <span class="blank _9"> </span>disponha <span class="blank _9"> </span>a <span class="blank _a"> </span>pronto<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y31 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">pagamento <span class="blank _1"> </span>se <span class="blank _d"> </span>a <span class="blank _7"> </span>justificativa <span class="blank _1"> </span>se <span class="blank _d"> </span>basear <span class="blank _d"> </span>unicamente <span class="blank _1"> </span>n<span class="blank _3"> </span>a <span class="blank _1"> </span>restrição <span class="blank _d"> </span>financeira <span class="blank _1"> </span>do <span class="blank _d"> </span>consumidor </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y32 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">junto a órgãos <span class="blank _0"></span>de proteção ao c<span class="blank _0"></span>rédito. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y33 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">ST<span class="blank _b"></span>J.<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _c"></span>3ª <span class="blank _c"></span>Tu<span class="blank _b"></span>rm<span class="blank _0"></span>a.<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>R<span class="blank _0"></span>Es<span class="blank _b"></span>p <span class="blank _c"></span>1.5<span class="blank _b"></span>94.<span class="blank _0"></span>02<span class="blank _b"></span>4-<span class="blank _0"></span>SP<span class="blank _b"></span>, <span class="blank _c"></span>Re<span class="blank _b"></span>l. <span class="blank _c"></span>Mi<span class="blank _0"></span>n<span class="blank _0"></span>. <span class="blank _c"></span>Ri<span class="blank _b"></span>ca<span class="blank _0"></span>rd<span class="blank _b"></span>o <span class="blank _c"></span>Vil<span class="blank _0"></span>la<span class="blank _b"></span>s <span class="blank _c"></span>Bô<span class="blank _b"></span>as <span class="blank _c"></span>Cu<span class="blank _0"></span>e<span class="blank _0"></span>va<span class="blank _b"></span>, <span class="blank _c"></span>jul<span class="blank _b"></span>ga<span class="blank _0"></span>do<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>em<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _c"></span>27<span class="blank _0"></span>/1<span class="blank _b"></span>1/2<span class="blank _b"></span>01<span class="blank _b"></span>8 <span class="blank _b"></span>(<span class="blank _0"></span>In<span class="blank _b"></span>fo <span class="blank _c"></span>6<span class="blank _0"></span>40<span class="blank _b"></span>).<span class="blank _0"></span> </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y10c ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x10 h9 y10d fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">SEGURO </div><div class="t m0 x36 h9 y10e fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É abusiva cláusula prevista em seguro de acidentes pessoais que exclua complicações </div><div class="t m0 x37 h9 y10f fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">decorrentes de gravidez, parto, aborto, intoxicações alimentares, exames e tratamentos </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y110 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y111 w4 h29"><div class="t m0 xf hb y112 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>abu<span class="blank _b"></span>si<span class="blank _b"></span>va <span class="blank _b"></span>a <span class="blank _b"></span>exc<span class="blank _b"></span>lu<span class="blank _0"></span>s<span class="blank _0"></span>ão<span class="blank _b"></span> d<span class="blank _0"></span>o<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span>se<span class="blank _b"></span>gur<span class="blank _b"></span>o <span class="blank _b"></span>de<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span>a<span class="blank _0"></span>ci<span class="blank _b"></span>de<span class="blank _0"></span>nt<span class="blank _b"></span>es <span class="blank _b"></span>pe<span class="blank _b"></span>ss<span class="blank _0"></span>oa<span class="blank _b"></span>is<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>em <span class="blank _b"></span>co<span class="blank _b"></span>ntr<span class="blank _b"></span>ato<span class="blank _b"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span>de<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _b"></span>ad<span class="blank _0"></span>es<span class="blank _b"></span>ão <span class="blank _b"></span>pa<span class="blank _b"></span>ra <span class="blank _b"></span>as<span class="blank _b"></span> h<span class="blank _b"></span>ipó<span class="blank _b"></span>te<span class="blank _b"></span>ses<span class="blank _b"></span> d<span class="blank _b"></span>e:<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y113 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">a) gravidez, par<span class="blank _0"></span>to ou aborto e sua<span class="blank _0"></span>s consequênci<span class="blank _0"></span>as; </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yaa ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">b) perturbações e i<span class="blank _b"></span>n<span class="blank _3"> </span>toxicações <span class="blank _0"></span>alimentares de qual<span class="blank _0"></span>quer espécie; e <span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y31 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">c) <span class="blank _f"> </span>todas <span class="blank _f"> </span>as <span class="blank _13"> </span>intercorrências <span class="blank _f"> </span>ou <span class="blank _13"> </span>complicações <span class="blank _f"> </span>consequentes <span class="blank _13"> </span>da <span class="blank _f"> </span>realização <span class="blank _13"> </span>de <span class="blank _f"> </span>exames, </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y32 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">tratamentos cl<span class="blank _0"></span>ínicos ou cirúrgicos. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y33 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="ls1">3ª Tur<span class="blank _0"></span>ma. REsp 1.635<span class="blank _0"></span>.238-SP, Rel. Min. <span class="blank _0"></span>Nancy Andrighi, julgad<span class="blank _b"></span>o em 11/12/2018 (Info 640). </span></span></span></div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y114 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x38 h9 y115 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">CORRETAGEM </div><div class="t m0 x39 h9 y116 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É devida a comissão de corretagem ainda que o <span class="blank _0"></span>resultado da intermediação imobiliária <span class="blank _3"> </span>tenha </div><div class="t m0 x3a h9 y117 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">sido diferente do negócio que o contratante queria inicialmente celebrar </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y118 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y119 w4 h2a"><div class="t m0 xf hb y2c ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É <span class="blank _8"> </span>devida <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>comissão <span class="blank _8"> </span>de <span class="blank _6"> </span>corretagem <span class="blank _8"> </span>ainda <span class="blank _6"> </span>que <span class="blank _8"> </span>o <span class="blank _6"> </span>resultado <span class="blank _8"> </span>út<span class="blank _3"> </span>il <span class="blank _8"> </span>da <span class="blank _6"> </span>intermediação <span class="blank _8"> </span>imobiliária </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y2d ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">seja negócio de na<span class="blank _0"></span>tureza diversa da <span class="blank _0"></span>inicialmente co<span class="blank _0"></span>ntratada. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y11a ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Ex: <span class="blank _8"> </span>corretor <span class="blank _8"> </span>foi <span class="blank _8"> </span>contratado <span class="blank _8"> </span>para <span class="blank _8"> </span>procurar <span class="blank _3"> </span>um <span class="blank _6"> </span>interessado <span class="blank _8"> </span>em <span class="blank _8"> </span>comprar <span class="blank _8"> </span>o <span class="blank _8"> </span>t<span class="blank _3"> </span>erreno; <span class="blank _3"> </span>en<span class="blank _3"> </span>contro<span class="blank _0"></span>u </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y2f ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">um <span class="blank _1"> </span>interessado <span class="blank _1"> </span>em <span class="blank _1"> </span>fazer <span class="blank _2"> </span>um <span class="blank _d"> </span>contrato <span class="blank _1"> </span>de <span class="blank _1"> </span>parceria <span class="blank _1"> </span>para <span class="blank _1"> </span>loteamento <span class="blank _1"> </span>urbano; <span class="blank _1"> </span>o <span class="blank _1"> </span>contrato <span class="blank _1"> </span><span class="ls1b">de </span></div><div class="t m0 xf hb y30 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">parceria foi celebrado; mesmo o terreno não tendo sido vendido, o corretor deverá <span class="blank _3"> </span>receber a<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y31 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws4">comiss<span class="ls15 wsa">ão</span><span class="ws5"> por ter a<span class="blank _0"></span>proximado as partes, ger<span class="blank _0"></span>ando um ganho para o s<span class="blank _0"></span>eu contrata<span class="blank _0"></span>nte. </span></div><div class="t m0 xf hc y15 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="ls1">3ª Turma. <span class="blank _3"> </span>REsp 1.765.004-SP, Rel. <span class="blank _3"> </span>Min. Ricardo Villas Bôas Cueva, <span class="blank _3"> </span>Rel. Acd. <span class="blank _3"> </span>Min. Paulo <span class="blank _3"> </span>de Tarso </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xf hc y16 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Sanseverino, j<span class="blank _0"></span>ulgado em 27/11/20<span class="blank _b"></span>18<span class="blank _3"> </span> (Info 640). </div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pf9" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="9"><div class="pc pc9 w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x2 y11b w5 h2b" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/5a5f0e60-95f7-466b-bd7d-79549058eda4/bg9.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x14 hf y35 ffd fs7 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="ff13 fs8 ls6">Informat<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo </span></div><div class="t m0 x15 h10 y36 ff13 fs8 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">comentado </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y37 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y38 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x3 h3 y3 ffb fs1 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo 640-STJ (15/02/2019) <span class="ffc ws0">–</span> Márcio André Lopes Cavalcante<span class="ls7"> </span>| 3 </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y39 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x9 h9 y11c fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">CONTRATO DE TRANSPORTE </div><div class="t m0 x3b h9 y11d fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls0 ws5">O <span class="ls1">Vale-Pedágio e a dobra do frete, previstos na L<span class="blank _0"></span>ei nº 10.209/2001, <span class="blank _3"> </span>não estão sujeitos à </span></div><div class="t m0 x18 h9 y11e fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">supressio nem podem ser reduzidos com base no art. 412 do CC </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y11f ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y120 w4 h2c"><div class="t m0 xf hb y121 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A <span class="blank _2"> </span>Lei <span class="blank _6"> </span>nº <span class="blank _2"> </span>10.2<span class="blank _0"></span>09/2001<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _2"> </span>estabelece <span class="blank _6"> </span>que <span class="blank _2"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>e<span class="blank _3"> </span>mpres<span class="blank _0"></span>a <span class="blank _2"> </span>que <span class="blank _6"> </span>contratar <span class="blank _6"> </span>uma <span class="blank _2"> </span>empresa <span class="blank _6"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>transport<span class="blank _0"></span>e </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y122 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">rodoviário <span class="blank _b"></span>deverá pa<span class="blank _0"></span>gar, <span class="blank _b"></span>de forma <span class="blank _b"></span>antecipada <span class="blank _b"></span>e separada<span class="blank _0"></span>, <span class="blank _0"></span>os <span class="blank _0"></span>valores <span class="blank _b"></span>que <span class="blank _0"></span>o <span class="blank _0"></span>transportador <span class="blank _b"></span>terá </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y123 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">que arcar c<span class="blank _0"></span>om os pedágios nas estrada<span class="blank _0"></span>s. Esse pagamento é cha<span class="blank _b"></span>mado de Vale-Pedágio. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y92 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O art. <span class="blank _3"> </span>8º da <span class="blank _3"> </span>Lei <span class="blank _3"> </span>prevê <span class="blank _3"> </span>que o <span class="blank _3"> </span>embarcador/co<span class="blank _0"></span>ntratante que <span class="blank _3"> </span>não pagar <span class="blank _3"> </span>ao transportador o <span class="blank _3"> </span>valor </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y93 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">do <span class="blank _8"> </span>pedágio <span class="blank _6"> </span>estará <span class="blank _6"> </span>sujeito <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>uma <span class="blank _6"> </span>multa <span class="blank _8"> </span>equivalente <span class="blank _6"> </span>ao <span class="blank _6"> </span>dobro <span class="blank _8"> </span>do <span class="blank _6"> </span>valor <span class="blank _6"> </span>do <span class="blank _6"> </span>frete. <span class="blank _8"> </span>Essa <span class="blank _6"> </span>multa <span class="blank _6"> </span>é </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y94 ff14 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">conhecida como <span class="blank _0"></span>“dobra do frete”. <span class="ff10"> </span></div><div class="t m0 xf hb y95 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A <span class="blank _2"> </span>obrigação<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _2"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>pagame<span class="blank _0"></span>nto <span class="blank _2"> </span>antecipado <span class="blank _6"> </span>do <span class="blank _2"> </span>Vale-Pedágio <span class="blank _2"> </span>previsto <span class="blank _6"> </span>pela <span class="blank _2"> </span>Lei <span class="blank _2"> </span>nº <span class="blank _2"> </span>10.209<span class="blank _0"></span>/2001 <span class="blank _2"> </span>é </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y124 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">norma co<span class="blank _0"></span>gente <span class="blank _7"> </span>que <span class="blank _7"> </span>não <span class="blank _7"> </span>admite o <span class="blank _d"> </span>in<span class="blank _3"> </span>stituto <span class="blank _d"> </span>da <span class="ff12 ws4">supressio</span>. <span class="blank _7"> </span>Isso <span class="blank _7"> </span>significa <span class="blank _d"> </span>que, mesmo <span class="blank _7"> </span>que <span class="blank _7"> </span>o </div><div class="t m0 xf hb yb9 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">transportador <span class="blank _b"></span>não tenh<span class="blank _0"></span>a <span class="blank _0"></span>cobrado <span class="blank _b"></span>o pagamento <span class="blank _b"></span>antecipado <span class="blank _0"></span>do <span class="blank _0"></span>pedágio <span class="blank _b"></span>durante lo<span class="blank _0"></span>ngo <span class="blank _0"></span>período, </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y11 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">ele não perde o direi<span class="blank _0"></span>to de exigir essa <span class="blank _0"></span>quantia. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y125 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Além <span class="blank _6"> </span>disso, <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>dobra <span class="blank _6"> </span>do <span class="blank _2"> </span>frete <span class="blank _6"> </span>(art. <span class="blank _6"> </span>8º <span class="blank _6"> </span>da <span class="blank _6"> </span>Lei <span class="blank _2"> </span>nº <span class="blank _8"> </span>10.209/2001<span class="ls1a">) <span class="blank _8"> </span></span>é <span class="blank _2"> </span>uma <span class="blank _8"> </span>sanção <span class="blank _6"> </span>legal, <span class="blank _6"> </span>de <span class="blank _6"> </span>caráter </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y41 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">especial, razão <span class="blank _3"> </span>pela <span class="blank _3"> </span>qual <span class="blank _3"> </span>não <span class="blank _3"> </span>é <span class="blank _3"> </span>possível <span class="blank _3"> </span>a <span class="blank _3"> </span>convenção das <span class="blank _3"> </span>partes <span class="blank _3"> </span>para <span class="blank _3"> </span>lhe <span class="blank _3"> </span>alterar <span class="blank _3"> </span>o <span class="blank _3"> </span>conteúdo e </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y31 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">também não é pos<span class="blank _0"></span>sível a sua r<span class="blank _0"></span>edução com bas<span class="blank _0"></span>e no art. 412 do<span class="blank _0"></span> CC. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y15 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="blank _0"></span><span class="ls1">3ª <span class="blank _0"></span>Turma. <span class="blank _b"></span>REsp 1.694<span class="blank _b"></span>.324<span class="blank _3"> </span>-SP, <span class="blank _0"></span>Rel. <span class="blank _b"></span>Min. Nancy <span class="blank _b"></span>Andrighi, R<span class="blank _0"></span>el. Acd. <span class="blank _b"></span>Min. Mo<span class="blank _0"></span>ura Ribe<span class="blank _b"></span>i<span class="blank _3"> </span>ro, j<span class="blank _0"></span>ulgado <span class="blank _0"></span>em </span></span></span></div><div class="t m0 xf hc y16 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">27/11/2018 (Inf<span class="blank _0"></span>o 640). </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y126 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2f h9 y127 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">SISTEMA FINANCEIRO DE HABITAÇÃO </div><div class="t m0 x1b h9 y128 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É possível a adjudicação direta do imóvel ao credor hipotecário que oferece o preço da </div><div class="t m0 x3c h9 y76 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">avaliação judicial do bem, independentemente da realização de<span class="blank _0"></span> hasta<span class="blank _3"> </span> pública </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y129 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y12a w4 h17"><div class="t m0 xf hb y41 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Em <span class="blank _b"></span>ação <span class="blank _0"></span>de <span class="blank _b"></span>execução <span class="blank _0"></span>hipotecária, <span class="blank _b"></span>o <span class="blank _b"></span>credor <span class="blank _b"></span>hipot<span class="blank _3"> </span>ecário <span class="blank _b"></span>pode <span class="blank _b"></span>requerer <span class="blank _0"></span>a <span class="blank _b"></span>adjudicação <span class="blank _b"></span>do imóv<span class="blank _0"></span>el </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y31 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">penhorado <span class="blank _3"> </span>pelo <span class="blank _3"> </span>valor <span class="blank _3"> </span>constante <span class="blank _8"> </span>do <span class="blank _3"> </span>laudo <span class="blank _3"> </span>de <span class="blank _8"> </span>avaliação, in<span class="blank _3"> </span>dependentem<span class="blank _0"></span>ente <span class="blank _3"> </span>d<span class="blank _3"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>realização de </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y32 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">hasta pública. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y16 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="ls1">3ª Tur<span class="blank _0"></span>ma. REsp 1.721<span class="blank _0"></span>.731-SP, Rel. Min. <span class="blank _0"></span>Nancy Andrighi, julgad<span class="blank _b"></span>o em 27/11/2018 (Info 640). </span></span></span></div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y12b ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x3d h9 y12c fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">ALIMENTOS </div><div class="t m0 x12 h9 y12d fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É admissível o uso da técnica executiva de desconto em folha de dívida de natureza alime<span class="blank _0"></span>ntar </div><div class="t m0 x3e h9 y12e fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">ainda que haja anterior penhora de bens do devedor </div><div class="t m0 x2 h24 y12f ffb fs9 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y130 w4 h2d"><div class="t m0 xf hb y31 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É admissível o uso<span class="blank _0"></span> da técnica execu<span class="blank _0"></span>tiva de desconto em fo<span class="blank _0"></span>lha de dívida <span class="blank _0"></span>de natureza alime<span class="blank _0"></span>ntar </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y32 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">ainda que haja a<span class="blank _0"></span>nterior penhora <span class="blank _0"></span>de bens do dev<span class="blank _0"></span>edor. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y33 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="ls1">3ª Tur<span class="blank _0"></span>ma. REsp 1.733<span class="blank _0"></span>.697-RS, Rel. Min. <span class="blank _0"></span>Nancy Andrighi, julgad<span class="blank _b"></span>o em 11/12/2018 (Info 640). </span></span></span></div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y131 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x3 h9 y132 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">CURATELA </div><div class="t m0 x3f h9 y133 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O rol de legitimados para propor a ação de levan<span class="blank _0"></span>tamento de cura<span class="blank _3"> </span>tela, </div><div class="t m0 x40 h9 y134 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">previsto no art. 756, § 1º do CPC/2015, não é taxativo </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y135 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xe y136 w4 h2e"><div class="t m0 xf hb yb3 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O <span class="blank _3"> </span>motivo <span class="blank _3"> </span>que <span class="blank _3"> </span>levou <span class="blank _3"> </span>o <span class="blank _3"> </span>juiz <span class="blank _3"> </span>a <span class="blank _3"> </span>decretar <span class="blank _3"> </span>a <span class="blank _3"> </span>curatela <span class="blank _3"> </span>pode <span class="blank _3"> </span>deixar <span class="blank _3"> </span>de <span class="blank _3"> </span>existir.<span class="blank _3"> </span> <span class="blank _3"> </span>Neste <span class="blank _3"> </span>caso, <span class="blank _3"> </span>deverá <span class="blank _3"> </span>ser </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y137 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">ajuizada uma ação par<span class="blank _0"></span>a levantamento da c<span class="blank _0"></span>uratel<span class="blank _0"></span>a. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y32 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">É o que prevê o<span class="blank _0"></span> art. 756<span class="blank _0"></span> do Código Civil: </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y16 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Art. 756.<span class="blank _0"></span> Levantar-<span class="ls1c wse">se</span>-á a curatela q<span class="blank _0"></span>uando cessar<span class="blank _0"></span> a causa que a <span class="blank _0"></span>determinou. </div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div> <div id="pfa" class="pf w0 h0" data-page-no="a"><div class="pc pca w0 h0"><img fetchpriority="low" loading="lazy" class="bi x0 y138 w6 h2f" alt src="https://files.passeidireto.com/5a5f0e60-95f7-466b-bd7d-79549058eda4/bga.png" alt="Pré-visualização de imagem de arquivo"><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x14 hf y35 ffd fs7 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="ff13 fs8 ls6">Informat<span class="blank _0"></span>ivo </span></div><div class="t m0 x15 h10 y36 ff13 fs8 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">comentado </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y37 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y38 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x3 h3 y3 ffb fs1 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Informativo 640-STJ (15/02/2019) <span class="ffc ws0">–</span> Márcio André Lopes Cavalcante<span class="ls7"> </span>| 4 </div></div><div class="c xe y139 w4 h30"><div class="t m0 xf hb y13a ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">§ <span class="blank _6"> </span>1º <span class="blank _2"> </span>O <span class="blank _6"> </span>pedido <span class="blank _6"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>le<span class="blank _0"></span>vantamento <span class="blank _8"> </span>da <span class="blank _2"> </span>curatela<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _6"> </span>poderá <span class="blank _6"> </span>ser <span class="blank _2"> </span>feito <span class="blank _6"> </span>pelo <span class="blank _6"> </span>interdito, <span class="blank _6"> </span>pelo <span class="blank _6"> </span>curador <span class="blank _6"> </span>ou </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y8f ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">pelo Ministério Púb<span class="blank _0"></span>lico e será apensado <span class="blank _0"></span>aos auto<span class="blank _0"></span>s da interdição. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y13b ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">O <span class="blank _3"> </span>rol <span class="blank _8"> </span>de <span class="blank _3"> </span>legitimados <span class="blank _8"> </span>para <span class="blank _3"> </span>propor <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>ação <span class="blank _3"> </span>de <span class="blank _8"> </span>levantamento <span class="blank _3"> </span>de <span class="blank _3"> </span>curatela, <span class="blank _3"> </span>previsto <span class="blank _8"> </span>no <span class="blank _3"> </span>art. <span class="blank _8"> </span>756, <span class="blank _3"> </span>§ </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y13c ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">1º do CPC/2<span class="blank _0"></span>015, não é taxativo. </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y13d ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Exemplo: <span class="blank _8"> </span><span class="ff14">João <span class="blank _8"> </span>foi <span class="blank _8"> </span>atropelado <span class="blank _3"> </span>por <span class="blank _6"> </span>um <span class="blank _8"> </span>veículo <span class="blank _3"> </span>conduzido <span class="blank _8"> </span>por <span class="blank _8"> </span>funcionário <span class="blank _8"> </span>da <span class="blank _8"> </span>empresa <span class="blank _8"> </span>“X”.</span> <span class="blank _6"> </span>E<span class="blank _0"></span>m </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y13e ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">razão <span class="blank _2"> </span>das <span class="blank _2"> </span>sequelas <span class="blank _2"> </span>sofridas,<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _2"> </span>João <span class="blank _2"> </span>foi <span class="blank _2"> </span>interditado. <span class="blank _2"> </span>Em <span class="blank _2"> </span>ação <span class="blank _2"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>indenização<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _2"> </span>movida <span class="blank _1"> </span>por <span class="blank _2"> </span>João<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y13f ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">contra <span class="blank _10"> </span>a <span class="blank _10"> </span>empresa,<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _10"> </span>a <span class="blank _10"> </span>ré <span class="blank _10"> </span>foi <span class="blank _10"> </span>condenada <span class="blank _a"> </span>a <span class="blank _10"> </span>pagar <span class="blank _10"> </span>pensão <span class="blank _a"> </span>mensal <span class="blank _10"> </span>vitalícia <span class="blank _a"> </span>em <span class="blank _4"> </span>v<span class="blank _0"></span>irtude <span class="blank _10"> </span>de,<span class="blank _b"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y140 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">supostamente, <span class="blank _b"></span>o autor <span class="blank _b"></span>não <span class="blank _0"></span>poder <span class="blank _b"></span>mais trabalhar<span class="blank _0"></span>. <span class="ff14">P<span class="blank _0"></span>assados <span class="blank _b"></span>alguns anos, <span class="blank _b"></span>a empresa <span class="blank _b"></span>“X” ajuizo<span class="blank _0"></span>u </span></div><div class="t m0 xf hb y141 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">ação de <span class="blank _8"> </span>levantamen<span class="blank _0"></span>to <span class="blank _3"> </span>da curatela <span class="blank _3"> </span>em <span class="blank _8"> </span>face de <span class="blank _3"> </span>João <span class="blank _3"> </span>ao <span class="blank _3"> </span>fundamento d<span class="blank _3"> </span>e <span class="blank _3"> </span>que <span class="blank _3"> </span>há <span class="blank _3"> </span>prova, <span class="blank _3"> </span>posterior </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y142 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">à <span class="blank _2"> </span>sentença <span class="blank _6"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>interdiçã<span class="blank _b"></span>o, <span class="blank _2"> </span>que <span class="blank _2"> </span>atestaria <span class="blank _6"> </span>que <span class="blank _2"> </span>o <span class="blank _6"> </span>interdito <span class="blank _2"> </span>não <span class="blank _6"> </span>possui <span class="blank _2"> </span>mais <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _2"> </span>enfermidade <span class="blank _6"> </span>que </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y143 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">justificou a <span class="blank _3"> </span>sua interdição. Por <span class="blank _3"> </span>entender <span class="blank _3"> </span>que existem <span class="blank _3"> </span>elementos probató<span class="blank _0"></span>rios suficientes <span class="blank _3"> </span>para </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y99 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">demonstrar <span class="blank _0"></span>que o <span class="blank _b"></span>in<span class="blank _3"> </span>terdito <span class="blank _0"></span>não possui <span class="blank _b"></span>mais a patolo<span class="blank _0"></span>gia que <span class="blank _0"></span>resultou e<span class="blank _0"></span>m sua <span class="blank _b"></span>in<span class="blank _3"> </span>terdição, <span class="blank _0"></span>o que </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y9a ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">poderia <span class="blank _8"> </span>gerar <span class="blank _8"> </span>também <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>cessação <span class="blank _3"> </span>da <span class="blank _6"> </span>pensão <span class="blank _8"> </span>vitalícia, <span class="blank _8"> </span>o <span class="blank _8"> </span>STJ <span class="blank _6"> </span>concluiu <span class="blank _8"> </span>que <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>empresa, <span class="blank _8"> </span>mesmo </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y42 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">não <span class="blank _3"> </span>estando n<span class="blank _3"> </span>o <span class="blank _3"> </span>rol do <span class="blank _3"> </span>art. <span class="blank _3"> </span>756, <span class="blank _3"> </span>§ <span class="blank _3"> </span>1º <span class="blank _8"> </span>do <span class="blank _3"> </span>CPC/2015, possui <span class="blank _3"> </span>legitimidade <span class="blank _3"> </span>para <span class="blank _3"> </span>o <span class="blank _3"> </span>ajuizamento <span class="blank _3"> </span>da </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y9c ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">ação de levan<span class="blank _0"></span>tamento da curatela. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y16 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="ls1">3ª Tur<span class="blank _0"></span>ma. REsp 1.735<span class="blank _0"></span>.668-MT, Rel. Min. Nan<span class="blank _0"></span>cy Andrighi, julgad<span class="blank _0"></span>o em 11/12/2018 (<span class="blank _0"></span>Info 640). </span></span></span></div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y144 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y145 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div><div class="c xa y146 w3 h1e"><div class="t m0 x41 h8 ybd fff fs5 fc2 sc0 ls1 ws5">DIREITO EMPRESARI<span class="blank _0"></span>AL </div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y147 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x21 h9 y148 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">TÍTULOS DE CRÉDITO </div><div class="t m0 x42 h9 y149 fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Não é possível a oposição de exceções pessoais à empresa de factoring </div><div class="t m0 x43 h9 y14a fff fs6 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">que comprou duplicata mercantil com aceite </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y14b ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h25 y14c ff12 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Importante!!! </div><div class="t m0 x2 h25 y14d ff12 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Atualize o Info 564-ST<span class="blank _0"></span>J </div><div class="t m0 x2 h25 y14e ff12 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">Mudança de entendi<span class="blank _b"></span>m<span class="blank _3"> </span>ento! </div></div><div class="c xe y14f w4 h31"><div class="t m0 xf hb y125 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">A <span class="blank _8"> </span>duplicata <span class="blank _3"> </span>mercantil, <span class="blank _3"> </span>apesar <span class="blank _8"> </span>de <span class="blank _8"> </span>causal <span class="blank _8"> </span>no <span class="blank _8"> </span>momento <span class="blank _3"> </span>da <span class="blank _8"> </span>emissão, <span class="blank _3"> </span>com <span class="blank _8"> </span>o <span class="blank _8"> </span>aceite <span class="blank _8"> </span>e <span class="blank _8"> </span>a <span class="blank _8"> </span>circulação<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y41 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">adquire abstração e <span class="blank _3"> </span>autonomia, desvinculando-se do negócio <span class="blank _3"> </span>jurídico subjacente, impedindo<span class="blank _0"></span> </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y31 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">a <span class="blank _2"> </span>oposição <span class="blank _6"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>exceções <span class="blank _2"> </span>pessoais <span class="blank _6"> </span>a <span class="blank _2"> </span>terceiros <span class="blank _2"> </span>endossatários<span class="blank _0"></span> <span class="blank _2"> </span>de <span class="blank _2"> </span>boa-fé, <span class="blank _2"> </span>como <span class="blank _2"> </span>a <span class="blank _6"> </span>ausência <span class="blank _2"> </span>ou <span class="blank _2"> </span>a </div><div class="t m0 xf hb y32 ff10 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5">interrupção da pr<span class="blank _0"></span>estação de serviços<span class="blank _0"></span> ou a entrega das mer<span class="blank _0"></span>cadorias. </div><div class="t m0 xf hc y16 ff11 fs0 fc0 sc0 ls9 ws6">ST<span class="ls1 ws4">J<span class="lsa ws5">. <span class="blank _b"></span><span class="ls8">2<span class="lsb">ª <span class="ls1">Seção. <span class="blank _b"></span>EREsp 1<span class="blank _0"></span>.439.749-RS, <span class="blank _b"></span>Rel. Min. <span class="blank _b"></span>Maria <span class="blank _0"></span>Isabel <span class="blank _b"></span>Gallotti, j<span class="blank _0"></span>ulgado <span class="blank _b"></span>em 28/11/2<span class="blank _b"></span>018<span class="blank _3"> </span> (In<span class="blank _0"></span>fo <span class="blank _0"></span>640).<span class="blank _0"></span> </span></span></span></span></span></div></div><div class="c x1 y1 w2 h0"><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y150 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y151 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y152 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y153 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y154 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y155 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y156 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y157 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y158 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y159 ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y15a ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y15b ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y15c ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y15d ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div><div class="t m0 x2 h2 y15e ffb fs0 fc0 sc0 ls1 ws5"> </div></div></div><div class="pi" data-data="{"ctm":[1.000000,0.000000,0.000000,1.000000,0.000000,0.000000]}"></div></div>
Compartilhar