Prévia do material em texto
Water Reporting Good practice guide, 2nd Edition Acknowledgements The development of this publication would not have been possible without the input and support of the individuals below. ICMM gratefully acknowledges the following contributions: Consultant The publication was developed by Amy Herod with input and support from the individuals and organisations below. ICMM team Dawn Brock led the process to develop this guide, with input and support from Alice Evans, Hayley Zipp and Aidan Davy. Alice and Will Beaven (Positive 2) and Nic Benton (ICMM) provided creative design support. Special thank you The ICMM Water Working Group were key contributors to this document. The group provided direction, input and expert review to the guide. Working group members included: Elena Bezina (Polyus) Tony Da Cruz and Cecil Mutambanengwe (Anglo Gold Ashanti) Troy Jones (Teck) Sarah Williams (BHP) Chris McCombe (Minerals Council of Australia) Patty Simpson and Elsa Doucet (Orano) Amy Allen (Barrick) Brant Whiting (Freeport-McMoRan) Katrina Burke (South32) Scott Diggles (Rio Tinto) Briana Gunn (Newmont) Nicole King (Alcoa) Simone Liefferink and Andre Launbshers (Sibanye Stillwater) Nosimo Macatsha (Goldfields) Walter Aguilar and Mario Velasco (Minera San Cristobal) Blair Sands (Newcrest) Henrietta Salter (Anglo American) Rene Braeunig and Linda Wrong (Glencore) Patrick Brading (Norsk Hydro) David Machin (MMG) João Vieire Dias (Vale) Pule Soaisa (African Rainbow Minerals) Stephen Foot (Antofagasta Minerals) Alberto Ugarteche (Minsur) We also acknowledge the contributions of the many colleagues that some working group members in turn consulted with inside their own companies. List of Acronyms ANZECC Australian and New Zealand Environment and Conservation Council ARMCANZ Agriculture and Resource Management Council of Australia and New Zealand CHPP Coal handling and processing plant ICMM International Council on Mining and Metals GRI Global Reporting Initiative JV Joint venture MAR Managed aquifer recharge MCA Minerals Council of Australia OMW Other managed water SBTN Science Based Targets Network TDS Total dissolved solids TSF Tailings storage facility UNEP United Nations Environment Program WAF Water Accounting Framework WASH Water, sanitation, and hygiene WRI World Resources Institute WTP Water treatment plant WWF World Wildlife Fund Contents Foreword 5 How to use this guidance 6 Guide structure 6 Navigation icons 7 Limitations 7 What has changed in this edition of the guidance? 7 01 ICMM Water Reporting Commitments 8 1.1 Why is corporate water reporting important for the mining and metals industry? 8 1.2 ICMM water reporting commitments 9 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 13 2.1 Overview 13 2.2 Summarising site details and context 13 2.3 Understanding and setting site boundaries 16 2.4 Site water accounting and ICMM reporting metrics 21 2.5 Assessing water risks, opportunities and management response 50 03 Guidance: External Water Reporting 60 3.1 Overview 60 3.2 Understanding the mining and metals context: reporting limitations and exclusions 60 3.3 Setting and reviewing boundaries for external reporting 61 3.4 Meeting the minimum reporting commitments 63 3.5 Going beyond the minimum 66 Glossary 66 References 72 3Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Contents List of Tables Table 1 – ICMM minimum reporting commitments 10 Table 2 – Simple illustrative approach for summarising site context (guidance only) 15 Table 3 – Summary of ICMM water reporting metrics 24 Table 4 – Metrics required to meet the ICMM minimum reporting requirements 25 Table 5 – Example of additional granular site metrics 26 Table 6 – Summary of ICMM water quality categories 36 Table 7 – Simple illustrative approach for assessing site water risk, opportunity and management response (guidance only) 55 Appendices 71 Appendix A – Mapping ICMM water reporting metrics with external reporting platforms 74 Appendix B – Mapping between ICMM metrics and MCA Water Accounting Framework (WAF) 81 Appendix C – Operational example of site water accounting and assesment 85 Appendix D – Guidance for aggregating site metrics for external reporting 98 Appendix E – Example of compiling corporate information for external reporting 101 List of Figures Figure 1 – Site water accounting boundaries and reporting metrics 19 Figure 2 – Operational example: A TSF water balance 30 Figure 3 – Guidance for classifying water quality (from WAF)9 34 Figure 4 – Guidance for classifying water type 39 Figure 5 – Operational examples: Classifying water 40 Figure 6 – Guidance for classifying precipitation and run-off for sediment dams and sumps 42 Figure 7 – Operational example: Accounting and reporting mine site precipitation and run-off 44 Figure 8 – Guidance for setting reporting boundaries 62 4Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Contents Foreword Corporate transparency around water has never been so important. We live and operate in a world of increasing pressure on water resources, growing societal concerns around water access, and rising expectations around the stewardship of this vital resource. Water challenges are increasingly prevalent in many operating environments and in many forms. These are further exacerbated by the impact of climate change, which brings more frequent and extreme wet and dry weather shocks that disrupt local water dynamics. The circumstances these factors give rise to will require an unprecedented level of system transformation to mitigate, adapt and build resilience. For companies, transparency of their water dependencies and performance (in terms of risks, opportunities and management response) is foundational for effectively engaging stakeholders and enabling informed decision making. The mining and metals industry is highly dependent on water for its operations. As an industry we have a leading role to play in contributing practical solutions to water resource challenges. Members of the International Council on Mining and Metals (ICMM) have made firm commitments to water stewardship, including implementing robust water governance within their businesses, transparency and disclosure around water use, managing water more effectively at a site level and working with others to resolve shared challenges at the catchment-scale. ICMM’s Water Stewardship: Position Statement, published in 2017, requires members to apply strong and transparent corporate water governance, including to publicly report company water performance, material risks, opportunities and management response using consistent industry metrics and recognised approaches. Alongside this commitment, ICMM published A Practical Guide to Consistent Water Reporting which sets out minimum reporting commitments and provides supporting guidance around how to deliver on these. ICMM has actively supported the efforts of members to progress implementation, build capacity, promote pre-competitive peer learning, and improve the consistency and quality of external water reporting. During this same period, external water reporting requirements have also evolved. For example, the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) launched its revised Standard 303: Water and Effluents in 2018 with an increase in water reporting requirements, to which all members are required to report as a condition of ICMM membership. In addition, substantial work has been undertaken by the owners of various reporting initiatives to enhance alignment between key reporting platforms and harmonise reporting metrics. This updated version of the guidance supports the industry’s continuing evolution. Its purpose endures: to support the sector in compiling simple and relevant informationin place dry density, moisture content] Case study flow (ML/a): 240 Calculation: Based on 10% w/w moisture content and 1.8 t/ m3 particle density Reconciling timeframes — The primary objective of a water balance is the management and optimisation of operational performance and risk – reconciled over an appropriate timeframe. However, for the purpose of reporting, material water flows are quantified for the reporting period which is typically one year. — Internal flows within the TSF may not conceptually reconcile with the reporting timeframe (eg water which enters the TSF in tailings slurry in one reporting period may seep to groundwater years later). For the purpose of reporting, only the net position for the TSF over the reporting period is recorded. Hence, any material time-lags (eg associated with changing operational practice or characteristics) will be accommodated by year-on-year reporting. TSF Water Balance Component ML/a Inflow Precipitation 285 Run-off 255 Tailings slurry 6,960 Total in 7,500 Outflow Entrainment 240 Evaporation 900 Seepage 1,500 Reclaim 4,860 Total out 7,500 Change in storage (∆S) 0 Figure 2. Operational example: A TSF water balance 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Box 2:11 Tips and tools Brief overview: The water balance approach The concept of the water balance is widely used in hydrological and hydrogeological studies to describe the flow dynamics of a system over a given timeframe. The water balance equation states that all water inputs to the system must equal all water outputs from the system plus any change in internal storage volume, as shown below. Water inputs = Water outputs + (± Change in storage) (Equation 1) Therefore, 0 = Water inputs + Water outputs + (± Change in storage) (Equation 2) In the mining and metals context, water balances may be developed at different scales for different operational management, optimisation and planning purposes. — Site water balances are a fundamental operational water management tool and provide the foundation of effective water management and consistent reporting metrics. — Smaller operational sub-balances may also be developed to better understand or manage particular components of the overall site water balance, eg TSFs, water reticulation in underground workings, processing plants or imported water requirements (see Figure 2 and Box 2:12). — At the broader scale, catchment water balances may be developed to understand water availability and security for a range of scenarios, identify shared water challenges and collective actions opportunities, and set appropriate contextual water targets. For water reporting purposes, site reporting metrics are based on the site water balance and site water account (see Box 2:10). For each reporting period, the overall site (or company aggregated) water balance may be represented by the following equation: ICMM withdrawal (op water + OMW) = ICMM total discharge + ICMM total consumption + (± Change in storage) (Equation 3) Where, if the withdrawal volume exceeds the total discharge and consumption volumes, then the resulting change in storage will be positive and vice versa (see Section 2.4.8). The balance approach provides an important check on the accuracy of site accounting information and may be used to estimate the magnitude of poorly constrained elements. 31Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Surface water withdrawal (imported water input) CHPP demand Net rainfall and evaporation (climatic loss) Water treatment plant WM1 WM2 Dam (new water store) Vehicle washdown demand Potable water demand Box 2:12 Operational examples Using sub-balances to constrain unknowns: Coal handling and processing plant (CHPP) water demand What: Develop a sub-balance of imported water use across a coal mine site to better understand the water supply demand of the CHPP and identify potential optimisation opportunities. Basic approach Step 1: Develop a simple imported water flow circuit which identifies: — The main (imported water) input(s) to the system, including: - Surface water withdrawal (from river). — The main outputs from the system, including: - Potable water demand - Vehicle wash down demand - CHPP demand - Net climatic loss from the water storage dam. — Known material water flow volumes, including: - Surface water withdrawal (water meter WM1) – 2,052 ML/a - Water treatment plant (WTP) demand (data from WTP engineers) – 105 ML/a - Vehicle wash down demand (water meter WM2) – 807 ML/a - Net climatic loss from the water storage dam (based on estimates of catchment rainfall run-off and lake evaporation rates) – 22 ML/a. Step 2: Use the flow circuit and water balance equation to estimate the imported water demand of the CHPP. Water inputs = Water outputs + (± Change in storage volume) Imported water input = Potable water demand + Vehicle washdown demand + CHPP demand + Net climatic loss CHPP demand = Imported water input – (Potable water demand + Vehicle washdown demand + Net climatic loss) = 2,052 - (105 + 807 + 22) = 1,118 ML/a Step 3: Assess and verify the estimate – is this reasonable? Is this consistent with other data/ observations? Does the estimate fit within the wider site water balance? Is the level of uncertainty and resulting risk acceptable? If not, address through further metering, monitoring and analysis. 32Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 2.4.2 Water quality ICMM water quality categories Understanding and actively managing the range of water qualities present across a mining and metals site is fundamental to achieving operational targets, minimising the risk of impact to receiving environments, and realising opportunities to enhance the value of water by promoting circular management. Due to the importance of water quality in the mining context, water should be accounted and reported by water quality using the two categories summarised here and detailed in Table 6: — High quality water typically has high socio- environmental value with multiple potential beneficial uses and/or receptors, including water supply for drinking, agriculture, food production, amenity value, industrial uses and ecosystem function. — Low quality water typically has lower socio- environmental value as the poorer quality may restrict potential suitability for use by a wide range of other users or receptors, excluding potential industrial uses and adapted ecosystem function. However, lower quality water may often be used by the mining and metals industry, where available and appropriate, to help meet the operational water demand and reduce the take of higher quality water. Box 2:13 Point to note Relationship to freshwater and other external reporting platforms The ICMM high and low water quality categories are based on the consideration of a range of physical, chemical and biological water quality parameters. They allow transparency in the mining and metals context for the following reasons: — The majority of the significant volumes of water accessed and managed by mining and metals operations is not of freshwater quality (iethe withdrawal of higher quality water. However, the ICMM water quality categories do not align with external focus on freshwater, which is typically classified on the basis of salinity alone (with a threshold of 1,000 mg/L TDS).11 The ICMM approach is considered to be a more mature and appropriate system for the mining and metals industry. Therefore, to promote consistency and reinforce industry-specific best practice, ICMM members should report water quality using the ICMM categories (of high and low) when reporting to external reporting platforms. A suggested footnote is provided in Appendix A for member companies to include when reporting via external platforms to explain this position. 33Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Assessing water quality using a risk-based approach ICMM water quality categories and classification principles are based on those of MCA’s WAF – which uses a risk-based approach to classify water quality based on consideration of a number of water quality parameters appropriate to the mining and metals context, as illustrated in Figure 3. Mappings between ICMM and WAF water quality categories are provided in Figure 3 and Appendix B. WAF water quality categories 1–3 are also provided in the figures in this guidance to support WAF implementing companies. Following the WAF approach, water quality categories are based on the level of treatment that would be required to raise the quality of the water to drinking water standards (as outlined in Table 6). This provides a consistent and transparent approach for categorising absolute water quality relative to widely recognised standards for drinking water quality (eg relevant national drinking water guidelines or WHO drinking water guidelines)17; rather than attempting to define appropriate threshold values for a broad range of parameters across a wide range of environmental contexts. However, this approach is largely a theoretical measure because in most mining and metals contexts there is no intent to actually treat the water to drinking water quality, nor use the water for drinking water supply. Further, the categorisation approach may not be indicative of the risk of potential impact to receiving environments or ecosystems, which is more appropriately understood by assessing the quality of the discharge relative to the quality of the receiving environment (see Table 6 and Box 2:14). The categorisation of water quality is based on: required field testing of TDS and pH, supported by discretionary laboratory testing, as appropriate to the baseline water quality conditions and/or risk analysis of the operational context and environmental setting. Figure 3: Guidance for classifying water quality (from WAF)9 Or Or Or TDS: > 5,000 mg/L? pH: 10? Constituents in concentrations harmful to human health?1,2 High level of treatment theoretically required to raise the water to drinking water quality WAF category 3 ICMM low quality WAF category 2 WAF category 1 ICMM high quality Notes ¹ Based on discretionary laboratory analysis of parameters identified through risk-based analysis of the operational and water context ² Present in concentrations that exceed the drinking water threshold limits used in the assessment TDS: 1,000 – 5,000 mg/L? pH: 4 – 6 or 8.5 – 10? Coliforms > 100 cfu/100ml? Persistent turbidity: not removed by sedimentation? Or Water characteristics Water characteristics Or All other water Moderate level of treatment theoretically required to raise the water to drinking water quality Low level of treatment theoretically required to raise the water to drinking water quality No No Yes Yes Yes 34Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 The water quality classification approach may be applied to any operational context and/or water. This provides a pragmatic approach which raises awareness and advances industry practices while remaining achievable for sites with lower maturity levels. As with all risk-based approaches, a degree of professional judgement is required. However, key uncertainties which pose a material risk should be addressed through additional analysis and testing. Key points to consider when assessing water quality are outlined below. — Establish the baseline: There is no requirement for all waters to be tested for all parameters. However, it is good practice to establish a comprehensive understanding of the baseline conditions of the key water types present across the site (based on operational and hydrological-hydrogeological models). — Undertake risk-based assessment and monitoring: It is recommended that the suite of parameters used for on-going monitoring and reporting should be determined by risk analysis of the baseline water quality conditions, or as required by local regulatory and permitting conditions. The suite of test parameters should be reviewed regularly or following any material changes (operational or hydrological). — Default classification of water quality: In the absence of any understanding of water quality (neither test results nor risk analysis of the operational context) the following default classifications should be used, which represent the highest risk to water as a shared resource: - Water withdrawals should be classified as ICMM high quality. - Water discharges should be classified as ICMM low quality. 35Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Table 6 – Summary of ICMM water quality categories ICMM Water Quality Categories Characteristics High Quality Low Quality Theoretical level of treatment required to raise to appropriate drinking water quality standards (as WAF9). Low to moderate level of treatment required – eg disinfection, neutralisation, removal of solids or traces of chemicals. High level of treatment required. Parameter thresholds Field testing pH 4–10 TDS 10 TDS > 5,000 mg/L Laboratory analysis As appropriate to the local water context. As appropriate to the local water context. Typical potential value (socio-environmental)1 High with multiple potential beneficial uses and/or receptors – including water supply for drinking, agriculture, food production, amenity value, industrial uses and ecosystem function. Low with reduced suitably for use by a wide range of users/receptors – excluding potential industrial uses and adapted ecosystem function. Examples Water associated with inland water systems with low levels of total dissolved solids (ie salinity), naturally occurring contaminants (eg dissolved metals) and anthropogenic pollution – including lakes, rivers, ponds, wetlands and groundwater. — Industrial effluents, including mine affected water (eg with very low or very high pH levels, or high levels of total dissolved solids or metals). — Naturally occurring brackish, saline (including seawater) and hypersaline waters (ie waters with elevated levels of total dissolved solids). — Waters with elevated levels of naturally occurring contaminants (eg dissolved metals) due to weathering of bedrock. — Waters with elevated levels of anthropogenic pollutants (eg biohazards, nutrients, chemicals, hydrocarbons or turbidity). Typical relationship with regulatory discharge criteria Unlikely to exceed local regulatory discharge criteria or recognised guideline values for freshwater ecosystems (eg UN Environment Programme (UNEP) guidelines18 and references therein). Variable: — Industrial effluents and polluted waters are likely to exceed local regulatory discharge criteria (without treatment). — Treatedeffluents or wastewater may meet local regulatory discharge criteria which recognise elevated levels of total dissolved solids (eg discharges to seawater) or naturally occuring contaminants. — All are likely to exceed recognised guideline values for freshwater ecosystems (eg UNEP guidelines and references therein). Note: 1 See note on the relationship between water quality and potential value in water scarce areas in Box 2:14. 36Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Box 2:14 Point to note The relationship between water quality categories and the risk of potential impact to receiving environments and ecosystems For consistency and transparency, the water quality categorisation approach is based on the theoretical level of treatment required to raise the quality of the water to widely recognised standards for drinking water quality (see Table 6). However, to understand the risk of the potential impact to receiving environments or ecosystems, it is also important to consider the quality of the discharge relative to the quality of the receiving environment. For example, a discharge of low salinity water (high quality) may pose a high risk of negative impact to a brackish or saline wetland (classified as low quality due to naturally high levels of total dissolved solids or salinity) and its adapted ecosystems. Similarly, mining companies may invest substantial efforts to treat discharge water to a quality which is appropriate for the quality of the receiving environment, but is still classified as low quality water (eg discharges to seawater). Therefore, water quality thresholds that are appropriately defined for the baseline quality of the receiving environment should be used when assessing and understanding potential impact risks relating to quality. It is the responsibility of each company to determine the appropriate quality values for impact assessment. This may include locally established thresholds (eg those agreed with local regulators or required for compliance purposes), internally derived limits, or recognised guideline values (eg UNEP guidelines for freshwater and references therein or the Australian and New Zealand Environment and Conservation Council (ANZECC) and Agriculture and Resource Management Council of Australia and New Zealand (ARMCANZ) guidelines for fresh and marine water quality).19 To enhance transparency and alignment with external reporting platforms, the minimum commitments require companies to report any material regulatory non-compliances relating to discharge quality limits, as an indicator of potential impact risk; and provide opportunity for companies to explain their approach to managing risks and realising opportunities associated with water quality (see Table 1). The relationship between water quality and potential value in water scarce areas In areas with high levels of water scarcity, water of relatively low absolute quality may still hold high value to local stakeholders as it is the only water available. For example, rural communities in developing countries that do not have access to municipal drinking water may use untreated low quality surface water or groundwater for drinking and/or agricultural purposes, even if the low quality of the water negatively impacts crop productivity (eg due to salinity issues). 2.4.3 Water withdrawal Two metrics are used to appropriately describe water withdrawal in the mining and metals context, including operational water withdrawal and OMW withdrawal. Detailed descriptions, minimum reporting requirements and rationale, and calculation approaches are provided below. In addition, guidance to aid the classification of water as operational water or OMW is provided in Figure 4, and operational examples are provided in Figure 5. Further guidance for addressing the common challenge areas of classifying precipitation and run-off associated with sediment dams, in-pit sumps and active workings is provided in Figures 6 and 7 respectively. Operational water withdrawal Overview: Operational water withdrawal includes all water that enters the operational water system used to meet the operational water demand. The water is available for use by the site within an operational task or activity. Operational water withdrawal volumes are accounted and reported by source type (surface water, groundwater, seawater and third-party water) and water quality category (high and low quality). Minimum reporting commitment: Reporting of (company) aggregated operational water withdrawal volumes, by source type and water quality category, for all sites within the company, and for all sites situated in water stressed areas. 37Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Reporting rationale: Water withdrawal is of key interest to external stakeholders and often interpreted as a measure of a company’s site’s (or company’s) water dependency and potential for impact. Therefore, withdrawal metrics are widely used for benchmarking purposes. As illustrated in Figure 4, any water which enters the operational water system used to supply the operational water demand will be classified as an operational water withdrawal. As this water is theoretically available for use, and in many contexts is used to offset the need for additional active withdrawals (ie imported water, make- up water or new water). It is important to note that in some mining contexts, operational water withdrawal volumes may substantially exceed the actual volume of water required for, or used by, the site (eg for processing, dust control, product transportation, cooling). Further, the magnitude of this difference will likely reflect the extent to which climatic factors (particularly precipitation and run-off) influence the site water balance. Therefore, if material differences are present, it is proposed that the actual operational water use volume may be calculated and reported as a separate metric (see Section 2.4.7). Calculation approach: As illustrated in Appendix C, identify and sum all inflows to the operational water system boundary – these may include, but are not limited to: — Water that is actively drawn from surface water bodies (eg lakes and rivers), groundwater (eg borefields or wellfields), seawater and third parties. — Precipitation, run-off and groundwater inputs which comprise a material contribution to the site water balance (via active or passive means). — Water entrained in ore or raw materials that is recoverable and makes a material contribution to the site water balance. OMW withdrawal Overview: OMW withdrawal includes water that enters the operational boundary and is actively managed without intent to supply the operational water demand (ie is not used by the site within an operational task or activity). Active management includes water that: — Is physically pumped within the landscape, such as: - Pumping and discharge of groundwater to control water levels (dewatering) that is not used to supply the operational water demand. - Evacuation and discharge of stormwater in active workings following a wet weather event. - Withdrawal of water from the environment (eg surface water, groundwater or seawater) or a third party to supply communities and other third parties. — Is actively treated (using methods which require energy and/or physical inputs, such as reverse osmosis, filtration, precipitation and coagulation) by the site prior to release. For example, active treatment of poor quality water that is captured in the landscape or drawn from the environment (eg legacy workings). — Has material consumptive losses such as evaporation (relating to storage or recharge basins), or other losses or entrainment that is material in the contextof the catchment setting. OMW withdrawal volumes are typically accounted by source type (surface water, groundwater, seawater and third-party water) and water quality category (high and low quality). Minimum reporting commitment: Reporting of (company) aggregated OMW withdrawal volumes (from all sources), by water quality category, for all sites within the company and for all sites situated in water stressed areas. Reporting rationale: Reporting of OMW withdrawal provides greater transparency of a site’s (or company’s) holistic water dependencies and activities. Further, reporting of OMW withdrawal as a separate volume to operational water withdrawal allows transparency around water which is intended or available for use (operational water), versus water which is actively managed (OMW). Point to note Box 2:15 Point to note Produced water as a withdrawal source Produced water is a term used by some external reporting platforms to describe water that enters the company’s boundary as a result of extraction (eg in crude oil), processing (eg sugar cane crushing) or use of any raw materials.11 In the mining and metals context, water entrained in ore extracted from the ground that is recoverable and material to the site water balance is classified and accounted as a withdrawal from groundwater (not as produced water). 38Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Operational water All water which enters the operational water system used to supply the operational water demand. Account and report metrics OMW Water which is actively managed by the operation without the intent to supply the operational water demand. Account and report metrics Exclude Not accounted Include in site water risk and opportunity assessment; and reporting narrative if material at the company level. 1. Is the water actively withdrawn or captured to supply the operational water demand (eg for processing, dust suppression, cooling)? For example: - Water which is actively drawn from the environment (eg borefields, pit sumps, rivers, lakes and the ocean) or received from third parties (eg municipal supply or other service providers). - Actively harvested rainwater (eg from hard standing or roofs). 2. Does the water enter directly into an operational task? For example into a processing plant or beneficiation facility, including via entrainment in the ore / input stream. 3. Does the water enter into an active TSF? For example via precipitation, run-o , snowmelt or groundwater seepage? 4. Does the water enter into an operational water store? For example via precipitation, run-o , snowmelt or groundwater seepage? Note: An operational water store is a purpose built structure designed to collect / hold water which receives or supplies operational water. 5. Is the water actively managed without intent to supply the operational water demand? For example: Figure 4: Guidance for classifying water type 6. Is the water otherwise a�ected (flow, quality or timing) by the company’s activities or contact with its assets? For example changes in sediment load, quality or flow dynamics which have a material impact (positive or negative) on the downstream catchment, ecosystems or other catchment stakeholders. No No No No No No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes b) Is the water actively treated by the site prior to release? For example active treatment (by methods requiring energy and/or physical inputs) of poor quality water that is: - Captured in the landscape (eg sediment dams). - Drawn from the environment (eg legacy workings). C) Does the management of the water result in material consumptive losses? For example evaporation (eg relating to storage or recharge basins) entrainment or task loss which is material in the context of the catchment se�ing. a) Is the water physically pumped within the landscape? For example: - Pumping and release of groundwater to control water levels (dewatering). - Evacuation and release of stormwater in active workings following a wet weather event. - Pumping of water from the environment or a third party to supply communities and other third parties. This enables effective benchmarking, especially in mining contexts where OMW volumes may substantially exceed operational water withdrawal volumes due to operating dynamics and/or climatic factors. Calculation approach: As illustrated in Appendix C, identify and sum all inflows to the operational boundary that are actively managed (eg physically pumped, actively treated or have material consumptive losses). 39Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 1) Desalinated seawater for supply (operation and community) Operational context: Withdrawal and desalination of seawater by the company to provide a reliable supply of freshwater for its operations and a local community. Withdrawal classification: • Operational water withdrawal (seawater): The volume of seawater withdrawn for desalination for operational supply, as used to meet the operational demand. • Other managed water withdrawal (seawater): The volume of seawater withdrawn for desalination for community supply, as actively managed (pumped and treated). 2) Ex-pit dewatering for supply and discharge Operational context: Pumping of water from ex-pit bores to control groundwater levels in the pit – 70% is directly recharged to groundwater downgradient and 30% is transferred for use within the processing plant. Withdrawal classification: • Operational water withdrawal (groundwater): The volume withdrawn and pumped to the processing plant for supply, as used to meet the operational demand. • Other managed water withdrawal (groundwater): The volume withdrawn and directly recharged, as actively managed (pumped). 3) Treatment and discharge of water from closed workings Operational context: Dewatering of low quality groundwater from closed workings to control groundwater levels in an adjacent active operation. The dewatered e�luent is treated and directly discharged to a creek. Withdrawal classification: • Other managed water withdrawal (groundwater): As actively managed (pumped and treated), but not to meet the operational demand. 4) TSF seepage collection, treatment and discharge Operational context: Collection and treatment of seepage from a TSF toe drain prior to discharge to a creek. Discharge classification: • Total discharge (to surface water), as released to the environment. • Note: For sites going beyond the minimum requirements and breaking down discharge volumes as operational water and other manage water – this would be classified as operational water discharge, as the water leaves an operational task (the TSF) within the operational water system. Figure 5 – Operational examples: Classifying water 40Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 42Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 0301 1) Sediment dams An artificial dam structure used to passively reduce the sediment load of runo from active mining areas (including disturbed ground and waste dumps) prior to discharge Abstraction for supply (eg dust suppression) Discharge to stream PrecipitationEvaporation Return of worked water (eg from TSF) Universal water flow Context dependent water flow Run-o from disturbed ground 1) Does the sediment dam receive worked water? ie water that has been used in an operational task (eg for dust control, mineral processing or decant from a TSF). 2) Is the water in the sediment dam used for supply? ie for use in an operational task (eg for dust control or mineral processing). 3) Is the water physically pumped and/or actively treated by the site? ie treated with methods that requireenergy and/or physical inputs. OMW The water is actively managed. All material water flows associated with the sediment dam are accounted as other managed water. Not accounted The water is not considered to be actively managed. Include any risks or opportunities in the site assessment, and reporting narrative (if material at the company level). 4) Does the management of the water result in material consumptive losses? eg due to evaporation. No No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Operational context Water classification Operational water The sediment dam is functioning as an operational (mixed) water store and is part of the operational water system. All material water flows associated with the sediment dam are accounted as operational water. 2) In-pit sumps An excavation in the lowest part of the landscape used to passively drain or capture surface water and/or groundwater Universal water flow Context dependent water flow 1) Does the sump receive worked water? ie water that has been used in an operational task (eg for dust control or in-pit drilling). 2) Is the water in the sump used for supply? ie for use in an operational task (eg for dust control or in-pit drilling). 3) Is the water physically pumped and/or actively treated by the site? ie removed from the pit by pumping (eg for stormwater control). OMW The water is actively managed. All material water flows associated with the sump are accounted as other managed water. Not accounted The water is not considered to be actively managed. Include any risks or opportunities in the site assessment, and reporting narrative (if material at the company level). Note: Examples are provided for illustrative purposes only. In some operating contexts, run-o� from mining disturbed ground may not be discharged to the environment. 4) Does the management of the water result in material consumptive losses? (eg due to evaporation). No No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Operational context Water classification Operational water The sump is functioning as an operational (mixed) water store and is part of the operational water system. All material water flows associated with the sump are accounted as operational water. Precipitation Evaporation Return of worked water (eg from in-pit drilling) Discharge to stream Run-o� from disturbed ground Abstraction for supply (eg in processing plant) Figure 6: Guidance for classifying precipitation and run-off for sediment dams and sumps 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 43Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 0301 Open pit TSF Waste dump Borefield Reservoir Processing plant Decant pond Sediment dam Sump Run-o� direction Sub-catchment boundary Undisturbed / rehabilitated ground Disturbed ground Annual preciptitation = 570mm/astre am Di�use run-o� Di�use run-o� Di�use run-o� Mining lease boundary N 1 2 4 3 Consistent accounting and reporting of precipitation and run-off Step 1: Identify water catchment areas and potential precipitation and run-off collection points. Collection points: 1) TSF 3) Sediment dam 2) In-pit sump 4) Process water reservoir Step 2: Classify the precipitation run-off associated with each collection point and account/report the volumes as appropriate – as illustrated below. Basic estimation approaches provided for guidance where limited data are available. 1) TSF catchment What: Precipitation and run-off to the TSF. Classification: Operational water – as enters an operational task (the TSF). Account: The following contributions Direct precipitation to active TSF (1,140 ML/a = 570 mm/a x 200 ha x 0.01) Run-off from disturbed ground (124 ML/a = 570 mm/a x 145 ha x 0.15 x 0.01) Run-off from undisturbed ground (84 ML/a = 570 mm/a x 295 ha x 0.05 x 0.01) Report: 1,348 ML/a as operational water withdrawal from surface water (high water quality). 2) In-pit sump catchment What: Precipitation run-off to the in-pit sump. Operational context: Water in the sump is used for dust control in the pit. Classification: Operational water – as the water will be used in an operational task/activity (dust control). Account: The following contributions Direct precipitation to the pit – not material Run-off from disturbed ground (154 ML/a = 570 mm/a x 180 ha x 0.15 x 0.01) Report: 154 ML/a as operational water (high water quality). Note: The approach to accounting and reporting water associated with in-pit sumps depends on the operational context of the sump – see Figure 6 for additional guidance Diffuse run-off to the environment What: Run-off which does not enter an on-site collection point. Classification: Affected water if the run-off has a material affect on the receiving environment, ecosystems or other catchment stakeholders. Account: Not accounted. Report: Include in site water risk and opportunity assessment if material at the site level; and include in external reporting narrative if material at the company level. 3) Sediment dam What: Precipitation run-off to the sediment dam used to manage the sediment load of water that discharges to the stream. Operational context: The sediment dam neither receives or supplies water used in operational tasks or activities. No active treatment is undertaken prior to discharge. Evaporative losses associated with the sediment dam are not considered to be material (in the context of the catchment setting). Classification: Not classified. Account: Not accounted. Report: Include in site water risk and opportunity assessment; and company reporting narrative if material (at the company level). Note: The approach to managing, accounting and reporting water associated with sediment dams depends on the operational context of the dam – see Figure 6 for additional guidance 4) Reservoir catchment What: Direct precipitation to the reservoir used to supply the processing plant. Classification: Operational water – as enters an operational water store (the reservoir). Account: Direct precipitation to the reservoir (46 ML/a = 570 mm/a x 8 ha x 0.01) Report: 46 ML/a as operational water withdrawal from surface water (high quality). Basic estimation approaches: Direct precipitation (ML/a) = precipitation (mm/a) x area (ha) x 0.01 Run-off (ML/a) = precipitation (mm/a) x area (ha) x run-off coefficient x 0.01 Figure 7: Operational example: Accounting and reporting mine site precipitation and run-off 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 2.4.4 Water discharge Overview: Total water discharge includes water that is released to the water environment (surface water, groundwater or seawater) or to a third party, including operational water and OMW. Total water discharge volumes are accounted and reported by destination type (surface water, groundwater, seawater and supply to third party) and water quality category (high and low quality). Minimum reporting commitment: Reporting of (company) aggregated total discharge volumes, by destination type and water quality category, for all sites within the company, and for all sites situated in water stressed areas. Reporting rationale: Reporting total water discharge, particularly by water quality category, is of key interest to external stakeholders and often interpreted as an indicator of the potential for impact on the receiving catchment, ecosystems and catchment stakeholders. As outlined in Section 2.4.2, ICMM water quality categories provide a measure of absolute water quality based on the theoretical level of treatment required to raise the quality of the water to widely recognised standards for drinking water quality. Therefore, to understand the risk of potential impact to receiving environments or ecosystems, it is also important to consider the quality of the discharge relative to the quality of the receiving environment (see Box 2:14). Calculationapproach: As illustrated in Appendix C, identify and sum all outflows from the operational boundary to the environment or a third party. These may include, but are not limited to water that is: — Actively or passively released to surface water bodies (eg rivers, lakes and seawater). — Actively pumped to groundwater (eg MAR systems) or passively released to groundwater (eg via seepage which is material to operational or catchment water dynamics). — Transferred to third parties (including other sites which are operated by the company but sit outside the site operational boundary). Depending on the context, effluent from amenities facilities and water treatment plants may be accounted as a consumptive loss rather than discharge. For example, where the effluent from a wastewater treatment plant is evaporated on sprayfield. 2.4.5 Water consumption Overview: Total water consumption includes water that is removed by evaporation, entrainment (in product or waste) or other losses, and not released back to surface water, groundwater, seawater or a third party. Total water consumption includes consumptive losses associated with operational water and OMW. At the minimum level, water consumption is accounted and reported as total volumes only. However, companies may choose to account and report water consumption by its constituent types (evaporation, entrainment and other losses) and/or by water quality. Minimum reporting commitment: Reporting of (company) aggregated total consumption volumes (ie total of all evaporative, entrainment and other losses associated with operational water and OMW), for all sites within the company, and for all sites situated in water stressed areas. Reporting rationale: Total water consumption is of key interest to external stakeholders as it describes the total volume of water removed due to the site’s activities and no longer available to the local catchment or other water users. Water consumption metrics are often interpreted as a measure of a site’s (or company’s) potential for impact and are widely used for benchmarking purposes. Understanding water consumption is also central to developing efficient water systems, as reducing consumptive losses helps to reduce water withdrawals (make-up water), improve efficiencies and enhance the value of the water withdrawn (intensity), which is especially important in water stressed areas with increased competition for water access. In addition, water consumption values may be used for calculating embedded water and developing Life Cycle Assessments or water footprinting.20 Calculation approach: Total water consumption volumes may be calculated using the two approaches outlined below. — Calculated as the sum of component losses: Water removed by evaporation, entrainment (in product and waste) and other losses, as Equation 4. — Derived by balance: If the other components of the site water balance are known, as Equation 5. 44Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Box 2:16 Tips and tools Calculating water consumption Points to consider when calculating consumption as the sum of its constituent parts (evaporation, entrainment and other losses) are outlined below. Use the water balance to identify key operational activities where water is consumed (by evaporation, entrainment and other losses). As necessary, use sub-balances for key operational activities or components to help constrain unknowns (see Box 2:12). Evaporation is an important component of all mining water balances Key operational activities: TSFs, uncovered water storage facilities (eg dams), dust control (eg haul road watering), cooling and drying activities. Basic approaches Evaporation associated with dust control (on haul roads and open surfaces): — Flow meters: Use flow meters on filling points to estimate truck fill and watering volumes. Fill point flow meters are often mechanical and must be regularly calibrated to maintain and check accuracy. Note: Some fill points have pumping circuits that run continuously (and return water back to the tank when not filling a truck), which provide an over- estimate of fill volumes. In this situation, truck counting (see below) should be used to constrain flow meter data. — Truck counting: Count the number of trucks filled to estimate watering volumes; and/or use GPS truck movements (where available) to constrain truck fill counts. Note: Fill count records can be corelated with rainfall records to identify simple relationships that can be used for forecasting dust control demands under different rainfall conditions. Evaporation rates from open water (stores and TSFs): — Pan evaporation rates: Estimate using available pan evaporation rates and a suitable conversion factor (as illustrated in Figure 2). — By water balance: Estimate a typical site evaporation rate using a sub-balance for a water store with known storage volumes. Step 1: Identify one or more dry periods (ie when precipitation inputs are minimal). Step 2: Allow for any change in volume in the water store, and any other known water inputs or outputs associated with the store eg abstractions for supply, returns from processing facilities or TSFs, and groundwater seepage (if known to be material). Note: For the purpose of estimating evaporation rates, assume seepage to groundwater is minimal if not known. Step 3: Assume all remaining losses are due to evaporation and use to derive a typical evaporation rate (which can be applied across the site). Total consumption = Total evaporation + total entrainment + total other losses (Equation 4) Total consumption = (Operational water withdrawal + OMW withdrawal) - total discharge - (± change in storage) (Equation 5) Where possible, calculating consumption as the sum of the consistent components (as Equation 4) is encouraged as although more onerous, this method matures understanding of the site water dynamics, information gaps, risks and performance optimisation opportunities. As illustrated in Appendix C, this is achieved by identifying and summing all outflows from the operational boundary associated with evaporation, entrainment (in product or and waste) or other losses. Additional guidance for calculating water consumption is provided in Box 2:16. For sites with low discharge volumes and no material OMW flows, the total consumption volume may be similar to the operational water withdrawal volume (and is often called imported water, make-up water or new water). 45Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 2.4.6 Operational water reuse and recycle Overview: Operational water reuse and recycle (reuse/ recycle) is water that has been used in an operational task and is recovered and used again in an operational task, either without treatment (reuse) or with treatment (recycle). Operational water reuse/recycle is accounted and reported by volume (see Box 2:17). Minimum reporting commitment: Reporting of (company) aggregated volumes for all sites within the company, and for all sites situated in water stressed areas. Reporting rationale: Operational water reuse/recycle metrics are central to understanding operational water efficiencies and communicating the substantial efforts undertaken by mining and metals companies to optimise efficiencies, reduce water withdrawals (imported water, make-up water or new water) and enhance the value of the water withdrawn (intensity), especially in water stressed areas. Calculation approach: Following the WAF approach, identify and sum all flows of worked water (both untreated and treated) to operational tasks (see Section 2.4.1).This may include, but is not limited to: — Water directly recovered from other operational tasks, eg decant returns from TSFs which are used in processing plants. Box 2:17 Point to note Key change: reporting reuse/recycle as volumes To promote consistency, the format of the ICMM water reporting metric has been changed in this edition of the guidance. Reporting of reuse/recycle volumes is now required in place of reporting of efficiency percentages (previously calculated relative to operational water use). Box 2:18 Further reference Calculating water reuse/recycle volumes MCA (2021), Water Accounting Framework for the Minerals Industry: User Guide, Version 1.4. Box 2:16 – continued Tips and tools Entrainment (in product and waste) Key operational activities: Mineral processing and concentrating facilities, TSFs. Basic approaches — By water balance: Use sub-balances for key processing and concentrating facilities to help constrain unknowns. — Estimate using material properties: Work with process engineering teams to estimate entrainment volumes based on material tonnages and properties (eg moisture contents, solids voids ratio and in place dry densities). Other losses Key operational activities: Mineral processing and amenities facilities. Basic approach: Use the site water balance (or sub-balances) to estimate other losses, by assuming that it is the volume required to ‘close’ the water balance or sub-balance (where all other components are known). Other losses derived by balance should not normally exceed 5–10 per cent. In such circumstances, additional monitoring is required to improve understanding and data accuracy. — The proportion of worked water flows to tasks from the mixed water store (which contains both new and worked water). — Worked water returned from treatment plants. A worked example of calculating reuse/recycle metrics is provided in Appendix C; and further detailed guidance is provided in the Water Accounting Framework for the Minerals Industry: User Guide (see Box 2:18). 46Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 2.4.7 Operational water use Overview: Operational water use is the volume of water that is used in operational tasks. Minimum reporting commitment: Recommended for transparency (but not required to meet the minimum reporting commitments). Reporting rationale: Operational water use describes the actual volume of water required, or used, to sustain operational activities. This may provide valuable context for understanding the relative magnitude of operational water withdrawal volumes, especially in operating contexts where the operational water withdrawal is: — Substantially lower than the actual operational water demand due to high levels of water reuse/recycle (especially in water stressed areas); or — Substantially greater than the actual operational water demand due to climatic influences (largely relating to high volumes of precipitation and run-off). Calculation approach: Following the WAF approach, identify and sum all flows to operational tasks (aggregated to the highest practical level) (see Section 2.4.1 and Appendix C). This may include, but is not limited to: — Water from water stores (new water stores and mixed water stores). — Water directly recovered from other operational tasks, eg decant returns from TSFs which are used in processing plants. — Water from treatment plants. — Water inflows to the site which directly enter an operational task (eg water entrained in ore which is processed, if recoverable and material). 2.4.8 Change in storage (delta storage or ∆storage) Overview: Change in storage, or delta storage (∆storage), is effectively an accounting term which allows the key metrics of water withdrawal, discharge and consumption to be related in a simple balance equation (Equation 3 – see Section 2.4.1). Delta storage may be positive (reflecting an increase in the volume in storage) or negative (reflecting a decrease in the volume in storage) over the accounting period, depending on the relative magnitude of inputs (withdrawals) and outputs (discharge and consumption) to the system. Many operational facilities have on-site water stores which allow the practical management of operational water flow within the facility. Water stores are commonly in the form of tanks, pipes, dams, reservoirs or mine pits. There are many operational reasons to have water stores on a site, including to: — Balance operational water demands, inflows and outflows. — Collect water that has already been used and recovered within the site for further treatment and/or use by the facility (ie reuse and recycle). — Manage wet and dry weather flows or seasonal climatic variations. — Manage varying operational water demands, eg associated with maintenance shut-downs or permitting restrictions. As the term suggests, the delta storage value only indicates the change in volume over the accounting period and does not describe the total volume of water in storage. The capacity of on-site water stores typically depends on the nature of the operational facility, local climatic conditions and the local water context. As appropriate, sites may also choose to monitor and record total storage volumes. This may act as an internal register of water assets and/or liabilities and be used to inform risk and opportunity management strategies, and build climate resilience. Minimum reporting commitment: Recommended reporting of the (company) aggregated change in storage (delta storage) volume for all sites within the company, and for sites situated in water stressed areas (can be calculated from overall company water balance using Equation 3); but is not required to meet the minimum reporting commitments. Reporting rationale: Reporting of the operational water delta storage volume allows complete transparency of the overall water balance. Calculation approach: Delta storage can be derived by balance where the other components of the site water balance equation are known. At the site level, the value derived mathematically by balance should broadly reconcile with the actual change in the volume of water in storage at the site over the same period and provides a useful check for validating site data. 47Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 2.5 Assessing water risks, opportunities and management response 2.5.1 Capturing complexity in a simple and comparable format Water access and management is a local issue. Water risks, opportunities and appropriate management responses are largely governed by the local operational and water context. Therefore, a broad and complex range of operational risks, opportunities and management responses are likely to be present across a company’s portfolio of mining and metals assets. Developing a comprehensive understanding of site water risks, opportunities and appropriate management responses is a detailed and complex process, which is outside the scope of this guidance. The focus of this section is how to review and compile detailed site level risk and opportunity assessments and management responses in a consistent and comparable format that can be aggregated and analysed to inform accurate and appropriate external reporting, tailored to the minimum reporting commitments. This may be achieved using company specific methods and frameworks, where available. The key points to consider when assessing and compiling site level information for external reporting to the minimum commitments are outlined in the sections below. Box 2:20 Point to note Simple illustrative approach for assessing and compiling water risk,opportunity and management response The simple illustrative approach as outlined in Table 7 and illustrated in Appendix C uses a number of simple disclosure statements to capture key context, risk, opportunity and response information in a simple and consistent format, using categorised responses. It is recognised that describing complex and varied site level information with categorised responses significantly reduces the level of detail collated. However, this simple approach is considered effective, because the categorised responses are based on the synthesis of detailed context, risk, opportunity and response assessment work, using industry standard and/or company specific tools. Importantly, this approach captures and communicates the key elements of operational context, risk, opportunity and response in a consistent, comparable and useable manner. The illustrative approach is provided for guidance only. It may be used or developed as required to suit individual company needs but should not constrain or limit the approach used, nor the reporting statements made. Box 2:19 Operational examples Understanding changes in operational water storage volumes — A dry year with reduced rainfall run-off inflows (lower withdrawal) and high evaporative losses from dams (higher consumption) leads to increased use of water in storage – resulting in a reduction in the volume in storage, and a negative delta storage value. — A wet year with increased rainfall run-off inflows (higher withdrawal) allows increased capture of rainfall run-off for future use – resulting in an increase in storage, and a positive delta storage volume. — Operational shut-downs reduce production rates, water use and consumption which leads to an accumulation of water – resulting in an increase in storage, and a positive delta storage volume. 48Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 2.5.2 Water risks and opportunities The intent is to compile a summary of the key material water risks and opportunities present at the site (see Box 2:21 for definitions). It is important to use standardised company risk frameworks (ie those which define likelihood and consequence thresholds for the company) when assessing site risk and opportunity levels. This ensures the comparability of results between different sites and allows site-level risks and opportunities which are material at the company level to be appropriately identified and included in external reporting (see Section 3.3.1). The key points to consider when compiling site water risk and opportunity information are outlined below. The illustrative approach for summarising site risks and opportunities is outlined in Table 7, and directly aligns with external guidance (CEO Water Mandate’s Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines10 and CDP Water Security 2021 Reporting Guidance12). In addition, an operational example of compiling site water risk and opportunity information for the purpose of external reporting to the minimum commitments is provided in Appendix C. — Regulatory non-compliances relating to discharge qualities associated with the site (if present) – this allows understanding of the site’s approach to managing the quality of water released to the environment, and potential for associated impacts or risks to the catchment, ecosystems or stakeholders. Importantly, high levels of compliance with regulatory conditions are an indicator of the substantial efforts taken by the site to appropriately manage water discharge quality prior to release (eg via monitoring, treatment and other controls). — Baseline water stress of the catchment(s) within which the site is situated –baseline water stress is an indicator of the likelihood of facing water-related risks due to ambient catchment conditions (see Box 2:21). In addition, assessment of baseline water stress and the identification of sites situated in water-stressed areas is required for meeting the minimum reporting commitments (see Table 1). For transparency and comparability, it is also important to note the assessment methods used (eg publicly available tools and/or company specific approaches). — Water risks associated with the site –this allows understanding of the materiality of water risks to the viability, value and performance of the site (ie the extent to which water related challenges pose a risk to operating to plan). Any material negative water- related impacts associated with the site should also be considered in the assessment as these will usually translate into material risks. — Water risk may be considered and classified in a number of ways. Two common approaches are to classify water risk as either physical, reputational and regulatory. CDP has expanded these categories to also include technology and markets, as outlined in Table 7.12 Alternatively, risks may be considered as company risks (ie operational or internal to the site) and basin risks (ie associated with catchment dynamics or external to the site).21 However, both approaches are based on an understanding of the shared water challenges within the catchment and how these may translate to risks to the site (see Box 2:21). — For transparency and comparability, it is also important to note the assessment methods and risk framework used (eg publicly available tools and/or company specific approaches); including any approaches (or scenarios) used to assess potential water risks (and opportunities) associated with climate change22 (see Box 2:22 and Box 2:23). — Water opportunities associated with the site – this allows understanding of the potential for water to have a positive impact on the performance, value or reputation of the site (or company). Any positive water related impacts associated with the site should also be considered in the assessment as these may translate into opportunities. — Water opportunities may be considered in a number of ways. A common approach is to classify opportunities as either operations, brand value or new markets.10 However, for site-level assessments it may be more helpful to classify opportunities as efficiency, resilience, products and services, and markets (and reputation),12 as outlined in Table 7. 49Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Box 2:21 Point to note Water risk and opportunity definitions Water risk: The possibility of an organisation experiencing a water-related challenge (eg water scarcity, water stress, flooding, infrastructure decay, drought). The extent of risk is a function of the likelihood of a specific challenge occurring and the severity of the challenge’s impact. The severity of the impact itself depends on the intensity of the challenge, as well as the vulnerability of the actor.10 Water opportunity: The possibility of water driving positive value or outcomes for the company.10 Assessing and reporting impact The term ‘impact’ is generally used to describe the effect (positive or negative) of a company (or site) on the economy, environment and/or society.11 For simplicity, when reporting to the ICMM minimum reporting commitments, any material impacts (negative and positive) may be considered and reported in the discussion of material risks and opportunities, as appropriate. However, companies may also choose to describe significant impacts more explicitly in the supporting narrative. Identifying water stressed areas Water stress is the term used to describe ‘the ability, or lack thereof, to meet human and ecological demand for fresh water’.10 As illustrated in the figure below, water stress is a broad term which considers a number of physicalaspects, including water availability, quality and accessibility. For example, water stress may be considered to be high if water resources are: physically scarce; not directly suitable for use due to quality constraints; or not available for access due to regulatory restrictions or a lack of infrastructure. Water stress contributes to the overall baseline risk profile of a site or location. Water stress does not include risks relating to flooding. This is important to note, especially when assessing and communicating risks associated with climate. Assessing baseline water stress levels: Water stress should be assessed at the catchment scale (as a minimum). Two publicly available tools that are widely used to gain a high-level overview of baseline water stress. Two commonly used tools are WRI Aqueduct Floods, Water Risk Atlas and WWF Water Risk Filter. However, it is important to note that these tools assess the availability component of water stress only using a variety of methods, but do not consider water quality or accessibility23,24. In addition, due to the scale of the datasets used by these tools, the results should always be verified and complemented by local knowledge developed by operating within the local context. Identifying water stressed areas: The following global risk indicators and thresholds are commonly recognised to identify areas of water stress when using publicly available tools (and verified/moderated using local knowledge): : — Baseline water stress equal to or greater than "high" (40-80 per cent) or classified as “arid and low water use” when assessed using the WRI Aqueduct — Baseline water depletion equal to or greater than "high" (50-75 per cent) when assessed using the WRI Aqueduct — Water depletion equal to or greater than risk score 3 when assessed using the WWF Water Risk Filter — Blue water scarcity equal to or greater than risk score 3 when assessed using the WWF Water Risk Filter — Available water remaining (AWARE) equal to or greater than risk score 3 when using the WWF Water Risk Filter. Note: The approach used to make the assessment should also be noted for clarity and comparability. 50Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment https://www.wri.org/applications/aqueduct/floods/ https://www.wri.org/applications/aqueduct/floods/ https://www.wri.org/applications/aqueduct/water-risk-atlas/ https://waterriskfilter.panda.org/ 02 0301 Box 2:21 – continued Point to note Water scarcity Water stress Governance Water risk for businesses • Physical • Reputational • Regulatory Availability Quality Accessibility Non-water-stress-related factors (eg flooding) Risk due to basin context Example shared water challenges Shared water challenge: A water-related issue, concern or threat shared by the site and one or more stakeholders within the catchment(s). Examples include physical water scarcity, deteriorating water quality and regulatory restrictions on water allocation. Water scarcity: The volumetric abundance, or lack thereof, of freshwater resources. Water stress: The ability, or lack thereof, to meet human and ecological demand for fresh water. Compared to scarcity, ‘water stress’ is a more inclusive and broader concept. Water risk: The possibility of an entity experiencing a water-related challenge (eg water scarcity, water stress, flooding, infrastructure decay, drought). Risk due to company operations, products and services Note: publicly available tools currently only assess the availability component of water stress. 51Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Box 2:21 – continued Point to note Risk assessment approaches typically consider both inherent (or raw) and managed (or residual) risks, ie the likelihood and consequence of a particular negative outcome occurring without (inherent risk) and with specific mitigation controls (managed risk). When summarising site level risk assessments for external reporting, it is important to clearly identify whether the risks are inherent and/or managed to ensure that this information is appropriately considered when compiled at the company level. When reporting risk, companies should clearly state the type of risk being reported (managed or inherent). Companies looking to move beyond minimum reporting may choose to report inherent and managed to demonstrate the effectiveness of their mitigation strategies – especially if reporting more granular facility level data. Box 2:22 Further reference Assessing water risk and opportunity — ICMM (2015), A practical guide to catchment-based water management for the mining and metals industry. p.28. — WBCSD (2018), CEO Guide to Water: Building resilient business. p.8. Overviews and comparisons of available tools — WWF and WBCSD (2020), Right tool for the right job: tools and approaches for companies and investors to assess water risks and shared water challenges. — IPIECA (2014), Review of water risk tools: Guidance document for the oil and gas industry. Understanding climate change, water risk and resilience opportunities — ICMM (2019), Adapting to a Changing Climate: Building resilience in the mining and metals industry. — Global Commission on Adaptation (2019), Adapt now: A global call for leadership on climate resilience. Chapter 4. — German Environment Agency (2020), Impacts of climate change on mining, related environmental risks and raw material supply. — GIZ, PIK and Adelphi (2020), Stop Floating, Start Swimming: Water and climate change – interlinkages and prospects for future action. — Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (2017), Technical Supplement: The Use of Scenario Analysis in Disclosure of Climate- Related Risks and Opportunities. — UNESCO, UN-Water (2020), United Nations World Water Development Report 2020: Water and Climate Change. — WWF (2020), Water Risk Scenarios: TCFD-aligned scenarios to help companies and investors turn risk into resilience. 52Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Box 2:23 Tools and tips Publicly available tools for assessing water risks (*including baseline water stress): — Ceres AquaGauge — Ecolab Water Risk Monetizer — GEMI Local Water Tool — WFN Water Footprint Assessment Tool — WRI Aqueduct Floods — WRI Aqueduct Water Risk Atlas * — WWF Water Risk Filter * Publicly available tools for assessing water opportunity — WWF Water Risk Filter Tools for understanding water risks under different climate scenarios — ICMM Mining Climate Assessment (MiCA) tool (for ICMM members) — WRI Aqueduct Water Risk Atlas — WWF Water Risk Filter 2.5.3 Management response The intent is to compile a summary of the management actions and strategies being undertaken at the site to mitigate material risks and realise opportunities. The key points to consider when compiling management response information are outlined below. The illustrative approach for summarising management response is outlined in Table 7, and directly aligns with external guidance.10,21 In addition, an operational example of summarising management response information for the purpose of external reporting to the minimum commitments is provided in Appendix C. — Management response – this provides insight into the water management and stewardship approaches, strategies and initiatives undertaken at the site. These may be considered in a number of ways, however one approach is to classify and describe activities as internal action, collective action and/or influencing governance (aligned with WWF water stewardship steps).19 Alternatively, the CDP WaterSecurity 2021 Reporting Guidance, which uses more specific categories, may be used (see Table 7).12 For transparency and comparability, it is also important to note the assessments methods used (eg publicly available tools and/or company specific approaches). — Setting water targets – this describes the type and level (ie corporate, site specific or both) of water targets set to measure and manage water performance. A range of different water targeting approaches may be used as appropriate to the company’s broader water strategy and maturity level, and the site’s local water context (see Box 2:24, Box 2:25). 53Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment https://www.ceres.org/resources/tools/ceres-aqua-gauge-comprehensive-assessment-tool-evaluating-corporate-management https://app.waterriskmonetizer.com/ http://gemi.org/localwatertool/ https://waterfootprint.org/en/resources/interactive-tools/ https://www.wri.org/applications/aqueduct/floods/ https://www.wri.org/applications/aqueduct/water-risk-atlas/ https://waterriskfilter.panda.org/ https://waterriskfilter.panda.org/ https://icmm-mica-live.azurewebsites.net/Account/Login?ReturnUrl=%2f https://www.wri.org/applications/aqueduct/water-risk-atlas/ https://waterriskfilter.panda.org/ 02 0301 Box 2:24 Points to note Box 2:25 Further reference Setting water targets Targets are ‘measurable, actionable, and time-bound objectives’ that help to drive the appropriate response or actions required to achieve a desired (or improved) outcome.26 Water is a local issue and target setting is often most effective when water targets are both tailored to the local water context, and aligned with the company’s broader water strategy.27 The use of targets to manage and optimise operational performance and manage risk within the business is well established across the mining and metals industry. However, there is increasing focus on setting water targets which are aligned to the local catchment water context. This approach prompts the site to understand its contribution to shared water challenges; and tailor its response effectively to deliver improved outcomes for all catchment stakeholders. In addition, enterprise water targets may also be set to provide the critical link between bottom up operational context and top down corporate strategy. Key initiatives for developing water targets are outlined below. CEO Water Mandate (and partners): Setting site water targets informed by catchment context28 This outlines three key elements (and associated actions) for setting effective site water targets, including: — Element 1: Water targets should respond to priority water challenges within the catchment. — Element 2: The ambition of water targets should be informed by the site’s contribution to water challenges and desired conditions. — Element 3: Water targets should reduce water risk, capitalise on opportunities and contribute to public sector priorities. WRI (and partners): Setting enterprise water targets29 This outlines a three-step approach to help companies set enterprise water targets, based on: — Step 1: Assess water materiality and prioritise sections of the value chain. — Step 2: Assess water-related risks and prioritise locations. — Step 3: Set and disclose enterprise water targets. Science Based Targets Network (SBTN): Science based targets for nature This is a comprehensive and integrated approach that is being developed to set targets based on the best available science that align with the Earth’s limits and societal sustainability goals. Responding to water risks and setting targets — ICMM (2015), A Practical Guide To Catchment- Based Water Management. Step 3, p.46. — CEO Water Mandate and partners (2019), Setting Site Water Targets Informed By Catchment Context: A Guide For Companies. — WWF and HandM Group (2021), Putting water strategy into context: A practical guide to connect corporate strategic objectives to local water context. — WRI and partners (2021), Setting Enterprise Water Targets: A Guide for Companies. — SBTN (2020), Science-Based Targets for Nature: Initial Guidance for Business. 54Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Table 7 – Simple illustrative approach for assessing site water risk, opportunity and management response (guidance only) Statement Description Example assessment approach Example compilation approach Rationale Water risks and opportunities Catchment water stress level Describes the baseline stress level of the catchment within which the site is situated – where water stress is ‘the ability, or lack thereof, to meet the human and ecological demand for freshwater’. — Based on assessment made using publicly available tools and verified against local knowledge. — Rank as: 1 (very low) to 5 (very high) — Unknown Allows identification and reporting of sites located in water stressed areas. Catchment water stress assessment method Identifies the assessment approach or tool used to determine the baseline water stress level. — Company specific — Publicly available tools — WRI Aqueduct tools — WWF Water Risk Filter Allows transparency around the method(s) used to assess baseline water stress. Regulatory non- compliance level Describes any non-compliances with regulatory limits set for the quality of water discharges associated with the site (during the reporting period). — Based on site regulatory compliance records and company specific risk frameworks. — Rank consequence level as: 1 (very low) to 5 (very high) — None Allows transparency around the potential for associated impacts or risks to receiving environments and ecosystems. Water risk level Describes the water risk level associated with the site – where water risk is the possibility of the site experiencing a water related challenge which may negatively impact business viability, performance or value. — Based on water risk assessments made using: publicly available tools and/or company specific methods (and risk frameworks) — Water risks may be considered over different time horizons (eg as CDP W4.2)12. — Rank risk level as: 1 (very low) to 5 (very high) — Unknown Allows understanding of the materiality of water risks associated with a site to overall business viability and performance. Water risk types Describes the key water risk types associated with the site. — Based on water risk assessment made using: publicly available tools; company specific methods; and/or following CDP W4.2 — Risk types may be split into sub-types to enhance granularity and/or considered over different time horizons (eg as CDP W4.2) 12. — Physical — Reputational — Regulatory and markets — Technology Allows transparency around the type of water risks associated with a site. 55Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Statement Description Example assessment approach Example compilation approach Rationale Water risk assessment method Identifies the approach or tools used to assess site water risks. — Company specific — CDP W4.212 — Publicly available tools - Ecolab Water Risk Monetizer - GEMI Local Water Tool - WFN Water Footprint Assessment Tool - WRI Aqueduct - WWF Water Risk Filter Allows transparency around the method(s) used to assess water risks associated with a site. Climate change scenario analysis Describes how climate change is considered in site water risk and opportunity assessment, and over whaton water including consistent metrics, which provides a solid foundation for consistent water reporting. The guidance also aims to align with GRI, provide clarity on reporting expectations for external stakeholders and promote better understanding of the industry’s operational water context, practices and reporting. While the primary target audience is ICMM member companies, we encourage other mining companies to adopt and implement the approaches and metrics within the guide to support enhanced transparency on water across the mining and metals sector. Rohitesh Dhawan President and CEO, ICMM 5Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Foreword Guide structure This guide is structured in the following sections. Section 1 ICMM water reporting commitments – introduction and overview of the minimum reporting commitments for ICMM members Section 2 Guidance: Internal site level accounting and assessment – outlines the importance of site level information as the fundamental building block of consistent reporting; and provides points to consider when developing and compiling site level metrics and assessments for the purpose of external reporting Section 3 Guidance: External water reporting – outlines points to consider when preparing external reports to meet the minimum reporting commitments Appendix A Mapping ICMM water reporting metrics with external reporting platforms – summarises mappings between ICMM water reporting metrics and key external reporting platforms; and provides suggested explanatory footnotes for ICMM members to use when reporting to other external platforms Appendix B Mapping between ICMM metrics and MCA WAF – summarises the direct alignment between ICMM and WAF metrics Appendix C Operational example of site water accounting and assessment – provides a worked example of site level water accounting and assessment to meet the minimum reporting commitments for a Chilean copper mine site Appendix D Guidance for aggregating site metrics for external reporting – provides guidance around aggregating site metrics for external reporting to avoid double counting Appendix E Example of compiling corporate information for external reporting – provides an example of compiling corporate information to meet the minimum reporting commitments (for a fictitious mining and metals company) How to Use this Guidance 6Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition How to Use this Guidance Navigation icons The following navigation icons are used throughout the document to aid referencing, enhance useability and increase the accessibility of information. Further reference Operational example Point to note Tips and tools Limitations The guidance provided in this document only applies to revenue generating mines and smelting facilities; and is not intended to apply to legacy properties, closed sites, remote construction projects, research facilities, supporting site infrastructure (such as utility or transport corridors), non-operated joint ventures (JVs) or supply chains. To support consistent and accurate water reporting, this document includes guidance on the water accounting of mining facilities (eg processing plants and tailings storage facilities (TSFs)) which are an important component of the site water balance. However, guidance relating to the development of site water balances and the broader management of mining facilities is outside the scope of this guidance. What has changed in this edition of the guidance? The key focus of this revision has been to: — Improve ICMM water reporting metrics definitions to support consistent reporting. — Broaden the minimum reporting commitments by including metrics for: - Holistic reporting of water withdrawal, discharge and consumption for water associated with meeting the operational water demand (operational water) and water that is actively managed (other managed water (OMW), previously termed ‘diversions’). - Reporting of aggregated water metrics for all sites within the company and for all sites situated in water stressed areas. — Enhance the supporting guidance by leveraging the insights and learnings gained during implementation of the first edition. 7Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition How to Use this Guidance Section 1 ICMM Water Reporting Commitments 1.1 Why is corporate water reporting important for the mining and metals industry? Corporate transparency around water is particularly important for the mining and metals industry as it is recognised to have a high level of water interaction and dependency due to the nature of its activities.1,2,3 This situation creates both water risks and opportunities for the company and local catchment, as outlined below. Mining and metals operations are typically geographically fixed, long-life assets. The location of mining assets is largely determined by geology and operators must manage the water risks and shared water challenges that arise due to the local catchment conditions – whether this is water scarcity, flood risk or poor water quality. This trend is likely to increase as demand for minerals grows to support the transition to a low-carbon economy.4 However, the long-life nature of mining and metals assets also creates opportunities to invest in local communities, improve local livelihoods and work collaboratively with local stakeholders to advance sustainable water outcomes, equitable water access and improved water governance within the catchment. All mining and metals facilities need water to sustain operations. Water is commonly required for dust control, mineral processing and concentrating, waste management and power generation. Substantial progress has been made in recent years to enhance operational efficiencies by promoting recovery and reuse to reduce dependency on external water resources. Innovative solutions are being developed to further reduce water requirements in tailings management. In addition, energy efficient treatment technologies are being developed to allow use of low quality water for operational supply. 8Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 01 ICMM Water Reporting Commitments 02 0301 Mining operations may need to manage substantial volumes of water, but this may not necessarily be for use. Most mining operations alter landforms by excavating open pits and underground mines, and constructing waste facilities. The resulting level of interaction with surface water and groundwater depends on the nature of the operation and the local water conditions – both of which vary substantially across different commodities and geographies.5 For example, in some contexts, dewatering of below-water table orebodies is required to enable safe working conditions in open pits and underground workings. In addition, mining and metals operations situated in remote areas may provide the water supply to adjacent townships, communities and other mining operations, creating further social and economic value. In these ways, mining operations often manage substantial volumes of water that are not required to meet the operational water demand. ICMM water reporting metrics provide transparency around these practices to promote informed decision making. The global challenge of deteriorating water quality presents both risk and opportunity for the mining and metals industry. There is an increasing awareness of the challenge of deteriorating water qualities across rich and poor countries.6 This situation relates to rising levels of pollution from a wide range of sources (including communities, agriculture and industry) and a vast range of contaminants (including faecal matter, nutrients, plastics and pharmaceuticals). The potential impact of the mining and metals industry ontime horizons. — Based on the approach used by the site (or company) to understand the potential impacts of climate change over different time horizons and/or for different scenarios. — Climate influences considered in the short-term — Climate influences considered in the medium-term — Climate influences considered in the long-term — Not considered Allows transparency around how risks and opportunities associated with climate change are considered. Water opportunity level Describes the water opportunity level associated with the site – where water opportunity is the possibility of water having a positive impact on business viability, performance or value. — Based on water opportunity assessment made using: company specific methods; and/ or following CDP W4.3 — Water opportunities may be considered over different time horizons (eg as CDP W4.3).12 — Rank opportunity level as: 1 (none) to 5 (very high) — Unknown Allows understanding of the potential for water to have a positive impact on business performance and value. Water opportunity types Describes the water opportunity types associated with the site. — Based on assessment made using: publicly available tools; company specific methods; and/or following CDP W4.3 — Opportunity types may be further split into sub-types to enhance granularity and/or considered over different time horizons (eg as CDP W4.3).12 — Efficiency — Resilience — Products and services — Markets (and reputation) — Other Allows transparency around the type of water opportunities associated with a site. Opportunity assessment method Identifies the approach or tool used to assess site water opportunities. — Company specific — CDP W4.312. — WWF Water Risk Filter Allows transparency around the method(s) used to assess water opportunities associated with a site. 56Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Statement Description Example assessment approach Example compilation approach Rationale Management Response Management response level Describes the management response level associated with the site. — Based on review and appraisal of site water management practices. — Detailed guidance is provided in ICMM’s A Practical Guide to Catchment-Based Water Management for the Mining and Metals Industry. — Rank response level as: 1 (very low) to 5 (very high) Allows transparency around water management and stewardship approaches taken to manage risk and realise opportunity at the site. Management response type Identifies the management response types taken by the site. — Based on review and appraisal of site water management practices following WWF Water Stewardship Steps and/or CDP W4.2 management strategies (primary response categories).12 — Internal actions — Collective action (external) — Influence governance Target type Identifies the type of water targets set by the site. — Based on review of site water management practices or following CDP W8.1a targets and goals.12 — Water withdrawals — Water consumption — Water discharge — Water quality — Water use — Water reuse/ recycling — WASH — Ecosystem health — Community engagement — Other — None Allows transparency around the company’s approach to water management and target setting at the site. Target level Identifies the level at which water targets are set. — Corporate — Site specific — Corporate and site (aligned) 57Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment Section 3 Guidance: External Water Reporting 3.1 Overview This section provides points to consider when preparing external reports to meet the minimum reporting commitments outlined in Table 1. Consistent and accurate external reporting builds on the comprehensive water accounting and assessment work undertaken at the site level (see Section 2). Collectively, the aggregation and analysis of these fundamental building blocks allows clear understanding of a company’s water interactions, risks, opportunities and management response. The minimum reporting commitments provide a structured approach to communicating this information to external stakeholders. This approach comprises two key components – the ICMM water reporting metrics and the accompanying narrative. Both elements are critically important for the mining and metals industry due to the nature of its activities and water dependencies (see Section 1.1). Importantly, the narrative provides the fundamental context required to understand the significance and meaning of the reporting metrics, and enables appropriate benchmarking by external stakeholders. The guidance in this section focuses on: — Understanding the mining and metals context – including an overview of reporting limitations and exclusions (see Section 3.2). — Setting and reviewing boundaries for external reporting – including what to report and aggregating site reporting metrics to avoid double counting (see Section 3.3). — Meeting the minimum reporting commitments – including an overview of key requirements (see Section 3.4). — Going beyond the minimum – including opportunities to move along the reporting maturity curve (see Section 3.5). 3.2 Understanding the mining and metals context: reporting limitations and exclusions 3.2.1 Benchmarking water reporting metrics Due to the nature of the industry’s activities, the ICMM water reporting metrics are heavily dependent on operational context. This may have a stronger influence on these values than site water management practices. This situation arises as water dependencies and requirements vary significantly with commodity type (eg coal versus gold), beneficiation type (eg flotation versus heap leach), beneficiation level (eg copper concentrate versus copper cathode), mining method (eg underground versus open pit), orebody position in the landscape and climatic setting. For example, the need to dewater largely depends on the proportion of ore below the water table; while the need to manage significant surface water flows typically depends on the position of an orebody in the landscape and/or annual precipitation. In addition, the ability to enhance site water efficiency largely depends on ore beneficiation methods, which are often determined by commodity type and ore grade. Similarly, it is not possible to use low quality water to meet the operational water demand, and reduce withdrawal of high quality water, if no lower quality water is locally available. Companies within the industry operate across a broad range of contexts and geographies and large diversified mining and metals companies may operate across a broad range of contexts even within their own portfolio. It is therefore essential to consider operational context when using mining and metals metrics for benchmarking purposes. 3.2.2 The challenges of reporting water intensity metrics Water intensity metrics express a given volume of water (eg volume of water withdrawn or consumed) normalised to some output scaling factor (eg tonne of ore processed, product produced or dollar earnings 59Water Reporting: Good practice guide 03 Guidance: External Water Reporting 59Water Reporting: Good practice guide, 2nd Edition 02 0301 before interest and taxes). They are widely requested by external stakeholders for benchmarking purposes. However, ICMM do not require, nor recommend, external reporting of a consistent water intensity metric at the minimum level. This is due to the challenges associatedwith defining a consistent metric, which is meaningful and benchmarkable at the company level in the mining context, as outlined below: — Company aggregated intensity metrics are not meaningful given the broad range of operating contexts present across the industry. To promote achievability while driving consistency, the minimum reporting commitments are focused on reporting of company aggregated metrics. However, water intensity metrics are strongly influenced by operating context; and mining and metals companies typically operate across a broad range of operating contexts – including variable commodities, mining methods, beneficiation methods, beneficiation levels and catchment settings. Therefore, intensity metrics aggregated to the company level hold no direct meaning. — Mining bespoke metrics used for internal performance optimisation have little meaning to external stakeholders. Water intensity metrics are widely used across the industry for internal site level performance management and optimisation purposes. Different units are typically used depending on the site context and management objectives. Commonly used units include the volume of water withdrawn or consumed per tonne of ore mined or processed. However, the metrics used are not consistent, which makes aggregation at the company level challenging; also the metrics hold little meaning for external stakeholders nor support inter-sector benchmarking. — Financial-based metrics are highly dependent on volatile commodity prices. Although they are often preferred by the investor community for inter-sector benchmarking and are aggregable at the company level, the effectiveness of financial-based metrics for benchmarking mining industry water performance is substantially reduced by the volatility in commodity prices. Further, accessing the financial data required to develop these metrics is challenging due to the complex ownership models and frequent divestments inherent in mining company portfolios. — Numerous different product-based metrics are required for a diverse mining and metals company. Product-based metrics must be defined for each different commodity type and beneficiation level to support the meaningful benchmarking of water performance. Therefore, a wide range of different metrics would be required for diversified commodity companies, which is not practical, meaningful or comparable at the company level. Further, options to limit reporting to the top five products by revenue is unlikely to be representative of the company as a whole, nor meaningful for overall performance benchmarking. While reporting of intensity is not required for meeting the minimum reporting commitment, companies may choose to report self-defined metrics, appropriate to their operational portfolio, to help communicate their year-on-year water performance. However, these metrics will not generally be appropriate for broader external benchmarking activities. 3.3 Setting and reviewing boundaries for external reporting 3.3.1 Corporate reporting boundaries The first step when preparing information for external reporting is to define appropriate reporting boundaries which determine what information should be included. During this process it is important to review the boundaries set when compiling the underlying site level accounting and risk, opportunity and response assessments (see Section 2.3) to ensure alignment. Key points to consider when setting corporate boundaries for reporting to the minimum reporting commitments are outlined below: — Spatial boundaries: The minimum reporting commitments and supporting guidance apply to revenue generating mines and smelting facilities/ extractive metallurgy. They are not intended to apply to legacy properties, closed sites, remote construction projects, research facilities, supporting site infrastructure (such as utility or transport corridors), non-operated joint ventures (JVs) or supply chains. 60Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 03 Guidance: External Water Reporting 02 0301 Figure 8 provides further guidance for setting appropriate spatial boundaries and deciding what to include. In addition, guidance around setting external reporting boundaries for JV sites is provided in Box 3:1. — Materiality boundaries: These define what to include based on significance and will depend on the operational portfolio and profile of the company. GRI11,30 defines material topics as those which: - Reflect the company’s significant economic, environmental and social impacts; or - Substantively influence the assessments and decisions of stakeholders. When selecting material information for external reporting it is also important to review the materiality boundaries used for the site-level assessments (see Section 2.3.2). This is to ensure that the information included in external reports is material at the corporate level – as what may be material at the site level, may not be material at corporate level. However, the use of company standard risk and assessment frameworks throughout the process, from site-level assessments (see Section 2.5) to corporate reporting, promotes alignment and aids this screening process. 61Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 03 Guidance: External Water Reporting 02 0301 Is the facility operational? Is it a remote construction project? Is it disconnected from an active operation for the purposes of water provision (eg HQ o�ce)? It is a closed or legacy site? Is it a revenue generating mining, smelting, processing or handling facility? Is it supporting infrastructure? Is it material to the company’s water balance or business value? Is it a power generation or water treatment facility? It is a mining camp, o�ce building or research facility? It is a utility or transport corridor? Is it a township? Include Exclude Include Include Exclude Exclude Yes Yes Yes No No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes No No No Yes No NoNo Yes Yes Yes No Notes: ¹ It is the responsibility of each company to include or exclude assets based on the ownership model, management responsibility and overall materiality to business value. ² To aid consistency, this flowchart provides guidance around the minimum level of reporting; and may be applied at a scale (site to corporate) appropriate to the reporting company. Figure 8: Guidance for se�ing reporting boundaries 62Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 03 Guidance: External Water Reporting 02 0301 — Temporal boundaries: Corporate water reporting is typically undertaken on an annual cycle. To achieve consistency, the minimum reporting commitments require a description of the current state for the reporting period (ie one year). However, reporting metrics and risks for the current reporting year may be compared with those from previous periods to illustrate temporal trends. In addition, companies may choose to include an element of forward projection into the risk and opportunity assessment (see Sections 2.3.3 and 2.5.2). 3.3.2 Site accounting boundaries and metrics aggregation The ICMM water reporting metrics required to meet the minimum reporting commitments are volumetric and can be aggregated by simple addition. However, it is important to review water boundaries when aggregating site water metrics for external reporting to avoid double accounting – particularly where water transfers are present between different individual sites. For example, where there are material water transfers between: — Individual mining sites that are geographically clustered within an operational complex; — Individual sites that are connected across the mine-to-market value chain (ie between a mine and a remote smelter site); and/or — Individual sites connectedby water treatment and supply networks. Additional guidance around aggregating reporting metrics for sites with complex accounting boundaries is provided in Appendix D. 3.4 Meeting the minimum reporting commitments 3.4.1 ICMM water reporting metrics The ICMM water reporting metrics required to meet the minimum reporting commitments are summarised in Tables 1, 3 and 4, and detailed supporting guidance is provided in Section 2.4. To support external benchmarking, ICMM members should use the template provided in Table 4 to report the metrics required to meet the minimum reporting commitments. The table should be made publicly available (eg accessible on the company website or included in corporate sustainability or water reports) and may be built on to develop infographics, graphs or tables to support the accompanying narrative. In addition, companies may also choose to report a broader suite of water metrics for greater transparency (see Table 5) and are encouraged to do so as they look to move beyond reporting at the minimum level (see Section 3.5). Box 3: 2 Further reference Guidance around setting external reporting boundaries for water — CEO Water Mandate (2014), Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines: Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues. p.21. — GRI (2016), GRI 101: Foundation. p.8. Box 3:1 Point to note Setting external reporting boundaries for JVs When setting accounting and assessment boundaries for the purpose of meeting the minimum reporting commitments, it is important to consider and set boundaries relative to the company’s water requirements (ie the water required to sustain the company’s operational assets and meet the company’s production targets). For the purposes of defining water reporting boundaries, it should encompass assets over which the ICMM member company exercises control with regard to financial and operating policies and practices. This excludes non-operated JVs. JV companies that are majority owned by ICMM members (either singly or jointly) are encouraged to implement ICMM’s membership requirements, but any associated reporting would be undertaken by the operating company. 63Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 03 Guidance: External Water Reporting 02 0301 An example of compiling corporate information to meet the minimum reporting commitments is provided in Appendix E. 3.4.2 The reporting narrative The reporting narrative is the written statement which accompanies the ICMM water reporting metrics. The minimum reporting commitments are designed to help companies to generate a concise and relevant snapshot of the company’s water management and stewardship approach by posing a number of questions to answer. Aligned with external guidance,10 these questions are structured in the following three sections: — Interactions with water. — Water risks and opportunities. — Commitment and response. The disclosure narrative is critical to communicating water related information to a broad range of external stakeholders in a way which is easy to access and understand. This is fundamentally important as corporate water stewardship objectives and water management approaches vary greatly with industry, location and operating context. The key benefits of the accompanying narrative are outlined below: — Clearly articulates the relevancy of water to the company and the appropriateness of its response. — Provides fundamental meaning and context to the ICMM water reporting metrics – especially given the broad range of portfolios, commodities, geographies, vertical integration levels and operating contexts present across the mining and metals industry. — Removes ambiguity and the need for external stakeholders to interpret metrics, risks, opportunities and management response. — Demonstrates progress and showcases good practice – especially around the company’s water stewardship efforts, aspirations, partnerships and outreach activities (often enhanced by the use of case studies). 3.5 Going beyond the minimum The ICMM minimum reporting commitments focus on harmonising industry reporting at the minimum level to promote achievability while driving consistency. However, it is recognised that many ICMM members are currently reporting beyond the minimum level. Companies are encouraged to continuously build internal capabilities and external transparency as appropriate to their company’s strategies, operational context, and water risk and opportunity profile. The key points to consider when looking to move beyond reporting to the minimum commitments are outlined below: — Broaden the reporting metrics: The minimum commitments for reporting water metrics (as detailed in Tables 1, 3 and 4) aim to provide a consistent high-level overview of a company’s holistic water dependencies and activities. When moving beyond the minimum, companies are encouraged to consider reporting a broader suite of water metrics (examples are provided in Table 5) to provide greater transparency. Box 3:3 Point to note A consistent industry position for reporting metrics to other external reporting platforms To promote consistency and reinforce industry- specific best practice, ICMM members should use ICMM water reporting metrics when reporting to external reporting platforms. Suggested footnotes are provided in Appendix A for member companies to include when reporting via external platforms to explain this position. — Allows expression of brand image with emphasis on what is relevant to the company based on its wider values and external commitments. — Builds trust and creditability through transparency. 64Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 03 Guidance: External Water Reporting 02 0301 — Report more granular metrics: The minimum reporting commitments require reporting of ICMM water reporting metrics aggregated to the company level. When moving beyond the minimum, companies are encouraged to consider reporting ICMM water reporting metrics at the more granular asset or site levels to provide enhanced transparency. — Increase the narrative detail: The minimum reporting commitments aim for the accompanying narrative to provide a clear overview of the company’s water dependencies, risks, opportunities and response. This should be detailed enough to provide appropriate context for the accompanying reporting metrics. When moving beyond the minimum, companies can add increasing levels of details and examples to the narrative, aligned with the transparency aspirations of the company and the granularity level of the metrics reported. — Systematically include linkages and trade-offs: Water is a connector which crosscuts many aspects of the company’s operational and sustainability objectives. For example, from clean energy and greenhouse gas emission targets, to biodiversity and ecosystem health objectives, social goals and WASH commitments. Increasingly, water challenges cannot be managed in isolation but must be considered within this wider context, requiring complex interlinkages to be understood and trade-offs to be made. When moving beyond the minimum, companies are encouraged to provide more detail around the linkages between water and other fundamental aspects of the company, and the trade- offs made to protect and enhance business value. 65Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 03 Guidance: External Water Reporting active management (or actively managed) Water which is physically pumped within the landscape, actively treated (eg by methods requiring energy or material inputs), and/or has consumptive losses (eg relating to evaporation, entrainment or other losses) which are material in the context of the catchment. active treatment Methods requiring energy and/orphysical inputs (eg chemical) that are undertaken for the primary purpose of improving water quality (excluding dewatering for the purpose of thickening). aquifer A geological unit in the sub-surface that contains groundwater (Source: Adapted from AWS (2019), AWS International Water Stewardship Standard, Version 2.0.) baseline An initial set of observations or data used for the comparison of future status so as to observe changes (positive or negative). (Source: AWS (2019), AWS International Water Stewardship Standard, Version 2.0.) brackish water Water containing dissolved salts at a concentration greater than that of freshwater (1,000 md/L TDS), and significantly less than that of seawater (c 35,000 mg/L TDS) (Sources: Adapted from UNESCO (2012), International Glossary of Hydrology; United States Geological Survey (USGS) Dictionary of Water Terms. [Online]. Available at water. usgs.gov/edu/dictionary.html. Accessed 3 February 2021.) catchment The geographical zone in which water is captured, flows through and eventually discharges at one or more points. The concept includes both surface water catchment and groundwater catchment. A surface water catchment is defined by the area of land from which all precipitation received flows through a sequence of streams and rivers towards a single river mouth, as a tributary to a larger river, or to the sea. A groundwater catchment is defined by geological structure of an aquifer and groundwater flow paths. Depending on local conditions, surface and groundwater catchments may be physically separate or interconnected. Alternative terms are ‘watershed’, ‘basin’ and ‘river basin’. (Source: AWS (2014), AWS International Water Stewardship Standard, Version 1.0.) climate scenario analysis A process for identifying and assessing a potential range of outcomes of future events under conditions of uncertainty. For example, in the case of climate change scenarios allow an organisation to explore and develop an understanding of how the physical and transition risks of climate change may impact its businesses, strategies and financial performance over time. (Source: TCFD (2017), Final Report: Recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures.) change in storage, delta storage (∆storage) The net change in the volume of water stored over the accounting period. Delta storage can be positive (reflecting an increase in the volume in storage) or negative (reflecting a decrease in the volume in storage) over the accounting period, depending on the relative magnitude of inputs (withdrawals) and outputs (discharge and consumption) to the system. efficiency The concept of using less net water for an equivalent purpose or volume of production. (Source: AWS (2019), AWS International Water Stewardship Standard, Version 2.0.) Glossary 66Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Glossary embedded water Water that was used in the production or creation of an item, but not contained within it. For example, for a manufactured item (eg a car, computer), it is the water used during its manufacture. Alternative terms are ‘virtual water’ and ‘water footprint’. There are a range of methods and approaches to evaluating embedded water. (Source: Adapted from AWS (2019) AWS International Water Stewardship Standard, Version 2.0.) entrained water Water (moisture) which is held in ore, waste and product. In the context of water accounting, entrained water may be classified as a withdrawal (ie recoverable water entrained in mined ore) or a consumption (ie water entrained in waste or product), where material. Note: Water entrained in waste is accounted as a consumption, because the water held within the waste is no longer available to the site, water catchment of other users. freshwater Water with concentrations of total dissolved solids (TDS) equal to or below 1,000 mg/L. Note: This definition is based on ISO 14046:2014; USGS Water Science Glossary of Terms. [Online]. Available at water.usgs.gov/edu/dictionary.html. Accessed 1 June 2018; and the World Health Organization (2017), Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality. (Source: GRI (2020). GRI Standards Glossary.) groundwater Water below the surface of the Earth stored in pore spaces and fractures within rock or layers of sand and gravel (aquifers). (Source: Adapted from AWS (2019), AWS International Water Stewardship Standard, Version 2.0.) impact The effect (positive or negative) an organisation has on the economy, the environment, and/or society. (Source: GRI (2020), GRI Standards Glossary.) imported water Water that has been actively withdrawn by the site from the environment (eg borefields or rivers) or third parties (eg municipal to industrial suppliers) to meet the operational water supply demand; may also be called ‘make-up water’ or ‘new water’. inherent (or raw) risk The risk that exists in the absence of controls, ie not taking into account any potential mitigation or management measures that could be implemented (Source: CDP (2021). Water Security 2021 Reporting Guidance.) local community Persons or groups of persons living and/or working in any areas that are economically, socially or environmentally impacted (positively or negatively) by an organisation’s operations. (Source: GRI (2020), GRI Standards Glossary.) managed (or residual) risk The risk remaining after a specific action has been taken to manage the risk (Source: CDP (2021). Water Security 2021 Reporting Guidance.) municipal water Water supplied by a municipality or other public entity. (Source: adapted from CDP (2021). Water Security 2021 Reporting Guidance.) new water For the purposes of water accounting, new water is water that has been withdrawn but not previously used by the site in an operational task. ICMM new water is equivalent to WAF raw water. New water may also be used more generally to describe water that has been actively withdrawn by the site from the environment (eg borefields or rivers) or third parties (eg municipal or industrial suppliers) to meet the operational water supply demand (also see imported water). non-operated joint venture An independently managed asset where a company may have an equity interest in the joint venture but does not operate or control the day-to-day operations of the business or asset. 67Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Glossary operational water Water that enters the operational water system used to meet the operational water demand. It is therefore available for use by the site within an operational task or activity. Once within the operational water system, operational water may be tasked (used), treated or stored; and ultimately may be released back to the local water system or a third party (discharged) or removed from the local water system (consumed). operational water store A purpose built artificial structure designed to collect/hold water which receives and/or supplies operational water. operational water use The volume of water that is needed (or ‘used’) to sustain operational tasks that require water. other managed water (OMW) Water which is actively managed (eg physically pumped, actively treated or has material consumptive losses) by the operation but does not enter the operational water system used to supply the operational water demand (ie is not used by the site in an operational task or activity). Note: OMW does not include diversion of surface water within the landscape via culverts and stream realignments. ICMM OMW is equivalent to WAF diversions. operational task Operational activities that use water, eg dust control, underground mining, coal handling and processing, ore processing, co-disposal, amenities use, tailings storage facilities (TSFs). Note: Dewatering is not a task as it generates but does not use water. (Source: Adapted from MCA (2014), Water Accounting Frameworkfor the Minerals Industry.) physical risk Risks relating to having too little water, too much water, water that is unfit for use, or inaccessible water. (Source: CEO Water Mandate (2014). Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues.) potential water pollutants Physical (including thermal), biological, or chemical agents (organic, inorganic substances or heavy metals) that have the direct or indirect potential to negatively modify/contaminate water bodies and/or water ecosystems or affect human health. (Source: CDP (2021). Water Security 2021 Reporting Guidance.) produced water Water that enters an organisation’s boundary as a result of extraction (eg crude oil), processing (eg, sugar cane crushing), or use of any raw material, and has to consequently be managed by the organization. (Source: GRI (2020), GRI Standards Glossary, based on CDP (2021). Water Security 2021 Reporting Guidance.) Note: In the mining and metals context, water entrained in ore extracted from the ground (where recoverable or material) should be classified and accounted as a withdrawal from groundwater (not as produced water). receiving water body The surface water or groundwater body that ultimately receives a site’s discharge of water or wastewater (Source: AWS (2019), AWS International Water Stewardship Standard, Version 2.0.) recycled/reused water Water that has been used in an operational task and is recovered and used again in an operational task, either without (reuse) or with (recycle) treatment. regulatory risk Risks relating to changing, ineffective, or poorly implemented public water policy and/or regulations. (Source: CEO Water Mandate (2014). Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues.) reporting period Specific time span covered by the information reported (Source: GRI (2020), GRI Standards Glossary.) 68Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Glossary reputational risk Risks relating to stakeholder perceptions that a company does not conduct business in a sustainable or responsible fashion with respect to water. (Source: CEO Water Mandate (2014). Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues.) residual (or managed) risk The risk remaining after a specific action has been taken to manage the risk. (Source: CDP (2021). Water Security 2021 Reporting Guidance.) run-off The part of precipitation that flows towards a river on the ground surface (ie surface run-off) or within the soil (ie subsurface flow). (Source: UNESCO (2012), International Glossary of Hydrology.) For the purpose of accounting and reporting consistent metrics, only run-off that makes a material contribution to the site (company) water balance (eg via active harvesting or passive capture in operational water stores, TSFs or other actively managed water features) is included. seawater Water in a sea or in an ocean. (Source: ISO 14046:2014.) sediment dam An artificial dam structure used to passively reduce the sediment load of run-off from active mining areas (including waste dumps and disturbed ground) prior to discharge. shared water challenge A water related issue, concern or threat shared by the site and one or more stakeholders within the catchment(s). Examples include physical water scarcity, deteriorating water quality and regulatory restrictions on water allocation. (Source: AWS (2019), AWS International Water Stewardship Standard, Version 2.0.) sump An excavation in the lowest part of the landscape used to passively drain or capture surface water and/or groundwater. supply chain The network of all suppliers and their activities that contribute to providing all materials, ingredients and services to the site to support its normal production and operational activities. (Source: AWS (2019), AWS International Water Stewardship Standard, Version 2.0.) surface water Water that occurs naturally on the Earth’s surface in ice sheets, ice caps, glaciers, icebergs, bogs, ponds, lakes, rivers, and streams. (Source: CDP (2021). Water Security 2021 Reporting Guidance.) target A measurable, actionable, and time-bound objectives that help to drive the appropriate response or actions required to achieve a desired (or improved) outcome (Source: SBTN (2020), Science-Based Targets for Nature: Initial Guidance for Business. [PDF]. task See operational task. third-party water Water provided by, or to, an entity that is external to the site or company, eg a municipality, utility provider, industrial company or community. total consumption Water that is removed by evaporation, entrainment (in product or waste) or other losses, and not released back to surface water, groundwater, seawater or a third party. total discharge Water that is released to the water environment (surface water, groundwater or seawater) or to a third party, including operational water and other managed water value chain The entire sequence of activities or partners that provide value to or receive value from an organisation’s products and services, either within, upstream or downstream of direct operations. (Source: CDP (2021). Water Security 2021 Reporting Guidance.) 69Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Glossary WASH Acronym for Water, Sanitation and Hygiene. It is used in the international development sector to refer to the combined area of effort to address basic human water needs and rights related to access to safe and sufficient water for drinking, food preparation and washing. It also includes the provision of good washing and toilet facilities and the principal of hygiene education to combat the spread of water-related illnesses and disease. (Source: CEO Water Mandate (2014), Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines: Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues.) wastewater Used water of reduced quality discharged from a site. (Source: AWS (2019), AWS International Water Stewardship Standard, Version 2.0.) water balance A model that describes the flow dynamics of a system over a given timeframe, where water inputs to the system must equal all water outputs from the system plus any change in internal storage volume. In the mining and metals context, water balances may be developed at different scales for different operational management, optimisation and planning purposes. The site water balance is a fundamental operational water management tool that provides the foundation of effective water management and consistent reporting metrics. The site water balance model describes the integrated dynamics of water inputs, movements within site, and outputs; and allows estimation/calculation of unmeasured flows. water consumption Water that is removed by evaporation, entrainment (in product or waste) or other losses, and not released back to surface water, groundwater, seawater or a third party. For the purposes of water accounting, this water may be classified as operational water or other managed water. However, ICMM minimum reporting commitments require reporting of total consumption volumes (including operational water and other managed water). water demand The actual quantity of water required for various needs over a given period. (Source: Adapted from the CEO Water Mandate (2014), Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines: Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues) water discharge Water that is released back to the water environment (surface water, groundwater or seawater) or to a third party. For the purposes of water accounting, this water may be classified as operational water or other managed water. However, ICMM minimum reporting commitments require reporting of total discharge volumes (including operational water and other managed water). water intensity A metric providing the relationship between a volumetric aspect of water and a unit of production,financial metric or any other unit (Source: CDP (2021). Water Security 2021 Reporting Guidance.) water quality The physical, chemical, biological, and organoleptic (taste-related) properties of water. (Source: CEO Water Mandate, (2014), Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines: Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues) Note: ICMM categorises water quality as either high or low quality. water opportunity The possibility of water driving positive value or outcomes for the company. For example, efficiency, resilience, products and services, and markets (and reputation) (Source: Adapted from CEO Water Mandate (2014), Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues and CDP (2021). Water Security 2021 Reporting Guidance.) 70Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Glossary water risk The possibility of an entity experiencing a water-related challenge (eg, water scarcity, water stress, flooding, infrastructure decay, drought). The extent of risk is a function of the likelihood of a specific challenge occurring and the severity of the challenge’s impact. The severity of impact itself depends on the intensity of the challenge, as well as the vulnerability of the actor. (Source: CEO Water Mandate (2014), Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues.) water scarcity The volumetric abundance, or lack thereof, of freshwater resources. Scarcity is human driven; it is a function of the volume of human water consumption relative to the volume of water resources in a given area. As such, an arid region with very little water, but no human water consumption would not be considered scarce, but rather ‘arid.’ Water scarcity is a physical, objective reality that can be measured consistently across regions and over time. Water scarcity reflects the physical abundance of freshwater rather than whether that water is suitable for use. For instance, a region may have abundant water resources (and thus not be considered water scarce) but have such severe pollution that those supplies are unfit for human or ecological uses. (Source: CEO Water Mandate (2014), Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues.) water stewardship The use of water that is socially and culturally equitable, environmentally sustainable and economically beneficial, achieved through a stakeholder-inclusive process that involves site- and catchment-based actions. (Source: AWS (2019), AWS International Water Stewardship Standard, Version 2.0.) water store A purpose built structure designed to collect or hold operational water (eg tanks, dams, reservoirs and disused pits). water stress The ability, or lack thereof, to meet the human and ecological demand for freshwater. Water stress comprises three primary components: availability, quality and accessibility. Water stress is based on subjective elements and is assessed differently depending on societal values, such as the suitability of water for drinking or the requirements to be afforded to ecosystems. (Source: Adapted from CEO Water Mandate (2014), Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues.) water treatment plant A facility which uses active treatment methods (ie those requiring energy and/or physical inputs (eg chemicals) for the primary purpose of improving water quality (excluding dewatering for the purpose of thickening). water withdrawal Water that is drawn from the environment (surface water, groundwater or seawater) or third parties. For the purposes of ICMM accounting and reporting, this water is classified as either operational water or other managed water. worked water Water that has previously been used by the site an operational task or activity (eg mineral processing). 71Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Glossary 1. Ceres (2011), The Ceres Aqua Gauge: A Framework for 21st Century Water Risk Management. [PDF]. Available at www.ceres. org/sites/default/files/reports/2017-03/Ceres_AquaGauge_ All_101113.pdf 2. WRI (2010), Mine the Gap: Connecting Water Risks and Disclosure in the Mining Sector. [PDF]. Available at www.wri.org/publication/ mine-gap 3. UNEP Finance Initiative (2012), Extractives Sector, Issue 3. [PDF]. Available at www.unepfi.org/fileadmin/documents/CLS3.pdf 4. World Bank (2020), Minerals for Climate Action: The Mineral Intensity of the Clean Energy Transition. [PDF]. Available at pubdocs.worldbank.org/en/961711588875536384/Minerals-for- Climate-Action-The-Mineral-Intensity-of-the-Clean-Energy- Transition.pdf 5. WWF (2020), An analysis of water risk in the mining sector. [PDF]. Available at d2ouvy59p0dg6k.cloudfront.net/downloads/ analysis_of_water_risk_in_mining_sector__wwf_water_risk_filter_ research_series_.pdf 6. World Bank (2019), Quality Unknown: The Invisible Water Crisis. [PDF]. Available at openknowledge.worldbank.org/ handle/10986/32245 7. WBCSD (2017), Business guide to circular water management: spotlight on reduce, reuse and recycle. [PDF]. Available at www. wbcsd.org/Programs/Food-and-Nature/Water/Resources/ spotlight-on-reduce-reuse-and-recycle 8. ICMM (2017) Water Stewardship: Position Statement. [PDF]. Available at www.icmm.com/en-gb/about-us/member- requirements/position-statements/water-stewardship 9. MCA (2021), Water Accounting Framework for the Minerals Industry, Version 1.4. [PDF]. Available at minerals.org.au/sites/ default/files/WAF_UserGuide_v1.3_(Jan_2014).pdf 10. CEO Water Mandate (2014), Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines: Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues. [PDF]. Available at ceowatermandate.org/files/ Disclosure2014.pdf 11. GRI (2018), GRI 303: Water and Effluents 2018. [PDF]. Available at www.globalreporting.org/standards/media/1909/gri-303-water- and-effluents-2018.pdf 12. CDP (2021), Water Security 2021 Reporting Guidance. [Online]. Available at www.cdp.net/en/guidance/guidance-for-companies #8b7fadc232e1bab9268512963662f431 13. Alliance for Water Stewardship (2019), AWS International Water Stewardship Standard, Version 2. [PDF]. Available at a4ws.org/ the-aws-standard-2-0/ 14. ICMM (2015), A Practical Guide to Catchment-Based Water Management for the Mining and Metals Industry. [PDF]. Available at: www.icmm.com/en-gb/guidance/environmental-stewardship/ catchment-based-water-management 15. ICMM (2019), Adapting to a Changing Climate: Building resilience in the mining and metals industry. [PDF]. Available at www.icmm. References com/en-gb/guidance/environmental-stewardship/adapting- climate-change-2019 16. ICMM (2017), A Practical Guide to Consistent Water Reporting. [PDF]. Available at www.icmm.com/en-gb/guidance/ environmental-stewardship/water-reporting 17. WHO (2017), Guidelines for drinking-water quality, 4th ed. [PDF]. Available at www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789241549950 18. UNEP (2018), A Framework for Freshwater Ecosystem Management, Volume 4. [PDF]. Available at www.unep.org/ resources/publication/framework-freshwater-ecosystem- management 19. ANZECC and ARMCANC (2000), Australian and New Zealand Guidelines for Fresh and Marine Water Quality. [PDF]. Available at www.waterquality.gov.au/anz-guidelines/resources/previous- guidelines/anzecc-armcanz-2000 20. Water Footprint Network. Available at waterfootprint.org/en/ 21. WWF (2013), Water Stewardship. [PDF]. Available at awsassets.panda.org/downloads/ws_briefing_booklet_lr_ spreads.pdf 22. Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosure (TCFD) (2017), The Use of Scenario Analysis in Disclosure of Climate- Related Risks and Opportunities. [PDF]. Available at assets. bbhub.io/company/sites/60/2020/10/FINAL-TCFD-Technical- Supplement-062917.pdf 23. WRI (2019), Aqueduct 3.0: Updated Decision-Relevant Global Water Risk Indicators. [PDF]. Available at www.wri.org/ research/aqueduct-30-updated-decision-relevant-global-water-risk-indicators 24. WWF (2020), Water Risk Filter Methodology. [PDF]. Available at waterriskfilter.panda.org/en/About/DataAndMethods 25. WWF and WBCSD (2020), Right Tool for the Job: Tools and Approaches for Companies and Investors to Assess Water Risks and Shared Water Challenges. [PDF]. Available at www. wbcsd.org/Programs/Food-and-Nature/Water/Resources/ Right-tool-for-the-job 26. SBTN (2020), Science-Based Targets for Nature: Initial Guidance for Business. [PDF]. Available at sciencebasedtargetsnetwork.org/wp-content/ uploads/2020/11/Science-Based-Targets-for-Nature-Initial- Guidance-for-Business.pdf 27. WWF and H&M Group (2021), Putting water strategy into context: A practical guide to connect corporate strategic objectives to local water context. [PDF]. Available at wwfint. awsassets.panda.org/downloads/wwf_embedding_context_ into_strategy_hr.pdf 28. CEO Water Mandate and partners (2019), Setting Site Water Targets Informed by Catchment Context: A Guide For Companies. [PDF]. Available at ceowatermandate.org/ watertargets/wp-content/uploads/sites/30/2019/08/ CEOWaterMandateSiteWaterTargetsGuide.pdf 29. WRI and partners (2021), Setting Enterprise Water Targets: A Guide for Companies. [PDF]. Available at www.wri.org/ research/setting-enterprise-water-targets-guide-companies 30. GRI (2016), GRI 101: Foundation 2016. [PDF]. Available at www. globalreporting.org/standards/media/1036/gri-101- foundation-2016.pdf 72Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition References https://www.ceres.org/sites/default/files/reports/2017-03/Ceres_AquaGauge_All_101113.pdf https://www.ceres.org/sites/default/files/reports/2017-03/Ceres_AquaGauge_All_101113.pdf https://www.ceres.org/sites/default/files/reports/2017-03/Ceres_AquaGauge_All_101113.pdf https://www.wri.org/research/mine-gap https://www.wri.org/research/mine-gap https://www.unepfi.org/fileadmin/documents/CLS3.pdf https://pubdocs.worldbank.org/en/961711588875536384/Minerals-for-Climate-Action-The-Mineral-Intensity-of-the-Clean-Energy-Transition.pdf https://pubdocs.worldbank.org/en/961711588875536384/Minerals-for-Climate-Action-The-Mineral-Intensity-of-the-Clean-Energy-Transition.pdf https://pubdocs.worldbank.org/en/961711588875536384/Minerals-for-Climate-Action-The-Mineral-Intensity-of-the-Clean-Energy-Transition.pdf https://d2ouvy59p0dg6k.cloudfront.net/downloads/analysis_of_water_risk_in_mining_sector__wwf_water_risk_filter_research_series_.pdf https://d2ouvy59p0dg6k.cloudfront.net/downloads/analysis_of_water_risk_in_mining_sector__wwf_water_risk_filter_research_series_.pdf https://d2ouvy59p0dg6k.cloudfront.net/downloads/analysis_of_water_risk_in_mining_sector__wwf_water_risk_filter_research_series_.pdf https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/32245 https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/32245 https://www.wbcsd.org/Programs/Food-and-Nature/Water/Resources/spotlight-on-reduce-reuse-and-recycle https://www.wbcsd.org/Programs/Food-and-Nature/Water/Resources/spotlight-on-reduce-reuse-and-recycle https://www.wbcsd.org/Programs/Food-and-Nature/Water/Resources/spotlight-on-reduce-reuse-and-recycle https://www.icmm.com/en-gb/about-us/member-requirements/position-statements/water-stewardship https://www.icmm.com/en-gb/about-us/member-requirements/position-statements/water-stewardship https://www.minerals.org.au/sites/default/files/WAF_UserGuide_v1.3_(Jan_2014).pdf https://www.minerals.org.au/sites/default/files/WAF_UserGuide_v1.3_(Jan_2014).pdf https://ceowatermandate.org/files/Disclosure2014.pdf https://ceowatermandate.org/files/Disclosure2014.pdf https://www.globalreporting.org/standards/media/1909/gri-303-water-and-effluents-2018.pdf https://www.globalreporting.org/standards/media/1909/gri-303-water-and-effluents-2018.pdf https://www.cdp.net/en/guidance/guidance-for-companies#8b https://www.cdp.net/en/guidance/guidance-for-companies#8b https://a4ws.org/the-aws-standard-2-0/ https://a4ws.org/the-aws-standard-2-0/ https://www.icmm.com/en-gb/guidance/environmental-stewardship/catchment-based-water-management https://www.icmm.com/en-gb/guidance/environmental-stewardship/catchment-based-water-management https://www.icmm.com/en-gb/guidance/environmental-stewardship/adapting-climate-change-2019 https://www.icmm.com/en-gb/guidance/environmental-stewardship/adapting-climate-change-2019 https://www.icmm.com/en-gb/guidance/environmental-stewardship/adapting-climate-change-2019 http://www.icmm.com/en-gb/guidance/environmental-stewardship/water-reporting http://www.icmm.com/en-gb/guidance/environmental-stewardship/water-reporting https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789241549950 https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789241549950 https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789241549950 https://www.waterquality.gov.au/anz-guidelines/resources/previous-guidelines/anzecc-armcanz-2000 https://www.waterquality.gov.au/anz-guidelines/resources/previous-guidelines/anzecc-armcanz-2000 https://waterfootprint.org/en/ https://awsassets.panda.org/downloads/ws_briefing_booklet_lr_spreads.pdf https://awsassets.panda.org/downloads/ws_briefing_booklet_lr_spreads.pdf https://assets.bbhub.io/company/sites/60/2020/10/FINAL-TCFD-Technical-Supplement-062917.pdf https://assets.bbhub.io/company/sites/60/2020/10/FINAL-TCFD-Technical-Supplement-062917.pdf https://assets.bbhub.io/company/sites/60/2020/10/FINAL-TCFD-Technical-Supplement-062917.pdf https://www.wri.org/research/aqueduct-30-updated-decision-relevant-global-water-risk-indicators https://www.wri.org/research/aqueduct-30-updated-decision-relevant-global-water-risk-indicators https://www.wri.org/research/aqueduct-30-updated-decision-relevant-global-water-risk-indicators https://waterriskfilter.panda.org/en/About/DataAndMethods https://www.wbcsd.org/Programs/Food-and-Nature/Water/Resources/Right-tool-for-the-job https://www.wbcsd.org/Programs/Food-and-Nature/Water/Resources/Right-tool-for-the-job https://www.wbcsd.org/Programs/Food-and-Nature/Water/Resources/Right-tool-for-the-job https://sciencebasedtargetsnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Science-Based-Targets-for-Nature-Initial-Guidance-for-Business.pdf https://sciencebasedtargetsnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Science-Based-Targets-for-Nature-Initial-Guidance-for-Business.pdf https://sciencebasedtargetsnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Science-Based-Targets-for-Nature-Initial-Guidance-for-Business.pdf https://wwfint.awsassets.panda.org/downloads/wwf_embedding_context_into_strategy_hr.pdf https://wwfint.awsassets.panda.org/downloads/wwf_embedding_context_into_strategy_hr.pdf https://wwfint.awsassets.panda.org/downloads/wwf_embedding_context_into_strategy_hr.pdf https://ceowatermandate.org/watertargets/wp-content/uploads/sites/30/2019/08/CEOWaterMandateSiteWaterTargetsGuide.pdf https://ceowatermandate.org/watertargets/wp-content/uploads/sites/30/2019/08/CEOWaterMandateSiteWaterTargetsGuide.pdf https://ceowatermandate.org/watertargets/wp-content/uploads/sites/30/2019/08/CEOWaterMandateSiteWaterTargetsGuide.pdf https://www.wri.org/research/setting-enterprise-water-targets-guide-companies https://www.wri.org/research/setting-enterprise-water-targets-guide-companies https://www.globalreporting.org/standards/media/1036/gri-101-foundation-2016.pdf https://www.globalreporting.org/standards/media/1036/gri-101-foundation-2016.pdf https://www.globalreporting.org/standards/media/1036/gri-101-foundation-2016.pdf Appendices Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Table A1 – Mapping ICMM reporting metrics with external reporting platforms Reporting Metric ICMM Minimum Reporting Commitments (2021) GRI 303: Water and Effluents (a) SASB Metals and Mining Sustainability Accounting Standard (b) WEF Stakeholder Capitalism Metrics (c) DJSI Corporate Sustainability Assessment for Mining and Metals (d) CEO Water Mandate Corporate Water Disclosure Guideline (e) CDP Water Security Questionnaire (f) Reporting context Consistent approach to water reporting for the mining and metals industry Framework forreporting sustainability goals, performance and impacts Industry specific sustainability reporting framework designed for investors The SCMs are intended to mainstream reporting on ESG indicators Industry specific assessment of company sustainability for global benchmarking by investors Framework for reporting corporate water disclosure to stakeholders Framework for reporting water on behalf of investors and supply chain members W it h d ra w a l Metric definition Operational water: Operational water: All water that enters the operational water system used to supply the operational water demand and is available for use. OMW: Water that is actively managed (eg physically pumped, actively treated or has material consumptive losses) without intent to supply the operational water demand. Sum of all water drawn from surface water, groundwater, seawater or a third party for any use over the course of the reporting period. Sum of all water drawn from all sources including surface water (including water from wetlands, rivers, lakes and oceans), groundwater, rainwater collected directly and stored by the entity, water and wastewater obtained from municipal water supplies, water utilities, or other entities. Same as SASB definition. Same as GRI definition. The volume of freshwater abstraction from surface or groundwater. Part of the freshwater withdrawal will evaporate, another part will return to the catchment where it was withdrawn, and yet another part may return to another catchment or the sea. The sum of all water drawn into the boundaries of the organisation from all sources for any use over the course of the reporting period. For the metal and mining sector, water withdrawals include water diversions to enable comparability because it is water that crosses the company boundary. Reporting requirement Operational water withdrawal volumes, by source type and water quality (high and low), for: — All sites (as aggregated totals). — For all sites situated in areas of water stress (as aggregated totals). OMV volumes (for all sources), by water quality (high and low), for: — All sites (as aggregated totals). — For all sites situated in areas of water stress (as aggregated totals). Relates to GRI 303-3: — The total water withdrawal from all areas in megalitres, and a breakdown of this total by source. (2) — The total water withdrawal from all areas with water stress in megalitres, and a breakdown of this total by source.(2) — A breakdown of total water withdrawal from each of the sources listed above in megalitres by Freshwater ( 1,000 mg/L TDS).(3) Relates to EM-MM-140a: — The amount of water, in thousands of cubic meters, withdrawn from freshwater sources. — Water withdrawn in locations with high or extremely high baseline water stress (as classified by the WRI Aqueduct tool) as a percentage of the total water withdrawn Relates to Planet: Core metrics and disclosure: — Megalitres of water withdrawn. — The percentage of water withdrawn in regions with High or Extremely High Baseline Water Stress, according to WRI Aqueduct Water Risk Atlas tool. — Estimate and report the same information for the full value chain where appropriate. Relates to section 2.3.4: — Total municipal water supplies (or from other water utilities) in million cubic meters for previous 4 years and indicate your target for current year. — Fresh surface water in million cubic meters for previous 4 years and indicate your target for current year. — Fresh groundwater in million cubic meters for previous 4 years and indicate your target for current year. For basic level reporting: — Total water withdrawals located in water-stressed areas. — Percentage of total withdrawals located in water-stressed or water-scarce areas. — For advanced level reporting: — Detailed location specific withdrawals by source type (surface water, renewable and non-renewable groundwater, municipal water, recycled water, runoff, saltwater and wastewater) for hot-spot areas. — Relates to question W1.2b, W1.2d, W1.2h (pp.11–12). — Relates also to questions W5.1 and W5.1a (pp.48–49). Appendix A: Mapping ICMM Water Reporting Metrics with External Reporting Platforms The relationship between the ICMM water reporting metrics and those of key external disclosure platforms is summarised in the following tables. To promote consistency and reinforce industry-specific best practice, ICMM members should use ICMM water reporting metrics when reporting to external reporting platforms. Suggested footnotes are provided in Table A2 for member companies to include when reporting via external platforms to explain this position. Guidance for mapping between the ICMM water reporting metrics and MCA’s WAF is provided in Appendix B. — Table A1 – Mapping ICMM reporting metrics with external reporting platforms — Table A2 – Mapping GRI and ICMM, and explanatory footnotes for ICMM members reporting to GRI — Table A3 – Mapping of GRI disclosures 303-3, 303-4 and 303-5 against ICMM metrics — Table A4 – Mapping of GRI facility-level information against ICMM metrics — Table A5 – Mapping GRI supply chain information against ICMM metrics Appendix A 74 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Reporting Metric ICMM Minimum Reporting Commitments (2021) GRI 303: Water and Effluents (a) SASB Metals and Mining Sustainability Accounting Standard (b) WEF Stakeholder Capitalism Metrics (c) DJSI Corporate Sustainability Assessment for Mining and Metals (d) CEO Water Mandate Corporate Water Disclosure Guideline (e) CDP Water Security Questionnaire (f) D is c h a rg e Metric definition Water that is released to the water environment (surface water, groundwater or seawater) or to a third party, including operational water and OMW. Sum of effluents, used water and unused water released to surface water, groundwater, seawater or a third party, for which the organisation has no further use, over the course of the reporting period. Water can be released into the receiving waterbody either as (point source discharge or non-point-source discharge. Water discharge can be authorised or unauthorised. None None Only water used for cooling and returned to the source at equal or higher quality should be reported under discharge. Water effluents discharged to subsurface waters, surface waters or sewers that lead to rivers, oceans, lakes, wetlands, treatment facilities and groundwater through either: — A defined discharge point (point- source discharge). — Over land in a dispersed or undefined manner (non-point- source discharge). — Wastewater removed from the organisation via truck. — Discharge of collected rainwater or domestic sewage is not a discharge. The sum of effluents and other water leaving the boundaries of the organisation and released to surface water, groundwater, or third parties over the course of the reporting period. Reporting requirement Total discharge volumes (operational water and OMW), by destination and water quality (high and low), for: — All sites (as aggregated totals). — All sites situated in areas of water stress (as aggregated totals). Relates to GRI 303-4: — The total water discharge to all areas in megalitres and a breakdown of this total by destination. — A breakdown of total water discharge to all areas in megalitres by Freshwater and Other water.(3) — The total water discharge to all areas with water stress in megalitres and a breakdown of this total by Freshwater and Other water.(3) None None Relates to section 2.3.4: — Water returned to the source of extraction at similar or higher qualityas raw water extracted (only applies to fresh surface water and groundwater withdrawal). For advanced level reporting: — Detailed location specific discharges by destination type (groundwater, sewers and surface water) and quality (for hot-spot areas). — Relates to question W1.2b, W1.2i, W2.2a, W2.2b (pp.11–13, 23–24). — Also relates to questions W5.1 and W5.1a (pp.48–49). C o n su m p ti o n Metric definition Water that is removed by evaporation, entrainment (in product or waste) or other losses, and not released back to surface water, groundwater, seawater or a third party (including operational water and OMW). Sum of all water that has been withdrawn and incorporated into products, used in production or generated as waste, has evaporated, transpired, or been consumed by humans or livestock, or is polluted to the point of being unusable by other users, and so not released back to surface water, groundwater, seawater or a third party over the course of the reporting period. Water consumption includes water stored during the reporting period for use or discharge in a subsequent reporting period. Water that evaporates during withdrawal, usage and discharge; water that is directly or indirectly incorporated into the entity’s product or service; water that does not otherwise return to the same catchment area from which it was withdrawn, such as water returned to another catchment area or the sea. Same as SASB definition Total net freshwater consumption = Municipal water (A) + Fresh surface water (B) + Fresh ground water (C) - Water returned to the source of extraction at similar or higher quality as raw water extracted (D). Please do not include salt or brackish water into the reported figures. Rainwater collected and wastewater should not be reported. The volume of freshwater used and then evaporated or incorporated into a product. It also includes water abstracted from surface or groundwater in a catchment and returned to another catchment or the sea. It is important to distinguish the term ‘water consumption’ from the term ‘water withdrawal’ or ‘water abstraction’. The amount of water that is drawn into the boundaries of the organisation and not discharged back to the water environment or a third party over the course of the reporting year. Water consumption in metals and mining sector should report on the volumes of water lost to evaporation from open water surfaces, entrained in remaining waste material (such as tailings, coarse rejects, and concentrates) or water stored over the reporting year. Reporting requirement Total consumption volumes (operational water and OMW) for: — All sites (as aggregated totals). — All sites situated in areas of water stress (as aggregated totals). Relates to GRI 303-5: — The total water consumption from all areas in megalitres. — The total water consumption from all areas with water stress in megalitres. — The change in water storage in megalitres, if water storage has been identified as having a significant water-related impact. Relates to EM-MM-140a: — The amount of water, in thousands of cubic meters, consumed in its operations. — Water consumed in locations with High or Extremely High Baseline Water Stress as a percentage of the total water consumed. Relates to Planet: Core metrics and disclosure: — Megalitres of water consumed. — The percentage of water consumed in regions with High or Extremely High Baseline Water Stress, according to WRI Aqueduct Water Risk Atlas tool. — Estimate and report the same information for the full value chain where appropriate. Relates to section 2.3.4: — Total net freshwater consumption (A+B+C+D). For advanced level reporting relates to: — Detailed location specific consumption (for hot-spot areas). — Relates to question W1.2b (pp.11– 13) — Also relates to questions W5.1 and W5.1a (pp.48–49). Appendix A 75 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Reporting Metric ICMM Minimum Reporting Commitments (2021) GRI 303: Water and Effluents (a) SASB Metals and Mining Sustainability Accounting Standard (b) WEF Stakeholder Capitalism Metrics (c) DJSI Corporate Sustainability Assessment for Mining and Metals (d) CEO Water Mandate Corporate Water Disclosure Guideline (e) CDP Water Security Questionnaire (f) R e u se /R e c yc le Metric definition Water that has been used in an operational task and is recovered and used again in an operational task, either without treatment (reuse) or with treatment (recycle). None None None None The act of processing used water and wastewater through another cycle before discharge to final treatment and discharge to the environment. Water and wastewater (treated or untreated) that has been used more than once before being discharged from the organisation’s boundary, so that water demand is reduced. This may be in the same process (recycled), or used in a different process within the same facility or another of the organisation’s facilities (reused). Reporting requirement Water reuse/recycle volumes for: — All sites (as an aggregated total). — All sites situated in areas of water stress (as an aggregated total). None None None None For advanced level reporting relates to: — Recycled water identified by withdrawal source type. — Volume of water recycled to demonstrate internal action to improve efficiency. Reuse/recycle questions removed in the 2020 questionnaire. W a te r ri sk s a n d o p p o rt u n it ie s Risk definition The possibility of an entity experiencing a water-related challenge (eg water scarcity, water stress, flooding, infrastructure decay, drought). The extent of risk is a function of the likelihood of a specific challenge occurring and the severity of the challenge’s impact. The severity of impact itself depends on the intensity of the challenge, as well as the vulnerability of the actor (CEO Water Mandate (2014)). Opportunity definition Refers to the potential positive impact on an organisation resulting from improved water security or an action to progress it, eg cost savings, access to new markets, supply chain resilience (CDP Water (2020)). Reporting requirement Report: — The proportion of sites (as an absolute number or a percentage) located in water-stressed areas. Relates to GRI 303-1, provide a description of: — How the organisation interacts with water, including how and where water is withdrawn, consumed and discharged, and the water-related impacts caused or contributed to, or directly linked to the organisation’s activities, products or services by a business relationship. — Approach used to identify water- related impacts, including scope, timeframe, and tools or methodologies. — How water-related impacts are addressed, including how the organisation works with stakeholders to steward water as a shared resource, and how it engages with suppliers or customers with significant water-related impacts. Relates to EM-MM-140a: — Analyse all operations for water risks and identify activities that withdraw and consume water in locations with High (40–80%) or Extremely High (> 80%) Baseline Water Stress as classified by WRI Aquaduct Water Risk Atlas tool. — List of facilities or operations located in areas of High or Extremely High Baseline Water Stress. Relates to Planet: Expanded metrics and disclosure: — Report wherever material along the value chain: the valued impact of freshwater consumption and withdrawal. None For basic level reporting: — High level assessment of risks at a portfolio level. — High level opportunities assessment. — For advanced level reporting relates to: — Detailed assessment of risksbased on extensive, location specific analysis at the facility level. — Detailed assessment of opportunities. — Value chain risks and opportunities. — Relates to question W2.1a and W-MM3.2c. — Relates to questions W3.3, W4.1 and W4.2 on risk and W4.3 on opportunities. — Relates to question W6.6 on responses to risks. — Relates to questions W7 on business strategy and climate change risk. References: GRI (2018), GRI 303: Water and Effluents 2018. [PDF]. Available at www.globalreporting.org/ standards/media/1909/gri-303-water-and-effluents-2018.pdf a. Sustainability Account Standards Board (SASB) (2018), Metals and Mining Sustainability Accounting Standard.[PDF]. Available at www.sasb.org/wp-content/ uploads/2018/11/Metals_Mining_Standard_2018.pdf b. World Economic Forum (WEF) (2020), Measuring Stakeholder Capitalism: Towards Common Metrics and Consistent Reporting of Sustainable Value Creation. [PDF]. Available at www.weforum.org/reports/measuring-stakeholder-capitalism-towards- common-metrics-and-consistent-reporting-of-sustainable-value-creation c. Dow Jones Sustainability Index (DJSI) (2020), Corporate Sustainability Assessment for Mining and Metals [PDF/Online]. https://portal.csa.spglobal.com/survey/documents/ SAM_CSA_2020_Sample_Questionnaire_MNX.pdf d. CEO Water Mandate (2014), Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines: Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues. [PDF]. Available at ceowatermandate. org/files/Disclosure2014.pdf e. CDP (2021), Water Security Questionnaire: Reporting Guidance. [Online]. Available at www.cdp.net/en/guidance/guidance-for-companies#8b7fadc232e1bab92685129636 62f431 Notes: Some ICMM members are listed as Aluminium or Iron and Steel industries rather than Mining and Metals for both DJSI and SASB platforms. While DJSI uses the same reporting metrics across 50+ industries, SASB requires Iron and Steel Producers to report recycled water as a percentage (recycled volume divided by the volume of withdrawn water), any volume of water reused multiple times is to be counted as recycled each time it is recycled and reused. There is no such requirement in the Metal and Mining Standard, which is why this section of the table above is blank. There are variations in the terms and key metrics required for reporting across the numerous disclosure platforms. To promote consistency and reinforce industry-specific best practice, ICMM members should use ICMM water reporting metrics when reporting to external reporting platforms, including GRI (which is a condition of ICMM membership). Suggested footnotes are provided in the table below for member companies to explain this position. Appendix A 76 http://www.sasb.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/Metals_Mining_Standard_2018.pdf http://www.sasb.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/Metals_Mining_Standard_2018.pdf http://www.weforum.org/reports/measuring-stakeholder-capitalism-towards-common-metrics-and-consistent-reporting-of-sustainable-value-creation http://www.weforum.org/reports/measuring-stakeholder-capitalism-towards-common-metrics-and-consistent-reporting-of-sustainable-value-creation http://www.icmm.com/en-gb/guidance/environmental-stewardship/adapting-climate-change-2019 http://www.icmm.com/en-gb/guidance/environmental-stewardship/adapting-climate-change-2019 http://ceowatermandate.org/files/Disclosure2014.pdf http://ceowatermandate.org/files/Disclosure2014.pdf http://www.cdp.net/en/guidance/guidance-for-companies#8b7fadc232e1bab9268512963662f431 http://www.cdp.net/en/guidance/guidance-for-companies#8b7fadc232e1bab9268512963662f431 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Table A2 – Mapping GRI and ICMM, and explanatory footnotes for ICMM members reporting to GRI Element ICMM GRI 1) Interactions with water Narrative 1.1 What are the company’s main: a. water activities? b. water sources used for withdrawal? c. consumptive water uses? d. water discharges? 303-1a Metrics 1.2 Present the following volumes (in megalitres) aggregated for all sites: a. Operational water withdrawal by source type (surface water, groundwater, seawater and third party water) and water quality category (high and low). b. OMW withdrawal by water quality category (high and low). 303-3a, 303-3c c. Total discharge by destination type (surface water, groundwater, seawater and to third parties) and water quality (high and low). 303-4a, 303-4b d. Total consumption. 303-5a 1.3 Present the following volumes (in megalitres) aggregated for all sites situated in water stressed areas: a. Operational water withdrawal by source type (surface water, groundwater, seawater and third party water) and water quality category (high and low). b. Other managed water withdrawal by water quality category (high and low). 303-3b c. Total discharge by destination type (surface water, groundwater, seawater and to third parties) and water quality (high and low). 303-4c d. Total consumption. 303-5b 2) Water challenges and opportunities Narrative 2.1 Overall, how material is water to business value and performance? 2.2 What are the material water risks or challenges facing the company? 303-1a 2.3 Does the company hold significant operations in water stressed areas? 2.4 Has the company had any material regulatory non-compliances relating to the quality of its discharges? If yes, briefly describe. 303-4d iii 2.5 What water opportunities are available to the company? 303-1a Metrics 2.6 Provide the proportion of sites (as an absolute number or a percentage) located in water stressed areas. 3) Commitment and response Narrative 3.1 How does the company integrate water into business strategy and leadership? 3.2 What are the company’s approach and commitments to water stewardship? 3.3 How does the company promote stakeholder engagement, and with whom? 3.4 How does the company identify and manage material water risks and realise opportunities? Including risks associated with: a. Water quality? b. Exposure to water stress? c. Climate change? 3.5 Does the company set water performance targets? If so, describe what targets are set and why. If not, outline why not 303-1b 303-1c 303-1d 303-2a 303-4d 2.4.2 Include any relevant case studies to illustrate Metrics 3.6 Present operational water reuse/recycle volumes for: a. All sites (as an aggregated total). b. For all sites situated in water stressed areas (as an aggregated total). Appendix A 77 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition ICMM Standardised Reporting Metrics Metric Source/Destination/Type Volume of Water by Quality High (ML) Low (ML) Total (ML) All sites Operational water withdrawal Surface Water (303-3-c-i) (303-3-c-ii) (303-3-a-i) Groundwater (303-3-c-i) (303-3-c-ii) (303-3-a-ii) Seawater (303-3-c-i) (303-3-c-ii) (303-3-a-iii) Third-Party Water (303-3-c-i) (303-3-c-ii) (303-3-a-v) Total (303-3-c-i) (303-3-c-ii) (303-3-a) Other Managed Water withdrawal (303-3-a) Total Discharge1 Surface Water (303-4-a-i) Groundwater (303-4-a-ii) Seawater (303-4-a-iii) Supply to Third Party (303-4-a-iv) Total (303-4-b-i) (303-4-b-ii) (303-4-a) Total consumption1 (303-5-a) Operational water reuse/recycle Operational water use (recommended only) Change in storage (delta storage) (recommended only) (303-5-c) Sites situated in water stressed areas Operational water withdrawal Surface Water (303-3-c-i) (303-3-c-ii) (303-3-b-i) Groundwater (303-3-c-i) (303-3-c-ii) (303-3-b-ii) Seawater (303-3-c-i) (303-3-c-ii) (303-3-b-iii) Third-Party Water (303-3-c-i) (303-3-c-ii) (303-3-b-v) Total Withdrawal (303-3-b) Other Managed Water withdrawal Total Discharge1 Surface Water Groundwater Seawater Supply to Third Party Total (303-4-c-i) (303-4-c-ii) (303-4c) Total consumption1 (303 – 5b) Operational water reuse/recycle Operational water use (recommended only) Change in storage (delta storage) (recommended only) Note: 1 includes ICMM operational water and other managedwater quality, due to the nature of the industry’s operational activities, is well recognised. Work continues to manage this risk by improving operational practices and closure planning; harnessing innovations in water treatment technologies, real-time monitoring systems and data solutions; and building trust through community participatory monitoring programmes. However, the global challenge of deteriorating water qualities and the rapid need to build climate resilience, also brings opportunities for mining and metals operations to work collectively with catchment stakeholders to develop circular water management solutions to reduce pressure on freshwater resources.7 In recognition of the importance of water reporting for the mining and metals industry, the ICMM Water Stewardship: Position Statement 8 includes a commitment to all members to ‘apply strong and transparent corporate water governance’, including to ‘publicly report company water performance, material risks, opportunities and management response using consistent industry metrics and recognised approaches’. This guidance supports members in achieving this commitment in the following ways: — Outlines the minimum reporting commitments for ICMM member companies to promote transparency through consistent and relevant reporting on the industry’s water interactions, risks, opportunities, and the range of activities being undertaken to progress water management practices, manage risk, support stewardship initiatives, engage stakeholders and deliver improved catchment outcomes. — Defines an appropriate set of consistent water reporting metrics for the mining and metals industry, which are based on the Minerals Council of Australia’s (MCA’s) Water Accounting Framework for the Mineral Industry (WAF),9 to drive consistent metrics that are benchmarkable at all scales. — Provides practical supporting guidance around meeting the minimum reporting commitments in order to continually build capacity within the industry and enhance understanding by external stakeholders. 1.2 ICMM water reporting commitments 1.2.1 What are ICMM water reporting commitments? The ICMM’s minimum commitments for annual water reporting are outlined in Table 1. This information should be made publicly available eg on company websites or in company reports. Aligned to external guidance, eg the CEO Water Mandate Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines, the commitments are structured to generate an overview narrative, supported by consistent metrics, which describe a company’s water interactions, risks and opportunities, and management response. Importantly, the narrative allows the context and meaning of the supporting metrics to be clearly articulated, as the magnitude and significance of these metrics may vary substantially year-on-year and between companies due to the unique nature of the industry’s activities and water handling requirements (see Sections 1.1 and 3.2). 9Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 01 ICMM Water Reporting Commitments https://www.icmm.com/en-gb/about-us/member-requirements/position-statements/water-stewardship https://www.icmm.com/en-gb/about-us/member-requirements/position-statements/water-stewardship 02 0301 Table 1 – ICMM minimum reporting commitments Element Minimum Reporting Commitment 1) Interactions with water Narrative 1.1 What are the company’s main: a. Water activities? b. Water sources used for withdrawal? c. Consumptive water uses? d. Water discharges? Metrics 1.2 Present the following volumes (in megalitres) aggregated for all sites: a. Operational water withdrawal by source type (surface water, groundwater, seawater and third-party water) and water quality category (high and low). b. Other managed water (OMW) withdrawal by water quality category (high and low). c. Total discharge by destination type (surface water, groundwater, seawater and to third parties) and water quality (high and low). d. Total consumption. 1.3 Present the following volumes (in megalitres) aggregated for all sites situated in water stressed areas: a. Operational water withdrawal by source type (surface water, groundwater, seawater and third-party water) and water quality category (high and low). b. OMW withdrawal by water quality category (high and low). c. Total discharge by destination type (surface water, groundwater, seawater and to third parties) and water quality (high and low). d. Total consumption. 2) Water risks and opportunities Narrative 2.1 Overall, how material is water to business value and performance? 2.2 What are the material water risks or challenges facing the company? 2.3 Does the company hold significant operations in water-stressed areas? 2.4 Has the company had any material regulatory non-compliances relating to the quality of its discharges? If yes, briefly describe. 2.5 What water opportunities are available to the company? Metrics 2.6 Present the proportion of sites (as an absolute number or a percentage) located in water stressed areas. 3) Commitment and response Narrative 3.1 How does the company integrate water into business strategy and leadership? 3.2 What are the company’s approach and commitments to water stewardship? 3.3 How does the company promote stakeholder engagement, and with whom? 3.4 How does the company identify and manage water risks and realise opportunities? Including those associated with: a. Water quality? b. Exposure to water stress? c. Climate change? 3.5 Does the company set water performance targets? If so, describe what targets are set and why. If not, outline why not. Include any relevant case studies to illustrate. Metrics 3.6 Present operational water reuse/recycle volumes (in megalitres) for: a. All sites (as an aggregated total). b. For all sites situated in water-stressed areas (as an aggregated total). Note: The template provided in Table 4 should be used for reporting the required metrics to promote consistency. 10Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 01 ICMM Water Reporting Commitments 02 0301 1.2.2 How do ICMM water reporting commitments relate to other reporting platforms? To promote consistency and comparability, the water reporting metrics and disclosure statements outlined in the minimum reporting commitments build directly on external reporting guidance and definitions, including those of CEO Water Mandate,10 GRI11 and CDP12 as well as the MCA’s WAF. These are referenced throughout this document. The relationship between the ICMM water reporting metrics and those of key external disclosure platforms is summarised in Appendix A. Guidance for mapping between the ICMM water reporting metrics and MCA’s WAF is provided in Appendix B. 11Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 01 ICMM Water Reporting Commitments Section 2 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 2.1 Overview The purpose of this section is to provide guidance around internal water accounting and assessment at the site level, which is the foundational building block of accurate external reporting and corporate transparency. A defined and consistent approach to site level accounting and assessment is fundamental to adequately capturing the diverse range of operational contexts, water practices, risks, opportunities and management responses that occur across a company’s operational portfolio in a comparable format which can be analysed. This may be achieved in a variety of ways. However, this section outlines the key points to consider for generating simple and comparable site level datasets tailored to meeting the minimum reporting commitments, which can be aggregated at any scale – asset, regional or company. This includes a consistent set of water reporting metrics, which arewater ICMM Standardised footnotes for reporting to GRI STD 303 GRI Metric GRI reference Suggested explanatory ICMM footnote Withdrawal (303-3-a) (303-3-b) and all related Aligned with ICMM definitions, the following two metrics are used to appropriately describe water withdrawal in the mining and metals context: — Operational water: All water which enters the operational water system used to meet the operational water demand (and is available for use). — OMW: Water which is actively managed (eg physical pumped, actively treated, or has material consumptive losses) without intent to meet the operational water demand. Water quality (303-3-c-i) (303-3-c-ii) (303-4-b-i) (303-4-b-ii) Aligned with ICMM definitions, water is accounted and reported by the following two categories: — High quality water – high socio-environmental value with multiple potential beneficial uses and/or receptors. — Low quality water – lower socio-environmental value as the poorer quality may restrict potential suitability for use by a wide range of other users/receptors, excluding adapted ecosystem function. The categories have been defined to maximise transparency in the mining and metals context; and are based on a range of physical-chemical- biological water characteristics appropriate to the local context. Produced water (303-3-a-iv) (303-3-b-iv) Aligned with ICMM definitions, water entrained in ore extracted from the ground is reported as a withdrawal from groundwater (not as produced water). Consumption (303-5-a) (303-5-b) Aligned with ICMM definitions, consumption is the sum of water removed by evaporation, entrainment (in product and waste) and other losses. To maximise transparency, consumption does not include any change in storage (delta storage), which may be reported as a separate value. Change in storage (303-5-c) Aligned with ICMM recommendations, the change in storage volume is reported to allow complete transparency of the overall water balance; and does not indicate an associated water-related impact. Key GRI required metrics Direct correspondence between ICMM and GRI requirements Indirect correspondence – use ICMM standardised footnote Outside scope of ICMM minimum reporting commitments ICMM standardised footnotes Water withdrawal Water quality Produced water Consumption Change in storage Appendix A 78 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Table A3 – Mapping of GRI disclosures 303-3, 303-4 and 303-5 against ICMM metrics This is an example template taken from GRI 303: Water and Effluents 2018 and offers an example of how to present information for Disclosures 303-3, 303-4, and 303-5. The example template has been mapped against the ICMM metrics using the key provided. Water withdrawal (303-3) All areas Areas with water stress Water withdrawal by source Surface water (total) ML (303-3-a-i) ML (303-3-b-i) Freshwater (≤1,000 mg/L TDS) ML (303-3-c-i) ML (303-3-c-i) Other Water (>1,000 mg/L TDS) ML (303-3-c-ii) ML (303-3-c-ii) Groundwater (total) ML (303-3-a-ii) ML (303-3-b-ii) Freshwater (≤1,000 mg/L TDS) ML (303-3-c-i) ML (303-3-c-i) Other Water (>1,000 mg/L TDS) ML (303-3-c-ii) ML (303-3-c-ii) Seawater (total) ML (303-3-a-iii) ML (303-3-b-iii) Freshwater (≤1,000 mg/L TDS) ML (303-3-c-i) ML (303-3-c-i) Other Water (>1,000 mg/L Total Dissolved Solids) ML (303-3-c-ii) ML (303-3-c-ii) Produced water (total) ML (303-3-a-iv) ML (303-3-b-iv) Freshwater (≤1,000 mg/L TDS) ML (303-3-c-i) ML (303-3-c-i) Other Water (>1,000 mg/L TDS) ML (303-3-c-ii) ML (303-3-c-ii) Third-Party Water (total) ML (303-3-a-v) ML (303-3-b-v) Freshwater (≤1,000 mg/L TDS) ML (303-3-c-i) ML (303-3-c-i) Other Water (>1,000 mg/L TDS) ML (303-3-c-ii) ML (303-3-c-ii) Total Third-Party Water withdrawal by withdrawal source Surface Water ML (303-3-b-v) Groundwater ML (303-3-b-v) Seawater ML (303-3-b-v) Produced Water ML (303-3-b-v) Total water withdrawal Surface Water (total) + Groundwater (total) + Seawater (total) + Produced Water (total) + Third-Party Water (total) ML (303-3-a) ML (303-3-b) Water discharge (303-4) All areas Areas with water stress Water discharge by destination Surface Water ML (303-4-a-i) Groundwater ML (303-4-a-ii) Seawater ML (303-4-a-iii) Third-Party Water (total) ML (303-4-a-iv) Third-Party Water sent for use to other organisations ML (303-4-a-iv) Total water discharge Surface Water + Groundwater + Seawater + Third-Party Water (total) ML (303-4-a) ML (303-4-c) Water discharge by freshwater and other water Freshwater (≤ 1,000 mg/L TDS) ML (303-4-b-i) ML (303-4-c-i) Other water (> 1,000 mg/L TDS) ML (303-4-b-ii) ML (303-4-c-ii) Water discharge by level of treatment Note that this is recommended, but not required No treatment ML (clause 2.4.2) Treatment level [Provide the title for treatment level] ML (clause 2.4.2) Treatment level [Provide the title for treatment level] ML (clause 2.4.2) Treatment level [Provide the title for treatment level] ML (clause 2.4.2) Water consumption (303-5) All areas Areas with water stress Water consumption Total water consumption ML (303-5-a) ML (303-5-b) Change in water storage, if water storage has been identified as having a significant water-related impact ML (303-5-c) Key for mapping against ICMM metrics GRI required metrics Direct correspondence between ICMM and GRI requirements. Indirect correspondence – use ICMM explanatory footnote. Outside the scope of ICMM minimum reporting commitments. GRI recommended metrics Indirect correspondence – outside ICMM scope but can be derived from approach/metrics. Outside scope of ICMM minimum reporting commitments. ICMM standardised footnotes Water withdrawal Water quality Produced water Consumption Change in storage Appendix A 79 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide Table A4 – Mapping of GRI facility-level information against ICMM metrics This is an example template taken from GRI 303: Water and Effluents 2018 and provides an example of how to present information on facilities located in areas with water stress as per the reporting recommendations specified in Disclosures 303-3 (clause 2.2.1) and 303-5 (clause 2.5.1). The example template has been mapped against the ICMM metrics using the key provided. Facilities in areas with water stress Facility A Facility B [Facility X] Water withdrawal (clause 2.2.1) Surface Water ML ML ML Groundwater ML ML ML Seawater ML ML ML Produced Water ML ML ML Third-Party Water ML ML ML Water consumption (clause 2.5.1) Total water consumption ML ML ML Table A5 – Mapping GRI supply chain information against ICMM metrics This is an example taken from GRI 303: Water and Effluents 2018 of how to present information on the organisation’s suppliers as per the reporting recommendations specified in Disclosures 303-3 (clause 2.2.2), 303-4 (clause 2.4.3), and 303-5 (clause 2.5.2). The example template has been mapped against the ICMM metrics using the key provided. Water withdrawal (clause 2.2.2) Total water withdrawal in megaliters by suppliers with significant water-related impacts in areas with water stress ML Water discharge (clause 2.4.3) Percentage of suppliers with significant water-related impacts from water discharge that have set minimum standards for the quality of their effluent discharge % Water consumption (clause 2.5.2) Total water consumption in megaliters by suppliers with significant water-related impacts in areas with water stress ML Key for mapping against ICMM metrics GRI required metrics Direct correspondence between ICMM and GRI requirements. Indirect correspondence – use ICMM explanatory footnote. Outside the scope of ICMM minimum reporting commitments. GRI recommended metrics Indirect correspondence – outside ICMM scope but can be derived from approach/metrics. Outside scope of ICMM minimum reporting commitments. ICMM standardisedfootnotes Water withdrawal Water quality Produced water Consumption Change in storage Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Table B1 - Summary of ICMM and WAF metrics ICMM Metric ICMM Definition WAF Metric Operational Water Withdrawal Water that enters the operational water system used to meet the operational water demand. WAF Inputs – from surface water, groundwater, seawater and third parties. OMW Withdrawal Water that is actively managed (eg physically pumped, actively treated or has material consumptive losses) without intent to supply the operational water demand. WAF Diversion Inputs – from surface water, groundwater, seawater and third parties. Total Discharge Water that is released to the water environment (surface water, groundwater or seawater) or to a third party, including operational water and OMW. Sum of: — WAF Outputs – to surface water, groundwater, seawater and third parties. — WAF Diversion Outputs – to surface water, groundwater, seawater and third parties. Total Consumption Water that is removed by evaporation, entrainment (in product or waste) or other losses, and not released back to surface water, groundwater, seawater or a third party (including operational water and OMW). Sum of: — WAF Outputs – to other (evaporation, entrainment and task loss). — WAF Diversion Outputs – to other (evaporation, entrainment and task loss). Reuse/Recycle Water that has been used in an operational task and is recovered and used again in an operational task, either without treatment (reuse) or with treatment (recycle). Sum of: — Total volume of reused water (untreated worked water) — Total volume of recycled water (treated worked water) Operational Water Use (recommended for reporting) The volume of operational water used in operational tasks. Total of all flows to tasks Delta Storage (∆Storage) (recommended for reporting) The net change (positive or negative) in the volume of water in storage (operational water and OMW) during the reporting period. The net change (positive or negative) in the volume of water in storage for input-output flows and diversion flows during the reporting period. Note: ICMM OMW is equivalent to WAF diversions. Box B1 Points to note Appendix B: Mapping ICMM metrics with MCA’s WAF ICMM reporting metrics are based on WAF metrics and water quality categories. The key difference between these systems is perspective. WAF is a bespoke mine site water accounting tool, which is based on an input- output model (see box below). The same basic accounting approach, definitions and metrics are used by ICMM. However, the metrics and quality categories have been renamed and simplified to describe water dependency and performance for the purpose of external reporting (see Section 2.4). Direct mappings between WAF and ICMM metrics and quality categories are summarised in the following tables. Brief overview: MCA WAF A bespoke water accounting framework for the mining and metals industry. It comprises two key components that are directly relevant to generating ICMM water reporting metrics, as outlined below: 1. Input-Output Statement: This describes water flows (and associated quality) between the environment and the operational facility, including: - Inputs: Water received by the operational facility for intended use by the operational facility. - Outputs: Water removed from the operational facility after it has been through a task, treated or stored for use by the operational facility. - Diversions: Water that flows from an input to an output without being utilised by the operational facility. 2. Statement of Operational Efficiencies: This describes the proportion of reused and recycled flows in relation to the total flows to tasks Output Divert Surrounding community and environment Each input has a quality category Each output has a quality category Operational Facility Store Task Treat (if any) Input An operational example of using WAF metrics to generate ICMM reporting metrics is provided in Appendix C. Table B1 – Summary of ICMM and WAF metrics Table B2 – Mapping WAF input-output statement to ICMM reporting metrics (inputs – withdrawal) Table B3 – Mapping WAF input-output statement to ICMM reporting metrics (outputs – discharge and consumption) Table B4 – Mapping WAF statement of operational efficiencies to ICMM reporting metrics Table B5 – Mapping WAF and ICMM water quality categories Appendix B 81 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Table B2 – Mapping WAF input-output statement to ICMM reporting metrics (inputs and withdrawal) WAF Input-Output Statement ICMM Water Reporting Metrics Input- Output Source/ Destination Inputs/ Outputs Volume of Water by Quality Category Number (ML) Metric Source Volume of Water by Quality (ML) 1 2 3 Total High Low Total Input Surface Water Precipitation and Run-off Operational Water Withdrawal Surface WaterRivers and Creeks External Surface Water Storages Groundwater Aquifer Interception GroundwaterBorefields Entrainment Seawater Estuary Seawater Sea/Ocean Third Party Supply Contract/Municipal Third Party Water Waste Water Total Inputs Total Op Water Diversion Input Surface Water Discharge OMW Withdrawal Environmental Flows Groundwater Aquifer Interception Borefields Entrainment Seawater Estuary Sea/Ocean Third-Party Supply Contract/Municipal Waste Water Total Diversion Inputs Total OMW Notes: For mapping water quality categories: ICMM High = WAF Category 1 + WAF Category 2; and ICMM Low = WAF Category 3 (see Table B5) Appendix B 82 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Table B3 – Mapping WAF input-output statement to ICMM reporting metrics (outputs, discharge and consumption) WAF Input-Output Statement ICMM Water Reporting Metrics Input- Output Source/ Destination Inputs/ Outputs Volume of Water by Quality Category Number (ML) Metric Source Volume of Water by Quality (ML) 1 2 3 Total High Low Total Output Surface Water Discharge Operational (Op) Water Discharge Surface Water Environmental Flows Groundwater Seepage Groundwater Reinjection Seawater Discharge to Estuary Seawater Discharge to Ocean Supply to Third Party Supply to Third Party Total Op Water Discharge Other Evaporation Operational Water Consumption Total Op Water ConsumptionEntrainment Task Loss Total Outputs Diversion Output Surface Water Discharge OMW Discharge Surface Water Environmental Flows Groundwater Seepage Groundwater Reinjection Seawater Discharge to Estuary Seawater Discharge to Ocean Supply to Third Party Supply to Third Party Total Diversion Outputs Total OMW Discharge Notes: For mapping water quality categories: ICMM High = WAF Category 1 + WAF Category 2; and ICMM Low = Category 3 (see Table B5) OMW Consumption Total OMW Consumption Total Discharge (Op Water + OMW) Total Consumption (Op Water + OMW) Appendix B 83 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd EditionWater Reporting: Good Practice Guide Table B4 – Mapping WAF statement of operational efficiencies to ICMM reporting metrics WAF Operational Efficiencies ICMM reporting metrics Total of all flows to tasks (ML/a) Corresponds to operational water use Total inflows to mixed water store (ML/a) Total untreated worked water flows to tasks (ML/a) Sum of untreated and treated worked water flows to tasks corresponds to operational reuse/recycle volume Reuse efficiency (%) Total treated worked water flows to tasks (ML/a) Recycle efficiency (%) Table B5 – Mapping WAF and ICMM water quality categories WAF water quality categories ICMM water quality categories Category 1 Water of a high quality and may require minimal and inexpensive treatment (eg disinfection and pond settlement of solids) to raise the quality to appropriate drinking water standards. High QualityHigh with multiple potential beneficial uses and/or receptors – including water supply for drinking, agriculture, food production, amenity value, industrial uses and ecosystem function. Category 2 Water of a medium quality with characteristics covering a range of values. Moderate treatment, such as disinfection, neutralisation, removal of solids and chemicals, would be required to meet applicable drinking water standards. Category 3 Water of low quality with characteristics including high values of TDS, elevated levels of dissolved metals or extreme pH levels. Significant treatment would be required to meet applicable drinking water standards. Low Quality Low with reduced suitably for use by a wide range of users/receptors – excluding potential industrial uses and adapted ecosystem function. Note: ICMM and WAF water quality categories are based on the theoretical level of treatment required to raise the quality of the water to drinking water standards; and use the same classification principles (see Section 2.4.2 and Figure 3) Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Site level information provides the fundamental building blocks of accurate and consistent external reporting. This appendix provides an operational example of site water accounting and assessment for the purpose of meeting the ICMM minimum reporting commitments for a copper mining site in Northern Chile. It illustrates a five-step approach to compiling the site level information required to support accurate and consistent external reporting to the ICMM minimum requirements: Appendix C: Operational Example of Site Water Accounting and Assessment Step 1: Understanding the site and local water context. Step 2: Summarising site details, context and boundaries. Step 3: Site water accounting and ICMM reporting metrics. Step 4: Summarising site risk, opportunity and response. Step 5: Summarising site information for aggregation. This example follows the illustrative approach outlined in Section 2.5 for assessing and summarising context, risk, opportunity and response. This illustrative approach is presented for guidance only; and should not constrain or limit the approach used by individual companies, nor be used as a template for auditing purposes. Further, this example demonstrates an internal assessment and data collation process which can contain commercially sensitive information and is not intended for external disclosure. The example presented is based on a diverse range of material compiled from different sources, including operating sites, publicly available information and broader experience of global mine water management practices. Thus, the operation presented does not represent any individual site or mining company. Operational example: Chilean copper mine site Step 1: Understanding the site and local water context 1a) Site location and catchment setting Site setting and climatic conditions — The case study site is a copper operation situated in the foothills of the Andes Mountains, approximately 1,000 m above sea level and around 35 km inland from the coast in Northern Chile. — The landscape in the area typically comprises dry, rocky terrain with incised valleys and sparse natural vegetation. In upland areas, the valleys form deep ravines with steep sides. However, nearer to the coast, the topography becomes more subdued as the valleys become wider with increasing thicknesses of sandy alluvial deposits which create flat valley bottoms. — The area has a semi-arid interior climate and is situated in a transitional zone between the desert climate of the Atacama to the north and the Mediterranean climate of Central Chile to the south. — The average annual temperature is 17C, characterised by warm summers – with an average daily range of 12–28C in January – and mild winters – with an average daily range of 6–17C in June. — Annual total evapotranspiration rates are high at 2,300 mm/a, with low atmospheric humidity and cloud cover. — Annual precipitation is very low, with a long-term average of 140 mm/a for the site, and strongly seasonal, with the majority – 85 per cent – of annual precipitation occurring as rainfall between May and August. Precipitation associated with summer storms also occurs, especially in the mountainous areas. — Annual precipitation is strongly influenced by El Niño and La Niña events. For example, the area may receive two to three times the average precipitation during El Niño years, and only half, or less, during La Niña years. — Natural run-off rates within the catchment are typically high, at 85–90 per cent, due to the occurrence of thin soil cover, typically low permeability bedrock and steep topography. Catchment setting and water resources — The site is situated near the upgradient boundary of a catchment, of approximately 10,000 km2, which rises in the high Andean Mountains and discharges to the Pacific Ocean. — Surface water flow is typically ephemeral (non- permanent) and shows a flashy response to rainfall, especially within the upper catchment. The highest flows typically occur from November to January, associated with snow and ice melt in the Andes. Localised areas of semi-permanent flow may also occur due to domestic and/or mining discharges, and groundwater springs. — Surface water flow becomes more permanent with increasing distance downstream towards the coast. Water supply dams have been installed on the major river. — Groundwater potential within the valley floor areas is moderate, associated with the occurrence of saturated alluvial fill. However, groundwater potential increases significantly in the lower section of the major river, where the saturated alluvial fill forms a regionally important aquifer. — Groundwater potential away from the valley floor areas is variable. Locally important aquifers may occur where intense fracturing of the bedrock creates secondary permeability. However, these aquifers are highly dependent on rainfall recharge to maintain sustainable yields. — Ambient water quality (surface water and groundwater) is typically good. However, elevated levels of electrical conductivity (EC), sulphates and metals (aluminium, arsenic, copper, iron and manganese) do occur, associated with both natural and anthropogenic (mining) sources. — In addition, surface water quality may be locally impacted by discharges from industrial sites and sewage treatment plants. Acid and metalliferous drainage (AMD) associated with abandoned mine workings also occurs in some areas of the catchment. Land use — Mining and agriculture are the dominant land uses in the catchment. — There are several established mining districts within the catchment which have extensive historic workings, active operations and growth potential. Mining in this area produces copper, gold, silver, manganese and arsenic. — Agriculture is limited to the flat valley floor areas, which have been cultivated to produce grapes for wine and pisco, avocados, citrus, papayas and olives. These crops are dependent on the water supply associated with the surface water channels and associated valley fill aquifers. Agricultural production is supported by an extensive system of irrigation channels. 1b) Operational Overview — The operation comprises an open pit and a processing plant which produces copper concentrate (65 ktpa). — The supergene (sulphide) portion of the copper porphyry deposit is excavated in an open pit. The extracted ore is crushed and milled; and then concentrated using flotation, sorting and thickening techniques. Appendix C 85 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Wellfield #1 Wellfield #2 Supply to local community Supply to adjacent mine Task loss Water entrained product%Oremoisture % Dust suppression Process water reservoir TSF Freshwater reservoir Treatment plant Thickening plant Processing plant Operational water system boundary 7,275 2,632 63 19 116 538 459 654 3,833 12,060 1,433 8,337 1,524 426 16,885 24,723 24,72341,608 648 Flows in ML/a 2,823 6,440 Water entrained in tailings % Dewatering of open pit Evaporation Wetland support 712554 Rainfall run-o Seepage to groundwater Figure C1: Site water balance — The copper concentrate slurry is transported by road to a port facility. The tailings are thickened and pumped to a TSF. Operational water supply and third-party allocations — A supply borefield situated within the catchment, but at distance from the site, is used to meet the operational water demand. The borefield abstracts groundwater from the alluvial aquifer in the lower section of the major river. The water is pumped via a series of tanks and pumping stations to the mine site. The water is of high quality. Operational water activities — A simplified water flowchart is provided in Figure C1. — Water use across the site has been configured to maximise the recovery and reuse, minimise losses and reduce the need for additional ‘make-up’ water (ie the volume of new water required to meet the operational water demand). — Water abstracted from the supply borefield is pumped to the freshwater reservoir. — Water in the freshwater reservoir is used to: top up the process water dam; supply the processing plant; and control dust. — The process water dam is used to supply the processing plant and for dust control purposes. The process water dam receives new water from the freshwater reservoir, dewater from the pit, and reclaimed water from the TSF (decant and drain 1). — The ore feed to the processing plant contains entrained water. Water is also entrained in the copper concentrate product leaving the processing plant (8 per cent water). — Tailings slurry (35 per cent solids) is pumped from the processing plant to the thickener plant, where the tailings are thickened (65 per cent solids) and then pumped to the TSF. — Water recovered in the thickening plant is treated and used to supply the processing plant. The processing plant also receives water recovered from the TSF (drain 2). — The operation is essentially a zero discharge site, however, small amounts of seepage to groundwater from the TSF are expected (and modelled). — Water meters are installed to monitor operational flows across the site and are used to maintain an up-to-date water balance. Measurements of daily rainfall are made and a calibrated hydrological model is used to simulate TSF inputs and outputs, including rainfall-run-off (from disturbed ground), groundwater seepage and evaporation. Monitoring of ore moisture content is undertaken for processing purposes. — Water abstracted from the supply borefield and pumped to the mine site is also used to supply third parties including local residents. — Dewatering of the open pit is undertaken to maintain safe working conditions using a system of ex-pit wells and in-pit sumps. The dewater is used for process supply; and a component of the dewater derived from the ex-pit wells is used to maintain local wetland function. The dewater typically shows elevated levels of EC, sulphates and metals (TDS 2,200 mg/L). 1c) Water stress, risk, opportunity and management response Water risk assessment tool results — Two publicly available water risk assessment tools (WWF Water Risk Filter and WRI Aqueduct Water Risk Atlas) have been used to provide a high-level screen of the water risks associated with the catchment. The results are outlined in Tables C1 and C2 below. They provide an important input to the detailed site level risk and opportunity assessment process (see Step 4). Water stress and security — The above water risk assessment tools indicate that water scarcity and stress present the most significant risk in this catchment. Additional local site knowledge is provided below around water stress, water security and the site’s management response. — In summary, freshwater resources in the catchment are scarce. Water stress is high and increasing due to limited resources and rising demands, compounded by the impacts of climate change. Water scarcity — Water resources in the catchment are highly dependent on rainfall to maintain surface water flows and groundwater recharge. However, long- term monitoring in the lower catchment shows a marked decline in annual precipitation since the early 20th century. Despite the influence of El Niño and La Niña cycles, the 30-year moving average (baseline) in the area has declined significantly over this period. This trend suggests advancing aridity, resulting in increasing water scarcity. — As a result, surface water flows in the major river have declined and many dams in the area show water levels significantly below (> 90 per cent) their design capacity. — In addition, groundwater levels within the main regional aquifers in the catchment show evidence of decline. Appendix C 86 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Water use and security — In northern Chile water demand typically exceeds availability. The greatest deficit is in the north, and gradually decreases southwards as precipitation increases with the changing climate zones. — Within the catchment, the main water consumers are agriculture (60 per cent), industry (20 per cent), mining (15 per cent) and potable water supply (5 per cent). Water demands are increasing due to expanding agriculture, new mining projects, industrial growth and increasing urbanisation. For example, urban water consumption within the major cities rose 25 per cent in 2002–2012. — Within the last 10 years, water resources (surface and groundwater) within much of the catchment have been declared as exhausted (or depleted) with restrictions placed on the allocation of new water rights. — Further, sustainability assessments of one of the main aquifers in the catchment suggest that the level of currently allocated consumptive water rights substantially exceeds the sustainable supply level. — The potential for conflict between water uses and users is well established and escalating with on- going conflicts between the farming community, civil society groups and mining companies. Climate Change — Aligned with the company’s wider approach, a range of climate transition and physical scenarios are used to understand the potential impact of climate change over different time horizons. They indicate that current water stress and scarcity challenges will likely increase for the following reasons: - A 2–4C temperature increase. - An increase in the number of hot and windy days in summer, which is likely to increase evapotranspiration rates. - A decrease in the number of cold days in winter, which is likely to reduce the occurrence of frost and snow, associated meltwater run-off and groundwater recharge. - A decrease in the occurrence of extreme rainfall events during April to August, which may reduce the risk of flood events Management response — The site has an Integrated Water Management Plan which sets the strategic direction for water management, aligned with the company’s corporate water strategy and water targets. The plan: — Describes water use, monitoring, management and reporting commitments across all aspects of the operation, and specifies water-related roles and responsibilities. — Outlines context specific water targets for the site (aligned with company strategies and targets), including 5 year targets to: - Develop alternative seawater and low quality water (eg industrial waste water) withdrawal sources to reduce relianceon groundwater withdrawal from the supply borefield. - Implement improved treatment technologies to improve water quality and reuse rates. — Includes water risk, opportunity register and action plan which is reviewed and revised on an annual basis, with both operational and corporate input. — Outlines internal and external communication policies to disseminate water-related information. — Details current water improvement projects and actions, as summarised below. a. Optimise internal water efficiency by: - Trialling a new flocculant and improving monitoring of solids monitoring equipment to improve recovery and reuse within the thickening plant. - Using new technologies to upgrade on-site water treatment facilities and increase the water reuse. b. Reduce dependency on groundwater by developing alternative water supply options, including the desalination of seawater and/or the treatment of industrial or municipal waste water. c. Secure water rights (if required) associated with water derived from the mine workings, due to current regulatory uncertainty. d. Undertake collective action projects to address shared water challenges in the wider catchment, including: - Expanding and improving the rural drinking water system. Table C1 – WWF Water Risk Filter tool assessment summary Water Risk Assessment Summary (Mining Filter) Operational Risk Basin Risk Physical Risk 4.2 Quantity – scarcity 4.5 Quantity – flooding 4.8 Water quality 3.0 Ecosystem services status 1.2 Regulatory Risk 2.7 Enabling environment (policy and laws) 3.3 Institutions and governance 2.5 Management instruments 1.9 Infrastructure and finance 3.6 Reputational Risk 3.0 Cultural importance 3.0 Biodiversity importance 3.0 Media scrutiny 3.1 Conflict 3.0 OVERALL Basin Risk Not completed 3.8 Notes: Scores are in risk rank categories: 1 (very limited); 2 (limited); 3 (some); 4 (high); and 5 (very high). Filter applied for: Extractives Industries I (low grade ore, precious metals, diamonds, copper, nickel, tar sands).See WWF Water Risk Filter website for additional guidance (waterriskfilter.panda.org/). Assessment made in March 2021. - Contributing funding, data and technical expertise to improve understanding of the local catchment dynamics by constructing new surface water gauging and rainwater monitoring stations with telemetry (remote data capture). - Supporting an NGO-led scoping study to improve the capacity and efficiency of rainwater capture, channelling and dam storage. - Proactively participating in a multi-stakeholder catchment initiative to monitor and remediate elevated arsenic levels which occur in hot spots across the catchment (unrelated to the site). - Actively working with government and other catchment stakeholders to develop a catchment water plan, to help manage and reduce the potential for conflict between catchment water users. Appendix C 87 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Table C2 – WRI Aqueduct Water Risk Atlas assessment summary Risk Type Risk Indicator Score Result CURRENT Overall water risk (NO WEIGHTINGS) 3–4 high risk Physical Risks Quantity Overall 4–5 Extremely high risk 1. Water stress >80% Extremely high 2. Water depletion 50–75% High 3. Interannual variability >1.00 Extremely high 4. Seasonal variability 0.66–1.00 Medium – high 5. Groundwater table decline Insignificant trend 6. Riverine flood risk 1–2 in 1,000 Low – medium 7. Coastal flood risk 0–9 in 1m Low 8. Drought risk 0.4–0.6 Medium Physical Risks Quality Overall 0–1 Low risk 9. Untreated connected wastewater 80% Extremely high Business as usual >80% Extremely high Optimistic 40–80% High 2040 Pessimistic >80% Extremely high Business as usual >80% Extremely high Optimistic >80% Extremely high Notes: Indicator scores are converted to risk rank categories (low to extremely high). Assessment made in March 2021. Step 2: Summarising site details, context and boundaries Use the illustrative approached provided in Table 2 to summarise key site details, context and boundaries – as shown in Tables C3 and C4 below. Table C3 – Summary site details and context Statement Example Responses Summary Catchment(s) Catchment name (eg from global river basins as mapped in publicly available tools) Unnamed catchment, northern Chile Climatic Conditions — Arid or semi-arid environment — Moderate precipitation with distinct dry season — Moderate precipitation — Very high precipitation and/or frequent major storm events Arid or semi-arid environment Commodity Summarise commodity (eg aluminium, coal, copper, gold, iron ore, lithium, zinc) Copper Main Operational Water Activities — Cooling or drying processes — Dewatering — Discharge — Dust control — Flood control — Open pit mining — MAR — Mineral processing — Mineral separation — Mineral transportation — OMW flows — Sediment control — Solution mining — Surface water re-alignment — Tailings management — Underground mining — Waste management — Water treatment 1. Water supply 2. Mineral processing 3. Dust control Main Consumptive Water Uses — Evaporation (specify related activity) — Entrainment – product — Entrainment – waste — Other losses — Entrainment (waste) — Evaporation (from TSF and dust control) Water Treatment Activities — Biological reaction — Disinfection — Distillation — Electrodialysis — Flocculation/coagulation — Filtration — Precipitation — Reverse osmosis — Sedimentation — Flocculation/coagulation — Filtration Water Treatment Driver — Compliance — Environmental management — Improved operational efficiency — Operational water supply — Third-party supply provision — WASH services (amenities) Improved operational efficiency Discharge Quality Limit Types — Regulatory (external) — Recognised guidelines (external) — Self-determined (internal) — None None – no regulated discharges Appendix C 88 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Table C4 – Summary of site boundaries Boundary Summary Catchment Catchment boundary defined to include remote borefield used to supply the site water demand (and third parties); and the scope of collective action initiatives undertaken by the site to address shared water challenges. Operational Geographically defined to include all operational water activities (including remote borefield) and align with legal boundaries. Operational water supply system Conceptually determined to include all operational tasks (ie activities which require water) based on the site water balance (see Figure C1). - Discharges – aggregate all discharges with common characteristics (ie same quality and destination), add to the discharge column in orange. - Consumption – aggregate all consumption with common characteristics (ie same quality, and type where accounted), add to the consumption column in red. Note: In this example, consumption is calculated as the sum of the constituent losses (evaporation, entrainment and other losses). However, the balance equation can also be used to calculate consumption where change in storage values are known, as illustrated in Box C1. - Operational tasks – aggregate all tasks to the highest practical level following the recommended task aggregation typesprovided in Table C5, add to the task column in grey Note: The processing plant and thickening plant are aggregated into a single task as both are processing activities. - Water stores - Aggregate all operational water stores which only receive new water, add to the store column in blue and mark as the new water store. Repeat for other managed water stores (if present). - Aggregate all operational water stores which receive new and/or worked water, add to the store column in blue and mark as the mixed water store Notes: no aggregation of operational water stores required for this site. No other managed water stores are present at this site. - Treatment plants – aggregate all operational water treatment plants with common characteristics, add to the treatment column in purple. Repeat for other managed water treatment plants (if present). Notes: No other managed water treatment plants are present at this site. e. Add all internal flows (and volumes) between the components (stores, tasks and treatment plants). Colour the flows by water quality category and/ or as new water versus worked water to aid understanding. See Figure C3 Compile ICMM reporting metrics Use the simplified water accounting model (see Figure C3) to generate ICMM reporting metrics, using the template provided in Table 4 – as illustrated in Table C8. Calculate ICMM operational water reuse/recycle and operational use metrics Use the simplified water accounting model (see Figure C3) to calculate operational water reuse/reycle and operational use metrics, using the approach detailed in Table C9. Add these values to the metrics summary table. (Table C8) Step 3: Site water accounting and ICMM reporting metrics ICMM reporting metrics may be derived in the following two ways: Option 1: Develop a simplified water accounting model and ICMM reporting metrics based on the site water balance (see Figure C1). Option 2: Create ICMM reporting metrics directly from an existing WAF account. Option 1: Create ICMM reporting metrics from site water balance data Create a simplified water accounting model Create a simplified water accounting model based on the site water balance provided in Figure C1. The model is a schematic representation of all key water flows and components associated with the site. As outlined below, when creating the model all individual flows and components (ie stores, tasks and treatment plants) with common characteristics are aggregated to the highest practical level (see Table C5) and represented once within the model to provide the simplification. Use the site water balance (Figure C1) to follow the steps outlined below. a. Identify and classify all water inflows and outflows on the site water balance, including: - Operational water withdrawals – all water flows which enter the operational water system from surface water, groundwater, seawater or third- party sources, and highlight in green. - OMW withdrawals – water flows which are drawn from surface water, groundwater, seawater or third-party sources and actively managed by the site (eg physically pumped, actively treated or has material consumptive losses), and highlight in yellow. - Discharges – all water flows which are released to the environment (surface water, groundwater or seawater) or a third party, and highlight in orange. - Consumption – all water removed from the system due to evaporation, entrainment or other losses, and highlight in red. See Figure C2 b. Identify all operational water components within the operational water system boundary on the site water balance, including: - Stores – purpose built/artificial structures (including pits) which collect or hold operational water, and highlight in blue. - Tasks – operational activities that require water, and highlight in grey. - Treatment plant (if present) – facilities that use active methods (ie requiring energy or physical inputs) for the primary purpose of improving water quality (excluding thickening), and highlight in purple. See Figure C2 c. Identify any other managed water components on the site water balance, including stores and treatment plants. Note: Not present on this site d. Review the marked-up site water balance figure (see Figure C2), aggregate all flows and components with similar characteristics to the highest possible level, and redraw the information in the left-to-right format illustrated in Figure C3 and summarised in Tables C5 and C6. - Withdrawals – aggregate all operational water withdrawals with common characteristics (ie same source and quality), add to the withdrawal column in green. Repeat for other managed water withdrawals and add to the withdrawal column in yellow. Table C5 – Recommended task aggregation levels (from WAF) WAF Operational Model Task Types Task type (aggregated to highest practical level) Task purpose Example of sub-tasks for aggregation Mining Ore extraction from the ground Open pit, underground and in situ operations Mineral processing Separating ore/minerals from gangue and waste materials and concentrating Crushing, (re)grinding, flotation, agglomeration, heap leach, thickening Tailings management Storage of waste material Construction and use of TSFs Dust control Control of dust on haul road and other dust sources Watering of roads, stockpiles, waste rock and high walls Amenities Drinking water and sanitation facilities Drinking fountains, toilets and showers Miscellaneous Other uses Power generation Appendix C 89 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Table C6 – Summary of simplified site accounting model: inflows and outflows Flow Description Source/ Destination Water Quality Category Quantification Method Water inflows and outflows Operational Water Withdrawal 1. Water from the supply borefield Groundwater High measured 2. Water derived from dewatering of the pit Groundwater High measured 3. Water entrained in the ore feed Groundwater Low measured 4. Rainfall run-off input to the TSF (no material inputs to the other stores) Surface water High simulated from measured rainfall OMW Withdrawal 1. Supply to third parties, including local residents Groundwater High measured 2. Dewater used to maintain wetland function Groundwater High measured Total Discharge 1. Supply to third parties, including local residents Supply to third party High measured 2. Dewater used to maintain wetland function Surface water High measured 3. Seepage of water from the TSF to groundwater Groundwater Low simulated using hydrological model Total Consumption 1. Evaporation from the TSF and of water used for dust control (Evaporation) n/a simulated from measured evaporation 2. Operational loss of water within the processing plant (Task loss) n/a measured and estimated from site balance 3. Water entrained in the concentrate (product) and the tailings within the TSF (which is neither lost to evaporation or seepage) (Entrainment) n/a measured and modelled Figure C2: Site water balance classified as withdrawal, discharge, consumption and internal components Wellfield #1 Wellfield #2 Supply to local community Supply to adjacent mine Task loss Water entrained product%Ore moisture % Dust suppression Process water reservoir TSF Freshwater reservoir Treatment plant Thickening plant Processing plant 7,275 2,632 63 19 116 538 654 3,833 12,060 459 1,433 8,337 1,524 426 16,885 24,723 24,72341,608 648 Flows in ML/a 2,823 Operational water withdrawal OMW withdrawal Discharge Consumption Task Water store Treatment plant Evaporation 712554 6,440 Rainfall run-o Seepage to groundwater Water entrained in tailings % Dewatering of open pit Wetland support Operational water system boundary Appendix C 90 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd EditionTable C8 – Summary of simplified site accounting model: inflows and outflows ICMM Water Reporting Metrics Metric Source/Destination/Type Volume of Water by Quality High (ML) Low (ML) Total (ML) All sites Operational Water Withdrawal Surface Water 554 554 Groundwater 8,708 648 9,356 Seawater Third Party Water Total 9,262 648 9,910 OMW Withdrawal 3,091 0 3,091 Total Discharge1 Surface Water 459 459 Groundwater 712 712 Seawater Supply to Third Party 2,632 2,632 Total 3,091 712 3,803 Total Consumption1 8,700 Operational water Reuse/recycle 50,374 Operational water use 59,783 Change in storage (delta storage) 498 Notes: 1 Includes ICMM operational water and OMW. Orebody dewatering (operational supply) Entrainment in ore Precipitation and runo� Borefield (third party supply) Orebody dewatering (wetland support) Operational water withdrawal Seepage to groundwater Supply to third parties Discharge to wetland (surface water) Task loss Entrainment (in product and waste) Evaporation Dust control TSF Processing plant New water store Mixed water store Treatment plant Operational water system High quality Low quality Both G ro un d w at e r G ro un d w at e r Surface water Other managed water withdrawal Discharge TreatmentTasksWater stores Consumption Key 7,275 1,433 2,632 116 3,833 2,823 554 2,632 459 459 648 12,060 8,337 24,723 24,723 63 19 6,440 1,524 712 654 (116 + 538) 16,885 426 538 Borefield (operational supply) Figure C3 – Simplified water accounting model Box C1 Points to note Calculating water consumption In this example, consumption is calculated as the sum of the constituent losses (evaporation, entrainment and other losses). Although more onerous, this method is preferred as it matures understanding of the site water dynamics, information gaps, risks and performance optimisation opportunities. Consumption may also be calculated using the balance approach, if the change in storage (∆Storage) volume is known – as illustrated below. Where consumption is calculated as the sum of constituent losses, it is good practice to check this value against the value derived by balance. This allows a check of the water balance and enables any key issues to be identified. Total consumption = Total withdrawal (Op water + OMW) – (Total discharge + ∆Storage) Total consumption = (9,910 + 3,091) – (3,803) - (+ 498) Total consumption = 8,700 ML/a Table C7 – Summary of simplified site accounting model: internal components Component Description Water Quality Category Quantification Method Within operational water model Stores (blue) 1. Freshwater store – receives new water from the supply borefield (new water store) High measured inputs, outputs and storage levels (may vary with time) 2. Process water store – receives new and worked water (mixed water store) Low Tasks (grey) 1. Dust control High and Low measured and modelled inputs and outputs (tasks should not store water, except TSFs) 2. Processing plant (includes processing and thickening plants due to task aggregation) Low TSF Low Treatment plants (purple) 1. Treatment plant associated with processing (tailings thickening) Low measured input and output Appendix C 91 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Table C9 – Method Steps: Calculating operational water reuse/recycle and use Step Approach ML/a 1) Calculate operational water use (ML/a) List and then sum all the inflows to tasks, including: From new water store to processing plant 3,833 From mixed water store to processing plant 12,060 Groundwater entrainment in ore feed to processing plant 648 From TSF to processing plant 426 From treatment plant to processing plant 24,723 From processing plant to tsf 16,885 Rainfall to TSF 554 From new water store for dust control 116 From mixed water store for dust control 538 Operational water use (total flows to tasks) (ML/a) 59,783 2) Calculate proportion of worked water in mixed water store (ML/a) List and then sum all inflows to the mixed water store, including: New (make-up) water from the new water store 2,823 New groundwater from dewatering (aquifer interception) 1,433 Worked water reclaimed from the TSF 8,337 Total inflows to mixed water store (ML/a) 12,593 Calculate the proportion of worked water in the mixed water store, as: Sum of worked water inflows Sum of all inflows Sum of worked water inflows to mixed water store (ML/a) 8,337 Sum of all inflows to mixed water store (ML/a) 12,593 Proportion of worked water in mixed water store 0.66 3) Calculate operational water reuse/ recycle volume (ML/a) List and then sum all worked water inflows to tasks (untreated and treated), including: From mixed water store to processing plant (as total volume x proportion of worked water, eg 12,060 x 0.66) 7,984 From TSF to processing plant 426 from processing plant to TSF 16,885 From mixed water store for dust control (as total volume x proportion of worked water, eg 538 x 0.66) 356 From treatment plant to processing plant 24,723 Operational water reuse/recycle (total worked water flows to tasks) (ML/a) 50,374 Option 2: Create ICMM reporting metrics from an existing WAF account ICMM reporting metrics directly align with WAF metrics, as outlined in Appendix B. Use the WAF input-output statement (Table B9) and statement of operational efficiencies (Table B10) to create ICMM reporting metrics – as illustrated in Tables B10 – B12. Table C10 – WAF input-output statement WAF Input-Output Statement Input- Output Source/ Destination Inputs/Outputs Volume of Water by Quality Category Number (ML) 1 2 3 Total Input Surface Water Precipitation and Run-off 554 554 Rivers and Creeks - External Surface Water Storages - Groundwater Aquifer Interception 1,433 1,433 Borefields 7,275 7,275 Entrainment 648 648 Seawater Estuary - Sea/Ocean - Third Party Supply Contract/Municipal - Waste Water - Total Inputs 7,275 1,987 648 9,910 Output Surface Water Discharge - Environmental Flows - Groundwater Seepage 712 712 Reinjection Seawater Discharge to Estuary Discharge to Sea/Ocean Supply to Third Party Other Evaporation 116 2,062 2,178 Entrainment 6,459 6,459 Task Loss 63 63 Total Outputs 116 - 9,296 9,412 WAF Diversions Input Groundwater Aquifer Interception 459 459 Borefields 2,632 2,632 Total Diversion Inputs 2,632 459 - 3,091 Output Surface Water Environmental Flow 459 459 Other Supply to Third Party 2,632 2,632 Total Diversion Outputs 2,632 459 - 3,091 Change in Storage 498 Appendix C 92 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd EditionWater Reporting: Good Practice Guide Table C11 – WAF statement of operational efficiencies WAF Operational Efficiencies ICMM reporting metrics Total of all flows to tasks (ML/a) 59,783 Corresponds to operational water use (59,783 ML/a) Total inflows to mixed water store (ML/a) 12,593 Total untreated worked water flows to tasks (ML/a) 25,651 Sum of untreated and treated worked water flows to tasks corresponds to operational reuse/recycle volume (50,374 ML/a)Reuse efficiency (%) 43 Total treated worked water flows to tasks (ML/a) 24,723 Recycle efficiency (%) 41 Table C12 – Mapping WAF and ICMM reporting metrics: inputs and withdrawals WAF Input-Output Statement ICMM Water Reporting Metrics Input- Output Source/ Destination Inputs/ Outputs Volume of Water by Quality Category Number (ML) Metric Source Volume of Water by Quality (ML) 1 2 3 Total High Low Total Input Surface Water Precipitation and Run-off 554 554 Operational Water Withdrawal Surface Water 554 554 Rivers and Creeks - External Surface Water Storages - Groundwater Aquifer Interception 1,433 1,433 Groundwater 8,708 648 9,356 Borefields 7,275 7,275 Entrainment 648 648 Seawater Estuary - Seawater Sea/Ocean - Third Party SupplyContract/ Municipal - Third Party Water Waste Water - Total Inputs 7,275 1,987 648 9,910 Total Op Water 9,262 648 9,910 Diversion Input Surface Water Discharge - OMW Withdrawal Environmental Flows - Groundwater Aquifer Interception 459 459 Borefields 2,632 2,632 Total Diversion Inputs 2,632 459 - 3,091 Total OMW 3,091 0 3,091 Notes: For mapping water quality categories: ICMM High (ML) = WAF Category 1 (ML) + WAF Category 2 (ML); and ICMM Low (ML) = Category 3 (ML). Use the ICMM reporting metrics derived from WAF metrics above to populate the template for reporting ICMM metrics (Table 3) to maintain consistency Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Table C13 – Mapping WAF and ICMM reporting metrics (outputs, discharge, consumption and change in storage) WAF Input-Output Statement ICMM Water Reporting Metrics Input- Output Source/ Destination Inputs/ Outputs Volume of Water by Quality Category Number (ML) Metric Destination/Type Volume of Water by Quality (ML) 1 2 3 Total High Low Total Output Surface Water Discharge Operational Water Discharge Surface Water Environmental Flows Groundwater Seepage 712 712 Groundwater 712 712 Reinjection Seawater Discharge to Estuary Seawater Discharge to Ocean Supply to Third Party Supply to Third Party Total Op Water Discharge 0 712 712 Other Evaporation 116 2,062 2,178 Operational Water Consumption Total Op Water Consumption 8,700 Entrainment 6,459 6,459 Task Loss 63 63 Total Outputs 116 0 9,296 9,412 Diversion Output Surface water Environmental Flows 459 459 OMW Discharge Surface water 459 459 Supply to Third Party 2,632 2,632 Supply to Third Party 2,632 2,632 Total OMW Discharge 3,091 0 3,091 Other Evaporation OMW Consumption Total OMW Consumption 0Entrainment Task Loss Total Diversion Outputs 2,632 459 0 3,091 Total Discharge (Op Water + OMW) 3,091 712 3,803 Total Consumption (Op Water + OMW) 8,700 Change in Storage (Delta Storage) 498 Change in Storage (Delta Storage) 498 Notes: For mapping water quality categories: ICMM High (ML) = WAF Category 1 (ML) + WAF Category 2 (ML); and ICMM Low (ML) = Category 3 (ML). Use the ICMM reporting metrics derived from the WAF metrics above to populate the template for reporting ICMM metrics (Table 4) to maintain consistency Appendix C 94 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Step 4: Summarising site impact, risk, opportunity and response Summarise the key risks, opportunities and response associated with the site, based on detailed assessment of the site context. It is important to use standardised company risk frameworks (ie which define likelihood and consequence thresholds for the company) to ensure comparability of results between different sites. For the purpose of this example, an assessment of the key risks and opportunities relating to the site, based on the information provided in Step 1, is summarised in Tables C14 and C15. A summary of site risk, opportunity and response is provided in Table C16. Step 5: Summarising site information for aggregation The site information required to prepare external reporting to the minimum commitments is summarised in the tables noted below in a consistent and comparable format. Table C3 – Site details and context summary Table C8 – ICMM reporting metrics Table C16 – Site risk, opportunity and response summary Table C14 – Site water risk assessment (based on CDP Water approach) Risk Type and Overview Potential impact Timeframe Likelihood Impact Magnitude Raw Risk Rank Response Strategies Managed Risk Rank Physical – increased water stress Water stress is high and rising due to limited water resources (water scarcity) and rising demand. — Higher operating costs — Plant disruption leading to reduced output 1-3 years Likely (4) High risk (4) High risk (16) — Infrastructure investment (to improve efficiency through optimising the thickening plant and upgrading treatment facilities). Low to medium (4) Physical – climate change increases water scarcity and stress Water scarcity likely to increase due to the forecast impacts of climate change, further increasing water stress. (Also Regulatory – increased difficulty in obtaining withdrawals/operations permits.) — Constraint on growth — Higher operating costs >6 years Almost certain (5) High (4) Very high risk (20) — Infrastructure investment (to develop alternative water supply options, including use of seawater and/or municipal or industrial waste water). Low to medium (5) Regulatory – regulatory uncertainty Uncertainty around the right to water derived within the operations (dewatering and rainfall run-off). — Higher operating costs — Plant disruption leading to reduced output — Delays in permitting 1-3 years Possible (3) Low – medium (2) Low to medium (6) — Engagement with public policy makers. — Engagement with other stakeholders in the catchment (to develop a catchment water plan). Low risk (4) Reputational – community opposition Established conflicts within the catchment between different water uses and users (eg the farming community, civil society and mining companies). — Brand image — Property damage Current Likely (4) Medium (3) Medium (12) — Engagement with community (through convening regular catchment stakeholder consultation sessions). — Basin restoration (through proactively participating in collective action to remediate arsenic hot spots). — Increased capital expenditure (to improve rural drinking water system and rainfall capture and dam storage facilities). Low risk (3) Appendix C 95 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd EditionWater Reporting: Good Practice Guide Table C15 – Site water opportunity assessment (based on CDP Water approach) Opportunity Type and Overview Response Strategy Timeframe Likelihood Benefit Magnitude Opp Rank Improved water efficiency and cost savings Continuing drive to optimise operational recovery, reuse and recycle of water and reduce losses. Leading to reduced demand for “make-up” water (from water supply borefield) and associated cost savings. With associated benefits to also improve climate change resilience and improve community relations (as below). — Establish site specific targets — Infrastructure investment — Increased investment in new technology current Almost certain (5) Low (1) Low – medium (5) Climate change adaptation Increased climate change resilience realised by: — developing alternative water supply options (seawater desalination and/or municipal or industrial waste water treatment) to meet the operational water demand – which may also have potential opportunity to create additional supply for third party municipal or industrial purposes; and — optimising operational efficiency to reduce reliance on the water supply borefield. — Increased capital expenditure — Engagement other stakeholders in the basin >6 years Likely (4) High (4) High (16) Improved community relations Opportunities to engage with the community to develop an integrated catchment water plan to understand catchment stakeholder water uses and requirements, for allocation planning. Opportunities to participate in a number of catchment restoration and improvement projects. — Engagement with public policy makers — Engagement other stakeholders in the basin — Strengthen links with local community — River basin restoration current Almost certain (5) Low – medium (2) Medium (10) Appendix C 96 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Statement Description Example Response Summary Water opportunity type Describe the water opportunity types associated with the site. — Efficiency — Resilience — Products and services — Markets (and reputation) — Other — Efficiency — Resilience Opportunityassessment method Identify the approach or tool used to assess site water opportunities. — Company specific — CDP Water 2021 W4.3 — WWF Water Risk Filter — CDP Water Management response level Describe the management response associated with the site. — Rank as response level: 1 (very low) to 5 (very high) 5 – very high Management response type Identify the management response types taken by the site. — Internal actions — Collective action (external) — Influence governance — Efficiency — Resilience Target type Identify the type of water targets set by the site. — Water withdrawals — Water consumption — Water discharge — Water quality — Water use — Water reuse/ recycling — WASH — Ecosystem health — Community engagement — Other — None — Water withdrawals — Water quality — Ecosystem health Target level Identify the level at which the targets are set — Corporate — Site specific — Corporate and site (aligned) — Corporate and site (aligned) Table C16 – Summary of site impact, risk, opportunity and response Statement Description Example Response Summary Catchment water stress level Describe the baseline stress level of the catchment within which the site is situated. — Rank stress level as: 1 (very low) to 5 (very high) — Unknown 4 - high Catchment stress assessment method Identify the assessment approach or tool used to determine the catchment stress level. — Company specific — Publicly available tools: — WRI Aqueduct — WWF Water Risk Filter — WWF Water Risk Filter — WRI Aqueduct — Company specific Regulatory non- compliance level Describe any materialnon- compliances with regulatory limits set for the quality of water discharges associated with the site (during the reporting period). — Rank consequence level as: 1 (very low) to 5 (very high) — None None identified Water risk level Describe the water risk level associated with the site. — Rank risk level as: 1 (very low) to 5 (very high) — Unknown 4 – high 2 – low Water risk type Describe the key water risk types associated with the site. — — Physical — Reputational — Regulatory and markets — Technology — Physical (scarcity) — Regulatory Water risk assessment method Identify the approach or tools used to assess site water risks. — Company specific — CDP Water 2021 W4.2 — Publicly available tools - Ecolab Water Risk Monetizer - GEMI Local Water Tool - WFN Water Footprint Assessment Tool - WRI Aqueduct - WWF Water Risk Filter — CDP Water Climate change scenario analysis Describe how climate change is considered in site water risk and opportunity assessment, and over what time horizons. — Climate influences considered in the short term — Climate influences considered in the medium term — Climate influences considered in long term — Not considered — Climate influences considered over the short, medium and long term Water opportunity level Describe the water opportunity level associated with the site. — Rank as opportunity level: 1 (none) to 5 (very high) — Unknown 3 – medium Appendix C 97 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Appendix D: Guidance for Aggregating Site Metrics for External Reporting This appendix provides guidance for aggregating site metrics for external reporting to avoid double counting (Figure D1), which is supported by three operational examples of sites with complex boundaries (Tables D1–D3). Aggregating site water metrics for external reporting (to avoid double counting) • The approach used to aggregate site water metrics for external reporting depends on the relationship with the boundary of the reporting entity – eg the company (minimum level) or asset (beyond minimum level). • This relationship determines how the water is classified, and if the water is included in external reporting metrics as illustrated in the accompanying operational examples. Overview: When aggregating site water metrics for external reporting, it is important to review water boundaries to avoid double counting, particularly where water transfers are present between individual sites. Step 2: Identify inter-site water transfers Is the water directly transferred to/received from another site operated by the company? Step 3: Review the boundary for the reporting entity eg company (minimum level) or asset (beyond minimum level). Direct water flow (to single site) Points to note: Inter-catchment water transfers • Both direct flows and inter-site water transfers may remove water from the catchment of origin. • In this situation, the water should be classified and accounted following the approach illustrated (ie as a direct flow or an internal transfer) and reported accordingly. • In addition, if the transfer presents a significant risk or opportunity to the site/company (eg due to export of water from/import of water to a water stressed area), then this should be captured in the water risk and opportunity assessment and reporting narrative. See Brazilian remote refinery example. • The water is a withdrawal from/discharge to the environment or a third party, or a consumption associated with a single site. Aggregation approach for external reporting • Include in reporting metrics. • Aggregate by simple addition. See Australian mining complex example. Direct water flow (to company/asset) The water is transferred between sites, but crosses the company (or asset water) boundary at a single point (i.e. as a consumption or direct withdrawal from/dis- charge to the environment or a third party). Aggregation approach for external reporting • Classify and account the water at the point at which it crosses the company (or asset) boundary. • Include in reporting metrics. • Aggregate by simple addition. See accompanying operational examples. Internal water transfer (within company/asset) The water is an internal transfer and does not cross the company/asset water boundary. • Exclude from reporting metrics. See accompanying operational examples. Step 4: Identify internal water transfers Does the water cross the company (or asset) boundary? For example, between sites that are geographically clustered, connected across the mine-to-market value chain, or connected by water supply networks. Yes Yes No No Step 1: Identify water flows which cross the site boundary Allowing for operating/ownership status and management responsibility limits. See Section 2.3.1. See Chilean water supply example. Approach Principle Figure D1: Guidance for aggregating site metrics for external reporting Appendix D 98 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Operational context: • Two individual copper mines, Chile • Connected by the same water supply delivery system (desalinated seawater) 1) Desalination plant operated by third party Asset water accounting Contribution to asset reporting metrics Operational water withdrawal = 20 k + 5 k = 25 k ML/a Accounting classification – individual sites Site 1 Operational water withdrawal from third party (80% of inflow) [20 k ML/a] Other managed water (OMW) withdrawal from third party, OMW Discharge to third party (20% of inflow) [5 k ML/a] Site 2 Operational water withdrawal from third party [5 k ML/a] Key: Direct flows (associated with a single site / entity) Individual site water accounting 2) Desalination plant operated by company Asset water accounting Contribution to asset reporting metrics Operational water withdrawal = 60 k ML/a (Operational water) Discharge = 35 k ML/a Note: Inter-site transfers become internal transfers and are not included in asset reporting metrics Accounting classification – individual sites Desal plant Operational water withdrawal from seawater [60 k ML/a] (Operational water) Discharge to seawater[35 k ML/a] (Operational water) Discharge to third party [25 k ML/a] Site 1 Operational water withdrawal from third party (80% of inflow) [20 k ML/a] OMW withdrawal from third party, OMW Discharge to third party (20% of inflow) [5 k ML/a] Site 2 Operational water withdrawal from third party [5 k ML/a] Individual site water accounting Ownership model: • Variable operating/ ownership models Catchment se�ing: • Situated within the same water catchment 3) Desalination plant operated by Site 1 Asset water accounting Contribution to asset reporting metrics Operational water withdrawal = 60 k ML/a (Operational water) Discharge = 35 k ML/a Note: inter-site transfer becomes internal transfer and is not included in asset reporting metrics Accounting classification – individual sites Site 1 Operational water withdrawal from seawater [60 k ML/a] (Operational water) Discharge to seawater [35 k ML/a] (Operational water) Discharge to third party [5 k ML/a] Site 2 Operational water withdrawal from third party [5 k ML/a] Individual site water accounting seawater [60 k ML/a] [35 k ML/a] Operational water withdrawal [20 k ML/a] OMW [5 k ML/a] Inter-site water transfer [5 k ML/a] Site boundary Site 2Site 1 1 Desal plant seawater [60 k ML/a] [35 k ML/a] Operational water withdrawal [20 k ML/a] Internal transfer [5 k ML/a] Direct flow to asset [5 k ML/a] Asset boundary Site 2Site 11 Desal plant seawater [60k ML/a] [35k ML/a] Internal transfer [5 k ML/a] Internal transfer [25 k ML/a] Asset boundary Site 2Site 1 1 2 Desal plant seawater [60 k ML/a] [35 k ML/a] Inter-site transfer [5 k ML/a] Internal transfer [25 k ML/a] Site 2Site 1 1 2 Desal plant seawater [60 k ML/a] [35 k ML/a] Internal transfer [5 k ML/a] Internal transfer [25 k ML/a] Site 2Site 1 1 2 Desal plant seawater [60k ML/a] [35 k ML/a] Inter-site water transfer [20 k ML/a] Inter-site water transfer [5 k ML/a] Site boundary Site 2Site 1 2 Desal plant 1a 1b seawater [60,000 k ML/a] [35,000 k ML/a] [25,000 ML/a] [5,000 ML/a] Site 2Site 1Desal plant Asset boundary Table D1 : Chilean water supply example: Calculating asset reporting metrics for individual mine sites connected by the same water supply delivery system (desalinated seawater) Appendix D 99 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Operational context: • Coal mining complex, Australia. • Three individual mining sites with inter-site water transfers. Ownership model: • All sites operated/owned by the same company. Catchment se�ing: • Situated within the same water catchment. Individual site water accounting Asset water accounting Key: Direct flows (associated with a single site / entity) 2) Water supply Operational water transferred from Site 2 to Site 1 for supply. Inter-site water transfers 1) Water entrained in ore Water entrained in coal extracted at Site 1 and transferred to Site 3 for processing. Site 1: (Operational water) Discharge to third party. Site 2: Operational water withdrawal from third party. Accounting classification – individual sites Site 1: OMW withdrawal from groundwater, OMW discharge to third party. Site 2: Operational water withdrawal from third party. 1) Water entrained in ore – reclassify water as op water withdrawal (from groundwater) and add to asset op water withdrawal total (as below). 2) Water supply – becomes internal transfer (as does not cross asset boundary) and is not included in asset totals. • Operational water withdrawal = 8,000 + 5,000 + 2,300 + 200 = 15,500 ML/a • OMW withdrawal = 4,000 ML/a • Total discharge = 2,000 + 1,300 + 900 + 4,000 = 8,200 ML/a • Total consumption = 6,000 + 3,500 + 1,500 = 11,000 ML/a • Change in storage = (15,500 + 4,000) – (8,200 + 11,000) = 300 ML/a Inter-site transfers Asset reporting metrics Operational water withdrawal from surface water, groundwater & third parties [8,000 ML/a] Inter-site water transfers [200 ML/a] [500 ML/a] [5,000 OMW withdrawal from surface water OMW discharge to surface water [4,000 ML/a] Water catchment boundary (Operational water) Consumption [1,500 ML/a] (Operational water) Discharge to surface water [900 ML/a] Site 3 Site 3 bound ary [6,000 ML/a] [2,000 ML/a] Site 1 Si te 1 b oundary Site 2 Site 2 Asset Si te 2 b o un d ar y [2,300 ML/a] [3,500 ML/a][1,300ML/a] 2 1 Operational water withdrawal [15,500 ML/a] Internal transfers [500 ML/a] OMW withdrawal, OMW Discharge [4,000 ML/a] Water catchment boundary (Operational water) Consumption [11,000 ML/a] (Operational water) Discharge [4,200 ML/a] Site 3 Site 1 Asset boundary 2 1 Direct flow to asset [200 ML/a] Table D2: Australian mining complex: Caluculating asset reporting metrics for mine sites with inter-site water transfers Individual site water accounting Company water accounting Accounting classification – individual sites • Site 1: (Operational water) Consumption (water entrained in slurry). • Site 2: Operational water withdrawal from third party. Contribution to company reporting metrics • The inter-site transfer becomes an internal transfer (as does not cross the company boundary) and is not included in the company reporting metrics. • Note: The inter-site transfer is also an inter-catchment transfer, as the water is removed from the catchment of origin (i.e. the mine site catchment). This does not change how the water is classified and included in company reporting metrics. However, if this transfer presents a material risk or opportunity to the site / company, this should be included in the water risk and opportunity assessment and reporting narrative. Operational context: • A bauxite mine site and a remote refinery site, Brazil. • Sites connected by a 150km pipeline used to transport ore slurry for processing. Ownership model: • Both sites operated/owned by the same company. Catchment se�ing: • Variable water catchment se�ings. Situated in the same water catchment Situated in di�erent water catchments Individual site water accounting Company water accounting Accounting classification – individual sites • Site 1: (Operational water) Consumption (water entrained in slurry). • Site 2: Operational water withdrawal from third party. Contribution to company reporting metrics • The inter-site transfer becomes an internal transfer (as does not cross the company boundary) and is not included in the company reporting metrics. Water catchment boundary Mine Boundary Mine Refinery boundary Mine Boundary Refinery boundary Refinery Inter-site water transfer [2,000 ML/a] Mine catchment boundary Refinery catchment boundaryWater catchment boundary Mine Refinery Internal transfer [2,000 ML/a] Mine catchment boundary Refinery catchment boundary Mine Refinery Inter-site water transfer [2,000 ML/a] Company boundary Mine Refinery Internal transfer [2,000 ML/a] Company boundary Table D1: Chilean water supply example: Calculating asset reporting metrics for individual mine sites connected by the same water supply delivery system (desalinated seawater) Appendix D 100 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Overview This appendix provides an example (iMine) of the key information required to meet the minimum reporting commitments, including: — Table E1 – Summary of internal supporting information including site context, risk, opportunity and response — Table E2 to E4 – The basic information required to meet the minimum reporting commitments – metrics and narrative Appendix E: Example of Compiling Corporate Information for External Reporting — Figure E1 – Example supporting case studies — Figure E2 – Example supporting graphic This information can be compiled and presented using many approaches, styles and formats, as appropriate to the company’s brand image and disclosure style. Table E1appropriately defined for the mining and metals industry, and based on the MCA’s WAF (as outlined in Appendix B). In addition, a simple illustrative approach for assessing and compiling water risks, opportunities and management response, aligned to external reporting guidance and platforms, is provided for companies looking to develop or update their approach. The guidance in this section focuses on: — Summarising site details and context – including catchment and context (see Section 2.2). — Understanding and setting site boundaries – including spatial, materiality and temporal (see Section 2.3). — Site water accounting and ICMM water reporting metrics – using operational data to generate consistent benchmarkable reporting metrics (see Section 2.4). — Assessing water risks, opportunities and management response – including key points to consider and a simple illustrative approach (see Section 2.5). Box 2:1 Point to note Guidance intent and reporting expectations This guidance around site level accounting and assessment is intended to help companies to develop comparable and material information as the foundation for accurate and consistent external reporting to the minimum commitments. This guidance also provides insight to external stakeholders around the complexity of operational water accounting and the generation of ICMM water reporting metrics. There is no ICMM requirement for data to be externally disclosed beyond that needed to meet the minimum reporting commitments (as outlined in Table 1). 2.2 Summarising site details and context Summarising key site details and context in a consistent and comparable format aids the compilation and analysis of site information at the company level to inform external reporting. Capturing the site context is particularly important for providing the information required to appropriately understand and communicate the site water reporting metrics (see Section 2.4) and site water risks, opportunity and response assessments (see Section 2.5). Consistent with external reporting guidance, useful site details to summarise include site name, location (including country) and catchment. As required, publicly available tools may be used to determine the extent and name of the local catchment within which a site is located (see Box 2:3). An operational example of site water accounting and assessment for the purpose of external reporting to the minimum commitments is provided in Appendix C. 13Water Reporting: Good practice guide 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Key contextual elements to consider (at the minimum level) are outlined below; and an illustrative approach for summarising site context is outlined in Table 2. — Climatic setting: This is often a good high-level indicator of the local water setting, likely level of water availability within the catchment, and potential need to manage significant surface water or run-off flows. — Commodity: This often determines the range of operational activities undertaken (mining and processing) and associated water interactions. — Key operational water activities: This provides an overview of the site’s water dependencies and handling requirements. — Water treatment practices and discharge quality limits: This this provides an overview of the site’s approach to managing water quality and associated risks. Box 2:3 Tips and tools Publicly available tools for delineating and naming catchments — The CEO Water Mandate Interactive Database of the World’s River Basins — World Wildlife Fund (WWF) HydroSHEDs — World Resources Institute (WRI) Aqueduct Water Risk Atlas — WWF Water Risk Filter Box 2:2 Point to note Different terms used for catchments In this guidance, the term ‘catchment’ is used to describe the geographical zone in which surface water or groundwater is captured, flows through and eventually discharges at one or more points.13 The extent to which surface water and groundwater catchments align or are connected is highly variable; and depends on the local topography and geology. Catchments may also be referred to as ‘watersheds’ or ‘(river) basins’. 14Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment https://ceowatermandate.org/disclosure/resources/river-basins/ https://ceowatermandate.org/disclosure/resources/river-basins/ https://www.hydrosheds.org/ https://www.wri.org/aqueduct https://www.wri.org/aqueduct https://waterriskfilter.panda.org/ 02 0301 Table 2 – Simple illustrative approach for summarising site context (guidance only) Statement Examples Rationale Catchment(s) Catchment name (eg from global river basins as mapped in publicly available tools). — Describes the site’s location(s) and sets the context and scale for assessing water risks, opportunities and management response (including the identification of water stressed areas). — Identifying all catchments associated with the site’s operational activities (including any remote catchments used for water withdrawal or discharge) provides important context for assessing potential risks and opportunities – especially where water is transferred between catchments with different water stress levels. Climatic Conditions — Arid or semi-arid environment — Moderate precipitation with distinct dry season — Moderate precipitation — Very high precipitation and/or frequent major storm events Annual precipitation categories provide important site context which may be useful in indicating: — The likely need to manage significant surface water and/or run-off flows. — The likely water availability within the wider catchment. Commodity Summarise commodity (eg aluminium, coal, copper, gold, iron ore, lithium, zinc). — Site water metrics are heavily dependent on site setting and commodity type – which may have a stronger influence on the metric values than site water management practices. — Identifying the main operational water activities provides the fundamental context for understanding reporting metrics and water risk, opportunity and response assessments. — Site context should always be considered when using water metrics for benchmarking, site level target setting, and/or performance monitoring purposes. Main Operational Water Activities — Cooling or drying processes — Dewatering — Discharge — Dust control — Flood control — Open pit mining — Managed aquifer recharge (MAR) — Mineral processing — Mineral separation — Mineral transportation — OMW flows — Sediment control — Solution mining — Surface water re-alignment — Tailings management — Underground mining — Waste management — Water treatment Main Consumptive Water Uses — Evaporation (specify related activity) — Entrainment – product — Entrainment – waste — Other losses — Identifying main consumptive losses provides important information for describing the company’s water interactions and provides context for understanding the reporting metrics. 15Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Statement Examples Rationale Water Treatment Activities — Biological reaction — Disinfection — Distillation — Electrodialysis — Flocculation/coagulation — Filtration — Precipitation — Reverse osmosis — Sedimentation — Describes water treatment activities and discharge quality limits associated with the site – which provides important context for understanding and reporting the company’s approach to identifying and managing water risks and opportunities associated with water quality. Water Treatment Driver — Compliance — Environmental management — Improved operational efficiency — Operational water supply — Third-party– Internal compilation of site context, risk, opportunity and response: iMine example Business Unit Metals Energy Division South America Australasia Africa Australasia Site Reference No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Location Chile Chile Peru Peru Australia Indonesia S. Africa Australia Australia Australia Australia Commodity Copper Copper, gold Copper, gold Copper Copper, gold Copper, gold Gold Met coal Met coal Met coal Thermal coal Contextual summary Main operational water activities Dust suppression, ore washing and processing, product transportation, waste management and cooling Main consumptive water uses Evaporation (dust control, evaporation from stores and TSFs) 72%; entrainment (in product and waste) 15% Risk-opportunity-response summary Baseline catchment stress level 4 4 5 3 2 2 4 2 2 2 1 Material regulatory non- compliances none none none none none none none none none none none Managed risk level 2 1 3 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 Primary risk Physical water stress Physical water stress Physical water stress Physical water stress Physical drought Regulatory water access uncertainty Physical water stress Physical drought Physical drought Physical drought Physical flooding Secondary risk Regulatory water access uncertainty Regulatory water access uncertainty Reputational community opposition to water access Regulatory water access uncertainty Physical flooding Physical flooding Reputational community opposition legacy AMD Reputational community opposition to TSF Physical flooding Reputational community opposition to discharge - Opportunity level 3 3 4 3 3 2 4 2 3 3 3 Main opportunity type1 Climate resilience Improving community relations Improving community relations Climate resilience Delivering cost savings Protecting social licence to operate Improving water efficiency Improving water efficiency Delivering cost savings Protecting social licence to operate Climate resilience Management response level 5 5 5 4 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 Response type1 IA, CA, IG IA, CA, IG IA, CA IA, CA IA, CA, IG IA, CA IA, CA, IG IA, CA, IG IA, CA, IG IA, CA, IG IA, CA, IG Target type Reuse-recycle Withdrawal Reuse-recycle Withdrawal Reuse-recycle Withdrawal Reuse-recycle Withdrawal Water quality Community engagement Reuse-recycle Withdrawal Community engagement Water quality Community engagement Water quality Target level Site specific aligned to corporate water strategy and targets Note: 1 IA – internal action, CA – collective action (external), IG – influence governance. Appendix E 101 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Table E2 – Information required for meeting the minimum reporting commitments ICMM WATER Reporting Metrics Metric Source/Destination/Type Volume of Water by Quality High (ML) Low (ML) Total (ML) All sites Withdrawal – Operational Water Surface Water 68,200 - 68,200 Groundwater 132,400 - 132,400 Seawater - 25,700 25,700 Third-Party Water 2,200 7,900 10,100 Total 202,800 33,600 236,400 OMW Withdrawal 40,300 26,900 67,200 Total Discharge1 Surface Water 47,400 - 47,400 Groundwater 15,100 15,200 30,300 Seawater - 15,300 15,300 Supply to Third Party 28,700 2,900 31,600 Total 91,200 33,400 124,600 Total Consumption1 175,800 Operational water reuse/recycle 654,600 Operational water use (recommended) 891,000 Change in storage (delta storage) (recommended) 3,200 Sites situated in water stressed areas Withdrawal – Operational Water Surface Water 32,300 - 32,300 Groundwater 92,000 - 92,000 Seawater - 25,700 25,700 Third-Party Water 1,600 7,900 9,500 Total 125,900 33,600 159,500 OMW Withdrawal 23,100 5,100 28,200 Total Discharge1 Surface Water 500 - 500 Groundwater - 1,800 1,800 Seawater - 14,100 14,100 Supply to Third Party 24,200 2,700 26,900 Total 24,700 18,600 43,300 Total Consumption1 143,600 Operational water reuse/recycle 510,100 Operational water use (recommended) 669,600 Change in storage (delta storage) (recommended) 800 Water stress and water risk exposure (all sites) Unit – tick as appropriate Value Proportion of sites situated in water stressed areas2 Number of sites ✓ Percentage of sites 4 Notes: 1 Includes ICMM operational water and other managed water; 2 Areas with high (40–80 per cent) or extremely high (> 80 per cent) levels of baseline water stress, or classified as ‘arid and low water’ when assessed using WRI Aqueduct Water Risk Atlas and verified/revised using local knowledge. Table E3 – Minimum reporting commitment narrative: iMine example Section Question Example Response 1) Interactions with water What are the main operational water activities? Within our operations, we access water for a variety of purposes, including dust suppression, ore washing and processing, product transportation, waste management and cooling. We also use water of variable qualities, and preferentially use low quality water where available and feasible, eg third party waste water and seawater. What are the main water sources used for withdrawal? Approximately 15–20 per cent of our water withdrawal was from low quality water (seawater and third party sources). The majority of our high quality water withdrawal was from groundwater and surface water sources. What are the main consumptive water uses? Evaporative losses associated with dust suppression, water storage and waste facilities is our main consumptive water use (80 per cent), while additional water is removed through entrainment in product and waste streams. What are the main discharges? Approximately 25 per cent of the water discharged from our operations was provided to a third party for beneficial use and the rest was returned to suitable environmental destinations (including surface water, groundwater and seawater). 2) Water challenges and opportunities Overall, how material is water risk to business value and performance? The operational challenges and water risks associated with our operations continue to rise across the catchments in which we operate, due to increasing pressure on water access and more extreme seasonal variabilities associated with climate change. We expect this trend to continue into the future. However, through our systematic approach to water risk identification and management, we are able to effectively manage these risks through a combination of increased expenditure and stakeholder engagement. Therefore, at the portfolio level, water is currently considered to present a low risk to overall business viability and value (based on risk to global revenue). What are the material water risks or challenges facing the company? Summarised in table below. Does the company hold significant operations in water-stressed areas? Approximately one-third of our operations (four out of eleven) are situated in areas with high or very-high levels of baseline water stress. These include three copper-gold operations in Chile and Peru, and one gold operation in South Africa. This assessment of water stress is based on analysis using the WRI Aqueduct tool combined with local knowledge. Has the company had any material regulatory non-compliances relating to the quality of its discharges? There have been no material regulatory non-compliances relating to the quality of our water discharges during the reporting period. What water opportunities available to the company? Significant water opportunities exist across our operations which collectively enhance the sustainability and value of our business, and contribute a positive impact on the catchments and communities within which we operate, including: — Building climate resilience by improving internal water efficiencies and diversifying our water supply source options. — Improving community relations through engagement and investment incollective action initiatives to address priority shared water challenges. — Improving water quality through new technologies and upgraded monitoring systems. Appendix E 102 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Section Question Example Response 3) Commitment and response How does the company integrate water into business strategy and leadership? We take a holistic approach which embeds water in our business strategy and provides a common framework for water management across all elements of our operations and planning cycles. Our strategic water aims are to: — Optimise our internal water performance. — Work collectively with catchment stakeholders to maximise shared value through addressing shared challenges. Water is a metric on our internal performance scorecard (aligned to our business strategy), with oversight by our executive leadership team (supported by quarterly briefings). What are the company’s approach and commitments to water stewardship? We recognise that water is a precious and shared resource with significant social, cultural, environmental and economic value. Water is also a fundamental requirement for all of our mining and refining operations. Our ability to secure access to water of suitable volumes and qualities is critical to the sustainability of our business. In response, we are committed to: — More deeply understanding water in our operations and host catchments. — Identifying and managing our internal water risks. — Proactively engaging with key stakeholders (communities, other water users and regulators) in the catchments within which we operate to understand priority catchment challenges. — Promote strategies which link internal operational and external catchment priorities to deliver shared water outcomes and mitigate business risk. Also see example case studies. How does the company promote stakeholder engagement, and with whom? How does the company identify and manage/ realise material water risks and opportunities? Including those associated with water quality, water stress and climate change. Our common framework for water stewardship requires that all our operations: — Maintain an up-to-date water balance. — Undertake extensive monitoring to understand baseline water qualities within the catchment and ensure that appropriate site-specific discharge quality criteria are set for each operation to minimise environmental impacts. — Review water performance, targets, risks and opportunities on an annual basis (with cross-functional input). — Include climate change scenarios in our assessment and forecasting of operational water requirements, risks and priority catchment challenges over the short, medium and long term. — Understand the water context of each catchment within which we operate; and identify priority challenges and collective action opportunities (eg relating to water quantity, quality and availability). — Set site-specific targets which are aligned and contribute towards our corporate water targets (see below). In addition, all of our operations situated in water-stressed areas are required to: optimise water reuse-recycling and reduce consumptive losses; and develop alternative low quality water supply sources (by 2030). Does the company set water performance targets? If so, describe what targets are set and why. We have two long-term corporate water targets, to: — Halve our reliance on high quality water from environmental sources (eg surface water and groundwater) in water-stressed areas by 2030, as appropriate to the site. This may achieved by: optimising internal efficiencies (improving reuse-recycle and reducing consumptive losses) and; preferentially using low quality water where available and feasible (eg example third party wastewater or seawater). — Deliver net positive water impact to the catchments within which we operate by 2030. This may be achieved by working with catchment stakeholders (including communities, other water users and regulators) to identify shared water challenges and actively participating (by contributing funding, data or technical expertise) in collective action projects to address priority challenges and deliver improved water security for all. Table E4 – Minimum reporting risk narrative: iMine example Risk Type Risk Description Locations Example Mitigating Strategies Physical Securing water access in water- stressed areas Four operations in Chile and Peru — Enhance water recovery, reuse and recycling, with site-specific performance targets for operations in water stressed areas. — Reduce evaporation (eg through installing waterproof membranes on water storage and waste facilities). — Secure diversified supply through use of wastewater and desalinated seawater. — Improve capture and storage of seasonal rainfall. — Diversify power suppliers to reduce reliance on hydropower. Securing water access in drought affected areas Five operations in South Africa and Australia Managing excess water associated with flood events Seven operations in Australia, Indonesia and Peru — Improve operational resilience through infrastructure investments (eg flood levees, bunding and water pumping equipment). — Build flood contingency capacity in operational scheduling. Reputational Managing community opposition associated with historical AMD and TSFs Three operations in Australia, South Africa and Peru — Engage with host communities to share knowledge and build trust. — Improve catchment monitoring and share results. — Invite catchment stakeholders to participate in water monitoring activities. — Work collectively with catchment stakeholders to rehabilitate historical impacts. Appendix E 103 Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition Figure E1 Example supporting case studies Total consumption (evaporation, entrainment and task loss) 175,800 ML Total discharge (surface water, groundwater, seawater and third parties) 124,600 ML Withdrawals iMine water balance Based on AngloGold Ashanti (2019). p.28.Sustainability Report 2019. R eu se d / r ecycled: 645,600 M L Seawater 25,700 ML Third parties 10,100 ML 891,000ML required to sustain operational activities including: Dust control Ore processing Ore washing Product transportation Waste management Cooling 2020 Other managed water (dewatering and third party supply) 67,200 ML Surface water (including precipitation) 68,200 ML Surface water (including precipitation) 68,200 ML Groundwater 132,400 ML Figure E2 Example supporting graphic Select Case Studies: Managing risk in water stressed areas Water supply security for all through desalination, Chile We provide a reliable and secure supply of freshwater for our host community and copper-gold operations in the Atacama Desert through pumping desalinated seawater from the coast. Reducing water use through power diversification, South Africa We are developing a solar electricity power generation plant to reduce our reliance on third party conventional power generation which is very water intensive. Select Case Studies: Creating value though water opportunities Generating power and security from wastewater, Peru We provide treated wastewater from our copper- gold operation in Peru to a third party for electrical power generation, which reduces their reliance on scarce freshwater resources and enhances our power supply security. Reducing dust and water consumption through new technologies, company-wide We are actively exploring innovative technologies across our business to reduce our evaporate losses – including the trial of new dust control additives and microbial agents which will significantly reduce the water, fuel, labour hours and costs required to control dust across our global operations. Select CaseStudies: The value of stakeholder engagement Chili River Public-Private Partnership, Peru We have developed a public-private partnership with the local government and a utility company to address increasing water scarcity in an already water-stressed area. Through this partnership, we treat municipal wastewater containing raw sewage which was being directly discharged to the local river. The treated water is used for supply at our copper-gold operation and returned to the river. Overcoming community opposition through collective action, South Africa We are working as part of a collective action group, facilitated by a leading NGO, to combat community concerns around the legacy of declining water quality associated with historical acid and metalliferous drainage. This engagement process has allowed us to share information, build community trust and confidence in our operations, and identify key areas for shared rehabilitation. Innovative water management through employee engagement We have engaged our employees on the importance of water to our business and our commitment to water stewardship. This has received a very positive response and generated a range of innovative ideas for water conservation and green-infrastructure opportunities across our operational facilities. Appendix E 104 ICMM 34–37 Liverpool Street London EC2M 7PP United Kingdom +44 [0] 20 7467 5070 info@icmm.com icmm.com Disclaimer This publication contains general guidance only and should not be relied upon as a substitute for appropriate technical expertise. Although reasonable precautions have been taken to verify the information contained in this publication as of the date of publication, it is being distributed without warranty of any kind, either express or implied. This document has been prepared with the input of various International Council on Mining and Metals (‘ICMM’) members and other parties. However, the responsibility for its adoption and application rests solely with each individual member company. At no stage does ICMM or any individual company accept responsibility for the failures or liabilities of any other member company, and expressly disclaims the same. Each ICMM member company is responsible for determining and implementing management practices at its facility, and ICMM expressly disclaims any responsibility related to determination or implementation of any management practice. Each ICMM member company is responsible for determining and implementing management practices at its facility, and ICMM expressly disclaims any responsibility related to determination or implementation of any management practice. Moreover, although ICMM and its members are committed to an aspirational goal of zero fatalities at any mine site or facility, mining is an inherently hazardous industry, and this goal unfortunately has yet to be achieved. In no event shall ICMM (including its officers, directors, and affiliates, as well as its contributors, reviewers, or editors to this publication) be liable for damages or losses of any kind, however arising, from the use of or reliance on this document, or implementation of any plan, policy, guidance, or decision, or the like, based on this general guidance. ICMM, its officers, and its directors expressly disclaim any liability of any nature whatsoever, whether under equity, common law, tort, contract, estoppel, negligence, strict liability, or any other theory, for any direct, incidental, special, punitive, consequential, or indirect damages arising from or related to the use of or reliance on this document. The responsibility for the interpretation and use of this publication lies with the user (who should not assume that it is error-free or that it will be suitable for the user’s purpose) and ICMM. ICMM’s officers and directors assume no responsibility whatsoever for errors or omissions in this publication or in other source materials that are referenced by this publication, and expressly disclaim the same. Except where explicitly stated otherwise, the views expressed do not necessarily represent the decisions or the stated policy of ICMM, its officers, or its directors, and this document does not constitute a position statement or other mandatory commitment that members of ICMM are obliged to adopt. ICMM, its officers, and its directors are not responsible for, and make no representation(s) about, the content or reliability of linked websites, and linking should not be taken as endorsement of any kind. We have no control over the availability of linked pages and accept no responsibility for them. The designations employed and the presentation of the material in this publication do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of ICMM, its officers, or its directors concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning delimitation of any frontiers or boundaries. In addition, the mention of specific entities, individuals, source materials, trade names, or commercial processes in this publication does not constitute endorsement by ICMM, its officers, or its directors. This disclaimer should be construed in accordance with the laws of England. ICMM stands for mining with principles. We bring together a third of the global metals and mining industry, along with key partners to drive leadership, action and innovation for sustainable development, ultimately delivering a positive contribution to society. Through collaboration, ICMM member companies set the standard for responsibly produced minerals and metals in a safe, just and sustainable world. June 2023 _Ref69660932 _Ref69221644 _Ref69662577 _Ref69213379 _Ref69213355 _Ref69221656 _Ref73702209 _Ref73702211 _Ref63773410 _Ref69666055 _Ref69666027 _Ref69666125 _Ref63171804 _Ref69474707 _Ref70084346 _Ref70084383 _Ref70084403 _Ref70084416 _Ref70084429 _Ref70087469 _Ref70090200 _Ref70005106 _Ref70007963 _Ref69474650 _Ref69474719 _Ref73708810 _Ref69474740 _Ref69474747 _Ref70084392 _Ref70085346 _Ref70086137 _Hlk70089330 _Ref69474678 _Ref69906882 _Ref69665980 _Ref69906192 _Ref70055975 _Ref69906327 _Ref69906894supply provision — Water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) services (amenities) Discharge Quality Limit Types — Regulatory (external) — Recognised guidelines (external) — Self-determined (internal) — None undertaking site level water accounting and assessment for external reporting, as outlined below and illustrated in Figure 1. — Water catchment boundary: The physical boundary that defines the extent of the maximum direct influence of the site on the local environment and stakeholders, aligned with water catchment boundaries.14 The water catchment boundary is typically used as the limit for site level water risk, opportunity and response assessments (see Section 2.5). Therefore, determining an effective scale for the boundary is fundamental to making accurate assessments (see Box 2:4). — Operational boundary: The physical boundary that defines the geographical extent of the site’s operational activities and typically aligns with the site’s legal boundaries (eg as described by mining leases, tenements or other permitting). The boundary may also define the extent of the site’s 2.3 Understanding and setting site boundaries Defining appropriate boundary conditions is critical to developing consistent site level accounting and assessment. Boundary conditions are set relative to the purpose and objectives of the work being undertaken and determine if or how water is considered, accounted for and assessed relative to the site. In the context of site level accounting and assessment for external reporting purposes, three key boundary types to consider are spatial, materiality and temporal – as outlined below. It is also important to review these boundary conditions when preparing information for external reporting, especially for water metrics to avoid double counting (see Section 3.3.2). 2.3.1 Spatial boundaries Spatial boundaries define what to include from an entity, geographical, physical or legal perspective. Three types of spatial boundaries are usually considered when 16Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 environmental management responsibilities and associated practices. The operational boundary is typically used to understand the extent of a site’s operational activities. — Operational water system boundary: The accounting boundary that defines the extent of the site’s operational water system, including all operational activities which require or use water (eg mineral processing, dust control, waste management, product handling or transportation and power generation); and all water stores or treatment plants which are part of the operational water system. The operational water system boundary is conceptually based and may not directly align with the geographical boundary of the site. The boundary is fundamental to consistent site water accounting, and determines how water within the operational boundary is classified, accounted and reported (see Section 2.4). 17Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Box 2:5 Further reference Determining an appropriate scale for water catchment boundaries — ICMM (2015), A Practical Guide to Catchment- Based Water Management for the Mining and Metals Industry. p.31. — Alliance for Water Stewardship (AWS) (2019), International Water Stewardship Standard, Version 2.0. pp.40–45. Setting water boundaries — ICMM (2015), A Practical Guide to Catchment- Based Water Management for the Mining and Metals Industry. p.29. Box 2:4 Point to note Determining an appropriate scale for site water catchment boundaries (based on the Alliance for Water Stewardship [AWS] approach)13 Water catchments may be defined at a range of scales from small sub-catchments measuring a few square kilometres, to very large catchments which span half a continent (eg the Amazon river catchment in South America, the Congo river catchment in Africa, or the Mississippi river catchment in North America). Determining an appropriate scale for a site’s water catchment is fundamental to accurately assessing water risks and opportunities relating to the site and developing an effective management response. Aligned with the AWS’ approach, a site’s water catchment should be defined at a scale which includes: — The upstream area within which the actions of other stakeholders (eg changes in water or land practices) would have a material impact on the site’s water withdrawals or management practices. — The downstream area within which the site’s water management practices (including water withdrawal, discharge and consumption) would have a material impact on water resources (ie flow dynamics and quality), other stakeholders and ecosystems. Broader areas will need to be considered if the site straddles more than one catchment; or if inter- catchment water transfers are present (either withdrawals or discharges). Setting boundaries for sites with complex ownership models and joint ventures (JVs) When setting accounting and assessment boundaries for the purpose of meeting the minimum reporting commitments, it is important to consider and set boundaries relative to the company’s water requirements (ie the water required to sustain the company’s operational assets and meet the company’s production targets). For guidance on JVs see Section 3.3.1. Where a company’s asset is nested within a third-party operation, accounting and assessment boundaries should be set relative to the limits of each company’s assets. This enables transparent accounting of the water required for each company to achieve its respective operational objectives. However, when undertaking environmental impact type assessments for the purpose of local permitting and reporting, it may be necessary to revise these boundaries and take a more holistic view of the net impact of the entire operation (ie both companies’ assets). 18Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Operational water withdrawal (reporting metric) Volume of water that enters the operational water system used to meet the operational water demand Other managed water withdrawal (reporting metric) Volume of water that is actively managed without intent to supply the operational demand Total consumption (reporting metric) Total volume of water that is removed by evaporation, entrainment (in waste or product) or other losses, and not released back to surface water, groundwater, seawater or a third party Total discharge (reporting metric) Total volume of water that is released back to the environment (surface water, ground or seawater) or a third party Reuse-recycle (reporting metric) Total volume of worked water used in operational tasks with or without treatment Water catchment boundary Operational boundary Store Operational water system Operational w ater u se optional (reporting m etric) Worked water TaskTreatment Operational water Other managed water Consumption Discharge New water Figure 1: Site water accounting boundaries and reporting metrics 2.3.2 Materiality boundaries Materiality boundaries define what to include based on significance,15 and will depend on the local context of the site. In general, a water flow (volume), risk or opportunity is considered to be material and should be included if it: — Influences water-related decisions made by internal and external stakeholders using the information (at the scale of the assessment). — May have a significant impact (negative or positive) on the site, environment, local stakeholders or communities (at the scale of the assessment). Additional points to consider for sitelevel water accounting and assessment are outlined below. — Site water accounting: Material flows will typically include those which comprise a material component of the site water balance, influence internal water management practices or require specific management actions. However, it is important to note that depending on the local context even relatively small volume flows, changes in timing or water qualities may have significant impacts and may therefore be material. — Site water risk and opportunity assessment: Assessments should be made using standard company risk frameworks (ie which define likelihood and consequence thresholds for the company) to ensure comparability of results between sites. 19Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 2.3.3 Temporal boundaries Temporal boundaries define the time step or period of the accounting or assessment. In general, external reporting is undertaken on an annual cycle and supporting site data are compiled to align with the reporting cycle, as outlined below. — Water accounting: While corporate water reporting is usually annual, collection of site data for operational management and accounting typically occurs on a range of intervals (daily, weekly, monthly or quarterly) depending on the nature of the data collected. In addition, corporate reporting cycles may not align with the timing of site level reporting to meet local regulatory or permitting conditions. Therefore, it is often useful to compile relevant data at a common temporal interval appropriate for the purpose (eg monthly) to allow simple data extraction for the reporting period required. In addition, it is valuable to compile and review data on a regular basis throughout the reporting period (eg at least quarterly) to allow on-going validation of data collection and quality. Review of successive years of data allows longer term trends or variabilities to be identified, eg those relating to operational changes or climatic influences. — Water risk and opportunity assessment: Assessments are often undertaken or updated on an (sub-)annual cycle corresponding to the external reporting cycle; and should also be updated following any material changes (eg operational, environmental, social, political or regulatory). Due to both the granularity of the assessment and the typically multi-year nature of the risks, opportunities and responses, year-on-year changes may be relatively small. Therefore, it may be valuable to consider the results of each annual assessment relative to previous results to identify any longer- term trends. Although not required to meet the minimum reporting commitments, companies may also choose to include an element of forward projection in the risk and opportunity assessment (ie by repeating the assessment for current and one or more future states, such as now, 2025 and 2035). Box 2:7 Tips and tools Box 2:6 Operational examples Assessing the materiality of flows (from WAF)9 Examples of material flows: — A wet weather event which requires pumping of water from active workings and discharge to a local stream. — The provision of low volumes of potable water to a mine camp or local community. — The discharge of low volumes of water to a local stream that is critical to maintaining ecosystem function. Example of a non-material flow: — The direct rainfall input to a small dam that is not significant in comparison to the magnitude of broader inflows to the site. Reconciling different ‘water years’ Site level water data are often collated for an annual ‘water year’ defined by the local climatic conditions (eg wet and dry seasons). These may not align with financial or corporate reporting cycles or year-ends, and may vary across a company’s portfolio, especially where sites are situated across broad geographies. Therefore, it is often useful to compile all relevant data at a common temporal interval (eg monthly) to allow simple data extraction for the reporting purpose and period required. Recording material operational changes (to aid data validation) It is good practice to record any material changes in operational activity as they occur during the reporting period. The record can be used to support the regular validation of data collection and quality, and to explain apparent anomalies. 20Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 and underground mines; to manage the quality of run-off from disturbed ground; or to provide water to local townships and communities in remote areas. ICMM recognises two types of water to allow full transparency of the different ways in which mining and metals operations access, manage and interact with water, as outlined below and illustrated in Figure 1. — Operational water relates to water that enters the operational water system used to meet the operational water demand; and is therefore available for use by the site within an operational task or activity. Once within the operational water system, operational water may be tasked (ie used in an operational activity which requires water), treated or stored; and ultimately may be released back to the environment (surface water, groundwater or seawater) or a third party (discharged), or removed from the local water system (consumed). Operational water volumes are accounted and included in ICMM water reporting metrics. — Other managed water (OMW) relates to water that is actively managed (eg physically pumped, actively treated or has material consumptive losses) without intent to supply the operational water demand (ie is not used by the site within an operational task or activity). OMW is withdrawn from the environment or a third party and may be treated or stored, before being released back to the environment or transferred to a third party. Active management of the water may also result in some removal of water from the local water system (consumption) – eg due to evaporation during storage, or other losses associated with water treatment. OMW volumes are accounted and included in ICMM water reporting metrics. This distinction in water types is the basis of generating consistent ICMM reporting metrics which enable effective benchmarking across differing contexts and scales (site, asset, company, industry and cross- industry). ICMM reporting metrics are based on the MCA’s WAF (as outlined in Appendix B), and collectively describe all material water volumes and qualities (categorised) associated with the operation of a site. As illustrated in Figure 1, ICMM reporting metrics describe: — Water inflows and outflows associated with the site – including water withdrawal, discharge and consumption (see Sections 2.4.3–2.4.5). Box 2:8 Operational examples How to account the timing of snow melt to the site water balance The situation: Snow melt provides a material water input to the operational water balance of a gold mining operation. However, there is often a lag between when the snow falls (eg in December) and when it melts (eg in March) which does not align with the company’s reporting year (eg the calendar year). How to account snow melt: The contribution from snow fall should be accounted in the site water balance at the point of entry to the accounting boundaries of the operation, as outlined below. — Timing: Water associated with snow fall typically enters the site water balance in the (useable) form of melt water. In this example, the water would be accounted when it enters the operational water balance as melt water during the snow melt period from March onwards. So, snow which physically falls in one calendar year would be accounted in the following reporting period. This approach is preferredas: - It provides a more accurate representation of water movement and availability on the site; and - Reflects when that volume of water would otherwise become available to the environment. — Measurement: Accounting the contribution of snow fall as melt water simplifies measurement and allows the use of standard estimation approaches. However, estimates of snow quantities may still be used to reconcile snow melt volumes where useful. 2.4 Site water accounting and ICMM reporting metrics As outlined in Section 1.1, all mining and metals facilities need water to sustain operations (eg dust control, mineral processing and concentrating, waste management and power generation). However, mining operations may also manage substantial volumes of water for other reasons than to meet the operational water demand. For example, to control groundwater levels and maintain safe working conditions in open pits 21Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 — Key water flows and dynamics internal to the site – including operational water reuse/recycle, operational water use, and change in storage (delta storage) (see Sections 2.4.6 –2.4.8). The ICMM water reporting metrics required to meet the minimum reporting commitments (see Table 1) are summarised in Table 3; and a template for reporting these metrics is provided in Table 4. It is important to note that reporting of water intensity metrics is not required, nor recommended, at the minimum level due to challenges in defining an intensity metric which is meaningful and benchmarkable at the company level (see Section 3.3.2). To promote achievability while driving consistency, the minimum commitments for water metrics include reporting of: — Water withdrawal volumes split by operational water versus OMW to enable transparency and benchmarking of water for supply (operational water), versus water which is actively managed without intent to meet the site water demand (OMW). — Total volumes (operational water and OMW) for water discharge and water consumption aligned with external stakeholder interests as an indicator of the overall potential of impact, risk or opportunity associated with a site or company. It is recognised that sites or companies may choose to account and report more granular water metrics to provide greater transparency of their water dependencies, risks and opportunities, as relevant to their operational context and company reporting strategy. For example, companies may choose to account and report discharge volumes and/or consumption volumes split by operational water and OMW (see Box 2:9). This may be important in operating contexts where OMW volumes are substantial (eg dues to operational dewatering or the provision of community supply); or where consumptive losses associated with specific operational activities are of particular interest to catchment stakeholders. To support companies in going beyond the minimum level, discharge and consumption flows in the operational examples provided in this section are also classified as operational water or OMW. An example of the range of more granular metrics which may be accounted at the site level for external reporting purposes, and their relationship with the minimum reporting commitments metrics, is illustrated in Table 5. Key points to consider when developing site water accounts, classifying water quality and generating site reporting metrics are outlined in the following sections. In addition, an operational example of creating a site water account and generating ICMM water reporting metrics is provided in Appendix C. Box 2:9 Point to note Revised terminology: OMW (formerly diversions) ICMM OMW was previously termed ‘diversions’ in the first edition of the ICMM water reporting guidance16 and is equivalent to WAF diversions.9 The terminology has been revised to: — Better reflect the definition of the water as water that is actively managed (eg physically pumped, actively treated or has material consumptive losses) without intent to supply the operational water demand. — Enhance understanding as the term ‘diversions’ was commonly misunderstood to include surface water that is physically diverted within the landscape (eg culverts and stream realignments) without being actively managed. Going beyond the minimum: reporting consumption and discharge metrics To provide greater transparency of water dependencies, risks and opportunities, companies may choose to go beyond the minimum commitment and report discharge volumes and/or consumption volumes split by operational water and OMW. In such situations, it is important to recognise operational water and OMW (and associated withdrawals, discharge, consumption) as two separate streams within the site water accounting model as illustrated below and aligned to MCA’s WAF (see Appendix B). 22Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Key changes to ICMM water reporting metrics and reporting requirements (relative to first edition) — Include OMW volumes in reporting of withdrawal, discharge and consumption metrics (in order to provide greater transparency of a site’s/company’s holistic water dependencies and activities). - See Section 2.4. — Report withdrawal (operational water and OMW), total discharge and total consumption volumes for water stressed areas (to provide clarity and context for reuse/recycle volumes). - See Sections 2.4.3–2.4.5 and Section 2.5.2. — Report water consumption as total volumes only (rather than as the constituent components of evaporation, entrainment and other losses, by water quality). - See Section 2.4.5. — Report reuse/recycle volumes (rather than efficiency percentages). - See Section 2.4.6. — Recommend reporting of operational water use volumes (for clarity). - See Section 2.4.7. — Recommend reporting of the annual change in storage (delta storage) (for clarity). - See Section 2.4.8. Box 2:9 – continued Point to note Operational water withdrawal Other managed water withdrawal Operational boundary Operational water system Operational water consumption Operational water discharge Other managed water consumption Other managed water discharge Total consumption Total discharge minimum reporting commitment minimum reporting commitment beyond minimum Operational water Other managed water 23Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Table 3 – Summary of ICMM water reporting metrics Metric ICMM Definition Minimum Reporting Commitment Reporting Rationale Metrics describing water inflows and outflows associated with the site/company Operational Water Withdrawal Water that enters the operational water system used to meet the operational water demand. Required: Reporting of aggregated volumes, by source type (surface water, groundwater, seawater and third party) and water quality category (high and low), for all sites within the company, and for all sites situated in water stressed areas. — Indicator of water dependency and access requirements and potential for associated risks and opportunities (including circular water management and use of low quality water). — Allows transparency around water withdrawal to meet the operational water demand (ie for use) and enables benchmarking. Other Managed Water (OMW) Withdrawal Water that is actively managed (eg physically pumped, actively treated or has material consumptive losses) without intent to supply the operational water demand. Required: Reporting of aggregated volumes (from all sources), by water quality category (high and low), for all sites withinthe company, and for all sites situated in water stressed areas. — Indicator of holistic water dependencies, activities and potential for associated risks and opportunities – especially in contexts where OMW volumes are high due to operating dynamics (eg dewatering activities or community supply) or climatic factors (eg wet weather events). Total Discharge All water that is released to the water environment (surface water, groundwater or seawater) or to a third party (including operational water and OMW). Required: Reporting of aggregated total volumes (operational water plus OMW), by destination type (surface water, groundwater, seawater and third party) and water quality category (high and low), for all sites within the company, and for all sites situated in water stressed areas. — Indicator of water dependency and potential for associated risks and opportunities relating to the downstream catchment and other stakeholders (including water quality risks and circular water management opportunities). Total Consumption All water that is removed by evaporation, entrainment (in product or waste) or other losses, and not released back to surface water, groundwater, seawater or a third party. Required: Reporting of aggregated total volumes (operational water plus OMW), for all sites within the company, and for all sites situated in water stressed areas. — Indicator of water dependency and potential risks associated with water losses. Metrics describing water flows internal to the site/company Reuse/ recycle Water that has been used in an operational task and is recovered and used again in an operational task, either without treatment (reuse) or with treatment (recycle). Required: Reporting of aggregated volumes for all sites within the company, and for all sites situated in water stressed areas. — Indicator of internal water management practices and ability to optimise systems to reduce withdrawal volumes – particularly in water stressed areas (where water availability is typically low and competition for access is high). Operational water use The volume of water used in operational tasks. Recommended: Reporting of aggregated volumes for all sites within the company, and for all sites situated in water stressed areas. — Indicator of water dependency and internal water management practices. — Provides context for understanding withdrawal volumes. Delta storage (∆Storage) The net change (positive or negative) in the volume of water in storage (operational water and OMW) during the reporting period. Recommended: Reporting of aggregated volumes for all sites within the company, and for all sites situated in water stressed areas. — Indicator of internal water management dynamics. — Allows transparency of all elements of the water balance. 24Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Table 4 – Metrics required to meet the ICMM minimum reporting requirements ICMM WATER Reporting Metrics Metric Source/Destination/Type Volume of Water by Quality High (ML) Low (ML) Total (ML) All sites Operational Water Withdrawal Surface Water Groundwater Seawater Third-Party Water Total Other Managed Water (OMW) Withdrawal Total Dischargea Surface Water Groundwater Seawater Supply to Third Party Total Total Consumptiona Operational water reuse/recycle Operational water use recommended Change in storage (delta storage) recommended Sites situated in water stressed areasb Operational Water Withdrawal Surface Water Groundwater Seawater Third-Party Water Total Other Managed Water (OMW) Withdrawal Total Dischargea Surface Water Groundwater Seawater Supply to Third Party Total Total Consumptiona Operational water reuse/recycle Operational water use recommended Change in storage (delta storage) recommended Water stress exposure (all sites) Unit – tick as appropriate Value Proportion of sites situated in water stressed areas No. sites % sites Notes: a Includes ICMM operational water and OMW. b See Box 2:21 for guidance on indentifying areas of water stress. 25Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Table 5 – Example of additional granular site metrics ICMM Consistent Water Reporting Metrics Metric Source/ destination Operational Water OMW Total High (ML) Low (ML) Total (ML) High (ML) Low (ML) Total (ML) High (ML) Low (ML) Total (ML) Withdrawal Surface Water Groundwater Seawater Supply to Third Party Total Discharge Surface Water Groundwater Seawater Supply to Third Party Total Consumption Evaporation Entrainment Other losses Total Operational water reuse/recycle Operational water use recommended Change in storage (delta storage) recommended Notes: Metrics required to meet the minimum reporting commitments (as detailed in Table 1 and Table 4). 26Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 2.4.1 Generating consistent site water metrics for reporting Consistent water metrics for external reporting are derived from site water balance and water accounting information, as summarised in Box 2:10. An overview of the general concept of a water balance is provided in Box 2:11; and a worked example of generating site water reporting metrics from site water balance and accounting information is provided in Appendix C. Box 2:10 Point to note Overview: Generating consistent site metrics for reporting Step 1: Site water balance What: A schematic model of the main operational water components, infrastructure and material flows (quantity and quality) associated with the site – will typically include: — Pits and underground workings — Mineral processing and tailings thickening facilities — Waste co-disposal and TSFs — Water dams, stores and tanks — Other key water infrastructure (eg treatment plants (if any), pipes, pumps, flow meters) — Water inflows and outflows (eg precipitation run-off, surface water, groundwater, seawater and third parties) — Consumptive losses (eg evaporation, entrainment and other losses). Why: A fundamental operational water management tool which provides the foundation of effective water management and consistent water reporting metrics. Used to optimise operational performance, manage risk, and inform business critical decisions – for example to: — Understand current and future water demand and availability, infrastructure capacity requirements, water quality constraints, treatment or storage requirements, and discharge quantities and qualities. — Assess potential environmental impacts and develop appropriate management and mitigation strategies. — Evaluate alternative water management options for different scenarios (eg operational, climatic or catchment). Sub-site water balances may also be developed to better understand or manage particular components of the overall site balance – for example, TSFs, water reticulation in underground workings, processing plants or imported water requirements (see Figure 2 and Box 2:11). How: The development of a site water balance is a complex process, which requires specialist input and draws on a range data inputs – which typically include: — Mine processing and dewatering data (eg mine plan, production rates and characteristics). — Physical data (eg topographic and bathymetric maps, survey results and digital terrain models). — Climatic data (eg precipitation and evaporation data) — Hydrological data (eg run-off coefficients, surface water flows, groundwater monitoring). — Water storage facility characteristics (egdesign specifications or as-built survey data). — Water flow and quality data (eg calibrated flow meter data, water truck counts, water quality monitoring). A range of approaches may be used to develop a site water balance, as appropriate to the operational complexity, water dynamics and risk profile of the site. Two common approaches include: — Deterministic models – which use set values for key data inputs to evaluate specific scenarios; and are typically developed using a simple spreadsheet approach. 27Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 02 0301 Box 2:10 – continued Point to note — Probabilistic models – which include uncertainty analysis of key variables/poorly constrained parameters to understand sensitivities and evaluate the likelihood of certain outcomes; and are typically developed using specific modelling software (eg Goldsim or Opsim). The site water balance is a live management tool which should be reviewed and updated on a regular basis (annually as a minimum), or following any material changes (operational, organisational, environmental, etc). Step 2: Site water account What: A simplified accounting model of the site water balance — where the detail and complexity of the site water balance is simplified into an accounting view which represents all key components and flows in a consistent way. Key elements of a site water account include: 1. Input-Output model – describes water inputs (operational water withdrawals and other managed water) and outputs (consumption and discharge) to/from the site. 2. Operational model – describes water flows internal to the site that occur between: - Stores – purpose built structures designed to collect or hold operational water (eg tanks, dams, reservoirs and disused pits). - Tasks – operational activities that require or use water (eg for mineral processing, waste management or dust control). Note: dewatering is not a task as it generates rather than uses water. - Treatment plants (if any) – facilities that use active methods (ie requiring energy or physical inputs, eg chemicals) for the primary purpose of improving water quality. The operational model also describes the status of water within the site as: - New water – water that has not previously been used by the site in an operational task. - Worked water – water that has previously been used by the site in an operational task. 3. Accuracy statement – describes the percentage of flows that are measured, simulated or estimated (with associated confidence levels). Why: Provides a consistent basis for benchmarking, optimising and communicating water dynamics to a range of intemal and external stakeholders. Provides the basis for calculating operational water reuse/recycle and operational water use metrics (see Sections 2.4.6 and 2.4.7). How: Based on the site water balance, all water components and flows are classified, and those with common characteristics are aggregated to the highest possible level, and represented once within the accounting model to provide the simplification. During the aggregation process: — All water stores are classified as either new water stores (which only receive new water) or mixed water stores (which receive both worked and new water) and represented once respectively — All tasks are aggregated to the highest possible level to ensure consistent operational water reuse/ recycle metrics -recommended task aggregation types and levels are provided in Appendix C Further guidance — A worked example is provided in Appendix C. — Detailed guidance is provided in MCA (2014) Water Accounting Framework for the Minerals Industry: User Guide, v1.3. Step 3: Site reporting metrics What: A set of consistent water reporting metrics that are appropriately defined for the mining and metals industry, and collectively describe all material water volumes and qualities (categorised) associated with the site. Why: Benchmarkable metrics for external reporting and broader communication processes. How: Reporting metrics are directly based on the site water account, as outlined in Sections 2.4.3 to 2.4.8 and illustrated in Appendix C. 28Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 Guidance: Internal Site Level Accounting and Assessment 30Water Reporting: Good Practice Guide: 2nd Edition 02 0301 Seepage collection ponds Tailings slurry Evaporation Precipitation Surface runo Decant reclaim Entrainment Seepage Water table Operational example: accounting Tailings Storage Facilities (TSFs) Key flows to consider when accounting water associated with a TSF Evaporation Flow type: ICMM consumption (op water) Description: Evaporation of standing water within the TSF (supernatant pond), as a minimum; plus evaporation from shallow saturated tailings (to extinguishment depth), where known. Quantification: Calculated using hydrological model or estimated [based on pond surface area, beach areas, measured evaporation rate or typical pan-evaporation rate with correction factor] Case study flow (ML/a): 900 Calculation: 900 ML/a = 0.01 x 50 ha x 1,800 mm/a Precipitation Flow type: ICMM operational water (op water) withdrawal Description: Direct capture of rainfall and/or snowfall Water quality category: ICMM high (WAF Category 1) Quantification: Calculated using hydrological model or estimated [based on TSF surface area and measured/ reference precipitation data] Case study flow (ML/a): 285 Calculation: 285 ML/a = 0.01 x 50 ha x 570 mm/a Tailings slurry Flow type: Internal Description: Water contained in tailings slurry Water quality category: ICMM low (WAF Category 3) Quantification: Measured or estimated [based on tailings input quantity and typical moisture/solids proportion] Case study flow (ML/a): 6,960 Calculation: 6,960 ML/a as 9,280 Mt/a of thickened tailings at 75% moisture Seepage to groundwater (GW) Flow type: ICMM discharge (op water) Description: Seepage of water from saturated tailings to groundwater system Water quality category: Typically ICMM low (WAF Category 3) Quantification: Calculated using hydrogeological model or estimated (with sense check to close the balance); only derived by balance where unable to estimate (due to high error margins) Case study flow (ML/a): 1,500 Calculation: Estimated through back calculation (includes decant transmission loss) Schematic TSF not to scale Note on data: Actual monitoring and measurement data should always be used, where available, in preference to modelling or estimation approaches. Mixed water store Process plant Evaporation Precipitation & run-o TSF Entrainment Seepage to GW 2404,860 1,500 900 6,960 540 Accounting view & reporting metrics Operational water withdrawal Discharge Consumption Run-off Flow type: ICMM operational water withdrawal Description: direct capture of run-off Water quality category: Variable depending on land use (typically ICMM high, WAF Category 1 or 2) Quantification: Calculated using hydrological model or estimated [based on TSF catchment surface area, measured/reference precipitation data and typical run-off coefficients] Case study flow (ML/a): 255 Calculation: 255 ML/a = 0.01 x 150 ha x 570 mm/a x 0.298 Reclaim water Flow type: Internal Description: Water recovered from the TSF via different methods (eg decant towers and barges, collection drains or wells), typically for treatment, reuse or release Water quality category: Typically ICMM low (WAF Category 3) Quantification: Measured (eg flow meters and water store volumes) Case study flow (ML/a): 4,860 Calculation: Measured Tailings entrainment Flow type: ICMM consumption (op water) Description: Water permanently contained in waste tailings Quantification: Calculated from measured, estimated or modelled parameters [based on tailings tonnage and composition, eg void ratio,