Baixe o app para aproveitar ainda mais
Prévia do material em texto
Artigo recebido em: 13.06.2016 Aprovado em: 31.10.2016 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 GOVERNO DOS ALGORITMOS Sergio Amadeu Silveira1 Universidade Federal do ABC (UFABC) Resumo (VWH�WH[WR�WUDWD�GD�JRYHUQDPHQWDOLGDGH�GRV�DOJRULWPRV�QR�VHWRU�S~EOLFR��'HEDWH� DV�QRo}HV�GH�JRYHUQR��JRYHUQDQoD�H�JRYHUQDPHQWDOLGDGH��$�SDUWLU�GHVVDV�GH¿- nições mostra o nível de penetração dos algoritmos em nossa sociedade e indica D�WHQGrQFLD�GH�H[SDQVmR�GH�VHX�XVR�QDV�LQVWLWXLo}HV�GR�(VWDGR��3RU�¿P��DQDOLVD� DV�LPSOLFDo}HV�GRV�DOJRULWPRV�QR�VHWRU�S~EOLFR�H�RV�GHVD¿RV�GH�PDQWr�ORV�VRE� FRQWUROH�GH�XPD�JHVWmR�GHPRFUiWLFD�H�VRFLDOPHQWH�LQFOXVLYD��VXSHUDQGR�DV�SHUV- SHFWLYDV�WHFQRFUiWLFDV��SRVLWLYLVWDV�H�QHROLEHUDLV�� 3DODYUDV�FKDYH��$OJRULWPR�� JRYHUQDPHQWDOLGDGH� DOJRUtWPLFD�� UHJXODomR� DOJR- UtWPLFD��SHUIRUPDWLYLGDGH��WHFQRSROtWLFD� GOVERNMENT OF ALGORITHMS $EVWUDFW 7KLV�SDSHU�GLVFXVVHV� WKH�JRYHUQPHQWDOLW\�RI� DOJRULWKPV� LQ� WKH�SXEOLF� VHFWRU�� ,W�GHEDWHV�WKH�QRWLRQV�RI�JRYHUQPHQW��JRYHUQDQFH�DQG�JRYHUQPHQWDOLW\��)URP� WKHVH� GH¿QLWLRQV� VKRZ� WKH� OHYHO� RI� SHQHWUDWLRQ� RI� DOJRULWKPV� LQ� RXU� VRFLHW\� DQG�LQGLFDWHV�WKH�WUHQG�RI�H[SDQVLRQ�RI�LWV�XVH�LQ�VWDWH�LQVWLWXWLRQV��)LQDOO\��LW� DQDO\]HV�WKH�LPSOLFDWLRQV�RI�DOJRULWKPV�LQ�WKH�SXEOLF�VHFWRU�DQG�WKH�FKDOOHQJHV� RI�NHHSLQJ�WKHP�XQGHU�WKH�FRQWURO�RI�D�GHPRFUDWLF�DQG�VRFLDOO\�LQFOXVLYH�PD- QDJHPHQW��VXUSDVVLQJ�WKH�WHFKQRFUDWLF��SRVLWLYLVW�DQG�QHROLEHUDO�SHUVSHFWLYHV� .H\�ZRUGV��$OJRULWKP��DOJRULWKPLF�JRYHUQDPHQWDOLW\��DOJRULWKPLF�UHJXODWLRQ�� SHUIRUPDWLYLW\��WHFKQRSROLWLFV� 1� &LHQWLVWD� 6RFLDO�� 'RXWRU� HP� &LrQFLD� 3ROtWLFD� SHOD� 8QLYHUVLGDGH� GH� 6mR� 3DXOR� �863��� 3URIHVVRU�GD�8QLYHUVLGDGH�)HGHUDO�GR�$%&��8)$%&���(�PDLO� VHUJLR�DPDGHX#XIDEF� edu.br���8QLYHUVLGDGH�)HGHUDO�GR�$%&���8)$%&��$Y��GRV�(VWDGRV���������%DLUUR�6DQWD� Terezinha - Santo André. CEP: 09210-580 268 Sergio Amadeu Silveira DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 1 INTRODUÇÃO $OJRULWPRV� SRGHP� VHU� GH¿QLGRV� FRPR� URWLQDV� ORJLFDPHQWH� HQFDGHDGDV��7DPEpP�SRGHP� VHU� FRPSUHHQGLGRV� FRPR�R� FRQMXQWR� GH�LQVWUXo}HV�LQWURGX]LGDV�HP�XPD�PiTXLQD�SDUD�UHVROYHU�XP�SUR- EOHPD�EHP�GH¿QLGR���,17521$���������³$OJRULWPRV�ID]HP�FRLVDV�� e sua sintaxe incorpora uma estrutura de comando para permitir que LVVR�DFRQWHoD�´��*2))(<��������S�������(P�JHUDO��HOHV�H[SUHVVDP� XPD� VROXomR� FRPSXWDFLRQDO� HP� WHUPRV�GH� VXDV� FRQGLo}HV� OyJLFDV� �FRQKHFLPHQWR�VREUH�R�SUREOHPD��D�SDUWLU�GH�HVWUXWXUDV�GH�FRQWUROH�� RX�VHMD��HVWUDWpJLDV�SDUD�UHVROYHU�R�SUREOHPD���.2:$/6.,��������� ([SUHVV}HV� FRPR� VRFLHGDGH� GD� LQIRUPDomR� �0$&+/83�� ������RX� VRFLHGDGH�HP� UHGH� �&$67(//6�������� FRPS}HP�FHQi- ULRV�FDUDFWHUL]DGRV�SHOR�XVR�LQWHQVLYR�GH�VRIWZDUHV��0$129,&+�� ������R�TXH�LPSOLFD�D�DPSOD�GLVVHPLQDomR�GH�DOJRULWPRV��&HOXODUHV�� WDEOHWV��VPDUW�79V��YHtFXORV��VHPiIRURV�LQWHOLJHQWHV��PHFDQLVPRV�GH� EXVFD�QD�ZHE��VLVWHPDV�GH�DSURYDomR�GH�FUpGLWR�EDQFiULR��HQWUH�WDQ- WRV�RXWURV�H[HPSORV�FRUULTXHLURV��WRGRV�HVVHV�GLVSRVLWLYRV�LQGLFDP� a crescente presença dos algoritmos em nosso convívio. A paisagem VRFLRWpFQLFD�HVWi�UHSOHWD�GH�DOJRULWPRV��JUDoDV�D�VHX�HQRUPH�VXFHVVR� H�H¿FiFLD�HP�QRVVDV�UHODo}HV�VRFLDLV��HFRQ{PLFDV�H�SROtWLFDV��0HV- PR�DVVLP��VRIWZDUHV�H�DOJRULWPRV�VmR�LQYLVtYHLV�SDUD�D�PDLRULD�GDV� SHVVRDV��(VVHV�FyGLJRV� VmR�DSUHVHQWDGRV�SHOR�PHUFDGR�FRPR�DOJR� TXH�QmR�SUHFLVDPRV�VDEHU�FRPR�H[LVWHP�RX�FRPR�IXQFLRQDP��GHVGH� TXH�FXPSUDP�VXDV�¿QDOLGDGHV�� 2�VRFLyORJR�3KLOLS�1��+RZDUG���������HP�XPD�EULOKDQWH�FRP- SDUDomR�FRP�R�,PSpULR�5RPDQR��FKDPRX�GH�3D[�7pFQLFD�R�DUUDQMR� SROtWLFR��HFRQ{PLFR�H�FXOWXUDO�GH�LQVWLWXLo}HV�H�GLVSRVLWLYRV�HP�UHGH� QRV�TXDLV�JRYHUQR�H�LQG~VWULD�HVWmR�¿UPHPHQWH�OLJDGRV�HP�SDFWRV�GH� GHIHVD�P~WXD��FRODERUDQGR�FRP�SURMHWRV��FRP�GHVLJQ��FRP�D�GH¿QL- omR�GH�SDGU}HV��FRP�D�PLQHUDomR�H�DQiOLVH�GH�GDGRV��(VVH�DUUDQMR�� SRXFR�GHPRFUiWLFR�H�YROWDGR�SULRULWDULDPHQWH�DR�IRUWDOHFLPHQWR�GDV� FRUSRUDo}HV��WHQGH�D�VH�DPSOLDU�FDVR�QmR�VHMD�WRUQDGR�YLVtYHO��FDVR� RV�DOJRULWPRV�QmR�VHMDP�DQDOLVDGRV�FULWLFDPHQWH�GLDQWH�GR�DYDQoR�GH� WHFQRORJLDV�FRPR�%LJ�'DWD��,QWHUQHW�GDV�&RLVDV��0DFKLQH�/HDUQLQJ�H� ,QWHOLJrQFLD�$UWL¿FLDO��HQWUH�RXWUDV��� 269 GOVERNO DOS ALGORITMOS DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 2 GOVERNO, GOVERNANÇA E GOVERNAMENTALIDADE 4XDQGR�VH�SHQVD�QD�SDODYUD�JRYHUQR��DV�FRUUHQWHV�SULQFLSDLV� da Ciência Política tratam da instituição ou da ação em torno do Es- WDGR�PRGHUQR��2�VRFLyORJR�0D[�:HEHU�GH¿QLX�R�(VWDGR�FRPR�XPD� ³>���@�UHODomR�GH�GRPLQDomR�GR�KRPHP�VREUH�R�KRPHP��IXQGDGD�QR� LQVWUXPHQWR�GD�YLROrQFLD�OHJtWLPD��LVWR�p��GD�YLROrQFLD�FRQVLGHUDGD� FRPR�OHJtWLPD��´��:(%(5��������S�������*RYHUQDU��QHVVD�FRQFHS- omR��VLJQL¿FD�GLULJLU�D�SROtWLFD�GH�(VWDGR�H�H[SUHVVD�UHODo}HV�GH�SR- GHU��OHJLWLPLGDGH�H�GRPLQDomR� /XFLR�/HYL��������QRV�DOHUWRX�SDUD�D�GLIHUHQoD�TXH�D�SDODYUD� JRYHUQPHQW�DGTXLUH�QRV�SDtVHV�DQJOR�VD[{QLFRV�DTXLOR�TXH�QR�FRQWL- nente europeu se designa com a expressão regime político. O que se GHVLJQD�QD�,WiOLD�FRP�D�SDODYUD�*RYHUQR��³>���@�QD�OtQJXD�LQJOHVD�VH� usam outros termos como cabinet na Grã-Bretanha e administration QRV�(VWDGRV�8QLGRV�´��/(9,��������S��������-i�RV�UHJLPHV�SROtWLFRV� GL]HP�UHVSHLWR�DR�FRQMXQWR�GH�LQVWLWXLo}HV�TXH�UHJXODP�D�OXWD�SHOR� poder e seu exercício. Uma das mais conhecidas tipologias dos regi- PHV�SROtWLFRV�IRL�KHUGDGD�GH�$ULVWyWHOHV��JRYHUQR�GH�XP��JRYHUQR�GH� poucos e governo de muitos. (VWH�WH[WR�XWLOL]DUi�RXWUD�SHUVSHFWLYD�SDUD�R�WHUPR�JRYHUQR�� TXH� VHUi�EDVHDGD�QRV�HVWXGRV�GH�0LFKHO�)RXFDXOW��1R�FXUVR�GDGR� QR�&ROOqJH�GH�)UDQFH��HP������� LQWLWXODGR�6HJXUDQoD��7HUULWyULR�H� 3RSXODomR��)RXFDXOW������E��UHJLVWURX�XP�FRQMXQWR�GH�UHÀH[}HV�VR- bre as questões do governo e da governamentalidade a partir de sua DQiOLVH�GD�SROtWLFD�PRGHUQD�GRV�VpFXORV�;9,,�H�;9,,,� 3RU�JRYHUQDPHQWDOLGDGH��HX�HQWHQGR�R�FRQMXQWR�FRQVWLWXtGR�SHODV� LQVWLWXLo}HV��SURFHGLPHQWRV��DQiOLVHV�H�UHÀH[}HV��FiOFXORV�H�WiWLFDV� TXH�SHUPLWHP�H[HUFHU�HVVD�IRUPD�EDVWDQWH�HVSHFt¿FD�H�FRPSOH[D� GH�SRGHU�TXH�WHP�SRU�DOYR�D�SRSXODomR��FRPR�IRUPD�SULQFLSDO�GH� saber a economia política e por instrumentos técnicos essenciais os GLVSRVLWLYRV�GH�VHJXUDQoD��(P�VHJXQGR�OXJDU��SRU�³JRYHUQDPHQWD- OLGDGH´�HQWHQGR�D�WHQGrQFLD��D�OLQKD�GH�IRUoD�TXH��HP�WRGR�R�2FL- GHQWH��QmR�SDURX�GH�FRQGX]LU��H�GHVGH�Ki�PXLWR��SDUD�D�SUHHPLQrQ- FLD�GHVVH�WLSR�GH�SRGHU�TXH�SRGHPRV�FKDPDU�GH�³JRYHUQR´�VREUH� WRGRV�RV�RXWURV�±�VREHUDQLD��GLVFLSOLQD����H�TXH�WURX[H��SRU�XP�ODGR�� R�GHVHQYROYLPHQWR�GH�WRGD�XPD�VpULH�GH�DSDUHOKRV�HVSHFt¿FRV�GH� JRYHUQR�>H��SRU�RXWUR�ODGR@��R�GHVHQYROYLPHQWR�GH�WRGD�XPD�VpULH� GH�VDEHUHV��(Q¿P��SRU�³JRYHUQDPHQWDOLGDGH´��FUHLR�TXH�VH�GHYHULD� HQWHQGHU�R�SURFHVVR��RX�DQWHV��R�UHVXOWDGR�GR�SURFHVVR�SHOR�TXDO�R� (VWDGR�GH�MXVWLoD�GD�,GDGH�0pGLD��TXH�QRV�VpFXORV�;9�H�;9,�VH� 270 Sergio Amadeu Silveira DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 WRUQRX�(VWDGR�DGPLQLVWUDWLYR��YLX�VH�SRXFR�D�SRXFR�³JRYHUQDPHQ- WDOL]DGR´���)28&$8/7������E��S�����������JULIRV�GR�DXWRU��� *RYHUQDU�p�FRQGX]LU�FRQGXWDV��VHJXQGR�R�SHQVDGRU�IUDQFrV�� )RXFDXOW� FRQVLGHUD�TXH�R�SRGHU�QmR�H[SUHVVD� DSHQDV� FRQIURQWR�� R� SRGHU�FRQVWLWXL�WDPEpP�YtQFXORV��LQFOXVLYH�DTXHOHV�TXH�LPSOLFDP�R� JRYHUQR��3DUD�)RXFDXOW������E���H[LVWHP�IRUPDV�GH�JRYHUQR�GH�VL�H� GH�JRYHUQR�GRV�RXWURV��2�VLJQL¿FDGR�GR�WHUPR�JRYHUQR�p�EHP�PDLV� DPSOR�GR�TXH�R�FLUFXQVFULWR�SHOD�VXD�GH¿QLomR�GH�VREHUDQLD�H�SHODV� IRUPXODo}HV�MXUtGLFDV��$VVLP��JRYHUQR�WHP�XPD�VLJQL¿FDomR�EDVWDQ- WH�DPSOD�FRPR�D�H[LVWHQWH�QR�VpFXOR�;9,��³>���@�>R�JRYHUQR@�QmR�VH� UHIHULD�DSHQDV�jV�HVWUXWXUDV�SROtWLFDV�H�j�JHVWmR�GRV�(VWDGRV��PDV�GH- signava a maneira de dirigir a conduta dos indivíduos ou dos grupos: JRYHUQR�GDV�FULDQoDV��GDV�DOPDV��GDV�FRPXQLGDGHV��GDV�IDPtOLDV��GRV� GRHQWHV�´��)28&$8/7��������S������ $� LGHLD� GH�TXH�R� DWR�JRYHUQDU� ³>���@� p� HVWUXWXUDU� R� HYHQWXDO� FDPSR�GH�DomR�GRV�RXWURV�´� �)28&$8/7��������S�������VH� WRUQD� IXQGDPHQWDO�SDUD�DQDOLVDUPRV�FRPR�JHVWRUHV�H�FLGDGmRV�SRGHP�SHQ- sar o poder em relação aos dispositivos – os algoritmos – que são FULDGRV�SRU�HPSUHVDV�TXH��HP�PXLWRV�FDVRV��EXVFDP�REMHWLYRV�EHP� GLVWDQWHV�GDTXHOHV�GHFODUDGRV�SHODV�OHLV�H�SHORV�SURJUDPDV�H�SURMHWRV� IRUPXODGRV�QR�LQWHULRU�GR�(VWDGR��3HQVDGRUHV�OLEHUDLV�H�QHROLEHUDLV� buscaram explorar outro termo menos comprometido com o Estado H�PDLV�FRPSURPLVVDGR�FRP�D�FRQFRUUrQFLD�QR�PHUFDGR��RX�VHMD��R� termo governança. -DPHV�1��5RVHQDX���������FLHQWLVWD�SROtWLFR�QRUWH�DPHULFDQR�� SURSXQKD� XPD� GH¿QLomR� GH� JRYHUQDQoD� EHP�GLVWLQWD� GD� QRomR� GH� JRYHUQR��(VVHV�WHUPRV�HP�5RVHQDX��������S���������WrP�VLJQL¿FDGR� GLIHUHQWH�GRV�XWLOL]DGRV�SRU�)RXFDXOW��FRPR�SRGHPRV�QRWDU�D�VHJXLU� […] governo sugere atividades sustentadas por uma autoridade IRUPDO�� SHOR� SRGHU� GH� SROtFLD� TXH� JDUDQWH� D� LPSOHPHQWDomR� GDV� SROtWLFDV� GHYLGDPHQWH� LQVWLWXtGDV�� HQTXDQWR� JRYHUQDQoD� UHIHUH�VH� D� DWLYLGDGHV� DSRLDGDV� HP� REMHWLYRV� FRPXQV�� TXH� SRGHP� RX� QmR� GHULYDU�GH� UHVSRQVDELOLGDGHV� OHJDLV� IRUPDOPHQWH�SUHVFULWDV�H�QmR� GHSHQGHP��QHFHVVDULDPHQWH��GR�SRGHU�GH�SROtFLD�SDUD�TXH� VHMDP� DFHLWDV� H�YHQoDP� UHVLVWrQFLDV��(P�RXWUDV�SDODYUDV��JRYHUQDQoD�p� XP� IHQ{PHQR�PDLV� DPSOR� GR� TXH� JRYHUQR�� DEUDQJH� LQVWLWXLo}HV� JRYHUQDPHQWDLV��PDV� LPSOLFD� WDPEpP�HP�PHFDQLVPRV� LQIRUPDLV� GH� FDUiWHU� QmR�JRYHUQDPHQWDO�� TXH� ID]HP� FRP�TXH� DV� SHVVRDV� H� RUJDQL]Do}HV�GHQWUR�GH�VXD�iUHD�GH�DWXDomR�WHQKDP�XPD�FRQGXWD� GHWHUPLQDGD��VDWLVIDoDP�VXDV�QHFHVVLGDGHV�H�UHVSRQGDP�VXDV�GH- PDQGDV�>«@�$�JRYHUQDQoD�p�XP�VLVWHPD�GH�RUGHQDomR�TXH�Vy�IXQ- 271 GOVERNO DOS ALGORITMOS DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 FLRQD�VH�IRU�DFHLWR�SHOD�PDLRULD��RX�SHOR�PHQRV�SHORV�DWRUHV�PDLV� SRGHURVRV�GR�VHX�XQLYHUVR���HQTXDQWR�JRYHUQRV�SRGHP�IXQFLRQDU� PHVPR�HP�IDFH�GH�DPSOD�RSRVLomR�j�VXD�SROtWLFD�� $�SHUVSHFWLYD�OLEHUDO�GH�5RVHQDX��������p�EHP�QHJDWLYD�IUHQ- te ao governo. Rosenau (2000) parece considerar melhor o acordo HQWUH� DJHQWHV� FRP� JUDQGH� SRGHU� QD� VRFLHGDGH�� LQFOXLQGR� R� SRGHU� HFRQ{PLFR��GR�TXH�R�DUUDQMR�VREHUDQR�GH�SRGHU��PHVPR�TXDQGR�IXQ- GDGR�HP�XP�UHJLPH�GHPRFUiWLFR��$�DomR�GH�JRYHUQR��SDUD�5RXVHQDX� ��������UHPHWH�j�LQVWLWXLomR�HVWDWDO�H�JRYHUQDU�VLJQL¿FD�GLULJLU�D�LQV- WLWXLomR�GR�(VWDGR��3DUD�)RXFDXOW������E���������JRYHUQDU�p�FRQGX- zir condutas dos indivíduos e dos processos coletivos disseminados QD�VRFLHGDGH��LQFOXLQGR�D�GLVFLSOLQD�GRV�FRUSRV�H�R�FRQWUROH���6HP� G~YLGD��R�GLUHFLRQDPHQWR�GHVVDV�FRQGXWDV�WDPEpP�H[LVWH�GHQWUR�GR� (VWDGR�H�FRQGX]��WDPEpP��DV�Do}HV�GRV�JHVWRUHV�H�DGPLQLVWUDGRUHV� S~EOLFRV��6RPHQWH�FRP�EDVH�QD�H[LVWrQFLD�GD�OHL�H�GD�KLHUDUTXLD�QmR� SRGHPRV�H[WUDLU�XPD�PDLRU�FRPSUHHQVmR�GRV�MRJRV�GH�SRGHU�H�GRV� XVRV�GH�GLVSRVLWLYRV�TXH�GH¿QHP�GHWHUPLQDGDV� WUDMHWyULDV� H� Do}HV� dos operadores das instituições estatais. A proposta da governamentalidade abre espaço para compre- HQGHU�RV�GLVSRVLWLYRV�HVSHFt¿FRV�GH�JRYHUQR�H�R�GHVHQYROYLPHQWR� de saberes que redundaram em estratégias e políticas de controle das populações. Também permite observar a relação dos dispositivos WpFQLFRV�FRP�D�OHL��DSDUDWR�MXUtGLFR���FRP�D�QRUPD��XVRV�FRQVROLGD- GRV��FRVWXPHV�H�pWLFD�FRWLGLDQD���FRP�RV�JHVWRUHV�H�FRP�DV�SHVVRDV� em interação com o Estado. O termo governança poderia ser empre- JDGR�VH�IRVVH�HQWHQGLGR�PDLV�DPSODPHQWH��QR�PHVPR�VHQWLGR�TXH� )RXFDXOW�HPSUHJD�D�H[SUHVVmR�JRYHUQR��7RGDYLD��DTXL�VHUi�XWLOL]DGD� D� SDODYUD� JRYHUQR� SDUD� WUDWDU� GD� TXHVWmR� TXH�%HQ�:DJQHU� ������� S�����WmR�EHP�HVWUXWXURX��³>���@�FRPR�VmR�JRYHUQDGRV�RV�DOJRULWPRV� HPEXWLGRV�QR�VRIWZDUH"´��$FUHVFHQWR�j�TXHVWmR�DQWHULRU��DV�VHJXLQ- WHV�SHUJXQWDV��TXDO�R�QtYHO�GH�FRQWUROH�TXH�RV�JHVWRUHV�S~EOLFRV�WrP� sobre os algoritmos que utilizam? Como deveria ser estruturada uma SUiWLFD�GHPRFUiWLFD�GH�JRYHUQR�GRV�DOJRULWPRV"� 3 INVISIBILIDADE, NEUTRALIDADE E DIMENSÃO PÚBLICA 1HP�VRIWZDUHV��QHP�RV�DOJRULWPRV�QHOH�FRQWLGRV�VmR�QHXWURV�� (OHV�JHUDP�HIHLWRV�H� IRUDP�FULDGRV�H�GHVHQYROYLGRV�SDUD�GHWHUPL- QDGDV�¿QDOLGDGHV��$SHVDU�GH�VHUHP�LPDWHULDLV�H�LQYLVtYHLV��RV�DOJR- 272 Sergio Amadeu Silveira DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 ULWPRV�WrP�XP�SRQWR�GH�SDUWLGD�H�XPD�¿QDOLGDGH�RULJLQDO�TXH�SRGH� WHU�VLGR�DOWHUDGD�SHORV�VHXV�XVXiULRV�RX�SHOR�SUySULR�DOJRULWPR��FDVR� WHQKD�HPEXWLGR�HP�VHX�FyGLJR�URWLQDV�GH�DXWRFRUUHomR�H�DSUHQGL]D- JHP��$OJRULWPRV�VmR�LQYHQo}HV��H��FRPR�WRGD�LQYHQomR��JXDUGD�DV� LQWHQo}HV�GRV�VHXV�FULDGRUHV��,VVR�p�PXLWR�LPSRUWDQWH��SRLV�RV�DOJR- ULWPRV�QmR�VmR�GHVHQYROYLGRV�SHOR�VHWRU�S~EOLFR��HP�JHUDO��QDVFHP� dentro de empresas e corporações que os vendem ao Estado. Para VHUHP�YHQGLGRV��VmR�DSUHVHQWDGRV�FRPR�PDUDYLOKDV�WpFQLFDV��FRPR� VROXo}HV�TXH�VLPSOHVPHQWH�ID]HP�R�TXH�TXHUHPRV��VHP�LQWHUIHULU�HP� QRVVDV�SUiWLFDV��HP�QRVVRV�JRVWRV��HP�QRVVDV�RSLQL}HV�H�HP�QRVVD� IRUPD�GH�FODVVL¿FDU�H�YHU��2�DOJRULWPR��FRPR�SURGXWR��SDUD�SDUHFHU� PDLV� H¿FD]�GHYH�SDUHFHU�PDLV� QHXWUR�� FRPSOHWDPHQWH� DGHTXDGR� H� submetido aos interesses de seus compradores. 3ULPHLUD�JUDQGH�TXHVWmR��RV�DOJRULWPRV�VmR�LQYLVtYHLV��FRP- SOH[RV�H�HVFULWRV�HP�OLQJXDJHP�PDWHPiWLFD���3RU�VHU�LQYLVtYHLV��SDUD� PXLWRV��RV�DOJRULWPRV�QmR�VmR�SHUFHELGRV��QD�SUiWLFD�p�FRPR�VH�QmR� existissem. O grande problema é que sua invisibilidade e virtualida- GH�JHUDP�HIHLWRV�UHDLV�H�GH�JUDQGH�UHOHYkQFLD��9DPRV�D�XP�UHFHQWH� H[HPSOR��(P�VHWHPEUR�GH�������D�$JrQFLD�GH�3URWHomR�$PELHQWDO� �(3$���GRV�(VWDGRV�8QLGRV��GHVFREULX�TXH�R�VRIWZDUH�LQVWDODGR�QD� FHQWUDO�HOHWU{QLFD�GRV�FDUURV�GD�9RONVZDJHQ�SRVVXtD�XP�DOJRULWPR� TXH� FRQVHJXLD� LGHQWL¿FDU� TXDQGR� R� YHtFXOR� HVWLYHVVH� VXEPHWLGR� j� FRQGLomR�GH�WHVWH��UHGX]LQGR�QDTXHOH�PRPHQWR�RV�SROXHQWHV�HPLWL- GRV�SHOR�PRWRU��$�IUDXGH�Vy�IRL�GHVFREHUWD�FRP�R�DSRLR�GH�SHVTXL- sadores da Universidade de West Virginia. O Conselho de Emissões GD�&DOLIyUQLD��&$5%��H�D�(3$�HVWLPDP�TXH�����PLO�YHtFXORV��IDEUL- FDGRV�HQWUH������H�������FRP�PRWRUHV�GLHVHO��YLRODYDP�D�OHJLVODomR� DPELHQWDO�� �(6&Æ1'$/2����� �������$OJRULWPRV� QmR� VmR� YLVtYHLV�� QHP�SHUFHSWtYHLV��PDV� VmR� FRQWXQGHQWHV�QD� H[HFXomR�GH� VXD�¿QD- lidade. $� VHJXQGD� JUDQGH� TXHVWmR� DGYpP� GD� IRUoD� GR� SRVLWLYLVPR� TXH� Mi� HUD� JUDQGH� QD� VRFLHGDGH� LQGXVWULDO� H� FUHVFHX� QD� VRFLHGDGH� LQIRUPDFLRQDO��2�SRVLWLYLVPR�IRL�WUDQVIRUPDGR�HP�VHQVR�FRPXP�H� DUWLFXODGR�SHOR�QHROLEHUDOLVPR�FRPR�XP�GRV� VXVWHQWiFXORV�GH� VXD� UDFLRQDOLGDGH��,VVR�IRUWDOHFH�R�PDUNHWLQJ�GDV�FRUSRUDo}HV�TXH�IRU- QHFHP�WHFQRORJLDV�SDUD�R�(VWDGR�FRPR�PHURV�SURGXWRV�FXMR�VHQWLGR� H�XVR�p�GH¿QLGR�SHOR�FRPSUDGRU��$�LPDWHULDOLGDGH�H� LQYLVLELOLGDGH� GRV�VRIWZDUHV�H�DOJRULWPRV�UHIRUoDP�D�SUiWLFD�GLVFXUVLYD�GH�XPD�WHF- nicidade neutra de uma racionalidade naturalizada que implicam o WUDWDPHQWR�QmR�SROtWLFR�H�QmR�FUtWLFR�GRV�FyGLJRV�QR�VHWRU�S~EOLFR�� 273 GOVERNO DOS ALGORITMOS DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 Um passo importante para recuperar a capacidade crítica GLDQWH�GRV� DOJRULWPRV� p� WHQWDU� FRPSUHHQGHU� VXD�GLPHQVmR�S~EOLFD� H�VXDV� LPSOLFDo}HV�SROtWLFDV��2�HVWXGLRVR�GRV�DOJRULWPRV��7DUOHWRQ� *LOOHVSLH� �������S�� ����� WUDGXomR�QRVVD��� GHVWDFRX� VHLV�GLPHQV}HV� GRV�³>���@�DOJRULWPRV�GH�UHOHYkQFLD�S~EOLFD´�TXH�WrP�YDOLGDGH�SROtWL- ca. A primeira diz respeito aos padrões de inclusão utilizados pelos DOJRULWPRV��(OHV�GH¿QHP�FODUDPHQWH�R�TXH�GHYH�RX�QmR�VHU�LQFOXtGR� HP�VXDV�RSHUDo}HV��7DPEpP�VmR�SURMHWDGRV�SDUD�DQWHFLSDU�D�HVFROKD� GRV�XVXiULRV�HP�GLYHUVRV�FLFORV�GH�DQWHFLSDomR��8PD�GDV�SULQFLSDLV� IXQo}HV�GRV�DOJRULWPRV�p�D�DYDOLDomR�GH�UHOHYkQFLD��RX�VHMD��VHU�FD- SD]�GH�REWHU�TXDLV�LQIRUPDo}HV�VmR�PDLV�RX�PHQRV�LPSRUWDQWHV�SDUD� cada pessoa. Todas as operações algorítmicas portam a promessa da REMHWLYLGDGH��DFLPD�GH�RSLQL}HV�H�SRQWRV�GH�YLVWD��(P�VHX�HPDUD- QKDPHQWR�FRP�D�SUiWLFD�GRV�XVXiULRV��RV�DOJRULWPRV�RV�DOWHUDP�H�VmR� WDPEpP�DOWHUDGRV�SRU�VXD�GLQkPLFD��3RU�¿P��*LOOHVSLH�REVHUYRX�TXH�RV�DOJRULWPRV�SURGX]HP�S~EOLFRV�FDOFXODGRV��DPRVWUDV�TXH�SDVVDP�D� UHFRQ¿JXUDU�D�YLVmR�TXH�SRVVXHP�GR�VHX�SUySULR�JUXSR�� 4 PERFORMATIVIDADE E TOMADA DE DECISÃO NO SETOR PÚBLICO &DGD� YH]�PDLV�� RV� DGPLQLVWUDGRUHV� H� JHVWRUHV� GH� HPSUHVDV� SULYDGDV�H�LQVWLWXLo}HV�S~EOLFDV�GHOHJDP�DRV�VRIWZDUHV�XPD�VpULH�GH� WDUHIDV�H�GHFLV}HV��(P�JHUDO��RV�VRIWZDUHV�SRVVXHP�GLYHUVRV�DOJRULW- PRV�TXH�IRUDP�FULDGRV�SDUD�UHDOL]DU�GLIHUHQWHV�FiOFXORV��FODVVL¿FD- o}HV�H�FRUUHODo}HV��HQWUH�RXWUDV�DWLYLGDGHV�PDLV�FRPSOH[DV��9iULDV� GHFLV}HV�� DQWHV� WRPDGDV� SRU� SHVVRDV�� HVWmR� VHQGR� VXEVWLWXtGDV� SRU� GHFLV}HV�DGRWDGDV�SRU�DOJRULWPRV��1D�DGPLQLVWUDomR�S~EOLFD�EUDVL- OHLUD�DWXDO��R�QtYHO�GDV�VROXo}HV�GDGDV�SRU�DOJRULWPRV�DLQGD�p�FRQVL- GHUDGR�GH�XP�EDL[R�JUDX�GH�LPSRUWkQFLD��PDV�VXD�UHOHYkQFLD�DXPHQ- WDUi�FRP�R�DYDQoR�GR�ELJ�GDWD��GD�GLVVHPLQDomR�GH�VHQVRUHV�FRQHFWD- dos às redes e com o crescimento das cidades digitais e inteligentes. $WXDOPHQWH�� PXLWDV� VROXo}HV� Mi� DXWRPDWL]DGDV� HVWmR� VXEVWLWXLQGR� HVTXHPDV�RSHUDGRV�SRU�DOJRULWPRV�PDLV�FRPSOH[RV��FRPR�QR�FDVR� GRV�PXQLFtSLRV�TXH�SDVVDUDP�D�XWLOL]DU� RV� VHPiIRURV� LQWHOLJHQWHV�� Outro exemplo pode ser encontrado na organização do atendimento S~EOLFR��RV�DOJRULWPRV�SDVVDP�D�JHUHQFLDU�D�SULRULGDGH�GH�UHFHSomR� QDV�UHSDUWLo}HV�S~EOLFDV�VXSHUDQGR�D�VLPSOHV�RUGHP�GH�FKHJDGD� $OJRULWPRV�SDUHFHP�HQYROYHU�GXDV�IRUPDV�GH�DXWRPDomR�UHODFLR- QDGDV��PDV�PXLWR�GLIHUHQWHV��(P�SULPHLUR�OXJDU��HOHV�DXWRPDWL]DP� R�SURFHVVR�GH�VXEPHWHU�GDGRV�j�DQiOLVH��UHDOL]DQGR�WDUHIDV�TXH�VH- 274 Sergio Amadeu Silveira DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 riam impossíveis de executar manualmente. Mas os resultados des- VDV�DQiOLVHV�DMXGDP�D�DXWRPDWL]DU�XP�VHJXQGR�H�PXLWR�GLIHUHQWH� FRQMXQWR�GH�RSHUDo}HV��D�WRPDGD�GH�GHFLVmR���%$52&$6��+22'�� =,(:,7=��������S�����WUDGXomR�QRVVD�� Os riscos dessa automatização podem ser observados quando R�JUDX�GH�LPSRUWkQFLD�VRFLDO�GDV�GHFLV}HV�DXPHQWD��1RV�~OWLPRV�WULQ- WD�DQRV��RV�PRGHORV�HVWDWtVWLFRV�H�VRIWZDUHV�WrP�SHQHWUDGR�QD�MXVWLoD� SHQDO�QRUWH�DPHULFDQD�SDUD�DSRLDU�RV�MXt]HV�H�SURFXUDGRUHV�QD�DYD- OLDomR�GR�ULVFR�H�QD�GH¿QLomR�GDV�SHQDV�GRV�FULPLQRVRV����&+5,6- 7,1��526(1%$/7��%2<'����������(P�������D�$UQROG�)RXQGDWLRQ� ODQoRX�XP�QRYR� LQVWUXPHQWR��R�3XEOLF�6DIHW\�$VVHVVPHQW� ��&RXUW� �36$���TXH�VH�EDVHLD�HP�GLYHUVDV�YDULiYHLV�UHODFLRQDGDV�FRP�D�LGD- GH��PRUDGLD��KLVWyULFR�FULPLQDO��HQWUH�RXWUDV��SDUD�GH¿QLU�D�SHQD��D� ¿DQoD�H�D�OLEHUGDGH�FRQGLFLRQDO�GRV�UpXV��6HJXQGR�RV�SHVTXLVDGRUHV� &KULVWLQ��5RVHQEODW�H�%R\G���������R�36$�HUD�XVDGR�SRU���� MXULV- GLo}HV�� LQFOXLQGR� WUrV�(VWDGRV� LQWHLURV� �$UL]RQD��.HQWXFN\�H�1HZ� -HUVH\��H�WUrV�FLGDGHV�SULQFLSDLV��&KDUORWWH��&KLFDJR��H�3KRHQL[���HP� ������'H�DFRUGR�FRP�D�)XQGDomR�$UQROG��D�XWLOL]DomR�GR�36$�WHP� UHGX]LGR�DV�WD[DV�GH�FULPLQDOLGDGH�H�WDPEpP�D�SRSXODomR�FDUFHUiULD� QDV�MXULVGLo}HV�RQGH�IRL�XVDGR��&RQWXGR��DV�GH¿QLo}HV�DOJRUtWPLFDV� também têm sido apontadas como reprodutoras e ampliadoras do UDFLVPR� H� VHOHWLYLGDGH� GR� -XGLFLiULR� QRUWH�DPHULFDQR�� �0$<%,1�� 2016). (PERUD�SRVVDPRV�HQWHQGHU�FRPR�R�DOJRULWPR�IXQFLRQD��RV�UHVXO- tados do algoritmo podem não ser previsíveis. Podemos entender FRPR�DV�UHGHV�QHXUDLV�H�R�DOJRULWPR�GH�DXWRDSUHQGL]DJHP�IXQFLR- QDP��PDV�HOHV�SRGHP�JHUDU�UHVXOWDGRV�TXH�QmR�SRGHP�VHU�SUHYLVWRV� com antecedência. Isso complica a responsabilidade ex ante em TXH�R�DOJRULWPR�H�VHXV�SURMHWLVWDV�VmR�UHVSRQViYHLV�SHODV�GHFLV}HV�� �-$166(1��.8.��������S�������WUDGXomR�QRVVD�� e�QHFHVViULR�GLVFXWLU�DV�LPSOLFDo}HV�GDV�GHFLV}HV�DXWRPDWL]D- GDV�HIHWXDGDV�SRU�DOJRULWPRV�TXH�SRVVXHP�D�FDSDFLGDGH�GH�DSUHQGL- ]DJHP�RX�GH�UHYLVmR�D�SDUWLU�GH�LQIRUPDo}HV�REWLGDV�DSyV�VXD�DomR� anterior. O algoritmo utilizado pelo motor de busca do Google é GHVVH�WLSR��$�FDGD�EXVFD�TXH�ID]HPRV��R�DOJRULWPR�DSUHQGH�FRP�RV� WHPDV� TXH�PDLV� QRV� LQWHUHVVDP�� FRP�DV� HVFROKDV� GH� OLQNV� TXH� ID- ]HPRV� H� FRP� RXWURV� HOHPHQWRV� TXH� FRQIRUPDP� DV� QRVVDV� RSo}HV� SUHIHUHQFLDLV��$VVLP��R�DOJRULWPR�UHFROKH�GDGRV�VREUH�QRVVDV�Do}HV�� QRVVDV�SUHIHUrQFLDV�H�GH¿QHP�QRVVR�SHU¿O��(OL�3DULVHU��������FKD- PRX�HVVH�SURFHVVR�GH�SHUVRQDOL]DomR��GH�FODVVL¿FDomR�H�LQVHUomR�GH� 275 GOVERNO DOS ALGORITMOS DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 QRVVDV�LGHQWLGDGHV�HP�JUXSRV�HVSHFt¿FRV�GH�¿OWHU�EXEEOH��1HP�RV� desenvolvedores que criaram o algoritmo conseguem saber como HOH�DJLUi�GHSRLV�GH�XP�WHPSR�GH�IXQFLRQDPHQWR��SRLV�HOH�DSUHQGHX� FRP�RV�GDGRV�FROHWDGRV�� HQ¿P�DV�GHFLV}HV�GR�DOJRULWPR�SRVVXHP� YtQFXOR�FRP�VXD�RULJHP��PDV�VXD�DXWRQRPLD�GHFLVyULD�p�JUDQGH��GL- ItFLO�GH�HVWLPDU�� (VVHV�DOJRULWPRV�VmR�GLVSRVLWLYRV�SHUIRUPDWLYRV��(P�OLQJXtV- WLFD��XP�HQXQFLDGR�p�SHUIRUPDWLYR�TXDQGR�RFRUUH�VLPXOWDQHDPHQWH� D�DomR�TXH�HOH�DSUHVHQWD��RX�VHMD��Ki�XPD�FRLQFLGrQFLD�HQWUH�D�SDOD- YUD�H�R�DWR��³$�SHUIRUPDWLYLGDGH�p�XPD�SHUVSHFWLYD�SDUWLFXODU�VREUH� D� QDWXUH]D� GD� LQWHUDomR�� TXH� p� R� UHVXOWDGR� OyJLFR� GH� XPD�SRVLomR� RQWROyJLFD�GR�WRUQDU�VH��WDPEpP�FRQKHFLGD�FRPR�¿ORVR¿D�GR�SUR- FHVVR��HP�RSRVLomR�D�XPD�RQWRORJLD�GR�VHU�´��,17521$��������S�� ���WUDGXomR�QRVVD���3RUWDQWR��R�FRQWUROH�GH�GLVSRVLWLYRV�TXH�VH�DOWH- UDP�FRQVWDQWHPHQWH�WUD]�XPD�VpULH�GH�QRYRV�GHVD¿RV�SDUD�TXHP�RV� utiliza. Os problemas podem ser maiores quando tratamos do uso de DOJRULWPRV�SHUIRUPDWLYRV�QDV�GHFLV}HV�GR�VHWRU�S~EOLFR��RQGH�D�UHV- SRQVDELOLGDGH�SHORV�DWRV�GD�JHVWmR��D�WUDQVSDUrQFLD�H�D�HVWDELOLGDGH� MXUtGLFD��p�IXQGDPHQWDO�� 0DFKLQH�/HDUQLQJ�RX�$SUHQGL]DJHP�GH�0iTXLQD�p�R�FDPSR� de estudo que se concentra em algoritmos de indução e em outros DOJRULWPRV�TXH�VmR�GH¿QLGRV�SRU�VXD�FDSDFLGDGH�GH�DSUHQGHU��.2- +$5,��3529267�� �������(VVHV� DOJRULWPRV� TXH� DSUHQGHP�FRP�D� H[SHULrQFLD�Mi�HVWmR�VHQGR�HPSUHJDGRV�SRU�DXGLWRUHV�¿VFDLV�SDUD�D� GHWHFomR�GH�IUDXGHV��PDV�SRGHUmR�VHU�XWLOL]DGRV�SDUD�DGPLQLVWUDU�R� WUkQVLWR�GH�XPD�FLGDGH��SDUD�RUJDQL]DU�R�VLVWHPD�GH�PDWUtFXODV�H�DV� turmas em uma grande universidade ou em um sistema regional de HQVLQR��HQWUH�RXWURV�H[HPSORV��7RGDYLD��HVVHV�DOJRULWPRV�SRGHP�HQ- JHQGUDU�SURFHGLPHQWRV�QmR�SUHWHQGLGRV��PDV� FULDGRV�SRU� LQGXomR�� 6HJXQGR�R�SURIHVVRU�GR�0,7�0HGLD�/DE��.HYLQ�6ODYLQ��HP�������R� algoritmo que regula os preços na Amazon entrou em um processo GH�FRQFRUUrQFLD�GHVHQIUHDGD�HQWUH�RV�WtWXORV�GD�SUySULD�ORMD�YLUWXDO�� 8P�GRV� OLYURV�GH�%LRORJLD��7KH�0DNLQJ�RI�D�)O\��FKHJRX�D�FXVWDU� 86�������PLOK}HV���(63(&,$/,67$������������(UURV�VLPLODUHV�SR- GHP�VHU�SURGX]LGRV�SRU�DOJRULWPRV�SUHGLWLYRV��RX�VHMD��TXH�UHDOL]DP� SURJQyVWLFRV�D�SDUWLU�GR�DFRPSDQKDPHQWR�GH�SHU¿V�H�GH�HOHPHQWRV� TXH�FRPS}HP�VXD�iUHD�GH�GHFLVmR� 8PD�GDV�SULQFLSDLV�TXHVW}HV�TXH�DSDUHFHP�SDUD�D�JHVWmR�S~- EOLFD�HP�WRUQR�GH�DOJRULWPRV�SHUIRUPDWLYRV�H�SUHGLWLYRV�p�D�VHJXLQWH�� 276 Sergio Amadeu Silveira DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 como o gestor pode governar um algoritmo que se altera constan- WHPHQWH"�&RPR�p�SRVVtYHO�WRUQi�OR�WUDQVSDUHQWH�SDUD�RV�JHVWRUHV�H� para a sociedade que é governada por ele? Esses questionamentos WrP�XPD�GLPHQVmR�WpFQLFD��PDV�VmR�SROtWLFRV��SRLV�GL]HP�UHVSHLWR�D� decisões sobre a vida das cidadãs e cidadãos. Com base no potencial SHUIRUPDWLYR�H�SUHGLWLYR�GRV�DOJRULWPRV�p�SRVVtYHO�DGRWDU�QR�VHWRU� S~EOLFR�DOJXQV�SDVVRV�LPSRUWDQWHV� ����6RIWZDUHV�H�DOJRULWPRV�GHYHP�WHU�R�FyGLJR�IRQWH�DEHUWR�� (VVD�GHFLVmR�HVEDUUD�QRV�PRGHORV�GH�QHJyFLRV�GH�HPSUH- VDV�IRUQHFHGRUDV�GH�WHFQRORJLD�SDUD�R�(VWDGR��TXH�VH�ED- seiam em licenças de propriedade intelectual restritivas. ����&yGLJR�DEHUWR�QmR�p�VX¿FLHQWH�SDUD�DFRPSDQKDU�D�DWXD- omR�GRV�DOJRULWPRV�SHUIRUPDWLYRV��3RU�LVVR��p�QHFHVViULR� DGRWDU�SURFHGLPHQWRV�GH�DXGLWRULD��DYDOLDomR�IUHTXHQWH�H� correção de rumos e de decisões adotadas. 3 - Delimitadores de decisão devem ser incorporados nos al- JRULWPRV��RX�VHMD��R�JHVWRU�S~EOLFR�GHYH�LPSRU�IURQWHLUDV� GHFLVyULDV� SDUD� RV� DOJRULWPRV�� R� TXH� HYLWDUi� HTXtYRFRV� SUHYLVtYHLV�H�FRQVLGHUDGRV�LQDFHLWiYHLV�����,QFRUSRUDU�QRV�SURMHWRV�GH�GHVHQYROYLPHQWR�GH�VRIWZDUHV� e algoritmos os procedimentos que assegurem a privaci- GDGH�QR�DUPD]HQDPHQWR��SURFHVVDPHQWR�H�XVR�GH�GDGRV� SHVVRDLV��LQGLVSHQViYHLV�SDUD�R�VHUYLoR�S~EOLFR��,VVR�LP- SOLFD�QHFHVVDULDPHQWH�D�DGRomR�GH�FULSWRJUD¿D�H�QtYHLV�GH� acesso para proteger os dados dos cidadãos. �� ��'DGRV�SHVVRDLV�TXH�QmR�VmR� LQGLVSHQViYHLV�QmR�GHYHP� VHU�FROHWDGRV��,VVR�HYLWD�GLYHUVDV�GL¿FXOGDGHV�H�FXVWRV�HP� sua proteção. 6 - Toda gestão de dados deve possuir documentos descre- vendo sua guarda e utilização. Essas declarações de po- lítica de privacidade e de gestão algorítmica devem ser WUDQVSDUHQWHV��GH�IiFLO�DFHVVR�H�SRVVXLU�PHFDQLVPRV�FOD- ros para garantir o seu cumprimento. ����$OJRULWPRV�GH�GLPHQVmR�S~EOLFD�QmR�SRGHP�VHU�FULDGRV�H� desenvolvidos sem a participação dos gestores e adminis- WUDGRUHV�S~EOLFRV��1mR�VmR�QHXWURV��QHP�DSHQDV�WpFQLFRV�� SRUWDQWR�� QmR� GHYHP� VHU� FRPSUDGRV� FRPR� VH� FRPSUDP� PHUFDGRULDV� SDGURQL]DGDV�� 1mR� p� D� JHVWmR� S~EOLFD� TXH� 277 GOVERNO DOS ALGORITMOS DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 GHYH�VH�DGHTXDU�jV�VROXo}HV�GLVSRQtYHLV�QR�PHUFDGR��PDV� as soluções adquiridas devem ser adequadas aos interes- VHV�H�SHFXOLDULGDGHV�GR�VHWRU�S~EOLFR�� Esses procedimentos não evitam as possíveis distorções e implicações negativas que os algoritmos podem gerar na organiza- omR�H�QDV�GHFLV}HV�H�SUiWLFDV�GRV�VHUYLoRV�S~EOLFRV��/XFDV�,QWURQD� �������DOHUWD�TXH�D�OyJLFD�DOJRUtWPLFD�p�UHGXFLRQLVWD��2V�SUREOHPDV� VmR� UHGX]LGRV� SDUD� TXH� VHMDP� H[SUHVVRV� DOJRULWPLFDPHQWH� H� VmR� IRUPDWDGRV�FRQIRUPH�RV�FRQKHFLPHQWRV�WpFQLFRV�GLVSRQtYHLV�SHORV� SURJUDPDGRUHV��$OpP�GLVVR��HP�JHUDO��RV�SUREOHPDV�VmR�DGHTXDGRV� às soluções disponíveis e aos produtos vendidos pelas corporações. (VWH�UHGXFLRQLVPR�SRGH�WHU�FRQVHTXrQFLDV�SHUIRUPDWLYDV�VLJQL¿FDWL- YDV���,17521$��������� 'RQDOG�0DF.HQ]LH�D¿UPRX�TXH�RV�DOJRULWPRV�QmR�H[SUHVVDP� VLPSOHVPHQWH�R�PXQGR��DV�LQWHQo}HV�GRV�SURJUDPDGRUHV��DV�IXQo}HV� e os processos que automatizam. Os algoritmos não modelam o PXQGR��PDV�H[HFXWDP�SHUIRUPDWLYDPHQWH�Do}HV�VREUH�XPD�UHDOLGD- GH�TXH�YDL�SURGX]LQGR�GLIHUHQWHV�HQWLGDGHV�j�PHGLGD�TXH�DJHP��2E- VHUYDQGR�R�PHUFDGR�¿QDQFHLUR��0DFNHQ]LH��������QRV�PRVWUD�TXH� RV�PRGHORV�PDWHPiWLFRV�H�RV�VLVWHPDV�GH�QHJRFLDomR�¿QDQFHLUD�QmR� DSHQDV�DXWRPDWL]DP�R�FiOFXOR�GR�YDORU��(VVD�PRGHODJHP�H�GLQkPLFD� DOJRUtWPLFD� FULD� QRYDV� SUiWLFDV� H� JHUD� QRYRV� FRPSRUWDPHQWRV� GRV� JHVWRUHV�GH�IXQGRV��GRV�DQDOLVWDV�H�GRV�LQYHVWLGRUHV�TXH�LQFRUSRUDP� a agência de tais modelos na realização de suas escolhas. (MA- &.(1=,(�������� 1HVWH�VHQWLGR��R�XVR�FUHVFHQWH�GH�DOJRULWPRV�QD�JHVWmR�H�QRV� VHUYLoRV�S~EOLFRV�QmR�SRGH�VHU�YLVWR�FRPR�VLPSOHVPHQWH�XPD�LQR- vação ou uma mera modernização. Deve ser compreendido no con- WH[WR�TXH�/XFDV�,QWURQD��������FKDPRX�GD�SHUIRUPDWLYLGDGH�GRV�DO- JRULWPRV��GH�JRYHUQR�GRV�DOJRULWPRV�TXH�JRYHUQDP�DV�iUHDV�GR�VHWRU� S~EOLFR�HP�TXH�DWXDP��,QWURQD��������SURS}H�TXH�VHMDPRV�FDSD]HV� GH�ORFDOL]DU��FRPSUHHQGHU�D�QRomR�GD�DWULEXLomR�GH�DJrQFLD�GDGD�DRV� algoritmos. Precisamos assumir que os algoritmos possuem conse- TXrQFLDV�QRUPDWLYDV�H�SHUIRUPDWLYDV�UHODFLRQDGDV�DR�SRGHU�GHVWLQD- GR�DR�VHX�SURMHWR� 5 CONCLUSÃO: controle e governo dos algoritmos Governar implica utilizar dispositivos e tecnologias de con- WUROH��3DUD�R�H[HUFtFLR�GR�JRYHUQR�GDV�SRSXODo}HV��GHVGH�R�VpFXOR� 278 Sergio Amadeu Silveira DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 ;9,,,��WrP�VLGR�XWLOL]DGRV�LQVWUXPHQWRV�HVWDWtVWLFRV��DV�FLrQFLDV�VR- FLDLV�H�RXWUDV�WHFQRORJLDV�ELRSROtWLFDV���)28&$8/7���������$WXDO- PHQWH��DV�WHFQRORJLDV�GD�LQIRUPDomR�WUD]HP�YDQWDJHQV�LUUHFXViYHLV� para a gestão dos governos e instituições do Estado. A aplicação JHQHUDOL]DGD�GR�ELJ�GDWD�QD�JHVWmR�S~EOLFD�WHQGHUi�D�HVWUXWXUDU�XP� FDPSR�EHP�PDLRU�SDUD�R�XVR�GH�DOJRULWPRV��WDOYH]�QD�PHVPD�GLUHomR� HP� TXH� HOHV� VmR� XWLOL]DGRV� QR�PHUFDGR� ¿QDQFHLUR��$OJRULWPRV� GH� DOWD�IUHTXrQFLD�YmR�FRQGX]LQGR�RV�LQYHVWLPHQWRV�H�UHIRUPDWDQGR�D� GLQkPLFD�GRV�PHUFDGRV�GH�DOWR�ULVFR���*,/(6�������� $OJRULWPRV� VmR� GHVHQYROYLGRV� IRUD� GR� (VWDGR�� 7DOYH]� VHMD� SUHFLVR�UHSHQVDU�HVVD�SUiWLFD�DFODPDGD�H�YROWDGD�jV�HPSUHVDV��)RX- FDXOW������D��S����������QRV�PRVWURX�TXH�R�OLEHUDOLVPR�EXVFRX�HV- WDEHOHFHU�IRUPDV�QmR�HVWDWDLV�GH�JRYHUQDPHQWDOLGDGH�GRV�YLYHQWHV�� ³>���@� p� QHFHVViULR� JRYHUQDU� SDUD� R�PHUFDGR�� HP� YH]� GH� JRYHUQDU� SRU� FDXVD�GR�PHUFDGR´�� -i�SDUD�R�QHROLEHUDOLVPR��QmR�p�R�PHUFD- GR��PDV�D�FRQFRUUrQFLD�TXH�GHYH�VHU�R�SULQFtSLR�UHJXODGRU�GH�WXGR�� �)28&$8/7������D���(�TXHP�GHYH�UHSUHVHQWDU�H�VH�SUROLIHUDU�QHVVH� mundo concorrencial são as empresas. Elas devem ser a medida da YHUGDGH�H�GD�YHUL¿FDomR�VH�DOJR�HVWi�VHQGR�H[HFXWDGR�FRUUHWDPHQWH� RX�QmR��³e�HVVD�PXOWLSOLFDomR�GD�IRUPD�µHPSUHVD¶�QR�LQWHULRU�GR�FRU- SR�VRFLDO�TXH�FRQVWLWXL��D�PHX�YHU��R�HVFRSR�GD�SROtWLFD�QHROLEHUDO�´� �)28&$8/7������D��S�������JULIR�GR�DXWRU�� $V�VRFLHGDGHV�GHPRFUiWLFDV�SUHFLVDP�DVVXPLU�TXH�R�FHQiULR� atual é tecnopolítico. Tal como o velho tecnocrata que acreditava QD� VXSUHPDFLD�GR� VHX� VDEHU� WpFQLFR�� DOJXPDV�FRUUHQWHV�GRV�QRYRV� JHVWRUHV�S~EOLFRV�� HQFDQWDGRV�FRP�DV�SURPHVVDV�QHROLEHUDLV�H� VHX� GLVFXUVR�GH� LQRYDomR�� DFUHGLWDP�TXH�DV� HPSUHVDV� FULDP�VRIWZDUHV� H�DOJRULWPRV�TXH�IXQFLRQDP�PDUDYLOKRVDPHQWH�EHP��SRLV�VmR�SUR- GXWRV�TXH�GHYHP�VHU�DGTXLULGRV�SHOR�PHOKRU�SUHoR��GDGD�D�XPD�YD- ULHGDGH�GH�RIHUWDV�FRQFRUUHQWHV��$EUHP�PmR�GH�FULDU�H�GHVHQYROYHU� RV�GLVSRVLWLYRV�WHFQROyJLFRV�GH�JRYHUQR��FRPR�VH�HVWHV�IRVVHP�DSR- OtWLFRV��$FDEDP�FRQWULEXLQGR�SDUD�ID]HU�GD�VRFLHGDGH�XP�DJUHJDGR� FRQGX]LGR�SHODV�FRUSRUDo}HV�SULYDGDV��1HVVH�FRQWH[WR��RV�DOJRULW- PRV�VmR�DFWDQWHV��/$7285��������FDGD�YH]�PDLV�VHP�WUDQVSDUrQFLD� H�VHXV�HIHLWRV�SRGHP�UHSUHVHQWDU�SHULJRV�SDUD�DV�GHPRFUDFLDV��SDUD�D� GHOLEHUDomR�GHPRFUiWLFD�H�SDUD�DV�JHVW}HV�LQFOXVLYDV�� A alternativa ao positivismo e às perspectivas da neutralidade DOJRUtWPLFD�SRGH�HVWDU�QD�IRUPDomR�GH�UHGHV�GH�FRPSDUWLOKDPHQWR� GH�VROXo}HV�DOJRUtWPLFDV��QD�FRPSUHHQVmR�GH�TXH�D�FRQVWUXomR�GH� 279 GOVERNO DOS ALGORITMOS DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 VRIWZDUHV� SDUD� R� VHWRU� S~EOLFR� p� XP� SURFHVVR�� H� QmR� XP� SURGXWR� acabado a ser adquirido no mercado. Também pode estar na criação GH�FROHWLYRV�GH�JHVWmR�DOJRUtWPLFD�H�GH�WHFQRORJLDV�GD�LQIRUPDomR�� 8PD�GDV�WDUHIDV�LQLFLDLV�GHVVHV�FROHWLYRV�SRGHULD�VHU�D�UHDOL]DomR�GH� XP�PDSHDPHQWR�GRV�DOJRULWPRV��GDV�GHFLV}HV�TXH�Mi�VmR�H�TXH�SRGH- ULDP�VHU�DXWRPDWL]DGDV��EHP�FRPR�D�IRUPXODomR�GH�SROtWLFDV�GH�XVR� GRV�GDGRV�H�GH�SURWHomR�GD�SULYDFLGDGH�GRV�FLGDGmRV��6HP�G~YLGD�� R�VHWRU�S~EOLFR�SDUD�DWXDU� WHFQRSROLWLFDPHQWH�GHYHUi�VH�DSUR[LPDU� PDLV�GDV�XQLYHUVLGDGHV�H�GRV�FROHWLYRV�GH�FXOWXUD�WHFQROyJLFD��GRV� hackers e dos makers. REFERÊNCIAS %$52&$6��6���+22'��6���=,(:,7=��0��Governing algorithms: a SURYRFDWLRQ�SLHFH��,Q��*29(51,1*�$/*25,7+06��D�FRQIHUHQFH� RQ�FRPSXWDWLRQ��DXWRPDWLRQ��DQG�FRQWURO��������1HZ�<RUN��$QDLV�� 1HZ�<RUN��������'LVSRQtYHO��https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers. FIP"DEVWUDFWBLG �������!��$FHVVR�HP����RXW������� &$67(//6��0��$�HUD�GD�LQIRUPDomR��HFRQRPLD��VRFLHGDGH�H�FXOWXUD�� São Paulo: 3D]�H�7HUUD������� &+5,67,1��$���526(1%/$7��$���%2<'��'��&RXUWV�DQG�3UHGLFWLYH� Algorithms. In: '$7$�$1'�&,9,/�5,*+7��&ULPLQDO�-XVWLFH�DQG� &LYLO�5LJKWV�3ULPHU��������:DVKLQJWRQ��'&��$QDLV����:DVKLQJWRQ��'&�� 'DWD� 6RFLHW\������� (6&Æ1'$/2�GD�9RONVZDJHQ��YHMD�FRPR�D�IUDXGH�IRL�GHVFREHUWD�� *���6mR�3DXOR��������$XWR�(VSRUWH��'LVSRQtYHO��http://g1.globo.com/ FDUURV�QRWLFLD���������HVFDQGDOR�GD�YRONVZDJHQ�YHMD�R�SDVVR�SDVVR� do-caso.html!��$FHVVR�����MDQ������� (63(&,$/,67$�DOHUWD�SDUD�DPHDoD�GRV�DOJRULWPRV��,*��6mR�3DXOR�� DJR��������7HFQRORJLD��'LVSRQtYHO�HP��http://tecnologia.ig.com.br/ especialista-alerta-para-ameaca-dos-algoritmos/n1597173189284. html!��$FHVVR�HP�����MDQ������� )28&$8/7��0��(P�GHIHVD�GD�VRFLHGDGH��FXUVR�QR�&ROOqJH�GH�)UDQFH����������������HG��6mR�3DXOR��(GLWRUD�:0)�0DUWLQV�)RQWHV�������� ______. Nascimento da biopolítica: curso dado no College de France �������������6mR�3DXOR��0DUWLQV�)RQWHV������D� BBBBBB��2�VXMHLWR�H�R�SRGHU��,Q��'5(<)86��+��/���5$%,12:�� P. 0LFKHO�)RXFDXOW���8PD�7UDMHWyULD�)LORVy¿FD��SDUD�DOpP�GR� 280 Sergio Amadeu Silveira DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 HVWUXWXUDOLVPR�H�GD�KHUPHQrXWLFD��5LR�GH�-DQHLUR��)RUHQVH� 8QLYHUVLWiULD��������S���������� BBBBBB��6HJXUDQFD��WHUULWyULR��SRSXODomR��FXUVR�GDGR�QR�&ROOHJH�GH� )UDQFH��������������6mR�3DXOR��0DUWLQV�)RQWHV������E� *,/(6��-��6WRFN�WUDGLQJ�µIUDFWXUHV¶�PD\�ZDUQ�RI�QH[W�FUDVK��1HZ� 6FLHQWLVW��>6��O�@��IHE��������'LVSRQtYHO�HP��KWWSV���ZZZ�QHZVFLHQWLVW� FRP�DUWLFOH�GQ������VWRFN�WUDGLQJ�IUDFWXUHV�PD\�ZDUQ�RI�QH[W� FUDVK�!��$FHVVR�HP�����MDQ�������� *,//(63,(��7��7KH�5HOHYDQFH�RI�$OJRULWKPV��,Q��*,//(63,(��7��� %2&=.2:6.,��3��-���)227��.��$��0HGLD�WHFKQRORJLHV��HVVD\V�RQ� FRPPXQLFDWLRQ��PDWHULDOLW\��DQG�VRFLHW\��&DPEULGJH��0$��0,7�3UHVV�� 2014. *2))(<��$��$OJRULWKP��,Q��)8//(5��0���(G����6RIWZDUH�VWXGLHV��D� OH[LFRQ��&DPEULGJH��0$��0,7�3UHVV��������S�������� +2:$5'��3��1��3D[�WHFKQLFD��KRZ�WKH�,QWHUQHW�RI�WKLQJV�PD\�VHW�XV� IUHH�RU�ORFN�XV�XS��1HZ�+DYHQ��<DOH�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV������� ,17521$��/��'��$OJRULWKPV��SHUIRUPDWLYLW\�DQG�JRYHUQDELOLW\� �HDUO\�GUDIW���,Q��*29(51,1*�$/*25,7+06��D�FRQIHUHQFH�RQ� FRPSXWDWLRQ��DXWRPDWLRQ��DQG�FRQWURO��������1HZ�<RUN��$QDLV��1HZ� <RUN��������'LVSRQtYHO��KWWS���JRYHUQLQJDOJRULWKPV�RUJ�ZS�FRQWHQW� XSORDGV�����������SDSHU�LQWURQD�SGI!��$FHVVR�����GH]������� -$166(1��0���.8.��*��7KH�FKDOOHQJHV�DQG�OLPLWV�RI�ELJ�GDWD� DOJRULWKPV�LQ�WHFKQRFUDWLF�JRYHUQDQFH��*RYHUQPHQW�,QIRUPDWLRQ� 4XDUWHUO\��>6��O�@��Y������Q�����S�����±���������� .2+$5,��5���3529267��)��*ORVVDU\�RI�7HUPV��VSHFLDO�,VVXH�RQ� $SSOLFDWLRQV�RI�0DFKLQH�/HDUQLQJ�DQG�WKH�.QRZOHGJH�'LVFRYHU\� 3URFHVV��0DFKLQH�/DHUQLQJ��%RVWRQ��Y������Q�������S�����������IHE�� mar. 1998. 'LVSRQtYHO��KWWS���DL�VWDQIRUG�HGX�aURQQ\N�JORVVDU\�KWPO!�� $FHVVR�HP�����MDQ������� .2:$/6.,��5��$OJRULWKP �ORJLF��FRQWURO��&RPPXQLFDWLRQV�RI�WKH� $&0��1HZ�<RUN��Y������Q�����S���������������� /$7285��%��-DPDLV�IRPRV�PRGHUQRV��5LR�GH�-DQHLUR��(GLWRUD����� 1994. /(9,��/��*RYHUQR��,Q��%2%%,2��1��HW�DO���2UJV����'LFLRQiULR�GH� Política. ���HG��%UDVtOLD��')��(G��81%������� 0$&+/83��)��7KH�SURGXFWLRQ�DQG�GLVWULEXWLRQ�RI�NQRZOHGJH�LQ�WKH� 8QLWHG�6WDWHV��3ULQFHWRQ��3ULQFHWRQ�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV������� 281 GOVERNO DOS ALGORITMOS DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18764/2178-2865.v21n1p267-281 0$&.(1=,(��'��$Q�HQJLQH��QRW�D�FDPHUD��KRZ�¿QDQFLDO�PRGHOV� VKDSH�PDUNHWV��&DPEULGJH��0$��/RQGRQ��0LW�3UHVV������� 0$129,&+��/��6RIWZDUH�WDNHV�FRPPDQG��1HZ�<RUN��$ &�%ODFN�� 2013. 0$<%,1��6��6LVWHPD�GH�DOJRULWPR�TXH�GHWHUPLQD�SHQD�GH�FRQGHQDGRV� FULD�SROrPLFD�QRV�(8$��%%&�1HZV��6mR�3DXOR��RXW��������'LVSRQtYHO� HP��http://www.bbc.com/portuguese/brasil-37677421!��$FHVVR����� dez. 2016. 3$5,6(5��(��2�¿OWUR�LQYLVtYHO��R�TXH�D�LQWHUQHW�HVWi�HVFRQGHQGR�GH� YRFr��6mR�3DXOR��=DKDU������� 526(1$8��-��1��*RYHUQDQoD��RUGHP�H�WUDQVIRUPDomR�QD�SROtWLFD� PXQGLDO��,Q��526(1$8��-��&=(03,(/��2��*RYHUQDQoD�VHP� *RYHUQR��%UDVtOLD��')��(G��8Q%��������S�������� :$*1(5��%��$OJRULWKPLF�UHJXODWLRQ�DQG�WKH�JOREDO�GHIDXOW��VKLIWLQJ� QRUPV�LQ�,QWHUQHW�WHFKQRORJ\��(WLNN�L�3UDNVLV��1RUGLF�-RXUQDO�RI� $SSOLHG�(WKLFV��1RUZD\��Y������Q�����S������������� :(%(5��0��&LrQFLD�H�SROtWLFD��GXDV�YRFDo}HV��6mR�3DXOR��(GLWRUD� &XOWUL[�������
Compartilhar