Logo Passei Direto
Buscar

MacCarthy e Fernandes 2000

Ferramentas de estudo

Material
páginas com resultados encontrados.
páginas com resultados encontrados.

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Prévia do material em texto

<p>PRODUCTION PLANNING & CONTROL, 2000, 11, NO. 5, 481-496 A multi-dimensional classification of production systems for the design and selection of production planning and control systems BART L. MACCARTHY and FLAVIO C. F. FERNANDES Keywords production systems, classification, production of the production planning and control area: it tends to inter- planning and control, analysis and design of production systems face with all functional areas of the An important objective of the classification system proposed here is to provide a tool to assist in undertaking this difficult task. Real production Abstract. A primary requirement for improved understanding systems are becoming more hybrid in order to be able to cope of the management of production systems is an appropriate with change. We show that our classification can successfully classification of such systems. This paper proposes a classifica- deal with such systems. tion that facilitates a better understanding of real production systems. It combines all the essential features, e.g. the flow of materials with new classification perspectives with respect to 1. Introduction response time, repetitiveness and work organization. As much previous work has influenced the approach proposed here, the paper also presents a review of relevant literature. The classifi- Scientific knowledge is based on classification. It has cation has four groups of characteristics, comprising eight been asserted for instance that expert systems are, in gen- dimensions of descriptors, encompassing 12 variables. Choosing eral, classification systems (Jain 1988). It is not surprising or designing an appropriate production planning and control therefore that a classification of classifications has been system (PPCS) is a difficult task due to the integrative character given. Good (1965) proposed the following classes based Authors: B. L. MacCarthy, Division of Maufacturing Engineering and Operations Management, University of Nottingham, University Park, Nottingham NG7 2RD, UK, and F. C. F. Fernandes, Department of Production Engineering at Federal University of São Carlos, via Washington Luiz, KM 235-13565-905, São Carlos, SP, Brazil. BART MACCARTHY is a Senior Lecturer in the Division of Manufacturing Engineering and Operations Management at the University of Nottingham. Prior to his appointment in 1987 he had substantial experience in research and management in manufacturing industry including the engineering, textiles and clothing sectors. He has been Vice-Dean of the Faculty of Engineering for 3 years and was acting Head of Division during the academic year 1996/1997. His research spans systems analysis, modelling, optimization, and simulation in manufacturing, operations and logis- tics. He has researched and published widely on decision support for planning and Current research projects include the analysis and modelling of responsiveness in order fulfillment processes, statistical process control for performance measurement in scheduling and the modelling of supply chains in the public sector. FLAVIO C. F. FERNANDES has been an Assistant Professor at the Federal University of São Carlos in Brazil since 1991. He has authored more than 30 papers on production planning and control and operations research, and refereed for several academic and professional journals. During 1988 he has been a visiting scholar in the Division of Manufacturing Engineering and Operations Management of the University of Nottingham in the UK. One of his principal current interests is how to reduce the gap between theory and practice in the production planning and control Production Planning & Control ISSN 0953-7287 print/ISSN 1366 5871 online 2000 Taylor & Francis Ltd</p><p>482 B. L. MacCarthy and F. C. F. Fernandes on the purposes of producing classifications: (i) for men- classifications of production subsystems in 2.2. In section tal clarification and communication; (ii) for discovering 2.3 we highlight the limitations of existing classifications, new fields for research; (iii) for planning an organiza- especially from the perspective of PPCS. In particular we tional structure or machine; (iv) as a check list; (v) for outline the major deficiencies that need to be addressed fun. The classification we propose in this paper falls prin- with respect to contemporary manufacturing enterprises cipally into the third group but, as our classification in section 2.4. argues a new point of view, it is also useful for mental clarification and communication. Burbidge (1985) noted that when an engineer designs a 2.1. A review of production system classification machine, laws of physics and metallurgy help to produce an efficient design, but there is not a set of scientific laws 2.1.1. Pioneering classifications to help a production engineer faced with the problem of designing an efficient production system. We contend The pioneering classifications are well known. Mallick that this situation has not changed significantly in the and Gaudreau (1951) identified three types of produc- intervening years. One of the reasons for this is that tion: (i) continuous process (with disintegration, e.g. there is not an appropriate classification of real produc- petrol refining; or with integration, e.g. synthetic rubber tion systems. Existing classifications are oversimplified, processing); (ii) mass production; and (iii) intermittent only consider a limited number of aspects or take a spe- process. Wild (1971) splits the last type, names some of cific perspective. These classifications tend to be of little the classes differently and presents the following similar or limited value for analysing complex real production classification: (i) process manufacture; (ii) mass produc- systems or for aiding operations managers in selecting or tion; (iii) batch production; (iv) jobbing manufacture designing appropriate production planning and control (unitary production). Many textbooks have followed systems (PPCSs). Selecting or designing an appropriate this type of scheme. PPCS is a difficult task due to the integrative character of Burbidge (1962) defined the following production the production planning and control function: it tends to types: (i) line production [batch quantity (BQ): 1; type interface with all functional areas of the enterprise. A key of flow (TF): line]; (ii) batch production (BQ: more than aspect of designing or selecting an effective PPCS is the 1; TF: functional); (iii) jobbing production (BQ: same as ability to classify production systems. This paper focuses order quantity, generally small; TF: functional); (iv) pro- on this area, as we believe it constitutes a significant gap cess batch production (BQ: more than 1; TF: line); (v) between theory and practice in operations management. process jobbing production (BQ: same as order quantity, It would be pretentious to propose a totally watertight generally small; TF: line). The following types of layout classification. Moreover, any such claim is likely to be were presented: (i) functional layout; (ii) group layout; easily contradictable. In practice any classification is a and (iii) line layout. Burbidge (1971), relating these types trade-off between the level of detail needed for usefulness of layout and some characteristics of production control, and the level of aggregation desirable for usability. We defines seven types of production systems: (i) line produc- believe our classification here will be a significant con- tion; (iii) line batch production; (iii) group batch produc- tribution for understanding complex real production tion; (iv) functional batch production; (v) line jobbing systems, and for aiding design or selection of production production; (vi) group jobbing production; (vii) func- planning and control systems in practice. tional jobbing production. This paper has been influenced by much previous Insufficient attention has been given to empirical data work. Therefore, a literature survey is presented in sec- on real production systems. Woodward (1965, 1980) con- tion 2. The multi-dimensional classification is presented ducted research on manufacturing firms in a region in the in section 3. Section 4 shows how to apply the approach. UK. From information collected from 92 firms their pro- The final section presents the conclusions. duction systems were then classified into 11 categories: (i) production of units to requirements; (ii) production of prototypes; (iii) fabrication of large equipment in stages; 2 Review of literature on the classification of (iv) production of small batches to customers' orders; (v) production systems production of large batches; (vi) production of customers' large batches on assembly lines; (vii) mass production; Here we survey the most important literature directly (viii) intermittent production of chemicals in multi-pur- relevant to the aim of this paper. We have selected refer- pose plant; (ix) continuous flow production of liquids, ences that are illustrative of approaches taken to the gases and crystalline substances; (x) production of stan- subject. We present a review of classifications of produc- dardized components in large batches subsequently tion systems in section 2.1 and a fairly brief review of assembled diversely; (xi) process production of crystalline</p><p>Multi-dimensional classification of production systems 483 substances, subsequently prepared for sale by standard- equipment being linked by a material flow and an infor- ized production methods. Eight firms did not fit any of mation flow. He presented two equivalent classifications the categories, a further four were extremely mixed and on the basis of features of use-a parallel classification the other two were in transition. and a morphological block The classification of Conway et al. (1967) should also Schmidt et al. (1985) proposed classes derived from the be noted as it is used particularly in operational research: relationship between task divisibility, routing restrictions (i) single machine; (ii) parallel machines; (iii) flow-shop; and production rate uniformity. Frizelle (1989) presents and (iv) job-shop. As noted by Botta et al. (1997), this a categorization for plants by means of three letters was expanded by Lenstra to include hybrid organizations and T) that resemble the 'shape' of the plant. The 'V characterized by parallel machines at any processing plant' 'is characterized by few raw materials subdividing stage. into many finished products'. The 'A plant' presents 'many raw materials being assembled into few finished products'. The 'T plant' has a number of components 2.1.2. Classifications derived by attributes that 'can be assembled in a multiplicity of ways'. Sipper and Shapira (1989) classify production systems Here we consider classifications based on attributes in accordance with the inventory control policy as: (i) that are perceived as important in production systems pure WIP system; (ii) modified WIP system (planned or manufacturing enterprises more generally. Johnson to partly satisfy expected shortages); (iii) modified JIT and Montgomery (1974) classify production systems system (without any intermediate buffer stock and lots based on the types of products and processes as follows. greater than one); and (iv) pure JIT system (unitary (i) Continuous system: few families of similar products lots). produced on a large scale. (ii) Intermittent system: fre- In order to clarify the meaning of repetitive and inter- quent changes in the production stages from one product to another, as a consequence of the large variety of man- mittent manufacturing, De Toni and Panizzolo (1992) ufactured items. They identify two subclasses: (a) inter- define six categories of manufacturing systems: (i) indi- mittent flow-shop system: the flow pattern of all items is vidual [type of plant (TP): yards]; (ii) unique (TP: the same; intermittent job-shop system: items do not laboratories); (iii) intermittent (TP: job-shops and have the same flow pattern. (iii) Large project system: cells); (iv) discontinuous (TP: batch plants); (v) repeti- products are complex and special, and in many cases, are tive (TP: discrete lines); and (vi) continuous (TP: process produced in unitary quantities. They also consider a lines). The classes were obtained by combining classifica- fourth the pure stock system-where items tion of manufacturing systems, production volume and are bought, warehoused, distributed and sold, without how the product is produced. a processing phase. Wild (1995) in his well-known textbook first classifies Observing that cellular manufacturing is intermediate the operational system by function (manufacture, trans- in terms of application between the job-shop and the port, supply and service), and then by structure. Wild flow-shop, Black (1983) proposed the following classifica- classifies manufacturing systems as: (i) make from stock, tion: (i) large project system; (ii) job-shop; (iii) cellular to stock, to customer; (ii) make from to stock, to manufacturing; (iv) flow-shop; (v) continuous system. customer; (iii) make from stock, direct to customer; (iv) Putnam (1983) summarized the basic differences make from source, direct to customer. between job-shop and flow-shop systems. Pyoun et al. (1995) present a classification of the realiz- Constable and New (1976) consider three characteris- able flexibility in automated manufacturing systems. tics in their approach: the structure of products (simple They identify: (i) mass production; (ii) mid-variety and or complex); the layout (in line, functional or group lay- mid-volume; and (iii) multi-variety and small-volume out); and the nature of the customers' orders (for stock or production systems. Jichao (1996) classifies production by order). Buffa and Miller (1979) adopt a classification systems for the purpose of variability detection, as: (i) with four types of inventory production systems: (i) con- simple production system (includes either a single process tinuous system for stock; (ii) continuous system by order; or independent multiple processes); and (ii) complex pro- (iii) intermittent system for stock; and (iv) intermittent duction system (many processes with close inter-relation- system by order. An intermittent system indicates that ships). Dulmet et al. (1997) propose a classification of production occurs in lots. Large projects are included processes according to the relationship between process in category (iv). and product. In their approach the degree zero object is Nys (1984) defined the technological system (TS) as the product, degree one object has direct leverage on the the part of a manufacturing system that comprises a set of product (e.g. tools and pallets) up to the degree n object, equipment for executing the technological process, the which has direct leverage on the degree n - object They</p><p>484 B. L. MacCarthy and F. C. F. Fernandes state that it is sufficient to define five levels for a description of a system; (iv) multi-product single-machine system; (v) given shop. mixed-product sequential flow line I, where all the prod- ucts have the same sequence of operations and there is no necessity for machine resetting; (vi) multi-product 2.1.3. Descriptive classifications sequential flow line where products have the same opera- tional sequence but they have to be produced separately These are classifications based on a description of the in batches; (vii) mixed-product bypass flow line I where attributes of firms or production systems in a finite num- some products are not processed in all machines and ber of classes. Ingham (1971) defined eight types of busi- equipment resetting is not necessary; (viii) mixed-prod- ness according to the relationships between marketing uct bypass flow line II, where some products are not and production. From his work, it is possible to identify processed in all machines and equipment resetting is the following classification: make to stock; customize to necessary; (ix) multi-product backtracking flow line order, i.e. the client can specify its needs in terms of where equipment resetting occurs, production is in design of certain class of products; make to order, i.e. batches and the variation in operational sequences is the items among a wide range of options are manufac- due to omitted and/or backtracked operations and the tured after the confirmation of customers' orders; make to product flow is bidirectional; and (x) multi-product order and to stock, i.e. make from orders for a wide range multidirectional backtracking system where the products of products and make for stock in the case of standard are batched, the operational sequences are SO varied that products with considerable and continual demand; make flow is multidirectional, and therefore, line production is products to order and major components to stock (this not feasible. class corresponds to what is now known as assemble to Burbidge (1970) identified four categories of group order); totally customized to order, i.e. 'the firm does not technology systems: (i) single-machine system; (ii) offer a range of products but a production service within group layout system; (iii) total group layout system the limits of its equipment'. (group layout plus classification and coding system, Barber and Hollier (1986a, 1986b) developed a classi- value analysis, variety reduction, standardization); and fication of engineering batch manufacturing companies (iv) line flow system, with characteristics between class based on questionnaire evidence. They propose six (iii) and mass production. groups according to the level of production control com- Many classifications of flexible manufacturing systems plexity. It is clear that several of the measures have been (FMS) have been presented, e.g. Groover (1980), Kusiak difficult to estimate or interpret for many firms and (1985), and Maimon and Nof (1986). Browne et al. responses were necessarily subjective. (1984) classified FMSs as: flexible machining cells, flex- McCarthy al. (1997) consider the evolution of manu- ible machining systems, flexible transfer lines and flexible facturing changes in order to show how to construct a transfer multi-lines. Stecke and Browne (1985) added the classification based on cladistics (Kitching et al. 1998) descriptor 'type of material handling system' to the pre- and give an example using the automotive sector. They vious classification, the resulting classification is based emphasize that with cladistics 'it is possible to examine on the flow pattern of parts and more specifically on the the way in which characters change within groups over routing flexibility. MacCarthy and Liu (1993) and Liu time, the direction in which characters change, and the and MacCarthy (1996) presented a classification scheme relative frequency with which they change Thus, for FMSs based on a consistent set of definitions. They organizational cladograms can be used as a tool for distinguished between: (i) a single flexible machine achieving successful organizational change'. Un- (SFM); (ii) a flexible manufacturing cell (FMC); (iii) fortunately, other sectors are not nearly as well documen- a multi-machine flexible manufacturing system ted in the literature as the automotive sector. (MMFMS); and (iv) a multi-cell flexible manufacturing system (MCFMS), and show the relationship between them. 2.2. Classifications of production subsystems Important contributions were made by Petrov (1966), 2.3. General comments on existing classifications Wild (1972) and Carrie (1975). Aneke and Carrie (1984) integrated existing classifications of simple flow lines The only significant previous paper that we have found (mass production) and group technology flow line using that has reviewed production system classifications is that six criteria. The classification reduces to: (i) single-prod- by McCarthy (1995) with 14 references. He noted that uct single-machine system; (ii) single-product multi- previous classifications, with the exception of Barber and machine system; (iii) mixed-product single-machine Hollier (1986a), were subjective and that cladistics pro-</p><p>Multi-dimensional classification of production systems 485 vided a way of making an objective classification. We Consider assembly as a process related only to would argue however that all classifications are necess- assembly lines, ignoring the fact that other types arily subjective and that the important issue is not the of installations may also carry out assembly opera- subjectivity of the classification but rather its usefulness. tions. Classification has to be subjective because it represents an author's perspective on production systems. Although Many further issues are crucial in contemporary Barber and Hollier (1986a) use a quantitative approach manufacturing organizations and need to be addressed in arriving at their classification scheme, it is also sub- in effective classifications. In the past, changes in business jective because the number of groups, the characteristics needs occurred at low speeds and simple classifications of the system may possess and the factors utilized to measure production systems were appropriate as a basis for the characteristics are all chosen. Moreover, McCarthy designing a production system. In today's environments, et al. (1997) also present an essentially subjective classifi- in order to accommodate more rapid changes, manu- cation, e.g. there are many subjective choices in the facturing systems have become more and more hybrid. chosen clade. There is a real need for a classification that treats hybrid All attempts at classification are necessarily approxi- production systems in depth. A further issue is that of mations and can always be criticized on this basis. Any work organization. Previous classifications do not con- classification involves choosing between the level of detail sider this issue but it is vital in contemporary organiza- and the level of aggregation. However, if the perspective tions. Response time and repetitiveness are also critical and the rationale are clear then the benefits of a good variables from a control viewpoint and an effective clas- classification are many. Some of the classifications dis- sification must address them. It is not sufficient just to cussed here are useful in providing insight and under- add a new variable to an existing classification. The over- standing of production systems, and some have clearly all scheme must be coherent in order to be applied effec- demonstrated their usefulness in particular domains. tively. We argue, however, that there is a real need for classifi- The classification we present in the remainder of this cations with defined objectives and areas of application. paper addresses these issues and most of the points noted Unfortunately this is not the case in many of the classifi- above in a rational way. Our principal objective is to aid cations above. the design and selection of production planning and con- trol systems. The previous classifications that were most influential to us are: Wild (1971), Burbidge (1971), Ingham (1971), Johnson and Montgomery (1974), 2.4. Developing a classification for the design or selection of Constable and New (1976), Black (1983) and Aneke PPCS and Carrie (1984). The need for improved classifications for the study, analysis, design and management of production systems 3. A multi-dimensional classification for in today's global economies is clear. For example, production systems Banerjee (1997) shows evidence that 'in spite of many millions having been spent in manufacturing planning 3.1. Overall structure and control systems no real solution to the need for greater responsiveness and flexibility has been found'. In A production system may be defined as a set of inter- the context of contemporary manufacturing organiza- related elements that are designed to act in a manner that tions, and in particular their control systems, the follow- generates final products whose commercial value exceeds ing are drawbacks that can be applied in some measure the costs of generating them. From the nature of these to the classifications discussed above. elements, two types of subsystem may be identified: physical systems and managerial systems. In the first Too general or very superficial to be of use in any the elements are physical entities (e.g. a machine) and context. in the second the elements are procedures that transform Disregard of important concepts, e.g. flow pattern. data into information in a decision process (e.g. an MRP Consideration of flow-shop characteristics only system). Naturally people design and operate both types within group technology cells. of subsystem and can therefore be considered as elements Placing the concept of job-shop in the context of of both. flow lines. Here we propose a multi-dimensional classification for Failing to distinguish between assembly lines and production systems. We identify four main groups of production lines. characteristics, comprising eight dimensions (A/B/C/D/</p><p>486 MacCarthy and F. C. F. Fernandes E/F/G/H). Where appropriate, important variables cases it may also be necessary to consider it under pro- within some of the dimensions have also been identified. cessing characteristics. The four groups and their associated dimensions arc as Table 1 illustrates the structure of the classification follows. scheme. We use the forward slash symbol (/) to separate the dimensions and the underscore symbol (_) to sepa- (1) General characterization: encompasses the follow- rate the variables. Letters and numbers are used as short- ing dimensions: enterprise size (A); response time hand notation for levels or categories of each within each (B); repetitiveness (C); and automation level (D). dimension. (2) Product characterization: encompasses the prod- uct description (E). (3) Processing characterization: encompasses the pro- cessing description (F). 3.2. Dimensions and variables of the classification system (4) Assembly characterization: encompasses the dimensions: types of assembly (G) and types of 3.2.1. General characterization work organization (H). 3.2.1.1. First dimension enterprise size The choice of these groups, dimensions and variables Several descriptors may define the size of an enterprise: was determined by our principal objective, i.e. that the turnover, number of employees, market share, etc. For classification be a valuable tool for designing or choosing the purpose of analysing the PPCS, turnover or revenue a PPC system. Our selection is influenced by our indus- are not good descriptors because either or both may be trial and academic experience in PPC. It is our view that large if, e.g. raw materials are very expensive. The more the dimensions, variables and levels represent a sufficient relevant descriptor of enterprise size is the number of set in terms of breadth, depth and level of detail to cap- employees. By the number of employees, a firm in the ture the salient characteristics of most production systems UK is considered large if it has more than 250 employees from the perspective of production planning and control. (in Brazil, more than 500) and it is considered medium In particular we have addressed the deficiencies of exist- sized if the number of employees is between 50 and 250 ing classifications with respect to the reality of contem- (between 100 and 500 in Brazil). porary manufacturing organizations. The relevance of 3.2.1.2. Second dimension (B): response time the scheme to production planning and control systems Simply stating that a production system is make-to- is discussed in section 4, and examples of applications are stock or make-to-order, etc. is of little use from the presented in section 4.2. point of view of designing modern production planning In the following section we present a description of the and control systems. Here we identify the dimension, scheme. We enlarge on the discussion where we feel it response time, which specifies how, strategically, an necessary to justify our selection of dimensions and vari- enterprise wants to attend to its customers' needs. ables. We also emphasize some parts of the classification Figure 1 illustrates three important parameters of an because of their importance and novelty. In particular industrial production system: supplier lead time (SL), we present new insights in relation to the existing classi- production lead time (PL) and distribution lead time fication literature on response time, repetitiveness level, (DL). The 'first tier' refers to the first vendor in the flow of materials and types of work organization. The supply chain. The response time (RT) of the production latter we have highlighted under assembly but in some system is the sum of SL, PL and DL. Effective manage- Table 1. The multi-dimensional classification system (MDCS). General characterization Enterprise size Response time Repetitiveness level Automation level Product characterization Product description Product structure Level of customization Number of products Processing characterization Processing description Types of buffer Type of layout Types of flow Assembly characterization Types of assembly Types of work organization</p><p>Multi-dimensional classification of production systems 487 first tier factory customers least 75% of the items are non-repetitive and to bc semi-repetitive if at least 25% of the items are repetitive and at least 25% of the items are Undoubtedly these cut-off points are somewhat arbi- inputs transformation outputs trary, but they do reflect our experience of real produc- tion systems. Using these definitions we identify a range SL PL from maximum repetitiveness (the pure continuous DL system) to the minimum repetitiveness (large-scale RT projects). Figure 1. Response time (RT) of a production system. C = PC: pure continuous system, e.g. petroleum refining. ment of response time is central to the achievement of C = SC: semi-continuous system, e.g. each pro- competitive advantage. In the extreme case where the cessing unit is a pure continuous system and there enterprise maintains stocks of all purchased materials are combinations of routes through processing units. and all final products, RT equals DL. Essentially In the process industries these are sometimes known response time is a policy decision influenced by techno- as batch processing production systems. logical and operational constraints, marketing, and C = MP: mass production system. Almost all items customers' requirements and strategy. are repetitive. We identify the following values for the parameter B of C = RP: repetitive production system. At least 75% the classification: of the items are repetitive. In the case of the metal/ mechanical parts sector, a typical RP production B = SL + PL + DL if the system produces by order; system is the cellular manufacturing system with B = DLa (P%) if the system produces for stock and flow-shop pattern of flow. the service level is equal to P%; C = SR: semi-repetitive production system. There B = DLb (P%) if the system does not produce (only are a considerable number of both repetitive and buys, stocks, sells and delivers items) and the service non-repetitive items. In the case of the mechanical level is equal to P%; parts sector, a typical SR production system is the B = PL + DL if the system produces to order but cellular manufacturing system with job-shop pat- maintains stocks of raw materials; tern of flow. B = SL + DL if the system does not produce but it C = NR: non-repetitive production system. The sells to order. majority (at least 75%) of items are not repetitive. C = LP: large projects. 3.2.1.3. Third dimension (C): repetitiveness In the report by APICS (1982), the term 3.2.1.4. Fourth dimension (D): automation level ness' is associated with the production volume of discrete The importance of the automation level for the control items: the larger the volume, the more repetitive the of production systems has been recognized for a long production system is considered to be. However, in an time. Bright (1958) demonstrated that the nature of the environment where the production volume is very low control has a close relationship with the levels of auto- due to very large processing times, e.g. one item per mation. We differentiate the following states. month, and the system only produces this item, then, in spite of the low production volume, clearly the system N. Normal automation comprises all types of must be considered to be repetitive. Repetitiveness must mechanization where the human has a high degree therefore be considered to be a function of more variables of participation at the operational or execution than just production volume. The approach we adopt is level. Here we include classical flow-shop and job- to firstly define what we mean by a repetitive product shops, cellular manufacturing systems with flow- and then define what we mean by repetitiveness of a shop characteristics (CM1); cellular manufacturing production system. We define a product to be repetitive systems with job-shop characteristics In if it consumes a significant percentage of the annual CM the flow pattern is common and in CM2 the available time of the production unit (we specify at least flow pattern is variable, allowing stages to be missed 5%). We define a production system to be repetitive if at out and allowing counter-flows (figure 2). least 75% of the items that it produces are repetitive ones. F. Flexible automation has, at the operational or We define a production system to be non-repetitive if at execution level, computer control taking the main</p><p>488 B.L. MacCarthy and F.C.F. Fernandes OVERFLOW production system with just a few additional operations. (4) Standard products: the clients do not interfere WORK WORK WORK in the product design. STATION STATION STATION Number of products: we distinguish between: a b C S: for a single product; and M: for multiple products. COUNTER-FLOW Thus, a product characterization of ML_2_M describes a production system with multiple products Figure 2. Typical material flow in the semi-repetitive cellular having multi-levels and at least some customer-defined manufacturing product design parameters. The idea of a homogeneous product range is important when we come to applying role by means of technologies, e.g. local area net- the classification. By this we mean that all products fall works and computer numerical control, and will into the same product characterization. We have seven often be accomplished by some form of FMS tech- possible sets of homogeneous products (SL_1, SL_2, nology. Here we distinguish between flow-shop flex- SL_4, ML_1, ML_2, ML_3, ML_4). The case SL_3 ible manufacturing system and job-shop (single level and 'mushroom' customization) is not poss- flexible manufacturing system ible. R. Rigid automation is the type found in transfer lines with highly specialized and dedicated auto- matic equipment. M. Mixed automation occurs where the production 3.2.3. Processing characterization system has processing units with different automa- tion levels. For example it could be composed of a 3.2.3.1. Fifth dimension (F): processing description manufacturing cell with normal level of automation This important aspect of production systems is repre- and a FMS (flexible automation). sented by three variables. Types of layout: for this variable we identify the 3.2.2. Product characterization following types of layout: FIFTH P: product layout; 3.2.2.1. Fourth dimension (E): product description F: functional layout or layout by process; We identify three variables under the product descrip- G: group layout; tion. FP: fixed position layout: the resources (human, equipment) move and not the product. Product structure: here we simply differentiate Types of buffer: for this variable we distinguish between: between the following types of buffer: SL: denoting single-level products requiring no (1) buffers before the first production stage; assembly; and (2) intermediary buffers between production ML: denoting multi-level products requiring ass- stages; embly. (3) buffers after the last production stage. Level of customization: we distinguish between the Types of flow: the third variable defines the follow- following. ing types of flow: (1) Customized products where the clients define F1: single-stage, e.g. a machining centre; all the parameters of the product design. F2: single-stage with identical machines in parallel; (2) Semi-customized products where the clients F3: single-stage with non-identical machines in define part of the product design. parallel; (3) 'Mushroom' Mather (1998) F4: unidirectional multi-stage processing (e.g. a describes this concept as delaying product dif- classical flow-shop system); ferentiation as late as possible in the production F5: unidirectional multi-stage processing that allows system. There are a number of standard com- stages to be skipped; ponents or modules that are combined in a F6: unidirectional multi-stage processing with equal large number ofways in the final stages of the machines in parallel;</p><p>Multi-dimensional classification of production systems 489 F7: unidirectional multi-stage processing with iden- tical machines in parallel but allowing stages to be skipped; F8: unidirectional multi-stage processing with non- identical machines in parallel; F9: unidirectional multi-stage processing with non- identical machines in parallel, allowing stages to be skipped; F10: multi-directional multi-stage processing (e.g. a classical job-shop); F11: multi-directional multi-stage processing with identical machines in parallel; F12: multi-directional multi-stage processing non- Figure 6. Multi-directional, multi-stage processing with non- identical machines in parallel. identical parallel machines. Obviously F12 is the most complex type of flow and all previous types are particular cases of this one. A descrip- tion, e.g. G_1-3_F5 is a processing facility with group layout and buffers before the first and after the last pro- duction stages with type of flow F5 (unidirectional multi- stage processing that allows stages to be skipped). 3.2.4. Assembly characterization G 3.2.4.1. Seventh dimension (H) We distinguish between nine types of assembly. Figure 3. Single-stage processing, the general case. Al: Mixing (e.g. chemical ingredients). A2: Assembly of a large engineering project (e.g. a large bridge) typically in a layout of fixed position A3: Assembly of heavy products (e.g. a large tool- machine) in a layout of fixed position. A4: Assembly of light products (e.g. a medical equipment) in one workstation or in one of a set of parallel workstations. A5: Paced assembly line where a conveyor never stops and the workers may move to perform their Figure 4. Uni-directional, multi-stage processing with identical tasks. parallel machines. A6: Paced assembly line where a conveyor stops for a number of units of time (cycle time) and the workers remain fixed at their individual work- stations. A7: Semi-paced assembly line where a conveyor always moves and the worker releases the product only when he finishes his tasks. A8: Unpaced assembly line where a conveyor always moves and the worker simply attaches the product to the conveyor when he finishes his tasks. A9: Unpaced assembly line where a transporter Figure 5. Uni-directional, multi-stage processing with non- only moves when a worker activates it after finishing identical parallel machines. his tasks (e.g. an overhead travelling crane).</p><p>490 H B. L. MacCarthy and F. C. F. Fernandes 3.2.4.2. Eighth dimension type of organization of the work Repetitiveness For this dimension we adopt a classification of the organization of the work based on Johnson (1991). Our Transfer Line classification is the first to encompass this aspect. Work organization may also be relevant to other types of pro- FMS 1 cesses, but from a production control perspective it has Flowshop System line I much greater impact in assembly operations. We distin- guish the following five types. (I) Individual work: the number of workers is equal to the number of workstations. In the case of as- sembly lines, the criterion for allocating each task line II to a workstation is the balancing of the whole linc. Two specific categories can be identified. (Ia) Without rotation. Each worker is fixed on a Jobshop System workstation. (Ib) With rotation. After each task has been allo- cated to a workstation, the first set of workers of the first matched set of workstations form Normal Flexible Rigid the first team and the second set of workers Automations Automation Automation form the second team, etc. Workers in the same team may rotate their workstations. Figure 7. The level of automation and the level of repetitiveness. (T) Team work. The workstations (or sublines) are pre-defined and each one is operated by a single team with several workers. The tasks carried out by cach worker of the teams are decided by balanc- systems there is a correspondence between the volume of ing of the subline. Two specific cases can be identi- production per product and variety of products, size of fied. the production system and level of repetitiveness of the (Ta) Every task is assigned to a specific work- production system. station. The relationship between volume of production Q and (Tb) Just some tasks are assigned to a specific work- variety of products P is well known. For high Q and low station. P a product layout is appropriate, for medium Q and (G) Self-managed work groups. As in the team work medium P a group layout is appropriate, and for low Q cases the workstations are first defined and then the and high P a functional layout is appropriate. The repe- tasks to be performed by each workstation, but the titiveness level essentially combines P and Q in one vari- group of workers of each workstation has autonomy able. This is illustrated in figure 7 relating repetitiveness to organize the work inside the group. level and automation level. Here we plot the typical level of repetitiveness against the level of automation for some important modern manufacturing systems. The level of 4. Appraisal and application of the multi- repetitiveness increases from job-shop, to CM2, and dimensional classification system flow-shop systems. Naturally has greater repeti- tiveness than FMS2 Transfer lines have the greatest repe- 4.1. Relationships between the dimensions in the classification titiveness level. What is uncertain is the position of lines I scheme and II; this depends very much on the technology and control system employed in the FMS. Certain groups of characteristics occur quite com- The response time, level of customization and the way monly in production systems. Here we illustrate some we apply our classification enables us to treat the rela- typical relationships between the general characteriza- tionship between the production system and the custo- tion dimensions we have identified. For instance, the mers in a deeper way than in traditional textbook numbers of employees, level of automation and size of classifications, e.g. Ingham (1971) and Wild (1995). the production system tend to be correlated. The size of The response time and the level of customization describe the production system is closely related to important fea- the relationship between the production system and the tures of the production system, e.g. the amount of capital market, and it is important therefore that literature that can be invested in a PPCS. Also in real production related to PPC systems specifies this relationship.</p><p>Multi-dimensional classification of production systems 491 4.2. Using the classification to choose the overall structure of a not work well in non-repetitive situations. For some cases PPCS there is the possibility to choose OPT type systems. For large projects, PERT/CPM may be the most appropriate All the 12 variables considered in our multi-dimen- choice. sional classification have direct impact on the complexity While the level of repetitiveness has a strong impact on of the production planning and control (PPC) activities. the choice of basic PPCS, the other variables have sig- Table 2 indicates the typical impact of each variable on nificant impact on the complexity of the detailed system the complexity of PPC activities and the relationship to be For example, MRP may be chosen as the between each variable and the level of repetitiveness. basic system but the parametrization of the system Repetitiveness is an important variable in our classifica- depends on the complexity of the PC activities. These tion and we believe it to be the key variable for choosing are related to the variables in table 2 and also the con- the overall structure of the PPCS. Table 2 also indicates straints that are restricting the production system. the relationship between the variables and the choice of a PPCS. The last line of table 2 is justified by the following reasoning: for discrete items the more repetitive the pro- 4.3. Applying the scheme duction system is the more likely that the simplest of all PPCS-the kanban-can be chosen; for intermediate Table 3 gives a complete view of the attributes of the situations period batch control (PBC; Burbidge 1996) is multi-dimensional classification scheme. likely to be appropriate and for non-repetitive situations If the production system is composed of one set of an MRP-based approach is likely to be necessary. homogenous products and one processing unit and/or Kanban and PBC due to their logic and procedures do one assembly unit, the application of the multidimen- Table 2. The variables and the choice of a PPC system. Level of repetitiveness of production systems Pure Semi Mass Semi- Non- Large Other variables continuous continuous production Repetitive repetitive repetitive projects Enterprise size For all levels of repetitiveness, the larger the enterprise the greater the complexity of production planning and control (PPC) activities Response time DL(a-P%) DL(a-P% DL(a-P%) PL + DL PL + DL or SL + PL + DL SL + PL + DL Automation level Rigid Rigid Rigid Normal or Normal or Normal or Normal flexible flexible flexible Product structure For all level of repetitiveness, the PPC activities for multi-level products are much more complex than for single- level products Level of Standard Standard Standard Standard Mushroom Semi- Customized customization products or mushroom or mushroom or mushroom or semi- customized customized or customized Number of products For all levels of repetitiveness, the PPC activities for multi-products are much more complex than for single- product Types of layout Product Product Product Group Group Functional Fixed layout layout layout layout layout layout position Types of buffer (i) and (iii) (i), (ii) (i), (ii) (i), (ii) (i), (ii) (i), (ii) Without and (iii) and (iii) and (iii) or (i) or (ii) buffers Types of flow The complexity of PPC activities increases from (F1) in direction to (F12) Types of assembly (A1) or (A1) or (A5) or (A6) (A5) or (A6) (A7) or (A8) (A3) or (A4) (A2) disassembly disassembly or (A7) or or (A7) or or (A9) or or no no assembly no assembly no assembly assembly Types of work If there is assembly, the type of work organization has organization a direct impact on the way you will balance the work in the assembly Basic production A spread- A spread- Kanban Kanban or PBC or MRP PERT/ control system sheet to sheet to PBC OPT CPM possible to bc control the schedule chosen rate of flow the work</p><p>492 B. L. MacCarthy and F. C. F. Fernandes Table 3. Summary of multi-dimension classification system (MDCS). General characterization Processing characterization (A) Enterprise size (F) Processing description (L): large number of employees Types of layout (M): medium number of employees (S): single workstation (S): small number of employees (P): product layout (B) Response time (F): functional layout (layout by process) (SL + PL + DL) if the system produces by order (G): group layout - P%)) if the system produces for stock and (FP): layout of fixed position the service level is equal to P% Types of buffer (DL( - P%)) if the system docs not produce (only buy, (1): buffer before the first production stage stock, deliver and sell items) and the services level is (2): buffers between intermediary stages equal to P% (3): buffer after the last product stage (PL + DL) if the system produces by order but maintains Types of flow stocks of raw materials mono-stage (SL + DL) the system does not produce and attends the (F2): mono-stage with equal machines in parallel clients by order (F3): mono-stage with uncqual machines in parallel (C) Repetitiveness level (F4): uni-directional multi-stages (PC) pure continuous system (F5): variable unidirectional multi-stages (SC) semi-continuous system (F6): uni-directional multi-stages with equal (MP) mass production system machines in parallel (RP) repetitive production system (F7): variable uni-directional multi-stages with (SR) semi-repetitive production system equal machines in parallel (NR) -> non-repetitive production system (F8): uni-directional multi-stages with unequal (LP) large project machines in parallel (D) Automation level (F9): variable uni-directional multi-stages with (N): normal automation unequal machines in parallel (F): flexible automation (F10): multi-directional multi-stages (R): rigid automation multi-directional multi-stages with equal (M): mix automation machines in parallel (F12): multi-directional multi-stages with unequal machines in parallel Product characterization Assembly characterization (E) Product description (G) Types of assembly Product structure (A1): mixture of chemical ingredients (SL): single-level products (A2): assembly of a large project (ML): products (A3): assembly of heavy products in a layout of Level of customization fixed position (1): customized products (A4): assembly of light products in one or in (2): semi-customized products parallel workstations (3): mushroom (A5): paced assembly line where the conveyor (4): standard products never stops Number of products (A6): paced assembly line where the conveyor stops (S): single-products for C (cycle time) units of time (M): multi-products (A7): assembly (A8): unpaced assembly line I (A9): unpaced assembly line II (H) Types of work organization (I): individual workers (T): work teams (G): work groups sional classification is straightforward. Otherwise, we (2) If the level of automation is mixed (dimension must consider the following general approach (figure 8). B = M) then we have to specify for each pro- We have to make the following explicit. cessing unit the level of automation and other descriptors (type of layout, type of buffer (1) The number n, of products in each case = and type of flow). = where the modulus sym- (3) An assembly characterization (dimensions G and bol indicates the number of elements in the set). H) for each assembly unit (1,</p><p>Multi-dimensional classification of production systems 493 n F _AL, A/B/C/D/ 2 2 General Characterisation m m n Product Processing Assembly Chracterisation Characterisation Characterisation Figure 8. The approach to apply the multi-dimensional classification. F_1-2-3_F12_N G 1 F6 N L/PL+DL/SR/M/ML4 G / A8 G General Product G F10 F Characterisation Assembly Characterisation Characterisation G Processing Characterisation Figure 9. The classification for the example problem. (4) Depending on the complexity of the production flow-shop flow pattern. The fourth and fifth processing system, we may need to show the relationship units are flexible manufacturing systems with job-shop between the processing units and buffers. A direc- type flow patterns and buffer after the last stage. There ted graph may be an appropriate approach. is one assembly unit of the unpaced type where the con- veyor always moves and the worker only attaches the Here we first present a concise illustrative example and product to the conveyor when he finishes his tasks with then apply the approach to four examples from the normal level of automation operated by work groups. literature. Figure 9 shows the classification for this production A production system manufactures machines utilized system and figure 10 uses a directed graph to show the in the construction of roads. There are 2000 employees. relationship between the units and the buffers. There are processing units with flexible levels of automa- We have also applied the approach to four production tion and others with normal levels of automation. The systems described in recent literature in production plan- system produces to order but maintains stocks of raw ning and control. Obviously the amount of detail given in materials. It is a semi-repetitive production system. The each source is limited and variable, and the results are products are complex, standard, multilevel ones. There necessarily incomplete, but it was felt to be an objective are five processing units. The first one has a functional test of the applicability of the approach. Table 4 sum- layout with buffers between the intermediate stages, marizes the major characteristics of each of the systems before the first and after the last stage, a normal level from the information provided in the source. of automation and a multi-directional multi-stage flow Artiba (1994) gives more detail for the processing char- pattern with non-identical machines in parallel. The sec- acteristics-a production system composed of six pro- ond and third processing units are manufacturing cells cessing units all with flow pattern (F4) and the with normal levels of automation. The second one has a transport of the materials between adjacent workstations buffer before the first stage and a uni-directional flow is made through pipes. The relationships among the six pattern with identical machines in parallel. The third units are shown in figure 11 [e.g. the products that pass one has a buffer after the last stage and a unidirectional processing unit follow through to PU4 or PU5].</p><p>494 B. L. MacCarthy and F. C. F. Fernandes Processing Unit 1 (F12) PU 3 (F4) PU 2 (F6) PU 4 (F10) PU 5 (F10) Figure 10. The relationship between units and buffers. PU 1 (F4) PU 4 (F4) PU 2 (F4) PU 5 (F4) PU 3 (F4) PU 6 (F4) Figure 11. The relationships among the six units (based on Artiba 1994). Table 4. Application of the MDCS to some literature examples. References Characterization Variables [1] [2] [3] [4] * * * * General Enterprise size Response time * * * * Repetitiveness level NR MP MP SC Automation level F R R R Product Product description: Product structure ML ML ML ML Level of customization 1 3 4 3 Number of products M M M M Processing Processing discription: Types of layout F S P P Types of buffers 2 1-3 2 1-3 Types of flow F11 F1 F4 ** Assembly Types of assembly A4 A4 A5 A1 Types of organization of work - - - I Notes: A trace (-) means that the descriptor considered docs not apply; an asterisk (*) means that the information was omitted; and a double asterisk (**) means that additional description will be provided on the information cannot put into a simple table. References: [1] Anwar, M.F. and Nagi, R., 1998, Integrated scheduling of material handling and manufacturing activities for just-in-time production of complex assemblies. International Journal of Production Research, 36, 653-681. [2] Maimon, O. Z. and Braha, D., 1998, A genetic algorithm approach to scheduling PCBs on a single machine. International Journal of Production Research, 36, [3] Dowlatshahi, S., 1996, An efficient solution for determining location and size of buffer stocks. Production Planning & Control, 7, 282-291. [4] Artiba, A., 1994, A rule-based planning system for paralle] multiproduct manufacturing lines. Production Planning & Control, 5, 5. Conclusions are very superficial whilst others disregard important ele- ments. The lack of useful classifications is one reason that Different classifications and taxonomies are necessary we believe underlies the lack of progress in operations for different purposes as different perspectives on manu- management generally and production planning and facturing systems are important for different aspects of control in particular. analysis and design. However, many previous classifica- The classification scheme described here can be suc- tions have limited application: some are not explicit cessfully applied to real production systems because it about the purpose of the proposed classification and/or can treat in-depth the typical hybrid cases that arise in</p><p>Multi-dimensional classification of production systems 495 practice. Each specific production system demands a BUFFA, E. S., and MILLER, J. G., 1979, Production-Inventory specific, if not unique, production control system. For Systems Planning and Control (US: Richard D. Irwin). example, under the general heading of assembly lines, BURBIDGE, J. L., 1962, The Principles of Production Control (first edition) (London: MacDonald & Evans). there are in reality, several different types, each of BURBIDGE, J.L. (ed.), 1970, Final Report, International Seminar on which requires a different production control system. Group Technology (Turin: Turin International Centre). Our classification highlights the essential characteristics BURBIDGE, J. L., 1971, The Principles of Production Control (third that enable a better understanding of production systems edition) (London: MacDonald & Evans). and their relationship with the production planning and BURBIDGE, J. L., 1975, The Introduction of Group Technology control function. In future research, we intend to demon- (London: William Heinemann). BURBIDGE, J. L., 1985, Automated production control. In strate further its utility for aiding in the selection or P. Falster and R. B. Mazumder (eds) Modelling Production design of appropriate production planning and control Management Systems (North-Holland: Elsevier Science BV) systems. More generally it may be used for research, pp. 19-35. particularly in studying the gap between practice and BURBIDGE, J. L., 1996, Period Batch Control (Oxford: Clarendon theory in the production planning and control area. It Press). CARRIE, A. S., 1975, The layout of multi-product lines. may also be used for teaching in operations management International Journal of Production Research, 13, 541-557. and industrial engineering. We see it being used to CONSTABLE, C.J., and NEW, C. C., 1976, Operations Management, help students in classifying systems from detailed a Systems Approach Through Text and Cases (London: Wiley). descriptions and in classifying production systems studied CONWAY, R. W., MAXWELL, W. L., and MILLER, L. W., 1967, in the field. Theory of Scheduling (Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley). DE TONI, A., and PANIZZOLO, R., 1992, Repetitive and intermittent manufacturing: comparison of characteristics. Acknowledgement Integrated Manufacturing Systems, 3, 23-37. DULMET, LHOTE, F., and ORTIZ-HERNANDEZ, J., 1997, A processes classification for the representation of production The authors wish to acknowledge the support of the systems. Fifth International Conference on Factory 2000. The FAPESP in funding this work. Technology Exploitation Process. IEE Conference Publication no. 435, pp. 496-500. FRIZELLE, G. D. M., 1989, OPT in perspective. Advanced Manufacturing Engineering, 1, 74-80. References I. J., 1965, Categorisation of classification. In Mathematics and Computer Science in Medicine and Biology ANEKE, N. A. G., and CARRIE, A. S., 1984, A comprehensive (London: HMSO), pp. 115-128. flowline classification scheme. International Journal of Production GROOVER, M., 1980, Automation, Production Systems and Computer Research, 22, 281-297. Manufacturing (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: APICS REPETITIVE MANUFACTURING GROUP, SECOND INGHAM, H., 1971, Balancing Sales and Production (London: British QUARTER 1982, Repetitive manufacturing. Production and Institute of Management). Inventory Management, 23, 78-86. JAIN, A. K., 1988, EXPSYS: offshore structures expert BANERJEE, S. K., 1997, Methodology for integrated manu- Proceedings of the 5th ASCE Society of Civil Engineering) facturing planning and control systems design. In A. Artiba Specialty Conference, Blacksburg, USA, 25-27 and S. E. Elmaghraby The Planning and Scheduling of JICHAO, X., 1996, Variability detection and robustness design in Production Systems (London: Chapman & Hall), pp. complex production system. Computers & Industrial Engineering, BARBER, K. D., and HOLLIER, R. H., 1986a, The use of numer- 775-778. ical analysis to classify companies according to production JOHNSON, L. A., and D. C., 1974, Operations control complexity. International Journal of Production Research, Research in Production Planning, Scheduling and Inventory Control 24, 203-222. (New York: Wiley). BARBER, K. D., and HOLLIER, R. H., 1986b, The effects of JOHNSON, R. V., 1991, Balancing assembly lines for teams and computer-aided production control systems on defined work groups. International Journal of Production Research, 29, company types. International Journal of Production Research, 24, 1205-1214. 311-327. KITCHING, I. J., FOREY, P. L., HUMPHRIES, C. J., and BLACK, J. T., 1983, Cellular manufacturing systems reduce WILLIAMS, D. M., 1998, Cladistics-the Theory and Practice of setup time, make small lot production economical. Industrial Persimony Analysis (2nd edition) (Oxford: Oxford University Engineering, 15, Press). BOTTA, V., GUINET, A., and BOULLE, D., 1997, Object-oriented KUSIAK, A., 1985, Flexible manufacturing systems: a structural analysis with structured and integrated specifications and approach. International Journal of Production Research, 23, 1057- solutions (OASISS) for production system control. Journal 1073, of Intelligent Manufacturing, 8, 3-14. J., and B. L., 1996, The classification of BRIGHT, J. R., 1958, Automation and Management (Boston: FMS scheduling problems. International Journal of Production Harvard University Press). Research, 647-656. BROWNE, J., DUBOIS, D., RATHMILL, K., SETHI, S. P., and B. L., and LIU, J., A new classification STECKE, E., 1984, Classification of flexible manufacturing scheme for flexible manufacturing systems. International systems. FMS Magazine, 2, Journal of Production Research, 31, 299-309..</p><p>496 B. L. MacCarthy and F. C. F. Fernandes MAIMON, O., and NOF, S. Y., 1986, Analysis of multi-robot PYOUN, Y. S., CHOI, B. K., and PARK, J. C., 1995, Flexibility systems. IIE Transactions (Institute of Industrial Engineers), 18, value as a tool for improving decision making in flexible 226-234. automation. Engineering Economist, 40, 267-282. MALLICK, R. W., and GAUDREAU, A. T., 1951, Plant Layout SCHMITT, T. G., KLASTORIN, T., and SHTUB, A., 1985, (New York: Wiley). Production classification system, concepts, models and MATHER, H., 1988, Competitive Manufacturing (Englewood Cliffs: strategies. International Journal of Production Research, 23, 563- Prentice Hall). 578. McCARTHY, L., 1995, Manufacturing classification: lessons SIPPER, D., and SHAPIRA, R., 1989, JIT WIP -a trade-off from organizational systematics and biological taxonomy. analysis. International Journal of Production Research, 27, 903-914 Integrated Manufacturing Systems, 6, 37-48. STECKE, K. E., and BROWNE, J., 1985, Variations in flexible McCARTHY, I., LESEURE, M., RIDGWAY, K., and FIELLER, N., manufacturing systems according to the relevant types of 1997, Building a manufacturing cladogram. International automated materials handling. Material Flow, 2, 179-186. Journal of Technology Management, 13, 269-286. WILD, R., 1971, The Techniques of Production Management NYS, D. A., 1984, Classification of machine tool equipment used (London: Holt, Rinehart and Winston). for machining housing type components. Soviet Engineering R., 1972, Mass Production Management (London: Wiley). Research, 4, 39-43. WILD, R., 1995, Production and Operations Management (5th edi- PETROV, V. A., 1966, Flowline Group Production Planning (London: tion) (London: Cassell Eductional). Business Publications). WOODWARD, J., 1965, Industrial Organization-Theory and Practice PUTNAM, A. O., 1983, MRP for repetitive manufacturing shops: (1st edition) (Oxford: Oxford University Press). a flexible kanban system for America. Production and Inventory WOODWARD, J., 1980, Industrial Organization-Theory and Practice Management, 60-88. (2nd edition) (Oxford: Oxford University Press).</p>

Mais conteúdos dessa disciplina