Logo Passei Direto
Buscar
Material

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Escolha uma das opções e acesse esse e outros materiais sem bloqueio. 🤩

Cadastre-se ou realize login

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Prévia do material em texto

Third RILEM workshop 9-10 on Testing and Modelling the Chloride Ingress into Concrete September 2002, Madrid, Spain TIME DEPENDENCY OF CHLORIDE DIFFUSION COEFFICIENTS IN CONCRETE Visser, Gaal, G.C.M.², and de Rooij, M.R.¹ 'TNO Building Construction and Research, the Netherlands Digitalizado com CamScanner University of Technology, the Netherlands Abstract Most of the based currently short used time-dependent models to predict chloride diffusion in crete are models on be used term exposure tests. Consequently, there is some serious doubt con- these can is to model long term exposure tests (field data). An additional if factor 1/(1-n) required to model long term exposure tests accurately. In this paper, the difference and mathematical consequences between short term (cₛ, D₀ n) either solution, the equations should be solved at the same time for long term and exposure in tests is explained. To obtain optimum values for the three variables and ride profiles the determined at different ages. If the variables are determined by the correct chlo- approach, values can be exchanged between the two models. 1. Introduction steel. One of The the main causes of damage of concrete structures is corrosion of reinforcement chloride reinforcement can corrode due to external species migrating into the chloride resulting in chloride induced corrosion. This process is assumed to concrete, begin when e.g. threshold content in concrete at the position of the reinforcement reaches the are used. value. To predict this moment in time diffusion based chloride ingress chloride models Thirty many years ago, a first diffusion model was proposed by Collepardi [1]. Since sure) new models have been introduced including effects like the environmental (expo- then, ageing However, one of the most important factors influencing the chloride diffusion conditions [2] and concrete composition [3]. a decreasing of concrete. diffusion Due rate. to ongoing hydration, the concrete becomes denser, resulting is the inThird RILEM workshop on Testing and Modelling the Chloride Ingress into Concrete 9-10 September 2002, Madrid, Spain Third RILEM workshop 9-10 on Testing and Modelling the Chloride Ingress into Concrete September 2002, Madrid, Spain focuses on the time dependency of the diffusion one coefficient. It is shown that 1E-11 tration there are field data (continuous exposure). the other variables by performing short term pene- This paper basically two ways of calculating the relationship: by using long term pene- PC 8E-12 tration tests migration or tests (discrete exposure). When the be are determined by the correct or the values for the diffusion coefficient can exchanged between the two methods. apparent diffusion coefficient (m²/s) 6E-12 PC/PFA 4E-12 PC/BFS 2. Modeling chloride ingress 2E-12 Collepardi 2.1. [1] proposed a model to estimate chloride ingress based on Fick's second law Apparent diffusion coefficient Digitalizado com CamScanner 0 of diffusion, assuming a constant diffusion coefficient and a constant surface chloride 0 2 4 6 8 10 content. The analytical solution for this situation is: x exposure time (year) (1) Figure 1 Decrease in apparent diffusion coefficient with exposure time (data from [4]), wherein: chloride content at time t and depth symbols: apparent diffusion coefficients determined from chloride content initial chloride content in the concrete profiles (equation 1); solid lines: best-fit aging model (equation 2), concrete surface chloride content with PC = Portland cement, PC/PFA =Portland cement and fly ash, depth from exposure surface PC/BFS = Portland cement and 70% blast furnace slag t exposure time apparent diffusion coefficient Deducted from data like presented in Figure 1, a reference diffusion coefficient was in- Based on this approach, the diffusion coefficient and the surface chloride content can be troduced that could be transformed to a time dependent diffusion coefficient by: determined from a measured chloride profile, e.g. by means of least square approxima- tion. = (2) However, by applying equation (1) to field data, it was found that the apparent diffusion coefficient changed with exposure time (see e.g. [4], [5]). As an example of such a time- wherein: D(t) time dependent diffusion coefficient dependent behaviour of the apparent diffusion coefficient, Figure 1 shows the decrease D₀ reference diffusion coefficient at reference time to in diffusion coefficient with exposure time for reinforced concrete specimens exposed in to reference time (usually 28 days) the splash zone at the UK Coast. t time n age exponent 2.2. Time dependent diffusion coefficient This is not the only model used to include the time dependency of the diffusion coeffi- A first conclusion that can be drawn from Figure 1 is that the apparent diffusion coeffi- cient (see e.g. [7]), but most models include a similar exponential time behavior, where cient is not constant. This has a major impact on the prediction models for the onset of the decrease in diffusion coefficient is introduced by the age exponent n. In principle, the corrosion: a time dependency of the diffusion coefficient should be included in order to age exponent n can have any value larger than 0. The larger the age exponent becomes, be able to correctly predict this time. A first concise attempt to include the effect of age- the faster the decrease in diffusion coefficient is, compared to a reference diffusion coef- ing of concrete on the diffusion coefficient in relation to the service life has been made within the Brite/Euram project DuraCrete [6]. ficient. The time t must be larger than to. The limitations for n and t stem from the fact that under normal conditions, it is not possible for the diffusion coefficient to increase with time, when the conditions are kept constant.Third RILEM workshop on Testing and Modelling the Chloride Ingress into Concrete Third RILEM workshop on Testing and Modelling the Chloride Ingress into Concrete 9-10 September Madrid, Spain 9-10 September 2002, Madrid, Spain Equation for field data 3. Mathematical consequences of time dependency 3.2. When chloride concrete profiles samples from or field structures data are are analyzed a different approach is necessary. In Equation for discrete exposure tests the field, In the section on chloride exposed continuously to chloride since their 3.1. the DuraCrete program, the time dependent diffusion coefficient as given in equation reference time to. coefficient that be modeling it has already been shown that the crete (2) was that has not been previously exposed to chloride is briefly (test-time one or In originally derived for the Rapid Chloride Migration tested (RCM) test. In this test con- apparent diffusion In can calculated from chloride profiles, is not stant but time dependent. from field essence data. this means equation (1) cannot be used for evaluat- con- two days) for its chloride migration behaviour. If identical concrete samples differing ing chloride profiles that first A time dependent diffusion coefficient is required. only in age are tested in the RCM-test, the obtained diffusion coefficients plotted versus It was then shown as a concise attempt for a time dependent diffusion coeffi- time should look like the graph given in Figure 2. The exposure time is so brief com- cient equation (2) was proposed. Generally, as the next step, equation (2) is substituted in equation (1) to obtain a relationship for the time dependent prediction of the chloride Digitalizado com CamScanner pared to the age of the concrete, that a discrete diffusion coefficient is obtained. The solid line going through the three discrete diffusion coefficients is described by the rela- profile. However, this substitution if is mathematically inconsistent! Equation (2) can only tion presented in equation (2). For a reference time to a reference diffusion coefficient D₀ be substituted in equation (1) the time dependent diffusion coefficient can be consid- is found (usually to = 28 days). ered constant and the exposure time is brief. The discrete coefficient as obtained from the RCM-test can be used as such. D(t) Ddiscr 1 When a concrete sample or structure is exposed continuously from the beginning of its life time, the penetration of chloride over time depends on a continuously changing dif- fusion coefficient. This is illustrated in Figure 3. Ddiscr 2 =D(t₂) D(t) Ddiscr 3 = t₁ t₂ t Figure 2 Schematized decrease in diffusion coefficient (solid line) and calculated diffu- Dcont sion coefficients at discrete exposure times Because the testing time in the RCM test is brief, the discrete diffusion coefficient can be t3 t considered a constant for the concrete samples of that specific age. Because the discrete diffusion coefficient can be considered as a constant, the discrete diffusion coefficient Figure 3 Schematized decrease in diffusion coefficient (solid line) and calculated con- the can chloride be substituted profile: in equation (1), leading to the following equation for the prediction of tinuous diffusion coefficients at different exposure times The total history of the changing diffusion coefficient is only included when solving Fick's second law anew. It results in a time-history of the diffusion coefficient given by (3) integrating equation (2): (4) for In this brief equation exposures. tage is now the age of the concrete, and t is the exposition time, valid onlyThird RILEM workshop on Testing and Modelling the Chloride Ingress into Concrete 9-10 September 2002, Madrid, Spain Third RILEM workshop on Testing and Modelling the Chloride Ingress into Concrete 9-10 September 2002, Madrid, Spain factor 1/(1-n) is missing in most analyses, as noted earlier by Bentz and Feng [8]. The Due to the integration it is now valid again to substitute equation (3) in equation (I) re- Folkstone. Chloride after profiles 6 months, have 1, been 2, 3, determined 6 and 8 for 6 concrete compositions and three paper are of the experiments, see only [4]. The and averaged over the three curing regimes. For curing regimes for three compositions years exposure. The data shown in this sulting in: full details concrete compositions are given in Table 1. (5) Table 1 Concrete mix details (in for the Folkstone specimens. Code PC PC/PFA 288 PC/BFS Portland cement 278 110 Fly ash - In this equation t is representing the exposure time. Notice that by the chosen integration 97 - boundaries, the equation is valid only for exposure times much larger than the age of the Slag - - Digitalizado com CamScanner concrete, and that the age at which the exposure start should be small. Water 190 255 170 0.66 177 Wbr 0.54 0.48 Gravel 1240 1305 1250 3.3. Optimization of parameters Sand 660 585 There are now two equations for the prediction of chloride profiles: one applicable to 600 short term discrete diffusion approach (equation 3), and one applicable to field data us- 4.2. Calculation by apparent diffusion approach ing a long-term continuous diffusion approach (equation 5). In these equations there are three unknown variables that need to be optimized when solving the equations: the chlo- Based on the Folkstone chloride profiles, the surface chloride contents and the appar- ride surface content the reference diffusion coefficient D₀ and the age exponent n. ent diffusion coefficients were recalculated using equation (1) (Table 2). Next, the When solving this equation for various chloride profiles, it is not correct to determine at reference diffusion coefficients D₀ (at 28 days) and the age exponent n were determined using equation (2) (Table 3, see also Figure 1). first the apparent diffusion coefficient by equation (1) and next the time dependent factor by equation (2) or (4) because then not the optimum values for the three variables are n). found, but only the optimum values for two sets of two variables (D(t) and and D₀ and Table 2 Recalculated best fitted coefficients for the apparent diffusion approach using equation (1), surface chloride content in % by mass of concrete, apparent diffusion coefficient in m²/s. It should be noted that equation (5) is indeterminate when only one chloride profile is PC available, i.e. there will be many solutions resulting in the same well-fitted chloride pro- PC/PFA PC/BFS file. Hence, when only one chloride profile is available, at best the time-dependent diffu- age (year) Cₛ 0.5 sion coefficient and the surface chloride content can be determined. 0.40 8.25 0.42 4.34 0.58 7.51 Finally, it should be noted that the three unknown variables in the two equations (3 and 0.72 2.90 0.68 1.66 0.68 2.92 5) represent exactly the same variables. Failing to recognize this and thus using only one 2 0.46 5.63 0.45 1.92 0.46 ferent. equation for the two different types of exposure tests will result in variables that are dif- 1.88 3 0.42 5.64 0.54 1.05 0.54 0.99 6 0.30 8.59 0.51 0.60 0.46 1.03 4. Consequences for modeling field data 8 0.31 7.87 1.37 0.30 0.49 0.69 4.1. Used data modeling Data from field Thomas and Bamforth [4] have been used illustrate when Table 3 Best fitted coefficients of the ageing formula in the apparent diffusion ap- mining first data and based on the two different approaches, to i.e. the the consequences proach using equation (2) (standard deviations between brackets) The solving data equation 5 for all profiles and next simultaneously. (D₀ and n), and the "new approach" "old method" by means deter- of Code PC PC/PFA PC/BFS been exposed have for been 8 years obtained in the from splash field zone experiments at the southeast in which coast concrete of the UK, specimens near have (average, t% by mass of concrete) 0.45 (0.15) 0.52 (0.36)¹ 0.54 (0.09) D₀ (10⁻¹² m²/s) 6.48 19.2 55.4 n the outlier at 8 year has been omitted in the calculation 0 of the average 0.8 1.0Third RILEM workshop on Testing and Modelling the Chloride Ingress into Concrete Third RILEM workshop on Testing and Modelling the Chloride Ingress into Concrete 9-10 September 2002, Madrid, Spain 9-10 September 2002, Madrid, Spain In Table it can be seen that the age exponent of PC is zero, i.e. the diffusion coeffi- cient remains essentially constant during the exposure time. This is a consequence of the From Figure 4, it can be seen that individual chloride profiles are sometimes not fitted low level of variation in the apparent diffusion coefficients with age of this concrete (see well at all, contrary to the single that fits in the apparent diffusion approach. This is a conse- Table 2). For the other two concrete mixtures, the apparent diffusion coefficient de- quence both of the requirement of the the surface chloride content remains constant with rapidly with age, hence high age exponents are found. The reference diffu- time, as well as the increase chloride profiles over time. In the continuous diffu- mally sion creases coefficient found very in laboratory (at 28 days) experiments, for PC with whereas a wbr of the 0.66 reference is low compared diffusion coefficient to values nor- for sion approach all profiles are fitted at the same time to get the best optimization of the three values. Unfortunately, it is very difficult to judge the value of the first point in the PC/BFS is unrealistic high. It should be noted that the BFS used in these experiments is profiles, when the first point is low compared to the entire profile. Furthermore, an a- relatively slow reacting (compared to Dutch slag cement). Note also that the surface priori assumption is made on a constant surface chloride content. However, the used data chloride contents are averaged over the best-fit values for each chloride profiles, and not is obtained in the splash zone and a constant surface chloride content may not be present optimum values. [2]. On the other hand, there is no trend in the variation of the surface chlorides (see Ta- Digitalizado com CamScanner Calculation by continuous diffusion approach ble 2), so that the observed variations may well be within the normal variation within the 4.3. The chloride profiles from Folkstone have also been used in the calculation of the opti- splash zone. mum values for D₀ and n by means of the continuous diffusion approach (using equa- tion 5). As an example, the results for PC are shown in Figure 4 and Table 4. The calculation of the optimum values in the continuous diffusion approach is very sta- ble. However, for age factors close to 1, the calculated reference diffusion coefficient D₀ 6 months is very sensitive to the data in the calculation (since n=1 is a singularity point). This is 0,5 year illustrated in Table 4 by the second set of results of PC-BFS. Omitting just a single point 2 year in the calculation results in a reference diffusion coefficient that is 4 times as high. Note content % on 0.4 year that the surface chloride content and the age exponent are much less sensitive. 6 year 0,3 4.4. year Comparison between apparent and continuous diffusion approach Comparing the results of the continuous diffusion approach with those of the apparent 02 diffusion approach, it can be seen that the two approaches give almost similar results for PC/BFS, with the exception of the reference diffusion coefficient (which differ about a 0,1 factor 1/(1-n)), while for PC/PFA and PC the results of the two approaches differ. In Figure 5, the implication of these differences can be seen. 0 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 For the PC concrete, the age exponent is 0 for the apparent approach, whereas for the distance from exposure surface (mm) continuous approach the age exponent is 0.12 so that the chloride ingress is faster for the Figure 4 Chloride profiles of PC at various times (symbols) and best-fitted profiles apparent diffusion solution even though the reference diffusion coefficient is lower and (lines) on the basis of the continuous diffusion approach (equation 5) assum- the surface content is higher. For the PC/PFA concrete, the age exponent is however ing continuous exposure; optimized for all profiles together. lower in the continuous approach than in the apparent diffusion approach so that the chloride ingress is slower for the apparent diffusion solution. Table Code 4 Best fitted coefficients in the continuous diffusion approach For the PC/BFS concrete, an age exponent of 1 was found in the apparent diffusion ap- proach. As can be seen as well in the figure, this implies an instantaneous build-up of PC' PC/PFA chloride penetration limited to a surface layer after which the diffusion stops, i.e. there is (average) D₀ (10⁻¹² m²/s) 0.35 no further chloride penetration. Although this seems unlikely in practice, as an approach 0.53 9.0 for long term chloride penetration, it may be valid in case the concrete becomes dense so n 4.0 0.12 0.6/2.1 quickly that the chloride penetration can be neglected after initial ingress. For the con- 2 the the bold outlier values at a depth are calculated of 5 mm after by omitting one year the of chloride exposure content is omitted at 5 mm in 0.58 the after calculations one year of exposure tinuous approach, the age exponent is slightly smaller than so that this initial build-up of a chloride profile takes a slightly longer time. The progress with time is however neg- ligible as well. 430 431Third RILEM workshop on Testing and Modelling the Chloride Ingress into Concrete Third RILEM workshop on Testing and Modelling the Chloride Ingress into Concrete 9-10 September 2002, Madrid, Spain 9-10 September 2002, Madrid, Spain References PC, app 1. Collepardi, M., Marcialis, A., Turriziani, R.: 'Penetration of Chloride Ions into Ce- PC, cont ment Pastes and Concretes', J.Am.Cer.Soc., October 1972, 534-535. content (% on concrete) 0,4 PC/PFA, app 2. Costa, A. and Appleton, J., Chloride penetration into concrete in marine environ- PC/PFA, cont Part 1: Main parameters affecting chloride penetration, Mat.&Struct. 32:252- PC/BFS, app 259, 1999 0,3 PC/BFS, cont 3. Johannesson, B., Transport and sorption phenomena in concrete and other porous Digitalizado com CamScanner 0.2 media. Lund University Report TVBM-1019, 2000. 4. Thomas, M.D.A. and Bamforth, P.B.: Modelling chloride diffusion in concrete. Ef- 0,1 fect of fly ash and slag. Cem.&Concr.Res. 29: 487-495, 1999 5. Sandberg, P., Tang, L. and Andersen, A., Recurrent studies of chloride ingress in 0,0 uncracked marine concrete at various exposure times and elevations. 0 10 20 30 40 50 Cem.&Concr.Res. 29(10):1489-1502, 1998 exposure time (year) 6. DuraCrete, Performance based design for durability of concrete. Modelling of deg- Figure 5 Chloride content at a depth of 25 mm radation (Task 2 Summary Report), CUR, Gouda, 1998 7. Dhir, R.K., Jones, M.R. and Ng, S.L.D.: Prediction of total chloride content profile 5. Conclusion and diffusion coefficients for concrete, It is found that different solutions exist of Fick's second law of diffusion for different Mag.Concr.Res. 50(1): 37-48, 1998 experiments differing by the length of exposure times. Two solutions have been derived, one for short term exposure tests, in which the diffusion coefficient during the test can be 8. Bentz, D.P. and Feng, X., Time-dependent diffusivities: possible misinterpretation considered constant and one for long term exposure tests in which the diffusion coeffi- due to spatial dependency. In: Testing and modeling the chloride ingress into con- cient is time dependent during the exposure. Failure to recognize the existence of two crete (eds. C. Andrade and J. Kropp), RILEM Proc.19, RILEM Publ., 2000 solutions for the two types of tests can result in a wrongful prediction of future chloride profiles. On the other hand, when the variables are determined by the correct approach, the values can be exchanged between the two methods. To obtain optimum values for the three variables (c,, D₀ and n) in either solution, the equations should be solved at the same time for chloride profiles determined at different ages. When only chloride profiles of one age are available the time-dependency of the chloride diffusion coefficient cannot be determined; just an apparent diffusion coeffi- cient over that particular exposure time can be obtained.

Mais conteúdos dessa disciplina