Logo Passei Direto
Buscar
Material
páginas com resultados encontrados.
páginas com resultados encontrados.

Prévia do material em texto

Mathematical Association is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Mathematical Gazette.
http://www.jstor.org
Napier's Education: A Speculation 
Author(s): Alex Inglis 
Source: The Mathematical Gazette, Vol. 20, No. 238 (May, 1936), pp. 132-134
Published by: Mathematical Association
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3606286
Accessed: 15-02-2016 11:43 UTC
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/
 info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content 
in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. 
For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
This content downloaded from 150.131.192.151 on Mon, 15 Feb 2016 11:43:38 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org
http://www.jstor.org/publisher/mathas
http://www.jstor.org/stable/3606286
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
THE MATHEMATICAL GAZETTE 
NAPIER'S EDUCATION--A SPECULATION. 
BY ALEX. INGLIS. 
It has been shown * that the evolution of logarithms involves 
consideration of Napier's knowledge of Greek; this in turn is con- 
nected with his " educational and cultural environment ". He cer- 
tainly studied abroad for some years but where he spent the time 
is largely a matter for speculation. Now even speculation must be 
based on some form of reasoning, therefore let it be taken as a 
hypothesis that as his mathematical equipment was considerably in 
advance of that of his contemporaries, this equipment must have 
been the result of ideas planted by his teachers. Consequently an 
explanation of Napier's travels may be made by considering his 
work in mathematics and by discovering similarities in the works of 
mathematicians who were in Europe during the years of his residence 
abroad. It must be remembered also that it was a time of acute 
religious differences, and that he belonged to a family that was 
ardently Protestant in its sympathies. His own Protestantism is 
quite openly expressed in his work on the Apocalypse. Therefore 
these speculations are based on the " historico-religious " background 
of the period and on Napier's mathematical attainments. 
It was a period of unrest and disorder in Scotland which was 
mainly due to the state of unstable equilibrium produced by the 
Reformation affecting all the activities of the time. Politically Scot- 
land was in alliance with France, but in her true interests " Flanders 
was more valuable to her; . . . in prosaic fashion the intercourse 
was productive of unmixed good in showing the way to an intelligent 
cultivation of the resources of the country ". t Most of the trade was 
with the Low Countries and the commercial treaty was renewed in 
1545. While the Catholic party was strong in its support of the 
French alliance, the Protestants were bitterly opposed to it and were 
successful in bringing it to an end by the Treaty of Edinburgh in 
1560. " The Scottish scholar, to his loss, now forced himself to be 
content with such learning as he could get in St. Andrews or Glasgow 
or Aberdeen. The cultured Scotsman had no longer, as it were, one 
foot in Paris and one in Edinburgh; his horizon was contracting." $ 
John Napier certainly matriculated at St. Salvator's College, St. 
Andrews, in 1563, for Mark Napier found a record of it in Edinburgh. 
According to Hume Brown, the length of time Napier spent at St. 
Andrews is uncertain and his further movements are unknown.? 
Mark Napier states quite definitely that he left St. Andrews for the 
University of Paris in 1564. 1! There are many arguments against 
this, the chief being that it is unlikely that a Protestant father of 
* Mathematical Gazette, July 1935, 192-205. 
t P. Hume Brown, History of Scotland, i. 344. 
+ R. L. Mackie, A Short History of Scotland, 238. 
? Napier Memorial Volume, 37. 
|I Memoirs, 106. 
132 
This content downloaded from 150.131.192.151 on Mon, 15 Feb 2016 11:43:38 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
NAPIER'S EDUCATION 
the time would send his son to be educated at a stronghold of 
Catholicism, particularly as one of the reasons for removing him 
from St. Andrews may have been his friendship " with a certain 
Gentleman, a Papist ". * Adam Bothwell, Bishop of Orkney, had 
written in December 1560: " send your son John to the schools; 
over to France or Flanders; for he can learn no good at home ". 
Bothwell was an influential man at the time and likely to be familiar 
with conditions at home and abroad, and he advised: " send your son 
to Catholic France or Protestant Flanders; educationally both are 
equally good ". Therefore it seems quite likely that Napier went to 
Protestant strongholds of Europe, and curiously enough the " Greek 
theory " shows that he probably spent some time at Geneva t-the 
Vatican of Protestantism! 
An examination of the De Arte Logistica shows that Napier had a 
considerable knowledge of algebra. In it he used the "Pascal 
Triangle " for the extraction of roots; he carried his calculations 
only as far as fourth powers but indicated how the higher roots may 
be obtained. Michael Stifel, 1486-1567, also used the " triangle " 
in his Arithmetica Integra, 1544, and according to Hutton he used it 
for the extraction of roots.: Another mathematician of the time 
familiar with the "triangle " was Johann Scheubel, professor of 
mathematics at the University of Tiibingen, 1550-1570. He was 
" scholarly, heavy, balanced, dignified ", ? in fact a type likely to 
appeal to a Scot. In his De Numeris et Diversis Rationibus, 1545, he 
used the " triangle " to extract roots as high as the twenty-fourth. 
A further link between Scheubel and Napier is that while abroad the 
latter " studied the history of Arabic notation, which he traced to 
its Indian source ". |I Now Scheubel left in manuscript a copy of 
Robert of Chester's translation of al-Khowarizmi's Algebra. He 
was obviously interested in the origins of algebra, for he possessed a 
copy of a work written in the twelfth century before printing was in 
existence, and which would therefore be difficult to procure. It is 
the first work bearing the word" algebra " in its title. ? Incidentally, 
Scheubel is the first modern mathematician to mention Diophantus, 
which he does in his A Igebra Compendiosa Facilisque Descriptio, 1552. ** 
Simon Stevin, 1548-1620, is also credited with having developed 
the use of the " triangle " and of having extracted roots by its aid. 
Stevin and Napier are also connected through their pioneer work on 
decimal notation. Decimal fractions were definitely propounded 
for the first time in Stevin's Arithmetic, published in 1585. Napier's 
De Arte Logistica was written probably soon after his return home in 
1571, and in it there is a notation for decimal fractions. 
Stifel was an Augustine monk who followed Luther-he was 
* The preface to the Plaine Discovery. 
t Mathematical Gazette, July 1935, 198. 
+ Mathematical and Philosophical Dictionary. 
? D. E. Smith, History of Mathematics, i. 329. 
II H. W. Turnbull, The Great Mathematicians, 61. 
'| i). E. Smith, i. 203. ** Hutton, i. 79. 
133 
This content downloaded from 150.131.192.151 on Mon, 15 Feb 2016 11:43:38 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
THE MATHEMATICAL GAZETTE THE MATHEMATICAL GAZETTE 
certainly a Protestant; Stevin was an official of Prince Maurice of 
Orange-he was probably a Protestant; all that is known of Scheubel 
is that he was a professor of mathematics. The connections between 
the mathematicalwork of these three men and that of Napier is 
rather striking, to say the least, and it is natural to wonder whether 
he came into contact with Stifel and Scheubel while studying in 
Germany. Stevin he may have met almost anywhere, for Stevin's 
official duties caused him to travel about Europe. Consequently it 
may be argued thus: Napier was sent abroad with letters of intro- 
duction probably to Protestants, and hence most likely to the Low 
Countries as there was a definite tie between them and Scotland. 
Through these contacts later he connected with Protestants in Ger- 
many and so met Stifel and Stevin. The case of Scheubel presents 
rather more difficulty. But both Stifel and Stevin knew the coeffi- 
cients of (1 + x), where n is positive, integral and no more than 17. 
Napier's interest would be aroused, and he might hear of the man 
who could extract roots as high as the twenty-fourth by means of 
similar expressions. Thus he came to know Scheubel, studied at 
Tiibingen and so learnt something of the origins of algebra. 
Some years ago a most interesting suggestion was made by 
Professor H. Stanley Allen of the University of St. Andrews con- 
cerning the evolution of logarithms. Professor Allen suggested that 
there may have been some connection between Napier's work on 
spherical trigonometry and this discovery; further, that Napier's 
interest in the geometry of the sphere was fostered through con- 
sideration of problems in navigation, such as the sailing of a vessel 
along a rhumb line. This suggestion certainly agrees with the 
speculations above, for it presumes that Napier must have learnt 
something of navigation somewhere. At that time Scotland was not 
a maritime nation, in fact the longest voyage made by Scottish 
vessels was merely across the North Sea-little more than a coasting 
journey. The sea-going adventurers of England, Spain, Portugal 
and Holland were all endeavouring to find fame and fortune through 
long voyages to little known parts of the world; therefore, in these 
countries navigation problems would be frequently discussed. Did 
Napier study in any of these ? Spain and Portugal can be definitely 
omitted on religious grounds. If he had spent any time in England 
his name would appear most probably in the records of Oxford or 
Cambridge. It does not, and even if by some chance he was else- 
where in England it is unlikely that some record would not be found. 
Therefore Holland is the remaining country; it was largely Protes- 
tant, it was associated commercially with Scotland, and it was 
interested in navigation. ALEX. INGLIS. 
1054. Codex de Mathematicis et Maleficiis. 
Mathematicus was the name given to astrologers: as a law of Diocletian 
put it, " artem geometriae disci atque exerceri publice interest. Ars autem 
mathematica damnabilis est et interdicta omnino ".-W. E. H. Lecky, 
Rationalism in Europe, p. 41 (1910). [Per Prof. H. G. Forder.] 
certainly a Protestant; Stevin was an official of Prince Maurice of 
Orange-he was probably a Protestant; all that is known of Scheubel 
is that he was a professor of mathematics. The connections between 
the mathematical work of these three men and that of Napier is 
rather striking, to say the least, and it is natural to wonder whether 
he came into contact with Stifel and Scheubel while studying in 
Germany. Stevin he may have met almost anywhere, for Stevin's 
official duties caused him to travel about Europe. Consequently it 
may be argued thus: Napier was sent abroad with letters of intro- 
duction probably to Protestants, and hence most likely to the Low 
Countries as there was a definite tie between them and Scotland. 
Through these contacts later he connected with Protestants in Ger- 
many and so met Stifel and Stevin. The case of Scheubel presents 
rather more difficulty. But both Stifel and Stevin knew the coeffi- 
cients of (1 + x), where n is positive, integral and no more than 17. 
Napier's interest would be aroused, and he might hear of the man 
who could extract roots as high as the twenty-fourth by means of 
similar expressions. Thus he came to know Scheubel, studied at 
Tiibingen and so learnt something of the origins of algebra. 
Some years ago a most interesting suggestion was made by 
Professor H. Stanley Allen of the University of St. Andrews con- 
cerning the evolution of logarithms. Professor Allen suggested that 
there may have been some connection between Napier's work on 
spherical trigonometry and this discovery; further, that Napier's 
interest in the geometry of the sphere was fostered through con- 
sideration of problems in navigation, such as the sailing of a vessel 
along a rhumb line. This suggestion certainly agrees with the 
speculations above, for it presumes that Napier must have learnt 
something of navigation somewhere. At that time Scotland was not 
a maritime nation, in fact the longest voyage made by Scottish 
vessels was merely across the North Sea-little more than a coasting 
journey. The sea-going adventurers of England, Spain, Portugal 
and Holland were all endeavouring to find fame and fortune through 
long voyages to little known parts of the world; therefore, in these 
countries navigation problems would be frequently discussed. Did 
Napier study in any of these ? Spain and Portugal can be definitely 
omitted on religious grounds. If he had spent any time in England 
his name would appear most probably in the records of Oxford or 
Cambridge. It does not, and even if by some chance he was else- 
where in England it is unlikely that some record would not be found. 
Therefore Holland is the remaining country; it was largely Protes- 
tant, it was associated commercially with Scotland, and it was 
interested in navigation. ALEX. INGLIS. 
1054. Codex de Mathematicis et Maleficiis. 
Mathematicus was the name given to astrologers: as a law of Diocletian 
put it, " artem geometriae disci atque exerceri publice interest. Ars autem 
mathematica damnabilis est et interdicta omnino ".-W. E. H. Lecky, 
Rationalism in Europe, p. 41 (1910). [Per Prof. H. G. Forder.] 
134 134 
This content downloaded from 150.131.192.151 on Mon, 15 Feb 2016 11:43:38 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
	Article Contents
	p. 132
	p. 133
	p. 134
	Issue Table of Contents
	The Mathematical Gazette, Vol. 20, No. 238, May, 1936
	Work for University Entrance Scholarships [pp. 73 - 87]
	Fractional Calculus [pp. 88 - 92]
	Gleanings Far and Near [pp. 92 - 153]
	Rider-Work in Geometry [pp. 93 - 109]
	Exhibition of Mathematical Films [and Discussion] [pp. 110 - 114]
	A Property of the Secant [pp. 115 - 119]
	The Rehabilitation of Differentials [and Discussion] [pp. 120 - 131]
	Napier's Education: A Speculation [pp. 132 - 134]
	Presentation to Mr. Pendlebury [pp. 135 - 136]
	Correspondence
	Algebraic Equations with Complex Coefficients [p. 137]
	Mathematical Notes
	1183. Bieberbach's Trisection [p. 138]
	1184. A Geometrical Transformation [pp. 138 - 139]
	1185. A Group of Coaxial Circles; Generalization of the Orthopoletheorem [p. 140]
	1186. Integers Expressible as the Sum of Two Rational Cubes [pp. 140 - 141]
	1187. On Note 1152 [pp. 141 - 142]
	1188. An Elementary Collision Problem [pp. 142 - 143]
	1189. Group Theory Definitions in Webster's "New International Dictionary" [pp. 143 - 144]
	1190. Special Integrals of Differential Equations [p. 144]
	1191. The Remainder Theorem [pp. 144 - 145]
	1192. Sur les points de Feuerbach [pp. 145 - 148]
	1193. The Elementary Theorems in Analytical Statics [pp. 148 - 149]
	1194. Note on Spherical Trigonometry [pp. 149 - 150]
	1195. The Reduction of the Mass-Accelerations and the Momentum of a Rigid Lamina [pp. 150 - 152]
	1196. A Lewis Carroll Problem [pp. 152 - 153]
	1197. Construction of a Regular Pentagon [p. 153]
	Reviews
	untitled [pp. 154 - 156]
	untitled [pp. 156 - 157]
	untitled [pp. 158 - 159]
	untitled [pp. 159 - 160]
	untitled [pp. 160 - 161]
	untitled[p. 161]
	untitled [pp. 161 - 163]
	untitled [p. 163]
	untitled [pp. 163 - 164]
	untitled [pp. 164 - 165]
	untitled [p. 165]
	untitled [p. 166]
	untitled [p. 166]
	untitled [pp. 166 - 167]
	untitled [pp. 167 - 168]
	untitled [p. 168]

Mais conteúdos dessa disciplina