Arguição de Descumprimento de Preceito Fundamental (ADPF)

Prévia do material em texto

!"#$%&'()*(+*,-#./!$.*01'()*(2!*-*$1'(3#0)4.*0145(6 +237 8
 !"#$%&' () *)+,#-.!$-)/0' () 1!),)$0'
2#/(3-)/034 5 *126
73$ 303,3! #- 30' 8#) ()+,#-.!3 !"#"$%& '()*+,")%+- #&).%$%(#$&)+-
9:;*1'(< )9$03!:'#:!).3!3!:4)+&':3:.!),)$0':;#/(3-)/034=(!*,#51401*()*(41'()'(2')*!(2>:5$-'?
 !0<:=>?
 (@'0,1$1#$%&'(/!*AB(4( +23=(.4,()*$C4(/4!4(4(5*$($0D!4-'0,1$1#-$'045(!*"#54.*014!
@)"#43-)/03%&'
A)$ B<CC?DBB
+$,/E*(,':!*('(/!'-*,,'(*(;#5"4.*01'()4(4!"#$%&'()*()*,-#./!$.*01'()*(/!*-*$1'(D#0)4.*0145=(0',(1*!.',()'(F8G=()'(4!1?(8HI()4
@'0,1$1#$%&'(3*)*!45?
@'.'(4(!*"#54.*014%&'()*/*0)$4()*(5*$=(/4,,'#(4(,*!(#1$5$J4)4(4/*04,(*.(8KKK=(-'.(4(*)$%&'()4(L*$(K?MMINKK
E*);)$0'+ (' +$+0)-3F
 (@'0,1$1#$%&'()*(MM(4./5$'#('(-'01!'5*(-'0-*01!4)'()*(-'0,1$1#-$'045$)4)*O
P!'#C*(/'01',(D4A'!QA*$,(4'(-'01!'5*=(.4,=(.*,.'(4,,$.=(R4A$4(45"#.4,(.41<!$4,(S#*(0&'(*!4.(,#,-*1TA*$,()'(-'01!'5*
-'0-*01!4)'(41!4A<,()4( +UV
30':-#/$,$.34 30'+:3/0)!$'!)+:G:H2:5!),).%&'6 30'+:/&':/'!-30$9'+<
 +23(A*$'(/4!4(1*014!(,#/!$!(*,,*,()*D*$1',O(4).$1$!(4'(-'01!'5*(-'0-*01!4)'(*,,*,(41',(S#*(*!4.($0,#,-*1TA*$,(4'(-'01!'5*
-'0-*01!4)'()*(-'0,1$1#-$'045$)4)*
U)*$4V(!*,'5A*!(/!':5*.4,()'(,$,1*.4?
W'(*01401'=(4(L*$(D'$(D*$14(-'.("!4#()*(,#:;*1$A$)4)*(.#$1'("!40)*O
A)"$0$-3('+
X&'(',(.*,.',(5*"$1$.4)',()4( +U
 IJKLMNO:N+:4)"$0$-3('+:/&':)+0&':.!)9$+0'+:/3:H'/+0$0#$%&':2)()!34P:-3+:/3:A)$:/Q:B<CRCDBB:53!0<:?QP:$/,$+':S6
Y#401'(Z(-4/4-$)4)*(/',1#541[!$4(*(/*!1$0B0-$4(1*.Q1$-4(-4:*.(4,(.*,.4,(!*"!4,
S/,$+' SSO H$(3(&'+ 4)"$0$-3('+ 5T6
3'$(A*14)'O(!*-'0R*-$4('()$!*$1'()*(/!'/',$1#!4(4',(-$)4)&',
U3+:/&':+)!$3:$/0)!)++3/0):"3!3/0$!:4)"$0$-$(3():3':,$(3(&'T !"#$%&'!($()*$'&+,"&-./0&1(6\UL] ^(]_W+_X7=(.4,V
 '(.*,.'(1*./'(S#*(,*!$4($./'!1401*=(/'$,()*D*0)*!(/!*-*$1'(D#0)4.*0145(<=(/'!(*C*./5'=()*D*0)*!()$!*$1'(D#0)4.*0145=('
*C-*,,'()*()*.40)4(/')*!$4(4D*14!('(D#0-$'04.*01'()'(/![/!$'(,$,1*.4O
 !"#$%&'()*(+*,-#./!$.*01'()*(2!*-*$1'(3#0)4.*0145(6 +237 I
2*0,4!()*(#.4(D'!.4(S#*(4'(.*,.'(1*./'(/*!.$1$,,*(4'(-$)4)&'=(,*.(4D*14!('(D#0-$'04.*01'()'(/![/!$'(,$,1*.4
H3-.' -30)!$34
 1',()'(2')*!(2>:5$-'
`(.4$,(4./5'O(0&'(D454(*.(5*$('#(41'(0'!.41$A'O _0"5':4(41',(S#*(0&'(D'!4.(4).$1$)',(/*54( +U
 0'+:3/0)!$'!)+:G:H2 0'+:-#/$,$.3$+ 0'+:/&':/'!-30$9'+
H'-':','!!):':,'/0!'4):():30'+:/&':/'!-30$9'+T
1!),)$0' 2#/(3-)/034T
@'.'(4(5*$(0&'(*C/5$-4=(<(/!*-$,'(/*0,4!(*01&'()*(S#*(D'!.4(4()'#1!$04(-'01!$:#$(*()*(S#*(D'!.4('(XP3(*01*0)*O
S/0)!.!)03%&':3-.4$30$93T(P'!04(1#)'(/!*-*$1'(D#0)4.*0145(*
4-4:4()*,S#45$D$-40)'('(1*!.'O
S/0)!.!)03%&':!)+0!$0$93T(a4$(-'0D#0)$!(-'.(/!$0-T/$',?
2!$0-T/$',(,&'(0'!.4,(*,1!#1#!401*,()'(_,14)'(:!4,$5*$!'
6PT1#5'(U=(@37?(^*,1!$0"*(.#$1'('(45-40-*()4( +23(*($./*)*
,#4(#1$5$J4%&'(*.(-4,'()*(D*!$.*01',(Z(A45'!*,(14.:<.(.#$1'
$./'!1401*,
S()$3 VW+$,3P #0$4$X3(3 .)43 ('#0!$/3 ) Y#!$+.!#(Z/,$3
X&'(',(/'01',(!*5*A401*,()'(1*C1'(-'0,1$1#-$'045O 2!$0-T/$',(D#0)4.*014$,O()$!*$1',(D#0)4.*014$,O(-5Q#,#54,
/<1!*4,
1'+$%[)+:('#0!$/W!$3+O
A\S]: A^J@IN:J:7S* A:_J@@ KN:`@
X&'(4S#*54,(0'!.4,(S#*(,&'(D#0)4.*014$,(/4!4(4
*,1!#1#!4%&'()*(#.4(-'0,1$1#$%&'(D*)*!45O
X&'(4S#*54,(S#*($)*01$D$-4.(D'!.4()*(*,14)'=(,$,1*.4()*
"'A*!0'=(D#0-$'04.*01'()',(/')*!*,=(',(/!$0-T/$',(*()$!*$1',
D#0)4.*014$,O(4S#*54,(0'!.4,(41$0*01*,(Z('!)*.(*-'0b.$-4(*
,'-$45
aSAU @:UJK*J_
X&'(',()$!*$1',(*("4!401$4,(D#0)4.*014$,(*(4,()*.4$,
-5Q#,#54,(/<1!*4,O
X&'(',(/ !$)#0 $&.1.").02"$./
4!1?(cd=($0-?(aUUO(/!$0-T/$',(1&'()*5$-4)',(04(@3(S#*(,*
D'!*.(D*!$)',()&'(*0,*;'(4($01*!A*0%&'(D*)*!45
_#.!)-':I!$V#/34:2)()!34
U01<!/!*1*(D$045()4(@'0,1$1#$%&'O
_.(#51$.4(4045$,*(<(S#*.()*-$)*('(S#*(<(/!*-*$1'(D#0)4.*0145O
XP3(0&'()*D$0$#=(.4,(*,14:*5*-*#(45"#0,(A*1'!*,(41!4A<,()*(;#!$,/!#)B0-$4=(*,14:*5*-*0)'(45"#0,(/4)!E*,O
_)!&':3++$-O
,4W#+#43+:.b0!)3+ .!$/,c.$'+:;#/(3-)/03$+ ($!)$0'+:$/($9$(#3$+:):,'4)0$9'+
($!)$0'+:+',$3$+ ($!)$0'+:.'4c0$,'+ /'!-3+:G:'!"3/$X3%&':.'4c0$,'d3(-$/$+0!30$93
5;)()!34$+-'6
_#V+$($3!$)(3()
`(#.($0,1!#.*01'(#1$5$J4)'()*(D'!.4(,#:,$)$Q!$4=('#(,*;4=(S#40)'(0&'(-'#:*!(0*.( +U=(0*.( +@O
e1$5$J4)'(S#40)'(0&'(R'#A*!('#1!'(.*$'(*D$-4J()*(,404!(4(5*,$A$)4)*?
 !"#$%&'()*(+*,-#./!$.*01'()*(2!*-*$1'(3#0)4.*0145(6 +237 c
9(-4!Q1*!(,#:,$)$Q!$'()*A*(D$-4!()*.'0,1!4)'(04(/*1$%&'
?:;'!-3+:():$/0)!.!)03!:)++3:+#V+$($3!$)(3()
_,"'14.*01'(1')',(',(.*$',(*D$-4J*,()*(,*,,4!(4(5*,$A$)4)*
_,A4J$4!$4(.#$1'('(-'01*>)'
]*$'(*D$-4J(*(4/1'(Z(,404!()*(D'!.4(4./54=("*!45=($.*)$414?
S#40)'(0&'(-'#:*!('#1!4(4%&'()'(-'01!'5*(-'0-*01!4)'
1!',)($-)/0'
2!'-*,,'(*(;#5"4.*01'V(3"$1)4156787955
e#)+0&'O
$?(1)0$%&':$/$,$34
J4)-)/0'+:8#):()9)-:)+03!:.!)+)/0)+O
/!*-*$1'(D#0)4.*0145(A$'54)'(6/!'A4()4
A$'54%&'7
41'(S#*,1$'04)' /*)$)' -4!Q1*!(,#:,$)$Q!$'?
e#)+0&'O
 :8#)-:()9):+)!:)/()!)%3(3:3:.)0$%&':$/$,$34T 2'&%!.&-)&$.,$ 345
$$?(1)($(':():$/;'!-3%[)+
X'5$-$14($0D'!.4%E*,(Z,(4#1'!$)4)*,(!*,/'0,QA*$,(/*54(/!Q1$-4()'(41'
P4.:<.(4-'01*-*(S#401'(4',(41',(!*-*/-$'04)',(/*54(@'0,1$1#$%&'O(A4$()$!*-$'04!(4'(!*,/'0,QA*5
$$$?( (9'"3('da)!34:(3:\/$&':5 a\6
 (L*$(0&'(/!*AB('$1$A4=($,1'(<=(0&'(':!$"4O 2*!.$1*=(.4,(0&'(D4J(4(*C$"B0-$4
W4(/!Q1$-4('(X#/!*.'(P!$:#045(3*)*!45(D4J(4(-$14%&'
$A?(1!',#!3('!da)!34:(3:@).fV4$,3:51a@6
`('#A$)'(,*./!*(S#*(4,(4!"#$%E*,(0&'(D'!*.(D'!.#54)4,(/'!(*5*O
A?(`#4"3-)/0'
 ,'4g$(':':.)($(' ()*-54!4f,*(4($0-'0,1$1#-$'045$)4)*()'
41'
@)Y)$03(':':.)($(' ()*-54!4f,*(4(-'0,1$1#-$'045$)4)*()'(41'
 !"#$%&'()*(+*,-#./!$.*01'()*(2!*-*$1'(3#0)4.*0145(6 +237 d
X*(1!414!()*(41'(401*!$'!(Z(@'0,1$1#$%&'=(0&'(A4$(,*(D454!(*.($0-'0,1$1#-$'045$)4)*('#(-'0,1$1#-$'045$)4)*=(.4,(*.
!"#" :;&1&(1);&
 ;$/34$(3() /' ,'/0!'4) () ,'/+0$0#,$'/34$(3() ,'/,)/0!3(' 93$ +)! 3 -)+-3O !"#&)<"#"! +
#&).%$%(#$&)+-$*+*" *" (, +%&
J;)$0'+ (3 (),$+&'
)!"3 '-/)+
6-4!4-1*!T,1$-4,()'(-'01!'5*(-'0-*01!4)'7
9$/,#43/0)+
Z([!"&',()'(2')*!(g#)$-$Q!$'(*()4( ).$0$,1!4%&'(2>:5$-4
6D*)*!45=(*,14)#45(*(.#0$-$/457?
='"$%&.1*+1*"#-+!+:;&1*"1$)#&).%$%(#$&)+-$*+*">
)h 0#/, !).!$+0$/30i!$'+
N^_<:]')#54%&'()',(*D*$1',(6,*"#!40%4(;#!T)$-4(N(*C-*/-$'045($01*!*,,*(,'-$45(Z(INc7