Buscar

Revista de Estudos Criminais - Módulo II

Prévia do material em texto

135
a realizaçãO dO tiPO cOMO Pedra 
angular da teOria dO criMe. eleMentOs 
Para O abandOnO dO cOnceitO PrÉ- 
-tÍPicO de açãO e de suas FunçÕes
FaBio roBerto d’avila*
5(6802��2�SUHVHQWH�HVFULWR�EXVFD�UHYLVLWDU�R�SUREOHPD�GR�FRQFHLWR�
GH�DomR�HP�GLUHLWR�SHQDO��DSyV�PDLV�GH�XPD�GpFDGD�GR�QRVVR�SULPHL-
UR�HVWXGR�VREUH�R�WHPD

��$�SRVLomR�WRPDGD�QDTXHOD�DOWXUD�p�DTXL�UHL-
WHUDGD�H�GHVHQYROYLGD��3URS}H�VH�R�DEDQGRQR�GR�FRQFHLWR�SUp�WtSLFR�
GH�DomR�H�GD�WRWDOLGDGH�GDV�IXQo}HV�TXH�OKH�VmR�DLQGD�KRMH�DVVLQDOD-
GDV�SHOD�GRXWULQD�PDMRULWiULD��LQFOXVLYH�GD�SUySULD�IXQomR�GH�GHOLPL-
WDomR��XVXDOPHQWH�SRXSDGD�SHOD�FRUUHQWH�FUtWLFD��(P�VHX�OXJDU��FRPR�
SRQWR�GH�SDUWLGD�GD�WHRULD�GR�FULPH��VXJHUH�VH�a realização do tipo legal 
de crime��2�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�� FXMD� UHIRUPXODomR�p� LJXDOPHQWH�SUR-
SRVWD��SHUGH�HP�UHOHYkQFLD�VLVWHPiWLFD��PDV�QmR�p�DEDQGRQDGR��(OH�
GHL[D�GH�VHU�XP�HOHPHQWR�SUp�WtSLFR�SDUD�DVVXPLU�VH�FRPR�HOHPHQWR�
FRQVWLWXWLYR�GR�WLSR��H[HUFHQGR��QHVWD�FRQIRUPDomR��D�LQGLVSHQViYHO�
IXQomR�GH�UHIHUHQFLDO�FRPSRUWDPHQWDO�SDUD�R�MXt]R�GH�LPSXWDomR��$�
IRUPD�GH�H[SRVLomR�DGRWDGD��DQWHFLSDQGR�DV�FRQFOXV}HV�Mi�QRV�GRLV�
SULPHLURV�FDStWXORV�H�RSWDQGR�SRU�XPD�UHGDomR�REMHWLYD�H�FRPSDUWL-
PHQWDGD��WHP�FRPR�ÀQDOLGDGH�PDLRU�D�FODUH]D�
3$/$95$6�&+$9(��&RQFHLWR�GH�DomR��FRQGXWD���WHRULDV�GD�DomR��
IXQo}HV�GD�DomR��IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR��WHRULD�GR�FULPH�
$%675$&7��7KH�FXUUHQW�DUWLFOH�UHYLVLWV�WKH�SUREOHP�FRQFHUQLQJ�WKH�
FRQFHSW�RI�DFWLRQ�LQ�FULPLQDO� ODZ��PRUH�WKDQ�D�GHFDGH�DIWHU�RI�RXU�
ÀUVW�VWXG\�RQ�WKH�WRSLF��7KH�SRVLWLRQ�WDNHQ�DW�WKDW�WLPH�LV�KHUH�UHLWH-
* 3URIHVVRU� 7LWXODU� GD� )DFXOGDGH� GH� 'LUHLWR� GD� 38&56� H� GR� 3URJUDPD� GH� 3yV�*UDGXDomR�
HP�&LrQFLDV�&ULPLQDLV� �0HVWUDGR�H�'RXWRUDGR��GD�38&56��'RXWRU�HP�&LrQFLDV� -XUtGLFR� 
�&ULPLQDLV�SHOD�)DFXOGDGH�GH�'LUHLWR�GD�8QLYHUVLGDGH�GH�&RLPEUD��3yV�'RXWRU�HP�&LrQFLDV�
&ULPLQDV�SHOD�8QLYHUVLGDGH�GH�)UDQNIXUW�DP�0DLQ��$GYRJDGR�&ULPLQDO�
** $�DomR�FRPR�FRQFHLWR�FRPSUHHQVLYR�GR�DJLU�H�RPLWLU��/LQKDV�FUtWLFDV�DR�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�
como Oberbegriff, Revista de Direito Penal da Universidade Autónoma de Lisboa������������S����
H� VV�� � $�DomR� FRPR�FRQFHLWR� FRPSUHHQVLYR�GR�DJLU� H� RPLWLU��/LQKDV� FUtWLFDV� DR� FRQFHLWR�
de ação como Oberbegriff� ,Q��6286$��1H\�)D\HW�GH��2UJ����Ensaios penais em homenagem ao 
3URIHVVRU�$OEHUWR�5XÀQR�5RGULJXHV�GH�6RXVD��3RUWR�$OHJUH��5LFDUGR�/HQ]��������
136
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
136
UDWHG�DQG�IXUWKHU�GHYHORSHG��7KH�SURSRVDO�ZH�PDNH�LV�WR�DEDQGRQ�
WKH�SUH�W\SLFDO�FRQFHSW�RI�DFWLRQ�DQG��DORQJ�ZLWK�LW��DOO�RI�WKH�IXQF-
WLRQV�WKDW�DUH�VWLOO�DVVLJQHG�WR�LW�E\�WKH�PDMRULW\�GRFWULQH��LQFOXGLQJ�
WKH�GHOLPLWDWLRQ�IXQFWLRQ�XVXDOO\�SUHVHUYHG�E\�WKH�FULWLFV�RI�WKH�FRQ-
FHSW��,QVWHDG��DV�D�VWDUWLQJ�SRLQW�RI�WKH�FULPH�WKHRU\��ZH�VXJJHVW�WKH�
QRWLRQ�RI�performing the actus reus (Tatbestand)��7KH�FRQFHSW�RI�DFWLRQ��
ZKRVH�UHIRUPXODWLRQ�ZH�DOVR�VXJJHVW�� ORVHV�LWV�V\VWHPDWLF�UHOHYDQ-
FH��EXW�LV�QRW�FRPSOHWHO\�DEDQGRQHG��1R�ORQJHU�EHLQJ�D�SUH�W\SLFDO�
HOHPHQW��LW�DVVXPHV�LWVHOI�DV�D�FRQVWLWXWLYH�HOHPHQW�RI�WKH�actus reus, 
H[HUFLVLQJ��LQ�WKLV�IUDPH��WKH�NH\�UROH�RI�EHKDYLRUDO�UHIHUHQFH�IRU�WKH�
HYDOXDWLRQ�RI�WKH�FULPLQDO�DWWULEXWLRQ��7KH�IRUP�RI�H[SODQDWLRQ�KHUH�
DGRSWHG��ZKHUH�ZH�DQWLFLSDWH�WKH�FRQFOXVLRQV�LQ�WKH�ÀUVW�WZR�FKDS-
WHUV�DQG�RSW�IRU�DQ�REMHFWLYH�DQG�FRPSDUWPHQWDOL]HG�ZULWLQJ��KDV�DV�
PDLQ�SXUSRVH�WKH�DUWLFOH·V�LQWHOOLJLELOLW\�
.(<:25'6��&RQFHSW�RI�DFWLRQ��FRQGXFW���WKHRULHV�RI�DFWLRQ��DFWLRQ�
IXQFWLRQV��GHOLPLWDWLRQ�IXQFWLRQ��FULPH�WKHRU\�
680É5,2����$�DomR�FRPR�UHDOL]DomR�GR�WLSR������2�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR��
����)XQo}HV�DWULEXtGDV�j�DomR�H�D�VXD�FUtWLFD����$�GRXWULQD�QDFLRQDO�
H�D� IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR������$�DomR�QD�GRXWULQD�QDFLRQDO�� ����$�
IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR����1RWDV�FUtWLFDV�DFHUFD�GD�IXQomR�GH�GHOLPL-
WDomR����$�HYROXomR�KLVWyULFD�GR�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�H�DV�UD]}HV�SDUD�R�
VHX�DEDQGRQR������2�FRQFHLWR�FDXVDO��QDWXUDO��GH�DomR������2�FRQFHLWR�
ÀQDO�GH�DomR������2�FRQFHLWR�VRFLDO�GH�DomR������2�FRQFHLWR�QHJDWLYR�
GH�DomR������2�FRQFHLWR�SHVVRDO�GH�DomR��5HIHUrQFLDV�
1 a açãO cOMO realizaçãO dO tiPO
����2�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR
3RU�DomR��RX�FRQGXWD��HP�GLUHLWR�SHQDO�GHYH�VH�HQWHQGHU�o comporta-
mento que realiza, dolosa ou culposamente, o tipo legal de crime��$�UHDOL]DomR�GR�
WLSR��H�QmR�R�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR��FRQVWLWXL��QHVVD�SHUVSHFWLYD��R�SRQWR�GH�SDUWLGD�
GD�WHRULD�JHUDO�GR�FULPH�
(VVH� FRQFHLWR� LQVHUH�VH� HP�XPD� FRUUHQWH� FUtWLFD� jV� WHRULDV� GD� DomR� FRPR� VXSUD-
FRQFHLWR�GD�HVWUXWXUD�WHyULFD�GR�FULPH��vide infra���(P�VHX�OXJDU��L�H���FRPR�PDUFR�]HUR�GD�
HVWUXWXUD�GR�FULPH��SURS}H�VH�R�FRQFHLWR�GH�realização típica��R�TXDO�GHYHUi�VHU�HVWXGDGR�D�
SDUWLU�GDV�VXDV�TXDWUR�JUDQGHV�IRUPDV�GH�PDQLIHVWDomR��WLSR�GH�LOtFLWR�FRPLVVLYR�GRORVR��
WLSR�GH�LOtFLWR�RPLVVLYR�GRORVR��WLSR�GH�LOtFLWR�FRPLVVLYR�FXOSRVR�H�WLSR�GH�LOtFLWR�RPLVVLYR�
FXOSRVR��2�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR��SRU�VXD�YH]��HPERUD�UHGLPHQVLRQDGR�HP�LPSRUWkQFLD��FRQWL-
QXD�D�FXPSULU�XP�SDSHO�IXQGDPHQWDO�QD�WHRULD�JHUDO�GR�FULPH��7RUQD�VH�HOHPHQWR�FRQVWL-
WXWLYR�GR�IDWR�WtSLFR�H�SDVVD�D�H[HUFHU��HP�HVVrQFLD��D�IXQomR�GH�UHIHUHQWH�FRPSRUWDPHQWDO�
SDUD�ÀQV�GH� LPSXWDomR�� DEDQGRQDQGR�DV� IXQo}HV�GH�XQLmR�� FODVVLÀFDomR�H�� LQFOXVLYH�� D�
IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR��vide infra���3RU�ÀP��LPSRUWD�REVHUYDU�TXH�R�FRQFHLWR�SURSRVWR�QmR�
HVWi�UHVWULWR�DR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�KXPDQR��DEULQGR�VH�WDPEpP�j�SHVVRD�MXUtGLFD�FRPR�VX-
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
137137
MHLWR�DWLYR�GH�FULPH��(P�TXH�SHVH�D�ODUJD�FRQWURYpUVLD�HP�WRUQR�GD�YLDELOLGDGH�PDWHULDO�GH�
XPD�UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH�SHQDO�GD�SHVVRD�MXUtGLFD��D�RSomR�SHOR�DEDQGRQR�GH�XP�FRQFHLWR�
SUp�WtSLFR�GH�DomR�LPSHGH�D�VXD�GLVFXVVmR�QHVVD�VHDUD��4XDOTXHU�WHQWDWLYD�GH�VHOHomR�GR�
VXMHLWR�DWLYR�GR�FULPH�SUpYLD�j�DQiOLVH�GD�WLSLFLGDGH�UHFRORFDULD��QHFHVVDULDPHQWH��D�DWUL-
EXLomR�GH�XPD�IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR�SUp�WtSLFD�DR�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR��R�TXH��QHVWH�FRQWH[WR��
H�SRU�WXGR�TXH�VH�YHUi�D�VHJXLU��QmR�QRV�SDUHFH�DGHTXDGD�H�QHP�PHVPR�QHFHVViULD�
����)XQo}HV�DWULEXtGDV�j�DomR�H�D�VXD�FUtWLFD
3RU�DQRV�D�GRXWULQD�SHQDO�EXVFRX�XP�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�TXH�SXGHVVH�VHU�
GHÀQLGR�HP�XP�PRPHQWR�SUpYLR�jV�YDORUDo}HV�MXUtGLFR�SHQDLV�H��GHVVH�PRGR��
LQGHSHQGHQWH�GRV�MXt]RV�GH�WLSLFLGDGH��LOLFLWXGH�H�FXOSDELOLGDGH��%XVFDYD�VH�
XPD�HVSpFLH�GH�elemento primeiro, de denominador comum da noção de crime, 
SUHVHQWH�HP�WRGDV�DV�GLIHUHQWHV�IRUPDV�GH�PDQLIHVWDomR�GR�LOtFLWR�WtSLFR��8P�
HOHPHQWR�TXH�� XPD�YH]� LGHQWLÀFDGR� HP�XP�PRPHQWR�SUp�MXUtGLFR� �RX�� DR�
PHQRV��SUp�WtSLFR���WHULD�SRWHQFLDOLGDGH�GH�VHUYLU�FRPR�SHGUD�DQJXODU�GH�WRGD�
D�FRQVWUXomR�WHyULFD�GR�FULPH��VHP��WRGDYLD��SUHGHWHUPLQDU�HVVD�HVWUXWXUD��
(QWHQGLGR�QHVVHV�WHUPRV��FRPSHWLULD�DR�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�WUrV�IXQo}HV�
IXQGDPHQWDLV1: �L��IXQomR�GH�FODVVLÀFDomR��HOHPHQWR�EiVLFR���VHJXQGR�D�TXDO�WRGDV�
DV�IRUPDV�GH�H[SUHVVmR�GR�LOtFLWR�WtSLFR�²�FRPLVVLYDV�RX�RPLVVLYDV��FXOSRVDV�
RX�GRORVDV�²�GHYHP�FRUUHVSRQGHU�D�GLIHUHQWHV�HVSpFLHV�GH�XP�PHVPR�JrQHUR�
UHSUHVHQWDGR�SHOD�DomR�� �LL�� IXQomR�GH�XQLmR� �IXQomR�GH�GHÀQLomR� H� HOHPHQWR�GH�
união)��D�TXDO�H[LJH�GD�DomR�XP�FRQWH~GR�PDWHULDO�DSWR�D�UHXQLU�RV�MXt]RV�GH�
WLSLFLGDGH��LOLFLWXGH��FXOSDELOLGDGH�H��SDUD�DOJXQV��WDPEpP�SXQLELOLGDGH��GH�
IRUPD�D�WRUQDU�VH�R�substantivo�DR�TXDO�VmR�YLQFXODGRV�RV�atributos�WtSLFR��LOtFL-
WR�H�FXOSiYHO��RX�DLQGD��QD�H[SUHVVmR�GH�5R[LQ��D�´FROXQD�YHUWHEUDOµ� de todo 
R� VLVWHPD�SHQDO��2� FRQFHLWR� GH� DomR� QmR�GHYH�� SRUpP�� DQWHFLSDU� TXDOTXHU�
MXt]R�GH� LPSXWDomR��PDQWHQGR�VH�QHXWUR�HP�UHODomR�DRV�GHPDLV�HOHPHQWRV�
do crime���(iii)�H��SRU�ÀP��D�função de delimitação��DWUDYpV�GD�TXDO�R�FRQFHLWR�GH�
1 9HU�-(6&+(&.��+DQV�+HLQULFK��:(,*(1'��7KRPDV��Lehrbuch des Strafrechts. Allgemeiner 
Teil�����HG��%HUOLQ��'XQFNHU�	�+XPEORW��������S�������',$6��-RUJH�GH�)LJXHLUHGR��Direito penal��
3DUWH�JHUDO�����HG��SRUWXJXHVD�����HG��EUDVLOHLUD��6mR�3DXOR��&RLPEUD�(GLWRUD�57��W����������� 
S������H�VV���52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$OOJHPHLQHU�7HLO�����HG��0�QFKHQ��9HUODJ�&��+��%HFN��
Y��,��������S������H�VV���0$5,18&&,��*LRUJLR��Il reato come “azione”��&ULWLFD�GL�XQ�GRJPD��0LODQR��*LXIIUq��������S�����
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������
�� $OJXPDV�VLVWHPDWL]Do}HV�RSWDP�SRU�GLIHUHQFLDU�D� IXQomR�GHÀQLWyULD�GD�IXQomR�GH�XQLmR��
FRPR�RFRUULD��SRU�H[HPSOR��QD����HGLomR�GR�Lehrbuch�GH�-HVFKHFN��QD����HGLomR��-HVFKHFN�H�
:HLJHQG�GHL[DP�GH�PHQFLRQDU�D�IXQomR�GH�XQLmR���-(6&+(&.��+DQV�+HLQULFK��:(,*(1'��
138
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
138
DomR�GHYH�VHU�FDSD]�GH�H[FOXLU�WRGRV�RV�IHQ{PHQRV�TXH��GH�DQWHPmR��SRVVDP�
VHU�FRQVLGHUDGRV�LQGLJQRV�GH�TXDOTXHU�FRQVLGHUDomR�MXUtGLFR�SHQDO��IXQFLR-
QDQGR�FRPR�R�SULPHLUR�JUDQGH�ÀOWUR�GR�VLVWHPD�SHQDO�
2�TXH�VH�SUHWHQGLD��SRUWDQWR��HUD�D�HODERUDomR�GH�XP�YHUGDGHLUR�´VX-
SUDFRQFHLWR�GH�DomRµ��Oberbegriff���GRWDGR�GH�UHOHYkQFLD�VLVWHPiWLFD��FODVVLÀ-
FDWyULD�H�SUiWLFD��0DV�QmR�Vy��2�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR��HP�JUDQGH�PHGLGD��H[SUHV-
VDYD�WDPEpP�XP�SUHFLVR�PRGR�GH�YHU�R�KRPHP�H�DV�FRLVDV�GR�GLUHLWR�SHQDO��
FRP�LPSRUWDQWHV�FRQVHTXrQFLDV�GRJPiWLFDV��'Dt�QmR�VXUSUHHQGHU�R�IDWR�GH�
DOJXQV�GRV�JUDQGHV�VLVWHPDV�SHQDLV��FRPR�R�FDXVDOLVPR�H�R�ÀQDOLVPR��SDUWL-
UHP�MXVWDPHQWH�GH�XPD�GHWHUPLQDGD�WHRULD�GD�DomR��vide infra���
2�DWHQGLPHQWR�D�WRGDV�HVVDV�H[LJrQFLDV��GH�PRGR�D�MXVWLÀFDU�D�IXQomR�
EiVLFD� HVWUXWXUDO� DVSLUDGD�SHOR� FRQFHLWR�XQLWiULR�GH�DomR�� WHP�VH� UHYHODGR��
HQWUHWDQWR��GHPDVLDGDPHQWH�SUREOHPiWLFR��$V�WHQWDWLYDV�OHYDGDV�D�FDER�SRU�
7KRPDV��Lehrbuch des Strafrechts��S��������&RQWXGR��D�JUDQGH�SUR[LPLGDGH�H[LVWHQWH�HQWUH�
HODV� SDUHFH� WRUQDU� SUHIHUtYHO� XPD� DERUGDJHP� FRQMXQWD�� FRPR� ID]HP�5R[LQ� H� )LJXHLUHGR�
'LDV��YHU�QRWD����
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
139139
LQ~PHUDV�HODERUDo}HV��v.g.��FDXVDO��ÀQDO��VRFLDO��QHJDWLYD�RX�SHVVRDO�GD�DomR���
UHYHODP�IDOKDV��HPERUD�QmR�FRLQFLGHQWHV��HP�SRQWRV�VXEVWDQFLDOPHQWH�GLYHU-
VRV�H�GH�GLItFLO�FRUUHomR��(VVDV�IDOKDV��Mi�Ki�DOJXP�WHPSR��YrP�VHQGR�REMHWR�GH�
FUtWLFD�QmR�Vy�SHOD�OLWHUDWXUD�HVSHFLDOL]DGD��FRPR�SRU�LQ~PHURV�PDQXDLV�GH�
GLUHLWR�SHQDO��H��QHVWD�PHGLGD��WDPEpP�HOHPHQWR�SURSXOVRU�GR�VXUJLPHQWR�GH�
WHRULDV�DOWHUQDWLYDV��0DLV��$V�FRQWXQGHQWHV�FUtWLFDV�jV�WHQWDWLYDV�GH�FRQVWUX-
omR�GH�XP�VXSUDFRQFHLWR�PXOWLIXQFLRQDO�GH�DomR��FDSD]�GH�FRUUHVSRQGHU�DRV�
H[LJHQWHV�DQVHLRV�GD�GRJPiWLFD�SHQDO��WrP�GDGR�YD]mR�D�XPD�VHJXQGD�DOWHU-
QDWLYD��D�UHQ~QFLD�D�XP�WDO�FRQFHLWR�SUp�WtSLFR�GH�DomR��HP�SURO�GD�UHDOL]DomR�
WtSLFD�FRPR�FDWHJRULD�HOHPHQWDU�HVWUXWXUDO�GD�WHRULD�GR�FULPH��
2�FRQFHLWR�RUD�SURSRVWR�YDL�MXVWDPHQWH�QHVVH�~OWLPR�FDPLQKR��3HODV�UD-
]}HV�TXH�VHUmR�D�VHJXLU�DVVLQDODGDV��QmR�MXOJDPRV�YLiYHO�RX�PHVPR�QHFHVViULD�
D�GHIHVD�GH�XP�VXSUDFRQFHLWR�GH�DomR��(P�VHX�OXJDU��L�H���FRPR�SRQWR�GH�SDUWL-
GD�GD�HVWUXWXUD�WHyULFD�GR�FULPH��SURS}H�VH�D�UHDOL]DomR�GR�WLSR�OHJDO�GH�FULPH��
2�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�SHUGH�HP�UHOHYkQFLD�VLVWHPiWLFD��PDV�QmR�p�²�H�QHP�GHYH�VHU�
²�DEDQGRQDGR��(OH�GHL[D�GH�VHU�XP�HOHPHQWR�SUp�WtSLFR�SDUD�DVVXPLU�VH�FRPR�
HOHPHQWR�FRQVWLWXWLYR�GR�WLSR�GH�LOtFLWR��1mR�UHQXQFLD��SRUpP��D�LQGLVSHQViYHO�
SRVLomR�GH�UHIHUHQFLDO�FRPSRUWDPHQWDO�SDUD�R�MXt]R�GH�LPSXWDomR�SHQDO��
2 a dOutrina naciOnal e a FunçãO de deliMitaçãO
����$�DomR�QD�GRXWULQD�QDFLRQDO
&RQTXDQWR�QmR�GHWHQKD�D�PHVPD�IRUoD�GH�RXWURUD��R�ÀQDOLVPR�DLQGD�
H[HUFH�FRQVLGHUiYHO�LQÁXrQFLD�QD�GRXWULQD�QDFLRQDO��FRP�FRQVHTXrQFLDV�UH-
�� $� UHQ~QFLD� DR� FRQFHLWR�GH� DomR� FRPR� VXSUDFRQFHLWR�GD� HVWUXWXUD�GR� FULPH� UHPRQWD� DRV�
FpOHEUHV� HVFULWRV� GH� %HOLQJ� H� 5DGEUXFK� �%(/,1*�� (UQVW�� 'LH� /HKUH� YRP� 9HUEUHFKHQ��
7�ELQJHQ��-��&��%��0RKU��������S�Y��9RUZRUW��5$'%58&+��*XVWDY��'HU�+DQGOXQJVEHJULII�LQ�
VHLQHU�%HGHXWXQJI�U�GDV�6WUDIUHFKWVV\VWHP��%HUOLQ��*XWWHQWDJ��������S������H�VV���H�HQFRQWUD�
H[SUHVVmR�QD�REUD�GH�DXWRUHV�FRPR��',$6��-RUJH�GH�)LJXHLUHGR��Direito penal��3*��S������H�VV���
*$//$6��:LOKHOP��=XPJHJHQZlUWLJHQ�6WDQG�GHU�/HKUH�YRP�9HUEUHFKHQ��,Q��Beiträgezur 
Verbrechenslehre��%HUOLQ��:DOWHU�GH�*UX\WHU��������S������/(1&.1(5��7KHRGRU��(,6(/(��-|UJ��
,Q��6&+g1.(��$GROI��6&+5g'(5��+RUVW��Strafgesetzbuch Kommentar������HG��0�QFKHQ��&��+��
%HFN��������9RUEHP�������VV���51�����S�������2772��+DUUR��Grundkurs Strafrecht��$OOJHPHLQH�
6WUDIUHFKWVOHKUH�����HG��%HUOLQ�H�1HZ�<RUN��:DOWHU�GH�*UX\WHU��������S�����H�VV���),$1'$&$��
*LRYDQQL��086&2�� (Q]R��Diritto penale�� 3DUWH� JHQHUDOH�� ��� HG�� %RORJQD�� =DQLFKHOOL�� ������ 
S�������0$5,18&&,��*LRUJLR��Il reato come “azione”��SDVVLP��HP�H[DXVWLYD�SHVTXLVD�VREUH�R�
WHPD��52;,1��&ODXV��&RQWULEXLomR�SDUD�D�FUtWLFD�GD�WHRULD�ÀQDOLVWD�GD�DFomR��,Q��Problemas 
fundamentais de direito penal�� 7UDG�� $QD� 3DXOD� GRV� 6DQWRV� H� /XtV� 1DWVFKHUDGHW]�� ��� HG��
/LVERD��9HJD��������S������H�VV���TXH�FRUUHVSRQGH�j�SULPHLUD�SRVLomR�GH�5R[LQ��SXEOLFDGD�
originalmente na ZStW������������S������H�VV���SRVWHULRUPHQWH�UHYLVWD�SHOR�DXWRU��vide infra���
140
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
140
OHYDQWHV�QR�kPELWR�GD�DomR��1D�REUD�GH�&LULQR�GRV�6DQWRV��D�DomR�p�GHÀQLGD�
FRPR�´DWLYLGDGH�GLULJLGD�SHOR�ÀPµ���5HDOH� -~QLRU�GHIHQGH�D� LGHLD�GH� DomR�
FRPR�H[SUHVVmR�´GH�XPD�HVFROKD�FRQVFLHQWHPHQWH�UHDOL]DGD�H�GD�HOHLomR�GRV�
PHLRV�FRQVRDQWHV�FRP�RV�ÀQV�SURSRVWRV�SHOR�TXH�R�DJLU�p�XP�FRQGX]LU�VHµ��(�
DFUHVFHQWD�TXH��VHQGR�HOD�IUXWR�GH�XPD�HVFROKD�IXQGDGD�HP�YDORUHV��´Ki��QD�
DomR��FRPR�XP�GDGR�GR�UHDO�DOpP�GD�ÀQDOLGDGH�D�¶LQWHQFLRQDOLGDGH�VLJQLÀFD-
WLYD·µ��Vy�Ki�DomR�´TXDQGR�H[LVWH�FRQVFLrQFLD�GR�ÀPµ�-���'H�RXWUD�SDUWH��*XHL-
URV�H�-DSLDVV~�FRQVLGHUDP�PDLV�DGHTXDGD�D�SURSRVWD�GH�5R[LQ��HQGRVVDQGR��
em seu recente Curso de direito penal��R�FRQFHLWR�SHVVRDO�GH�DomR���2XWUDV�RULHQ-
WDo}HV�DLQGD��FRPR�VH�SRGH�VXUSUHHQGHU�QR�WUDEDOKR�GH�%LWHQFRXUW��EXVFDP�
uma via di mezzo�� SRU�PHLR�GD� FRPELQDomR�GH� WHRULDV�� (VVH� DXWRU�� HPERUD�
UHFRQKHoD�UD]mR�DR�SRVLFLRQDPHQWR�FUtWLFR9��GHÀQH�D�DomR�FRPR�´FRPSRUWD-
PHQWR�KXPDQR�YROXQWiULR�FRQVFLHQWHPHQWH�GLULJLGR�D�XP�ÀPµ�� – conceito 
GH�FDUL]�ÀQDOLVWD��FRPR�VH�SHUFHEH�²�H�VXVWHQWD�D�VXD�FRPSDWLELOLGDGH�FRP�
D� WHRULD� VRFLDO�� ´2V� SRVWXODGRV� IXQGDPHQWDLV� GDV� GXDV� WHRULDV� ²� H[HUFtFLR�
GH� DWLYLGDGH�ÀQDO� H�XP�DJLU� VRFLDOPHQWH� UHOHYDQWH� ²� QmR� VH� H[FOXHP��PDV�
VH�FRPSOHPHQWDPµ11��(��SRU�ÀP��SRU�PpULWR�GD�REUD�GH�%XVDWR����WHP�REWLGR�
UHSHUFXVVmR� HQWUH� QyV� D� GHQRPLQDGD� WHRULD� GD� DomR� VLJQLÀFDWLYD� GH�9LYHV�
$QWyQ��(VVD�RULHQWDomR��TXH�FRPXQJD�GH�DOJXQV�SUHVVXSRVWRV�GD�WHRULD�FUtWL-
FD��FRPR�D�LQYLDELOLGDGH�GH�XP�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�SUp�WtSLFR��SURS}H�VH�D�XPD�
DSUR[LPDomR� HQWUH� DomR� H� WLSR�� DEDQGRQDQGR�DV� IXQo}HV�GH� FODVVLÀFDomR� H�
�� 6$1726��-XUDUH]�&LULQR��Direito penal��3DUWH�JHUDO�����HG��&XULWLED��,&3&��/XPHQ�-XULV��������
S������
�� 5($/(�-Ô1,25��0LJXHO�� Instituições de direito penal��3DUWH�JHUDO��5LR�GH� -DQHLUR��)RUHQVH�� 
Y��,��������S�������
�� $GRWDQGR� XPD� RULHQWDomR� ÀQDOLVWD�� WDPEpP� 1XFFL�� SDUD� TXHP� ´FRQGXWD� p� D� DomR� RX�
RPLVVmR��YROXQWiULD�H�FRQVFLHQWH��LPSOLFDQGR�XP�FRPDQGR�GH�PRYLPHQWDomR�RX�LQpUFLD�GR�
FRUSR�KXPDQR��YROWDGR�D�XPD�ÀQDOLGDGHµ��18&&,��*XLOKHUPH�GH�6RX]D��Manual de direito 
penal��3DUWH�JHUDO�����HG��6mR�3DXOR��5HYLVWD�GRV�7ULEXQDLV��������S�������
�� 628=$��$UWXU�GH�%ULWR�*XHLURV��-$3,$66��&DUORV�(GXDUGR�$GULDQR��Curso de direito penal��
5LR�GH�-DQHLUR��(OVHYLHU��������S������H�VV��6REUH�R�FRQFHLWR�SHVVRDO�GH�DomR��vide infra�
9 %,7(1&2857��&H]DU�5REHUWR��Tratado de direito penal��3DUWH�JHUDO������HG��6mR�3DXOR��6DUDLYD��
Y��,��������S������
�� %,7(1&2857��&H]DU�5REHUWR��Tratado de direito penal��S������
11 %,7(1&2857��&H]DU�5REHUWR��Tratado de direito penal��S������
�� 9HU� %86$72�� 3DXOR�&pVDU��5HÁH[}HV� VREUH� R� VLVWHPD� SHQDO� GR� QRVVR� WHPSR�� 5LR� GH� -DQHLUR��
/XPHQ�-XULV��������S������H�VV���H��GR�PHVPR�DXWRU��Direito penal��3DUWH�JHUDO��6mR�3DXOR��$WODV��
������S������H�VV��H�����H�VV��
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
141141
XQLmR��HP�SURO�GD�PDQXWHQomR�GD�IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR��´2�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�
QmR�SRGH�PDLV�GR�TXH�H[HFXWDU�XPD�IXQomR�QHJDWLYD�GH�HVWDEHOHFHU�OLPLWHV�
GH�DXVrQFLD�GH�DomRµ���
����$�IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR
(P�YHUGDGH��D�TXHVWmR�DFHUFD�GR�DWHQGLPHQWR�jV�IXQo}HV�GH�XQLmR�H�
FODVVLÀFDomR��WmR�GHEDWLGD�HP�RXWURV�HVSDoRV��QXQFD�GHVSHUWRX�JUDQGH�DWHQ-omR� GD� GRXWULQD� QDFLRQDO�� VHQGR�� LQFOXVLYH�� SRU� YH]HV�� UHOHJDGD� j� SRVLomR�
GH�SRUPHQRU�PHUDPHQWH�WHyULFR��0DLRU�LPSRUWkQFLD�VHPSUH�IRL�GHGLFDGD�j�
´IXQomR�SUiWLFDµ�GR� FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�� L�H��� j� IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR��7HQGR�
FRPR�PLVVmR�GHÀQLU��Mi�j�SDUWLGD��DTXLOR�TXH�QmR�GHVSHUWD�TXDOTXHU�LQWHUHV-
VH�GR�GLUHLWR�SHQDO��D� IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR�DSUHVHQWD�VH�FRPR�R�SULPHLUR�
ÀOWUR�GR� VLVWHPD��SURPHWHQGR�XPD� VROXomR� MXUtGLFR�SHQDO�SUiWLFD� H� UiSLGD�
SDUD�XP�JUDQGH�Q~PHUR�GH�FDVRV��D�VLPSOHV�DXVrQFLD�GH�DomR��6H�SRU�DomR�
IRU�HQWHQGLGR��S��H[���R�comportamento humano, voluntário, consciente e dirigido 
D� XP�ÀP�� QmR� H[LVWLUi� DomR�QRV� FDVRV� HP�TXH�QmR�KRXYHU�XP� VHU�KXPDQR�
QD�SRVLomR�GH�VXMHLWR�DWLYR�RX�TXDQGR�R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�KXPDQR�QmR�WLYHU�
VLGR�SUDWLFDGR�GH�IRUPD�FRQVFLHQWH��YROXQWiULD�RX�ÀQDO��(��QmR�KDYHQGR�DomR��
DSUHVHQWDP�VH�SUHMXGLFDGRV�RV�MXt]RV�GH�WLSLFLGDGH��LOLFLWXGH�H�FXOSDELOLGDGH��
LQWHUURPSHQGR�VH��GH�LPHGLDWR��D�DQiOLVH�MXUtGLFR�SHQDO�GR�IDWR��7DLV�FDVRV��
L�H���DV�KLSyWHVHV�WUDGLFLRQDOPHQWH�UHFRQKHFLGDV�FRPR�GHVSURYLGDV�GH�DomR��
FRVWXPDP�VHU�UHXQLGRV�QRV�VHJXLQWHV�JUXSRV�
(a) Ausência de comportamento humano��SDUWLQGR�VH�GD�H[LJrQFLD�GH�XP�FRP-
SRUWDPHQWR�humano�QD�EDVH�GD�FRQGXWD��QmR�SRGHP�VHU�VXMHLWRV�GH�DomR�DQL-
PDLV��HQWHV�LQDQLPDGRV��IHQ{PHQRV�GD�QDWXUH]D�H��QHP�PHVPR��SHVVRDV�MX-
UtGLFDV��
(b) Coação física irresistível (também denominada de vis absoluta)��GL]�UHVSHLWR�jV�
KLSyWHVHV�GH�DWLYLGDGH�RX�LQDWLYLGDGH�FRUSRUDO�GHWHUPLQDGD�SRU�XPD�IRUoD�
ItVLFD�DOKHLD�DR�VXMHLWR�H�HP�UHODomR�j�TXDO�HOH�QmR�SRGLD�UHVLVWLU��$�GHWHUPLQD-
omR�ItVLFD�UHWLUD�D�voluntariedade�GR�PRYLPHQWR��LPSRVVLELOLWDQGR�R�UHFRQKHFL-
PHQWR�GH�XPD�DomR��([HPSORV��(i)�QD�EHLUD�GH�XPD�SLVFLQD��$�p�YLROHQWDPHQWH�
HPSXUUDGR�SRU�%��YLQGR�D�FDLU�VREUH�XPD�FULDQoD�TXH�Oi�EULQFDYD��FDXVDQGR-
�OKH�OHV}HV�FRUSRUDLV�²�QHVVH�FDVR��QmR�Ki�DomR�SRU�SDUWH�GH�$��PDV�DSHQDV�
de B, autor da coação����(ii)�R�SDL�TXH��DPDUUDGR�QDV�PmRV�H�SpV��p�REULJDGR�D�
�� %86$72��3DXOR�&pVDU��Direito penal��S������
�� ([HPSOR� VHPHOKDQWH� HP� -(6&+(&.�� +DQV� +HLQULFK��:(,*(1'�� 7KRPDV�� Lehrbuch des 
Strafrechts��S�������628=$��$UWXU�GH�%ULWR�*XHLURV�� -$3,$66��&DUORV�(GXDUGR�$GULDQR��
Curso de direito penal��S������
142
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
142
DVVLVWLU�j�PRUWH�GR�ÀOKR��VHP�SRGHU�LPSHGL�OD�²�WHP�VH�DTXL�XPD�FRDomR�ItVLFD�
a determinar uma inatividade����1mR�Ki�DomR�RPLVVLYD�SRU�SDUWH�GR�SDL��PDV�
DSHQDV�GDTXHOH�TXH�R�DPDUURX��
$�FRDomR�ItVLFD�QmR�GHYH�VHU�FRQIXQGLGD�FRP�D�ÀJXUD�GD�coação moral irresistível, 
WDPEpP�FRQKHFLGD�FRPR�vis compulsiva��$�FRDomR�PRUDO�LQFLGH�VREUH�D�SVLTXH�GR�FRDJLGR��
7UDWD�VH�GH�XPD�DPHDoD��L�H���GD�SURPHVVD�GH�XP�PDO�FRP�YLVWDV�D�URPSHU�D�UHVLVWrQFLD�GR�
FRDJLGR�H��GHVVH�PRGR��OHYi�OR�j�SUiWLFD�GH�XPD�FRQGXWD��1HVVH�FDVR��QmR�DSHQDV�H[LVWH�
DomR��FRPR�HOD�SRGHUi�VHU�WtSLFD�H�LOtFLWD��2�UHFRQKHFLPHQWR�GD�FRDomR�PRUDO�LUUHVLVWtYHO�
LPSOLFD�DSHQDV�D� LQH[LVWrQFLD�GH�FXOSDELOLGDGH� �DUW�����GR�&3�����([���(P�UHIHUrQFLD�DRV�
H[HPSORV�Mi�XWLOL]DGRV��KDYHULD�FRDomR�PRUDO�VH��DR�LQYpV�GH�HPSXUUDU�%��$�R�FRDJLVVH�D�
SXODU�VREUH�D�FULDQoD��VRE�D�DPHDoD�GH�XPD�IDFD��RX�VH��QR�VHJXQGR�FDVR��DR�LQYpV�GH�DPDU-
UDU�R�SDL��HOH�IRVVH�DPHDoDGR�GH�PRUWH�SHOR�FRDWRU��PHGLDQWH�R�XVR�GH�DUPD�GH�IRJR��FDVR�
WHQWDVVH�VDOYDU�R�ÀOKR��2EVHUYD�VH��SRU�ÀP��TXH�R�uso de violência física prévia�H�D�SURPHVVD�
GD�VXD�FRQWLQXLGDGH�HP�FDVR�GH�UHVLVWrQFLD�QmR�WUDQVIRUPD�XPD�FRDomR�PRUDO�HP�ItVLFD��
([HPSOR��$�HVSDQFD�%�DWp�TXH�HVWH�FHGD�j�VXD�YRQWDGH�H�UHDOL]H�D�DomR�SRU�$�GHWHUPLQDGD��
FRQVLVWHQWH�QD�IDOVLÀFDomR�GH�XP�GRFXPHQWR��7UDWD�VH��SRLV��GH�XPD�KLSyWHVH�GH�FRDomR�
PRUDO��H�QmR�ItVLFD��
&DVR����7-6&��DSHODomR�FULPLQDO�����PXOKHU�FRQGHQDGD�SRU�QmR�WHU�LPSHGLGR�R�PD-
ULGR�GH�DEXVDU�VH[XDOPHQWH�GDV�ÀOKDV�PHQRUHV��HVWXSUR�GH�YXOQHUiYHO�QD�IRUPD�RPLVVLYD���
1D�PHGLGD�HP�TXH�HUD�PmH�GDV�YtWLPDV��WHULD�R�GHYHU�OHJDO�GH�LPSHGLU�RV�DEXVRV��GHYHU�
GH�JDUDQWLD���$SHOR�VRE�D�DOHJDomR�GH�coação física irresistível��7DO�TXDLV�DV�ÀOKDV��D�PmH�VHULD�
YtWLPD�GDV�DJUHVV}HV�GR�PDULGR��2�WULEXQDO�DIDVWRX�D�DOHJDomR�GH�FRDomR�ItVLFD�LUUHVLVWtYHO��
PDV�DEVROYHX�SRU�DXVrQFLD�GH�WLSLFLGDGH��'H�IDWR��QmR�Ki�FRDomR�ItVLFD�LUUHVLVWtYHO��DJLQGR�
FRUUHWDPHQWH�R�WULEXQDO��(QWUHWDQWR��D�VROXomR�ÀQDO�DWULEXtGD�DR�FDVR�p�HTXLYRFDGD��1mR�
VH�WUDWD�GH�H[FOXVmR�GD�WLSLFLGDGH��PDV�GH�OtPSLGD�KLSyWHVH�GH�FRDomR�PRUDO��D�TXDO��VH�
LUUHVLVWtYHO��DIDVWD�DSHQDV�D�FXOSDELOLGDGH��
&DVR����7-6&��DSHODomR�FULPLQDO���: semelhante ao caso 1, trata-se de mulher acu-
VDGD�GH�HVWXSUR�QD�IRUPD�RPLVVLYD��SRU�QmR�WHU�LPSHGLGR�R�FRPSDQKHLUR�GH�DEXVDU�VH-
[XDOPHQWH� GD� ÀOKD�PHQRU��$� DFXVDGD�� DEVROYLGD� HP�SULPHLUD� LQVWkQFLD�� DOHJD� WHU� VLGR�
DPHDoDGD�SRU�PHLR�GH�XPD�SHTXHQD�IRLFH��D�TXDO�WHULD��LQFOXVLYH��GHL[DGR�PDUFDV�HP�VHX�
SHVFRoR��2�7ULEXQDO�FRQÀUPD�D�DEVROYLomR�GH�SULPHLUR�JUDX��PDV�LQRYD�QR�IXQGDPHQWR��
Reconhece a ausência de ação�H��SRU�FRQVHTXrQFLD��GH�WLSLFLGDGH��HP�UD]mR�GD�RFRUUrQFLD�GH�
coação física irresistível��DPHDoD�UHDOL]DGD�SRU�PHLR�GD�IRLFH���(VVH�IXQGDPHQWR��HQWUHWDQWR��
p�HTXLYRFDGR��$�DPHDoD�SRU�PHLR�GH�XPD�IRLFH�QmR�FRQVLVWH�HP�FRDomR�ItVLFD��PDV�PRUDO��
$�FRDomR�ItVLFD�HP�KLSyWHVHV�RPLVVLYDV�Vy�p�UHFRQKHFLGD�HP�VLWXDo}HV�QDV�TXDLV�Ki�impos-
sibilidade física�GH�DJLU��DOJXpP�HVWDU�DPDUUDGR��SRU�H[����H�QmR�QRV�FDVRV�HP�TXH�D�RPLVVmR�
GHFRUUH�GD�GHFLVmR�GH�QmR�DJLU�SDUD�QmR�VRIUHU�R�PDO�SURPHWLGR�SRU�PHLR�GD�FRDomR��QmR�
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������
�� 6REUH� D� coação irresistível� QR� DUW�� ��� GR�&yGLJR� 3HQDO�� YHU� 72/('2�� )UDQFLVFR� GH�$VVLV��
Princípios básicos de direito penal�����HG��6mR�3DXOR��6DUDLYD��������S������H�VV��
�� 7-6&��$SHODomR�&ULPLQDO�Q�����������������IHY�������
�� 7-6&��$SHODomR�&ULPLQDO�Q�����������������VHW��������
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
143143
DJH��SDUD�QmR�VHU�PRUWD��S��H[����1RV�FDVRV�GH�RPLVVmR�GHFRUUHQWH�GD�SURPHVVD�GH�XP�PDO��
HVWi�VH�GLDQWH�GH�XP�OtGLPR�SUREOHPD�GH�FXOSDELOLGDGH��QR�TXDO�GHYHUi�VHU�DQDOLVDGR�VH�
HUD�H[LJtYHO�GR�UpX�FRQGXWD�GLYHUVD��L�H���VH��DSHVDU�GD�FRDomR��HOH�GHYHULD�WHU�DJLGR��RX�VH�
WDO�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�HUD�GHOH�LQH[LJtYHO��FRQÀJXUDQGR�XPD�KLSyWHVH�GH�FRDomR�PRUDO�irre-
sistível��8P�VHJXQGR�HTXtYRFR�UHVLGH�QR�UHFRQKHFLPHQWR�GH�atipicidade��SRU�GHFRUUrQFLD�GD�
DXVrQFLD�GH�DomR��3DUD�D�WHRULD�ÀQDO�GD�DomR��R�H[DPH�GD�FRQGXWD�DQWHFHGH�DR�GD�WLSLFLGDGH��
GH�PRGR�TXH��QD�DXVrQFLD�GH�DomR��D�WLSLFLGDGH�VHTXHU�FKHJD�D�VHU�DQDOLVDGD���
(c) Comportamentos desprovidos de consciência��FRUUHVSRQGH�D�PRYLPHQWRV�SUD-
WLFDGRV�HP�HVWDGRV�GH�LQFRQVFLrQFLD��VRQR�SURIXQGR��GHVPDLR��KLSQRVH��HP-
EULDJXH]�OHWiUJLFD��HQWUH�RXWURV19�
2V�HVWDGRV�KLSQyWLFRV�WrP�OHYDQWDGR�DOJXPD�FRQWURYpUVLD��/HQFNQHU�H�(LVHOH�DVVL-
QDODP�TXH�D�KLSQRVH��QD�UHDOLGDGH��FRQVLVWH�HP�XPD�´SHUWXUEDomR�GR�FRQKHFLPHQWRµ��H�
QmR�SURSULDPHQWH�XPD�DXVrQFLD�GH�FRQVFLrQFLD��R�TXH�UHVXOWDULD�DSHQDV�QD�H[FOXVmR�RX�
UHGXomR�GD�FXOSDELOLGDGH����5R[LQ��SRU�VXD�SDUWH��REVHUYD�TXH�HOD�QmR�SRGH�VHU�HTXLSDUD-
GD�DRV�PRYLPHQWRV�FDXVDGRV�SRU�VRQKRV��XPD�YH]�TXH��GLIHUHQWH�GDTXHOHV��QD�KLSQRVH�D�
DomR�p�WUDQVPLWLGD�SVLTXLFDPHQWH�H�DGDSWDGD�DR�PXQGR�FLUFXQGDQWH��2EVHUYD�TXH�KDYHULD�
XPD�HVSpFLH�GH�´EDUUHLUD�GH�FDUiWHUµ��Charakterschranke��TXH� LPSHGLULD�D�H[HFXomR�SHOR�
KLSQRWL]DGR�GH�Do}HV�HVWUDQKDV�j�VXD�SHUVRQDOLGDGH��FRPR��S��H[���D�SUiWLFD�GH�XP�GHOLWR��
'HVVH�PRGR��H�SDUWLQGR�GH�XPD�LGHLD�GH�FRQGXWD�FRPR�PDQLIHVWDomR�GD�SHUVRQDOLGDGH��
UHFRQKHFH�R�DXWRU��QHVVHV�FDVRV��D�H[LVWrQFLD�GH�DomR��LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWH�GD�SUREOHPiWLFD�
DWLQHQWH�j�FRQVFLrQFLD�GR�DWXDU���
�G��0RYLPHQWRV� UHÁH[RV� �SXUDPHQWH� VRPiWLFRV��� QmR� VH� UHFRQKHFH� D� H[LVWrQFLD�
GH�DomR�HP�PRYLPHQWRV�SXUDPHQWH�VRPiWLFRV��7UDWD�VH�GH�FRPSRUWDPHQWRV�
�SRVLWLYRV�RX�QHJDWLYRV��GHWHUPLQDGRV�SRU�´HVWtPXORV�GLULJLGRV�GLUHWDPHQWH�
DR�VLVWHPD�QHUYRVR�DXW{QRPRµ���H�TXH��SRU�HVVD�UD]mR��VH�DSUHVHQWDP�GHVSUR-
YLGRV�GH�YROXQWDULHGDGH��6mR�PDQLIHVWDo}HV�PHUDPHQWH�FRUSRUDLV��$�WtWXOR�
de ilustração, a doutrina���FRVWXPD�UHIHULU�R�DWDTXH�GH�HSLOHSVLD��R�HVSLUUR��R�19 9HU�%,7(1&2857��&H]DU�5REHUWR��Tratado de direito penal��3*��S�������)5$*262��+HOHQR�
&OiXGLR��Lições de direito penal��3DUWH�JHUDO������HG��5LR�GH�-DQHLUR��)RUHQVH��������S������
�� /(1&.1(5�� 7KHRGRU�� (,6(/(�� -|UJ�� ,Q�� 6&+g1.(�� $GROI�� 6&+5g'(5�� +RUVW��
Strafgesetzbuch Kommentar��9RUEHP�������VV���51�����S������
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������
�� 628=$��$UWXU�GH�%ULWR�*XHLURV��-$3,$66��&DUORV�(GXDUGR�$GULDQR��Curso de direito penal, 
S������
�� 9HU� )5$*262�� +HOHQR� &OiXGLR�� Lições de direito penal�� S�� ����� %,7(1&2857�� &H]DU�
5REHUWR��Tratado de direito penal��3*��S�� �����628=$��$UWXU�GH�%ULWR�*XHLURV�� -$3,$66��
&DUORV� (GXDUGR� $GULDQR�� Curso de direito penal�� S�� ����� 52;,1�� &ODXV�� Strafrecht�� $7�� 
S������H�VV���/(1&.1(5��7KHRGRU��(,6(/(��-|UJ��,Q��6&+g1.(��$GROI��6&+5g'(5��+RUVW��
Strafgesetzbuch Kommentar��9RUEHP�������VV���51�����S������
144
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
144
UXERU�HPRFLRQDO��R�Y{PLWR�LQVXVFHWtYHO�GH�FRQWHQomR��D�FRQYXOVmR�GHFRUUHQWH�
GH�XP�FKRTXH�HOpWULFR��HQWUH�RXWURV�
3UREOHPiWLFR� WHP�VH�PRVWUDGR�R� WUDWDPHQWR� MXUtGLFR�GLVSHQVDGR�DRV�movimentos 
UHÁH[RV�VRE�LQÁXrQFLD�SVtTXLFD e aos denominados atos automáticos��(P�DPERV�RV�FDVRV��QmR�
VHULD�SRVVtYHO�LGHQWLÀFDU�FRQVFLrQFLD��YROXQWDULHGDGH��ÀQDOLGDGH�RX�SODQLÀFDomR����R�TXH�
OHYDULD�j�FRQFOXVmR�SHOD�DXVrQFLD�GH�DomR��&RQWXGR��R�LQHTXtYRFR�LQWHUHVVH�MXUtGLFR�SHQDO�
VREUH�WDLV�DWRV�WHP�FRQGX]LGR�D�WHQWDWLYDV�GH�UHFRQKHFLPHQWR�GH�XPD�DomR��R�TXH�EHP�
LOXVWUD�R�HQIUHQWDPHQWR�GD�PDWpULD�QD�REUD�GH�5R[LQ��9HMDPRV��
(i) 0RYLPHQWRV�UHÁH[RV�VRE�LQÁXrQFLD�SVtTXLFD��GLIHUHQWH�GRV�PRYLPHQWRV�UHÁH�� 
[RV�SXUDPHQWH�VRPiWLFRV��KDYHULD�VLWXDo}HV�HP�TXH�R�PRYLPHQWR�UHÁH[R�HQFRQWUD�VH�́ VRE�
LQÁXrQFLD�SVtTXLFDµ��i.e.��HP�TXH�R�PRYLPHQWR�p�´WUDQVPLWLGR�SVLTXLFDPHQWH�H�GLULJLGR�D�
XP�REMHWRµ��FRPR�RFRUUH�QRV�PRYLPHQWRV�UHÁH[RV�GH�GHIHVD��&RQTXDQWR�QmR�KDMD�DTXL�
XPD�´UHÁH[mR�FRQVFLHQWHµ��5R[LQ�VXVWHQWD�KDYHU�XPD�PDQLIHVWDomR�GD�SHUVRQDOLGDGH�H��
assim, uma ação����VREUH�R�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�HP�5R[LQ��vide infra���([���DR�ID]HU�XPD�FXUYD��
HQWUD�XP�LQVHWR�SHOD�MDQHOD�GR�YHtFXOR�H�YDL�FRQWUD�RV�ROKRV�GR�PRWRULVWD��R�TXDO�UHDOL]D�
´¶XP�PRYLPHQWR�GHIHQVLYR�EUXVFR·�FRP�D�PmRµ��SHUGHQGR�R�FRQWUROH�GR�FDUUR�H�RFDVLR-
nando uma colisão��-���
(ii) $WRV�DXWRPiWLFRV��p�XPD�FDUDFWHUtVWLFD�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�KXPDQR�D�DXWRPDWL-
]DomR�GH�PRYLPHQWRV�UHDOL]DGRV�UHSHWLGDPHQWH�H�SRU�XP�ORQJR�SHUtRGR�GH�WHPSR��FRPR�VH�
SRGH�REVHUYDU��S��H[���QRV�PRYLPHQWRV�UHDOL]DGRV�DR�GLULJLU��GHEUHDU��IUHDU��ID]HU�PDUFKDV��
DFHOHUDU�HWF��(VVD�DXWRPDWL]DomR�UHWLUDULD�GR�PRYLPHQWR�D�UHÁH[mR�FRQVFLHQWH��SHU�PLWLQGR�
XPD�SUiWLFD�PDLV�UiSLGD��&RQWXGR��HPERUD�GHVSURYLGD�GH�FRQVFLrQFLD��DLQGD�DVVLP�VHULD�
SRVVtYHO��QD�SHUVSHFWLYD�GR�DXWRU��UHFRQKHFHU�D�H[LVWrQFLD�GH�XPD�DomR��QD�PHGLGD�HP�TXH�
´DV�GLVSRVLo}HV�SDUD�D�DomR�DSUHHQGLGD�SHUWHQFH�j�HVWUXWXUD�GD�SHUVRQDOLGDGHµ����([���GLUL-
JLQGR�R�VHX�YHtFXOR�j�QRLWH��HP�XPD�YHORFLGDGH�GH����NP�KRUD��R�PRWRULVWD�p�VXUSUHHQGL-
GR�SRU�XP�DQLPDO�GR�WDPDQKR�GH�XPD�OHEUH�D����RX����PHWURV�j�IUHQWH��&RP�R�REMHWLYR�GH�
�� 1HVVH� VHQWLGR��52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7�� S�� ����� VHJXQGR�R� TXDO� VHULD� SRVVtYHO� IDODU�
DSHQDV� HP� XPD� ´GLUHomR� ÀQDO� LQWHUQDµ� RX� HP� XPD� ´ÀQDOLGDGH� LQFRQVFLHQWHµ�� 2EVHUYD�
DLQGD�� HP� FRPHQWiULR� DRV�PRYLPHQWRV� UHÁH[RV� VRE� LQÁXrQFLD� SVtTXLFD�� TXH� GHVGH� XPD�
SHUVSHFWLYD�FDXVDO�RX�GH�XPD�SHUVSHFWLYD�ÀQDO�GD�DomR��VHULD�SUHFLVR�QHJDU�D�H[LVWrQFLD�GH�
XPD�DomR��52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S�������
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������
�� 7UDWDPHQWR�VHPHOKDQWH�WHP�VLGR�GLVSHQVDGR�DRV�DWRV�LPSXOVLYRV��GHQRPLQDGRV�GH�ações em 
curto-circuito��HP�UD]mR�GH�WHU�QD�VXD�RULJHP�XP�SURFHVVR�SVtTXLFR��/(1&.1(5��7KHRGRU��
(,6(/(�� -|UJ�� ,Q�� 6&+g1.(�� $GROI�� 6&+5g'(5�� +RUVW�� Strafgesetzbuch Kommentar, 
9RUEHP�������VV���51�����S�������YHU��WDPEpP��0(=*(5��(GPXQG��Strafrecht��(LQ�/HKUEXFK��
���HG��0�QFKHQ��/HLS]LJ��'XQFNHU�XQG�+XPEORW��������S������H�VV���H��HQWUH�QyV��)5$*262��
+HOHQR�&OiXGLR��Lições de direito penal��S������H�VV����2V�OLPLWHV�GHVVD�FDWHJRULD��WRGDYLD��QmR�
QRV�SDUHFHP�VXÀFLHQWHPHQWH�FODURV��UD]mR�SHOD�TXDO�R�VHX�XVR�p�DTXL�HYLWDGR����
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������H�VV�
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
145145
GHVYLDU�GR�DQLPDO��R�PRWRULVWD�JLUD�D�GLUHomR�SDUD�D�HVTXHUGD��FKRFDQGR�VH�FRP�R�guardrail 
H�FDXVDQGR�D�PRUWH�GR�SDVVDJHLUR���
3 nOtas crÍticas acerca da FunçãO de deliMitaçãO
(P�TXH�SHVHP�RV�HVIRUoRV�HPSUHHQGLGRV�H�D�DSDUHQWH�VLPSOLFLGDGH�H�
FRUUHomR�GRV� FULWpULRV� DSUHVHQWDGRV�� D� SUHWHQVD� IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR�QmR�
p� UHDOL]iYHO�SRU�XP�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�SUp�WtSLFR�� VHMD� HOH�TXDO� IRU� �VREUH�DV�
GLIHUHQWH� WHRULDV��vide infra���$V�VROXo}HV�SURSRVWDV��TXH�QR�PDLV�GDV�YH]HV�
QmR�SDVVDP�GH�FULWpULRV�GH�LPSXWDomR�LQGHYLGDPHQWH�DQWHFLSDGRV��UHVXOWDP��
QmR�UDUDPHQWH��FRQIXVDV��FRQWUDGLWyULDV�H��HP�WHUPRV�PHWRGROyJLFRV��LPSRV-
VtYHLV��9HMDPRV�DTXL��D�WtWXOR�GH�LOXVWUDomR��DSHQDV�GRLV�SRQWRV�
3ULPHLUR��$�DomR�p�XP�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�H[FOXVLYDPHQWH�humano��2�~QL� 
FR� DVSHFWR� GH� UHOHYR� GHVVD� DVVHUWLYD�� SRQWR� GH� SDUWLGD� GRV�PDLV� YDULDGRV�
FRQFHLWRV��GL]�UHVSHLWR�DR�SUREOHPD�GD�SHVVRD�MXUtGLFD�FRPR�VXMHLWR�DWLYR�GH�
FULPH��,QGHSHQGHQWH�GR�PpULWR�GD�TXHVWmR��TXH�DTXL�QmR�HVWi�HP�MRJR��QmR�p�
GLItFLO�GH�SHUFHEHU�TXH�RV�HVWULWRV�OLPLWHV�GH�XP�FRQFHLWR�SUp�WtSLFR�GH�DomR�²�
LVWR�p��GH�XP�FRQFHLWR�HODERUDGR�HP�XP�HVSDoR�SUpYLR�DRV�MXt]RV�SUySULRV�GD�
MXULGLFLGDGH�SHQDO�H��SRUWDQWR��VHP�DFHVVR�D�HOHV�²�QmR�p��GHÀQLWLYDPHQWH��R�
IRUR�DGHTXDGR�SDUD�GLVFXWLU�WDO�PDWpULD��0DLV��4XDQGR�VH�DÀUPD�XP�FRQFHLWR�
GH�DomR�H[FOXVLYDPHQWH�KXPDQR�H�GHOH�VH�YDOH�SDUD�DIDVWDU�D�UHVSRQVDELOLGD-
GH�SHQDO�GD�SHVVRD�MXUtGLFD��R�TXH�VH�WHP�QD�UHDOLGDGH�p�XPD�OtPSLGD�SHWLomR�
GH�SULQFtSLR��8P�FRQFHLWR�DVVLP�IRUPXODGR�p�PDLV�R�UHVXOWDGR�GH�XP�SRVLFLR-
QDPHQWR�GH�EDVH�LGHROyJLFD��GRJPiWLFD��SROtWLFR�FULPLQDO�H�RX�FULPLQROyJLFD�
GR�TXH�XPD�SUHPLVVD�QDWXUDO�RX�VRFLDO�HP�VL�PHVPR�YiOLGD�TXH�SRVVD�SUHGH-
WHUPLQDU�j�SDUWLGD�WRGD�D�HVWUXWXUD�WHyULFD�GR�FULPH��(P�RXWUDV�SDODYUDV��Ki�
PXLWDV�UD]}HV�SDUD�VH�RSRU�j�UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH�SHQDO�GD�SHVVRD�MXUtGLFD��PDV�
R�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�QmR�p�XPD�GHODV��
6HJXQGR��2V�FULWpULRV�XWLOL]DGRV��DSDUHQWHPHQWH�LQGHSHQGHQWHV�GD�MX-
ULGLFLGDGH�SHQDO��VmR�HP�UHDOLGDGH�FULWpULRV�GH�LPSXWDomR��(i)�$�FRDomR�ItVLFD�
Vy�H[FOXL�D�DomR�VH�IRU�LUUHVLVWtYHO��6HU�RX�QmR�LUUHVLVWtYHO�QmR�p�DOJR��SRUpP��
TXH�SRVVD�VHU�GHWHUPLQDGR�VHP�FULWpULRV�GH�YDORU��FRPR�VH�FRUUHVSRQGHVVH�
D�XP�VLPSOHV�FiOFXOR�GH�IRUoDV�ItVLFDV��1mR�Ki�G~YLGD�GH�TXH�Ki�UHOHYR�SH-
QDO�VH��S��H[���D�SHVVRD�HPSXUUDGD�QD�EHLUD�GD�SLVFLQD�FRQWULEXLX�GH�IRUPD�
QHJOLJHQWH�SDUD�R�IDWR��RX�VH�R�SDL��SRU�QHJOLJrQFLD��QmR�SHUFHEHX�TXH�KDYLD�
FRPR�HVFDSDU�GDV�DPDUUDV�H�LPSHGLU�D�PRUWH�GR�ÀOKR��(ii)�'D�PHVPD�IRUPD��
RV�DWRV�HP�HVWDGR�GH�LQFRQVFLrQFLD�RX�RV�PRYLPHQWRV�UHÁH[RV�LUmR�H[FOXLU�D�
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������
146
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
146
DomR�DSHQDV�QRV�FDVRV�HP�TXH�QmR�KRXYHU�UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH�QD�IRUPD�GH�actio 
libera in causa��,VVR�VLJQLÀFD�TXH��SDUD�DSOLFDU�R�FULWpULR�GH�H[FOXVmR�GD�DomR��
p�SUHFLVR�DQDOLVDU�D�UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH�MXUtGLFR�SHQDO�GR�IDWR�QD�VXD�LQWHLUH]D��
YDOH�GL]HU�� p�SUHFLVR� LQJUHVVDU�QR�kPELWR�GD� WLSLFLGDGH�H� FRQVLGHUDU�R� IDWR�
D� SDUWLU� GRV� UHVSHFWLYRV� FULWpULRV� GH� LPSXWDomR�� (� VH� LVVR� p� DVVLP�� QmR� ID]�
VHQWLGR�DOJXP��DSyV�D�FRQFOXVmR�GD�DQiOLVH�MXUtGLFR�SHQDO��UHWRUQDU�j�IDVH�GD�
DomR�SDUD�H[FOXt�OD��0XLWR�SHOR�FRQWUiULR��7DO�UHJUHVVmR�p�LPSRVVtYHO��'DGR�
R�PpWRGR�GH�DQiOLVH�HVFDORQDGR��Vy�Ki�D�YHULÀFDomR�GD�WLSLFLGDGH�VH�KRXYHU�
DomR��/RJR��LPSRVVtYHO�FKHJDU�j�WLSLFLGDGH��VHP�R�UHFRQKHFLPHQWR�SUpYLR�GD�
H[LVWrQFLD�GH�XPD�DomR��(��in casu��FRPR�VH�Yr��p�LPSRVVtYHO�UHFRQKHFHU�XPD�
DomR��VHP�D�DQiOLVH�SUpYLD�GD�WLSLFLGDGH��(iii)�1R�TXH�VH�UHIHUH�j�RPLVVmR��QmR�
p�GLIHUHQWH��6y�VH�SRGH�IDODU�HP�RPLVVmR�VH�KRXYHU�SRVVLELOLGDGH�GH�DomR��2�
FRPSRUWDPHQWR�GR�SDL�TXH��HP�UD]mR�GH�HVWDU�DPDUUDGR��QmR�S{GH�VDOYDU�R�ÀOKR��vide supra��DSHQDV�QmR�FRQÀJXUDULD�XPD�DomR�VH�UHFRQKHFLGD�D�LPSRVVL-
ELOLGDGH�GH�DJLU��2FRUUH�TXH�D�SRVVLELOLGDGH�GH�DJLU�GHSHQGH�GLUHWDPHQWH�GH�
PXLWDV�YDULiYHLV��L�H.��QDWXUH]D��IXQGDPHQWR�H�H[WHQVmR�GR�GHYHU�GH�DJLU��H�
GH�HOHPHQWRV�HVWULWDPHQWH�SHVVRDLV�H�FLUFXQVWDQFLDLV��LPSOLFDQGR�XPD�DQiOLVH�
TXH�p�SUySULD�GR�MXt]R�GH�LPSXWDomR�QRV�FULPHV�RPLVVLYRV����(iv)�$�H[LJrQFLD�
GH�FRQVFLrQFLD�p�TXDVH�XPD�FRQVWDQWH�HP�WRGDV�DV�GLIHUHQWHV�WHRULDV�GD�DomR��
VHP�FRQVFLrQFLD�QmR�Ki�DomR��&RQWXGR��FRPR�EHP�UHFRQKHFH�5R[LQ��vide su-
pra���HOD�QmR�HVWi�SUHVHQWH�HP�FDVRV�GH�LQGLVFXWtYHO�UHOHYR�SHQDO��FRPR�QRV�
PRYLPHQWRV�UHÁH[RV�VRE�LQÁXrQFLD�SVtTXLFD�H�QRV�DWRV�DXWRPiWLFRV��3RLV�p�
H[DWDPHQWH�R�SUpYLR�UHFRQKHFLPHQWR�GH�UHOHYR�SHQDO�TXH�OHYD�D�HVIRUoRV�QR�
VHQWLGR�GH�FRQWRUQDU�R�SUREOHPD�QR�kPELWR�GD�DomR��R�TXH�GHPRQVWUD�VHU�HVVH�
QDGD�PDLV�GR�TXH�XPD�DQWHFLSDomR�GH�FULWpULRV�GH� LPSXWDomR�H�QmR��FRPR�
VH�TXHU�ID]HU�FUHU��XP�MXt]R�QHXWUR�HP�WHUPRV�MXUtGLFR�SHQDLV��SDXWDGR�SRU�
FDWHJRULDV�GR�VHU�RX�GD�SHVVRD�
3RU�ÀP��SRGHULD� VH�SHQVDU� TXH� R� LPSDVVH�GD� IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR�
UHVLGLULD�H[FOXVLYDPHQWH�QR�FDUiWHU�SUp�WtSLFR�GD�DomR��FRQWRUQiYHO�SRU�PHLR�
GH�XP�FRQFHLWR�FUtWLFR�GH�DomR�FRPR�UHDOL]DomR�GR�WLSR��8PD�WDO�FRQFOXVmR��
�� -HVFKHFN� H� :HLJHQG� WHQWDP� FRQWRUQDU� HVVH� SUREOHPD� YDOHQGR�VH� GH� XPD� ´FDSDFLGDGH�
JHUDO�GH�DomRµ��D�TXDO�QmR�OHYDULD�HP�FRQVLGHUDomR�DV�FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV�SHVVRDLV�GR�RPLWHQWH�
�-(6&+(&.�� +DQV� +HLQULFK�� :(,*(1'�� 7KRPDV�� Lehrbuch des Strafrechts�� S�� ������ 7DO�
UHFXUVR�� WRGDYLD�� QmR� UHVROYH� R� SUREOHPD�GD� QDWXUH]D� MXUtGLFR�SHQDO� GRV� UHIHUHQFLDLV� GH�
DQiOLVH��0DV�� DLQGD� TXH� LVVR� IRVVH� VXSHUDGR�� XPD� FDSDFLGDGH�PHUDPHQWH� JHUDO� GH� DomR��
DOKHLD� j� FRQFUHWXGH�GR� IDWR�� LPSOLFDULD� R� UHFRQKHFLPHQWR�GH�XPD� VLPSOHV�SUHVXQomR�GH�
RPLVVmR�
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
147147
SRUpP��VHULD�HTXLYRFDGD����1mR�p�SRVVtYHO�DWULEXLU�XPD�IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR�
j�DomR�VHP�OKH�GHVLJQDU�XP�FRQWH~GR�SUySULR�H�H[FOXVLYR�TXH�OKH�SHUPLWD�
H[HUFHU�HVVD�IXQomR��UHVXOWDQGR��DR�ÀP�H�DR�FDER��HP�XP�HVIRUoR�GH�DXWRQR-
PL]DomR��SRU� WRGR�R�H[SRVWR�� LQ~WLO��GHVQHFHVViULR�H��QR�kPELWR�GD�SUySULD�
WLSLFLGDGH��PHWRGRORJLFDPHQWH�LQDGHTXDGR��
4 a eVOluçãO histÓrica dO cOnceitO de açãO e as razÕes 
Para O seu abandOnO
����2�FRQFHLWR�FDXVDO��QDWXUDO��GH�DomR
2�FRQFHLWR�FDXVDO�GH�DomR�UHPRQWD�j�GHQRPLQDGD�concepção clássica de 
crime��GHVHQYROYLGD�QR�ÀQDO�GR�VpFXOR�;,;�QD�$OHPDQKD��D�SDUWLU��SULQFLSDO-
PHQWH��GRV�FpOHEUHV�HVFULWRV�GH�)UDQ]�YRQ�/LV]W�H�(UQVW�%HOLQJ����(VWDEHOHFLGD�
D�SDUWLU�GRV�SUHVVXSRVWRV�LGHROyJLFRV�H�PHWRGROyJLFRV�GR�HQWmR�KHJHP{QLFR�
SRVLWLYLVPR�QDWXUDOLVWD��D�FRQFHSomR�FOiVVLFD�GR�FULPH�HPSHQKDYD�VH�HP�UH-
DOL]DU�QR�GLUHLWR�SHQDO�RV� LGHDLV�GH�H[DWLGmR�FLHQWtÀFD�SUySULR�GDV�FLrQFLDV�
QDWXUDLV��%XVFDYD�VH�R�Pi[LPR�SRVVtYHO�HP�WHUPRV�GH�REMHWLYLGDGH��RUGHP�H�
VHJXUDQoD��H��SDUD�WDQWR��YDOLD�VH�GH�FRQFHLWRV�OLPLWDGRV�D�UHDOLGDGHV�SHUFHSWt-
YHLV�SHORV�VHQWLGRV��D�UHDOLGDGHV�GR�PXQGR�QDWXUDO��2�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR��QHVVH�
FRQWH[WR��FRPR�SHGUD�DQJXODU�GH�WRGR�R�VLVWHPD�SHQDO��GHYHULD�DWHQGHU��GH�
IRUPD�LGHDO��D�HVVD�SUHFLVD�SUHWHQVmR��GHYHULD�VHU�FRQVWLWXtGR�H[FOXVLYDPHQWH�
SRU�UHDOLGDGHV�VHQVtYHLV���
2�SRVLWLYLVPR�MXUtGLFR��HP�WHUPRV�JHUDLV��FRUUHVSRQGH�D�XPD�FRUUHQWH�GH�SHQVD-
PHQWR�DPSODPHQWH�GLIXQGLGD�QD�VHJXQGD�PHWDGH�GR�VpFXOR�;,;�H�PDUFDGD��HQWUH�RXWUDV�
FRLVDV��SHOR�UHS~GLR�D�WRGD�H�TXDOTXHU�IRUPD�GH�PHWDItVLFD��HP�SURO�GH�XPD�SHUVSHFWLYD�
�� (P� VHQWLGR� FRQWUiULR�� GHIHQGHQGR� D� FRPSDWLELOLGDGH� GD� WHRULD� FUtWLFD� FRP� XPD� IXQomR�
QHJDWLYD� UHPDQHVFHQWH�� /(1&.1(5�� 7KHRGRU�� (,6(/(�� -|UJ�� ,Q�� 6&+g1.(�� $GROI��
6&+5g'(5��+RUVW��Strafgesetzbuch Kommentar��9RUEHP�������VV���51�����S������
�� 9HU�-(6&+(&.��+DQV�+HLQULFK��:(,*(1'��7KRPDV��Lehrbuch des Strafrechts��$7��S������H�
VV���52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������H�VV���',$6��-RUJH�GH�)LJXHLUHGR��Direito penal��3*��
S������H�VV��
�� .$8)0$11�� $UWKXU�� $� SUREOHPiWLFD� GD� ÀORVRÀD� GR� GLUHLWR� DR� ORQJR� GD� KLVWyULD�� ,Q��
.$8)0$11��$UWKXU��+$66(0(5��:LQIULHG�� ,QWURGXomR� j� ÀORVRÀD� GR� GLUHLWR� H� j� WHRULD� GR�
direito contemporâneas��7UDG��GH�0DUFRV�.HHO�H�0DQXHO�GH�2OLYHLUD��UHY��H�FRRUG��GH�$QWyQLR�
0DQXHO�+HVSDQKD��/LVERD��)XQGDomR�&DORXVWH�*XOEHQNLDQ��������S������H�VV���021&$'$��
/��&DEUDO�GH��)LORVRÀD�GR�GLUHLWR�H�GR�(VWDGR�����HG��&RLPEUD��&RLPEUD�(GLWRUD��Y��,�������������
UHLPS����S������H�VV��
148
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
148
HPSLULVWD����2�FRQKHFLPHQWR�GHYHULD�VHU�SURGX]LGR�QRV�HVWULWRV�OLPLWHV�GD�H[SHULrQFLD��GD�
REVHUYDomR�GRV�IDWRV�VHQVtYHLV�H�GD�FDXVDOLGDGH����3URSXQKD��QD�SUHFLVD�VtQWHVH�GH�&DEUDO�
0RQFDGD��´D�VXMHLomR�GH�WRGD�D�YLGD�GD�FXOWXUD�DRV�HVTXHPDV�GDV�FLrQFLDV�QDWXUDLV��FRP�D�
HQWURQL]DomR�GD�LGHLD�GH�FDXVDOLGDGH�PHFkQLFDµ��(��DVVLP�DJLQGR��DFDEDYD�SRU�UHSUHVHQ-
WDU�´QmR�Vy�XPD�PHFDQL]DomR�GH�WRGR�R�SHQVDPHQWR��PDV�XPD�VXEHVWLPDomR��RX�PHVPR�
XP�WRWDO�GHVSUH]R��SRU�WRGRV�RV�FRQWH~GRV�LGHDLV�H�HVSLULWXDLV�GD�YLGD�WDQWR�GR�LQGLYtGXR�
FRPR�GD�VRFLHGDGHµ���
(PERUD�R�FRQFHLWR�FDXVDO�GH�DomR�WHQKD�VRIULGR�YDULDo}HV�VLJQLÀFDWLYDV�
DR� ORQJR�GR� VHX�GHVHQYROYLPHQWR�²� FRPR��DOLiV��QmR�SRGHULD� VHU�GLIHUHQWH�
²��XPD�GDV�HODERUDo}HV�PDLV�H[SUHVVLYDV�GHVVH�SHUtRGR�SRGH�VHU�HQFRQWUD-
GD�QD����HGLomR�GR�Lehrbuch des deutschen Strafrechts, GH�Y��/LV]W��1HVVD�REUD��
SXEOLFDGD�HP�������SURSXQKD�R�DXWRU�XPD�GHÀQLomR�GH�DomR�HVWDEHOHFLGD�QD�
´FDXVDomR�GH�XPD�PRGLÀFDomR�QR�PXQGR�H[WHULRU�UHDOL]DGD�SRU�PHLR�GH�XP�
PRYLPHQWR�FRUSRUDO�KXPDQR�YROXQWiULRµ����+DYHULD��SRU�XP�ODGR��D�H[LJrQ-
FLD�FRQVWDQWH��H�SDUD� WRGDV�DV� IRUPDV�GH�DSDULomR�GR�FULPH��GRV�HOHPHQWRV�
H[WHULRUHV�movimento corporal humano e PRGLÀFDomR�GR�PXQGR�H[WHULRU, unidos 
HQWUH�VL�SHOR�nexo de causalidade��FDXVDOLGDGH�SHUFHELGD�QRV�WHUPRV�GD�WHRULD�
GD� HTXLYDOrQFLD� GDV� FRQGLo}HV��� H�� SRU� RXWUR�� D� H[LJrQFLD� GH�XP� HOHPHQWR�
VXEMHWLYR��D�voluntariedade�
%HOLQJ��HP�FRQWUDSDUWLGD��GHIHQGLD�XP�FRQFHLWR�PDLV�HQ[XWR�GH�DomR��
6HJXQGR�R�DXWRU��D�WHRULD�GD�DomR�QmR�GHYHULD�FRQWHPSODU�HOHPHQWRV�SUySULRV�
GR� IDWR� FULPLQRVR�� FRPR�R� UHVXOWDGR��R�REMHWR�GD�DomR� H� D� FDXVDOLGDGH��QD�
PHGLGD�HP�TXH�D�DXVrQFLD�GHVVHV�HOHPHQWRV�QmR�DIHWDULD�D�H[LVWrQFLD�GH�XPD�
DomR�HP�VL��PDV�VLP�DV�FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV�GH�XPD�GHWHUPLQDGD�DomR�H[LVWHQWH��
$IDVWDQGR�WDO�FRQWH~GR�GR�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR��UHVWDULD��SDUD�ÀQV�GH�YHULÀFDomR�
GD�VXD�H[LVWrQFLD��D�VLPSOHV�FRQVWDWDomR�GD�UHDOL]DomR�YROXQWiULD�GH�XP�PR-
YLPHQWR�FRUSRUDO�RX�GH�XP�QmR�PRYLPHQWR�FRUSRUDO����$�DomR�VHULD�GHÀQLGD�
�� 2�VXUJLPHQWR�GR�SRVLWLYLVPR�p�PXLWDV�YH]HV�DWULEXtGD�j�REUD�GR�IUDQFrV�$XJXVWH�&RPWH��
(VVD�SDWHUQLGDGH��WRGDYLD��QmR�JR]D�GH�FRQVHQVR��6HJXQGR�$UWKXU�.DXIPDQQ��WDO�GHVLJQDomR�
Vy�p�FRUUHWD�QR�VHQWLGR�GH�TXH�IRL�&RPWH�TXHP�EDWL]RX�HVWD�FRUUHQWH��D�SDUWLU�GD�LGHLD�GH�
´SRVLWLYLVPRµ�FRPR�´OLPLWDomR�GD�FLrQFLD�DR�TXH�p�H[SHULPHQWiYHO� �GDGR�¶SRVLWLYDPHQWH·µ�
�.$8)0$11��$UWKXU��$�SUREOHPiWLFD�GD�ÀORVRÀD�GR�GLUHLWR�DR�ORQJR�GD�KLVWyULD��S�������
�� 021&$'$��/��&DEUDO�GH��)LORVRÀD�GR�GLUHLWR�H�GR�(VWDGR��S������H�VV���.$8)0$11��$UWKXU��
$�SUREOHPiWLFD�GD�ÀORVRÀD�GR�GLUHLWR�DR�ORQJR�GD�KLVWyULD��S������
�� 021&$'$��/��&DEUDO�GH��)LORVRÀD�GR�GLUHLWR�H�GR�(VWDGR��S������H�VV��
�� /,6=7��)UDQ]�Y��Lehrbuch des deutschen Strafrechts�� ��� HG��%HUOLQ��/HLS]LJ��*XWWHQWDJ�� ����� 
�S������
�� %(/,1*��(UQVW��Die Lehre vom Verbrechen��S�����
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
149149
FRPR�PHUR� ´FRPSRUWDPHQWR� KXPDQR� YROXQWiULRµ�� D� FRPSUHHQGHU� WDQWR� D�
DomR�HP�VHQWLGR�HVWULWR� �PRYLPHQWR�FRUSRUDO�YROXQWiULR��� FRPR�R�FRPSRU-
WDPHQWR�RPLVVLYR� �LPRELOLGDGH�YROXQWiULD�����(VVH�FRQFHLWR��SRU�VXD� WmR�UH-
GX]LGD�FRQIRUPDomR��UHFHEHX�GR�SUySULR�%HOLQJ�D�GHVLJQDomR�GH�´IDQWDVPD�
H[DQJXHµ���
2�FRQFHLWR�FDXVDO��H�FRPR�GH�SURQWR�VH�SRGH�LQWXLU��QmR�ORJURX�DWHQGHU�
jV�IXQo}HV�SUHWHQGLGDV�SHOR�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR��'D�PHVPD�IRUPD�TXH�D�VXD�WHR-
ULD�GH�EDVH��R�SRVLWLYLVPR�QDWXUDOLVWD��PRVWURX�VH�PDQLIHVWDPHQWH�LQFDSD]�GH�
FRPSUHHQGHU�H�OLGDU�FRP�DV�FRLVDV�GR�GLUHLWR�SHQDO��WDPEpP�R�FRQFHLWR�FDXVDO�DSUHVHQWRX�VH�LQDSWR�HP�IRUPXODU�XP�FRQFHLWR�XQLWiULR�GH�DomR��
3ULPHLUDPHQWH��p�SUHFLVR�WHU�HP�FRQWD�TXH�D�WHQWDWLYD�GH�UHGX]LU�R�IDWR�
FULPLQRVR�D�UHDOLGDGHV�SVLFRItVLFDV�LPSOLFD�QmR�DSHQDV�GLVWRUo}HV�VLJQLÀFD-
WLYDV��PDV�R�HIHWLYR�H�GHOLEHUDGR�DEDQGRQR�GDTXLOR�TXH�Ki�GH�PDLV�SUySULR�
QD�LQIUDomR�FULPLQDO��R�VHX�VHQWLGR�VRFLDO��'HVFUHYHU�D�DomR�stricto sensu como 
LQHUYDomR�PXVFXODU�YROXQWiULD���RX�R�HVIRUoR�GH�%HOLQJ�HP�UHGX]LU�D�RPLVVmR�
D�XP�IHQ{PHQR�SVLFRItVLFR��PDQLIHVWR�QD�FRQWHQomR�GRV�QHUYRV�PRWRUHV�²�in 
verbis��´D�RPLVVmR�p�FRQWHQomR�GRV�QHUYRV�PRWRUHV��D�YRQWDGH�GRPLQD�RV�QHU-
YRV�DTXL�WDO�TXDO�QD�HVWLPXODomR�GR�FRUSR��HOD�GLUHFLRQD�VH�FRQWUD�D�LQHUYDomR�
H�D�FRQFHQWUDomR�PXVFXODUµ���²�SURGX]HP�SURQWR�HVWUDQKDPHQWR��GDGR�R�VHX�
GLVWDQFLDPHQWR�HP�UHODomR�j�UHDOLGDGH�GD�YLGD��(VVH�GLVWDQFLDPHQWR�SRGH-
ULD�VHU�FRPSHQVDGR��p�YHUGDGH��VH�FRUUHVSRQGHVVH�D�XP�GHVYHODU�GR�HIHWLYR�
FRQWH~GR�GHVVDV�FDWHJRULDV��HYHQWXDOPHQWH�WXUEDGR�HP�VXD�SHUFHSomR�FRPX-
QLWiULD��0DV�QmR�p�HVVH�R�FDVR��3HOR�FRQWUiULR��$�VXEPLVVmR�GR�GLUHLWR�SHQDO�
DRV�HVWULWRV�GRPtQLRV�GR�PXQGR�GR�VHU�PRVWURX�VH��DOpP�GH�DUELWUiULD�H�SRX-
FR�~WLO��YHUGDGHLUDPHQWH� LUUHDOL]iYHO��$�RPLVVmR�QmR�H[LVWH�HP�XP�PXQGR�
HVWULWDPHQWH�SVLFRItVLFR��(OD�DWp�SRGH�WHU�XPD�IHLomR�SVLFRItVLFD��PDV�MDPDLV�
H[LVWrQFLD�SVLFRItVLFD��QD�PHGLGD�HP�TXH�D�VXD�H[LVWrQFLD�HVWi�QHFHVVDULDPHQ-
WH�FRQGLFLRQDGD�D�XP�HOHPHQWR�HVWUDQKR�DR�PXQGR�GR�VHU��R�GHYHU�GH�DJLU��
(�DGHPDLV��QHP�PHVPR�XPD�VXD�HYHQWXDO�IHLomR�SVLFRItVLFD�SRGHULD�VHU�OLPL-
WDGD�j�FRQWHQomR�GRV�QHUYRV�PRWRUHV��$�LGHLD�GH�FRQWHQomR�SUHVVXS}H�D�GH�
LPSXOVR��L�H���GH�DOJR�D�VHU�FRQWLGR��(P�RXWUDV�SDODYUDV��WHULD�TXH�VH�SUHVVXSRU�
XPD�HVSpFLH�GH�LPSXOVR�QDWXUDO�GH�DomR�HP�DWHQGHU�R�GHYHU�MXUtGLFR��R�TXDO��
�� %(/,1*��(UQVW��Die Lehre vom Verbrechen��S����
�� %(/,1*��(UQVW��Die Lehre vom Verbrechen��S�����
�� /,6=7�� )UDQ]� Y��Das deutsche Reichsstrafrecht auf Grund des Reichsstrafgesetzbuchs und der 
übrigen strafrechtlichen Reichsgesetze�����HG��%HUOLQ��/HLS]LJ��*XWWHQWDJ��������S������
�� %(/,1*��(UQVW��Die Lehre vom Verbrechen��S�����
150
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
150
QD�RPLVVmR��YLULD�D�VHU�YROXQWDULDPHQWH�FRQWLGR�SHOR�VXMHLWR��,VVR��SRUpP��p�
FODUDPHQWH�LQVXVWHQWiYHO��$R�VRQHJDU�LPSRVWRV��v.g., o omitente certamente 
QmR�HVWi�D�FRQWHU�XP�LPSXOVR�QDWXUDO�GH�UHFROKHU�WULEXWRV��
,QGHSHQGHQWH�GLVVR��R�IDWR�p�TXH�XP�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�HVWDEHOHFLGR�QRV�
elementos movimento corporal, voluntariedade, PRGLÀFDomR�GR�PXQGR� H[WHULRU�e 
causalidade��FRPR�SURSRVWR�SRU�Y��/LV]W��QmR�p�FDSD]�GH�FRQWHPSODU�R�FRPSRU-
WDPHQWR�RPLVVLYR�H�QHP�PHVPR�D�WRWDOLGDGH�GRV�GHOLWRV�FRPLVVLYRV��IUDFDV-
VDQGR��DVVLP��WDPEpP�QR�DWHQGLPHQWR�GD�IXQomR�FODVVLÀFDWyULD��&DXVDOLGDGH�
H�PRGLÀFDomR�GR�PXQGR�H[WHULRU�QmR�VmR��HYLGHQWHPHQWH��FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV�GRV�
FULPHV�RPLVVLYRV�²�R�SDL�TXH�DVVLVWH�R�ÀOKR�PRUUHU�DIRJDGR�VHP�DJLU�HP�VHX�
VRFRUUR�QmR�p�FDXVD�ItVLFR�PHFkQLFD�GD�PRUWH�GR�ÀOKR��PDV�VLP�R�DIRJDPHQWR�
H�RV�HOHPHQWRV�GD�VXD�FDGHLD�FDXVDO��LVWR�p��R�SDL�QmR�FDXVD�D�PRUWH�GR�ÀOKR��H�
VLP�GHL[D�GH�LPSHGL�OD��H�QHP�WRGRV�RV�GHOLWRV�FRPLVVLYRV�PRGLÀFDP�R�PXQ-
GR�H[WHULRU��FRPR�EHP�LOXVWUD�D�FRQGXWD�GH�YLRODomR�GH�GRPLFtOLR�FXMD�IHLomR�
QDWXUDO�UHVWULQJH�VH�DR�SUySULR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�GH�HQWUDU�RX�SHUPDQHFHU�HP�
FDVD�DOKHLD�RX�HP�VXDV�GHSHQGrQFLDV��DUW������GR�&3���
3RU�PDLV�TXH�Y��/LV]W��QDV�SULPHLUDV�HGLo}HV�GR�VHX�Lehrbuch��WHQKD�VH�HVIRUoDGR�HP�
demonstrar a causalidade da omissão����WDO�SUHWHQVmR�DFDERX�SRU�VHU�SRU�HOH�PHVPR�DEDQ-
GRQDGD��1D�HGLomR�EUDVLOHLUD�GH�������WUDGX]LGD�SRU�-RVp�+\JLQR�'XDUWH�3HUHLUD��Y��/LV]W�
Mi�UHFRQKHFLD�TXH��GLIHUHQWH�GRV�FULPHV�FRPLVVLYRV��QRV�FULPHV�RPLVVLYRV�KDYHULD�DSHQDV�
uma equiparação�HQWUH�R�QmR�LPSHGLPHQWR�GR�UHVXOWDGR�H�D�VXD�FDXVDomR��´(VWD�HTXLSDUD-
omRµ��VmR�SDODYUDV�GR�DXWRU��´QmR�VLJQLÀFD�TXH�VH�GHYD�WDPEpP�YHU�QR�QmR�LPSHGLPHQWR�
XPD�FDXVDomR�GR�UHVXOWDGR��D�SXQLELOLGDGH�GD�RPLVVmR�p�FRPSOHWDPHQWH� LQGHSHQGHQWH�
GH�VXD�FDXVDOLGDGHµ��$GPLWLQGR�DLQGD�TXH�R�QmR�LPSHGLU�SRGHULD�VHU�SXQLGR�GH�IRUPD�
PDLV�EUDQGD�TXH�R�FDXVDU�H��LQFOXVLYH��TXH�D�RPLVVmR�SRGHULD�VHU�SXQLGD�LQGHSHQGHQWH�GR�
resultado���
'H�RXWUD�SDUWH��WDPEpP�R�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�GH�%HOLQJ��DLQGD�TXH�UHGX-
]LGR�D�HOHPHQWRV�PtQLPRV��FRQGXWD�KXPDQD�H�YROXQWDULHGDGH���QmR�VH�PRV-
WURX�DSWR�D� VXSHUDU�RV�SUREOHPDV� HQIUHQWDGRV�SHOD� HODERUDomR�GH�Y��/LV]W��
$� FRQÀJXUDomR� GHPDVLDGDPHQWH� HQ[XWD� GR� FRQFHLWR� GH� DomR� FRORFRX�� GH�
SURQWR��SUREOHPDV�UHODWLYRV�j�IXQomR�GH�XQLmR��8PD�QRomR�GH�DomR�UHGX]LGD�
j�VLPSOHV�LGHLD�GH�PRYLPHQWR�FRUSRUDO�YROXQWiULR�IDOKD�HP�DSUHVHQWDU�XP�
FRQWH~GR�PDWHULDO�DSWR�D�ÀJXUDU�FRPR�HOHPHQWR�GH�EDVH�SDUD�RV� MXt]RV�GH�
WLSLFLGDGH��LOLFLWXGH�H�FXOSDELOLGDGH��(VVH�SUREOHPD��DOLiV��p�UHFRQKHFLGR�SRU�
�� /,6=7��)UDQ]�Y��Das deutsche Reichsstrafrecht�����HG����������S�����H�VV���/,6=7��)UDQ]�Y��Lehrbuch 
des deutschen Strafrechts�����HG���������S������H�VV�
�� /,6=7��)UDQ]�Y��Tratado de direito penal alemão��7UDG��SRU�-RVp�+\JLQR�'XDUWH�3HUHLUD��5LR�GH�
-DQHLUR��)��%ULJXLHW��W��,��������S������H�VV�
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
151151
%HOLQJ�DR�GHVLJQDU�R�VHX�SUySULR�FRQFHLWR�FRPR�IDQWDVPD�H[DQJXH�� e de certo 
PRGR�VROXFLRQDGR�FRP�D�SURSRVLomR�GR�WLSR��H�QmR�GD�DomR��FRPR�FRQFHLWR�
GH�EDVH�H�SHGUD�DQJXODU�GD�WHRULD�GR�FULPH����'H�RXWUD�SDUWH��QR�TXH�WDQJH�
HVSHFLÀFDPHQWH�j�IXQomR�FODVVLÀFDWyULD��REVHUYD�VH�TXH�QHP�PHVPR�D�VLQJHOD�
QRomR�GH�YROXQWDULHGDGH�SRGH�VHU�H[LJLGD�GH�WRGDV�DV�IRUPDV�GHOLWLYDV��7DO�p�
R�TXH�RFRUUH�QDV�KLSyWHVHV�GH�FULPHV�RPLVVLYRV�SRU�FXOSD�LQFRQVFLHQWH��FRPR�
QD�RPLVVmR�GR�GHYHU�GH�DJLU��SRU�HVTXHFLPHQWR�LPSXWiYHO�D�WtWXOR�GH�QHJOL-
JrQFLD��1mR�Ki��DTXL��TXDOTXHU�YROXQWDULHGDGH�SRU�SDUWH�GR�DJHQWH��XPD�YH]�
TXH�HOH�VHTXHU�VH�RFXSD�GH�IRUPD�LQWHOHFWLYD�DFHUFD�GD�´DomRµ�FRPHWLGD�SRU�
VL��$OpP�GR�PDLV��QmR�QRV�SDUHFH�LJXDOPHQWH�VROXFLRQDU�D�TXHVWmR��YDOHU�VH�
GH�XPD�FRQFHSomR�GH�YROXQWDULHGDGH�SRWHQFLDO��LVWR�p��QR�IDWR�GH�WHU�KDYLGR�D�
SRVVLELOLGDGH�GH�DWHQGHU�YROXQWDULDPHQWH�DR�PDQGDPHQWR�GH�DJLU��HLV�TXH�VH�
PDQLIHVWDU�GH�IRUPD�YROXQWiULD�H�VHU�SRVVtYHO�PDQLIHVWDU�VH�GH�IRUPD�YROXQ-
WiULD�QmR�DSHQDV�VmR�FDWHJRULDV�ORJLFDPHQWH�GLVWLQWDV��FRPR�D�DÀUPDomR�GHVWD�
QHJD�D�SUySULD�H[LVWrQFLD�in concreto�GDTXHOD���
����2�FRQFHLWR�ÀQDO�GH�DomR
9DOHQGR�VH�GR� DJLU�GRORVR� FRPR�SDUDGLJPD�GR� IHQ{PHQR�GHOLWLYR� H�
EXVFDQGR�XPD�HODERUDomR�GH�EDVH�RQWROyJLFD��+DQV�:HO]HO��QD�SULPHLUD�PH-
WDGH�GR�VpFXOR�;;��SURSXJQDYD�XP�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�FHQWUDGR�QD� LGHLD�GH�
ÀQDOLGDGH��´$�ÀQDOLGDGH�RX�R�FDUiWHU�ÀQDO�GD�DomRµ��DÀUPDYD�:HO]HO��
IXQGDPHQWD�VH�QR�IDWR�GH�R�KRPHP��JUDoDV�DR�VHX�VDEHU�FDXVDO��SRGHU�SUH-
YHU��GHQWUR�GH�FHUWRV�OLPLWHV��DV�FRQVHTXrQFLDV�SRVVtYHLV�GH�VXD�DWLYLGDGH��
HVWDEHOHFHU��SRUWDQWR��ÀQV�GLYHUVRV�H�GLULJLU�VXD�DWLYLGDGH��FRQIRUPH�R�VHX�
SODQR��j�FRQVHFXomR�GHVVHV�ÀQV���
$�ÀQDOLGDGH�HUD�HOHYDGD�j�SRVLomR�GH�´FROXQD�YHUWHEUDO�GD�DomR�ÀQDOµ�
H��SRU�FRQVHTXrQFLD��R�UHFRQKHFLPHQWR�GD�H[LVWrQFLD�GH�XPD�DomR�KXPDQD�
SDVVDYD�D�GHPDQGDU�D�YHULÀFDomR�GH�GHWHUPLQDGDV� IDVHV�GHVVD�ÀQDOLGDGH��
a desenvolver-se, inicialmente, (i)�HP�XP�SODQR�LQWHUQR��PHUDPHQWH�PHQWDO��
com (a)� D� DQWHFLSDomR�GR�ÀP�SHUVHJXLGR�� (b)� D� VHOHomR�GRV�PHLRV� DGHTXD-
�� %(/,1*��(UQVW��Die Lehre vom Verbrechen��S�����
�� %(/,1*��(UQVW��Die Lehre vom Verbrechen��S��Y��9RUZRUW�
�� 9HU�52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��Y��,��S������
�� :(/=(/�� +DQV��Derecho penal aleman� 7UDG�� GD� ���� HG�� DOHPm� SRU� -XDQ� %XVWRV� 5DPtUH]�
\�6HUJLR�<ixH]�3pUH]�����HG��6DQWLDJR�GH�&KLOH�� -XUtGLFD�GH�&KLOH��������S������(P�FpOHEUH�
DVVHUWLYD��REVHUYDYD�:HO]HO�TXH�D�ÀQDOLGDGH�p�´YLGHQGHµ��HQTXDQWR�TXH�D�´FDXVDOLGDGH�p�
FHJDµ��:(/=(/��+DQV��Derecho penal aleman��S������
152
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
152
GRV��H�(c)�D�FRQVLGHUDomR�GRV�HIHLWRV�FRQFRPLWDQWHV��H��HP�VHJXQGR�PRPHQWR�� 
(ii)�HP�XP�SODQR�H[WHUQR��FRP�D�FRORFDomR�HP�SUiWLFD�GR�FXUVR�FDXVDO�DGHTXD-
GR�j�REWHQomR�GR�Mi�DQWHULRUPHQWH�SODQHDGR���
$� WHQWDWLYD�GH� VXSHUDomR�GR�PRGHOR� FDXVDO� QmR� VH�GDYD� D� SDUWLU�GH�
XPD�HIHWLYD� substituição�GRV� VHXV�SUHVVXSRVWRV�� HQWUH�RV�TXDLV� D� FDXVDOLGD-
de, mas sim de uma complementação�SHOR�HOHPHQWR�ÀQDOLGDGH����2�SUHWHQGLGR�
SDUDGLJPD�RQWROyJLFR�p��LVWR�VLP��HULJLGR�D�SDUWLU�GD�combinação desses dois 
HOHPHQWRV�GH�QDWXUH]D�LJXDOPHQWH�RQWROyJLFD��FDXVDOLGDGH�H�ÀQDOLGDGH��'Dt�
DÀUPDU�FRUUHWDPHQWH�0DULQXFFL�TXH�R�́ WRUWRµ�RQWROyJLFR�GD�WHRULD�FDXVDO�QmR�
HVWi��DRV�ROKRV�GR�ÀQDOLVPR��QD�YDORUL]DomR�GD�FDXVDOLGDGH��PDV�HP�KDYr�OD�
GLVVRFLDGR�GD�ÀQDOLGDGH���
(P� RSRVLomR� D� HVVH�PRGHOR�� WRGDYLD�� OHYDQWDP�VH� LQ~PHUDV� FUtWLFDV��
TXH��FRQTXDQWR�WHQKDP�VLGR�UHSHWLGDPHQWH�FRQVLGHUDGDV�SHODV�WHQWDWLYDV�GH�
FRUUHomR�QmR�Vy�GH�:HO]HO�FRPR�GH�PXLWRV�RXWURV�ÀQDOLVWDV��QmR�REWLYHUDP�
UHVSRVWDV�VDWLVIDWyULDV��1R�TXH�WDQJH�PXLWR�SDUWLFXODUPHQWH�j�IXQomR�FODVVLÀ-
FDWyULD��HP�UHODomR�j�TXDO�D�PDQXWHQomR�GH�XP�FULWpULR�RQWROyJLFR�GH�FDXVD-
OLGDGH�Mi�GHL[D�LQWXLU�DV�GLÀFXOGDGHV��RV�SUREOHPDV�VH�WRUQDP�DEVROXWDPHQWH�
LQVXSHUiYHLV��1mR�Ki�FDXVDOLGDGH�RQWROyJLFD�QD�RPLVVmR�H��SRU�LVVR��PHQRV�
DLQGD��D�SRVVLELOLGDGH�GH�FRQWURODU�R�FXUVR�FDXVDO�QR�VHQWLGR�GH�DWLQJLU�RV�ÀQV�SOD-
neados����(�VH�LVVR�p�DVVLP��VLPSOHVPHQWH�QmR�Ki�FRPR�UHFRQKHFHU�QD�RPLVVmR�
uma DomR�HP�VHQWLGR�ÀQDO���
'LDQWH�GHVVH�LPSDVVH��:HO]HO�EXVFD�FRQWRUQDU�D�TXHVWmR��SRU�PHLR�GD�
GHIHVD�GR�IHQ{PHQR�RPLVVLYR�FRPR�RPLVVmR�GH�XPD�DomR�ÀQDO��$R�RPLWLU��R�VX-
MHLWR�GHL[DULD�GH�SUDWLFDU�XPD�DomR�ÀQDO�SRVVtYHO��(��QHVWD�PHGLGD��GH�IRUPD�
VHPHOKDQWH�DR�TXH�VH�SDVVD�QD�WHRULD�FDXVDO��DÀUPD�D�H[LVWrQFLD�GH�ÀQDOLGDGH�
�� :(/=(/��+DQV��Derecho penal aleman��S�����H�VV�
�� 3DUD�XPD�HTXLSDUDomR�FUtWLFD�HQWUH�D�ÀQDOLGDGH�HP�VL e a voluntariedade dos naturalistas, ver 
0$5,18&&,��*LRUJLR��Il reato come “azione”��S�����H�VV�
�� 0$5,18&&,��*LRUJLR��Il reato come “azione”��S�����
�� 2772��+DUUR��Grundkurs Strafrecht��S�����
�� 5R[LQ�FKHJD�D�DÀUPDU�TXH�KRMH�Mi�QmR�VH�GLVFXWH�VREUH�D�LQFDSDFLGDGH�GH�R�FRQFHLWR�ÀQDO�GH�
DomR�ÀJXUDU�FRPR�HOHPHQWR�SULPiULR�GR�VLVWHPD�MXUtGLFR�SHQDO��HLV�TXH��SHOD�DXVrQFLD�GH�
FDXVDOLGDGH�QD�RPLVVmR��WRUQD�VH�LPSRVVtYHO�DEVRUYHU�HVVD�SDUWLFXODU�IRUPD�GH�H[SUHVVmR�
GR�LOtFLWR�WtSLFR��52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S��������6REUH�D�GLÀFXOGDGH�GR�FRQFHLWR�ÀQDO�
GH�DomR�HP�DEVRUYHU�RV�IHQ{PHQRV�RPLVVLYRV��YHU�WDPEpP�:(66(/6��-RKDQQHV��%(8/.(��
:HUQHU��Strafrecht��$OOJHPHLQHU�7HLO������HG��+HLGHOEHUJ��0�OOHU��������S�����
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
153153
WDPEpP�QD�RPLVVmR��SRUpP�DJRUD�GH�XPD�´ÀQDOLGDGH�SRWHQFLDOµ����'D�HVWUX-
WXUD�GD�GLUHomR�ÀQDO�GD�DomR��DÀUPD�:HO]HO��GHYH�GHVSUHQGHU�VH�D�´FDSDFLGD-
GH�GH�DomRµ��QHFHVViULD�DR�´SRGHU�ÀQDO�GR�IDWRµ���
(VVD� VROXomR� WDPEpP� QmR� VDWLVID]�� $TXL� YDOHP� DV�PHVPDV� REMHo}HV�
GLUHFLRQDGDV�j� WHRULD�FDXVDO��$omR�H�FDSDFLGDGH�GH�DomR��ÀQDOLGDGH�H�ÀQD-
OLGDGH�SRWHQFLDO��QmR�VmR��HP�KLSyWHVH�DOJXPD��FDWHJRULDV�HTXLYDOHQWHV�RX��
DR�PHQRV��TXH�SHUPLWDP�XP�GHQRPLQDGRU�FRPXP��7UDWD�VH��QD�YHUGDGH��OH-
YDQGR�HP�FRQVLGHUDomR�DV�SUHPLVVDV�GR�SUySULR�DXWRU��GH�FDWHJRULDV�TXH�VH�
H[FOXHP�PXWXDPHQWH��6y�ID]�VHQWLGR�IDODU�HP�ÀQDOLGDGH�SRWHQFLDO�H�FDSDFL-
GDGH�GH�DomR�QD�DXVrQFLD��UHVSHFWLYDPHQWH��GH�ÀQDOLGDGH�UHDO�H�GH�DomR�UHDO��
L�H���GH�XPD�GHWHUPLQDGD�DomR�TXH��HPERUD�SRVVtYHO�DR�VXMHLWR��QmR�FKHJRX�D�
VHU�SUDWLFDGD��QmR�FKHJRX�D�H[LVWLU��'Dt�DEVROXWDPHQWH�LPSRVVtYHO�UHWLUDU�GD�
capacidade de ação�R�HOHPHQWR�EiVLFR�FRPXP�GDV�PDQLIHVWDo}HV�FRPLVVLYDV�H�
RPLVVLYDV�GR�LOtFLWR�WtSLFR��FDSDFLGDGH�GH�DomR�QmR�p�DomR���
3RU�ÀP��DLQGD�QR�TXH�GL]�UHVSHLWR�DR�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�SRWHQFLDO��YDOH�
WDPEpP�WHU�HP�FRQWD�TXH�WDO�UDFLRFtQLR�Vy�p�SRVVtYHO�j�OX]�GH�XPD�expecta-
tiva de ação� LQIRUPDGD�SHOR�WLSR�SHQDO��R�TXH��SRU�VL�Vy��FRQWUDGL]�D�SUHWHQ-
GLGD�QDWXUH]D�RQWROyJLFD�H�SUp�WtSLFD�GD�DomR�ÀQDOLVWD����(P�XPD�GLPHQVmR�
YHUGDGHLUDPHQWH�RQWROyJLFD��D�SUySULD�´FDWHJRULD�GD�FDSDFLGDGHµ�GH�DomR�p�
LQLPDJLQiYHO��6XD�QDWDOLGDGH�HVWi�FRQGLFLRQDGD�D�H[LJrQFLDV�D[LROyJLFDV�HV-
WDEHOHFLGDV�� in casu�� SHOD�QRUPD�SHQDO�� 6RPHQWH�KDYHUi�RPLVVmR�� FDVR�KDMD�
XPD�GHWHUPLQDomR�GH�DJLU��FDVR�R�VXMHLWR�WHQKD�GHL[DGR�GH�SUDWLFDU�XPD�DomR�
TXH�HUD�GHOH�H[LJLGD��1mR�Ki�FRPR�VH�FRJLWDU�D�RPLVVmR�GH�XPD�DomR��VHP�R�
GHYHU�GH�SUDWLFi�OD��$VVLP��SDUD�D�IRUPXODomR�GH�XP�TXDOTXHU�MXt]R�DFHUFD�
GD�´RPLVVmR�GH�XPD�DomRµ��p�SUHFLVR�XPD�UHIHUrQFLD�WtSLFD�SUpYLD�j�FRQVLGH-
UDomR�DFHUFD�GD�DomR�ÀQDO��GH�IRUPD�D� LGHQWLÀFDU�D�H[LVWrQFLD�GH�XP�GHYHU�
GHVFXPSULGR��R�TXH��SRU�FRQVHJXLQWH��FRPR�VH�SHUFHEH��VXEWUDL�WRWDOPHQWH�D�
SUHWHQGLGD�GLPHQVmR�RQWROyJLFD�SUp�WtSLFD�GR�ÀQDOLVPR���
�� $ÀUPD�:HO]HO�� QHVVH� VHQWLGR�� TXH� D� ´RPLVVmR� p� D�QmR�SURGXomR�GD�ÀQDOLGDGH�SRWHQFLDO�
�SRVVtYHO��GH�XP�KRPHP�HP�UHODomR�D�XPD�GHWHUPLQDGD�DomRµ��:(/=(/��+DQV��Derecho 
penal aleman��S�������
�� :(/=(/��+DQV��Derecho penal aleman��S������
�� 1HVVH�VHQWLGR��DÀUPD�FRUUHWDPHQWH�5R[LQ�TXH�´FDSDFLGDGH�SDUD�UHDOL]DU�XPD�DomRµ�QmR�VH�
FRQIXQGH�FRP�D�DomR�HP�VL��52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S�������
�� 3DUD�DV�VXDV�UD]}HV�HP�VHQWLGR�FRQWUiULR��YHU�:(/=(/��+DQV��Derecho penal aleman��S������
�� %HP�DÀUPD�*DOODV��QR�kPELWR�GRV�FULPHV�RPLVVLYRV�p�SRVVtYHO�IDODU�VH��DWp�PHVPR��GH�XPD�
SUHH[LVWrQFLD� GD� QRUPD� MXUtGLFD� HP� UHODomR� DR� SUySULR� FRQFHLWR� GH� FRQGXWD� �*$//$6��
154
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
154
'H�PDLV�D�PDLV��WDPEpP�RV�FULPHV�FXOSRVRV�QmR�VmR�DGHTXDGDPHQWH�
H[SOLFDGRV�SRU�PHLR�GH�XPD�DomR�ÀQDO��&RPR� Mi� EHP�DVVLQDODYD�(GXDUGR�
&RUUHLD��DLQGD�TXH�VH�SRVVD�IDODU�HP�XPD�DomR�GHVFXLGDGD�GLULJLGD�ÀQDOPHQ-
WH��D�YHUGDGH�p�TXH�HOD��QD�PHGLGD�HP�TXH�QmR�FRQWHPSOD�R�UHVXOWDGR�LQGHVH-
MDGR��´QmR�SRGH�VHUYLU�GH�EDVH�j�WHRULD�GR�FULPHµ����2�GHVFXLGR�QmR�p�SDUWH�GD�
ÀQDOLGDGH�GD�DomR����(��QmR�R�VHQGR��D�H[LJrQFLD�GH�XPD�DomR�ÀQDO�SRXFR�WHUi�
D�GL]HU�QR�kPELWR�GR�LOtFLWR�WtSLFR�FXOSRVR�
����2�FRQFHLWR�VRFLDO�GH�DomR
$�SDUWLU�GH�IRUWHV�FUtWLFDV�DRV�FRQFHLWRV�FDXVDO�H�ÀQDO�GH�DomR��RV�GH-
IHQVRUHV�GR�PRGHOR�VRFLDO�SURS}HP�XPD�PXGDQoD�GH�SHUVSHFWLYD�DFHUFD�GD�
TXHVWmR��$R�LQYpV�GH�HPSUHHQGHU�HVIRUoRV�QR�VHQWLGR�GH�XPD�GHÀQLomR�RQ-
WROyJLFD��MXOJDP�VHU�SRVVtYHO�D�REWHQomR�GH�XP�FRQFHLWR�XQLWiULR�H�SUp�WtSLFR�
GH�DomR�D�SDUWLU�GH�XPD�RXWUD�GLPHQVmR��D�SDUWLU�GD�VXD�GLPHQVmR�VRFLDO��
$SHQDV�DV�Do}HV�VRFLDOPHQWH�UHOHYDQWHV�SRGHULDP�VHU�FRQVLGHUDGDV�GHWHQ-
WRUDV�GH� UHOHYR� MXUtGLFR���� (��GHVVH�PRGR��QmR�PDLV� FDWHJRULDV�GR�PXQGR�
GR�VHU��FRPR�D�FDXVDOLGDGH�RX�D�ÀQDOLGDGH��PDV�VLP�XP�HOHPHQWR�GH�FDUL]�
D[LROyJLFR��D�UHOHYkQFLD�VRFLDO��SDVVD�D�VHU�R�Q~FOHR�GR�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR��D�
FRQVWLWXLU�R�GHQRPLQDGRU�FRPXP�GDV�PDLV�YDULDGDV�HODERUDo}HV�TXH��GHVGH�
(EHUKDUG�6FKPLGW����QHVVH�kPELWR��WrP�VLGR�SURSRVWDV��$�DomR�WRUQD�VH��QD�
HODERUDomR�GH�-HVFKHFN�H�:HLJHQG�²�DOJXQV�GH�VHXV�PDLV�FpOHEUHV�DGHSWRV�
²�� R� ´FRPSRUWDPHQWR� VRFLDOPHQWH� UHOHYDQWHµ���� RX� DLQGD�� QD� GRXWULQD� GH�
:HVVHOV�H�%HXONH��´R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�VRFLDOPHQWH�UHOHYDQWH�GRPLQDGR�RX�
GRPLQiYHO�SHOD�YRQWDGHµ���
:LOKHOP��Zumgegenwärtigen Stand der Lehre vom Verbrechen��S�������9HU��DLQGD��0$5,18&&,��
*LRUJLR��Il reato come “azione”��S�����H�VV�
�� &255(,$�� (GXDUGR�� Direito criminal�� &RLPEUD�� $OPHGLQD�� ����� �UHLPSUHVVmR��� S�� �����
7DPEpP�',$6��-RUJH�GH�)LJXHLUHGR��Direito penal��S������
�� -(6&+(&.��+DQV�+HLQULFK��:(,*(1'��7KRPDV��Lehrbuch des Strafrechts��S������H�VV�
�� 1D�VtQWHVH�GH�2772��+DUUR��Grundkurs Strafrecht��S���������������
�� 3DUD�TXHP�D�DomR�FRQVLVWLD�HP�XPD�´PRGLÀFDomR�GR�PXQGR�H[WHULRU�VRFLDO�SRU�PHLR�GH�XP�
FRPSRUWDPHQWR�YROXQWiULRµ��/,6=7��)UDQ]�Y���6&+0,'7��(EHUKDUG��Lehrbuch des deustchen 
Strafrechts��(LQOHLWXQJ�XQG�DOOJHPHLQHU�7HLO������HG��%HUOLQ��/HLS]LJ��:DOWHU�GH�*UX\WHU��������
S�������
�� -(6&+(&.��+DQV�+HLQULFK��:(,*(1'��7KRPDV��Lehrbuch des Strafrechts��S������
�� :(66(/6��-RKDQQHV��%(8/.(��:HUQHU��Strafrecht��S�����
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
155155
$V�YDQWDJHQV�GH�XP�FRQFHLWR�GH�QDWXUH]D�QRUPDWLYD��SULQFLSDOPHQWH�
QR�TXH�WDQJH�j�IXQomR�FODVVLÀFDWyULD��VmR�HYLGHQWHV��$omR�H�RPLVVmR��QRV�OL-
PLWHV�GR�PXQGR�GR�VHU��VmR�LQVXVFHWtYHLV�GH�VHUHP�UHGX]LGRV�D�XP�FRQFHLWR�
~QLFR����PDV�QmR�R�VmR�HP�XPD�GLPHQVmR�YDORUDWLYD��7DQWR�D�DomR�FRPR�D�RPLVVmR�SRGHP��VLP��VHU�SHUFHELGDV�HP�XPD�GLPHQVmR�YDORUDWLYD�SUp�WtSLFD��
D�SDUWLU�GD�UHODomR�GR�´FRPSRUWDPHQWR�KXPDQR�FRP�R�PHLR�DPELHQWHµ�� ou, 
PDLV�HVSHFLÀFDPHQWH��QR�TXH�VH�UHIHUH�j�RPLVVmR��D�SDUWLU�GH�H[SHFWDWLYDV�GH�
DomR�VRFLDOPHQWH�IXQGDGDV����3DUWLQGR�GHVVH�SUHVVXSRVWR��VHULD�SRVVtYHO��HP�
WHVH��FRQGX]L�ORV�D�XP�FRQFHLWR�~QLFR��DWUHODGR�D�HVVH�MXt]R�GH�YDORU�SUpYLR�j�
MXULGLFLGDGH�SHQDO��
2�UHFRQKHFLPHQWR�GHVVDV�TXDOLGDGHV��SRUpP��QmR�LPSHGLX�TXH�R�FRQ-
FHLWR�VRFLDO�HQIUHQWDVVH�LJXDOPHQWH�LQ~PHUDV�GLÀFXOGDGHV�H��FRPR�DV�GHPDLV��
DFDEDVVH�SRU�IUDFDVVDU�QR�DWHQGLPHQWR�jV�P~OWLSODV�IXQo}HV�DWULEXtGDV�j�DomR�
como Oberbegriff��$�FRPHoDU�SHOR�TXH�Ki�GH�PDLV�HOHPHQWDU��QRWD�VH��QD�FRP-
SDQKLD�GH�5R[LQ����TXH�D�WHRULD�VRFLDO�QmR�RIHUHFH��HP�YHUGDGH��XP�FRQFHLWR�
GH�DomR�SURSULDPHQWH�GLWR��LVWR�p��XP�substantivo�DR�TXDO�HVWDULDP�YLQFXODGRV�
RV�DWULEXWRV�WtSLFR��LOtFLWR�H�FXOSiYHO��QRV�WHUPRV�GD�IXQomR�GH�XQLmR��(OD�DSH-
QDV�DWULEXL�PDLV�XP�SUHGLFDGR�j�DomR��FRQVLVWHQWH�QD�UHOHYkQFLD�VRFLDO��7HQGR�
RX�QmR�UHOHYkQFLD�VRFLDO��SHUPDQHFH�D�DomR��UHVWDQGR�VDEHU��DÀQDO��HP�TXH�
FRQVLVWLULD�HVVD�´DomRµ�UHPDQHVFHQWH��,VVR�SRU�XP�ODGR��3RU�RXWUR��HVWH�VLP�
R�JUDQGH�GHVDÀR�GR�FRQFHLWR�VRFLDO��HVWi�D�GHÀQLomR�GH�socialmente relevante��
6HQGR�HVVD�D�SHGUD�GH�WRTXH�GR�FRQFHLWR��GHOD�GHSHQGH�R�DWHQGLPHQWR�GDV�
UHVSHFWLYDV�IXQo}HV��-XVWDPHQWH�QHVVH�SUHFLVR�SRQWR��FRQWXGR��SHUFHEHP�VH�
OLPLWDo}HV�LQVXSHUiYHLV��
­�SULPHLUD�YLVWD�� OHYDQGR�HP�FRQVLGHUDomR�XPD�QRomR�DPSOD�GH� UH-
OHYkQFLD�VRFLDO��SRGH�VH�GL]HU�TXH�WRGDV�DV�FRQGXWDV�TXH�R�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�
EXVFD�H[FOXLU��FRPR�KLSyWHVHV�GH�FRDomR�ItVLFD�LUUHVLVWtYHO��DWRV�HP�HVWDGR�GH�
LQFRQVFLrQFLD�H�PRYLPHQWRV�UHÁH[RV��VHULDP�QD�UHDOLGDGH�VRFLDOPHQWH�UHOH-
YDQWHV��GHIUDXGDQGR��DVVLP��D�IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR����1mR�p�HVVD��WRGDYLD��
D�SUHWHQVmR�GR�FRQFHLWR�VRFLDO��3HOR�FRQWUiULR��(OH�EXVFD�XPD�LGHLD�GH�UHOH-
YkQFLD�VRFLDO�EHP�PDLV�UHVWULWD��FDSD]�GH�FRQVHUYDU�R�SRWHQFLDO�OLPLWDWLYR�GR�
�� -(6&+(&.��+DQV�+HLQULFK��:(,*(1'��7KRPDV��Lehrbuch des Strafrechts��S������
�� -(6&+(&.��+DQV�+HLQULFK��:(,*(1'��7KRPDV��Lehrbuch des Strafrechts��S������9HU�WDPEpP�
/,6=7��)UDQ]�Y���6&+0,'7��(EHUKDUG��Lehrbuch des deustchen Strafrechts��S������H�VV�
�� -(6&+(&.��+DQV�+HLQULFK��:(,*(1'��7KRPDV��Lehrbuch des Strafrechts��S������H�VV�
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������
�� $VVLP��52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������
156
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
156
FRQFHLWR�H��GHVVH�PRGR��D�VXD�IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR��2FRUUH�TXH��DR�WRPDU�
HVVH�FDPLQKR��R�MXt]R�GH�UHOHYkQFLD�VRFLDO�DFDED�SRU�DSUR[LPDU�VH�GHPDVLD-
GDPHQWH�GR� WLSR� OHJDO�GH�FULPH�� WHQGR�FRPR�FRQVHTXrQFLD�D�SHUGD�GD�VXD�
DXWRQRPLD�YDORUDWLYD��HOD�VH�FRQIXQGH�FRP�D�YDORUDomR�FRQWLGD�QR�WLSR��H�R�
HVYD]LDPHQWR�GD�IXQomR�GH�XQLmR����,QGR�DLQGD�PDLV�DOpP��H�GH�PRGR�PXLWR�
LQFLVLYR��0DULQXFFL�FKHJD�D�DÀUPDU�TXH��HQTXDQWR�D�WHRULD�ÀQDOLVWD�EXVFD�GDU�
FRQWH~GR�DR�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�DQWHFLSDQGR�R�dolo��D�WHRULD�VRFLDO�EXVFD�R�PHV-
PR�UHVXOWDGR�DQWHFLSDQGR�D�culpa���
3DUD�VXSHUDU�R�GpÀFLW�GH�GHOLPLWDomR��p�FRPXP�R�HVIRUoR�GD�WHRULD�VRFLDO�QR�VHQ-
WLGR�GH�DWULEXLU�PDLV�FRQVLVWrQFLD�DR�FRQFHLWR��PHGLDQWH�R�UHFXUVR�D�FDWHJRULDV�HVWUDQKDV�
j�GLPHQVmR�VRFLDO��FRPR�D�YROXQWDULHGDGH��D�GRPLQDELOLGDGH����D�FRQWURODELOLGDGH���HWF���
DV�TXDLV��SRU�VXD�YH]��FRORFDP�RXWURV�SUREOHPDV����$�YROXQWDULHGDGH�DFDUUHWD�DV�PHVPDV�
GLÀFXOGDGHV�Mi�RSRVWDV�DRV�PRGHORV�DQWHULRUHV��QHP�WRGRV�RV�GHOLWRV�WrP�QD�VXD�EDVH�XPD�
DomR�YROXQWiULD��FRPR�p�FDVR�GD�RPLVVmR�SRU�FXOSD�LQFRQVFLHQWH��H[���R�VLPSOHV�HVTXHFL-
PHQWR�GH�XP�GHYHU�GR�TXDO�GHFRUUH�XP�UHVXOWDGR�WtSLFR���$�GRPLQDELOLGDGH�H�D�FRQWUR-
ODELOLGDGH��SRU� VHX� WXUQR�� VmR� FDWHJRULDV�SUySULDV�GD� LPSXWDomR� MXUtGLFR�SHQDO� H��GHVVH�
PRGR��LQVXVFHWtYHLV�GH�VHUHP�DQWHFLSDGDV�D�XP�PRPHQWR�YDORUDWLYR�DQWHULRU�DR�WLSR��VHP�
FRP�LVVR�GHIUDXGDU�D�IXQomR�GH�XQLmR��
3RU�ÀP��QR�TXH�WDQJH�j�UHOHYkQFLD�VRFLDO�SURSULDPHQWH�GLWD��FRQTXDQWR�VH�SRVVD�
UHFRQKHFHU�DXWRQRPLD�D�XPD�GLPHQVmR�YDORUDWLYD�SUp�WtSLFD��QmR�VH�SRGH�QHJDU�TXH��HP�
PXLWRV�FDVRV��p�R�SUySULR�WLSR�TXH�GHWHUPLQD�R�TXH�p�RX�QmR�VRFLDOPHQWH�UHOHYDQWH��([FOXt�
GD��GH�SURQWR��SHODV�UD]}HV�Mi�DFLPD�H[SRVWDV��XPD�LGHLD�GH�UHOHYkQFLD�VRFLDO�lato sensu, a 
EXVFD�SHOR�UHOHYDQWH�RX�LUUHOHYDQWH�VRFLDOPHQWH�DFDED��QmR�UDUDPHQWH��SRU�VH�DSUR[LPDU�
GH�FDWHJRULDV�GH�LPSXWDomR�²�FRPR��DOLiV��EHP�LOXVWUD�D�FDWHJRULD�risco permitido�� – e, desse 
PRGR��GD�YDORUDomR�MXUtGLFR�SHQDO�tQVLWD�DR�WLSR��H[���VH�D�GLUHomR�GH�XP�YHtFXOR�DXWRPR-
WRU�p�RX�QmR�VRFLDOPHQWH�UHOHYDQWH�GHSHQGH�GH�VH�D�FRQGXomR�HVWi�RX�QmR�FRQIRUPH�DV�
UHJUDV�GH�WUkQVLWR�����1RV�FULPHV�RPLVVLYRV��DOLiV��LVVR�p�DLQGD�PDLV�H[XEHUDQWH��e�YHUGDGH�
TXH�Ki�H[SHFWDWLYDV�VRFLDLV�DXW{QRPDV�HP�UHODomR�DRV�GHYHUHV�GH�DJLU�SHQDOPHQWH�UHFHS-
FLRQDGRV��FRPR�VHULD�R�FDVR�GD�RPLVVmR�GH�XP�GHYHU�VRFRUUR��0DV�p�LJXDOPHQWH�YHUGDGH�
�� (VVD�p�D�FUtWLFD�PDLV�FRPXP�DR�PRGHOR�VRFLDO��9HU�52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S�������
',$6��-RUJH�GH�)LJXHLUHGR��Direito penal��S�������2772��+DUUR��Grundkurs Strafrecht��S�����H�
VV���0$5,18&&,��*LRUJLR��Il reato come “azione”��S�����H�VV��
�� 0$5,18&&,��*LRUJLR��Il reato come “azione”��S������
�� :(66(/6��-RKDQQHV��%(8/.(��:HUQHU��Strafrecht��S�����
�� -(6&+(&.��+DQV�+HLQULFK��:(,*(1'��7KRPDV��Lehrbuch des Strafrechts��S������H�VV�
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������
�� 9HU�0$5,18&&,��*LRUJLR��Il reato come “azione”��S�����H�VV�
�� 'Dt�REVHUYDU�0DULQXFFL��TXH��DR�ÀP�H�DR�FDER��R�TXH�VH�SHUFHEH�p�XPD�DSUR[LPDomR�GR�
´VHQWLGR�VRFLDOµ�GD�DomR�FRP�D�QRomR�GH�´FXOSD�REMHWLYDµ��0$5,18&&,��*LRUJLR��Il reato 
come “azione”��S������
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
157157
TXH�HP�RXWUDV�VLWXDo}HV�p�R�SUySULR�GLUHLWR�SHQDO�TXH�GHÀQH�R�GHYHU�GH�DJLU��H[���RPLVVmR�
GH�QRWLÀFDomR�GH�GRHQoD��DUW������GR�&3���WRUQDQGR�LPSRVVtYHO�D�VXD�DSUHFLDomR�VRFLDO�VHP�
R�QHFHVViULR�UHIHUHQFLDO�MXUtGLFR�SHQDO�
����2�FRQFHLWR�QHJDWLYR�GH�DomR
6RE�D�GHQRPLQDomR�GH�conceito negativo de ação WrP�VLGR�UHXQLGDV�HODER-
UDo}HV�TXH�EXVFDP�QD�LGHLD�GH�evitabilidade um elemento comum entre ação e 
RPLVVmR��FDSD]�GH�FRQGX]LU�D�XPD�GHÀQLomR�XQLWiULD�GH�DomR��2�VHX�SULPHLUR�
GHVHQYROYLPHQWR�FRVWXPD�VHU�DWULEXtGR���D�+HU]EHUJ��HP�HVFULWR�GDWDGR�GH�
������Die Unterlassung im Strafrecht und das Garantenprinzip���VHJXQGR�R�TXDO��
´HP�WHUPRV�MXUtGLFR�SHQDLVµ��´DJH�TXHP��FRPR�JDUDQWH��QmR�HYLWD�DOJR�TXH�
SRGLD�HYLWDUµ��(��QHVVD�OLQKD��GHIHQGH�R�DXWRU�TXH�D�DomR�GHYH�VHU�HQWHQGLGD�
FRPR�´R�QmR�HYLWDU�HYLWiYHO�HP�SRVLomR�GH�JDUDQWHµ����2ULHQWDomR�VHPHOKDQWH�
SRGH�VHU�LJXDOPHQWH�VXUSUHHQGLGD�QRV�WUDEDOKRV�GH�%HKUHQG��������²�DomR�p�
D�´QmR�HYLWDomR�HYLWiYHO�GD�VLWXDomR�WtSLFDµ�� – e, mais recentemente, no curso 
GH�GLUHLWR�SHQDO�GH�-DNREV�²�´FRQGXWD�p�D�HYLWDELOLGDGH�GH�XPD�GLIHUHQoD�GH�
UHVXOWDGRµ���
(ODERUDGR�QHVVHV�WHUPRV��R�FRQFHLWR�QHJDWLYR�WHP�HQIUHQWDGR�SRQWRV�GH�
RSRVLomR�LUUHIXWiYHLV��-i�j�SDUWLGD��HTXLYRFD�VH�HP�XPD�TXHVWmR�IXQGDPHQ-
WDO��'D�PHVPD�IRUPD�TXH�DV�WHQWDWLYDV�GH�HODERUDomR�GH�XP�FRQFHLWR�XQLWiULR�
GH�DomR�D�SDUWLU�GD�ação positiva �DomR�HP�VHQWLGR�HVWULWR��IUDFDVVDP�DR�JHQH-
UDOL]DU�LQGHYLGDPHQWH�HOHPHQWRV�HVWUDQKRV�DR�IHQ{PHQR�RPLVVLYR��WDPEpP�
D�WHQWDWLYD�GH�HODERUDomR�GH�XP�FRQFHLWR�XQLWiULR�D�SDUWLU�GD�RPLVVmR��GDQGR�
RULJHP�D�XPD�HVSpFLH�GH�´VXSUDFRQFHLWR�GH�RPLVVmRµ��HQIUHQWD�SUREOHPDV�GH�
LJXDO�QDWXUH]D��$�JHQHUDOL]DomR�GH�HOHPHQWRV�SUySULRV�GD�FRQGXWD�RPLVVLYD�
QmR�DSHQDV�WUDQVSRUWD�SDUD�R�DJLU�XPD�UHDOLGDGH�TXH�QmR�OKH�p�FRQGL]HQWH��
FRPR��HP�UD]mR�GD�SUySULD�QDWXUH]D�QRUPDWLYD�GD�RPLVVmR��DFDED�SRU�DQWH-
FLSDU�QD�SUp�WLSLFLGDGH�HOHPHQWRV�GH�LPSXWDomR��&RPR�p�IDFLOPHQWH�SHUFHSWt-
vel, a evitabilidade GH�XP�GHWHUPLQDGR�UHVXOWDGR�QmR�p�XPD�TXHVWmR�TXH�SRVVD�
�� 6HJXQGR�5R[LQ��+HU]EHUJ�IRL�R�SULPHLUR�D�XWLOL]DU�R�SULQFtSLR�GD�HYLWDELOLGDGH�FRPR�EDVH�
SDUD�XP�FRQFHLWR�XQLWiULR�GH�DomR��52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S�������
�� +(5=%(5*��5ROI�'LHWULFK��Die Unterlassung im Strafrecht und das Garantenprinzip��%HUOLQ��
:DOWHU�GH�*UX\WHU��������S������
�� %(+5(1'7�� +DQV�-RDFKLP�� Die Unterlassung imStrafrecht�� (QWZXUI� HLQHV� QHJDWLYHQ�
+DQGOXQJVEHJULIIV�DXI�SV\FKRDQDO\WLVFKHU�*UXQGODJH��%DGHQ�%DGHQ��1RPRV��������S������
�� -$.2%6��*�QWKHU��Strafrecht��$OOJHPHLQHU�7HLO�����HG��%HUOLQ��1HZ�<RUN��:DOWHU�GH�*UX\WHU��
������S������
158
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
158
VHU�UHVROYLGD�HP�kPELWR�SUp�WtSLFR��PDV�SUREOHPD�HVSHFtÀFR�GH� LPSXWDomR�
SHQDO�RX��PDLV�SURSULDPHQWH��GH�LPSXWDomR�REMHWLYD���
����2�FRQFHLWR�SHVVRDO�GH�DomR
(QWUH�DV�HODERUDo}HV�PDLV�UHFHQWHV��PHUHFH�HVSHFLDO�DWHQomR�R�FRQFHLWR�
GHVHQYROYLGR�SRU�&ODXV�5R[LQ��$OpP�GD�QRWiYHO�LQÁXrQFLD�GR�SHQVDPHQWR�
GH�5R[LQ�QRV�~OWLPRV�GHVGREUDPHQWRV�GD�GRJPiWLFD�SHQDO��R�VHX�FRQFHLWR�GH�
DomR�VXUJH�HP�XP�FRQWH[WR�PXLWR�SDUWLFXODU��(P�HVFULWR�SXEOLFDGR�HP�������
VXVWHQWDYD�R�DXWRU�²�QD�OLQKD�GR�TXH�VH�WHP�DTXL�GHIHQGLGR�²�TXH�QHQKXPD�
WHRULD�GD�DomR�SRGHULD�FRQVWLWXLU�D�EDVH�GR�VLVWHPD�SHQDO��DFUHVFHQWDQGR�TXH�
´QmR�VH�SRGH�VROXFLRQDU�QHQKXP�SUREOHPD�MXUtGLFR�FRP�FRQFHLWRV�TXH�VmR�
SUpYLRV�DRV�FRQWH~GRV�GH�VHQWLGR� MXUtGLFRµ����$SyV�HVVH�SULPHLUR�PRPHQWR�
GH�FHWLFLVPR��WRGDYLD��R�DXWRU�UHYr�R�VHX�SRVLFLRQDPHQWR�H�SDVVD�D�HPSUHHQ-
GHU�HVIRUoRV�HP�VHQWLGR�GLDPHWUDOPHQWH�RSRVWR��SURSRQGR�XPD�QRYD�WHRULD�
GD�DomR��SRU�HOH�GHQRPLQDGD�GH�FRQFHLWR�SHVVRDO����
(P� XPD� IRUPXODomR� DSDUHQWHPHQWH� VLQJHOD�� D� WHRULD� SHVVRDO� GHÀQH�
DomR�D�SDUWLU�GH�DSHQDV�GRLV�HOHPHQWRV��´PDQLIHVWDomRµ�H�´SHUVRQDOLGDGHµ��
$omR�p�VLPSOHVPHQWH�D�´PDQLIHVWDomR�GD�SHUVRQDOLGDGHµ��HQWHQGHQGR�FRPR�
WDO�´WXGR�R�TXH�IRU�DWULEXtYHO�D�XP�VHU�KXPDQR�FRPR�FHQWUR�GH�DomR�DQtPLFR-
�HVSLULWXDOµ��(VWDULDP�H[FOXtGDV��QHVVD�PHGLGD��WRGDV�DV�´UHDo}HVµ�PHUDPHQ-
WH�VRPiWLFDV�TXH�QmR�HVWmR�´VXEPHWLGDV�DR�FRQWUROH�GR�(Xµ��L�H���PDQLIHVWD-
o}HV�TXH�QmR�VmR�GRPLQDGDV�RX�GRPLQiYHLV�SHOD�YRQWDGH�H�FRQVFLrQFLD���XPD�
YH]�TXH�QmR�FRQVLVWLULDP�HP�PDQLIHVWDo}HV�GD�personalidade��'H�RXWUD�SDUWH��
VXVWHQWD�TXH��FRQTXDQWR�RV�SHQVDPHQWRV�H�LPSXOVRV�GD�YRQWDGH�IDoDP�SDUWH�
GD�´HVIHUD�DQtPLFR�HVSLULWXDO�GD�SHVVRDµ��DR�VH�PDQWHUHP�HP�XPD�GLPHQVmR�
LQWHUQD��QmR�FDUDFWHUL]DULDP�XPD�manifestação�GD�SHUVRQDOLGDGH���
2�FRQFHLWR�GH�5R[LQ��HP�TXH�SHVHP�RV�VHXV�PpULWRV��QmR�WHP�PHOKRU�
VRUWH�TXH�RV�GHPDLV��-i�j�SDUWLGD��SHUFHEH�VH�XPD�SUREOHPiWLFD�GHSHQGrQFLD��
�� $VVLP�� -(6&+(&.��+DQV�+HLQULFK��:(,*(1'��7KRPDV��Lehrbuch des Strafrechts�� S�� �����
',$6��-RUJH�GH�)LJXHLUHGR��Direito penal��S�������52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������H�VV�
�� 52;,1�� &ODXV�� &RQWULEXLomR� SDUD� D� FUtWLFD� GD� WHRULD� ÀQDOLVWD� GD� DFomR�� ,Q�� Problemas 
fundamentais de direito penal��7UDG��$QD�3DXOD�GRV�6DQWRV�H�/XtV�1DWVFKHUDGHW]�����HG��/LVERD��
9HJD��������S�������RULJLQDOPHQWH�SXEOLFDGR�HP�ZStW������������S������H�VV�
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������H�VV���YHU�WDPEpP��GR�PHVPR�DXWRU��,O�FRQFHWWR�GL�D]LRQH�
QHL�SL~�UHFHQWL�GLEDWWLWL�GHOOD�GRPPDWLFD�SHQDOLVWLFD�WHGHVFD��,Q��Studi in memoria di Giacomo 
Delitala��0LODQR��*LXIIUq��Y��,,,��S�������H�VV��������
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
159159
senão mesmo identidade, entre as noções de personalidade e dominabilidade/
controlabilidade��SDUD�TXH�XPD�GHWHUPLQDGD�PDQLIHVWDomR�KXPDQD�SRVVD�VHU�
FRQVLGHUDGD�PDQLIHVWDomR�GD�personalidade��p�SUHFLVR�VHU��DR�PHQRV��dominá-
vel SHOD�YRQWDGH�H�SHOD�FRQVFLrQFLD��(VVH�UHFXUVR��SUHVHQWH�WDPEpP�QD�WHRULD�
VRFLDO��VXMHLWD�VH�jV�PHVPDV�FUtWLFDV�Oi�IRUPXODGDV��'RPLQDELOLGDGH�H�FRQWUR-
ODELOLGDGH�QmR�VmR�SURSULDPHQWH�HOHPHQWRV�RQWROyJLFRV��PDV�VLP�FULWpULRV�GH�
LPSXWDomR��$OpP�GLVVR��QmR�p�DSOLFiYHO�D�WRGRV�RV�FDVRV��FRPR�EHP�LOXVWUD�
DV�KLSyWHVHV�GH�PRYLPHQWRV�UHÁH[RV�e ações automáticas QR�WUkQVLWR��(VWH�FRQ-
WURYHUWLGR�JUXSR�GH�FDVRV�²�Mi�OHYDQWDGR�FRPR�PRWLYR�GH�REMHomR�jV�WHRULDV�
FDXVDO�H�ÀQDO�HP�UD]mR�GD�DXVrQFLD�GH�voluntariedade e ÀQDOLGDGH��UHVSHFWLYD-
PHQWH�²�VmR�FDUDFWHUL]DGRV�MXVWDPHQWH�SHOD�IDOWD�GH�´UHÁH[mR�FRQVFLHQWHµ��R�
TXH��DOLiV��UHFRQKHFH�R�SUySULR�DXWRU����vide supra���(�VH�LVVR�p�DVVLP��VH�QmR�VmR�
SURYLGRV�GH�FRQVFLrQFLD��QmR�VH�SRGH�IDODU�HP�GRPLQDELOLGDGH�SHOD�YRQWDGH�
H�FRQVFLrQFLD���
3DUD�VXSHUDU�R�SUREOHPD��5R[LQ�UHFRQKHFH�D�H[LVWrQFLD�GH�XPD�´GLUH-
omR�ÀQDO�LQWHUQDµ�RX�´ÀQDOLGDGH�LQFRQVFLHQWHµ�H�GHIHQGH�D�SUHVHQoD�GR�TXH�
GHQRPLQD� ´DGDSWDomR� GR� DSDUDWR� DQtPLFR� D� FLUFXQVWkQFLDV� RX� HYHQWRV� GR�
PXQGR�H[WHULRUµ��D�TXDO�� VHJXQGR�DÀUPD��HVWDULD� LQVHULGR�QD� LGHLD�GH�SHU-
sonalidade����2� FDPLQKR�SURSRVWR�� SRUpP�� QmR� FRQGX]� D� ERP� WHUPR�� 3HOR�
FRQWUiULR��$R� LQYpV�GH�FRQWULEXLU�SDUD�D� VROXomR�GD�TXHVWmR��R�VXUJLPHQWR�
GHVVH�QRYR�FULWpULR�OHYD�D�WUrV�REMHo}HV�TXH�DOFDQoDP�D�WHRULD�FRPR�XP�WRGR��
3ULPHLUR��TXH�D�VXD�HODERUDomR�DWHQGH�j�´QHFHVVLGDGHµ�MXUtGLFR�SHQDO�GH�UH-
FRQKHFHU�DTXL�XPD�DomR��(P�RXWUDV�SDODYUDV��TXH�R�FRQFHLWR�SHVVRDO�GH�DomR�
HVWi��QD�YHUGDGH��LQIRUPDGR�SHOR�SUySULR�WLSR�SHQDO�H��DVVLP��EXVFD�FRQIRU-
PDU�DTXLOR�TXH�p�MXUtGLFR�SHQDOPHQWH�LQWHUHVVDQWH��GHIUDXGDQGR�GHVVH�PRGR�
D�IXQomR�GH�XQLmR��6HJXQGR��TXH�D�SRVVLELOLGDGH�GH�UHFRQKHFHU�XPD�´GLUHomR�
ÀQDO� LQWHUQDµ�²�FRQFHLWR�TXH� UHFODPD�XP�PDLRU�GHVHQYROYLPHQWR�²�HVWDULD�
SUHMXGLFDGD�a priori�SHOR�FULWpULR�LQLFLDO�GH�GRPLQDELOLGDGH��1mR�VH�SRGH�HV-
TXHFHU� TXH�� SDUD�5R[LQ�� VRPHQWH� p�PDQLIHVWDomR�GD� SHUVRQDOLGDGH�� DTXLOR�
TXH� IRU�GRPLQiYHO�SHOD�vontade e consciência��DTXL� LQH[LVWHQWH��$�VXD� LQVHU-
omR��SRUWDQWR��FRPR�FDWHJRULD�VHFXQGiULD��L�H���SRVWHULRU�DR�FULWpULR�´YRQWDGH�
H� FRQVFLrQFLDµ�� p� LPSRVVtYHO� H�� VH� DQWHULRU�� WHUPLQD� SRU� HVYD]LDU� R� FULWpULR�
LQLFLDO��7HUFHLUR�� TXH� HVWD�PXOWLSOLFLGDGH�GH� FULWpULRV� H[WUDtGRV�GR� FRQFHLWR�
de personalidade�LPSOLFD�XPD�QRomR�GH�SHUVRQDOLGDGH�H[FHVVLYDPHQWH�DEHUWD�
H�SOXULIRUPH��LQFDSD]�GH�DWHQGHU�DGHTXDGDPHQWH�j�IXQomR�GH�GHOLPLWDomR�
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������H�VV�
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������
160
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
160
'H�RXWUD�SDUWH��QR�TXH�WDQJH�j�IXQomR�FODVVLÀFDWyULD�RX��PDV�SUHFLVD-
PHQWH��j�SUHWHQVmR�GH�UHXQLU�DomR�H�RPLVVmR�VRE�XP�~QLFR�FRQFHLWR��PHOKRU�
r[LWR�QmR� WHP�D�SURSRVWD�GH�5R[LQ��e�EHP�YHUGDGH�TXH�R�DXWRU�VXVWHQWD�D�
H[LVWrQFLD�GH�XPD�GLPHQVmR�YDORUDWLYD�QD�FDWHJRULD�´PDQLIHVWDomR�GD�SHUVR-
QDOLGDGHµ��D�TXDO��IXQGDGD�QDV�H[SHFWDWLYDV�VRFLDLV��SRVVXLULD�D�FDSDFLGDGH�
GH�DSUHHQGHU�D�RPLVVmR�HP�XP�PRPHQWR�SUp�WtSLFR��H[���DOJXpP��GH�IRUPD�
LQWHQFLRQDO��QmR�VD~GD�XP�YHOKR�FRQKHFLGR�����&RQWXGR�� LVVR�HVWi� ORQJH�GH�
VROXFLRQDU�D�TXHVWmR��(P�SULPHLUR�OXJDU��LPSRUWD�VDEHU�D�SDUWLU�GH�TXDO�FUL-
WpULR�R�FRQFHLWR�SHVVRDO�GH�DomR�SUHWHQGH�DYDOLDU�D�RFRUUrQFLD�GR�QmR�DWHQGL-
PHQWR�GH�XPD�´H[SHFWDWLYD�GH�DomRµ��$�DSOLFDomR�GR�FULWpULR�LQLFLDO��LVWR�p��
GDV�HPDQDo}HV�DQtPLFR�HVSLULWXDLV�GR�VHU�KXPDQR��HP�QDGD�FRQWULEXL�QHVVH�
VHQWLGR��2QGH�UHVLGLULD��HQWmR��R�UHIHUHQFLDO�D[LROyJLFR�QHFHVViULR�SDUD�WDQWR"�
$�UHVSRVWD�HVWi�QRYDPHQWH�QR�Mi�ilimitado FRQFHLWR�GH�SHUVRQDOLGDGH��6HJXQ-
GR�REVHUYD�R�SUySULR�DXWRU��D�SHUVRQDOLGDGH�QmR�FRQVLVWLULD�HP�DSHQDV�XP�
HOHPHQWR��PDV�HP�´P~OWLSODV�FDWHJRULDV�YDORUDWLYDVµ���
(VVD�DPSOD�FRQIRUPDomR��WRGDYLD��LPS}H�D�DFHLWDomR�GH�XPD�HQWUH�GXDV�
DOWHUQDWLYDV��2X�VH�GHYH�UHFRQKHFHU�XPD�WDO�DPSOLWXGH�j�SHUVRQDOLGDGH��SDUD�
DOpP�GDTXHOD�Mi�DFLPD�FRQVWDWDGD��TXH�D�WRUQDULD�DEVROXWDPHQWH�LPSUDWLFiYHO�
FRPR�FULWpULR��RX�VH�GHYH�DTXL�UHFRQKHFHU�XPD�DSUR[LPDomR�FRP�R�FRQFHLWR�
VRFLDO�GH�DomR��VXEVWLWXLQGR�WRGDV�HVVDV�´P~OWLSODV�FDWHJRULDVµ��SRU�XPD�FD-
WHJRULD�DPSOD�GH�´UHOHYkQFLD�VRFLDOµ��VXMHLWD��QHVWD�PHGLGD��D�WRGDV�DV�FUtWLFDV�
TXH�OKH�VmR�RSRVWDV��LQFOXVLYH�SHOR�SUySULR�5R[LQ���
1mR�EDVWDVVH�LVVR��PHVPR�TXH�D�SHUVRQDOLGDGH�VH�DSUHVHQWDVVH�FRPR�
FULWpULR�VXÀFLHQWHPHQWH�GHOLPLWDGR�SDUD�DV�IXQo}HV�D[LROyJLFDV�D�TXH�VH�SUR-
S}H��D�YHUGDGH�p�TXH��DLQGD�DVVLP��QmR�HVWDULD�DSWD�D�SURSLFLDU�XP�FRUUHWR�
DWHQGLPHQWR�j�IXQomR�GH�XQLmR��$�~QLFD�DYDOLDomR�D[LROyJLFD�TXH�LQWHUHVVD�
SDUD�D�DSUHFLDomR�GD�RPLVVmR�MXUtGLFR�SHQDO�FRQVLVWH��FRPR�Mi�WLYHPRV�RSRU-
WXQLGDGH�GH�REVHUYDU��QD�DYDOLDomR�SHUPLWLGD�SHOD�WLSLFLGDGH��UHVXOWDQGR�DE-
VROXWDPHQWH�GHVQHFHVViULDV�RXWUDV�FRQVLGHUDo}HV�GH�FXQKR�YDORUDWLYR��1HP�
�� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������H�VV��� 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������
�� &RQFOXVmR� HVVD� TXH�� ORJLFDPHQWH�� QmR� FRUUHVSRQGH� j� YRQWDGH� GH� 5R[LQ�� 1HVVH� SRQWR��
LPSRUWD�PHQFLRQDU� D� FUtWLFD� GH� -HVFKHFN� H�:HLJHQG�� VHJXQGR� D� TXDO� R� FRQFHLWR� SHVVRDO�
VHULD� PXLWR� DPSOR�� DEUDQJHQGR�� LQFOXVLYH�� DFRQWHFLPHQWRV� VHP� TXDOTXHU� UHOHYR� VRFLDO�
�-(6&+(&.��+DQV�+HLQULFK��:(,*(1'��7KRPDV��Lehrbuch des Strafrechts��S��������&UtWLFD�
TXH�p� UHEDWLGD�SRU�5R[LQ�VRE�R�DUJXPHQWR�GH�TXH�D� UHOHYkQFLD� VRFLDO� FRUUHVSRQGH�D�XP�
FULWpULR�GHPDVLDGDPHQWH�YDJR�H�TXH�R�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR�GHYH�WDPEpP�FRPSUHHQGHU�IDWRV�
GHVSURYLGRV�GH�UHOHYR�VRFLDO��52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S��������
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
161161
VHPSUH�KDYHUi�R�QmR�DWHQGLPHQWR�GH�H[SHFWDWLYDV�SUpYLDV�jTXHOD�QRWLFLDGD�
SHOR� WLSR� SHQDO�� R� TXH�� REYLDPHQWH�� UHWLUD� D� SRVVLELOLGDGH� GH� LGHQWLÀFDU� D�
RPLVVmR�HP�XPD�GLPHQVmR�SUp�WtSLFD���
(P�SRVWXUD�FLHQWtÀFD�H[HPSODU��5R[LQ�UHFRQKHFH��QHVWH�SDUWLFXODU��DV�
OLPLWDo}HV�GR�VHX�FRQFHLWR�GH�DomR��6HJXQGR�R�DXWRU��H[LVWHP�KLSyWHVHV�HP�
TXH�R� WLSR�SHQDO�p�HIHWLYDPHQWH�R�SULPHLUR�IDWRU�GH�FRQVLGHUDomR�D[LROyJL-
FD��IDWRU�SULPHLUR�GH�FRQYHUVmR�GH�XP�QmR�ID]HU�HP�XPD�RPLVVmR�MXUtGLFR-
�SHQDOPHQWH�UHOHYDQWH��FRPR��v.g.��FRVWXPD�RFRUUHU�QDV�OHJLVODo}HV�SHQDLV�QR�
kPELWR�GD�HFRQRPLD��FRPpUFLR�H�LQG~VWULD���1HVVHV�FDVRV��DÀUPD�HOH��´QmR�Ki�
DomR�DQWHV�GR�WLSRµ��p��HP�UHDOLGDGH��R�WLSR�TXH�SUHVVXS}H�D�DomR91�
reFerÊncias
%(/,1*��(UQVW��'LH�/HKUH�YRP�9HUEUHFKHQ��7�ELQJHQ��-��&��%��0RKU�������
%,7(1&2857�� &H]DU� 5REHUWR�� Tratado de direito penal�� 3DUWH� JHUDO�� ���� HG�� 6mR� 3DXOR��
6DUDLYD��Y��,��������
%(+5(1'7�� +DQV�-RDFKLP�� Die Unterlassung im Strafrecht�� (QWZXUI� HLQHV� QHJDWLYHQ�
+DQGOXQJVEHJULIIV�DXI�SV\FKRDQDO\WLVFKHU�*UXQGODJH��%DGHQ�%DGHQ��1RPRV�������
%86$72��3DXOR�&pVDU��Direito penal��3DUWH�JHUDO��6mR�3DXOR��$WODV��������
BBBBBB��5HÁH[}HV�VREUH�R�VLVWHPD�SHQDO�GR�QRVVR�WHPSR��5LR�GH�-DQHLUR��/XPHQ�-XULV��������
&255(,$��(GXDUGR��Direito criminal��&RLPEUD��$OPHGLQD��������UHLPSUHVVmR��
',$6��-RUJH�GH�)LJXHLUHGR��Direito penal��3DUWH�JHUDO�����HG��EUDVLOHLUD�����HG��SRUWXJXHVD��
6mR�3DXOR��5HYLVWD�GRV�7ULEXQDLV�H�&RLPEUD�(GLWRUD��������
),$1'$&$�� *LRYDQQL�� 086&2�� (Q]R�� Diritto penale�� 3DUWH� JHQHUDOH�� ��� HG�� %RORJQD��
=DQLFKHOOL�������
)5$*262��+HOHQR� &OiXGLR�� Lições de direito penal�� 3DUWH� JHUDO�� ���� HG�� 5LR� GH� -DQHLUR��
)RUHQVH�������
*$//$6��:LOKHOP��=XPJHJHQZlUWLJHQ�6WDQG�GHU�/HKUH�YRP�9HUEUHFKHQ��,Q��Beiträgezur 
Verbrechenslehre��%HUOLQ��:DOWHU�GH�*UX\WHU�������
+(5=%(5*��5ROI�'LHWULFK��Die Unterlassung im Strafrecht und das Garantenprinzip��%HUOLQ��
:DOWHU�GH�������
-$.2%6��*�QWKHU��Strafrecht. Allgemeiner Teil�����HG��%HUOLQ��1HZ�<RUN��:DOWHU�GH�*UX\WHU��
�����
-(6&+(&.��+DQV�+HLQULFK��:(,*(1'�� 7KRPDV�� Lehrbuch des Strafrechts�� $OOJHPHLQHU�
7HLO�����HG��%HUOLQ��'XQFNHU�	�+XPEORW�������
�� 1HVVH�PHVPR�VHQWLGR��',$6��-RUJH�GH�)LJXHLUHGR��Direito penal��S������
91 52;,1��&ODXV��Strafrecht��$7��S������
162
Revista de estudos CRiminais 54
doutRina naCional
Julho/setembRo 2014
162
.$8)0$11��$UWKXU��$� SUREOHPiWLFD� GD� ÀORVRÀD� GR� GLUHLWR� DR� ORQJR�GD� KLVWyULD�� ,Q��
.$8)0$11��$UWKXU��+$66(0(5��:LQIULHG��,QWURGXomR�j�ÀORVRÀD�GR�GLUHLWR�H�j�WHRULD�GR�
direito contemporâneas��7UDG��0DUFRV�.HHO�H�0DQXHO�GH�2OLYHLUD��UHY��H�FRRUG��GH�$QWyQLR�
0DQXHO�+HVSDQKD��/LVERD��)XQGDomR�&DORXVWH�*XOEHQNLDQ�������
BBBBBB�� +$66(0(5�� :LQIULHG�� ,QWURGXomR� j� ÀORVRÀD� GR� GLUHLWR� H� j� WHRULD� GR� GLUHLWR�
contemporâneas�� 7UDG�� 0DUFRV� .HHO� H� 0DQXHO� GH� 2OLYHLUD�� UHY�� H� FRRUG�� GH� $QWyQLR�
0DQXHO�+HVSDQKD��/LVERD��)XQGDomR�&DORXVWH�*XOEHQNLDQ�������
/(1&.1(5�� 7KHRGRU�� (,6(/(�� -|UJ�� ,Q�� 6&+g1.(�� $GROI�� 6&+5g'(5�� +RUVW��
Strafgesetzbuch Kommentar������HG��0�QFKHQ��&��+��%HFN�������
/,6=7��)UDQ]�Y��Das deutsche Reichsstrafrecht auf Grund des Reichsstrafgesetzbuchs und der 
übrigen strafrechtlichen Reichsgesetze�����HG��%HUOLQ��/HLS]LJ��*XWWHQWDJ�������
BBBBBB��Lehrbuch des deutschen Strafrechts�����HG��%HUOLQ��/HLS]LJ��*XWWHQWDJ��������
BBBBBB��Tratado de direito penal alemão��7UDG��-RVp�+\JLQR�'XDUWH�3HUHLUD��5LR�GH�-DQHLUR�� 
)��%ULJXLHW��W��,��������
BBBBBB��6&+0,'7��(EHUKDUG��Lehrbuch des deustchen Strafrechts��(LQOHLWXQJ�XQG�DOOJHPHLQHU�
7HLO������HG��%HUOLQ��/HLS]LJ��:DOWHU�GH�*UX\WHU�������
0$5,18&&,��*LRUJLR��Il reato come “azione”��&ULWLFD�GL�XQ�GRJPD��0LODQR��*LXIIUq�������
0(=*(5�� (GPXQG�� Strafrecht�� (LQ� /HKUEXFK�� ��� HG�� 0�QFKHQ�� /HLS]LJ�� 'XQFNHU� XQG�
+XPEORW�������
021&$'$��/��&DEUDO�GH��)LORVRÀD�GR�GLUHLWR�H�GR�(VWDGR�����HG��&RLPEUD��&RLPEUD�(GLWRUD��
Y��,�������������UHLPS���
18&&,��*XLOKHUPH�GH�6RX]D��Manual de direito penal��3DUWH�JHUDO�����HG��6mR�3DXOR��5HYLVWD�
GRV�7ULEXQDLV�������
2772��+DUUR��Grundkurs Strafrecht��$OOJHPHLQH�6WUDIUHFKWVOHKUH�����HG��%HUOLQ�H�1HZ�<RUN��
:DOWHU�GH�*UX\WHU�������
5$'%58&+�� *XVWDY��Der Handlungsbegriff in seiner Bedeutungfür das Strafrechtssystem��
%HUOLQ��*XWWHQWDJ�������
5($/(�-Ô1,25��0LJXHO��Instituições de direito penal��3DUWH�JHUDO��5LR�GH�-DQHLUR��)RUHQVH��
Y��,�������
52;,1�� &ODXV�� &RQWULEXLomR� SDUD� D� FUtWLFD� GD� WHRULD� ÀQDOLVWD� GD� DFomR�� ,Q�� Problemas 
fundamentais de direito penal��7UDG��$QD�3DXOD�GRV�6DQWRV�H�/XtV�1DWVFKHUDGHW]�����HG��
/LVERD��9HJD�������
BBBBBB��,O�FRQFHWWR�GL�D]LRQH�QHL�SL~�UHFHQWL�GLEDWWLWL�GHOOD�GRPPDWLFD�SHQDOLVWLFD�WHGHVFD��
In: Studi in memoria di Giacomo Delitala��0LODQR��*LXIIUq��Y��,,,�������
BBBBBB��Strafrecht��$OOJHPHLQHU�7HLO�����HG��0�QFKHQ��9HUODJ�&��+��%HFN��Y��,�������
6$1726�� -XUDUH]�&LULQR��Direito penal�� 3DUWH� JHUDO�� ��� HG��&XULWLED�� ,&3&��/XPHQ� -XULV��
������
628=$��$UWXU� GH� %ULWR�*XHLURV�� -$3,$66�� &DUORV� (GXDUGR�$GULDQR��Curso de direito 
penal��5LR�GH�-DQHLUR��(OVHYLHU��������
6&+g1.(�� $GROI�� 6&+5g'(5�� +RUVW�� Strafgesetzbuch Kommentar�� ���� HG�� 0�QFKHQ�� 
&��+��%HFN�������
Doutrina nacional
revista De estuDos criminais 54
Julho/setembro 2014
163163
72/('2��)UDQFLVFR�GH�$VVLV��Princípios básicos de direito penal�����HG��6mR�3DXOR��6DUDLYD��
�����
:(/=(/��+DQV��Derecho penal aleman� 7UDG��GD�����HG��DOHPm�SRU�-XDQ�%XVWRV�5DPtUH]�\�
6HUJLR�<ixH]�3pUH]�����HG��6DQWLDJR�GH�&KLOH��-XUtGLFD�GH�&KLOH�������
:(66(/6�� -RKDQQHV��%(8/.(��:HUQHU��Strafrecht��$OOJHPHLQHU�7HLO������HG��+HLGHOEHUJ��
0�OOHU�������

Continue navegando